Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Cruelty of Nice Folks: On Being Black in America's Liberal Heartland

Rate this book
A revelatory look at one of America's most progressive cities—Minneapolis—as journalist Justin Ellis returns to his hometown to grapple with the quiet history of white supremacy there in the wake of George Floyd’s murder, and in turn uncovers his family’s story of surviving “Minnesota nice.”

It’s the “North,” they like to say, not the Midwest. It’s different. We’re nice here, progressive; Minneapolis is a city for everyone. But in 2020, George Floyd’s murder by police left many Americans stunned and wondering, “how could this happen in Minneapolis?” To Ellis, the real question is what made people think it couldn’t?

The Minneapolis Justin Ellis knows and loves—where he grew up and his family has lived for generations—is not the idealistic metropolis that its politicians and its most vocal proponents proclaim. The city of lakes was built on discrimination—in its housing, its schools, its politics—much like all other American cities. Black families were systematically cut out of the prosperous neighborhoods, lush parks and pristine lakes that make Minneapolis a haven of the heartland. Because of its image as a liberal ally in the fight for civil rights, Minneapolis has rarely been forced to confront this fact. In reality, as in the rest of America since its founding, the struggles of Black families in Minnesota have been celebrated or erased in an effort to maintain neighborly harmony and the quality of life Minnesotans cherish above all else.

The Cruelty of Nice Folks is both an indictment of the false face of progressivism and a love letter to the ways Black life has thrived despite the forces working against it. From the original theft of land upon which Minneapolis was built, through his family’s journey to establish a life there, to George Floyd’s murder, The Cruelty of Nice Folks is about one place—but it’s also about America. It is the story of a racial reckoning deferred, and of an America that remains tethered to the inequalities it has always been unwilling to confront.

432 pages, Hardcover

Published June 16, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Justin Ellis

12 books15 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
102 (45%)
4 stars
86 (38%)
3 stars
34 (15%)
2 stars
2 (<1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
Profile Image for Cole.
270 reviews79 followers
July 19, 2026
Thank you Harper Books for the #gifted copy in exchange for an honest review! #HarperBooksPartner

Despite its claims to be “the North, not the Midwest” because of its progressiveness, Minneapolis is a case study in the cruelty of nice folks. Despite being one of America’s most progressive cities, a number of examples of overt racism can be traced back to the city. The 2020 murder of George Floyd (rightfully) left the world in shock, but Justin Ellis asks why couldn't it happen in Minneapolis? After all, the murder of Philando Castile happened just a few years before.Tracing the through-line from a city built on discrimination and redlining to the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder, Justin Ellis offers an indictment of progressivism and a story of Black resilience.

Justin Ellis does a phenomenal job of forcing the reader to sit in the cognitive dissonance of progressive racism. It’s a data-driven mirror held up to the face of a city refusing to look, and a necessary follow up to what, if anything, has changed in the wake of George Floyd’s murder. With touches of his own family’s story and vulnerability of growing up Black in the liberal heartland, this book is a provocative and compelling read necessary for everyone to understand the sociopolitical context of racism in the U.S.

Reviewed as part of an #ARC from the publisher.

Read this book if you:
🌽have ever used the term “Midwest nice”
🧠 want to continue with independent study in critical race theory, despite the attacks
📣protested the murder of George Floyd

Follow me on Instagram for more book reviews!
Profile Image for S.
295 reviews31 followers
July 10, 2026
This is a meticulously researched, well-written hybrid history and memoir. My one bone to pick is that the last year of ICE-based violence is only the epilogue (last 30 or so pages of a 400+ page book), and while very astutely depicted could have been expanded upon. Alternatively, if that were to be a book itself, the subtitle of this one should’ve been more specific—why George Floyd’s murder is the story of America—rather than only “Minneapolis.”
Profile Image for Laura.
364 reviews36 followers
June 2, 2026
Overall, this book was well written. There are some editing errors, but I assume that will be fixed for publication. At times it rambled a bit, but it was well researched and provided an overview of race relations in Minneapolis, how they got to the point of George Floyd's murder, and what (if anything) has been done since.

I give it 3.5 stars.
Profile Image for Relena_reads.
1,258 reviews16 followers
July 26, 2026
Ellis's mixing of personal memoir and Twin Cities history was largely very successful. This is an important story and his deep family roots within MSP allowed him to use his history as a vessel to make the more abstract aspects of redlining and city planning be grounded in specifics. Ellis is able to carry us through how systems preserve inequity, even as people attempt to feel better about their personal actions, through both large-scale data and personal anecdotes.

Ellis's family arrived in the Twin Cities via the Great Migration, which is the majority experience for Black families in the area, but the thing that felt missing to me was a discussion of the experience of African-immigrants, especially Somali-Americans, in this story. While they aren't quite half of the Black population in MSP, they're almost there, and while the things that were occurring during the Humphrey's era certainly impacted them, their experience is much more contemporary and obviously part of the discussion in the Epilogue that was focused on the ICE surge under Trump. Ellis would likely have been a child during much of the Somali immigration to the cities and therefore shielded from cultural growing pains, but the Minnesota Historical Society has oral history resources from this population that Ellis could have used as he spent time there during his research. This is not to say that Ellis's story is not important on its own, but I would have liked to see time spent here to make it fuller for the modern Twin Cities.

I really appreciated Ellis's personal narration of this audiobook. I'm sure it was supremely difficult for him to relive the loss of his mother as he was narrating, but it also made the entire story more poignant and powerful.

Massive thanks to NetGalley for this audioARC!
Profile Image for Craig.
232 reviews2 followers
September 29, 2026
I admit I skimmed some of the personal stories the author shared about his family’s multiple homes, etc. But the strength of this book is tied to that personal connection. A black family trying to do what you have to do to “make it” in Minneapolis. And the city’s stubborn insistence that “all is good.” When it clearly is not. Enough history is shared and the George Floyd murder looms large in understanding the catch22 dilemma facing blackness in a liberal city. Exceptional book, that living in Minnesota and being reminded of the trauma was at once hard to read and yet took me less than a day to finish. The epilogue (re: invasion of Minneapolis and the response of Minnesotans) causes outrage to flare again, followed by a sense of hope.?
Profile Image for Katherine.
751 reviews6 followers
June 24, 2026
4.5/5 thought the mix of memoir and history was awesome. just a really important book! esp for those of us in the midwest
Profile Image for Marie.
Author 84 books146 followers
October 31, 2026
One author's exploration of the history of racial strife in Minneapolis and how it shapes the current era, including an intimate look at his own family's history in the area. It made me hungry for more longitudinal studies of generational wealth transfer... how many generations have to start over because of redlining, eminent domain, and other policies that make up "racism without racists."
Profile Image for Taylor (T-bag).
357 reviews6 followers
June 20, 2026
I think this is Justin’s debut writing and I’m so impressed! Lots of MN history, including recent history.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ALC in exchange for my honest review.
227 reviews4 followers
August 3, 2026
Ellis is a good story teller as he weaves his own 5 generation Mpls Black family history in his search for why Mpls 'nice' folks have been able to look away for generations from institutional racism.

The myth in MN starts with taking land from the natives and writing our history of brave, hardy settlers coming to a new, empty land. Ellis asks us to consider if whether the claim to a higher, progressive standard by Minnesotans was largely because initially there were few Blacks in MN.

Other larger northern cities showed their racism as the great migration brought thousands of Blacks looking for a better life. Mpls was quietly ensuring through real estate covenants that the Blacks would be restricted from 'white' neighborhoods.

George Floyd and another dozen incidents of white PD brutality against Blacks followed by rage and burning was an inevitable cycle given that politicians talked about equity but knew they would be voted out if neighborhoods were integrated.

Part of the covenant was that a white PD would ensure that Black rage stayed outside of nice neighborhoods, and in turn politicians would allow PD to protect themselves from accountability.

It's a bit repetitive as times but perhaps that's part of the msg - the white folks have access to the american dream - work hard; move your family to a nicer neighborhood with better schools and parks; see your home investment increase in value each generation (McKibben described this in his book about growing up in Lexington, MA where Blacks were also blocked entry).

The ICE shootings and protests occur just as he is finishing his 5 year book write and so he has to add an epilogue.

If you grew up In the Twin Cities, it's a 5 star read.

My family was 3 generations North Side, Mpls. We and the cousins moved to the suburbs with better schools around the time it became illegal to put a restriction in the house deed preventing non-whites from buying.

As Ellis documents, despite the communities of Blacks in pockets in both South and North Mpls, neither my spouse (South) nor I (North) ever saw any Blacks in our neighborhoods or schools.
852 reviews15 followers
July 14, 2026
The Cruelty of Nice Folks is an insightful, deeply researched, and emotionally resonant examination of race, place, and the often-overlooked contradictions within America's self-image. Justin Ellis uses Minneapolis as both a specific case study and a broader lens through which to explore how inequality can persist beneath a reputation for progressivism.

One of the book's greatest strengths is its balance of personal memoir and historical investigation. Ellis intertwines his family's experiences with the city's history, creating a narrative that feels both intimate and expansive. The result is a work that is as much about lived experience as it is about policies, institutions, and historical patterns.

What makes the book especially compelling is its willingness to challenge comforting assumptions. Rather than focusing only on overt acts of discrimination, Ellis examines how exclusion, inequality, and systemic barriers can exist within communities that view themselves as welcoming and socially conscious. This nuanced approach encourages readers to think more critically about the relationship between reputation and reality.

The historical research is exceptional. From housing policies and urban development to education and civic life, Ellis demonstrates how past decisions continue to shape present-day opportunities and outcomes. These connections are presented with clarity, making complex historical and social issues accessible without sacrificing depth.

Equally important is the humanity at the heart of the narrative. While the book confronts painful realities, it also celebrates the resilience, strength, and enduring contributions of Black families and communities who built meaningful lives despite persistent obstacles. That balance gives the work both emotional power and lasting significance.
169 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
February 22, 2026
Justin Ellis grew up in Minneapolis. It’s a city he knows well. His family has lived there for several generations. And it is a city he loves as well. The death of George Floyd on Memorial Day 2020 changed the story of both Minneapolis and Minnesota that many people like Ellis had come to believe. Minneapolis no longer felt like a comfortable home. As the author observes “life in Minneapolis had been upended.” Ellis is also an experienced journalist with experience in electronic and print venues. He presently works as projects editor for Defector, an employee-owned media company, where he oversees podcasts. He was encouraged to define his emotional reaction to George Floyd and present-day Minneapolis. This new book does seem like a true memoir in many respects. It is a non-fiction account of Ellis’ life in Minnesota; and it is a subjective narrative account relating some of his personal experiences. But it seems much more than mere memoir. Ellis is sincerely trying to emotionally understand just how Minneapolis turned out to be such a contradictory place. What he once saw as a progressive bastion and a center for art and humanities enjoying midwesterners had begun to be something dramatically different. And definitely much more threatening. The first chapter identifies the dilemma of what Minneapolis might be as Ellis calls a focus on “good intentions.” But even the hoped for good intentions have negatively affected many of the Black residents of the city and raises real concerns for this author as interested observer. Highly recommended to the reader who wants an honest and serious examination of modern community and social relations.
295 reviews
September 21, 2026
Ellis returned to Minneapolis in the winter of 2020 to help care for his mother, who was dying of cancer, and to find out more about his family history. The sections about his family relationships are moving and poignant. Unfortunately, he couldn't find out much about his history so instead he turned to the history of Minnesota in general and Minneapolis in particular. What he uncovers is despicable white folks who have done everything possible to hold on to their privilege while denying progress to anyone else. White liberals are especially awful because they pretend to be helpful but only make things worse. No white person has done anything right according to Ellis. Their hypocrisy and cruelty are demonstrated particularly in the aftermath of the George Floyd murder, but their reprehensible conduct extends back to the time when they first set foot in Minnesota territory. Even white folks who seemingly tried to do good were ineffective and awful. Apparently the only hope lies with Black people, who have justice and righteousness on their side. If you are white and want to feel terrible about your collective past and pessimistic about the future, this book is for you. I kept reading in the hope that there might be a glimmer of positivity. Nope. Guilt and shame go only so far before sinking into despair.
Profile Image for Liv.
228 reviews
July 6, 2026
Sometimes books don't need a global scope to get their message across. The Cruelty of Nice Folks focuses on Minnesota, and Ellis' experiences of growing up, and those of his family. It speaks of community, but also hardship, discrimination, and the struggle of survival in society poised to keep one "in their lane." Both emotionally resonant, and informative, Nice Folks features a wealth of quotes and sources, while also remaining incredibly personal. It's at times a challenging read, accessibly written, but also requires acknowledgement that even when racism isn't overt and buried under "Minnesota Nice", it's still there, and the impacts are still incredibly deep and destructive. I'd absolutely recommend this book to those interested in history, or memoirs. It features a description of the George Floyd murder, but also on Floyd as a person, and community member, not just a victim of police violence. The epilogue covers the recent events involving ICE in Minnesota, and leaves us with the question, what now? This isn't a book that promises to give all the solutions, but one that tries to make sure the reader is better informed and encourages them to dig deeper.
Profile Image for tinamarie.
12 reviews
October 24, 2026
Justin Ellis does a great job of interlacing Minnesota’s current and historical relationship with Black Americans and his personal experiences with his family, with his state and with his country. I absolutely adored his mom and his devotion to her.

At several points while reading I thought, why isn’t he more angry, I am angry reading this. But then I thought, maybe that’s the point? That, outside of the police (particularly in the murder of George Floyd), the racial injustice was much more subtle; masked by an insincere kindness that you just “couldn’t quite put your finger on” but knew it was there. Still, this doesn’t make it any less insidious. One could argue that this is worse than the in-your-face, out-in-the-open racism of the South. I do not know if that is true or not but I do foresee that Minnesota is about to have this comparison directly. It is looking like the in-your-face, out-in-the-open racism is coming for Minnesota.

I won this book as a Goodreads giveaway and I’m so happy I did. I also bought the Audible version so I could listen while driving. Ellis narrates it and that gives it even more of s personal feel.
Profile Image for Tiffany.
112 reviews2 followers
August 15, 2026
Thanks NetGalley for the ARC audio!

This should be required reading in high schools. Such an important book. Thoroughly researched. At first, I struggled a bit with a memoir feel combined with extensive research, but it ended up meshing really well for me in the end. There were a few moments where it was a little dry in the first third of the book, just because I am not from Minnesota, so I was not familiar with some of the things that he was talking about. That said, everyone can understand systemic racism, and the effects it has on black and brown bodies. I appreciated the information on who George Floyd actually was and learning about him versus just focusing on his death. It hurt my heart even more to learn the type of human he truly was. I also appreciated the afterward mentioning ICE, as that happened after the author had written the book. Such an impactful and powerful read. All white folks need to read this.
75 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
April 24, 2026
The Cruelty of Nice Folks: Why Minneapolis Is the Story of America for the Sad Beige Parent is a sharp, thought-provoking read that uses Minneapolis as a lens to examine broader American contradictions—especially the gap between outward politeness and deeper structural harm. Justin Ellis blends cultural critique with storytelling in a way that feels both accessible and unsettling, peeling back the “nice” veneer to reveal the complexities underneath.

What makes the book stand out is its willingness to sit in discomfort while still being engaging and readable. It doesn’t offer easy answers, but instead challenges readers to rethink assumptions about kindness, community, and what “nice” actually means in practice. A compelling pick for anyone interested in cultural analysis with a distinctly modern, critical edge.
Profile Image for Crystal Toller.
1,202 reviews10 followers
October 22, 2026
This is a part memoir part nonfiction history of how a progressive state like Minnesota discriminated against its Black residents. It begins with the killing of George Floyd and in the epilogue details the ICE operation in Minnesota. Incidentally the title of my book is The Cruelty of Nice Folks: Why Minneapolis Is the Story of America in hardback which I got from the library. The author details the beginning of discrimination with the redlining covenants that were adopted when black people tried to move into white neighborhoods. This is a real history lesson for those of us who know nothing about Minneapolis and shows how even enlightened people are not so enlightened. I really enjoyed reading this book and learned a lot.
381 reviews7 followers
Read
September 15, 2026
Woah!

I was expecting a relatively dry history of Black folks in Minnesota from a decolonial framework, which would have been fine! But what I got was better. Ellis digs into history, but the book is just as much about the present and uses the George Floyd killing as a linchpin to analyze contemporary racism and politics in the state. It's also deeply personal. Ellis talks about his own family and his mother's struggle with cancer. I was really impressed at how he was able to tie it all together. And the actions of folks in the book made a lot more sense when you're given so much historical context. It's a really thought-provoking and emotionally resonant work.
Profile Image for Suzanne thebookblondie.
295 reviews59 followers
November 8, 2026
📖Nonfiction November

The author, Justin Ellis, recounts his return to his hometown of Minneapolis right after the murder of George Floyd. He juxtaposes the nostalgia of his childhood with the police brutality and pervasive white supremacy that plague Minneapolis during this tome. Ellis finds himself reckoning with the truth of how Black Americans are systemically put at a disadvantage despite the idealistic childhood he remembers.

Ellis’s book was quotable and deeply reflective, often drawing on civil rights history in connection with the progressivism Minneapolis had boasted and the inequalities the city was forced to confront after Floyd’s murder.
Profile Image for Rachel Martinez.
76 reviews1 follower
September 14, 2026
I received a free copy of this book via Goodreads giveaway.

Interesting combination of the state of Minnesota and city of Minneapolis’ racial history, the story of George Floyd, and the author’s own family’s story in the state. At times I found myself a little confused by overly complex wording, mostly in the historical and modern-history sections; there is room for some light editing for spelling errors and missing words, and I am missing a page from the epilogue lol! Overall decent non-fiction book.
Profile Image for Meleah.
268 reviews1 follower
October 12, 2026
A powerful account of a man raised in Minneapolis who travels back to his hometown after a police officer murdered George Floyd. While there, he researches the racial history of his city and state, which has prided itself on its imagine as a progressive and liberal place. This book raises really profound points about power, community, personal and collective sacrifice, performative allyship, and the lack of value our country places on the lives of Black people. I was struck by the deep exploration of societal and political reform, as well as the critical need for personal introspection.
Profile Image for Alex Carlson.
410 reviews1 follower
November 7, 2026
Book #45 of 2026

This should be essential reading for Minnesotans as it both celebrates our state's progressive history, but also acknowledges the flaws. In a big picture sense, this is how history lessons should be taught. This book offers plenty of evidence that Minnesota has been ahead of the curve in promoting equality and inclusion, but there have been many mistakes made along the way - some due to neglect, others due to outright cruelty. I learned a lot and I will definitely revisit this book again.
Profile Image for J.J..
3,011 reviews23 followers
July 20, 2026
I learned a lot of Minnesota history and politics, especially redlining, and how it ultimately played a part in George Floyd's murder. I also think the author did a great job interweaving the life of his mother and her experiences, as her death was approaching, with all that was going external to the hospital. I think this was why I didn't give it all 5 stars, because I would have preferred 2 seperate stories. I wanted to know more about both.
72 reviews2 followers
September 28, 2026
And exceptionally well-written and researched history of Minnesota – especially of the Twin Cities, and Minneapolis in particular – combined with a personal memoir and family history across many generations. As a Twin Cities resident for most of my life, I appreciated learning about the political roots of our shared identity, and how that has influenced our response, or lack thereof, to an increasingly urgent need for racial reckoning and meaningful, systemic change.
408 reviews3 followers
September 29, 2026
I listened to this book. It’s a good book that covers the history of Blacks in Minnesota-particularly in Minneapolis. Redlining of housing caused blacks to live on the North side of Minneapolis. The book covers recent events such as defund the police, police reform, and the aftermath of George Floyd. Interspersed in the book is the writer’s story about his mother dying from cancer. All on all, it’s a little long but it helped me understand the current condition of blacks in Minneapolis.
116 reviews1 follower
October 22, 2026
I have lived in Minnesota, specifically various parts of the Twin Cities, most of my life. Including a 14 year stint in North MInneapolis. I thought I understood the people and the situations around me. Till I read this book. This will be as close as I can get to walking a mile in someone else's shoes. It was a tough read emotionally. However I am glad I did. To me this became a necessary read. I strongly recommend it for anyone living in Minneapolis let alone the Twin Cities.
Profile Image for David.
146 reviews7 followers
October 31, 2026
instead of reviewing the book - i might get to it later - i just want to relate what happened HERE in Minneapolis, MN's own Magers & Quinn Booksellers (my local bookstore): for perhaps a coupla WEEKS it stood in the New Releases kiosk where EVERYONE looks for current hardcover & softbacks. only when i went to buy it, it wasn't there. i found several copies, tucked away in the 'Minnesota;' Section - far, far from new releases - banished there. -sorta makes you think_aight ?
3 reviews
July 7, 2026
I like the structure of the book, as one review noted, "a mix of history and memoir".
I don't think the non-linear structure of how those elements are mixed are that great though.
I wish I liked this more than I do, but given there are still what can only be called clerical errors, I think I'll just have to stick with the rating as-is; hopefully a revision/re-issue will fix some of this.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews