What do you think?
Rate this book
Win a free print copy of this book!
8 days and 11:08:18
100 copies available
U.S. only
A Perfect Hand
Not yet published
Expected 19 May 26Win a free print copy of this book!
8 days and 11:08:18
100 copies available
U.S. only
A richly drawn, captivating, and endlessly amusing novel of love and subterfuge between a lady’s maid and her clandestine lover, set in the country estates of nineteenth-century England.
Miss Alice Lockey, daughter of a tenant farmer, has by dint of hard work, innate intelligence, and a cunning ability to predict the moods of her betters, raised herself to the lofty status of lady’s maid at Alderwick Park. Though her mother has advised Alice to work only until marriage, Alice has thus far resisted the temptations of matrimony among the neighboring widowers and pig farmers, more content to enjoy the fruits of her labor—or at least the portion of it her father will share after it is paid to him. Alice spends her days arranging Lady Jemima Alderwick’s blond hair into the latest French styles, chignons and plaits, laundering her lady’s surprisingly malodorous petticoats and drawers, and carefully sewing all manner of fripperies, ribbons, lace, and silk flowers, to her lady’s bonnets and gowns.
But when a visiting servant, a valet named Charlie Wells, catches her eye, Alice begins to understand the constraints of her position. In a ploy to spend time with the object of her affection, Alice attempts to arrange a romance between Lady Jemima Alderwick and Charlie’s employer, one Baronet Sir Nigel Wynstowe. If only they would fall in love—then Alice and Charlie might live together as man and wife! Challenged by Lady Jemima’s love for another and Sir Wynstowe’s eccentric personality, Alice must use all of her cunning to bring about this unlikely romantic union. Will this low-born servant successfully manipulate the hearts of these lords and ladies? Will Charlie and Alice ever improve their stations? Or, as the beginning of women’s suffrage begins to percolate in the drawing rooms and salons of London, will Alice discover a different sort of path for herself?
A deliciously funny, gorgeously detailed, utter enthralling novel, A Perfect Hand is a glorious novel of class, gender, and England on the cusp of enormous change.
Miss Alice Lockey, daughter of a tenant farmer, has by dint of hard work, innate intelligence, and a cunning ability to predict the moods of her betters, raised herself to the lofty status of lady’s maid at Alderwick Park. Though her mother has advised Alice to work only until marriage, Alice has thus far resisted the temptations of matrimony among the neighboring widowers and pig farmers, more content to enjoy the fruits of her labor—or at least the portion of it her father will share after it is paid to him. Alice spends her days arranging Lady Jemima Alderwick’s blond hair into the latest French styles, chignons and plaits, laundering her lady’s surprisingly malodorous petticoats and drawers, and carefully sewing all manner of fripperies, ribbons, lace, and silk flowers, to her lady’s bonnets and gowns.
But when a visiting servant, a valet named Charlie Wells, catches her eye, Alice begins to understand the constraints of her position. In a ploy to spend time with the object of her affection, Alice attempts to arrange a romance between Lady Jemima Alderwick and Charlie’s employer, one Baronet Sir Nigel Wynstowe. If only they would fall in love—then Alice and Charlie might live together as man and wife! Challenged by Lady Jemima’s love for another and Sir Wynstowe’s eccentric personality, Alice must use all of her cunning to bring about this unlikely romantic union. Will this low-born servant successfully manipulate the hearts of these lords and ladies? Will Charlie and Alice ever improve their stations? Or, as the beginning of women’s suffrage begins to percolate in the drawing rooms and salons of London, will Alice discover a different sort of path for herself?
A deliciously funny, gorgeously detailed, utter enthralling novel, A Perfect Hand is a glorious novel of class, gender, and England on the cusp of enormous change.
288 pages, Kindle Edition
Expected publication May 19, 2026
10 people are currently reading
7778 people want to read
About the author
Ayelet Waldman
27 books40.3k followersAyelet Waldman is the author of A Really Good Day: How Microdosing Made a Mega Difference in My Mood, My Marriage, and My Life, Love and Treasure, Red Hook Road and The New York Times bestseller Bad Mother: A Chronicle of Maternal Crimes, Minor Calamities and Occasional Moments of Grace. Her novel Love and Other Impossible Pursuits was made into a film starring Natalie Portman. Her personal essays and profiles of such public figures as Hillary Clinton have been published in a wide variety of newspapers and magazines, including The New York Times, Vogue, The Washington Post, and The Wall Street Journal. Her radio commentaries have appeared on "All Things Considered" and "The California Report."
You can follow Ayelet on Facebook and Twitter.
Love and Treasure is available for purchase here.
You can follow Ayelet on Facebook and Twitter.
Love and Treasure is available for purchase here.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews
Read
January 7, 2026
Book Riot’s Most Anticipated Books of 2026:
As a 19th century-set romance, this novel hits all the beats that you’d expect and the language is pitch-perfect. However, the main characters are a lady’s maid named Alice and a young valet she falls for, Charlie. Alice and Charlie’s employers, Lady Jemima Alderwick and Baronet Sir Nigel Wynstowe, are both highly specific in what they want and how they want their servants to act. In order to be together, Alice and Charlie have to trick the finicky aristocrats into a marriage. It’s a very fun upstairs-downstairs novel, perfect to read while traveling around the English countryside. —Julia Rittenberg
As a 19th century-set romance, this novel hits all the beats that you’d expect and the language is pitch-perfect. However, the main characters are a lady’s maid named Alice and a young valet she falls for, Charlie. Alice and Charlie’s employers, Lady Jemima Alderwick and Baronet Sir Nigel Wynstowe, are both highly specific in what they want and how they want their servants to act. In order to be together, Alice and Charlie have to trick the finicky aristocrats into a marriage. It’s a very fun upstairs-downstairs novel, perfect to read while traveling around the English countryside. —Julia Rittenberg
November 6, 2025
Thank you to Penguin Random House/ KNOPF for providing this ARC for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
A Perfect Hand by Ayelet Waldman is a historical romantic but not “romance” novel. Following Alice, a lady’s maid to Lady Jemima has fallen in love with Charlie, a valet. Unfortunately, due to the systems in place for servants in love, it’ll take a fair bit of scheming and influencing to find themselves able to be together. Combine this with Alice’s burgeoning interest in Universal Suffrage, and the story seems to spiral into (controlled, Victorian) chaos.
What I liked most about this book was that for once it seemed was that the story’s center was on the servant class. At no point does a duke, viscount, or queen fall in love with Alice or Charlie. While there are upper class people, this story is solidly not about them. They’re the set dressing and the bit parts. We instead find ourself in the world wedged between the demimonde and the upper crust. These people go to the music hall, but also know that they’ll be working for their livelihood. There may be some upward mobility, but it’s through their own efforts or their own means.
I also liked that Alice and Charlie have a realistic romance. I personally avoid “romance” books because of the unrealistic way I feel that they write dynamics. Charlie and Alice are much more realistic; pleasant and good natured attraction growing through the story through repeated meetings, letters, and mutual feelings of being cared for. This is a relationship free from drama and will-they-won’t-they. It felt refreshing to root for a couple because they felt relatable and normal.
What I didn’t like quite so much was the Lady Whistledown style narration that’s revealed in the final chapter. As someone who really enjoyed the pithy narration, it really felt better when it was an unrelated omniscient narrator. Trying to tack the narrative structure and narration onto someone after the fact felt like a desperate grab to use the well-liked Bridgerton style without actually improving the plot or understanding of the characters.
In a book review is there such a thing as half credit? On one hand, I appreciated the plot line of Alice’s interest in suffrage growing from a reading of some cast off literature to a fever pitch at the end of the book. It was nice to have a heroine with interests like politics and women’s liberation. On the other hand, it did feel a little bit clumsy and heavy handed. It’s nice to have the inclusion, but I’m not sure it’s so well executed.
Are you looking for a historical fiction option that gets away from the ballroom? Are you interested in cute but realistic romances? Do you like suffragettes? This is one has a lot of qualities to recommend it. I’m giving it a 3.75/5 rounded up to a 4/5.
A Perfect Hand by Ayelet Waldman is a historical romantic but not “romance” novel. Following Alice, a lady’s maid to Lady Jemima has fallen in love with Charlie, a valet. Unfortunately, due to the systems in place for servants in love, it’ll take a fair bit of scheming and influencing to find themselves able to be together. Combine this with Alice’s burgeoning interest in Universal Suffrage, and the story seems to spiral into (controlled, Victorian) chaos.
What I liked most about this book was that for once it seemed was that the story’s center was on the servant class. At no point does a duke, viscount, or queen fall in love with Alice or Charlie. While there are upper class people, this story is solidly not about them. They’re the set dressing and the bit parts. We instead find ourself in the world wedged between the demimonde and the upper crust. These people go to the music hall, but also know that they’ll be working for their livelihood. There may be some upward mobility, but it’s through their own efforts or their own means.
I also liked that Alice and Charlie have a realistic romance. I personally avoid “romance” books because of the unrealistic way I feel that they write dynamics. Charlie and Alice are much more realistic; pleasant and good natured attraction growing through the story through repeated meetings, letters, and mutual feelings of being cared for. This is a relationship free from drama and will-they-won’t-they. It felt refreshing to root for a couple because they felt relatable and normal.
What I didn’t like quite so much was the Lady Whistledown style narration that’s revealed in the final chapter. As someone who really enjoyed the pithy narration, it really felt better when it was an unrelated omniscient narrator. Trying to tack the narrative structure and narration onto someone after the fact felt like a desperate grab to use the well-liked Bridgerton style without actually improving the plot or understanding of the characters.
In a book review is there such a thing as half credit? On one hand, I appreciated the plot line of Alice’s interest in suffrage growing from a reading of some cast off literature to a fever pitch at the end of the book. It was nice to have a heroine with interests like politics and women’s liberation. On the other hand, it did feel a little bit clumsy and heavy handed. It’s nice to have the inclusion, but I’m not sure it’s so well executed.
Are you looking for a historical fiction option that gets away from the ballroom? Are you interested in cute but realistic romances? Do you like suffragettes? This is one has a lot of qualities to recommend it. I’m giving it a 3.75/5 rounded up to a 4/5.
September 25, 2025
I really liked this, kind of a romance set in 19th century England with Alice, a lady’s maid as the main character. It is interesting to see what the job entailed- which was everything, constant vigilance at anticipating her spoiled young lady’s every whim. She gets a half day off every two weeks, and her young lady makes her feel guilty even about having that brief time to herself. She’s a good character, curious and bright and increasingly bored of being a servant, even though it’s a pretty high position she’s worked her way up to and she’s very good at it.
A gentleman visiting the family brings his valet, Charlie, and a romance begins. The two servants realize that the only way they can be together is if they can manipulate their two employers into falling in love, a difficult task, because the gentleman is uninterested and the lady actively dislikes him and has a crush on someone else.
It’s fun to watch their machinations and to watch an interesting new world open up to Alice, a character I really liked. Plus, I just enjoy fiction that bashes terrible rich people.
Alice is very good at being a lady's maid, but she might be too bright and curious for this job? When she falls in love with Charlie, a handsome valet, the two of them conspire to make their lord and lady fall in love and marry so that they can actually get to see each other. I enjoyed this window into the world of 19th century servants, and I enjoyed Alice and Charlie's machinations. This novel will be released in spring of 2026.
A gentleman visiting the family brings his valet, Charlie, and a romance begins. The two servants realize that the only way they can be together is if they can manipulate their two employers into falling in love, a difficult task, because the gentleman is uninterested and the lady actively dislikes him and has a crush on someone else.
It’s fun to watch their machinations and to watch an interesting new world open up to Alice, a character I really liked. Plus, I just enjoy fiction that bashes terrible rich people.
Alice is very good at being a lady's maid, but she might be too bright and curious for this job? When she falls in love with Charlie, a handsome valet, the two of them conspire to make their lord and lady fall in love and marry so that they can actually get to see each other. I enjoyed this window into the world of 19th century servants, and I enjoyed Alice and Charlie's machinations. This novel will be released in spring of 2026.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
In the late 187os in England, Alice Lockey is an abigail (maid) to the ever-demanding young and wealthy, Lady Jemima. Alice prides herself on her work which is often tedious and unstimulating. When she meets Charlie Wells, she and he are both taken with each other. But how can a romance between the two proceed when he is a valet to another “house” of means? Maybe if they can somehow make a match between Lady Jemima and Charlie’s somewhat idiosyncratic Lord, the households would combine! The first part of the book is a wonderful, descriptive romp of the foibles of the rich and difficulties of the class that serve them. But Ayelet Waldman, never tips her hand as to what surprises will come as the story proceeds. Like a good play, the author has the narrator break down the fourth wall for the reader with insights into characters and what may be looming ahead. Vocabulary, setting, dialog and historical references make this a very good title for those wishing to escape into the past (which echoes into today). Recommended. Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for providing this title.
December 1, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley for this ARC!
What an odd little book. It was pleasant enough, but seemed as if nothing would happen for several chapters. The setting was impeccable, the quietly growing love story was endearing, and I enjoyed the unconventional manipulations of the household staff. The unexpected drama near the end seemingly came out of nowhere, but I dissolved in tears at the ending, which was truly unexpected and so lovely. I think some edits to the pacing and/or foreshadowing would make a big impact.
What an odd little book. It was pleasant enough, but seemed as if nothing would happen for several chapters. The setting was impeccable, the quietly growing love story was endearing, and I enjoyed the unconventional manipulations of the household staff. The unexpected drama near the end seemingly came out of nowhere, but I dissolved in tears at the ending, which was truly unexpected and so lovely. I think some edits to the pacing and/or foreshadowing would make a big impact.
September 16, 2025
2.5 rounded down -- This book felt like it was trying to do a crossover of Bridgerton and Downton Abbey (great concept!) but wasn't executed very well. I really appreciated the vocabulary and style, which felt very true to a 19th century novel. However, I felt like the narrator breaking the fourth wall made the book feel quite silly, which gave me whiplash when it was also trying to address labor issue, women's rights, and the abolitionist movement at the same time. I liked the ending quite a bit and I feel this was a fun silly read, it was just a bit all over the place and could have been better structured.
Thank you to Knopf, Pantheon, and Vintage and NetGalley for advanced access to this book in exchange for my unbiased review.
Thank you to Knopf, Pantheon, and Vintage and NetGalley for advanced access to this book in exchange for my unbiased review.
September 8, 2025
*2.5
There were some really good moments here, but everything felt very surface level. The romance plots, the class and gender equality element, the scheming all fell a bit flat and distant. Most of all, the choice in narration really took me out of the story; the somewhat omniscient narrator didn’t really work in this context and the constant fourth wall breaking became distracting.
*thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the eARC in exchange for my honest review*
There were some really good moments here, but everything felt very surface level. The romance plots, the class and gender equality element, the scheming all fell a bit flat and distant. Most of all, the choice in narration really took me out of the story; the somewhat omniscient narrator didn’t really work in this context and the constant fourth wall breaking became distracting.
*thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the eARC in exchange for my honest review*
January 17, 2026
This is a somewhat light story (for the most part) told in a Jane Austen tone.
The setting is the late 1800s in England amongst the gentry. A lady’s maid is the protagonist. There is a rather long love story between the maid and a gentleman’s valet that develops “downstairs” but then a twist that involves the women’s suffrage movement.
I enjoyed this book as lighter fare. There are some humorous asides from the narrator and the writing is engaging.
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
The setting is the late 1800s in England amongst the gentry. A lady’s maid is the protagonist. There is a rather long love story between the maid and a gentleman’s valet that develops “downstairs” but then a twist that involves the women’s suffrage movement.
I enjoyed this book as lighter fare. There are some humorous asides from the narrator and the writing is engaging.
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
February 28, 2026
Thank you to Penguin Random House & Knopf for the digital ARC!
A PERFECT HAND is a witty, funny, and feminist regency-style novel based on the love life of a lady’s maid. The story starts off slow-paced and tedious, but I quickly became enthralled in the lives and shenanigans of Alice and Charlie. I loved the mishaps and the feminist quotes equally! The book’s ending is on brand for Ayelet Waldman and I expected nothing less (complimentary, of course).
“So, too, can you and your daughters become anything you desire. May you go forth, your aspirations limited only by your imagination” ❤️
A PERFECT HAND is a witty, funny, and feminist regency-style novel based on the love life of a lady’s maid. The story starts off slow-paced and tedious, but I quickly became enthralled in the lives and shenanigans of Alice and Charlie. I loved the mishaps and the feminist quotes equally! The book’s ending is on brand for Ayelet Waldman and I expected nothing less (complimentary, of course).
“So, too, can you and your daughters become anything you desire. May you go forth, your aspirations limited only by your imagination” ❤️
Currently Reading
October 31, 2025i fear i was sold at the premise of a maid and her lover. and it's kinda giving jane austen (i hope lol)
October 27, 2025
Thank you to Ayelet Waldman, Knopf, Pantheon, and Vintage for providing this ARC in exchange for a review!
"A Perfect Hand" by Ayelet Waldman is a fun and entertaining approach to a historical romance that leads the reader on a journey through the struggles and experiences of working class women, during an era where they had to fight to be heard.
I loved the real-life references to people and events of the sufferage era, and how Waldman was able to involve them in the story with her own original characters
"A Perfect Hand" by Ayelet Waldman is a fun and entertaining approach to a historical romance that leads the reader on a journey through the struggles and experiences of working class women, during an era where they had to fight to be heard.
I loved the real-life references to people and events of the sufferage era, and how Waldman was able to involve them in the story with her own original characters
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is an extremely enjoyable refashioning of the 19th century historical fiction novel that comes at the story from the perspective of a ladies maid. It feels a bit Bridgerton-ish in its clever narration, and the read is fresh and fun as the novel opens up all the hidden doors to show how the class and gender assumptions of the time set up massive obstacles to women's independence and opportunity; it takes a very talented character indeed to find a way around such impediments, and Alice Lockey is that character. This author is a smart, interesting writer in whatever genre she touches (I remember enjoying her very funny "mommy-track mysteries" back in the day), and although this particular genre is not my usual fare, I read it with great amusement.
My thanks to NetGalley and the author for an early view of this novel.
My thanks to NetGalley and the author for an early view of this novel.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
They bonded over books.
Alice Locky, abigail to Lady Jemima, had just settled down to finally start Middlemarch. She was unusual in that she was brought up from the downstairs servants to the position of personal ladies' maid due to her initiative and winning personality. But it was a labor intensive job-she attended to all of her lady's needs and whims, rose before her and tucked her into bed at night. She felt that she earned her rest and reading time. But there was a problem in the servant's quarters. The resident bully and blowhard went after a visiting maid and a visiting manservant stuck up for her. Then that man, Charlie Wells, asked Alice if she enjoyed books by Charles Dickens. And he was cute...heart flutter. Turned out he was the personal servant to Lord Wynstone who was visiting Lord and Lady Alderwick, Jemima's parents.. Wynstone was very handsome and very wealthy but also very eccentric, not exactly Lady Jemima's cup of tea. She was glad he was leaving tomorrow.
Charlie and Alice met again in London when their master and mistress returned from their country estates. By this time, they knew that sparks were flying. The problem was that they would only get to see each other every so often and that does not a romance make-what to do? And so was hatched the perfect plan-all they had to do was marry off her lady and his gentleman, even though she despised him and he was at best, indifferent to her. To complicate matters, Lady Jemima had fallen for a cad and a bounder, but wouldn't believe anyone that told her that he was evil
Meanwhile, Alice was starting to read some interesting, yet radical, pamphlets on the rights of women, which made her reevaluate all of her life decisions, especially those of love and romance. Can this love story be saved?
Waldman turns the Regency romance novel on its head-instead of a tale of the gentry, she writes about a romance between their underlings, she brings in the budding ideas of women's rights and human equality, and she gives her main character choices. The narrative is written in the second person, with several asides to the reader, so you know she is addressing you but you don't know who the narrator is-you will be surprised to find out. A Perfect Hand was a refreshing take on the many Jane Austen read-alikes that channel her writing but don't add anything of their own. Tea and crumpets for all!
Alice Locky, abigail to Lady Jemima, had just settled down to finally start Middlemarch. She was unusual in that she was brought up from the downstairs servants to the position of personal ladies' maid due to her initiative and winning personality. But it was a labor intensive job-she attended to all of her lady's needs and whims, rose before her and tucked her into bed at night. She felt that she earned her rest and reading time. But there was a problem in the servant's quarters. The resident bully and blowhard went after a visiting maid and a visiting manservant stuck up for her. Then that man, Charlie Wells, asked Alice if she enjoyed books by Charles Dickens. And he was cute...heart flutter. Turned out he was the personal servant to Lord Wynstone who was visiting Lord and Lady Alderwick, Jemima's parents.. Wynstone was very handsome and very wealthy but also very eccentric, not exactly Lady Jemima's cup of tea. She was glad he was leaving tomorrow.
Charlie and Alice met again in London when their master and mistress returned from their country estates. By this time, they knew that sparks were flying. The problem was that they would only get to see each other every so often and that does not a romance make-what to do? And so was hatched the perfect plan-all they had to do was marry off her lady and his gentleman, even though she despised him and he was at best, indifferent to her. To complicate matters, Lady Jemima had fallen for a cad and a bounder, but wouldn't believe anyone that told her that he was evil
Meanwhile, Alice was starting to read some interesting, yet radical, pamphlets on the rights of women, which made her reevaluate all of her life decisions, especially those of love and romance. Can this love story be saved?
Waldman turns the Regency romance novel on its head-instead of a tale of the gentry, she writes about a romance between their underlings, she brings in the budding ideas of women's rights and human equality, and she gives her main character choices. The narrative is written in the second person, with several asides to the reader, so you know she is addressing you but you don't know who the narrator is-you will be surprised to find out. A Perfect Hand was a refreshing take on the many Jane Austen read-alikes that channel her writing but don't add anything of their own. Tea and crumpets for all!
October 18, 2025
Take a cup of the Bridgerton series, then stir in a half pound of Downton Abbey and sprinkle with a heavy hand of the Women's Suffragette movement as it began in the United Kingdom and you will have a nice recipe for a charming book written by Ayelet Waldman, titled A Perfect Hand.
The novel begins with our Heroine, Miss Alice Lockey, the daughter of a tenant farmer who has taken employment as an abigail, a fine lady's personal maid for Lady Jemima Alderwick. We, as the readers, follow Miss Alice as she cunningly tends her lady's many needs, often with pluck and ingenuity. Some tasks being more malodorous than others. In her employ she meets a man servant from another noble's household who is visiting her lady's family estate. She finds she has an interest in this gentleman. Intrigue and many exploits are hatched to help the two servants matchmake their employers so that the two of them might find a way to build a life together.
While in London with their employers, Miss Alice is introduced to new thinking and various individuals within the Women's Suffrage Movement. She catches a desire to become involved, but must find a way to do so while dealing with her employer's marriage prospects and her own love.
I thoroughly enjoyed the way Waldman created her characters, wove an interesting plotline and used various asides of a narrator to cue the reader into the lives of the characters. The asides reminded me of the Bridgerton series which I also have enjoyed. This tactic along with the victorian time period and the upstairs, downstairs relationships of lords and ladies being served by their staff created a fun, enjoyable read.
The twist at the end I did not see coming, but thoroughly enjoyed the emotions it evoked in me. Waldman is skilled at using humor as well as serious drama to keep her readers involved in the story as it develops throughout the book. A Perfect Hand is set to be published May 19, 2026. If you are a fan of the worlds of lords and ladies of the late 1800's, early 1900's, I would recommend this story to you. It definitely should be included in next spring's reading lists!
I received a uncorrected proof copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The novel begins with our Heroine, Miss Alice Lockey, the daughter of a tenant farmer who has taken employment as an abigail, a fine lady's personal maid for Lady Jemima Alderwick. We, as the readers, follow Miss Alice as she cunningly tends her lady's many needs, often with pluck and ingenuity. Some tasks being more malodorous than others. In her employ she meets a man servant from another noble's household who is visiting her lady's family estate. She finds she has an interest in this gentleman. Intrigue and many exploits are hatched to help the two servants matchmake their employers so that the two of them might find a way to build a life together.
While in London with their employers, Miss Alice is introduced to new thinking and various individuals within the Women's Suffrage Movement. She catches a desire to become involved, but must find a way to do so while dealing with her employer's marriage prospects and her own love.
I thoroughly enjoyed the way Waldman created her characters, wove an interesting plotline and used various asides of a narrator to cue the reader into the lives of the characters. The asides reminded me of the Bridgerton series which I also have enjoyed. This tactic along with the victorian time period and the upstairs, downstairs relationships of lords and ladies being served by their staff created a fun, enjoyable read.
The twist at the end I did not see coming, but thoroughly enjoyed the emotions it evoked in me. Waldman is skilled at using humor as well as serious drama to keep her readers involved in the story as it develops throughout the book. A Perfect Hand is set to be published May 19, 2026. If you are a fan of the worlds of lords and ladies of the late 1800's, early 1900's, I would recommend this story to you. It definitely should be included in next spring's reading lists!
I received a uncorrected proof copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A Perfect Hand by Ayelet Waldman
Rating: ★★★★★
In A Perfect Hand, Ayelet Waldman delivers a sparkling historical romp set in the 1880s that manages to be both hilariously witty and deeply earnest. The story follows Alice Lockley, a lady’s maid who has climbed the social ladder of service to a comfortable height, yet harbors a quiet, forbidden hunger for the education and literature usually reserved for the elite.
The heart of the story lies in the accidental meeting between Alice and Charlie Wells, a valet to Lord Nigel Wynstowe. Both Alice and Charlie are "well-sorted" in their careers, proud of how far they’ve come from their origins, yet their immediate attraction presents a heartbreaking professional dilemma: in their world, marriage usually means the end of service.
Their solution? A high-stakes matchmaking scheme. Watching Alice attempt to orchestrate a romance between her headstrong, self-absorbed, yet oddly well-meaning mistress, Jemima Alderwick, and Lord Nigel is pure comedy. Jemima is a fantastic foil to Alice; her lack of interest in her own education highlights Alice’s secret intellectual ambitions perfectly.
The reason this book really worked for me was threefold:
The unnamed narrator’s tone is a standout feature, frequently addressing the "gentle reader" in a way that feels immersive and nostalgic.
The humorous pacing: The book is filled with "plans within plans" and hilarious background maneuvers that keep the energy high from start to finish.
The "Twist": Just when you think you have the trajectory of a historical romance figured out, Waldman throws a curve ball. The ending is a brilliant subversion that is as surprising as it is satisfying and thought provoking.
A Perfect Hand is a joy to read for anyone who loves immersive world-building and complex character dynamics. It’s a refreshing take on the "upstairs-downstairs" trope, proving that the most interesting stories often happen in the shadows of the ballroom. I was genuinely surprised by the conclusion, and in the best way possible!
Rating: ★★★★★
In A Perfect Hand, Ayelet Waldman delivers a sparkling historical romp set in the 1880s that manages to be both hilariously witty and deeply earnest. The story follows Alice Lockley, a lady’s maid who has climbed the social ladder of service to a comfortable height, yet harbors a quiet, forbidden hunger for the education and literature usually reserved for the elite.
The heart of the story lies in the accidental meeting between Alice and Charlie Wells, a valet to Lord Nigel Wynstowe. Both Alice and Charlie are "well-sorted" in their careers, proud of how far they’ve come from their origins, yet their immediate attraction presents a heartbreaking professional dilemma: in their world, marriage usually means the end of service.
Their solution? A high-stakes matchmaking scheme. Watching Alice attempt to orchestrate a romance between her headstrong, self-absorbed, yet oddly well-meaning mistress, Jemima Alderwick, and Lord Nigel is pure comedy. Jemima is a fantastic foil to Alice; her lack of interest in her own education highlights Alice’s secret intellectual ambitions perfectly.
The reason this book really worked for me was threefold:
The unnamed narrator’s tone is a standout feature, frequently addressing the "gentle reader" in a way that feels immersive and nostalgic.
The humorous pacing: The book is filled with "plans within plans" and hilarious background maneuvers that keep the energy high from start to finish.
The "Twist": Just when you think you have the trajectory of a historical romance figured out, Waldman throws a curve ball. The ending is a brilliant subversion that is as surprising as it is satisfying and thought provoking.
A Perfect Hand is a joy to read for anyone who loves immersive world-building and complex character dynamics. It’s a refreshing take on the "upstairs-downstairs" trope, proving that the most interesting stories often happen in the shadows of the ballroom. I was genuinely surprised by the conclusion, and in the best way possible!
December 7, 2025
"My word, Alice Lockey, you are a cynic. I hope you marry for love. I know I intend to."
Thank you to NetGalley and Knopf for this ARC!
The very definition of an upstairs-downstairs novel turned on its head. A wonderful look into the power imbalances within nineteenth century estates, the power of women with plans, and the ability of people with a goal to see that goal happen. I will say--that Waldman is a fan of Austen is clear. This is not a modern novel with modern phrasing conveniently set within the world of the nineteenth century. It's more authentically set--lack of modern plumbing and hygiene included--and as a result it might be a challenging read for someone exclusively used to contemporary literature or historical fiction that focuses only on setting for the historical aspects.
Alice and Charlie's attempts to manipulate their respective nobles to provide them an opportunity to marry was clever and funny, and I legitimately laughed out loud fairly often while reading. These wild, self-absorbed, and frankly ridiculous nobles deserved every bit of meddling and shenanigans that befell them.
I loved that Alice was good at her job and not-necessarily dissatisfied, despite how clearly intelligent, well-read, and curious she is as a character. She wasn't perfectly content with her lot in life until someone illuminated her circumstances. If Alice is anything, she's aware. Like the rest of us, she's complicated, and the way that her needs and wants change the more she sees, learns, and experiences was commendable. It took me a few hours to fall all the way in, but it was a quick read and smooth sailing once I was caught--much like Alice in many things she does within these pages.
October 9, 2025
We all want to determine our own destiny. In Ayelet Waldman’s book, “A Perfect Hand”, we follow the life of Miss Alice Lockey. She is a daughter of a tenant farmer who finds work in a manor house on an English estate in the late 1800’s. Alice works her way from an under-housemaid to a senior position as a lady’s maid to the daughter of the family. In this time period in England women basically have no rights. Their fathers and then husbands make all the decisions for them with little to no input from the women. At least this is the case until the women’s suffrage movement begins to spread It’s philosophies.
I was disappointed with this book. The storyline was rough and the style of writing made it awkward to read. I assume this style was used to put the reader in the mood of Victorian England. I’ve read many Regency and Victorian based stories, but most were much easier to read than this book. The attitude and conditions that the author depicted seem accurate. The English Suffragette movement was much more militant than the U.S. movement. The conclusion of this book was true to the English movement. I just wish the book ending could have been a bit more positive. Readers who like historical fiction that isn’t glorified should read this book.
I want to thank Alfred A. Knopf of Penguin Random House for the complementary eARC of this book and for selecting me to review it on NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
#APerfectHand
#AlfredAKnopf/PenguinRandomHouse
#NetGalley
#EnglishSuffragette
#BritishSociety
#HistoricalFiction
I was disappointed with this book. The storyline was rough and the style of writing made it awkward to read. I assume this style was used to put the reader in the mood of Victorian England. I’ve read many Regency and Victorian based stories, but most were much easier to read than this book. The attitude and conditions that the author depicted seem accurate. The English Suffragette movement was much more militant than the U.S. movement. The conclusion of this book was true to the English movement. I just wish the book ending could have been a bit more positive. Readers who like historical fiction that isn’t glorified should read this book.
I want to thank Alfred A. Knopf of Penguin Random House for the complementary eARC of this book and for selecting me to review it on NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
#APerfectHand
#AlfredAKnopf/PenguinRandomHouse
#NetGalley
#EnglishSuffragette
#BritishSociety
#HistoricalFiction
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A Perfect Hand by Ayelet Waldman
Rating: 4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you to Penguin Random House, Knopf, Netgalley, and the author for access to this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
A Perfect Hand is a humorous, engaging, and entertaining read that is equal parts witty and fun. Ayelet Waldman has crafted an utterly charming historical fiction read set in 19th century England. A clever and amusing story that is full of authenticity and Jane Austen-era storytelling.
Alice Lockey, a daughter of a tenant farmer, is a lady’s maid at Alderwick Park for Lady Jemima Alderwick. While her mother has advised her to work only until marriage, Alice is happier when working. When Charlie Wells, a valet, gets her attention, Alice develops a plan in order to spend more time with him. Alice tries to arrange a romance between Lady Jemima Alderwick and Charlie’s employer, Baronet Sir Nigel Wynstowe. Lady Jemima is in love with someone else though and Sir Wynstowe is rather peculiar. Alice must give it all she has in order to create a romance between the two of them, while also navigating her attraction to Charlie.
A Perfect Hand is wonderfully witty, has excellent character growth, and provides a great blend of romance, history, and comedy. Alice and Charlie’s attempts to establish a romance between their employers are utterly hilarious and so entertaining. Alice is a great heroine, with her determination, capability, and perceptive nature.
Overall, A Perfect Hand is a well-written novel that is perfect for readers who enjoy historical fiction with a unique twist!
Rating: 4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you to Penguin Random House, Knopf, Netgalley, and the author for access to this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
A Perfect Hand is a humorous, engaging, and entertaining read that is equal parts witty and fun. Ayelet Waldman has crafted an utterly charming historical fiction read set in 19th century England. A clever and amusing story that is full of authenticity and Jane Austen-era storytelling.
Alice Lockey, a daughter of a tenant farmer, is a lady’s maid at Alderwick Park for Lady Jemima Alderwick. While her mother has advised her to work only until marriage, Alice is happier when working. When Charlie Wells, a valet, gets her attention, Alice develops a plan in order to spend more time with him. Alice tries to arrange a romance between Lady Jemima Alderwick and Charlie’s employer, Baronet Sir Nigel Wynstowe. Lady Jemima is in love with someone else though and Sir Wynstowe is rather peculiar. Alice must give it all she has in order to create a romance between the two of them, while also navigating her attraction to Charlie.
A Perfect Hand is wonderfully witty, has excellent character growth, and provides a great blend of romance, history, and comedy. Alice and Charlie’s attempts to establish a romance between their employers are utterly hilarious and so entertaining. Alice is a great heroine, with her determination, capability, and perceptive nature.
Overall, A Perfect Hand is a well-written novel that is perfect for readers who enjoy historical fiction with a unique twist!
August 29, 2025
This book was a light hearted whimsical 18th Century story about a lady’s maid who has always worked hard in her limited schooling and now in her job working for a spoiled English Lady. Jemima Alderwick. Alice has a love of books and for the new movement of women’s suffrage. When she falls madly in love with Charlie Wells, a fellow servant from a different manor house, the two ban together to find a way to be together. The only choice the two servants have is to be matchmakers to their employers. If their employers marry, Alice and Charlie, can also be together. The only problem is, their employers hate each other.
This was an enjoyable story with protagonists that I found myself cheering for as they try to unite their spoiled mistress and wealthy, hypochondriac baronet.. I was surprised when the narrator would break the fourth wall and speak directly to the reader, but it became clear later the significance of these interruptions. Being such a fun, whimsical story, I was shocked when the end took a serious turn, but I feel it really added importance to the story.
Thank you Net Galley and Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage and Anchor for the Advanced Reader Copy in exchange for an honest review. #NetGalley #APerfectHand
https://www.instagram.com/aaknopf/.
https://www.instagram.com/knopfcooks/
https://www.instagram.com/pantheonbooks/
https://www.instagram.com/ireadvintage/
This was an enjoyable story with protagonists that I found myself cheering for as they try to unite their spoiled mistress and wealthy, hypochondriac baronet.. I was surprised when the narrator would break the fourth wall and speak directly to the reader, but it became clear later the significance of these interruptions. Being such a fun, whimsical story, I was shocked when the end took a serious turn, but I feel it really added importance to the story.
Thank you Net Galley and Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage and Anchor for the Advanced Reader Copy in exchange for an honest review. #NetGalley #APerfectHand
https://www.instagram.com/aaknopf/.
https://www.instagram.com/knopfcooks/
https://www.instagram.com/pantheonbooks/
https://www.instagram.com/ireadvintage/
September 13, 2025
Kudos to Ayelet Waldman for writing a most delightful and unexpected historical (Regency Romance?) novel that despite its unusual style will bring a smile to your face and keep your finger turning pages. I used to enjoy her Mommy Track mysteries and have also read several of her non-fiction. She hasn't lost her talent for fiction, but his one is different. Prepare yourself for surprises if you liked Downton Abbey.
Alice Lockey is an abigail, a lady's maid, to Lady Jemima, the spoiled pretty daughter in the last quarter of the 19th century. Alice has it better than the scullery or kitchen maids, but her work is hard and requires tact and multiple talents. Unusual for the time, Alice is a reader and an independent thinker. At a house party she meets the valet of one of the guests and, as you'd expect, they fall in love. The "plot" is indeed a plot to interest Jemima in a match with Charlie's Lord", a phsyiogamist. (someone who studies proportion of faces and hands to determine high birth -don't' ask.)
The other plot line is the women's suffrage movement in England and America. Both plots are immersive and interesting. Expect to be addressed directly by the author and insights into cleaning, sewing, styles, odors and toileting. (I know, but you won't object.) Different, but Waldman hasn't lost it.
Thanks to Net Galley and Knopf publishing for the Arc of this upcoming novel.
Alice Lockey is an abigail, a lady's maid, to Lady Jemima, the spoiled pretty daughter in the last quarter of the 19th century. Alice has it better than the scullery or kitchen maids, but her work is hard and requires tact and multiple talents. Unusual for the time, Alice is a reader and an independent thinker. At a house party she meets the valet of one of the guests and, as you'd expect, they fall in love. The "plot" is indeed a plot to interest Jemima in a match with Charlie's Lord", a phsyiogamist. (someone who studies proportion of faces and hands to determine high birth -don't' ask.)
The other plot line is the women's suffrage movement in England and America. Both plots are immersive and interesting. Expect to be addressed directly by the author and insights into cleaning, sewing, styles, odors and toileting. (I know, but you won't object.) Different, but Waldman hasn't lost it.
Thanks to Net Galley and Knopf publishing for the Arc of this upcoming novel.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
19th century England. "Miss Alice Lockey, daughter of a tenant farmer, has by dint of hard work, innate intelligence, and a cunning ability to predict the moods of her betters, raised herself to the lofty status of lady’s maid at Alderwick Park." Alice attends to the whims of Lady Jemima Alderwick who is besotted with Mr. Thomas Smythe-Roberts--a whole 'nother story."...when a visiting servant, a valet named Charlie Wells, catches her eye, Alice begins to understand the constraints of her position. In a ploy to spend time with the object of her affection, Alice attempts to arrange a romance between Lady Jemima Alderwick and Charlie’s employer, one Baronet Sir Nigel Wynstowe."
Much later on the travails of suffragettes and working class [factory workers] women enter the narrative.
An easy enough read, mindful of Bridgerton especially as there are times when "gentle reader" is introduced. Yes, somewhat interesting, but also boring--much back and forth and scheming between Charlie and Alice who are conspiring to get their two employers together and end Jemima's affection for Smythe=Roberts [a scoundrel/revealed].
No spoiler, but I never predicted how the book might end [so kudos for that, but not enough].
An outlier in the praise for this novel.
19th century England. "Miss Alice Lockey, daughter of a tenant farmer, has by dint of hard work, innate intelligence, and a cunning ability to predict the moods of her betters, raised herself to the lofty status of lady’s maid at Alderwick Park." Alice attends to the whims of Lady Jemima Alderwick who is besotted with Mr. Thomas Smythe-Roberts--a whole 'nother story."...when a visiting servant, a valet named Charlie Wells, catches her eye, Alice begins to understand the constraints of her position. In a ploy to spend time with the object of her affection, Alice attempts to arrange a romance between Lady Jemima Alderwick and Charlie’s employer, one Baronet Sir Nigel Wynstowe."
Much later on the travails of suffragettes and working class [factory workers] women enter the narrative.
An easy enough read, mindful of Bridgerton especially as there are times when "gentle reader" is introduced. Yes, somewhat interesting, but also boring--much back and forth and scheming between Charlie and Alice who are conspiring to get their two employers together and end Jemima's affection for Smythe=Roberts [a scoundrel/revealed].
No spoiler, but I never predicted how the book might end [so kudos for that, but not enough].
An outlier in the praise for this novel.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
What delightful historical fiction! If I didn’t know better, I’d have thought the book was written by Jane Austin or a novelist of that perfect. The tone and story itself is consummate 19th C!
As the book blurb says, this book is about two 19th C servants plotting to get their employers married to each other so the two can marry and be together. Alice Lockey is maid to Lady Jemima Alderwick while Charlie Wells is valet to Viscount Nigel Wynstowe, one of Jemima’s suitors. Alicia can read (not many servants in those days could), so the books Jemima’s aunt gives her like those of John Stuart Mill, hold no interest for Jemima they do for Alice. Alice is intrigued. Then during one of Alice’s errands to London, she meets Emmeline, an administrator for the Society for the Promotion of Employment for Women or as its unfortunate acronym is known: SPEW (I found that so funny). Captivated by Emmeline and SPEW’s literature, Alice realizes she and Charlie may be mismatched. Alice has greater visions for herself. The ending to this book is so incredibly clever, I do not want to spoil it for future readers. Suffice it to say, it’s worth reading this book to find out.
This may seem a romance at face value but it’s deeper than that. We are treated to the lives of English servants not the peers and see what they face in their day to day existence. Alice views her life as potentially equal to a man (shocking!) and why not. This is a story about balancing love and ambition. Highly recommend.
My thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for allowing me access to this ARC.
As the book blurb says, this book is about two 19th C servants plotting to get their employers married to each other so the two can marry and be together. Alice Lockey is maid to Lady Jemima Alderwick while Charlie Wells is valet to Viscount Nigel Wynstowe, one of Jemima’s suitors. Alicia can read (not many servants in those days could), so the books Jemima’s aunt gives her like those of John Stuart Mill, hold no interest for Jemima they do for Alice. Alice is intrigued. Then during one of Alice’s errands to London, she meets Emmeline, an administrator for the Society for the Promotion of Employment for Women or as its unfortunate acronym is known: SPEW (I found that so funny). Captivated by Emmeline and SPEW’s literature, Alice realizes she and Charlie may be mismatched. Alice has greater visions for herself. The ending to this book is so incredibly clever, I do not want to spoil it for future readers. Suffice it to say, it’s worth reading this book to find out.
This may seem a romance at face value but it’s deeper than that. We are treated to the lives of English servants not the peers and see what they face in their day to day existence. Alice views her life as potentially equal to a man (shocking!) and why not. This is a story about balancing love and ambition. Highly recommend.
My thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for allowing me access to this ARC.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Matchmaking is a perilous endeavor. from A Perfect Hand by Ayelet Waldman
I do love novels written in the style of 19th c British literature. A Perfect Hand is a delight, with a strong authorial voice (from the fictional author of the tale), period details, an upstairs/downstairs double love story, and, to ice the proverbial cake, a young woman discovering her voice and claiming her power.
Our heroine Alice is bright, bookish, and knows she is lucky to work for a generous, if vapid, mistress, Lady Jemima. Jemima is drawn to a handsome suitor who she is unaware is a cad and pecunious scoundrel.
A visiting gentleman’s valet shows Alice special attention and they fall in love. The only way they can be together if is they can get his master and her mistress married. They begin planning a long game to expose Lady Jemima’s love interest’s ungentlemanly behavior. And somehow get together two people with nothing in common.
Alice comes under the influence of Lady Jemima’s suffragette aunt, reading radical books from her library and attending lectures.
Votes for women? Alice though. It seemed as unlikely as votes for goats or horses. from A Perfect Hand
There is a delicious twist that wraps the story up with a surprise.
I totally enjoyed it.
Thanks to Knopf for a free book through NetGalley
I do love novels written in the style of 19th c British literature. A Perfect Hand is a delight, with a strong authorial voice (from the fictional author of the tale), period details, an upstairs/downstairs double love story, and, to ice the proverbial cake, a young woman discovering her voice and claiming her power.
Our heroine Alice is bright, bookish, and knows she is lucky to work for a generous, if vapid, mistress, Lady Jemima. Jemima is drawn to a handsome suitor who she is unaware is a cad and pecunious scoundrel.
A visiting gentleman’s valet shows Alice special attention and they fall in love. The only way they can be together if is they can get his master and her mistress married. They begin planning a long game to expose Lady Jemima’s love interest’s ungentlemanly behavior. And somehow get together two people with nothing in common.
Alice comes under the influence of Lady Jemima’s suffragette aunt, reading radical books from her library and attending lectures.
Votes for women? Alice though. It seemed as unlikely as votes for goats or horses. from A Perfect Hand
There is a delicious twist that wraps the story up with a surprise.
I totally enjoyed it.
Thanks to Knopf for a free book through NetGalley
September 7, 2025
Alice Lockey was lucky enough to rise above her station to the position of lady's maid to the spoiled yet surprisingly at times compassionate and gentle Lady Jemima. Her tenant farmer family expects her to marry and become mistress and mother in her own home, but Alice is not convinced that is the life for her even though she does not yet know what else is available. During one house party for the elite, Charlie Wells, valet, shows up and Alice begins thinking perhaps marriage and a family life aren't so bad. When it became apparent that a marriage between the two is completely out of the question, they begin to conspire to matchmake their employers in order to also be together. With Alice's plans underway, she follows her Lady to the City where she encounters women who have chosen other, more independent life paths.
I loved this book - it reminded me of a book I devoured over and over as a teen: "Mayfair" by Nancy Fitzgerald. I love the Regency time period, the voice of the author narrating and conversing directly with the reader at different times in this book, and the characters. I love the ending that wasn't perfect, but right. Finally, I love that Alice Lockey was a real person!
I loved this book - it reminded me of a book I devoured over and over as a teen: "Mayfair" by Nancy Fitzgerald. I love the Regency time period, the voice of the author narrating and conversing directly with the reader at different times in this book, and the characters. I love the ending that wasn't perfect, but right. Finally, I love that Alice Lockey was a real person!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
If you love a Jane Austen book, and let's be real, who doesn't? You'll enjoy this look at the servants' view of things.
It's smart and sophisticated, well-plotted, flows easily, and has strong character development. It's easy to get lost in this well-paced story about Alice, abigail to Lady Jemima Alderwick, and Charlie, valet to Lord Winstowe. The two meet when Lord Winstowe visits the Alderwick home as a potential suitor to Lady Jemima, and they scheme fast for a way to be together.
I have often thought it would be interesting to get a servant class romance, and this delivers. The details are sharp, with a well-defined period, and the writing is excellent.
As others have noted, this breaks the fourth wall, and it was slightly overdone.
I was also underwhelmed by the ending. While the author definitely sets it up to happen that way, I still felt it was abrupt and jarring, like the author was waiting the whole time to say, "gotcha!" Like it didn't quite fit. It was interesting to see Alice reading Middlemarch and, without spoiling, wondering how the message of that book is at odds with this one's.
Thank you to NetGalley, Knopf, and Ayelet Waldman for the opportunity to review an advanced copy.
It's smart and sophisticated, well-plotted, flows easily, and has strong character development. It's easy to get lost in this well-paced story about Alice, abigail to Lady Jemima Alderwick, and Charlie, valet to Lord Winstowe. The two meet when Lord Winstowe visits the Alderwick home as a potential suitor to Lady Jemima, and they scheme fast for a way to be together.
I have often thought it would be interesting to get a servant class romance, and this delivers. The details are sharp, with a well-defined period, and the writing is excellent.
As others have noted, this breaks the fourth wall, and it was slightly overdone.
I was also underwhelmed by the ending. While the author definitely sets it up to happen that way, I still felt it was abrupt and jarring, like the author was waiting the whole time to say, "gotcha!" Like it didn't quite fit. It was interesting to see Alice reading Middlemarch and, without spoiling, wondering how the message of that book is at odds with this one's.
Thank you to NetGalley, Knopf, and Ayelet Waldman for the opportunity to review an advanced copy.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
2.5
Poorly written on the level of a Victorian pastiche — may work for some but if you really know the period this falls apart immediately. (Lots of historical details are wrong too, like one moment where a woman “shrugs off” a dress in a moment… girl…) But my real ire is reserved for the introduction of women’s suffrage etc into the book: she uses real historical figures in an overly cutesy way, raises questions about work and equality in a way that’s overly obvious, and then ends the book focusing on this aspect in a way that is frankly risible and overly sentimental. I don’t want to get into details since the book isn’t out yet but as an exercise I think this is utterly pointless. It has nothing to say about history and it’s not fun or cheeky enough to make up for that.
Waldman and her husband Michael Chabon were very equivocal in reacting to the allegations against Neil Gaiman, Chabon subscribes to a paid substack that claims Gaiman is innocent, and they’ve both supported their son who has been accused of rape and strangulation. So I’m also not exactly charmed by this superficial depiction of historical feminism coming from someone whose real world engagement with feminist causes is… fraught to put it mildly.
Poorly written on the level of a Victorian pastiche — may work for some but if you really know the period this falls apart immediately. (Lots of historical details are wrong too, like one moment where a woman “shrugs off” a dress in a moment… girl…) But my real ire is reserved for the introduction of women’s suffrage etc into the book: she uses real historical figures in an overly cutesy way, raises questions about work and equality in a way that’s overly obvious, and then ends the book focusing on this aspect in a way that is frankly risible and overly sentimental. I don’t want to get into details since the book isn’t out yet but as an exercise I think this is utterly pointless. It has nothing to say about history and it’s not fun or cheeky enough to make up for that.
Waldman and her husband Michael Chabon were very equivocal in reacting to the allegations against Neil Gaiman, Chabon subscribes to a paid substack that claims Gaiman is innocent, and they’ve both supported their son who has been accused of rape and strangulation. So I’m also not exactly charmed by this superficial depiction of historical feminism coming from someone whose real world engagement with feminist causes is… fraught to put it mildly.
October 11, 2025
I was pleasantly surprised by how imaginative and utterly unique this book was. Despite possessing Jane Austen and Romanticism esque, this book established it was not just a cheap recreation of books in the romantic movement. Despite the classical prose, I found this book easy to read and impossible to put down, finishing it within a few days.
The characters were all extremely enjoyable and just as distinctive as the writing is. The sharp wit of the posh 19th century characters will always be a favorite of mine. Especially Charlie and Alice, who truly are a match made in heaven with their charming personalities.
I also found applaudable that the usage of women's suffrage and class consciousness was used not as a tool for characterization, or as a small side plot, but the factor driving the conclusion. AND THE PLOT TWIST. Never have I read something that took me by surprise quite like the ending of this book. Though some may find it disappointing, I found it was beautiful that the author did not disregard the character development for a cheaper, more digestible ending.
I want to thank NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC!
The characters were all extremely enjoyable and just as distinctive as the writing is. The sharp wit of the posh 19th century characters will always be a favorite of mine. Especially Charlie and Alice, who truly are a match made in heaven with their charming personalities.
I also found applaudable that the usage of women's suffrage and class consciousness was used not as a tool for characterization, or as a small side plot, but the factor driving the conclusion. AND THE PLOT TWIST. Never have I read something that took me by surprise quite like the ending of this book. Though some may find it disappointing, I found it was beautiful that the author did not disregard the character development for a cheaper, more digestible ending.
I want to thank NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
**3 stars**
I went into A Perfect Hand by Ayelet Waldman expecting something along the lines of a Bridgerton/Downton Abbey hybrid, and while it didn’t fully land in that space for me, it was still an enjoyable read. Waldman’s writing style is engaging and polished, and I found myself invested in both the characters and their world. The pacing was steady throughout, and I especially appreciated that the story didn’t follow the predictable beats of a typical Regency romance.
One of the highlights for me was the twist toward the end, which added depth and reframed parts of the story in an interesting way. It elevated the book beyond a straightforward period romance and made it feel more layered.
That said, I personally would have loved a bit more romance and emotional payoff between the characters. The foundation was there, but I wanted just a little more to fully satisfy that aspect of the story. Overall, this was a solid and well-written novel that will appeal to readers who enjoy historical fiction with a twist, even if it didn’t quite reach four-star territory for me.
Thank you to Net Galley for the advanced copy to review. This is set to publish May 19.
I went into A Perfect Hand by Ayelet Waldman expecting something along the lines of a Bridgerton/Downton Abbey hybrid, and while it didn’t fully land in that space for me, it was still an enjoyable read. Waldman’s writing style is engaging and polished, and I found myself invested in both the characters and their world. The pacing was steady throughout, and I especially appreciated that the story didn’t follow the predictable beats of a typical Regency romance.
One of the highlights for me was the twist toward the end, which added depth and reframed parts of the story in an interesting way. It elevated the book beyond a straightforward period romance and made it feel more layered.
That said, I personally would have loved a bit more romance and emotional payoff between the characters. The foundation was there, but I wanted just a little more to fully satisfy that aspect of the story. Overall, this was a solid and well-written novel that will appeal to readers who enjoy historical fiction with a twist, even if it didn’t quite reach four-star territory for me.
Thank you to Net Galley for the advanced copy to review. This is set to publish May 19.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I would like to thank Net Galley for the opportunity to read this as an ARC. This is an enchanting novel about England, social classes and the fight for women suffrage It starts in 1879 and continues for several years. It is the story of Alice, maid to Lady Jemima , and Charlie, valet to Lord Wynstowe. Alice and Charlie meet below stairs at the home of Lady Jemima's family and are attracted to each other. Both being in service, they contrive a way to be together- they only have to have Lady Jemima and Lord Wynstowe fall in love , get married and then they can be together. While this sounds like it is the setting for a madcap version of Upstairs Downstairs, it has a deeper subtext and storyline. Narrated by an unnamed person( until the very end), we soon realize that Alice is bright and inquisitive and interested in topics her employer dismisses out of hand( women's rights for example).As Alice and Charlie continue to get their respective employers together, Alice falls in with a group of ladies who very much want more for women than just marriage and children. It is a fun story and one with many levels. I really enjoyed it.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
as someone who loves historical fiction, especially ones set in the victorian period or before, i ate this up like hot steamy and spicy noodles!
A Perfect Hand is a thoroughly charming and clever novel that feels like a delightful mashup of a Jane Austen comedy of manners and a Victorian feminist manifesto.
The story is told from the perspective of Alice, a determined lady's maid in 19th-century England who concocts an elaborate scheme to manipulate her mistress and a baronet into a marriage, all so she can marry the baronet's handsome valet, Charlie. It's a fun, engaging "marriage plot" but flipped to focus entirely on the servants' ambition and desire to improve their station.
I loved the sharp wit and the historical detail, especially how Waldman weaves in the real-life context of burgeoning women's suffrage and class struggles. The main character, Alice, is wonderfully cunning and spirited. It’s a smart, big-hearted story about class, gender, and finding one's own path. It manages to be both lighthearted and surprisingly deep.
A Perfect Hand is a thoroughly charming and clever novel that feels like a delightful mashup of a Jane Austen comedy of manners and a Victorian feminist manifesto.
The story is told from the perspective of Alice, a determined lady's maid in 19th-century England who concocts an elaborate scheme to manipulate her mistress and a baronet into a marriage, all so she can marry the baronet's handsome valet, Charlie. It's a fun, engaging "marriage plot" but flipped to focus entirely on the servants' ambition and desire to improve their station.
I loved the sharp wit and the historical detail, especially how Waldman weaves in the real-life context of burgeoning women's suffrage and class struggles. The main character, Alice, is wonderfully cunning and spirited. It’s a smart, big-hearted story about class, gender, and finding one's own path. It manages to be both lighthearted and surprisingly deep.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews