What do you think?
Rate this book
Same Girl: A Polyamorous Romance
Kai “Chosen” Sutton is all deep strokes, erotic moans, and passionate love. When he touches Mya Jones, it’s with intent—to own, to ravish, to wreck her for any other man. He’s ready to make her his wife. He believes he’s the only man who makes her body hum.
Ryan “Fyve” Patterson is the inferno to Mya’s control—reckless, aggressive, and grimy in the best ways. He doesn’t make love. He f*cks her like the world is ending—pounding strokes, throat chokes, on her knees. And he thinks she is all his.
Mya Jones is caught in a maelstrom of desire and adoration. Two men who offer her different kinds of love and complete worship—mind, body, and soul. How can she choose between two men who touch her like they own her and love her like they can’t breathe without her?
When old and new secrets are revealed, choices must be made. And Chosen and Fyve will either have to walk away or break every rule for a chance to share the only woman they want.
Ryan “Fyve” Patterson is the inferno to Mya’s control—reckless, aggressive, and grimy in the best ways. He doesn’t make love. He f*cks her like the world is ending—pounding strokes, throat chokes, on her knees. And he thinks she is all his.
Mya Jones is caught in a maelstrom of desire and adoration. Two men who offer her different kinds of love and complete worship—mind, body, and soul. How can she choose between two men who touch her like they own her and love her like they can’t breathe without her?
When old and new secrets are revealed, choices must be made. And Chosen and Fyve will either have to walk away or break every rule for a chance to share the only woman they want.
145 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 20, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews
September 3, 2025
I loved Fyve and Chosen, Mya not so much. That is the only reason for the low rating. The spice/smut was there! Mya’s reasonings were childish, like how long out of high school are y’all to want that kind of revenge? I’m glad the men were able to get it together. Mya is still not my first choice.
August 22, 2025
Same girl
This was a pretty good poly romance. I liked the characters together but I wish there was more of them on page showcasing how they navigated the relationship outside the bedroom. These two men were madly in love with her and her with them and even though they weren’t initially comfortable with sharing, they loved her enough to grant her that wish.
I was surprised about the reason behind Mya getting with them both initially especially with the book started out and would have thought her wanting to entertain both men would have been based off being hurt by her exhusband and not because of something from high school, but it all worked out for her and her men in the end. 3.75/5 stars
This was a pretty good poly romance. I liked the characters together but I wish there was more of them on page showcasing how they navigated the relationship outside the bedroom. These two men were madly in love with her and her with them and even though they weren’t initially comfortable with sharing, they loved her enough to grant her that wish.
I was surprised about the reason behind Mya getting with them both initially especially with the book started out and would have thought her wanting to entertain both men would have been based off being hurt by her exhusband and not because of something from high school, but it all worked out for her and her men in the end. 3.75/5 stars
August 23, 2025
This story has your attention from page one.
September 3, 2025
3.5⭐️ Mya knew she was wrong for that terrible “revenge plot” she came up with, but I loved how the MMCs loved her through her bullshit 😂. Chosen is definitely my favorite.
April 24, 2026
Rating 3.75 ⭐️ Let’s go ahead and turn the heat UP because this one came with pressure. Same Girl: A Polyamorous Romance is messy, intense and built on a foundation that was shaky from the very beginning.
Mya sis was NOT innocent in this. Let’s be clear. This whole situation started as payback, a plan rooted in hurt and old wounds from high school. Somewhere along the way she lost control of the game she created and caught real feelings. Completely lost the plot!!
That’s where things had the potential to be dangerous. Now it’s not just revenge it’s emotions, attachment and two FRIENDS who love her in completely different ways but just as deeply.
Chosen brings that intentional, steady, I see a future with you kind of love. Fyve he’s chaos, passion and intensity all wrapped into one.
What really stood out is how this book leans into the emotional side of a poly dynamic. It’s not just about desire it’s about insecurity, past hurt, ego and figuring out if love can actually exist outside of traditional boundaries. This could’ve gone LEFT real quick but somehow it worked in her favor. Still messy. Still risky. Still a game she probably shouldn’t have played in the first place but definitely entertaining to watch unfold. Babygirl is thoroughly satisfied!
Mya sis was NOT innocent in this. Let’s be clear. This whole situation started as payback, a plan rooted in hurt and old wounds from high school. Somewhere along the way she lost control of the game she created and caught real feelings. Completely lost the plot!!
That’s where things had the potential to be dangerous. Now it’s not just revenge it’s emotions, attachment and two FRIENDS who love her in completely different ways but just as deeply.
Chosen brings that intentional, steady, I see a future with you kind of love. Fyve he’s chaos, passion and intensity all wrapped into one.
What really stood out is how this book leans into the emotional side of a poly dynamic. It’s not just about desire it’s about insecurity, past hurt, ego and figuring out if love can actually exist outside of traditional boundaries. This could’ve gone LEFT real quick but somehow it worked in her favor. Still messy. Still risky. Still a game she probably shouldn’t have played in the first place but definitely entertaining to watch unfold. Babygirl is thoroughly satisfied!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 31, 2026
Yes I know it's fiction but this one was just a bit too far fetched for me lol I can't say I didn't enjoy it though.
Mya was someone who had her heart broken throughout her life, moreso by her trifflin husband who had a whole girlfriend and made a baby on her.
She started dating Fyve after he had done some renovations to her home but because he lived in another city, she only got to see him periodically. She loved him and wanted to make it work but also had a desire for more. So, she turned to Chosen, her tattoo artist.
The two of them were friends and it wasn't until they were at the Smoke Hour telling Smoke about their amazing women that they realized they were both dating Mya.
Neither of them were willing to let her go so after Chosen propose, he and Fyve exposed her lies. While they were both angry, they both loved and wanted Mya and she refused to choose between them.
This was definitely a wild ride!
Mya was someone who had her heart broken throughout her life, moreso by her trifflin husband who had a whole girlfriend and made a baby on her.
She started dating Fyve after he had done some renovations to her home but because he lived in another city, she only got to see him periodically. She loved him and wanted to make it work but also had a desire for more. So, she turned to Chosen, her tattoo artist.
The two of them were friends and it wasn't until they were at the Smoke Hour telling Smoke about their amazing women that they realized they were both dating Mya.
Neither of them were willing to let her go so after Chosen propose, he and Fyve exposed her lies. While they were both angry, they both loved and wanted Mya and she refused to choose between them.
This was definitely a wild ride!
September 1, 2025
Sensually Sexy!
I don’t think I’ve read a more mature polyamorous story. How Egypt handled their transition to a throuple, all parties expressing their desires, fears, expectations, etc., was eye opening. I loved the openness and trust between them. The reassurance. The idea of a threesome is so taboo, but when you see a relationship that shares genuine love, respect, and a desire to provide pleasure for all parties, and not just for the thrill of the act of sex itself, it’s something else entirely. The storyline itself was impressive, because it wasn’t the typical couple finding a third person or someone who had already been in a polygamous relationship and looking for another. Great writing all around! It was so sensual and sexy!
I don’t think I’ve read a more mature polyamorous story. How Egypt handled their transition to a throuple, all parties expressing their desires, fears, expectations, etc., was eye opening. I loved the openness and trust between them. The reassurance. The idea of a threesome is so taboo, but when you see a relationship that shares genuine love, respect, and a desire to provide pleasure for all parties, and not just for the thrill of the act of sex itself, it’s something else entirely. The storyline itself was impressive, because it wasn’t the typical couple finding a third person or someone who had already been in a polygamous relationship and looking for another. Great writing all around! It was so sensual and sexy!
November 11, 2025
Nice...
Mya was a broken woman who had to sort of reinvent herself. Her husband broke her down to a point that she was in need of serious healing. In walks Fyve...then walks Chosen. Unaware of their connection, she does a whole lot more than connect with these two. While I don't agree with her initial plan, I appreciate how everything turns out. Sometimes one man can't be everything you need when you've been hurt, but Fyve and Chosen together proved to be more than she'll ever need. I did want to see how Mya and Fyve's relationship progressed as he was more aggressive- I guess in his pursuits. Happy Reading Y'all.💋
Mya was a broken woman who had to sort of reinvent herself. Her husband broke her down to a point that she was in need of serious healing. In walks Fyve...then walks Chosen. Unaware of their connection, she does a whole lot more than connect with these two. While I don't agree with her initial plan, I appreciate how everything turns out. Sometimes one man can't be everything you need when you've been hurt, but Fyve and Chosen together proved to be more than she'll ever need. I did want to see how Mya and Fyve's relationship progressed as he was more aggressive- I guess in his pursuits. Happy Reading Y'all.💋
August 31, 2025
I have no idea where these why choose books have been coming from, but I am loving them. This story right here was so amazing! When I tell you she wrote the heck out of this book. Why have one when you can have two?! What started as some get back but quickly took a turn into something more. I truly believe not one person can give you everything you need and Mya found out first hand. Both Chosen and Fyve both gave her something different but completed her. It was definitely some twist and turns I didn’t see coming but I was here for it!
July 10, 2026
Yawn!
I’m not against reading about polyamorous relationships but this book just did NOT do it for me. I hate when I’m not able to finish a book for this specific reason because I literally will skip to the end without reading the rest of it. Something about the story line just didn’t click with me. I’m not sure if it was because of what went down when they were in high school or what. Nevertheless, my rating still stands.
I’m not against reading about polyamorous relationships but this book just did NOT do it for me. I hate when I’m not able to finish a book for this specific reason because I literally will skip to the end without reading the rest of it. Something about the story line just didn’t click with me. I’m not sure if it was because of what went down when they were in high school or what. Nevertheless, my rating still stands.
August 22, 2025
Same Girl ! Yes Please !
This wasn’t a long read and got straight to the point. Kudos to Mya she knew what she wanted and stood 10 toes down on that. The pace of the book was on point and you were able to understand each character and their personality. Egypt did a good job at developing the polyamorous relationship without making it
weird. Egypt also kept it sexy and spicy.
This wasn’t a long read and got straight to the point. Kudos to Mya she knew what she wanted and stood 10 toes down on that. The pace of the book was on point and you were able to understand each character and their personality. Egypt did a good job at developing the polyamorous relationship without making it
weird. Egypt also kept it sexy and spicy.
October 17, 2025
That was a lot. I am glad I read it, to say the least. But I always feel like there’s an important element missing from MFM romances. Since the guys don’t “touch” there’s always a lot of one on one activities not so much as a “group” because a lot less can be done ain’t the men don’t touch. But this was lovely and I’m glad she got to keep both her mans. Good on you Sis
December 25, 2025
Omg. I was coming for Egypt in 26 but, so glad I at least got this 1 in before hand. Mya was broken but, Chosen and Fyve did what had to be done putting Mya back together again. Lol. Wined, Dined, and filled in every Orpheus of her body, Lordy this was a great and fulfilling quickie with serious BDE. Loved it.
January 20, 2026
Good read!
Interesting read. It took me several weeks to finish reading this one. Not sure why it wasn’t an easier read for me but oh well. The concept was intriguing and the book cover was fire! It seemed like a very unconventional relationship for Chosen and Frye to agree to so easily.
Interesting read. It took me several weeks to finish reading this one. Not sure why it wasn’t an easier read for me but oh well. The concept was intriguing and the book cover was fire! It seemed like a very unconventional relationship for Chosen and Frye to agree to so easily.
February 2, 2026
Smut was great. Chosen and Fyve were great. Everything else was just annoying, especially Mya. Mya wanted her cake and eat it too. And those men just went along with it because they loved her. I also thought it would have taken the guys some more time to forgive her after what she did, or to even be in a poly relationship.
February 13, 2026
Excellent Read
This is the first time I read a something like this and I loved it. It took me to heights I’ve never been before. I felt the love that both men felt for her and the ultimate goal for them was making sure that she was happy. I loved this.
This was a very satisfying book. 10 stars on my list so far on my 2026 list of books.
This is the first time I read a something like this and I loved it. It took me to heights I’ve never been before. I felt the love that both men felt for her and the ultimate goal for them was making sure that she was happy. I loved this.
This was a very satisfying book. 10 stars on my list so far on my 2026 list of books.
June 27, 2026
I absolutely hated the name choices in this book. I know that may seem stupid to some but I can’t stand it. Fyve (Five) like why did you spell it that way? That irked me. Then a friend group and their husbands names Wynter, Nature, Peace, Storm, and Frost. Like why, just why? There was no real story line here for real. I love a good spicy book but this wasn’t it for me.
August 23, 2025
I love a good poly romance, and this was good. I didn't know the twist of them being in school together took me for a loop, but I was glad everything worked out. And the spicy scenes were super spicy!
January 16, 2026
Character dev: 👤👤👤
Originality: 📝📝📝📝
Narration: read on KU
Plot: 📖📖
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Action: 👊🏽
Troupe: poly romance, MFM
Triggers: n/a
A short and spicy read. If you’re looking for a poly romance where two men want the same girl and try to work it out. This is it.
Originality: 📝📝📝📝
Narration: read on KU
Plot: 📖📖
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Action: 👊🏽
Troupe: poly romance, MFM
Triggers: n/a
A short and spicy read. If you’re looking for a poly romance where two men want the same girl and try to work it out. This is it.
April 7, 2026
We messing with that same damn girl. Ah yeah
I wasn’t happy how everything started. The FMC was definitely wrong about how she went about things. Thankfully, both MMC able to overcome the betrayal due to fact that they both love her unconditionally just like she loved them.
I wasn’t happy how everything started. The FMC was definitely wrong about how she went about things. Thankfully, both MMC able to overcome the betrayal due to fact that they both love her unconditionally just like she loved them.
August 12, 2026
Mouth watering
The way my toes twisted. This had me considering a new life style, because baby if we all could be so lucky. Chile when being the same girl has you cumming out on top 😁
The way my toes twisted. This had me considering a new life style, because baby if we all could be so lucky. Chile when being the same girl has you cumming out on top 😁
August 26, 2025
I've enjoyed this book so much. Mya was a beautiful main character who deserved the world and much love and affection.
August 31, 2025
mannnn
Ohhh to have her life. Minus the divorce and the past trauma. I’m just saying. The level of maturity and security they had to have. This book was sensational!
Ohhh to have her life. Minus the divorce and the past trauma. I’m just saying. The level of maturity and security they had to have. This book was sensational!
August 31, 2025
🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
I loved it from beginning to end hot steamy spicy just how I like book baes❤️💞💋💌❣️🥵love how they loved each other and didn't hold back loved it
I loved it from beginning to end hot steamy spicy just how I like book baes❤️💞💋💌❣️🥵love how they loved each other and didn't hold back loved it
September 18, 2025
Whew
Thanks for the read. It was hot and different. Hmmm, maybe everyone has this freak in them. It takes the right person to bring it out.
Thanks for the read. It was hot and different. Hmmm, maybe everyone has this freak in them. It takes the right person to bring it out.
March 8, 2026
🤔
I guess she had the best of both worlds. Heck I can’t be mad! 🤷🏾♀️
I guess she had the best of both worlds. Heck I can’t be mad! 🤷🏾♀️
April 11, 2026
Made it to 41% and I'm just bored.
May 20, 2026
The story line was trash. Hs trauma as a whole grown woman is crazy. The spicy scenes was the saving grace. But Mya definitely needs to grow up
June 11, 2026
4.5 Stars
August 24, 2025
FMM yas she's in charge
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews