Very early into this book, author Jes Battis paraphrases an iconic line of the movie instead of quoting the correct line and I just could not get past it. It sort of set the tone for the rest of the book, where I feel like I know where the author is going, and then he just randomly zigs and makes me say, huh?
In addition, I feel like this collection of essays could benefit from another editing pass. Certain subjects are referred to multiple times, with very little new information given each subsequent time. This makes the collection feel disjointed and hastily thrown together, which I am sure it was not. Battis also tries to inject his personal experiences into his book, focusing on how the movie has shaped his life, which is an interesting idea, but ultimately pushes the audience away rather than drawing them in.
Despite those issues, there is much in this book that is enjoyable. The idea that maybe we should all let our inner goblin out once in a while to do goblin things is great, and advice we all should follow, really. The few times Battis steps away from his own experiences to discuss the movie through other lenses are also fascinating, as are the ideas he offers about Henson himself. Fans of other 1980s fantasy movies will enjoy reading about several other favorites as well. While It’s Only Forever is a slightly flawed book, it offers a modern take on a well-loved childhood movie, with a hefty dose of nostalgia.
Huge thanks to NetGalley for an ARC of this book!