Cream & Sugar

Shaun & Freddie #1

by S.T. Gillard

Shaun needs a new barista.

Freddie needs a job.

Exhausted, heartbroken and woefully understaffed, Shaun Harrison is at the end of his tether.

All his life, Shaun has dreamt of owning his own coffee shop. Now his dream is real, it's quickly becoming a nightmare. Staff are quitting left and right, he hasn't had a day off since he opened, not to mention he's still reeling from a brutal breakup.

When Freddie Young, a disarmingly handsome unemployed musician and self-confessed flirt-machine, walks through the café door one morning looking for a job, could it be Shaun's luck is finally turning around? Or are things about to get a whole lot more complicated?

For fans of D.P. Clarence and Isabel Murray, Cream & Sugar is a cosy MM coffee shop romcom full of nice boys, pining, and a healthy dash of spice. Set in a fictional Scottish town in winter, it's the perfect read to snuggle up by the fire with, (while sipping a latte and eating shameless amounts of cake).

Genres: M M Romance, Romance, LGBT, Christmas, Contemporary Romance, Cozy, Contemporary

319 pages, Kindle Edition

First published November 1, 2025

Reviews

[Snjez · Rating 2 out of 5]

I'll start with the positives. The cover is really cute. I liked the setting and everything coffee and coffee shop related. Since the story takes place in Scotland, an audio version of this story would have been great.

Everything else didn't work for me. Freddie and Shaun as characters felt very two-dimensional to me. There is no development throughout the story. They are attracted to each other from the moment they meet, even with Shaun being 'straight', and the author isn't subtle about Freddie's constant flirting and Shaun getting hard every time he sees Freddie. When something finally happens between them, they start calling each other boyfriends within like a day. I didn't buy their relationship at all. And I didn't like how the intimate scenes were written. Totally skimmed through the last one just to finish the book.

The side characters are even worse. Lara and Rory are annoyingly one-dimensional characters with one personal trait. Again, the author isn't subtle about how they act. Rory didn't even feel like a real person to me. Lara drama was ridiculous. Shaun was in a long-term relationship with a person like her? Yeah, right.

My first read by this author and I won't be picking up anything else by them.

[~✡~Dαni(ela) ♥ ♂♂ love & semicolons~✡~ · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book was the best surprise!

I was expecting a light & fluffy romance but got so much more.

All the sprinkles for:

~ The Scottish setting - I could practically feel the strong wind and lashing rain (the story takes place a few weeks before Christmas, but it's not holiday themed).

~ Shaun, owner of the Cream & Sugar café, and Freddie, barista in training and aspiring musician, who are smashing MCs: vulnerable, real, lovable.

~ Believable bi-awakening.

~ Dual, first-person POV.

~ Neurodivergent representation - Shaun is still coming to terms with his autism diagnosis; his ex shamed him, but Freddie gets it.

~ Slow burn - kisses, nipple play, wild sex on a table not meant to withstand such enthusiastic shagging.

~ Tender, appropriate relationship development - the MCs are so careful with each other, so respectful and kind.

~ The complicated relationship Freddie has with his older brother, Rory, who's always angry and not without cause (Rory's scary, but he means well, sort of, maybe).

~ Mostly sweetness but some angst too, delicately handled.

~ Hopeful HFN.

~ Polished, accessible writing style (the dialogue was spot on).

I'm not a fan of series about the same couple, but I'll make an exception for Shaun and Freddie.

[Carol [Goodreads Addict] · Rating 5 out of 5]

Cream & Sugar is book one in the Shaun & Freddie series by S.T. Gillard. I happened onto this book when I noticed the adorable cover. Once I read the blurb, I was all in. I can honestly say that I can’t believe this is this author’s debut book. The writing is wonderful, the story is sweet and swoony and engaging. I pretty much loved everything about it!!



Shaun Harrison is thirty three years old. One month earlier, he opened a brand new coffee shop, Cream & Sugar, also selling several favorite goodies he makes himself from family recipes. No matter how much he planned, though, nothing really prepares you for the lack of time, lack of sleep, and constant stress of opening your own business. Luckily, he hired a great supervisor Anna, to help run the shop. Shaun hasn’t had a full night’s sleep or a day off in the month since he opened his door. Business has been great but it’s all overwhelming. Especially when his part time barista quits with no notice, leaving him even more stressed. Which is exactly what brings Freddie to his door.



Freddie Young is twenty two years old and is a bit lost, living with his very grumpy older brother, Rory. Freddie is actually a talented singer and song writer who has big dreams but that’s as far as it went. With no job, no income and no prospects in sight, his brother gives him an ultimatum. Get a job, or get lost! Which is exactly what brought him to Cream & Sugar, and to Shaun!



What Freddie IS good at is flirting. And when he first meets one of the most gorgeous men he’s ever seen, he can’t help but to lay it on thick. Even though Freddie has no marketable skills, he’s a fast learner and Shaun is desperate. He is also just a bit mesmerized by Freddie, even though he’s never been attracted to a man before.

So there you go, the beginning of a beautiful, sweet, swoony love story that I absolutely adored. These two were just so cute together. Expect lots of blushing, awkward flirting and plenty of smiles with these two. I felt bad for Freddie with his rigid, grumpy brother. Not that Freddie didn’t deserve it at times. And Shaun was so adorable. These two just did it for each other and I loved watching it all unfold, as they filled in the missing pieces for one another.

The author says he’s not through with these two yet which I’m so excited about. This really was a feel good, angst free, wonderful story and I can’t wait for more.

“I didn’t know a kiss could feel this good.”

[patrícia · Rating 4 out of 5]

Arc Review: Cream & Sugar - S.T. Gillard
MC:Shaun(33) & Freddie (22) 4⭐

“Well,” the soft brush of Shaun’s beard grazes my neck, “I had to know what you taste like, Freddie.”
Bloody hell.“I see. And did I taste good?” I ask, though I think I can guess the answer.
A low hum from deep in Shaun’s chest. “Unbelievably good.”
“Better than coffee?”
“Don’t push it.”

Tropes & tags
☕️Cosy, coffee shop romance
🧁Bi-awakening
☕️Fictional Scottish town
🧁Humour
☕️Autistic MC
🧁Workplace romance
☕️Songs
🧁Good boys with feelings
☕️I would eat everything they serve🥐🥨🥪🥯🧇🥞🧁🍰🥧🍩🍪☕️🫖🧋
🧁Whipped cream!

First and foremost, that cover and all the art S.T. Gillard has on instagram TOTES ADORBS!!!! https://www.instagram.com/stgillard_w...

I really needed this book — after spending 600 pages inside the mind of a SK, I neeeeeeeded this like air and coffee!!! ☕️💨

And omg, this was sooooo good — funny, sweet, heartwarming, cozy, and simply delicious 🤤 It gave me everything that beautiful cover promised. The whole story feels like stepping into a tiny coffee shop where the smell of sugar and espresso hugs you the moment you walk in. Absolute comfort to read.

Freddie is pure chaos wrapped in charm — unreliable, playful, flirty, sometimes a total disaster, but so loveable that you can’t stay mad. His growth through the story was one of my favourite parts. And Shaun... what a gentle, kind soul. I adored how his character was written — thoughtful, vulnerable, and neurodivergent in a way that felt honest and layered. There’s such warmth in the way Gillard wrote him, especially because it was based on the author, and that always adds an extra lair of authenticity.

The writing itself? Fantastic. Smart, funny, emotional. Some lines hit straight in the heart, and I wasn’t expecting the little lyrical touches to make me teary 🥹

Now… one thing I didn’t like — Freddie suggesting Shaun buy a toy and practise alone. Why?! Their first time together should’ve been something special, especially since it was Shaun’s first gay experience. He deserved patience, care, and all the intimacy that comes with that moment. And we didn’t even get to see that conversation before Shaun bottomed? I wish that had been explored.

Still, this book gave me exactly what I needed — warmth, laughter, and a big dose of comfort. I can’t wait for book two (and maybe Rory’s story, please?). Indie debuts like this are such a joy to find, and S.T. Gillard’s definitely one to keep an eye on.

I’ll take my coffee hot,
Baby don’t waste a drop,
I’ll drink in the morning sun,
On a table for one.
If I have to wait in line,
To tell you that you are mine,
I’ll be here at closing time,
Can’t take me away, I’m here to stay.

I received a free copy of this book from the author and am voluntarily leaving a review.

⚠️Author TWs
Burn out
Panic attacks
Past death of a single-parent mother from cancer
Burglary
Threatened homelessness
Mention of relationship breakdown after autism diagnosis

❣️Book Safety & Content
Cheating: no
OM/OW Drama: Yes, ex girlfriend reappears and wants to reconnect, but no way Jose.
Sharing: no
Third-Act Breakup: no
Role Dynamics: Strict roles
POV: 1st person (dual)
Format: Duet (this is book 1)
Ending: HFN
Angst Level: Low
Spice Level: Low

[Justin · Rating 4 out of 5]

Heartfelt workplace romcom with extra cream & sugar (ayyy)

I really enjoyed this one! Shaun + Freddie are two disasters in their own right and fit together perfectly. Very much an opposites attract. Freddie, a shameless flirt (maybeee even a himbo?) and Shaun a business owner just trying to figure life out. They find each other right when they should.

The cast of characters really makes this book shine. I loved seeing the community of Shaun's shop, they provide so much joy and life to this book. The ending of the book DEF got me good, I love to cry about cute little guys in love!

If you want a lighthearted read about good boys, coffee, light spice and lots of laughs. This one is def for you! I can't wait for the next one!

Congrats on your debut, ST!

I was provided a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

[Bee · Rating 5 out of 5]

Oh my god, talk about a stellar debut! This was absolutely delightful and immensely relatable. What a wonderful surprise this book was. S.T. Gillard is definitely an author to keep an eye on because this was fantastic.

First of all, this book was so dang charming. Truly. I was hooked right from the start and it refused to let me go all until the end. The writing is funny, clever, and occasionally packs an emotional punch that leaves you a teary eyed mess. If I didn't know any better, I'd have never guessed that this is a debut, that's how good it is.

Where it truly shines is its characters. The side-characters were wonderful (though Rory took a while to warm up to), but the main characters are definitely the star of this show. Freddie is an absolute riot. His hilarious and witty and could probably (definitely) charm the pants off a nun. Being in his head was just a really fun time and it made me laugh a lot. Shaun, on the other hand, was a bit different. Let me tell you why, cause this deserves its own paragraph.

Shaun was diagnosed with autism late in life. Its very clear that his POV, this representation, is written straight from the heart, and it's beautiful. As someone who was also diagnosed with ASD late in life, I related to Shaun in a way I very rarely get to with books. At times it hurt because it was so painfully familiar. But most of the time, it made me feel so incredibly, wonderfully seen. No doubt Shaun is a character that will stay with me for a very long time.

Needless to say, the romance was beautiful. It's one of those delicious slow burn romances that just left me sighing dreamily in the end. Also, I really want a latte or cappucino now...

I am immensely excited to see what's next for this author. This story ends on a HFN, because we are getting more with these two characters, which is fantastic, if you ask me. I highly recommend this book to everyone. Please, please, please read it. You won't regret it.

I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review. My opinion is my own.

-----
Quotes:

As an anxious millennial, I’d rather pull out all my wisdom teeth with a pair of pliers than make a single telephone call.
---------
Shaun’s rear is so galactically chonky, it’s like a planet with its own gravitational pull. And here I am, a helpless space twink, perving from my rocket ship, unable to tear my eyes from the smooth round surface of… I guess, Uranus?
---------
He gives off gentleman vibes, but I bet there’s some filth in there, buried deep down beneath that gorgeous exterior.
“Come on,” Shaun says, beckoning me over. “I’ll show you how to clean my milk wand.” His cheeks turn from pink to red.
Knew it.
---------
At his touch, lightning explodes across my skin, spreading over my whole body. Every trace of anxiety vanishes. He kisses me slowly, gently, his perfect lips barely brushing mine, but sending waves of euphoria crashing through me. I didn’t know a kiss could feel this good.
---------
When I got my diagnosis, everything just made so much more sense. Like I finally had a reason why I struggle with things most people find easy. But also, it gave me permission to finally be who I really am.

[Shelby | Spicy.booknook · Rating 5 out of 5]

Perfect Balance of Sweet & Spicy

This was such a pleasant, lighthearted book to read...just so unbelievably charming. It has that perfect warmth you get from two characters that start out actually liking each other and becoming friends. Then you get this delicious slow burn that is so very believable for these two. This story just makes sense, and feels so real. The fact that it takes place in a Coffee shop in Scotland is bonus, and makes it feel like a warm blanket. All that said, as warm and cozy as the story is, the author did an excellent job bringing the heat.

I love these characters. They really are kind of opposite, with Freddie being just this side of immature, a little bit Himbo-ish, but having more experience in the bedroom (and not shy about it). He is a flirt, and its hilarious to see him tease poor Shaun to the point of turning into a tomato. Shaun is older, very gentle, and pretty much a workaholic. Building his shop from scratch has taken over his life and he needs help, so in steps a desperate for work Freddie. Those two together are just adorable. I just had so much fun reading this. Perfect balance of sweet & spicy. I cannot wait to see what else the author has in store for us.

Contemporary MM
Opposites Attract
Boss / Employee
Good Boy Vibes
Age Gap
Low Angst
Bi-awakening
Spice: 🔥🔥🔥

[Mir · Rating 3 out of 5]

2.5 Stars

I don’t think I read the same book as everyone else. Also, are all new releases age gaps with an inappropriately young main character? Feels like it.

The first half was quite good for the most part, with a very sweet slow burn. But unfortunately the only likable character in this entire book is Shaun. Freddie sucks, Rory sucks, the cafe manager sucks, Shaun’s ex sucks…literally everyone is so incredibly unlikable to me. The book starts with a scene from Freddie’s POV that put me off him immediately, and it just never ended.

After they got together, which was so sweet to be fair, things got crazy, with one dimensional “villains,” way too many exclamation marks, and the weirdest sex scenes - especially considering this was Shaun’s first time with a man.

The ending was just straight up the “Simply the Best” scene from Schitt’s Creek.

I do think this author has the something special needed to succeed but for me, it wasn’t with this one.

[Marcos “MSMDragon” · Rating 5 out of 5]

Cozy, sweet, and spicy!! Like a perfect chai latte!

I loved Freddie and Shaun. Their personalities and dynamic together made for a really good story. And the author did a great job addressing some more difficult topics, like grief, autism, and panic attacks.

[Monica · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was a wonderful read. I hadn't laughed so much with a book in a long while and I just loved it.
Freddie was hilarious and a great character. He was an unemployed musician whose brother threatened to kick him out of his house, he needed a job badly and he came across Shaun's café where a sign stated the business was looking to hire a barista.
Shaun was a teddy bear with a heart bigger than the moon. He was sweet, caring and such a good person it was difficult to not fall in love with him. He just wanted to keep his café, something he had always dreamt about and be happy. Freddie entering his life meant a lot of changes for him, but it was what he certainly needed to make both his business and his personal life work.
From the moment they first met sparks flew all around them, but this was a slow burn story and I liked that very much. It allowed for Shaun and Freddie to get to know each other, Freddie's non-stop flirting made Shaun realise he was bisexual and it also helped to boost his self-esteem after an excruciating break-up.
This book was full of banter, funny moments, lots of flirting and a romance between two men that were trying to make something with their lives. It was beautiful to witness how understanding Freddie was regarding Shaun's autism and how protective Shaun was towards Freddie when the latter's brother became an arsehole.
I really despised some of the secondary characters. Freddie's brother was awful and there was no excuse for his behaviour. I honestly didn't understand how Freddie could be so forgiving, he was also hurting for the loss of their mom. Then there was Shaun's ex-girlfriend who just wanted to use him to make money and become famous. She got what she deserved and I was extremely happy about it.
I truly enjoyed this book and even though it has a HFN ending (which I didn't know about), I didn't mind much because it was a great story. I guess I'll need to read the second part and find out how Freddie and Shaun are doing together.

[Chloe · Rating 5 out of 5]

Cream & Sugar by S.T. Gillard

🧡 Boss x Employee
🧡 Age Gap (11 years)
🧡 Bi-awakening
🧡 Autistic MC
🧡 Scottish Small Town
🔥 Nipple Play, Food Play (whipped cream), "Good Boy", Mild Spanking, Mild Public Fondling

This was such a great debut! The story itself was a really good balance of funny and sweet with cosy vibes and a splash of drama thrown in.

The author's writing flowed really well and I found it incredibly easy to read. I really enjoyed all of the British references, they were so relatable and I found myself laughing out loud at several points in the story.

The autism rep was portrayed so well in this book and I absolutely adored Shaun, he's such a wonderful MC. I loved how sweet and earnest he was and how much he cared for Freddie 🥹 he's definitely joined my list of top book boyfriends!

I do wish I would have known going into the book that it was a duet, as the ending felt a little quick to me and the story was left on more of a HFN, rather than a HEA, but I expect we will get that in book 2.

Overall, this was a really impressive debut that I'd definitely recommend. I'm already looking forward to the sequel! ☺️

Overall: ⭐⭐⭐⭐.5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️.5
Humour: 🤭🤭🤭
Intimacy: 🫂🫂🫂.5
Angst: 🥺🥺.5

First person dual pov 👀

Content Warnings
On page: anxiety, panic attacks, threatened homelessness, ableism
Mentioned: drug use, parent death from cancer, depression, burglary, previous relationship breakdown after autism diagnosis

I was given an ARC copy of this book to review by the author, all thoughts and opinions are my own.

[TC · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 ✨

Super duper cute. The spice didn’t quite do it for me, but I think I’m too picky and that’s my problem not the book’s. But overall a super sweet fun romcom-y read!

A quote that made me hehe:
“Shaun’s rear is so galactically chonky, it’s like a planet with its own gravitational pull. And here I am, a helpless space twink, perving from my rocket ship, unable to tear my eyes from the smooth round surface of… I guess, Uranus?”

[Benjamin Lund · Rating 5 out of 5]

I’m in love with everything about this book! The characters were all fantastic (yes even Rory, he just took some warming up to first), the setting was super charming, and the plot line was the perfect rom-com I didn’t know I needed in my life.

Freddie is a cheeky flirt who doesn’t know when to quit, but it’s what makes him so great. Shaun is more on the reserved side (at first), and he gives us some fantastic autism representation. When these two met for the first time, the chemistry was pretty much instant. The easy banter back and forth was humorous and adorable the whole way through. The way Freddie remained unapologetically himself, which worked to break down Shaun’s walls more and more. And when they finally… you know… collide their bodies together, it was breathtaking and magical.

Probably one of my favorite moments was when Shaun opened up about his autism diagnosis to Freddie. It was a beautiful, touching moment that brought a tear to my eye. Another favorite moment of mine was the scene that features whipped cream. That entire moment was absolutely delicious perfection. I didn’t want the scene to end. IYKYK!

I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys MM romance, rom-coms, a bit of spice, and autism representation. Job well done to author S.T. Gillard! I’ll be eagerly waiting for your next book!

[Lizzy · Rating 5 out of 5]

The author opens by telling us the book is ‘for anyone who needs more nice boys in their life’ and he was absolutely spot on with that. Freddie and Shaun really are the nicest boys. They’re the kind of people I would love to have in my life. The kindness that radiates from both of them made this a warm and fuzzy read from start to finish.

While Freddie can be a bit of a little shit - who clearly knows exactly how to push his brother’s buttons in only the way a younger sibling can do - he’s neither cruel nor without hurts himself. He and Rory just really know how to wind each other up and i think it’s important to remember that he is only 22 and weren’t most of us a bit of a pain in the arse in our youth?

Sweet Shaun seems like he needs a Freddie in his life to show him what acceptance looks like and hopefully unconditional love.

This story felt like a warm hug from start to finish, it was exactly like sitting in your favourite coffee shop on a rainy day.

S.T. Gillard is a sommelier of similes. There are some wonderful uses sprinkled throughout.
Some insightful, some dramatic, some atmospheric but more often than not absolutely snort out loud funny.

‘Gary’s glaring at me like I’ve just pissed through his letterbox’

I really enjoyed that we didn’t get the usual waffle that sometimes comes with a bi-awakening story. One MC explaining the mechanics of things to the other. I feel like we’re all grown ups here and don’t always need to see it spelled out on the page.
It was also nice to see Shaun think about what was happening to him but not have a total crisis.
He questioned his initial attraction to Freddie, but it didn’t become the entire plot line.

There were some wonderful (and not so wonderful- I’m looking at you Lara) side characters. Rory, oh grumpy Rory I need to know more for sure. Shaun’s lovely mum, it was nice to see some positive female rep included to offset the awful Ex-girlfriend.

All in all A+ vibes, sweet story, fantastic debut and I can’t wait to see more of these two in the future
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review

[Betty Loves Books Galore · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is an opposites attract romance, featuring Shaun and Freddie, and is a standalone book.

Shaun, a cafe owner, is exhausted and struggling to keep his dream coffee shop afloat as another staff member quits. When musician Freddie shows up looking for a job, Shaun wonders if his luck is changing.

This one was a slow burn and super sweet. Shaun and Freddie had such great chemistry and I loved the flirting - it was playful, tender, and just the right mix of teasing. Watching Shaun’s guarded heart slowly open up to Freddie’s charm was worth it.

The author has mentioned in their acknowledgements that there will be a following book for this couple, so stay tuned.

Things to expect in this book are:
Standalone book
MM romance
Small town
Set in Scotland
Slow burn
Opposites attract
Co-workers
Cafe owner x barista
Ex rugby player x musician
Hurt / Comfort
Cat dad
Flirting
Autism rep
Not-date date & dates
Bi awakening
Spicy times
Edging
Food play: whipped cream
Calls him good boy
Supportive family
HEA

[Jennifer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Really sweet rom-com

This is a really cute, light rom-com with low stakes. A few moments gave me second-hand anxiety, but most were resolved quickly. Freddie had me laughing my head off with some of his euphemisms and similes.

[Ri]

Cozy coffee shop contemporary romance
(Fictional) British small town
Café manager x out of work musician
Autistic rep
Bi-awakening

[Riley Klabunde · Rating 5 out of 5]

5 stars — warm, tender, and delightfully joy-filled.

Cream & Sugar is exactly the kind of romance I wish we saw more often: low-angst, character-driven, and overflowing with queer joy. This book wrapped itself around me like a soft blanket and refused to let go.

Freddie and Shaun have such effortless charm together. Their chemistry is gentle and comforting rather than dramatic, and it was refreshing to watch a romance unfold without relying on the usual third-act breakup or contrived conflict. Instead, it leans into growth, communication, and care.

Shaun’s bi awakening was handled with so much softness. It never felt rushed or sensationalized—it was simply a person learning who he is, and falling for someone who sees him clearly. Freddie’s confidence complements Shaun’s uncertainty beautifully.

Every page felt warm, sweet, and full of heart. It’s the kind of book that makes you believe in love again, in its simplest and most joyful form.

☕ Absolutely adored this. Freddie and Shaun have me permanently in my feelings.

[Andrew Smith-Mebust · Rating 5 out of 5]

I have been waiting for this one since I stumbled across it on Instagram. My previous work experience as a coffee shop manager, and barista as well as years in customer service, instantly drew me to this novel. I knew I’d be able to relate to the characters and it would be a good read. What I wasn’t expecting was this to be a PHENOMENAL read. This debit novel by S.T. Gillard completely blew me away. I think it may be one of my top reads, if not for sure one of the top 5 of the year(don’t make me choose there have been so many bangers this year!🫣)! The characters were so relatable, the setting was cozy, it was just a breath of fresh air. There was no angst, and it was just a solid romance from start to finish. Also the dialogue was insanely witty! I was laughing and giggling like a maniac, frequently enough that my husband actually checked in on me, and asked if I was ok. I can’t say enough good things about this book. Luckily for us this isn’t the last we will see of Freddie and Shaun, as it looks like 2 more novels are in the works. I know I will gladly be there to read the next installments!

Thank you again to S.T. Gillard and their team for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

✨🎸☕️🏉🎶🧁🍑🧁🎶 🏉 ☕️🎸✨

[Adriana · Rating 5 out of 5]

If serotonin were a book, Cream & Sugar would be it — a warm, slightly chaotic cup of comfort with just enough whipped cream.

We’ve got Shaun, the overworked, soft-hearted coffee shop owner with a galactically chonky ass (yes, that’s canon), and Freddie, the charming disaster who crashes into Shaun’s life like a hurricane of bad decisions but good intentions. It’s boss x employee, eleven-year age gap, bi-awakening, and a big dollop of “good boys with feelings.” It’s emotional comfort food.

The writing is great. Genuinely funny, full of heart, and way more polished than most debuts. The author's got that knack for humor that actually lands, it's the kind that makes you laugh-snort and then immediately get misty-eyed two paragraphs later. It’s British wit meets queer tenderness, and somehow it all just works.

Shaun’s late autism diagnosis is written with the kind of honesty that hits deep but never feels heavy-handed. It’s real, but also hopeful — the kind of rep that makes you exhale and go, “Oh. Someone gets it.” Correct me if I'm wrong here, tho.

Freddie, on the other hand, is pure chaos wrapped in charm. He flirts, he fumbles, he occasionally faceplants, but watching him grow is half the fun. Together, they’re the definition of opposites attract — the anxious caretaker and the impulsive free spirit somehow finding their rhythm.

It’s low-angst, high-charm, and totally re-readable. The supporting cast adds flavor (Rory, I see you, you grumpy legend), and the fictional Scottish setting feels so vivid you can practically hear the espresso machine humming in the background. The book ends on a HFN because this is only part one of a duet — but it’s satisfying enough to leave you smiling rather than screaming. I can’t wait to see where book two takes them (and if we get Rory’s story, I will combust).

In short: Cream & Sugar is the literary equivalent of your favorite café — familiar, comforting, and just the right amount of sweet — with a double shot of queer joy.

[Mhairi Brown · Rating 5 out of 5]

Now this is how you do a debut novel!

Honestly I cannot find one fault. I laughed and cried and gasped. I wanted to never put it down and drag it out forever at the same time. I’ve been in such a reading slump recently and this brought me back to my literary life. Just epic. Is it too soon to re-read? I may have to ignore my own rules and just start over again because the cosy, dark nights, cold days with warm hot chocolate and fuzzy socks vibes this book gives off is perfection. Move over Laurie Gilmore. There’s a new small town romance author in town and he’s hitting the ball out of the park.

Ok let’s get into the proper review.

I’m not going to lie. I’m VERY picky when it comes to small town romance books. They need to have that warm, hug in a mug kind of feeling. They need to be books you can go back to again and again because they just radiate cosy vibes. Oh and they must include characters that I instantly connect with. So I was really asking a lot when it comes to cream and sugar and it easily could have been a flop BUT not only did it tick all those boxes but the plot was actually something beyond just lovey, dovey romance. It was embarking on a journey of self discovery in Shaun’s case and personal growth in Freddie’s. ST Gillard has a fabulous way with words and metaphors that had me howling with laughter. This book is a total hit and a must read for autumn/winter.

Shaun is so loveable and sweet and you just want to pinch his cheeks one minute then climb him like a tree the next. Let’s be honest- we all fell for him the second his ass was described as “galactically chonky”.

Freddie is cheeky in a youthful and free way that is simultaneously endearing and entertaining. His confidence is something many only aspire to and it definitely makes him the comic of the story but we get to see his character mature and change delightfully (but not so much that he’s not still fun).

The stories woven in beside the romance aspect of the book are real and raw. I related to Freddie a lot and (dare I say it) even Rory because they lost their mum to cancer as did I. I always find that writing characters who have lost a parent is very risky because grief is so personal and differs between everyone but in those two characters I saw so much of myself and my coping mechanisms. It was refreshing.

Sean reminded me of my husband in every way. My husband is late diagnosed autistic which is a huge reason this book appealed to me and Sean’s behaviour in certain parts of the book was exactly what I’ve witnessed. I actually felt like I had some insight into how my husband thinks and why he acts the way he does. Just a fabulously written character.

Then of course there is the whole cosy coffee shop aspect of this book. One of my favourite parts was the “first date” to the coffee shop that taught Sean everything he knows. The relationships between not just Sean and Freddie but their friends and family, co workers and even exes are so meticulously written that even the smallest of side characters feels important and interesting and someone you would totally read a spin-off about.

The spice was a whole other level of fun and didn’t feel forced like it can in some books. It was relevant to Sean and Freddie’s story but still delicious to read and expertly portrayed.

Honestly I can find zero fault with this book. I actually forced myself to put it down because I wanted to drag it out as long as possible and now I don’t know what to do with myself. Please be quick with book two. I need more and I need to know if they ever replace that table.

[J Coles]

I haven’t read a low angst book in so long, I was starting to get worried I can’t read straight up romance anymore, but ST Gillard has won me over!

This was a light, fast paced, Rom-com set in a fictional town in Scotland. The book follows scatter brained Freddie and ultimate soft boy Shaun as they navigate feelings for one another whilst being boss and employee.

The book shows a personal understanding of autism, and neurodivergent traits in both MCs, and an equal partnership where both MCs support and show up for the other.

Plenty of British humour and sarcasm, as well as cosy vibes. Perfect for Autumn 🍂 AND Winter ❄️

I really enjoyed Cream & Sugar and I’m excited for book two!

[erm]

dnfing this after one chapter bc Freddie gave me the ick and already can’t stand him

[fictional affection · Rating 5 out of 5]

Loved this. Freddie took a minute but I was a goner for Shawn from the opening. They are wonderful and hot and I loved the setting and auxiliary characters. I hope Rory gets his own book next. I want to drink coffee and start this story over. While not heavy on the holidays it is a warm winter hug. Well done! 👏🏻

[Natasha Michael · Rating 5 out of 5]

☕🎸Freddie & Shaun☕🎸

Cream & Sugar is cozy, funny, heartfelt and so damn wholesome! Sometimes you just need a book that gives you the feel goods from start to finish, and this book is that! I was smiling through the whole entire thing!

Shaun & Freddie were absolutely perfect for each other! Freddie is one of those people who are just a ball of a sunshine all the time! He is a total flirt and also so kind, understanding and accepting, I adored him! Shaun was definitely starting to feel some dream chasing burnout at the beginning of the book but watching him come into his confidence and learn that he's perfect just the way he is was one of my favorite parts of this book! He is such a well-written and realistic character! Shaun & Freddie together were just a dream team!

I enjoyed all the side characters! Anna is just a bossy little spitfire but you could feel her love! Rory definitely needs to let some much needed feelings in, but his character definitely intrigued me! And Shaun's mom is just the sweetest thing and I love her! I can't wait to see were S.T. takes this world! I am so excited for more!


This book was so perfect, I can not believe this is S.T. Gillard's duet, every vibe that was promised with this book delivered, I felt warm, cozy, happy and also drank WAY to much coffee throughout the reading process! ☕😊

[Alastair H · Rating 5 out of 5]

What a perfect book for the start of the cozy season!! With extremely endearing and lovable MCs and a warm, slow burn romance to accompany them. This book is like reading a hug. It has a dash of the traditional rom com feel which amplifies the soft, familiar feel of it.

Freddie is happy go lucky and silly, clearly not taking life too seriously (to the point of detriment sometimes haha), but Shaun sees him for who he is instead of writing him off as irresponsible. Shaun is steadier and more serious of the two and is a good balance to Freddie shenanigans.

The background of the cafe makes you feel like you're bundled up in a warm cafe smelling coffee and listening to acoustic while snow falls outside. The story is very calming and cute and is such a good one for the season!!! Especially for a debut I thought it was well done and I'll be looking forward to what this author has to offer next.

[Zoë Elias · Rating 5 out of 5]

oh my!!

Omg this book! It felt like a warm blanket on cold snowy day. So cosy, so yummy, so funny!!

I ate it up!
The cute setting in a coffee café? Amazing!
The slow burn, the pining, everything was perfect!
And i laughed mny times at how funny it was .

I can’t wait for more books, this one was so well written.

10/10 !!!

[Beth · Rating 5 out of 5]

The author said they wanted to write a book about queer joy and that sums this story up perfectly! Set in a small Scottish town, Cream & Sugar feels like the book version of a hot drink and a sweet treat on a rainy afternoon. It’s warm, gentle and just the right amount of flirty!

Shaun and Freddie completely stole my heart. I adored the soft and slow nature of their romance, the bi-awakening and the sense of comfort throughout.

If you love cosy queer romances that are the emotional equivalent of a hug in book form, this one’s for you 🫶

[Peter · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was a fun and cozy debut by Gillard. Shaun and Freddie have great chemistry together from the start and develop alongside each other throughout the story. I loved the mental health rep and felt like it was handled appropriately and with good intentions. The banter and teasing were adorable from both parties, and the finale left me craving more.

[Toddles · Rating 5 out of 5]

CREAM & SUGAR
By S.T. Gillard
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I read this novel for pleasure because it was blowing up on Bookstagram. It Is available NOW on Amazon & Kindle Unlimited!
www.amazon.com/B0FLQKHRZB

This is a 316-page Fast Paced, Bi-Awakening, Cozy Hallmark Style, British Small-Town Coffee Shop MM Romance. This review will be short and sweet, I think. LOL! Watch that be a lie. A story about challenges and growth. One character trying to make sure his café is successful but not really taking care of himself in the process. The other character is perceived to be a Hot Mess, a musician with dreams but no path to his goals with a bad relationship with his brother.

--I was looking forward to instigating a scandalous workplace romance with my hot new boss.--

Written in alternating chapters, dual 1st person POV, Shaun just opened his Café, CREAM & SUGAR, but is struggling to keep customers and employees happy while working himself into the ground. He is tired and hasn’t had a day off since they opened. Freddie and his brother Rory have a blow out fight that concludes with an ultimatum, ‘Find a job, or get out!’ While out about in town Freddie comes across the Café and a drowning Shaun, which lead to a new job.

--If he’s not a coffee addict already, he soon will be. Welcome to the world of hospitality workers. Cut us and we bleed espresso.--

The plot is character forward with humor and mild drama. It’s such a cozy story to read during the cold season while wrapped up in a blanket burrito. It’s a story about differences and understanding. Shaun is on the spectrum and hasn’t had the greatest time with people respecting him for who he is. Freddie has a dream of playing music and singing. It’s his passion. Not only does he love it, but it helps keeps his mother’s memory alive within him. But his passion and his immaturity is the thorn in his brother’s foot that creates a constant rift between them. The two of them learn and accept each other and help each other thrive with what they want in life while falling hard in the other’s arms.

--“Come on, I’ll show you how to clean my milk wand.”--

It was written simply, quite easy to follow, and full of innuendos to keep you laughing. Shaun was written as very high functioning autistic individual and in a respectful tone. He wasn’t written for laughs or to be the butt of the joke, but as honest representation of a person that just handles and overcomes challenges just like us with different trajectories. His café was the setting for most of the book and how the author wrote the workings of the job gave me PTSD flashbacks to my former life as a barista. S.T Gillard nailed it! From the stress of the job to the types of customers, they wrote like they have first-hand experience making coffee and eSpresso for a decade. They also wrote his bi-awakening quite real. Being an overthinker already and on the spectrum, he goes through all the stages and processes each one before moving on to acceptance, but it’s done in a creative way with a dash of spice. Freddie was written in an authentic mind set. Lost with no true path in life, in his early 20s, he is just coasting and stalled out at the same time. He knows what he wants and that is to play music and sing, but kind of just waiting for it to fall in his lap while his brother is on his ass about every little thing. He flirts his way into working at the café and only starts to work there to keep a roof over his head. He hates the taste of coffee but isn’t afraid to learn even if he is a bit of a mess about it.

--I’m not that fussy with men, anatomically speaking, as long as they’re easy on the eyes, but a thick set of twitchy pecs sets me off like a hungry tiger on a buffalo. I can’t help it. It’s just biology. All I want to do is press my face against them and motorboat until I can’t breathe.--

The Spice was really good!! 3/5 🌶. It is a slow burn to get to that point, but it doesn’t feel like it, to be truthful. I was surprised when I got to the first spicy scene and realized how far I was into the book. It didn’t feel like I had read that much. But once these two get going, there is no stopping them, location and furniture be damned. Shaun’s first-time experiences don’t really feel like first times because he overly processed the hell out of his sexuality. He just jumped in at that point which was refreshing to see a character without fear in their eyes going into a new spicy experience.

--If this is what sex feels like when you actually like the guy, then wow. One-night stands can jog on.--

The ensemble was very minimal. Freddie’s brother, Rory, shared the antagonist role to created tension within the novel with Shaun’s ex, Lara. They both are challenges for our MCs and were created perfectly! The feeling of hate will pump through you every time one is mentioned or shows up with the underlining hope for a redemption for one of them. Anna, the café manager is a bit intense and passionate about the job and keeping Shaun on track. She tends to mother him aggressively, but it always comes from love. Her 5-year-old son make a couple appearances and opens the door for Freddie to do what he wants to do. Sometimes all it takes is a child to make dreams come true.

--“I think you’re the best boyfriend ever!”
“Get me that printed on a mug or it means nothing.”—

The novel is just the beginning!!!!! SURPRISE!!!!! Even though it’s written with a HEA, it’s just FOR NOW! This will be a duology with the potential for a spin-off down the road. But S.T. Gillard wrote Cream & Sugar with genius intent. The ending is satisfied if you don’t continue in the future to book two but if you are an obsessive reader that can’t leave anything hanging, they also wrote with an addictive vibe that will make you go on the hunt to see what these two men get themselves into next.

--“Good things come to good boys.”--

LOOK! I LIED…. It’s a long review….

💜Happy Reading🫶