What do you think?
Rate this book
The Forest Apothecary: Tales of Linwellyn
Holly, a witch attempting to cure the incurable, finds her life rudely interrupted by a tall, dark, and handsome stranger. He has an inexplicable knack for spiritual magics, brewing the perfect cup of tea, and knowing exactly what she needs without her asking for it. Unfortunately for him, she’s promised herself to a god of the wood, and it’s nearly time for the beast to collect.
Grey, the forest god, can’t seem to forget the pretty little witch he found in his wood. It never occurred to him she would not recognize his human face, or that it might leave him torn between keeping a secret to keep her affections, or telling a truth that could save her soul.
Their connection is shrouded in sorcery and secrets. Their world exists in three, and three still again. They know each other in the hollow parts of their bones, yet they've never truly met. The Harvest Festival approaches, what shall be reaped this season?
A debut, found family, fantasy romance that explores concepts of generational curses, eldest daughter syndrome, and the inconveniences of attentive gods (who also happen to be really, really hot).
Grey, the forest god, can’t seem to forget the pretty little witch he found in his wood. It never occurred to him she would not recognize his human face, or that it might leave him torn between keeping a secret to keep her affections, or telling a truth that could save her soul.
Their connection is shrouded in sorcery and secrets. Their world exists in three, and three still again. They know each other in the hollow parts of their bones, yet they've never truly met. The Harvest Festival approaches, what shall be reaped this season?
A debut, found family, fantasy romance that explores concepts of generational curses, eldest daughter syndrome, and the inconveniences of attentive gods (who also happen to be really, really hot).
216 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 11, 2025
4 people are currently reading
45 people want to read
About the author
M.M. Ingram
1 book8 followersM. M. Ingram (she/her) is an American writer with a love of dragons, magic, and storytelling. She enjoys tea, rain, and long naps in the middle of the day. She is the author of The Forest Apothecary, a dark fantasy romance that explores concepts of generational curses, eldest daughter syndrome, and the inconveniences of attentive gods (who happen to be really, really hot). You can find her on Youtube @experiencingm.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 87 reviews
October 11, 2025
Thank you to Tales and Teacups and the author for giving me the ARC of The Forest Apothecary.
I really wanted to love this as I was very excited by the blurb. There is definitely some great things about this story and I really liked the idea of the Apothecary in her cottage vibes. I also really liked the MC, Holly, and how her personality came across in the writing.
For me, the book came across too vague in terms of story building with too many secrets and it made getting into the story a bit difficult. I liked the characters overall but found Greys character hard to sympathise with as his love for Holly seemed too much in the beginning (this is explained later in the book but by that point I struggled to build a connection to his character.
I could see this being a cosy romance fantasy for some, but unfortunately, it was not the book for myself.
Thank you again for the opportunity to read the book.
I really wanted to love this as I was very excited by the blurb. There is definitely some great things about this story and I really liked the idea of the Apothecary in her cottage vibes. I also really liked the MC, Holly, and how her personality came across in the writing.
For me, the book came across too vague in terms of story building with too many secrets and it made getting into the story a bit difficult. I liked the characters overall but found Greys character hard to sympathise with as his love for Holly seemed too much in the beginning (this is explained later in the book but by that point I struggled to build a connection to his character.
I could see this being a cosy romance fantasy for some, but unfortunately, it was not the book for myself.
Thank you again for the opportunity to read the book.
September 27, 2025
ARC review!
“You’re entirely singular. In all the universe there is nothing like you. If I had my way, I wouldn’t breathe the air of a place without you in it.”
Love love love this book!!
Grey is the perfect MMC who falls fast and hard. He then woos and coaxes Holly into loving him with care and attention . Holly is absolute chaos and angst! She is desperately trying to find a cure for the incurable whilst also navigating broken and strained familial relationships.
This book is the perfect slow burn no rushed relationships around here!
I love an apothecary setting it always is so cosy and has cottage vibes something that I always love imagining!
“You’re entirely singular. In all the universe there is nothing like you. If I had my way, I wouldn’t breathe the air of a place without you in it.”
Love love love this book!!
Grey is the perfect MMC who falls fast and hard. He then woos and coaxes Holly into loving him with care and attention . Holly is absolute chaos and angst! She is desperately trying to find a cure for the incurable whilst also navigating broken and strained familial relationships.
This book is the perfect slow burn no rushed relationships around here!
I love an apothecary setting it always is so cosy and has cottage vibes something that I always love imagining!
October 15, 2025
✨️ARC REVIEW✨️
A cute cottage romance fantasy. Following Holly and Grey in this magical story was creative, but due to all Holly's barriers and being stubborn, the character connection wasn't there. I was mostly confused until the end . Family dynamics all over the place as the story. I think more world and character building would make this book great!
Thank you, Tales and Teacups, for the opportunity to read The Forest Apothecary
A cute cottage romance fantasy. Following Holly and Grey in this magical story was creative, but due to all Holly's barriers and being stubborn, the character connection wasn't there. I was mostly confused until the end . Family dynamics all over the place as the story. I think more world and character building would make this book great!
Thank you, Tales and Teacups, for the opportunity to read The Forest Apothecary
October 11, 2025
The Forest Apothecary: Tales of Linwellyn was an easy three-star rating for me, but I spent a long time debating whether it was able to make it to a fourth.
Some things I loved:
-Dual POV storytelling
-Black cat FMC
-Golden retriever MMC
-Interesting magic system
-Eldest Daughter vibes in MFC
Some things I didn't love:
-Fade to black romance
-Unclear storytelling
-Somewhat unlikable/unrelatable male character
My final thoughts:
I loved the magic system and the author's writing style, but I found myself spending a lot of the story confused and struggling to get my footing within the world. I love Grey as a character because I am always a sucker for a first-to-fall love interest, and he's just really easy to root for. I wasn't as fond of Holly and Poppy. Holly specifically was difficult for me because I found her unlikable and unrelatable. For me, it didn't even have anything to do with the Eldest Daughter thing; it was just something about her as a character for me. I found it hard to see her as someone I wanted to root for.
Overall, since I can't give partial stars, I'm going to round up and give this four stars as a representation of my 3 1/2 star rating.
⭐⭐⭐1/2
Some things I loved:
-Dual POV storytelling
-Black cat FMC
-Golden retriever MMC
-Interesting magic system
-Eldest Daughter vibes in MFC
Some things I didn't love:
-Fade to black romance
-Unclear storytelling
-Somewhat unlikable/unrelatable male character
My final thoughts:
I loved the magic system and the author's writing style, but I found myself spending a lot of the story confused and struggling to get my footing within the world. I love Grey as a character because I am always a sucker for a first-to-fall love interest, and he's just really easy to root for. I wasn't as fond of Holly and Poppy. Holly specifically was difficult for me because I found her unlikable and unrelatable. For me, it didn't even have anything to do with the Eldest Daughter thing; it was just something about her as a character for me. I found it hard to see her as someone I wanted to root for.
Overall, since I can't give partial stars, I'm going to round up and give this four stars as a representation of my 3 1/2 star rating.
⭐⭐⭐1/2
Read
October 6, 2025ARC REVIEW 📖✨
Unfortunately for me, this was a DNF 😔 I kept going until 80%, but it just wasn’t for me - I can see other people loved it though!
I do really appreciate the creativity of the author and I think it had lots of potential, I was just confused most of the time and it didn’t grab me.
I did however highlight a few passages and I really liked Grey…
“You’ll always haunt me, sweetheart.”
“My silly girl. I will never abandon you.”
“If you’re going to run off with anyone, it’s going to be me.”
Sadly just not for me 🫶
*I received a free ARC copy of this book. Thank you to talesandteacups for the opportunity*
Unfortunately for me, this was a DNF 😔 I kept going until 80%, but it just wasn’t for me - I can see other people loved it though!
I do really appreciate the creativity of the author and I think it had lots of potential, I was just confused most of the time and it didn’t grab me.
I did however highlight a few passages and I really liked Grey…
“You’ll always haunt me, sweetheart.”
“My silly girl. I will never abandon you.”
“If you’re going to run off with anyone, it’s going to be me.”
Sadly just not for me 🫶
*I received a free ARC copy of this book. Thank you to talesandteacups for the opportunity*
October 27, 2025
Thank you to Tales & Teacups PR and M.M. Ingram for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for a honest review.
Holly, a witch attempting to cure the incurable, finds her life rudely interrupted by a tall, dark, and handsome stranger. He has an inexplicable knack for spiritual magics, brewing the perfect cup of tea, and knowing exactly what she needs without her asking for it. Unfortunately for him, she’s promised herself to a god of the wood, and it’s nearly time for the beast to collect. Grey, the forest god, can’t seem to forget the pretty little witch he found in his wood. It never occurred to him she would not recognize his human face, or that it might leave him torn between keeping a secret to keep her affections, or telling a truth that could save her soul. Their connection is shrouded in sorcery and secrets. Their world exists in three, and three still again. They know each other in the hollow parts of their bones, yet they've never truly met. The Harvest Festival approaches, what shall be reaped this season?
Holly seems like she should be this warm and caring person. For me, she felt incredibly frosty and discombobulated. She’s in quite the tizz with this magical bargain she has made in desperation to save her sister. But she pushes everyone away, out of this bubble she has created for herself and whilst not coming off aloof, she isn’t approachable. Seeing that behaviour from a FMC, I felt it was such a shame because we can still have guarded characters but they still let people in - especially if they seem to care as much as Holly does about her sister.
Grey is a being on a mission, and that is to endear himself to Holly. I definitely admire his determination because Holly does not really make herself likeable, nor endears herself to him. If anything, I was rooting for Grey to turn to Emmeline and offer her his attentions instead because she just seemed so genuine. We don’t actually get a lot of details about what Grey truly is which I found frustrating. I was trying to work out if there were hints here and there but if there were, I did not find them. I like a side of mystery with my characters but that was a morsel too big for me.
This was a story that intrigued me with its synopsis and associated tropes. I absolutely adore anything to do with magic or witches or spells so I knew I needed to dive into this one. This plot is good, though not wow for me. It gives off these fantastic cozy vibes but I felt it lacked a little substance for my tastes. I think I’m a bit too much of a hardcore fantasy girlie to truly appreciate a cozy romantasy like this where there are some stakes but they aren’t astronomically high. The pacing was a little bit slow for me as well, though this did start picking up in the second half which I was glad for. Character wise, we’re quite restricted in who we get to know despite the setting of the majority of the story - Holly’s shop - being a well known and highly used establishment. I feel that perhaps expanding the cast a little bit, having Holly make friends and connections with others, would have only enhanced the overall story here. Romance wise… I’m not sure how I feel about it. I totally get Grey’s side of things but Holly is so closed off that even I felt like I would have stepped back if she was in front of me. I’m all for reluctant feelings but this felt too cold and drawn out for me. The ending was okay - I didn’t have any qualms with it which is always good. I do think others would enjoy this book, I just don’t vibe with it as much as I’d hoped.
Overall, The Forest Apothecary is a cozy magical story that is great for the Autumn months!
⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Thank you again to Tales & Teacups PR and M.M. Ingram for an advanced copy of this book.
Holly, a witch attempting to cure the incurable, finds her life rudely interrupted by a tall, dark, and handsome stranger. He has an inexplicable knack for spiritual magics, brewing the perfect cup of tea, and knowing exactly what she needs without her asking for it. Unfortunately for him, she’s promised herself to a god of the wood, and it’s nearly time for the beast to collect. Grey, the forest god, can’t seem to forget the pretty little witch he found in his wood. It never occurred to him she would not recognize his human face, or that it might leave him torn between keeping a secret to keep her affections, or telling a truth that could save her soul. Their connection is shrouded in sorcery and secrets. Their world exists in three, and three still again. They know each other in the hollow parts of their bones, yet they've never truly met. The Harvest Festival approaches, what shall be reaped this season?
Holly seems like she should be this warm and caring person. For me, she felt incredibly frosty and discombobulated. She’s in quite the tizz with this magical bargain she has made in desperation to save her sister. But she pushes everyone away, out of this bubble she has created for herself and whilst not coming off aloof, she isn’t approachable. Seeing that behaviour from a FMC, I felt it was such a shame because we can still have guarded characters but they still let people in - especially if they seem to care as much as Holly does about her sister.
Grey is a being on a mission, and that is to endear himself to Holly. I definitely admire his determination because Holly does not really make herself likeable, nor endears herself to him. If anything, I was rooting for Grey to turn to Emmeline and offer her his attentions instead because she just seemed so genuine. We don’t actually get a lot of details about what Grey truly is which I found frustrating. I was trying to work out if there were hints here and there but if there were, I did not find them. I like a side of mystery with my characters but that was a morsel too big for me.
This was a story that intrigued me with its synopsis and associated tropes. I absolutely adore anything to do with magic or witches or spells so I knew I needed to dive into this one. This plot is good, though not wow for me. It gives off these fantastic cozy vibes but I felt it lacked a little substance for my tastes. I think I’m a bit too much of a hardcore fantasy girlie to truly appreciate a cozy romantasy like this where there are some stakes but they aren’t astronomically high. The pacing was a little bit slow for me as well, though this did start picking up in the second half which I was glad for. Character wise, we’re quite restricted in who we get to know despite the setting of the majority of the story - Holly’s shop - being a well known and highly used establishment. I feel that perhaps expanding the cast a little bit, having Holly make friends and connections with others, would have only enhanced the overall story here. Romance wise… I’m not sure how I feel about it. I totally get Grey’s side of things but Holly is so closed off that even I felt like I would have stepped back if she was in front of me. I’m all for reluctant feelings but this felt too cold and drawn out for me. The ending was okay - I didn’t have any qualms with it which is always good. I do think others would enjoy this book, I just don’t vibe with it as much as I’d hoped.
Overall, The Forest Apothecary is a cozy magical story that is great for the Autumn months!
⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Thank you again to Tales & Teacups PR and M.M. Ingram for an advanced copy of this book.
November 10, 2025
I want to thank M.M. Ingram and Tales and Teacups for this ARC (Advanced Reader Copy).
What lengths would you go to in order to save your sister from a deadly, magical disease? Would you be willing to strike a deal with a monster in a dark forest? Even if it meant giving up your own life one day? M.M. Ingram explores this in her novel The Forest Apothecary. Holly is an apothecarist loved by her community for her different potions and medications that help crops, sickness, and a myriad of other things. Her sister, Poppy, is going to culinary school while hiding a sickness that is slowly stealing her life. When everything gets down to the wire and the timeline is almost up, a mysterious and slightly familiar man comes to work for Holly. What exactly are his intentions, and why does she feel like she can trust him almost from the very beginning?
I really loved some of the aspects of this story. For one, Holly is not an outcast of her community. I see so many fantasy novels where the main female character is an outcast in some fashion. Whereas Ingram had her to be one of the most loved of her community. To anyone on the outside, she simply appeared as a normal shop owner running a good, profitable business. She kept everything about her sister’s health under wraps.
I also like the world that Ingram created. There was the village and then the woods that housed potentially dangerous creatures the more you went into it. There was also a place called the Spirit that was an in-between place. While she did not dive into this as much as I would have liked, it was a really interesting concept that allowed for some diverse uses of magic.
I do want to go a bit into the genre description. The book is described as a cozy fantasy romance. However, I want to add that there are some dark romance aspects to it. For me, this caused a bit of confusion when reading the book as to what I should expect. However, I could see someone potentially really loving this mash-up of content. It was definitely more on the cozy side of things, though!
The Forest Apothecary by M.M. Ingram has romance, adventure, sisterly bonds, and found family, monsters, and magic. I would recommend it for adult audiences as there is cursing and quite a bit of talk about adult content. However, all bedroom scenes were closed doors! If you love cozy fantasy with a dash of darkness, this may be the book for you!
What lengths would you go to in order to save your sister from a deadly, magical disease? Would you be willing to strike a deal with a monster in a dark forest? Even if it meant giving up your own life one day? M.M. Ingram explores this in her novel The Forest Apothecary. Holly is an apothecarist loved by her community for her different potions and medications that help crops, sickness, and a myriad of other things. Her sister, Poppy, is going to culinary school while hiding a sickness that is slowly stealing her life. When everything gets down to the wire and the timeline is almost up, a mysterious and slightly familiar man comes to work for Holly. What exactly are his intentions, and why does she feel like she can trust him almost from the very beginning?
I really loved some of the aspects of this story. For one, Holly is not an outcast of her community. I see so many fantasy novels where the main female character is an outcast in some fashion. Whereas Ingram had her to be one of the most loved of her community. To anyone on the outside, she simply appeared as a normal shop owner running a good, profitable business. She kept everything about her sister’s health under wraps.
I also like the world that Ingram created. There was the village and then the woods that housed potentially dangerous creatures the more you went into it. There was also a place called the Spirit that was an in-between place. While she did not dive into this as much as I would have liked, it was a really interesting concept that allowed for some diverse uses of magic.
I do want to go a bit into the genre description. The book is described as a cozy fantasy romance. However, I want to add that there are some dark romance aspects to it. For me, this caused a bit of confusion when reading the book as to what I should expect. However, I could see someone potentially really loving this mash-up of content. It was definitely more on the cozy side of things, though!
The Forest Apothecary by M.M. Ingram has romance, adventure, sisterly bonds, and found family, monsters, and magic. I would recommend it for adult audiences as there is cursing and quite a bit of talk about adult content. However, all bedroom scenes were closed doors! If you love cozy fantasy with a dash of darkness, this may be the book for you!
October 23, 2025
ARC Review! Thank you to Tales and Teacups for the opportunity to read this book!
Holly has worked her whole life to save her sister, Poppy, from a curse that also plagued their mother. She feels wholly responsible for Poppy's fate, though this seems a little misplaced. She even bargains with a god of the woods, to whom she believes she owes herself, should she not find a cure for her sister. In the midst of her struggles, she meets Grey, a thorn in her side with a penchant for magic and a slight obsession with her...
The Eldest Daughter vibes are strong in this one. Being one myself, I wholly empathized with Holly's character, all her flaws, and her less-than-welcoming personality. I will not soon forget her character. I do feel like the reader was kind of dropped in the middle of the story with Holly and Poppy, where we could have benefited from more backstory between the two from the beginning. Poppy was unlikable and ungrateful for all Holly sacrificed for her, and we learn a little about why towards the end, but for me, it was too late to redeem her character. Grey was a good MMC, though, again, we could have benefited from more of his backstory pertaining to his love for Holly, which seemed like a lot all at once in the beginning. The scene where Holly learns Grey's true identity was a little confusing, and I had to read it multiple times to orient myself and understand it. The setting was absolutely charming. I love the idea of the little apothecary cottage on the edge of the forest. The world-building could use some improvement. I feel like the reader was assumed to know too much, and it became a little confusing and hard to connect with at times. A map also would have been helpful. Overall, I liked the writing and the plot, and I think the series has potential, but this book could benefit from more story development.
Holly has worked her whole life to save her sister, Poppy, from a curse that also plagued their mother. She feels wholly responsible for Poppy's fate, though this seems a little misplaced. She even bargains with a god of the woods, to whom she believes she owes herself, should she not find a cure for her sister. In the midst of her struggles, she meets Grey, a thorn in her side with a penchant for magic and a slight obsession with her...
The Eldest Daughter vibes are strong in this one. Being one myself, I wholly empathized with Holly's character, all her flaws, and her less-than-welcoming personality. I will not soon forget her character. I do feel like the reader was kind of dropped in the middle of the story with Holly and Poppy, where we could have benefited from more backstory between the two from the beginning. Poppy was unlikable and ungrateful for all Holly sacrificed for her, and we learn a little about why towards the end, but for me, it was too late to redeem her character. Grey was a good MMC, though, again, we could have benefited from more of his backstory pertaining to his love for Holly, which seemed like a lot all at once in the beginning. The scene where Holly learns Grey's true identity was a little confusing, and I had to read it multiple times to orient myself and understand it. The setting was absolutely charming. I love the idea of the little apothecary cottage on the edge of the forest. The world-building could use some improvement. I feel like the reader was assumed to know too much, and it became a little confusing and hard to connect with at times. A map also would have been helpful. Overall, I liked the writing and the plot, and I think the series has potential, but this book could benefit from more story development.
October 11, 2025
Tales and Teacups Arc review📚
Unfortunately, this book just wasn’t for me. I really wanted to like it and held out hope that it would grow on me as I read, however that didn’t quite happen. While this book did have some good features I don’t believe it made up for everything. I felt lost with the story as there were too many unanswered questions, and I struggled to connect with the characters and their actions. I think the world-building and character motivations needed more development to fully draw me in.
I had mixed feelings about the family dynamics especially between Holly and Poppy. It didn’t feel realistic to me that one sister would sacrifice so much and try so hard, yet their relationship would remain so distant. I really think seeing more interactions or backstory between them would have helped. That said, I did appreciate how Holly’s guilt was portrayed and shown to shape many of her actions.
Emmeline was an absolute cutie! I loved her character and would have loved to see more of her! Especially some more of her with Grey.
Speaking of Grey, I did enjoy his character, he was deeply invested and had some swoon-worthy lines for sure. I just wish we got a bit more on him and why he was so infatuated with Holly it felt like it could have been better explained .
The writing style itself was solid, and I can see why others might enjoy the book, especially if you are looking for a fall romance to quickly read. But overall, it was just a bit too confusing for me. I think the plot and characters could’ve benefited from more development, possibly even a longer book, to give a better understanding of the world and the motivations behind characters choices.
Unfortunately, this book just wasn’t for me. I really wanted to like it and held out hope that it would grow on me as I read, however that didn’t quite happen. While this book did have some good features I don’t believe it made up for everything. I felt lost with the story as there were too many unanswered questions, and I struggled to connect with the characters and their actions. I think the world-building and character motivations needed more development to fully draw me in.
I had mixed feelings about the family dynamics especially between Holly and Poppy. It didn’t feel realistic to me that one sister would sacrifice so much and try so hard, yet their relationship would remain so distant. I really think seeing more interactions or backstory between them would have helped. That said, I did appreciate how Holly’s guilt was portrayed and shown to shape many of her actions.
Emmeline was an absolute cutie! I loved her character and would have loved to see more of her! Especially some more of her with Grey.
Speaking of Grey, I did enjoy his character, he was deeply invested and had some swoon-worthy lines for sure. I just wish we got a bit more on him and why he was so infatuated with Holly it felt like it could have been better explained .
The writing style itself was solid, and I can see why others might enjoy the book, especially if you are looking for a fall romance to quickly read. But overall, it was just a bit too confusing for me. I think the plot and characters could’ve benefited from more development, possibly even a longer book, to give a better understanding of the world and the motivations behind characters choices.
November 11, 2025
A folklore, unique fantasy read with a touch of mystery. Thank you Tales & Teacups for the ARC!
🌟🌟🌟
”You’re entirely singular. In all the universe there is nothing like you.”
Holly has lived her life trying to find a cure for her sick sister, ignoring emotional connections and her own desires to avoid distractions from this. After an encounter with a forest God, she assumes the worst and has limited time. So when the mysterious Grey comes to her apothecary to work for her, she must battle between her own desires, her curse and her sister’s illness. Can she manage it all, or must she choose?
The folklore and fairy core aesthetic of this book was the most interesting part of this book. I loved the descriptions of the forest, the in-between and the forest God’s. I wish we had more lore and backstory on how the magic system works but for a first tale this is beautiful.
Whilst the romance and plot was good, I would have preferred more backstory to pull me into this universe. Everything was a mystery, or a puzzle we had to piece together. I loved the slow-burn which was very confusing at first without the backstory but I did love Grey’s devotion to Holly; he was patient, biding his time until she could work out her own feelings and relationships. I did find myself addicted to them, but it still felt very surface level and lacking substance in some parts.
”I want you to tell me what you think of me.” “You’re impressively muscular.” “That’s a description, not a compliment.”
Overall if you’re looking for a well written book with folklore and a man who yearns, then this is for you!
What’s included:
🧚 He falls first and harder
✨ Grumpy x Sunshine (she’s the grumpy one)
🧚 Found Family
✨ Workplace romance
🧚 Forced Proximity
✨ Gods and Monsters
🧚 Roommates to lovers
🌟🌟🌟
”You’re entirely singular. In all the universe there is nothing like you.”
Holly has lived her life trying to find a cure for her sick sister, ignoring emotional connections and her own desires to avoid distractions from this. After an encounter with a forest God, she assumes the worst and has limited time. So when the mysterious Grey comes to her apothecary to work for her, she must battle between her own desires, her curse and her sister’s illness. Can she manage it all, or must she choose?
The folklore and fairy core aesthetic of this book was the most interesting part of this book. I loved the descriptions of the forest, the in-between and the forest God’s. I wish we had more lore and backstory on how the magic system works but for a first tale this is beautiful.
Whilst the romance and plot was good, I would have preferred more backstory to pull me into this universe. Everything was a mystery, or a puzzle we had to piece together. I loved the slow-burn which was very confusing at first without the backstory but I did love Grey’s devotion to Holly; he was patient, biding his time until she could work out her own feelings and relationships. I did find myself addicted to them, but it still felt very surface level and lacking substance in some parts.
”I want you to tell me what you think of me.” “You’re impressively muscular.” “That’s a description, not a compliment.”
Overall if you’re looking for a well written book with folklore and a man who yearns, then this is for you!
What’s included:
🧚 He falls first and harder
✨ Grumpy x Sunshine (she’s the grumpy one)
🧚 Found Family
✨ Workplace romance
🧚 Forced Proximity
✨ Gods and Monsters
🧚 Roommates to lovers
November 1, 2025
The Forest Apothecary surprised me with its lyrical, almost poetic writing style—more rhythm than prose, yet still grounded in emotion. Holly Alcott’s devotion to saving her sister, Poppy, drives a haunting and tender narrative about sacrifice, love, and the thin line between humanity and the divine. Five years after striking a bargain with the god of the woods, Holly’s story unfolds like a fairytale steeped in moss and moonlight. The dual POV adds depth to both heartache and hope, and though the story closes with a happily-ever-after, I can’t help but feel the door is left slightly ajar for more. One line that lingered with me: “You could never be late, for even time stands still in the presence of such beauty.”
As a dark romance reader who prefers a higher-spice threshold, the fade-to-black intimacy left me wanting a bit more connection on the page—but it fits the ethereal, storybook tone M.M. Ingram crafted so beautifully. For readers who crave a slow-burn, paranormal romance with mythic undertones and lyrical storytelling, this one will feel like stepping into an enchanted forest.
✨ I was offered the chance to review this story thanks to Tales and Teacups PR (@talesandteacupspr) and the author M.M. Ingram (@experiencingm) — and I’m so glad I did.
As a dark romance reader who prefers a higher-spice threshold, the fade-to-black intimacy left me wanting a bit more connection on the page—but it fits the ethereal, storybook tone M.M. Ingram crafted so beautifully. For readers who crave a slow-burn, paranormal romance with mythic undertones and lyrical storytelling, this one will feel like stepping into an enchanted forest.
✨ I was offered the chance to review this story thanks to Tales and Teacups PR (@talesandteacupspr) and the author M.M. Ingram (@experiencingm) — and I’m so glad I did.
October 22, 2025
ARC review. Thanks you to the author and Tales & Teacups for the advance copy.
I think there was a lot of potential for the book, especially as a first book for the author. Magic system was pretty complex and there were some cute moments between FMC and MMC.
However, I don’t know if I received the latest edit but found there were some grammatical/ sentence errors (?)… I was just so confused the whole way through, but this could be cleared up with a good and thorough edit. FMC was also not someone I liked, nor was her sister, and I just didn’t click with the world. Maybe a large part of this was due to just constantly being in a state of confusion. Idk what the magic is doing, what the goal of the characters are, what the goals of the interactions are and even sometimes what is going on in the scene.
Some of the chapters jumped in the timeline and I was also confused about what they were doing when the chapter opened.
Overall, i really think with a good edit, this could be a really great book, but unfortunately when I read it, it was really difficult to get through. I’m wishing all the best to the author, and again, congrats of the first book!
I think there was a lot of potential for the book, especially as a first book for the author. Magic system was pretty complex and there were some cute moments between FMC and MMC.
However, I don’t know if I received the latest edit but found there were some grammatical/ sentence errors (?)… I was just so confused the whole way through, but this could be cleared up with a good and thorough edit. FMC was also not someone I liked, nor was her sister, and I just didn’t click with the world. Maybe a large part of this was due to just constantly being in a state of confusion. Idk what the magic is doing, what the goal of the characters are, what the goals of the interactions are and even sometimes what is going on in the scene.
Some of the chapters jumped in the timeline and I was also confused about what they were doing when the chapter opened.
Overall, i really think with a good edit, this could be a really great book, but unfortunately when I read it, it was really difficult to get through. I’m wishing all the best to the author, and again, congrats of the first book!
November 9, 2025
In this we meet Holly who has been working hard to save her sister from a mystery illness, and in doing so, promised herself to a god of the wood. As she's preparing to fill her final days, having failed so far to help her sister, a mystery man appears in her life and wants to help. What she doesn't know is that he is that Grey, is the god of the wood...
What I loved: The cosy cottagecore vibes, the will they/won't they, Emmeline, her apprentice (who is adorable), the overall plot.
What I struggled with: The story just felt confusing in places. I struggled to grasp what was happening at times with Holly trying to heal her sister, not being able to go in the woods, her budding relationship with Grey, her fears over the god in the wood coming to claim her, and running her business. Although we do find out the background later on, I was a bit confused by this point, and I feel like there are bits of the book I ended up just reading, rather than taking in the information.
Overall, I largely enjoyed it. The downside was just dealing with my confusion and not being entirely sure what was happening, although the plot beneath it was good. 3.5 stars.
What I loved: The cosy cottagecore vibes, the will they/won't they, Emmeline, her apprentice (who is adorable), the overall plot.
What I struggled with: The story just felt confusing in places. I struggled to grasp what was happening at times with Holly trying to heal her sister, not being able to go in the woods, her budding relationship with Grey, her fears over the god in the wood coming to claim her, and running her business. Although we do find out the background later on, I was a bit confused by this point, and I feel like there are bits of the book I ended up just reading, rather than taking in the information.
Overall, I largely enjoyed it. The downside was just dealing with my confusion and not being entirely sure what was happening, although the plot beneath it was good. 3.5 stars.
October 13, 2025
*Thank you to Tales & Teacups for the opportunity to review this ARC*
I liked our FMC, Holly, her character was interesting and her voice really shone through.
Lots of people really loved this book! I could absolutely see the appeal, the magical elements were particularly interesting! Unfortunately I found myself confused through a lot of it. The relationship between Grey and Holly seemed odd and forced toward the beginning and I just didn’t understand why he was so connected to her. As the reader it felt forced, by the time I got to understand a little more of the characters and their motivations I was already disengaged.
The magical elements of the story were great, but it made me feel like I wanted more world building. I was desperate to learn more of the world Holly lived in, but the story never really delivered for me.
Lots of people have loved, and will love this book I’m sure,unfortunately it just wasn’t for me.
I liked our FMC, Holly, her character was interesting and her voice really shone through.
Lots of people really loved this book! I could absolutely see the appeal, the magical elements were particularly interesting! Unfortunately I found myself confused through a lot of it. The relationship between Grey and Holly seemed odd and forced toward the beginning and I just didn’t understand why he was so connected to her. As the reader it felt forced, by the time I got to understand a little more of the characters and their motivations I was already disengaged.
The magical elements of the story were great, but it made me feel like I wanted more world building. I was desperate to learn more of the world Holly lived in, but the story never really delivered for me.
Lots of people have loved, and will love this book I’m sure,unfortunately it just wasn’t for me.
November 6, 2025
3.5 Stars (Rounded Up)
A witch trying to cure the incurable, a forest god who can’t forget her, and a story wrapped in curses, secrets, and magic.
This debut had such a creative concept, and I loved the magical, cottagecore vibes. Holly’s stubbornness made it a little hard to connect with her at times, same with her CHAOTIC family LOL.
I also found myself a little confused at times, especially around Grey. There was such an intriguing air of mystery surrounding him, and I really wished that part of the story had been developed more. I wanted her to realise who he was earlier, to give more time for that tension and revelation to unfold. A lot of major things seemed to happen right at the end (in the last 15% or so), and it felt a little rushed.
But Grey? I did love him. Him calling her “m’lady” and “my lady” had me melting. He was a little obsessed.
Thank you to the Author and Tales & Teacups for an opportunity to read an ARC for my honest opinion.
A witch trying to cure the incurable, a forest god who can’t forget her, and a story wrapped in curses, secrets, and magic.
This debut had such a creative concept, and I loved the magical, cottagecore vibes. Holly’s stubbornness made it a little hard to connect with her at times, same with her CHAOTIC family LOL.
I also found myself a little confused at times, especially around Grey. There was such an intriguing air of mystery surrounding him, and I really wished that part of the story had been developed more. I wanted her to realise who he was earlier, to give more time for that tension and revelation to unfold. A lot of major things seemed to happen right at the end (in the last 15% or so), and it felt a little rushed.
But Grey? I did love him. Him calling her “m’lady” and “my lady” had me melting. He was a little obsessed.
Thank you to the Author and Tales & Teacups for an opportunity to read an ARC for my honest opinion.
October 8, 2025
3.5 stars out of 5
-Dual POV
-Fade to black
-Black cat FMC
-Golden retriever MMC
This was a cozy fantasy novel reminiscent of Must Love Magic and Moonshine, minus the spice.
Lord Grey was my favorite character! He was sweet, strange, and possessive. His love for “his lady” was evident and could be felt throughout the book. His POV chapters were my favorite parts.
I didn’t find Holly or Poppy relatable unfortunately. I wish there was a way for me to connect to Holly as the FMC. She has a lot of barriers up and she pushed everyone away throughout the book, including sweet Grey. It was explained why as the story went on, but she wasn’t exactly a likable character.
Cute story with an interesting magic system. Good cozy read.
-Dual POV
-Fade to black
-Black cat FMC
-Golden retriever MMC
This was a cozy fantasy novel reminiscent of Must Love Magic and Moonshine, minus the spice.
Lord Grey was my favorite character! He was sweet, strange, and possessive. His love for “his lady” was evident and could be felt throughout the book. His POV chapters were my favorite parts.
I didn’t find Holly or Poppy relatable unfortunately. I wish there was a way for me to connect to Holly as the FMC. She has a lot of barriers up and she pushed everyone away throughout the book, including sweet Grey. It was explained why as the story went on, but she wasn’t exactly a likable character.
Cute story with an interesting magic system. Good cozy read.
October 11, 2025
This was more like a 3.5⭐️ read for me, but I always round up not down. I thought the writing was good, and I absolutely loved the setting and vibes of the story especially for this time of year (fall). Unfortunately, I had a hard time following the story much of the time. Some of the things I was confused about did become more clear as the story went on.
My favorite thing about the book was Grey. I enjoyed the way he loved and cared for Holly. I wish we had a little bit more of his backstory because he was a very interesting but mysterious character.
Overall, I would recommend this book if you are looking for a quick read with witchy/fall vibes in a land full of magic.
I received an ARC of this book. This is my honest review.
My favorite thing about the book was Grey. I enjoyed the way he loved and cared for Holly. I wish we had a little bit more of his backstory because he was a very interesting but mysterious character.
Overall, I would recommend this book if you are looking for a quick read with witchy/fall vibes in a land full of magic.
I received an ARC of this book. This is my honest review.
October 11, 2025
This book is a cosy cottage fantasy with themes explored of eldest daughter syndrome with the weight od the world on her shoulders.
Holly had a lot of barriers up which I felt stopped the reader a bit from relating to her and made her a less likeable character that I struggled to connect with. But Grey is a great character. He is kind, caring and sweet even though Holly pushes him away so much. He definitely fell first and harder.
The first half of the book I admit I was very confused, but things were explained later on which made more sense of the first half.
It is a cosy, autumn read. 3.5 stars.
Thanks talesandtecups and M.M Ingram for the opportunity to read an eARC and give an honest review.
Holly had a lot of barriers up which I felt stopped the reader a bit from relating to her and made her a less likeable character that I struggled to connect with. But Grey is a great character. He is kind, caring and sweet even though Holly pushes him away so much. He definitely fell first and harder.
The first half of the book I admit I was very confused, but things were explained later on which made more sense of the first half.
It is a cosy, autumn read. 3.5 stars.
Thanks talesandtecups and M.M Ingram for the opportunity to read an eARC and give an honest review.
October 16, 2025
4.5 ⭐️
I LOVED the romance in this book, the whole idea of Holly trying to find a cure for the incurable was fun and important in a way that drove her forward.
Grey was an amazing love interest, I am in love with how utterly obsessed he was with her right from the beginning because of their past, not known to her, Grey literally dedicated every second to doing things for her and honestly he was happy doing it. The found family in this book really grapples me because you can see that it’s not perfect with how Holly withdrew from their lives but they still stick around, Em was adorable and she made me smile multiple times.
I wasn’t sure what I was expecting going into this book but I am pleasantly surprised and happy with what I got
Thank you to the author for the ARC copy
I LOVED the romance in this book, the whole idea of Holly trying to find a cure for the incurable was fun and important in a way that drove her forward.
Grey was an amazing love interest, I am in love with how utterly obsessed he was with her right from the beginning because of their past, not known to her, Grey literally dedicated every second to doing things for her and honestly he was happy doing it. The found family in this book really grapples me because you can see that it’s not perfect with how Holly withdrew from their lives but they still stick around, Em was adorable and she made me smile multiple times.
I wasn’t sure what I was expecting going into this book but I am pleasantly surprised and happy with what I got
Thank you to the author for the ARC copy
Read
November 13, 2025This was a quick, cute, cozy read. Our FMC, Holly, runs an apothecary shop on the outskirts of her village, her potions helping farmers grow plentiful crops and helping townsfolk with their maladies. While this life is fulfilling for her, her one true goal is to find the cure to a magical disease her sister inherited. How far will she go to find the cure and who is this sad, pretty man that showed up just in time to help during the yearly harvest festival?
I read this book in one day. It was hard for me to pick one quote, as there were many standout lines in this for me. Our FMC was not a damsel in distress, but a staple to her community, skilled at her craft. I loved the cozy, cottage, forest setting. It had an excellent balance of fantasy and romance, with plentiful yearning. I only wish we had a little more backstory on our MMC, Grey, but maybe we'll get that in coming books? An excellent debut novel from an author I'm excited to read more from.
I read this book in one day. It was hard for me to pick one quote, as there were many standout lines in this for me. Our FMC was not a damsel in distress, but a staple to her community, skilled at her craft. I loved the cozy, cottage, forest setting. It had an excellent balance of fantasy and romance, with plentiful yearning. I only wish we had a little more backstory on our MMC, Grey, but maybe we'll get that in coming books? An excellent debut novel from an author I'm excited to read more from.
November 11, 2025
A fantasy romance with a whimsy and dreamlike vibe. Holly is burdened with the responsibility with curing her sister and each failure is gnawing on her mind and soul. Grey appears at Holly's shop and his only goal is to be with her no matter what. They're suddenly drawn to each other, unable to pull away. I can really feel Holly's desperation and knows her time cannot be wasted: her sister's life is timed and she cannot be distracted by her attraction to Grey. Although a small part of her can't help but indulge just to get away from her dreadful feelings.
I understand this is a romance, but I was more drawn to Holly and her sister's relationship: the feelings were intense and definitely enjoyed reading it.
thank you to Tales and Teacups and M.M Ingram for the ARC and I voluntarily give my review.
I understand this is a romance, but I was more drawn to Holly and her sister's relationship: the feelings were intense and definitely enjoyed reading it.
thank you to Tales and Teacups and M.M Ingram for the ARC and I voluntarily give my review.
October 15, 2025
Gods, magic, elves and beasts, The Forest Apothecary packs a punch in less than 300 pages!
The characters are faulted but hard not to love. Grey is possessive but at the same time selfless. Holly is self absorbed but equally, she is loyal and kind. The complexity of the characters and their development throughout the story is a testament to Infgram’s writing.
I enjoyed the writing style of this duel POV romance fantasy novel. The prose is emotive and imaginative while still being easy to follow. The world building is descriptive while not overwhelming, allowing the reader to easily become immersed without distracting from the plot.
Altogether an enjoyable read. 5 stars
The characters are faulted but hard not to love. Grey is possessive but at the same time selfless. Holly is self absorbed but equally, she is loyal and kind. The complexity of the characters and their development throughout the story is a testament to Infgram’s writing.
I enjoyed the writing style of this duel POV romance fantasy novel. The prose is emotive and imaginative while still being easy to follow. The world building is descriptive while not overwhelming, allowing the reader to easily become immersed without distracting from the plot.
Altogether an enjoyable read. 5 stars
November 8, 2025
The Forest Apothecary by M. M. Ingram is a whimsical, fantastic, creative book all wrapped into one. Holly Alcott, a witch dedicated to her apothecary more than her own desires. Desperate for a cure, she tries the impossible to save her beloved sister. We meet the lonely but ever so loyal Grim, who is enamored by Holly who doesn’t seem to notice his feelings. I adored how Holly grew into her own version of herself and opened up to her found family.
M.M. Ingram, your writing is amazing and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. I am extremely grateful to have received an ARC from @talesandteacupspr & @experiencingm 🩵
M.M. Ingram, your writing is amazing and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. I am extremely grateful to have received an ARC from @talesandteacupspr & @experiencingm 🩵
November 11, 2025
The Forest Apothecary is a gentle, enchanting journey into a world full of magical creatures and outworldly magical systems. The setting is perfect for readers who love a cozy fantasy landscape and a slowly burning romance.
Holly is easily likeable as a character though her single-mindedness can be so frustrating! However, never fear, Grey has come to distract her. His hesitancy on how to act as a human is really quite endearing.
If you're looking for a cozy fantasy romance with a touch of mystery and magic, this one is worth curling up with.
My thanks to Tales and Teacups for having me along this tour
Holly is easily likeable as a character though her single-mindedness can be so frustrating! However, never fear, Grey has come to distract her. His hesitancy on how to act as a human is really quite endearing.
If you're looking for a cozy fantasy romance with a touch of mystery and magic, this one is worth curling up with.
My thanks to Tales and Teacups for having me along this tour
September 28, 2025
A cosy cottage romantasy vibe that shines the light on so many aspects that over overlooked in life: such as the eldest daughter syndrome. With a slow-burning romance, what more can you ask for?
The MMC Grey is mysterious who woos the MFC into loving him. He definitely fell hard and fast first which I loved. But seriously a man who can make the perfect cup of tea: Sign me up please!!!
The MFC Holly, is the perfect representation of an elder daughter and overcomes a lot which made me love this book even more. She's the definition of a strong character who is trying her hardest to find a cure for the incurable whilst battling her own problems.
The MMC Grey is mysterious who woos the MFC into loving him. He definitely fell hard and fast first which I loved. But seriously a man who can make the perfect cup of tea: Sign me up please!!!
The MFC Holly, is the perfect representation of an elder daughter and overcomes a lot which made me love this book even more. She's the definition of a strong character who is trying her hardest to find a cure for the incurable whilst battling her own problems.
November 11, 2025
A cosy fantasy with magic, gods and witches.
It’s a journey of love, grief and fear as Holly desperately searches for a cure for her sister.
A very slow burn relationship. Holly was a little difficult to like as the FMC. Grey is intense and falls hard and fast.
I did struggle to get into this book and was confused at times. I liked the apothecary setting but would have preferred more world/story building.
Overall I rate this 3 stars. It had a lot of potential and I think a lot of people will enjoy it, as it’s a quick cosy magical read. I think with more in depth story building and a little easier to follow for me I would’ve rated this higher.
It’s a journey of love, grief and fear as Holly desperately searches for a cure for her sister.
A very slow burn relationship. Holly was a little difficult to like as the FMC. Grey is intense and falls hard and fast.
I did struggle to get into this book and was confused at times. I liked the apothecary setting but would have preferred more world/story building.
Overall I rate this 3 stars. It had a lot of potential and I think a lot of people will enjoy it, as it’s a quick cosy magical read. I think with more in depth story building and a little easier to follow for me I would’ve rated this higher.
November 12, 2025
Thank you to M.M. Ingram and Tales & Teacups for giving me to chance to read an ARC of “The Forest Apothecary.”
Cozy Fantasy Romance ✔️
Found Family ✔️
Forced Proximity ✔️
He Fell First ✔️
Grumpy x Sunshine ✔️
Dual POV ✔️
Slow Burn ✔️
It was cozy and somehow relatable to me: the FMC is chaotic, a bit stubborn and stuck in her head, missing something good right in front of her. Ingram’s writing style is poetic and lush. I could have gone for a smidge more depth overall but I enjoyed this story and the characters. It was a fairly quick read with a happily ever after!
Cozy Fantasy Romance ✔️
Found Family ✔️
Forced Proximity ✔️
He Fell First ✔️
Grumpy x Sunshine ✔️
Dual POV ✔️
Slow Burn ✔️
It was cozy and somehow relatable to me: the FMC is chaotic, a bit stubborn and stuck in her head, missing something good right in front of her. Ingram’s writing style is poetic and lush. I could have gone for a smidge more depth overall but I enjoyed this story and the characters. It was a fairly quick read with a happily ever after!
October 22, 2025
Thank you Tales and Teacups PR for giving me the opportunity.
I've given this book 3 stars because I was really confused for most of it. I think we needed more back story with a few of the characters. The authors writing is spot on I just think the world building and characters development needed more, maybe if this book was longer it would have given space for the back stories, motivations etc.
I've given this book 3 stars because I was really confused for most of it. I think we needed more back story with a few of the characters. The authors writing is spot on I just think the world building and characters development needed more, maybe if this book was longer it would have given space for the back stories, motivations etc.
October 13, 2025
The blurb for this book suggests it's based on the relationship between Holly and Grey, but I felt this was actually a background plot line to Holly trying to heal her sister.
Unfortunately I found it a bit disjointed and I didn't feel much for any of the characters. At times it felt slow and then other times really rushed, especially at the end.
I didn't feel there was an real depth to much of the story at all.
I received an advanced review copy in exchange for my honest review.
Unfortunately I found it a bit disjointed and I didn't feel much for any of the characters. At times it felt slow and then other times really rushed, especially at the end.
I didn't feel there was an real depth to much of the story at all.
I received an advanced review copy in exchange for my honest review.
November 9, 2025
This was a quick and easy read, but for about the first 60% of the book, my main thought was, "What is going on???" Upon finishing the book, I get what she was going for, but there was too much discovering as we went for me. I really liked the premise of the story; it's very classic fairy tale. I just had a really hard time with the execution.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 87 reviews