Have you ever been curious about how people live when nobody is watching? Have you wondered whether there's more going on than meets the eye?
Eric and Carl live in Dorset in a small white cottage under the shadow of a big cliff. Eric sells old records and antiques. Carl cooks, cleans and crochets. Nearing seventy, Eric is a lifelong accumulator of obscure objects whose easygoing, chaotic approach to life masks some of the unaddressed sadness of his past. The significantly younger Carl is an old soul who has a sophisticated emotional intelligence and likes swimming, mid-century female novelists, fibre arts and Dolly Parton. If you passed them on a walk, you may not pay them much attention. Most likely you would see Carl's long floppy ears, tail and fur and mistake him for a dog.
The story of Eric and Carl's friendship spans twenty-one a constant anchor in a changing world. During that time they adopt an eccentric, unlikely gang of fellow travellers. Their wanderings through South West England unfold against a backdrop of lived, local folklore and hints at future apocalypse. All the while, Carl's true nature remains a closely guarded secret.
Tom Cox's third novel is a rare gem, centred around the importance of friendship, the power of landscape and the joy of accepting the unusual. Everything Will Swallow You will make you think deeply about the place you occupy in the grand scheme of things and give fresh perspectives on how to live and love in the present moment.
I love Tom Cox as a writer. I have read his non-fiction, his fiction, his short stories and his novels and he never lets me down. He has a singular view of the world and an authorial voice all his own and no matter what he attempts, he succeeds and he generously takes you, the reader along for the ride. This is a psychedelic trip of a novel, with wild characters and a plot that sometimes utterly confounds expectation. It's the most experimental thing by Tom and yet it has strongly traditional elements that save the book at the times it promises to veer off the page and go somewhere entirely different. What was rather lovely, as a long time subscriber to Tom's writing on Substack and his website, is seeing him weave some of his non-fiction writing into the body of the novel. It was a real delight to recognise some of the faces and places of the novel from elsewhere.
Everything you’ll ever need to read about love, friendship, record collecting, curries and crows.
Maybe it’s the age that I’m reading this book at but there are many of it’s emotional notes that have hit home so hard that I’ve begun to rethink parts of my life, parts of my own character and I’ll be a better version of myself because of them.
Fans of Tom Cox’s writing will recognise many of his tools and devices in this novel. It draws a lot on Tom’s writing of nature, of memories and places. There are a few quick chapters that seemingly gear change too quickly but then, once you’re back on the dual carriageway of the narrative, you will realise were worthwhile side quests that deepen the tale.
Things happen in this book. Weird things. Magical things. Peculiar things. It’s a novel about friendship and loving support, about books and records, history and landscape. It’s about those who defy expectations, whose community and support network is small and self-chosen.
This book flits from place to place and time folds into time like the folds in the landscape of Dorset and Devon. It’s the sort of landscape where one wouldn’t be surprised to encounter mythical creatures. In Everything Will Swallow You, Tom Cox has imagined the most wise and erudite and domestic of them all. Unlike the elves who run away when you give them clothes, the enigmatic Carl delights in caring for his friends and knitting them the most beautiful garments. Of course, the fact that he appears to be a dog, except for those in the know, somewhat restricts his life, but he knows who he can trust with his secret.
This is a book that I rushed to read but find difficult to review. It’s always a good sign if the only things I write in my notes when I’m reading are passages I want to quote because they are profound or beautifully written or deserve to be remembered. This is one of those books. I loved it, zipped through it but can remember little about it. I’m sure it would reveal more gems if I reread. Sadly I won’t be able to do that* because it was sent to me by NetGalley as a digital ARC which has since expired. My review, such as it is, reflects my true opinion after reading the book.
* Updated 8 July 2026: Hurrah! I can read it again because I ordered a signed copy from Blackwells.
“An old gatepost was never just an old gatepost to Carl, a face on the cornice or bench end of a church never just a face, a standing stone never just a lump of granite. He saw every landmark as an arrow, a direct line into the fathoms of history. He had an instinctive feel for the grand folk threadwork of everything, rolling back through time, and the recent reading he’d been doing in the areas of topography and social history only heightened it. It was as if, to Carl, time was happening all at once, its events all potentially visible, like the moving lights you saw in the sky on a clear night that were in fact hundreds of years behind you.”
“There was something seductive to Eric about the idea of leaving the world a handmade present and moving on”, be that creating a garden, or rediscovering and selling obscure records, passing them on to fresh hands.
“Eric read books but felt scant physical attraction to them. When he’d finished them – and, no less frequently, when he hadn’t – he left them, usually much stickier and dog-eared than when he’d found them, in friends’ bathrooms, hotel rooms, on trains, buses, benches, on the walls above blacktop estuary footpaths.”
Batbridge Manor. A house so full of books that house clearers reckoned there were 50,000 of them there, inherited by Penny, who loves its links to the past.
Her uncle had lived a happy and sociable life, but after his death had been condemned as a hoarder by journalists and online commenters. “Had they ever known the joy of surrounding yourself with love and knowledge and learning? What exactly was the more socially acceptable way to live out your final years that they would commend: the one where a person does everything cleanly and neatly and correctly in the eyes of society, right until their final breath? And did it make anyone who achieves it better, or happier, in their last years on the planet?” (p.38)
As Penny explores the house, it holds so many memories for her that she is ambushed by the past as she opens cupboards and pokes around in virtually inaccessible corners. Let me tell you, it is infinitely worse to go through a deceased relative’s belongings and find nothing that sparks any memories because anything that held any childhood memories had already been taken by someone else, sold, or given away as a raffle prize.
Eric appreciates the beauty of age and decay, tumbling bricks and encroaching moss. There’s probably a Japanese word for that, rather than a German one; Germans are too inclined to neatness to have anything but a disparaging word for the phenomenon.
There are musings about death and legacy, about early promise, flaming high, soon ignored and dying young; murmurings about Nick Drake whose name I only know is real because of obsessed music lovers (all men, round about my age) commemorating him on Twitter. Even my prog rock-loving son hasn’t referred to him. But John and Beverley Martyn also existed, but have never before crossed my path, even in name. “But what precisely was so fucking great about being dead? Especially if you didn’t get to see people finally getting to give the music you’d made its dues? And what was left in death’s and art’s wake? What were the costs that fanned out from it into the lives of others, unglamorously but painfully?”
Oh, what a glorious book. I adored Tom’s previous, equally idiosyncratic novel Villager, and was looking forward to this immensely.
Eric, approaching 70, spends his time buying and selling vintage vinyl and walking the green woods and hills of south west England. He is accompanied on these walks by his best friend of 20-plus years, Carl.
Carl is a fan of the novels of Anita Brookner, Rosamond Lehmann, and Barbara Kingsolver, a keen knitter, a very capable gardener, and most people encounter him in the form of a very handsome dog.
This wonderful and original book is a rich and warm celebration of friendship and life as it is lived, the small joys and the could have beens and never weres that can make it all such a tantalisingly magical ride.
As we move through the gears and pendulums of Eric and Carl’s friendship Cox, with touching insight and humour, explores the enchantments in our relationship to each other, the land, nature, and history.
Following the life of Eric from young hopeful guitarist in the 60s to his current (literally and figuratively) rambling existence, Cox offers his perspective on the social changes during these times and honours those who secede from the norms and find their own way in life.
The book almost glows as you read it - the radiance of a bruised and dented group of friends finding and celebrating the best in each other. It’s a glow like nostalgia, an undefinable bittersweet sense of comfort, but this is not a nostalgic book. It’s a book about loving the now of your life, informed and shaped as it is by moments you treasure, regret, misremember, or have entirely forgotten.
Be in it, for it is all we have.
Finishing this book felt as satisfying as the rattle and knock of a Morton Flickpot.
A signed copy is now on order for my wife, who I am sure will love it as much as I.
Since I did not finish this book, I don't feel like I can give a proper rating.
However I do want to explain why I did not finish, after reading 100 pages, in case someone else is wondering whether this is a book for them.
You see, the blurb on the back of the book makes it sound like a gentle fiction about friendships and a cast of eccentric loveable characters... what it fails to mention is the "fantastical" dimension of this book, where one of the characters is actually a hairy dog-sea creature with 4 hands and 24 fingers, or another character randomly starts levitating. There is also a little side of sci-fi, with article clippings from 2108.
The writing is funny at times and perceptive, but a little too verbose for my liking - I had to re-read sentences several times, as they took detours to get to the point.
I don't think this is a bad book per se, just not the right one for me at this moment in time.
I love the way Tom Cox writes, and once again he has written a story that I don't think anybody else could have!
It's such an experience to read one of his stories, and this is another one of those special books that you can't really pin down 'why' it captures you, but it just does! His characters are special creations and I love how their mind starts with one thought, and then sidles off on a different tangent taking you on a completely different journey and train of thought!
It's beautifully descriptive capturing every sight, sound and smell and as you immerse yourself more into the story the characters just fill your heart with humour, sorrow and warmth that mirrors the ups and downs of life - there may have been some tears too!!
'Meander: moving slowly in no particular direction or with no clear purpose.' This definition perfectly explains the plot for this book, although there is so much more to a book than a plot of course.
It took a chapter for me to fully connect with the story. It is an unusual one with a couple who both talk and have a variety of interests, but one looks like a dog. They live in a white cottage in Devon, but the story travels around the country looking at their personal history and there are details of many locations showing accurate features of places, such as Lyme Regis, Nottingham, Liverpool and Cornwall to mention a few.
The main character is an ex guitarist and has an interest in music. He had a record shop at one point and talks a lot about music of all different styles. Other arts and trends are discussed, for example literature, fine arts and television, with a rather large critique about reality television and modern-day interests being superficial. Along their travels the couple meet a whole host of people who all become friends. Some of them are a quirky as the central pair of characters with very odd habits, like feeding earwax to their cat.
The writing is beautiful and stylish and just right for a tale such as this. There are many phrases that I re-read so I could fully absorb the craft of the expression. A true literary talent. This is a book about time and place, the beauty of the surroundings and living in the present. But mostly this is about friendship and acceptance. An original read.
This is now officially my favorite novel ever, and if you look at my list, you can imagine how many I've read.
POV of several wonderful characters, all in a non-linear fashion that Vonnegut couldn’t have achieved at his best. Perfectly sums up the end of the 20th Century and the beginning of the 21st, plus bits of things going back centuries. A tapestry of gardening, knitting, music, and knowledge. Beautiful descriptions of the walking paths and seaside of rural southwest England, and the power of friendship. Sad, funny, and thoughtful; always gentle and kind. It deserves the words “mesmerizing”, “lyrical”, “breathtaking”, and “masterpiece”.
Read slowly so you don't miss a thing. You never know when one word is going to unlock a whole chapter, or a phrase is going to stun you into amazement.
Tom Cox's previous novel, 1983, was autobiographical in a way that mirrored my own childhood, given I grew up not that far from Cox in either time or space. His protagonists this time out, Eric Inskip and Carl, are a little less obviously Cox than 1983's Benji; Eric is a couple of decades older, had a rockier upbringing, at one stage even reads a piece by Tom Cox. Carl, meanwhile, emerged from the sea and, although he prefers to walk upright when not in company, and has 24 fingers with which he likes to crochet, is usually mistaken for a dog. Still, in their sensibilities, their distrust of social media and the metropolis, their preference for old vinyl (definitely not 'vinyls'), twentieth century novels and rural pottering, they retain a noticeable resemblance to the Cox of his Substack, just as the wry, rambling prose which often suggests an anecdote getting away from itself, only to coalesce into moments of transcendent beauty, could easily be said newsletter on a particularly good evening. And blow me if their wanderings haven't once again ended up in territory I know pretty well myself; the main action of the novel takes place on the Jurassic Coast, where my parents moved in the noughties, and where Cox pulls off the impressive trick of finding places names daft enough to sit plausibly alongside the likes of Whitchurch Canonicorum, and where I had to look up a few to check which were real ones I simply hadn't happened to visit, and which were his own puckish inventions, frequently guessing wrongly on both counts. As if that weren't enough, a flashback to Sheffield was in the same neck of the woods as where I used to visit an ex, and in Nottingham, though my school is never mentioned, Eric takes a route which would go right past it. I was quite relieved when, during a mostly unhappy London interlude, he isn't mentioned as going any closer than a 15-minute walk from anywhere I've lived; had he ended up in the pub downstairs, I'd have been unnerved, but by that point hardly surprised.
So what's the book about, apart from freaking me out? Time, and loss, and collecting. Collecting the right people and pets around oneself, but also collecting records, or anything really, and the awareness that it's a vain attempt to build a hedge against oblivion, a frequently counterproductive attempt to bottle the sensation of great music changing your life, a hobby that can so easily tip over into pedantry or worse (I don't think it's any coincidence that, since completing this book, Cox has been winnowing his own collection)...but also, no sillier a way of spending one's brief time on Earth than any other, and a lot better than some. There's a lovely section here with what I think might be the central image of the book, or certainly one of them, where Eric (unofficially aided by Carl, who has much more of a knack for it) is employed as a gardener, makes a mess of a garden into a lovely little haven – all for a house that isn't his, which the owner is looking to sell, and where for all anyone knows the buyers might get rid of the lot. "What had it all been for? A person might as well ask 'What is anything for?' There was something seductive to Eric about the idea of leaving the world a handmade present and moving on". Of course, this coming to terms with impermanence is made easier by the presence of Carl who, with his occasional glimpses through time, ensures that lost moments can be remembered after all. Somehow, though, that never felt like a cheat.
Which is not to say everything here worked for me. The writing often gives a deceptive sense of a runaway train, only to resolve beautifully at the last, but every so often it does crash messily into the buffers – though I suspect that, at least in terms of metaphors and such, some of the ones which made me wince might be other people's favourites, and vice versa; that comes with the territory of writing an overstuffed ramble of a book that couldn't care less about fashion, and paradoxically I'm not sure the overall effect would work if every sentence worked. More of a problem is that Cox is trying to extol the benefits of life lived at an older, more offline pace, but can't really do that without sometimes showing the opposite, which seems to utterly capsize the rural calm he's acquired; I may be the only reader to think of Julian the Apostate when Cox reminds us never to read the comments by recounting a selection of comments, but I think my broader sense of regret might be shared. This also feeds into the occasional reports from a future which has suffered a suspiciously convenient apocalypse where 'gadgets' have ceased to exist but civilisation as a whole, and especially folklore journals, survives. Most vexing of all is a hyperbolic diatribe against, of all the inoffensive years, 2006, when supposedly "The United Kingdom was in the grip of a populist mindwarp, an unbending new plasticity, and epidemic of reverse cultural snobbery cleverly designed to serve corporations and their rapacity. Formerly sane and discerning people pretended to like terrible songs and books and television shows for fear of being cast out of their social circles for the newly illegal hobby of appreciating art made with passion, individuality and integrity." Well, I was there, I wasn't watching reality TV, and unlike Cox's reports from Nottingham parks or the byways of the Dorset-Devon border, I find this one unrecognisable going on embarrassing.
Still, I can forgive a certain amount of misdirected fire when it's so clearly in defence of something precious, loved, and worth protecting – the west of England; its odd little settlements and the even odder people (and Carls, and crows) who call them home; long evenings with friends! the perfect song for the moment. The awareness that even here you get the occasional binhead, but that they need not prevail. It has clearly been an absolute trial for Cox that this book was originally meant to be coming out from Unbound before their inglorious demise*, but for all that I wouldn't have wished that on him, somehow it fits the content and the theme that it flirted with becoming lost art through corporate shenanigans, that it escaped that fate – and especially that it's coming out in autumn rather than spring, a better time to console us over all that passes away.
*Whereas I usually annotate freebies with a simple '(Netgalley ARC)', some people have a longer version in which they thank the publisher. Well, I hope nobody thanked the original publisher which supplied this one, because the publisher does not deserve it.
Who knew that this random ridiculous slightly arduous, oftentimes unbelievable tale about a man and his Carl, would bring me to such a state of wholeness, would become the softest place to land in this sometimes too sharp world, over the course of the two weeks that I read it. Not me. Alas that is what happened
There’s a thing tom cox does which is so subtle it’s hard to name. He takes you on a rolling journey to the limit of your capacity for randomness and then drops the most brilliantly philosophical exert on the nature of existence in the most humanely mundane way possible, that you can’t help continue on his rolling tale of intrigue. The way he seamlessly blends philosophy and Meaning in his story of misfits and odds and ends, like when Carl says something along the lines of I’m beginning to realise this idea of self made is rubbish im Carl-made, Mel-made penny made (cue tears), or Billy’s allegory of the rolling sticky scrap heap (u just have to read it) Interspersed with brilliant humor, jokes that actually made me laugh out loud, detailed prose which will draw you in like no other (every once in a while bore you out but that was kind of part of it) and characters that are beyond relatable (especially those with six fingers). Also, don’t know if I’ve ever related to a book character more than I have with Carl.
I genuinely feel like a better person after reading this book. Thankyou Tom Cox! The books promise to endow ‘fresh perspective of how you live and love in the present moment’ was THOROUGHLY served.
Addition to this review cause I just thought of it - about a quarter of the way in I gave up on this book, there are some chapters that diverge a lot from the central plot line and at one of those points I got huffy and fed up. I jumped forward still wanting to know what happens to the characters, and I landed on this section of Eric speaking to Carl about choice
“always wondering if there’s a better option, always being shown that there might be… it’s just kind of a problem in general the way it makes us sit infront of Netflix for forty five minutes trying to decide what to watch then just watching Harold and Maude on DVD again, and the way it keeps people in a sort of holding pattern in the crevices at the side of real life, and makes music less special because there’s so much access to it, and means books don’t get read properly, except by you, and a few other people, and everyone just skims across the surface of everything and before they know it they’re dead and they’ve not properly engaged with anything.”
Hello sir, did you just speak directly to me? Me who was not properly reading this book, who was in fact just skimming across its surface not engaging with it. WHAT. This line hit me like a truck. And it made me rethink. It made me keep reading and boy am I grateful.
Relentless rat-a-tat-tat of garrulous whimsy 1.5 rating
I’m afraid I had to abandon this less than a tenth of the way through, as I was almost grinding my teeth in irritation,
The experience was of being talked AT, unstoppably and VERY LOUDLY by someone who speaks a mile and minute, never drawing breath, and telling a very long, very shaggy dog story to the wrong person (me)
I’ve raised my 1.5 star to 2 because I’m honest enough to know that Mr Cox has been unfortunate enough to just be paired with the wrong reader, for whom his voice grates.
He clearly has many lovers of his style and anarchic imagination (I can take delight in anarchic imagination, but not, sadly Tom’s) but this is just not at all a charm offensive which works on me.
I found the humour just tries far too hard. For what it’s worth (and may well help to attract the readers for whom his writing will find a happy home) I have also found the same difficulty with Terry Pratchett – horrifying those friends who adore Pratchett, who have amused me by explaining, chortling merrily, snippets of their favourite Pratchett moments, and had me, many times, assaying a Pratchett, only to abandon, early, feeling over-battered by what feels like a too relentless bashing of my funny bone
I really wish that it were possible, on Netgalley, with ARC’s to have a short excerpt available to read on the site, without having to request the title. I would have known, pretty quickly that this writer and this reader would not connect
I am so pleased to have read this with a book group as I would not have picked it otherwise. I found it hard to get going, and it took a huge amount of concentration throughout, but in the end I did think it worth it. I enjoyed the writing of their relationships, and the descriptions of settings. I did cry at the end which shows I was invested in, and cared about, the characters - even if I wasn’t always sure what was going on, especially to start with.
I knew from the start this book wasn't for me, but I read it for book club and it took me almost a month. The prose is lovely, but I still couldn't tell you what the plot was. Every character seemed to have whimsy as their entire personality. A sentence would promise "this is how A and B met," then wander through an entire chapter of other things before returning to it, which made the book hard and quite frankly painful to follow.
I'm sure there are readers who will love this style, and I'm not one of them. It nearly put me in a reading slump and I am so glad it’s over.
Beautiful. Funny. Whimsical. Moving. Poignant. Reflective. Magical. This wonderful book was so many things, it was so unique, clever and moving. I loved every page. One of the most unique and brilliant books I've read.
I borrowed this from the library as I had quite enjoyed 21st-Century Yokel by the same author. I liked parts of this book, such as the mystery of Carl, but found those parts were buried under long rambling asides and too many references to music records and their contributors. Because of those, it took me a long time to work my way through the book and I didn't enjoy it as much as I might have done without them. However, I imagine that a reader who is interested in music would really enjoy all the references. I might even have found the rambling asides more engaging if I had been listening to an audiobook and could have been doing something else while waiting for the story to drift back towards the plot. It did pick up towards the end but, for me, it wasn't enough reward for making my way through the rest of the book.
I did find it a bit odd that we are told multiple times how unique looking Carl is, so much so that everyone who meets him exclaims about it. But the character who has seen him before does not immediately recognise him or even mention that he looks similar. Perhaps he has changed since then but the lack of recognition meant that I was confused about the connection between the characters because I couldn't see how they would fail to mention it.
It is a rather odd story, but that was part of the charm for me. It was the rather more mundane music references and relationship woes that made the book drag for me. If either of those interest you though then you have a good chance of finding this an engaging read.
I have a huge amount of affection for Tom Cox and have read a number of his books, newspaper columns and blogs. He's a fantastic writer, so funny, imaginative and eloquent. It's not often that books make me cry but this definitely had that effect. Cox writes beautifully about friendship and bereavement. this is also a love letter to second hand music shops and those men that hoover up old vinyl at car boot sales (I'm married to one of those) and Cox's background as a music journalist really shines through. It made me want to live in an old cottage in Cornwall and take long walks over cliffs and attend local knitting groups. You might find the style at the same time quite dense and also quite sprawling but I would recommend that you stick with it. I couldn't put it down by the end.
I have never loved a book that baffled me as much as this one. Nor have I ever appreciated a book by the end that I disliked so much mid-way through. I was dangerously close to a DNF half way through this book. But I persevered and am so glad I did. Something clicked and suddenly a monochrome, misty narrative became a multi-coloured, vibrant, emotional adventure. If you, like me, struggle with this book in the early stages, keep going. You won’t regret it. That said, I have no idea what I just read and would be hard pushed to explain it. But I enjoyed it and recommend it. That’s worth 4 stars in anybody’s book.
It's rare that I DNF a book, especially one which has got so much going for it. I liked the quirky characters, I wanted to know where things were going with them - and it has some very good reviews - but I found it heavy going. It was just too wordy. They were good words, excellent words, eloquent and even poetic words - but there was so many of them that it became difficult to distinguish the plot.
For some people, these beautiful words would have been enough. But I wanted to get to the story, and it became too much of a struggle.
Just me. If you love words for themselves, you'll probably like this.
What a weirdly wonderful and wonderfully weird book. I loved reading this original book. The wry and colourful observations of life, friendship and the landscape were so beautiful and resonated so strongly with me. The story made me laugh and made me sad and I just loved all the characters. And oh what a beautiful ending. This is the sort of book that stays with you and you just want to keep going back to it. I received a free review copy of the book from the publisher in exchange for my honest and unedited review.
DNF. I didnt hate it, but Cox's signature style of gentle whimsy and wry observation struggles to come over in audiobook format. Whole stretches of prose slip by and if, like me, you try to listen while commuting, half the book had passed without my necessarily being able to say what was happening.
I may well wait to grab a paperback copy in due course. I do like Cox's writings so I'm reluctant to gade it based on the format.
I wish I'd loved this book as much as other reviewers had. I see snatches of what they're talking about. I enjoyed the whimsical, the amusing, the characters, but for me, they were buried in too much other stuff. I was not so keen on the other stuff. Just never a story I rushed back to.
I absolutely loved this book... it made me laugh out loud, cry and think... sometimes all at the same time.. a magical blend of dimensions and characters who have stayed with me long after I finished reading.
Similar to "Villager" and set in the same world, a mythically-informed West Country, which as Tom Cox says is really a country of its own, as Thomas Hardy knew, "Everything Will Swallow You" is just that bit more annoying. Its protagonists - Eric, Mel, Carl - larger than life but in Eric's case at least somehow that much messier, lives that are interesting to be sure but I don't really care about the minutiae of record-collecting and obscure and often spurious (obscurious?) bands from the 1970s and earlier. But then there's Carl. Reminding this reviewer of the troll / cat-ape in Johanna Sinisalo's splendid "Not Before Sundown": Carl (short for Housecarl, he comes out of the surf like a serf and only modernises his views later) is a canipithecoid, the educated dog-ape, a four-limbed, furred and tailed creature hiding 24 fingers in his paws, able to walk upright and to speak, and quite possibly of more than human intelligence. He is also keen on philosophical literature, and knitting ... hang on, haven't we seen that before, probably in claymation? Adding Wallace and Gromit to the mix is no great stretch. The author isn't a fan of dogs in general though - he notes, as I have, that "Where dogs went, wildlife scattered and hid." and that "Places which were less [used by] dog walkers were invariably the most wild and beautiful places." Dogs are apex predators where wildlife is concerned and if we want to encourage the wild to return, we should rein (or leash) in our indulgence of dogs. Carl, on the other hand, is respectful of wildlife and does his best not to alarm it. So 'is the cast of characters diverse?' well yes and no. There are as far as I recall no ethnic-minority and few LGBT characters, but there is a good male-female mix, and then there's Carl who isn't even human. Also, rural people are a minority, and one we tend to forget about. There is a good deal of good messiness and living in the moment and being part of a community of friends in this, which it's all about, as is Tom Cox's belief that the natural world is not an option, not something we can take or leave, but is the whole point. EWSY is maybe folk horror without the horror (or at least not the supernatural variety) but I found it a bit too tousled and brawling for me, these people are all very well but I know too many like them. I was reminded of Slacker - first time I saw that I thought it was the best thing since sliced bread but on rewatching, it's just a lot of people running their mouths based on a variety of mental health issues. Tom Cox's mythologised West Country does seem more populated than the urban-biased media would leave us to believe, and does same without, I'm glad to see, too much reliance on alcohol (like Eric, I rarely drink these days; not a good idea). I think it's a real place and his probably unnamed Town, while not Stroud (probably) was very much a depiction of Stroud so I enjoyed that also. I just thought there was too much going on here, without the concision and precision of Villager. I certainly need to read his blog posts and all the rest of the stuff that any decent Tom Cox character, downstream of Nick Hornby in his obsessions with living in the past like a Jethro Tull track, would probably reject.
Strange and beautiful, like a breathtaking fever-dream. There are lots of writers whom one might refer to as those with genius, gifted for stringing together evocative, visceral words and phrases, but who lack either the discipline or humility to craft that gift into something that still touches the earth while reaching the sky. Tom Cox is one of those few that manage this incredibly difficult balance.
One can easily just lose oneself in the words, drifting along like listening to good music, time disappearing, images floating before one's eyes, but the structure and narrative remarkably still shine through. There are so many moments and lines that after reading just made me stop, lower the book, stare into the distance, revel in the beauty and the truth, unable to continue until they were properly digested.
And the characters, so well crafted and developed, each flawed, interesting, lovely in their own right on their own terms. They felt so real, fully including Carl, who has no right to feel so solid to the reader. Even as the pages turned, and the feeling of approaching tragedy strengthened, it was released in such a loving and full-hearted way, it felt like Cox really loves his readers as well as his characters.
There's a magic here, which is no surprise to anyone who's read his work or followed him online, but somehow the knowing in no way diminishes the journey or the destination.
An odd and enchanting tale about two best friends set on the golden coasts of Dorset. This book is more than it seems though because theres certainly magic in the air. The story is about two best friends, one an avid reader and the other a retro record dealer, it is a meandering story that goes back and forth in time exploring the origins of its characters, the way the plot moves is like a tide ebbing and flowing and can be a bit confusing at times but no less enjoyable. Its Tom Cox's style of writing that make this book so moving, its got comedy and atmotohere but also in this one incredibly emotional and brimming with nostalgia. This was one of Tom's most sentimental tales and it really pulled on the old heartstrings, its a story about a kind of grief, a kind of longing for something that was or was never there. My only comlaint is that the main action of the concluding chapters felt a little rushed and confused, it led to a beautiful ending, but I kept winding back to see if I had missed something, almost like there should have been a better build up to the conclusion.
I won't spoil it but it took me a while to understand "who" Carl actually was at the beginning, but I think that was intentional!
The blurb led me to anticipate something atmospheric and perhaps a little strange, but I wasn't prepared for just how surreal and unconventional it would become. Talking animals, unexplained phenomena, folklore, real places and wandering streams of thought are all woven together into a story that feels more like a collection of observations and ideas than a traditional novel.
There were moments I enjoyed. The Dorset setting references were fun to spot, and there are some genuinely thoughtful reflections hidden amongst the pages. A few scenes were funny, a few were touching, and one particular character quickly became the highlight of the entire book for me.
Unfortunately, I struggled with the writing style. Long, meandering sentences, frequent digressions and an often unclear timeline made it difficult to stay engaged. I often found myself reading pages without feeling any connection to what was happening, and many sections felt far longer than they needed to be.
The final part pulled some of the threads together and helped me appreciate what the author was trying to achieve. I can see why some readers would love its dreamlike and unconventional approach. Sadly, it just wasn't a good fit for me.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!
I found certain elements of this book really charming, particularly following the cast of characters through their early, mid, and eventually, late lives in different settings and contexts depending on the circumstance. It definitely leans into the concept of whimsy and relies heavily on a sense of nostalgia and small-town cosiness, which is really lovely in its own way. Some of the descriptions are lovely, and there are definitely some sections of this book that give a very heavy 'curl up and read' sort of vibe.
I did find that parts of this book did wander off sometimes into weird pockets where I wasn't quite sure where it was going, but I can appreciate there's definitely an experimental aspect that maybe didn't click with me as much as it might for others. There was definitely an element in here that I really enjoyed, but I didn't find the characters easy to connect with. Maybe it was just a matter of not having had the requisite life experience or vibe of the characters themselves. I am sure that this book has a perfect audience - I just don't think that I am it!