MCDP-1 (Marine Corps Doctrinal Publication) is a short but illustrative document that outlines the Marines' (the United States' "expeditionary force-in-readiness") philosophy on warfighting. It begins with a brief discussion on the nature of war – i.e., what it is and what it is not – before discussing the theory, practice, and conduct of war.
War, defined as "the violent struggle between two hostile, independent, and irreconcilable wills, each trying to impose itself on the other", is, unfortunately, an inescapable reality of human existence. It is, the Marines note soberly, one of "the greatest horrors known to humanity", and as such should "never be romanticized". But insofar as it is an inexorable part of social reality, there must be some entity which assumes the terrible burden of executing and honing a nation's capability for warfare, especially because it is as much a timeless fixture of human existence as it is ever changing.
To this end, the Marines' doctrine is based on maneuver warfare, which is itself characterized by the rapid, flexible, and opportunistic application of maneuvers and tactics to incapacitate an enemy's ability to fight back. Because the nature of war is inherently unpredictable and disorderly, and because the logistics of war are constantly evolving with new technology, MCDP argues that precise planning will always be far less effective than developing a general disposition and philosophy that is radically adaptable to changing circumstances.
The implications of this seemingly tautological claim are not obvious. Because war is highly situational, creating an abstract set of rules for engagement is self-defeating. Instead, MCDP opts to outline a broad set of virtues, character traits, and ends, rather than specific procedures, requirements, or means. Because "success" in warfare often resists quantitative measurement in favor of qualitative evaluation, these guidelines include:
- The recognition that successful warfare depends primarily on developing a superior position to your adversary in the "rhythm" or "tempo" of war. Thus, it is important to obtain...
- ... tactical advantages such as speed, focus, surprise, and boldness. These advantages come to those who possess...
- ... virtues such as: decisiveness, "fortitude, perseverance, boldness, esprit", creativity, and adaptability, among others, and necessitate an organizational structure which encourages members to engage in...
- ... open and frank dialogue, effective and concise communication, and additionally allows for...
- ... decentralized and autonomous decision-making, where individuals are empowered to make decisions to accomplish missions that harmonize with broader strategic goals.
It goes without saying that these principles are germane not only to warfighting, but to excellent organizations in a variety of other contexts, including those situations less macabre and adversarial than warfare.