THE CANVAS KILLINGS (Jett Books 2025) by Elise Janes is a propulsive, spine-tingling, fast-paced crime thriller that combines the beauty and meaning of art with intergenerational trauma, complex relationships, history and the most unique serial killer narrative that is bold, original, horrifying and gloriously unforgettable. Full of suspense, misdirection and (possibly?) unreliable narrators, this story is a saga of fame, wealth, ambition, grief, family dysfunction, revenge, regret, betrayal and survival. It is one of the best literary crime thrillers I’ve read in a long time and the characters still live in my head (some of them in a good way, some perhaps in a way far longer than I might welcome).
The opening premise is powerful, shocking and disturbing: 30 years ago, renowned and celebrated Australian artist James Montague Ballantyne is convicted of murdering eight people and using their remains in his famous (subsequently infamous) paintings. This plot is such a fascinating point at which to begin: obviously the public – and particularly his clients, the owners of his work – are horrified by his heinous crimes. Gallerists who have sold his paintings, private owners, art critics – all who have been loud and prominent in their praise of Ballantyne’s acclaimed works, suddenly have to backpedal. Yes, his art is magnificent, but at what cost? The creepy and distasteful practice of him encouraging art aficionados to get up close and personal to his artworks is immediately and violently abhorred and castigated by everyone. It was a terrible time, monstrous crimes, and the public is collectively scarred by the illusion of beauty, when art can be comprised of universally hated materials.
But this is backstory. The narrative proper begins in the present day, when unassuming teacher Sam Reed becomes an accidental hero by foiling a robbery attempt at a corner store. With a couple of teenage girls as witnesses, his actions are instantaneously uploaded to social media and his face is all over the country, all over the world.
Sam Reed is a family man with children. Ordinary. Benign. But beneath that carefully constructed façade are secrets he has taken great pains to hide, and with his face splashed over screens, his anxiety heightens that someone, somewhere, will recognise him.
Sam’s colleague and good friend, Aiden Voss, is unsettled by Sam’s unravelling and cannot seem to help. He is originally a risk analyst, his life temporarily unmoored by his quest to discover the details of his sister’s death just a few years earlier. It was declared a suicide, but Aiden is not convinced.
And then there is the journalist, Tamsin Fischer, daughter of the legendary Zelda Munro-Fischer – an older woman with dementia now confined to a nursing home. But back in the day, Zelda covered the Ballantyne case with fervour and passion, even gaining one exclusive interview on the artist’s Blackheath property. Tamsin works under her mother’s shadow while looking for the disappearance of her birth mother, believed to be one of Ballantyne’s victims. Adopted by Zelda as a two-year-old, Tamsin has never felt Zelda to be the mothering type, and while she abhors her adoptive mother’s treasure trove of archived history about the Ballantyne killings, she is also driven to find out what really happened to her biological mother. In an unlikely alliance, Tamsin and Aiden work together to uncover their own mysteries.
With crisp and often humorous dialogue, grisly details, perfectly captured characterisations, gruesome content, fast paced action, scarily intelligent technological skills, authentic family and personal dynamics, a dash of romance, the weight of intergenerational trauma and legacy, friendship and familial duty, THE CANVAS KILLINGS achieves that most precious balance of gritty, confronting and visceral crime set against a backdrop of likeable and empathetic characters, ordinary family scenarios, the glamour and hype of the high-end art world, and the very real and relatable personal stories of people with childhoods they would rather forget, new lives created, ambitions chased and alliances forged. It is the perfect balance of light and dark.
This is an absolutely fantastic story written with emotion and literary skill while remaining true to its crime roots. It will surprise and horrify. It will endear you to characters and then force you to doubt your loyalties. It will question everything you thought you knew. And the ending is a triumph.