First of all, thank you to L. V. Brooks for the ARC, it was my very first and that was exciting! Also, English isn't my first language, so please excuse my grammatical errors.
This is a story of a girl, Juniper Haddock, that was hurt in a past relationship, and while drunk to forget her feelings, meet her "hallpass" (the only person she was allowed to cheat on her ex-husband), Ansel Barlowe. Ansel really likes the girl, but she is reluctant to start a new relationship. Then follows a series of different trope that isn't a bad idea, I mean I love fake dating, but isn't executed really as I would describe nice. And this is my honest and hopefully constructive review.
The good part:
- I liked the fact that Juniper had a great support system around her to help her figure out her feelings and them feelings protective of her, but we didn't saw them that much. I wanted to know more about Lara, and there were some "friends" that we saw only at the end to the (spoiler) proposal. Also, Lara uses they/them pronouns, love the representation.
- As I said, there were some great ideas, like the fake dating, her childhood celebrity crush, and everything. The fake dating, though, was weird, because they said no feelings and just kissing/touching in front of others and immediately started touching and slept side by side. Also, the childhood crush wasn't used nearly enough, and considering he was a rich AF actor, he didn't seem to be recognized in Seattle, only outside of planes? That wasn't really coherent. Do you see what I mean? Really great ideas, innovative, but could be more explained.
- I like how Ansel really reassure Juniper all throughout the book. Listen, I don't share a similar story to Juniper, so I don't understand what it's like to date after being in an abusive relationship, but I felt like at some point, Ansel needed a little bit of reassurance. But, for that opinion, I could be very wrong.
- I loved the short chapters, and how the names were written at the beginning. :))
The things I didn't like as much:
- There was a lot of subplot that didn't seem to have closure. For example, at some point, Ansel meet Joel (Juniper's ex-husband) and have a fight with him. But, after that, we don't see him anymore. Like, won't he press charges? Can't he go to the press and make money? Isn't weird that he just... disappear? Same thing for Lara, that after coming to confront their friend, and the thing that they confronts her about (Ansel) is there, they just... disappear until the epilogue, no information? Same thing Juniper's psychologist, we see that she is in therapy and talks about Ansel, but we just see them together once, but she really seem to need it more. If you introduce characters like that, which I believe were useful, maybe try to give them close?
- Some chapters didn't finished well. I sometimes thought it was missing pages, but other chapters were finished perfectly, so I know it just need some revision.
- I believe we don't know Juniper very well. The first time we meet her, she's drunk, which means we don't see her real personality. Also, we do Ansel like her so much? Why does he want to fight for her? We saw a lot of her flaws, and her problems, but not much of her redeeming qualities.
- It's hard to explain the main plot, because it was so hard to follow. I don't think there was a main goal throughout the book. There was Ansel's role in a movie, which was adapted from Juniper's favorite book, but we clearly don't talk about that nearly enough. My favorite book is made into a movie and I can't shut up about it (I'm obnoxious though hahah), so I feel it should be a more present topic of conversation.
- The petty part of my review is that it bothers me characters that are 40 years old and act as if they are 25. That's it.
That's about it for my review. Would I recommend the book? Not necessarily as it is, but if we polished a few plot lines and spend more time on Juniper's character and development, I certainly would. If the authors read this, first why? Don't read readers review, listen to your editor, but also, keep writing, because you have a lot of great ideas and write a great vulnerable female lead. Thank you so much for the ARC!