What do you think?
Room for Three More: A Reverse Harem Romance
She opened the door to renters. She didn’t expect to fall for the whole damn house.
Sally’s plan was return to Maple Hollow, fix up her late grandmother’s crumbling farmhouse, and keep to herself.
What she didn’t plan on? Three very attractive tenants. One very thin set of walls. And absolutely no rules about mixing business with pleasure.
Jack is the grumpy carpenter with rough hands and a habit of fixing her door… then lingering in the frame.
Micah is the sweet school counselor whose quiet confidence hides a deeply filthy mouth.
Dean is the tattooed mechanic who takes “let me help you with that” to dangerously new levels.
She only meant to rent out the rooms.
She didn’t mean to get kissed in the kitchen, undressed in the laundry room, or wake up tangled between all three of them.
Now her heart’s at risk—and so is her self-control.
Because these men don’t just want to share her bed.
They want her to stay. To belong.
To be theirs.
Sally’s plan was return to Maple Hollow, fix up her late grandmother’s crumbling farmhouse, and keep to herself.
What she didn’t plan on? Three very attractive tenants. One very thin set of walls. And absolutely no rules about mixing business with pleasure.
Jack is the grumpy carpenter with rough hands and a habit of fixing her door… then lingering in the frame.
Micah is the sweet school counselor whose quiet confidence hides a deeply filthy mouth.
Dean is the tattooed mechanic who takes “let me help you with that” to dangerously new levels.
She only meant to rent out the rooms.
She didn’t mean to get kissed in the kitchen, undressed in the laundry room, or wake up tangled between all three of them.
Now her heart’s at risk—and so is her self-control.
Because these men don’t just want to share her bed.
They want her to stay. To belong.
To be theirs.
103 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 15, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews
October 25, 2025
Such a fast read but really lacked so much detail. I’m not sure a poly or why choose really works for a short novella like this because you miss so much detail and connection.
October 26, 2025
Very shallowly written, even for a novella
The basic premise of the story is decent. Woman inherits a house and falls for the 3 tenants that originally are strictly for financial survival.
I'm not impressed with Sally as an FMC. She commands new house rules without any real necessity and then tosses them aside without much thought. She lacks depth and I dislike some of her actions along the way.
We know very little about the guys and, with the exception of Micah, their reasons for moving in are suspicious at best. How are readers supposed to believe Jack and Dean are in urgent need of temporary housing but they can wait 2 weeks to move in?
The book is very short, but there is exceptionally little relationship building regardless of the lack of pages. We see a lot of random occurrences and irrelevant conversations but very little substance filled interactions between the characters.
Worse than the puddle deep characters is the messy writing. The author mixes up details, sometimes within a single sentence. The most annoying scene for me is Sally mixing pie crust dough and one of the guys walking in exclaiming how good it smells. Until it begins to cook, dough has little scent. Overall it made for a very boring, very unenjoyable short story.
The basic premise of the story is decent. Woman inherits a house and falls for the 3 tenants that originally are strictly for financial survival.
I'm not impressed with Sally as an FMC. She commands new house rules without any real necessity and then tosses them aside without much thought. She lacks depth and I dislike some of her actions along the way.
We know very little about the guys and, with the exception of Micah, their reasons for moving in are suspicious at best. How are readers supposed to believe Jack and Dean are in urgent need of temporary housing but they can wait 2 weeks to move in?
The book is very short, but there is exceptionally little relationship building regardless of the lack of pages. We see a lot of random occurrences and irrelevant conversations but very little substance filled interactions between the characters.
Worse than the puddle deep characters is the messy writing. The author mixes up details, sometimes within a single sentence. The most annoying scene for me is Sally mixing pie crust dough and one of the guys walking in exclaiming how good it smells. Until it begins to cook, dough has little scent. Overall it made for a very boring, very unenjoyable short story.
February 16, 2026
2/5 Stars ⭐️
1/5 Spice 🌶️
MFMM (maybe others)
Why Choose
Land Lady
Roommates
Forced Proximity
Condom usage
So much time spent on just one pairing at first kind of made everything else seem like cheating afterwards. I love why choose but if not done correctly it can be uncomfortable. Though I think that was kind of the point in this book. Even though it worked out it still felt off to me. Book ended in a HFN.
I also don’t understand why the author tried to add in potential MM crossings in the last 5-8 mins of the book when none of that had been even remotely hinted at before then. It’s okay to have a strictly MFMM (etc) book and leave out that part. When you add it in as an after thought like this author tends to do it almost seems like it was thrown in disingenuously. I love a good MMMF (etc) book when done correctly but in more than a few books by this author it doesn’t seem right.
1/5 Spice 🌶️
MFMM (maybe others)
Why Choose
Land Lady
Roommates
Forced Proximity
Condom usage
So much time spent on just one pairing at first kind of made everything else seem like cheating afterwards. I love why choose but if not done correctly it can be uncomfortable. Though I think that was kind of the point in this book. Even though it worked out it still felt off to me. Book ended in a HFN.
I also don’t understand why the author tried to add in potential MM crossings in the last 5-8 mins of the book when none of that had been even remotely hinted at before then. It’s okay to have a strictly MFMM (etc) book and leave out that part. When you add it in as an after thought like this author tends to do it almost seems like it was thrown in disingenuously. I love a good MMMF (etc) book when done correctly but in more than a few books by this author it doesn’t seem right.
September 28, 2025
This was an enjoyable and quick read.
Sally decided to rent out her home and didn’t intend to fall for her tenants. Three men make Sally swoon: Jacks, a grumpy man who enjoys working with his hands; Micah, a sweet cinnamon roll with a dirty mouth; and Dean, a tattooed bad boy. These men are all vying for Sally’s attention.
I wish there was more depth to their characters. I would have loved to learn more about their lives and how they ended up in this situation.
Sally decided to rent out her home and didn’t intend to fall for her tenants. Three men make Sally swoon: Jacks, a grumpy man who enjoys working with his hands; Micah, a sweet cinnamon roll with a dirty mouth; and Dean, a tattooed bad boy. These men are all vying for Sally’s attention.
I wish there was more depth to their characters. I would have loved to learn more about their lives and how they ended up in this situation.
January 27, 2026
Very cute read! 🥰🫶💞 Character connections were pretty surface-level as far as the building of connections, but it IS a fast paced novella. It's a good book for people who want to start reading romance or if you need a wholesome palate cleanser after more dark reads.
February 17, 2026
cozy crew
Sweet fast paced story about a woman coming to her grandmothers home after finding her long term boyfriend cheating. My only complaint is that most of the story was off page and that where the most interesting parts happened.
Sweet fast paced story about a woman coming to her grandmothers home after finding her long term boyfriend cheating. My only complaint is that most of the story was off page and that where the most interesting parts happened.
August 23, 2026
Light hearted, sweet and cozy read
This is an excellent palette cleanser read. A sweet, cozy feel about finding love in unexpected circumstances. Learning to communicate with one another and allow relationships to build organically over time.
This is an excellent palette cleanser read. A sweet, cozy feel about finding love in unexpected circumstances. Learning to communicate with one another and allow relationships to build organically over time.
October 11, 2025
Easy quick read. If a book was a bowl of warm soup.
November 21, 2025
Great short story
This was a quick short story of why choose. It makes you crave more from this author.
I like the dynamic of each characters relationship with the fmc.
This was a quick short story of why choose. It makes you crave more from this author.
I like the dynamic of each characters relationship with the fmc.
November 23, 2025
cute
The only thing I would change is to add more of the other relationship dynamics that you mentioned it’s the end.. woulda been *chefs kiss*
The only thing I would change is to add more of the other relationship dynamics that you mentioned it’s the end.. woulda been *chefs kiss*
January 2, 2026
Rushed. That’s all I’ve got to describe this book.
December 3, 2025
Sally, Jake, Micah and Dean
Overall this book was cute & a quick read.
Came across as a more HFN instead of a HEA. I know spice is objective but I would rate .5
Overall this book was cute & a quick read.
Came across as a more HFN instead of a HEA. I know spice is objective but I would rate .5
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews