Sisters by chance; rivals by choice. A bookish cozy fantasy about two witches uncovering dark magic in a small town, for fans of Emily Grimoire and Erin Sterling.
Sisters Effie and Bonnie might both be witches, but they’re worlds apart. Reserved and bookish, Effie finds solace in library corners, while Bonnie knows all about being popular. They strive to stay away from one another - a challenging task in the confines of their small hometown, Yellowbrick Grove.
When their estranged Uncle Oswald draws Bonnie into a magical scheme under the guise of helping the locals, Bonnie readily agrees. But it turns out no good deed goes unpunished – Oswald’s real motives are truly wicked.
Within a day, Bonnie’s spells start misfiring and Effie notices something sinister taking root.
Can they unite to reverse this magical mishap? Or is life as they knew it over for good?
This was really fun and cute, while also navigating deeper themes like grief and found family. The story centers on two sisters with magical abilities and opposite personalities. Ever since losing their mother a year ago, the rift between them has only deepened, but they're so hung up on their differences that they don’t see how similar they actually are. They care and worry about the same things but they manifest it in different ways, and so each of them assumes the other one doesn’t care.
I enjoyed the way the characters grew and learned to see their own flaws. Although the romance sub plot competed a bit with the main story of the two sisters, it was really sweet and reminded me of the slow burn of older tv shows.
I loved the setting, a Gilmore Girls-esque small town with a picturesque and chaotic cast of side characters. The story goes into many tangents but everything adds to the cute small town flavor.
Overall I enjoyed this book very much! I listened to the audio version and the two narrators did an excellent job, I particularly recommend the audiobook ☺️💕
Thanks to Macmillan via NetGalley for providing an ALC
The focus is on two sisters who are very different people. Effie is very bookish, Bonnie a lot more outgoing. Very different sisters, but both witches. Living in small town makes it hard for them to avoid each other like they want to, and when their estranged Uncle turns up and pulls Bonnie into a magical scheme disguised as something helpful.
I enjoyed this a lot. I loved the complete differences in the sisters, and the development of their relationship through the book. I liked the premise of the story, but did feel it was a little slow at times, like there were some parts that just kept the story going but weren't required for the overall storyline. I would definitely class this as a cozy book with fantasy elements, with the smallest touch of a romance element. I listened to the audiobook and thought the narrators did a great job.
I would definitely recommend this to anyone who likes cozy reads (I keep saying cozy, but it really fits the bill) and especially those who don't like much of a focus on romance.
Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan for the audiobook arc in exchange for an honest review.
⭐️⭐️ Two’s a Charm by Heather Spellman. October Buddy Read with Laura.
I feel a little bad giving this one two stars because, honestly, it wasn’t particularly bad. But it also wasn’t particularly good for me.
The sprayed edges on this book are absolutely gorgeous, and that was what initially sucked Laura and me in. Sometimes a pretty book is just too tempting to resist! 😂 Unfortunately, the inside didn’t quite live up to the outside.
I found this book felt very young. I’m hesitant to label it YA because I read more in-depth books when I was younger, but I’d probably describe it as a cosy, almost YA-style read. I’m not entirely sure where it sits genre-wise, but I was expecting a little more substance.
One of my biggest issues was the characterisation. These are grown women who own their own businesses, yet they often came across as much younger than their actual ages and life experiences would suggest. Bonnie was particularly noticeable in this respect. I struggled to reconcile the fact that she was an adult business owner with the way she was written, which only added to the overall feeling that the book was aimed at a much younger audience. I wanted the characters to feel like fully developed adult women, but unfortunately, I just didn’t get that from them.
I even tried a little of the audiobook while doing some jobs around the house, but Bonnie’s character voice sounded so young and irritating to me that I genuinely wondered if I’d accidentally put on My Little Pony. 😭 I do feel bad saying that because I mean no disrespect to the author, but it really wasn’t for me.
My biggest issue overall was the lack of depth, both in the storyline and the characters. Very little actually happens, and despite the magical premise, there isn’t a huge amount of magic. Instead, we get hexed drinks, two sisters who aren’t getting along particularly well, and a story that seems to revolve largely around them becoming friends again.
But I kept waiting for something more to happen. I wanted more development, more substance and a stronger sense of purpose to the story. By the end, I was left wondering what the point had really been.
The writing itself wasn’t bad, although I did notice names such as Bobby changing to Bobbie, which left me wondering whether the book had been properly proofread.
My favourite part was definitely the library. Give me a cosy library setting and I’m immediately interested! I just wish that same charm had carried through into the rest of the story.
Ultimately, this was a book I was drawn to because of its beautiful appearance, but the story itself didn’t give me enough to connect with. I wanted more magic, more character development and a plot with a little more depth.
Sadly, this one wasn’t for me, and I wouldn’t recommend it. A case of judging a book by its gorgeous sprayed edges and being disappointed by what was inside. 📚
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Two’s A Charm was a bit of a mixed bag for me. It felt overly descriptive in places - sometimes it was a couple of pages before you got any dialogue, and I thought that some of the descriptions were unnecessarily detailed. It got to the point where I just skipped those kinds of pages and looked for when the dialogue started again, which is something I’ve never done with a book in recent memory.
However, once I got past those parts though, it was a good story. Loved how it was based off Wicked and this book added a very refreshing spin to it as well. Two’s A Charm was a fun book, but being too description heavy let it down a bit. If there was less of that in the story, I would’ve rated it higher.
This felt more YA than adult to me, but it was still a sweet and enjoyable read! It took a little while to get going, but I enjoyed how it all came together in the end. 💕
Two sisters with completely opposite personalities, both grieving the loss of their mother and finding their own ways to cope, alongside the difficult reality of people taking advantage of family. There was a lot of heart beneath the story, and by the end, it left me feeling warm and happy. 🥹❤️
Honestly, though, I wouldn’t really call this a Halloween read. 🎃 It felt much more like a heartwarming family story than a spooky seasonal read!
Unfortunately, Two's a Charm just wasn't for me. I kept waiting for the plot to pick up, but it felt like I was reading a slow burn where absolutely everything was a slow burn. The whole book dragged, and although there were moments when I thought, okay, this is actually getting somewhere, it never held my interest for long before sinking back into the same old routine.
The dialogue between the characters was probably the strongest part for me. There were moments of decent interaction, and I could see the potential in the story. Unfortunately, the constant inner monologue of Effie thinking Bonnie is selfish, Bonnie being selfish, and the two of them repeatedly judging each other became incredibly tiresome.
I also struggled to buy into their relationship as adult sisters. At times, it felt more like watching teenagers in high school, with all the mean-girl behaviour and assumptions about who thought what about whom. Yes, sisters fight. They misunderstand each other, get on each other's nerves and sometimes say hurtful things. But they also have good moments. I wanted to see more of that balance because, without it, their relationship felt unnecessarily distant for far too much of the book. We needed those glimpses of sisterhood to make their eventual reconciliation feel earned.
The Bonnie and Uncle Oswald collaboration could have created a much more compelling divide between the sisters. Instead, the conflict surrounding it didn't land as strongly as I hoped. I was particularly unconvinced by Effie, supposedly the more magically capable sister, failing to notice what was going on until Tessa essentially pointed it out to her. That felt like a convenient way to move the plot forward rather than a satisfying revelation. I wanted Effie to work things out for herself, and I needed the story to give me a convincing reason why she hadn't.
Then there were the little things that pulled me out of the story. The soggy pastry incident still bothers me. Why are we leaving a pastry on the bonnet of a truck in a torrential downpour? Make it make sense! And Bobby becoming Bobbie in two separate chapters? Surely that's the sort of inconsistency a proofreader should catch.
Ultimately, this book had potential, but it never quite came together for me. The plot dragged, the relationships didn't hit the way they should have, and I was left feeling more frustrated than invested.
Would I recommend it? No. Although, if you have an enemy who has wronged you and you fancy lending them a book that will slowly drain their will to read, I may have a suggestion. 😂
Two stars. It had its moments, but overall, it just didn't hit right for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I’ll admit, I first picked this up because the sprayed edition at The Works looked so cute, and after my surgery, I wanted something light and easy to read. I didn’t get to read Two’s A Cham as quickly as I’d have liked because life was a little chaotic as per usual but one afternoon whilst curled up under a blanket, I was off into the world of sisters, Effie and Bonnie.
I found in refreshing that both sisters are quite obnoxious and are flawed in their own way so neither of them are particularly the heroine of the story, and the tend to knock heads when it comes to their life because like a lot of siblings (I base this on my own children at various points as I’m an only child) they bicker constantly over the smallest things and are very different in the way they live their lives. The two are like light and dark, Effie is bookish, and Bonnie is very outgoing and unashamedly unapologetic over how she does things. Like another pair of extremely famous witches whose story hits the singer screen soon, who are very different and set in their ways? The sisters do have room to grow as the story unfolds.
I really liked how the main focal point of Two’s A Charm is the sisters and their journey of anger to acceptance, but the two sisters also have their own stories going on and this is where I found myself a little disappointed in the character development of the men in their lives. Effie who hasn’t had time for romance finds herself drawn to Theo but personally seemed like he could have easily been replaced by a cardboard character because there’s nothing about him except, he likes poetry and seems to always be where Effie is. I found myself wishing she’d just step out of her shell for herself and not a boy if I’m honest.
Bonnie’s story seemed to be thought out more and made me a little more invested in the story because I believed that a lot of her personality was a defence mechanism and that a lot of her anger towards her sister is misplaced. She’s far from a nice person and uses pretty much everyone around her, including Bobby who is infatuated with her. She’s got a point to prove, to herself and her family and I could easily see how she could be taken advantage of. Once again, I think Bonnie’s story could have benefited from some more depth and fleshing out to keep you invested in her life.
I did like that this was mainly focused on their journey and although again I think it could have been a bigger part of the story, their grief at the loss of their mother. They’re magical and I did love how differently the two used their craft to suit their lives but given that they’re witches and the magic is a large part of the story, I would have liked to see it more and perhaps the how and why explained more. This is a cute story, and I am glad I got it for that cold day when I needed a little escapism I just wish it had a little bit more to keep me fully invested, but if you want a swift cute book for spooky season -- Two’s A Charm is great for that kind of Wicked witchy feel.
What a treat! After reading horrors, thrillers, dark academia, and etc... for months, thus book was a much needed breath of fresh air, or I would even call it magical breath of air. It was an incredibly cosy and heartwarming read. Featuring a small town settings, sisterhood, a hit of magic, and a delightful 'he is sunshine and she is grumpy librarian' vibe, this book was absolutely perfect. If you like me and craving (specially this time of year) a soft blanket, a hot beverage and your favourite reading chair,you are sure to enjoy this book. I absolutely loved it!
Recommend-O-Meter: Good for a quick and fun read, though not as witchy as I’d hoped
The first thing to note is that I wouldn’t really label this as a hard romance. Like, sure there’s romance involved, but it’s very much not the focus of the book. Nothing wrong with that of course, but just a heads up!
Effie and Bonnie are rivals/sisters with magical gifts, though I’ll say this is more of a casual-book-that-happens-to-have-a-little-bit-of-magic situation rather than a full fledged fantasy. Think petty sibling fights with a little bit of the supernatural—Effie spelling the air more humid in order to ruin Bonnie’s hairdo, and the like.
None of the magic is really explained, though, save for that it was genetic and apparently only inherited on the women’s side of the family. Kinda a bummer for me, because I love magical worlds and wish this one had a bit more oomph to it. And aside from that, my biggest issue though is how high-school-clique-ish all the characters felt, even though they were supposedly well into their twenties.
Still, I enjoyed the book. I really like looking into family dynamics, so having a big focus on the sisters’ relationship (or lack thereof) was a plus for me. The calm unhurriedness of the story’s pacing was also good; after having read a couple of darker titles, this one was a nice little break from heaviness and complicated plot lines. It was like reading one of those old Disney live-action movies in book form, cliches galore and all.
Shoutout to all the Wizard of Oz references! Those bits were super fun to spot.
Audio Assessment: I don’t often read audibooks with dual narrators, but I think it was a good choice here considering the switching perspectives in each chapter. The voices were similar enough that it didn’t seem jarring, yet different enough to feel distinct, and both worked really well with the material in my opinion.
[I received an ALC of this book from the publisher on NetGalley. This does not in any way affect the contents of my review.]
Sisters Effie and Bonnie are opposites in every witchy way. Effie is calm, reserved and loves nothing more than burying her head in a book, and struggles a bit with things like self-worth and belief. Meanwhile, Bonnie is as dazzling as a diamond, poised and popular in all she does. Though, Bonnie sometimes does struggle with a bit of feeling inadequate in her magic being at the same level as Effie’s, and so when she is roped into a magical conspiracy by their estranged and reckless Uncle Oswald, her power is truly put to the test. She doesn’t want to ask Effie for help—determined to demonstrate her worth—yet behind his plan lays something truly wicked.
Effie doesn’t often step out of her comfort zone, happiest when she is around the simple things she loves and has a hold on, her magic, her books, and things that appease her introverted ways (that, we have in common tenfold.) But when she senses something peculiar spreading across Yellowbrick Grove, she doesn’t think that Bonnie will be at the heart of the darkness taking over town, wrapped in a plot she has no control over. She knows she has to step out of her place of safety for the sake of Bonnie, who’s magic is being tainted. The sisters are pulled together into something that unravels their suppressed grief, pushes them to confront their differences and reconnect their way through something as a team once and for all.
Overall, Two’s A Charm was quaintly cosy, bursting with feel-good sentiments and is entirely wonderfully witchy from start to finish. I adored Effie and Bonnie, more so Effie at the beginning but leant more toward Bonnie as the book went on. The atmosphere of the book was very reminiscent of things I have long adored—Wicked, Sabrina the Teenage Witch, and The Wizard of Oz. I loved the reflections of Glinda and Elphaba in Effie and Bonnie, and also how much that cosy feel of the book reminded me of Stars Hollow in Gilmore Girls. It bends more so into contemporary fantasy than romance, but there were still some romantic sparkles throughout. I left the book feeling like I’d read something wholesomely magical, setting Halloween week off in the most charmed way that made my heart feel full. An amazing story that I simply loved.
Autumnal vibes and magical mishaps abound in this cosy (and witchy) small town Romantasy that I couldn’t get enough of!
Firstly I absolutely loved Heather Spellman’s prose which was warm, whimsical and brimming with humour. The small town setting (called Yellowbrick Grove, a little nod to Wicked and Wizard of Oz) was lovely too, and added to the cosy, nostalgic Gilmore Girls meets Sabrina The Teenage Witch vibes. (Along with the romance involving town newcomer, Theo, which was soo adorable.)
But it was our Elphaba and Glinda-coded protagonists, sisters Effie and Bonnie, that really made this a standout read for me.
Differing in their personalities and approaches to life (Effie bookish and practical, Bonnie spontaneous and outgoing) we really delve into the complex and often contradictory bonds of sisterhood, which I really enjoyed. As the youngest of three sisters myself, I found their dynamics soo relatable.
Though, I did find Effie the easiest sister to connect with. Living in the shadow of her popular sister, she really struggles with her self worth. And, with the grief of losing her mother, (and her constant need for control) her reactions really brought a sense of depth that had me even more invested.
But I liked Bonnie too, and felt she underwent the biggest and most satisfying transformation; being more self reliant, confident (in taking on more responsibility) and realising how her actions affect others.
Of course (in typical witchy Rom-com fashion) it takes some serious magical misfires to get Effie and Bonnie to finally communicate. But once they do, (acknowledging feelings and reconciling differences) they make such an amazing team!
Overall, a heartwarming read exploring grief, friendship, sisterhood and love that fans of Sarah Hawley, Lucy Jane Wood or Erin Stirling should consider checking out.
Also, thanks to Bookbreak/ Pan MacMillan for the proof.
Two's a charm ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5) A nice cozy witchy read. I enjoyed it though most of the times I was frustrated with Bonnie and then Effie top later...but thankfully they settled their differences and came together! It's more of the story of two sisters with a dash of romance for both of them, I was totally rooting for Theo and Effie and Tessa too! Loved when they found the cats in the library! But some of the parts and interactions did feel very highschooley, And I wished the talk of settling their disagreements would've been more through. But despite it all, I enjoyed it!
Thanks Netgalley and publisher for providing me an ALC of this book!
Thank you to Anne from Random Things Tours for having me on the the Blog Tour.
The Chalmer Sisters are witches but they couldn’t be more different. Bookish introvert Effie would rather curl up with a good book and is the complete opposite to popular Bonnie who exudes confidence and is popular with everyone in town.
Bonnie is eager to prove her magic is just as good as Effie’s and decides to collaborate with her Uncle Oswald in a magical scheme to help the town and their businesses. But things don’t go as planned and soon Bonnie is out of her depth. But will her pride win over her asking her judgemental sister for help.
Overall this was a good read. It’s not as witchy filled as I thought it would be. It centres more on grief and familial issues. Effie is a hard character to like but you eventually understand why she is so prickly.
The townsfolk are all quirky and fun to read about and this definitely has the small town vibes we all love to read about.
A cozy magical story that follows two sisters who couldn’t be more different.
I had fun reading it but there were some things that bothered me. Both Effie and Bonnie keep making the same mistakes over and over again without and character growth. It did feel a bit repetitive. Both sisters didn’t really resolve their issues and just skipped to the happily ever after. I wished that topics like their shared grief would have been talked about more in depth.
Not really a halloween read as this isn't really spooky- it gave more Sabrina the teenage witch vibes, if Sabrina had a sister. Having lost their mother, both sisters who are total opposites are dealing with it in their own way. This very much looks at sisterly dynamics, a touch of romance and who is really family. Took a few chapters to get into it but it was quite heartwarming by the end. CAWPILE 5.86 3.5 STARS
I found this a very cosy read. I really enjoyed the characters and the plot. I think it started off slowly, but it did gradually build. I particularly enjoyed the dual POV ☺️
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan for the audiobook ARC in exchange for an honest review. The audiobook was an absolute pleasure to listen to! The story is simply perfect for a rainy day—when all you want is a cozy blanket and a warm cup of tea. As someone with a sister, I found many of the situations both relatable and emotionally authentic. It’s a wonderful fantasy to unwind with after a long, hard day.
Of course, there are also touches of romance, which I happily would have taken even more of—they were all so sweet! The narrators truly stole my heart; their performances were engaging, expressive, and never monotonous. Definitely recommending!
Two’s a Charm is a cosy and magical read about two very different witchy sisters learning to work together. I loved the blend of family drama, small-town charm, and gentle humour throughout. Effie and Bonnie’s relationship felt real — full of rivalry, warmth, and heart. The story balances emotion and whimsy beautifully, making it a perfect comfort read for fantasy fans who enjoy stories about sisterhood and second chances.
Thanks to Macmillan via NetGalley for providing an ARC
TWO'S A CHARM is definitely a cozy book, I'll say that. I love cozy. I don't need action or intense tension. But the pace is so slow and the characters are too flat for me to stay invested in the story. The writing is fine and the narrators are wonderful--you won't ever catch me say a single bad word about Kristen DiMercurio--and they certainly foster the cozy atmosphere. But unfortunately, there just isn't enough happening! The synopsis promises "Within a day, Bonnie’s spells start misfiring and Effie notices something sinister taking root" - um... when exactly? I gave up on this book half-way through and yes, spells misfire, but they always do that for Bonnie, even before the story starts. It's her whole thing. Also, who allowed so many B names in the cast? Bonnie, Bobbie, Bowow, and more.
TL;DR: Nice premise, perhaps the book is just too bloated for it the plot to take off in time
Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan for the audiobook ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Two's A Charm is a story about two sisters who are dealing not only with their mother's passing, but years of unspoken frustrations about one another. So what happens when one gets in over their head and is too stubborn and afraid to share their struggles? Absolute chaos...
I was excited by the promise of a new witchy book with a dose of romance as well as sisterhood themes, but unfortunately I found this very slow. It's full of miscommunication and passive aggressive silence that leads to lack of understanding which is okay for the beginning of a story, but that's the entire narrative. It felt repetitive and I just kept waiting for something new to happen to push the conflict and plot forward.
The romance is sudden and not super developed, though I did appreciate the librarian vibes from Effie and the quick comebacks she has for Theo. It did feel like her personality only was shown during their interactions though, and any other time it's her POV she's harsh and withdrawn. She had a lot of potential, as she's clearly feeling left out and low in self confidence, but this is never shown to us - just told over and over again. Bonnie felt more rounded as a character and so it was a bit easier to connect with her.
The townspeople have a lot of charm, and this was easily the best part of the book for me. I loved the quirky characteristics for each - the dog lover, the lawn obsessed, the darts crew... It was such fun to read about them!
The ending was very quick and left a lot of (fairly problematic) issues unresolved/unexplained, but I did like how everyone comes together. However, even by the end I was left questioning the magic of this world. Are there other witches? It seems so by the stack of magical items in Effie's basement room, but maybe not? There were just a lot of gaps in the story that I wish were filled...
Two’s A Charm was a really sweet read. There’s Effie, who appears to be more put together and levelheaded, and then there’s Bonnie, who flies by the seat of her pants and does whatever she wants to do in the moment, without giving consequences a second thought. Given the two completely opposite personalities, the sisters clash and have a tough time agreeing on practically everything. Another layer is the level of experience the sisters have; Effie appears to have a really good handle on her magic abilities, while Bonnie struggles. It puts even more of a wedge between them.
What made it a sweet read is how both women have their own crosses to bear and overcome, and ultimately figure out that it takes the support from one another to make that happen. Bonnie is outgoing and social, while Effie can’t be bothered–but in order to succeed in life, both professionally and personally, she needs to open up more. And Effie knows about order, which helps to keep out the chaos–something Bonnie needs to learn. It’s a big reason she decides to join forces with Uncle Oswald, because she wants more than anything to be accepted by Effie, to be told that she’s done a good job. Only, Oswald has his own motivations for his nasty scheme, and Bonnie finds that she’s only dug herself a really deep hole she can’t get out of.
I thought the scheme was well described and the outcome it has on Yellowbrick Grove really showed in the changes the townspeople experience. Bonnie keeps telling herself that what’s happening around her really isn’t as bad as she thinks it might be, a slippery slope that only makes her delve deeper into Oswald’s motives. Effie notices the changes, but can’t put her finger on what’s changed or what’s going on. Thrown into the mix is a potential romance for Effie, which is completely out of character for her, and makes no sense to Bonnie, who is usually the one who lands herself in relationships.
From the scheming, the magic, and Effie’s new relationship, both characters begin to change. Bonnie has to stand up to Oswald and really, to everyone who has put her in the role as the town’s affable girl, who never takes complaint with anything or anyone, and never really speaks up for who she is and what she wants. Effie needs to realize that it’s OK to rely on other people and seek out support, even if it’s the last thing she instinctively wants to do. The steps the two women take in reversing the magical mishap was fun to read, along with watching just how much the two grow, not just as individuals, but as sisters.
I received this audiobook for free from Netgalley & Macmillan.
First off, this should not be marketed as a romance, this was a story about 2 sisters who were also witches. The romance was in the background, and it helped one of the sisters out.
I'm gonna be frank with you, Bonnie was doing my head in so much in this book! I was ready to smack some sense into her from the very first chapter. Then really wanted to smack her again in the second chapter (her first POV chapter). This was genuinely my first note: "Bonnie is pissing me off!". Followed by "Madam, he doesn't like you! Move on!" Then it took her way too long to figure out the consequences of her actions. It didn't help with how long it took her to admit it. I was not a fan of her chapters, but I had to give it to the author and narrator for making me want to deck her. She took way too long to get there, but... I can't believe I'm writing this... when she explained herself (and from bits here and there), I got it. I understood. **sighs** **grumbles** I still wanna smack her a bit. **grumbles**
As much as I liked Effie, she was in her head too much and just needed a push in the right direction. Although, I understood where she was coming from, I could definitely relate to her. By the end of the book, as expected both sisters learnt from their mistakes and actually grew closer together.
On to the narrators, Georgina Sadler and Kristen DiMercurio, they delivered, emoted properly and had distinct voices. I don't know how I hadn't noticed there were 2 different narrators until this very moment writing this paragraph. I guess that's a testament to both of them, since I've been played by a few audiobooks with dual narrators.
At the end of the day, it was nice seeing the sisters finally work things out at the end.
If you're looking for a cozy, magical escape with a touch of family drama, "Two's a Charm" might just be the audiobook you need! Heather Spellman weaves a fun, lighthearted story about two sisters, Effie and Bonnie, who couldn't be more different and yet, they're forced to team up when their uncle’s spellcasting schemes turn everything upside down.
I really loved how the dynamic between the two sisters felt so real. Effie is the quiet, bookish type who’d rather keep her nose in a spellbook than deal with family drama, while Bonnie’s the wild one, always getting into trouble. Their banter and the way they learn to work together was both funny and heartwarming. It reminded me a bit of those “opposites attract” sibling bonds, which always pull at my heartstrings.
The narrators, Georgina Sadler and Kristen DiMercurio, did a fantastic job of bringing the characters to life. Each sister had such a distinct voice, and the dual narration really made the emotional moments hit harder. I could picture Effie’s cautious nature and Bonnie’s impulsive energy perfectly, thanks to the narrators' performances.
The magic system isn’t the most complex, but I didn’t mind that it’s more about the characters and their relationships, with a touch of quirky spells thrown in. The small-town setting really added to the charm, and I loved the lighthearted tone, even when things started getting a little tense with the family secrets and magical mishaps.
It wasn’t the most groundbreaking fantasy, but it was exactly what I needed something fun, cozy, and just a little bit magical. If you’re a fan of books with witchy vibes and sibling dynamics, this one is definitely worth checking out. Plus, the narrators make it such an enjoyable experience, I didn’t want it to end!
I enjoyed (mostly) listening to this audiobook. Did I get frustrated at Bonnie for some of her poor choices and not really thinking through it all before doing something she knew was a bit shady, since it was Oswald it brought it up to her? Yes, yes I did. Though if I thought of the sisters as in their early twenties, then a bit could be forgiven and I understood more of why Bonnie acted the way she did. Plus, some of her magical messes were quite funny. It balanced Effie (though I definitely liked her better and understood her way of living) who was more mature, though a bit oblivious to romance, and I would love to work in the library with her! This story was a nice slice of life in a small town with real magic and witches helping things along, sometimes sneakily, and sometimes saving the day (after causing the catastrophe in the first place! lol) and figuring out how to keep going after their mother's death and work together as sisters instead of clashing and hiding hex bags in each other's possessions.
Lighthearted, humorous, with a good message of working together, not taking the easy way to make money (Oswald is awful!), seeing the love in front of your nose, and the importance of memories of loved ones, plus a ghost in the library, hexed hair straighteners, and dog wrangling! Not quite perfect but an enjoyable book to listen to. The narrators, Georgina Sadler and Kristen DiMercurio, did a great job in bringing the sisters and their town of Yellowbrick Grove to life. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me a chance to laugh and enjoy my way through this audiobook.
I explicitly picked this book up because I thought I was going to hate it and I was so painfully correct. This book is just the definition of a book that exploits the common sales pitch line (i.e. Wicked meets Gilmore Girls) for the sake of upping sales and not for the sake of telling an actually compelling or engaging story. It attempts to do what it says on the tin, but lacks any understanding of the original characters and so therefore strips them down bare to their core archetypes, adding absolutely nothing else of substance. Moreover, it strips down the complex relationship between Glinda and Elphaba - or Bonnie and Effie whatever - to a sisterhood in which the only feeling is unadulterated loathing and nothing else. I’m just infuriated by the lack of effort and the brazen audacity to just lift things from the source material for the sake of a zombie-fied approximation that feels starkly like fan fiction. To be clear, I respect fan fiction and I even respect fan fiction that makes its way into the trad market after some creative retooling for the sake of copyright. These stories can sometimes be impressive for what they are and have enough substance to sustain themselves. But this is just creative media cannibalism, a hastily drawn copy with some taped on modifications rather than a story that dares to say “Yes and …”. I know I chose to read this, but for the fact these sort of formulaic cash grabs on pop culture are increasingly a thing, especially in the romance genre, I have to say I have zero regrets.