This book is the biggest literary surprise of my year so far. I kind of loved it? 💚💜
When I received this ARC as a free gift with purchase at my favorite local book shop on Bookstore Romance Day, I laughed out loud when I opened the daisy-printed wrapping paper to find…an orc romance? I was certain I wouldn’t read this book, but the cover was adorable and very “Beauty and the Beast”-coded, so I kept an open mind, read the first page…and couldn’t stop.
Author Isabelle Taylor has created a world in which a humanoid dragon can be a harried single mom, a Minotaur owns a flower shop and reads Oprah’s Book Club pics, an incubus can be casually shopping for poppyseed muffins at the grocery store, a werewolf runs an inn with his human wife, and a chimera (who also happens to be a part-time movie star) might serve your coffee at the local cafe. Despite the magical creatures populating Claw Haven, Alaska, this book reads more like a cozy, small town, contemporary romance, and I was totally into it.
Our male protagonist, Nick, is a massive, awkward, obnoxiously funny orc who immediately makes a terrible first impression on the bookish female protagonist, Violet. (Basically Belle, with a people-pleasing complex turned up to 11.) Nick immediately recognizes her as his future mate (apparently an orc thing?) and proceeds to unintentionally insult her and her interests with his wisecracks.
Cut to two years later. Nick is still visiting Vi at the bookstore, trying to win her over and pretty much screwing it up every time. Vi is wildly attracted to him, but hates his personality so much that she refuses to let him see past her customer service persona. She’s too busy to date anyway, as she says “yes” to nearly every favor asked of her.
Of course these opposites can’t resist the chemistry between them, which turns into an enemies-to-friends-to-lovers situation. But Nick wants Vi to like him before he tells her she’s his mate and asks if she wants to be with him. And Vi wants to make sure Nick likes her as more than a friend-with-benefits. Miscommunications abound, as they do in many romance books, before Beauty and The Beast—I mean Nick and Vi—can reach their happily-ever-after.
One of the many things I genuinely enjoyed about this book was the completely casual integration of the mythical creatures. Of course a fae is a bartender and occasionally hooks up with Nick. Of course VI’s boss is an elderly, cantankerous dragon who shuffles around in slippers. Of course the bookstore cat inexplicably has bat-like wings. Why not? It’s the author’s world and I’m just visiting.
And yet there was a realism that made me care about the characters as much as I would in a non-fantasy book. I was touched by Nick’s social anxiety, his baking habit (he’s the town’s anonymous “Baked Goods Bandit” who shares his treats with his neighbors), and his insecurities about being a high school dropout. He was oddly endearing, like the goofy high school jock you eventually find out isn’t as confident as he appears, and maybe even feels like shit about himself most days. Violet, too, was worried that no one would want to spend time with her if she wasn’t always solving their problems, or if she showed hints of her inner wildness.
Nick, like the golden-retriever-style-boyfriend he is, begins to share the load of Violet’s obligations, works through a learning disability to help with her shop’s book club, makes her laugh, and gives her physical pleasure she hasn’t known before. Violet brings him out of his house and into the community, validates his intelligence and competence, supports his baking, and is a romantic, connected intimate partner, which is new for him.
Speaking of intimacy, yes, there are descriptions of orc…um…anatomy, but it wasn’t as strange as I expected? He’s basically just a big guy who happens to be green and well-endowed. 😆 I can’t imagine how these situations work with a dragon or a chimera, but I trust that Isabelle Taylor has it all figured it out in her other books.
The copy I read was a proof, so there were some typos and transition issues that I’m sure will be fixed in the finished version. I also had a bit of trouble placing the time of year of the book. (Maybe I missed it?) They’re in Alaska and it was cold, but some of the characters were only wearing cardigans. And then in another chapter there was snow on the ground, which hadn’t been mentioned before. Was Vi riding her bike in the snow? Was Nick walking around in November wearing a tank top? When did he switch to wearing jackets? Did the elderly dragon have to navigate his wheelchair over patches of ice? Maybe literally no one else asks questions like this, but these details are important to me as a reader so that I can fully immerse myself into the world. I like to know what kind of sensory details the characters are dealing with.
It also bothers me when a romance book ends at the beginning of a relationship, even when there’s an epilogue. That’s not to say this issue is unique to this book, and it doesn’t seem to bother most romance readers. Many of the romance books I’ve read end with a confession or an agreement for the protagonists to finally be together, and I don’t get to see more of the relationship, except maybe a “one year later” epilogue. My issue is: I’ve spent an entire book falling in love with a couple and then it’s just…done? I don’t get to see them on a normal Tuesday, or going on a road trip, or waking up together on a weekend? Maybe that’s being an older reader—I want to see the “real” romance, the actual day-to-day relationship, rather than just the courtship and drama leading up to two characters becoming a couple.
That being said, the epilogue of this book did give me some of what I wanted to see. I just think Nick and Vi are so cute that I would read an entire second novel of them hanging out together as a couple…or at least a novella?
I would definitely read another Isabelle Taylor novel, because this one was adorable.
I’d recommend this book to any romance reader who enjoys:
💚 Golden retriever boyfriends
💚 Men (or orcs) built like Mack trucks
💚 Men (or orcs) who bake
💚 Beautifully bookish FMCs
💚 Romantic comedies
💚 Jane Austen references
💚 Steaminess with a hint of weird
💚 Quirky small towns
💚 Found family
💚 Fantasy characters in the ordinary human world
💚 Cozy vibes
Key to my ratings:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A personal favorite and/or an exemplary, near-perfect book for its genre. Either repaired or broke my heart, or perhaps broke it and then put it back together again? Regardless, my heart is not the same after reading it.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A memorable, excellent example of its genre that likely made me cry, laugh out loud, hug the book to my chest, or all of the above.
⭐️⭐️⭐️ An enjoyable read that was possibly a bit flawed or not fully my cup of tea, but still a solidly good book. I would likely recommend it to someone if they liked the genre.
⭐️⭐️ A book I was able to get through, but wasn’t a positive reading experience. Still has merit on some level.
⭐️ I don’t have the attention span to finish one-star books. 😆