From bitter beginnings to dark secrets….
Book Information
“The Lodge” by Sue Watson is a 350-page mystery/thriller with a planned publication date of October 24, 2023. The audio version is narrated by Tamsin Kennard & Alison Campbell. It spans 9 hours and 34 minutes. Thank you to Bookouture Audio for providing me with an advance reader copy of this book for review.
Summary
A couple of days ago, the Wilson family arrived at a grand Lodge perched on a cliff by the sea, hoping for a peaceful reunion. But not everyone was thrilled. The new wife had trust issues, the ex-wife felt jealous, and the mother-in-law was interfering. The husband, caught in the middle, had been keeping a dark secret. It’s a powder keg---and there are plenty of sparks.
My Thoughts
"The Lodge" by Sue Watson is a book that presents a compelling premise with a lot of potential for mystery, suspense, and psychological thrills. However, my reading of the book might be somewhat of an outlier, as many others have reviewed it very favorably. It seems like this is one of those cases where a book just doesn't resonate with everyone, as I didn't enjoy it as much as others did.
On the positive side, the book boasts an engaging premise set in a beautiful and well-thought-out environment. The prose and language used are commendable, and the technical aspects of the writing are well-executed. If you're a fan of books heavy on family dynamics, and unreliable narrators, or enjoy exploring insecure and manipulative characters, you might find this novel appealing. The story is skillfully told through the dual perspectives of the wife and the ex-wife, a narrative technique that effectively propels the plot forward. In the audio version of the book, the two narrators did an excellent job of conveying the story, especially considering the numerous characters involved.
However, there were aspects of the book that I didn't enjoy as much. The first half of the book proved to be quite a challenge to get through. It consisted of pages and pages, as well as chapters and chapters, that portrayed two women as insecure, petty, insulting, bitter, and snide. While character development is crucial, I found this part to be overwhelming and overdone.
In most books, establishing a connection between the reader and the characters is key. Unfortunately, in "The Lodge," that connection didn't happen for me. Instead, I either disliked or grew tired of the characters to the point where I didn't care if they survived the story.
The second half of the story redeemed itself with numerous reveals, twists, turns, and new information, though it did become somewhat repetitive. It transitioned from being twisty to convoluted, and I was frustrated with how even an incompetent police force should have been able to resolve the book's initial conflict in a matter of minutes, thus preventing the issues that arose later in the story.
The ending might come as a shock to some readers, but I had already assumed the identity of the guilty party, even though the specifics around it were somewhat different from what I had initially thought.
Recommendation
While "The Lodge" holds promise with its engaging premise and skillful writing, it may not be a perfect fit for those who struggle with a slow start or have difficulty connecting with the characters. On the other hand, if you're a fan of books that delve deep into family dynamics, employ unreliable narrators, and explore the complexities of insecure and manipulative characters, this novel might just be your cup of tea. Personally, though, it didn't quite hit the mark for me.
Rating
2.5 Snowy Stars