Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Return to Magic #11

Like Mother, Like Monster

Rate this book
Thanksgiving is descending on Whisper Cove, which means turkey, stuffing, and the local children’s holiday pageant. What Rowan Gray-Davenport doesn’t expect is a missing child.
Lana Davenport has made a new friend. Sadie has paranormal abilities just like her. Before Rowan can wrap her head around that and arrange a playdate, however, Sadie disappears from her bed. Who took her? More importantly, why?
Rowan is determined to find answers. Every clue she unearths, however, only creates another question. It seems Sadie’s past isn’t as opaque as it should be for a seven-year-old. Her parents might not have adopted her legally, and the people she was born to are not the warm and fuzzy sort.
Sadie is out there and she’s communicating with Lana in her dreams. It’s up to Rowan and her magical friends to find the little girl … and keep Lana safe in the process.
The only problem is the missing little girl’s family might be more than Rowan can survive. It’s all hands on deck for another crazy monster fight. Just who will come out victorious?

243 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 6, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lily Harper Hart

866 books802 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
879 (79%)
4 stars
188 (16%)
3 stars
38 (3%)
2 stars
5 (<1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
Profile Image for TheFairyKitmother TheFairyKitmother.
1,186 reviews5 followers
January 26, 2026
Hello hello! Here’s another book thoughts review from my little desert town in Southern California. Ok, so honestly I haven’t finished reading this book yet, but the only way I can begin my review is to select the stars and since I already know this book is a 5 star one, I selected the 5.

I want to tell you that this book is really heavy. It’s one of Harper Hart’s more serious stories. A little girl has been kidnapped. The little girl, Sadie, is 7 and she is one of Lana’s friend’s from school. I find it really strange and telling that Lana was so adamant about staying the night at Sadie’s house on the same night Sadie was abducted. I’m 68% of the way through this book and nothing has been said about that yet. In fact, I don’t know if anything will be said. I just believe there’s a reason Lana so desperately wanted to stay the night at Sadie’s. Lana had never asked before, so why then? Did Lana subconsciously or magically know something wrong was about to happen?

This book is from Rowan’s point of view, so we don’t get to spend much time with Harper, Jared, Zander and fam, Shawn, etc. This primarily takes place around Rowan and her family, including her father Paul. It’s also a lot around Lana because not only is Sadie Lana’s friend and therefore it’s really affecting Lana’s emotions, but also Sadie went to Lana in her dream asking Lana to help her. So of course Lana has a lot of pressure on her shoulders to find Sadie. That’s an awful lot for a 7 year old.

There is also talk about drugs and how drugs can affect your life. Sadie’s mom and dad are addicts and some of the people Rowan and Quinn talk to for clues are also addicts. So, there’s that. Really, any time a child’s life is in danger it will automatically make a situation dire. So that’s what we’re dealing with in this book. Not much magic is being used, so if you wanted that, this is not the book for that, although the dream walking is magic so there are little nooks and crannies of magic happening.

So, anyway, I’ll get back to the reading now and I’ll update you either when I think of something else to add or when I’m done and we find out what happened to Sadie. Why do I have the feeling Sadie won’t be mentioned in future books in this series though? That always happens. We read one of the books and learn a lot about a particular person and get kind of attached to them, but then the next book… zilch. Where is that person now? Ok, bye for now…

I’m back. I finished the book. It was sad really. It ended sort of well. Well, it turned out well for Rowan and her crew, but for Sadie she’ll definitely need some medical care and a lot of therapy. The ending wasn’t huge as far as how the bad guy was taken down, but it was satisfying enough. It was really a tragic tale and I know Lana will be affected enough to have nightmares for a bit.

And for Rowan, she’ll be fine. Speaking of Rowan, I was thinking about her - for obvious reasons - throughout this book and then I got to thinking how I’ve read Harper and Zander’s book series and Ivy’s series, but I haven’t read Rowan’s or Maddie’s. There are 4 main witches that are friends in this Return to Magic series - Rowan, Harper, Ivy, and Maddie. But what you may not have known is that each individual witch has a series of her own. Rowan’s is 9 books. So, what I’m going to do after I’m done with this review is start Rowan’s books. Book 1 of 9 is Welcoming Seas (A Rowan Gray Mystery Book 1).

In this book it gives a little glimpse of Rowan’s background in magic and how she got to where she is. It seems interesting so I’m going to find out about her. I like to have a better understanding of the characters I read about. That way I get more details as I read these books. In these books - the Return to Magic - sometimes they’re from Ivy’s POV and sometimes they’re from Maddie’s or Harper’s. They all come together and seek each other’s help.

So, onto Rowan’s stories I go…

Stay kind. Stay humble.
1,234 reviews22 followers
January 22, 2026
Finally we have Rowan and Quinn front and centre.

A young girl in Lora's class has.become close.friend.so much so that Lora is skint her mum nd dad (Rowan and Quinn) if she can go over to her friends house for a sleepover. Luckily the parents say not yet using the need.to get to know the family as their reason for saying no. I say luckily as next morning their friend Jared Hunter turns up to make enquires as Sadie, Lora's friend was abducted out of her bedroom during the night. Bad enough the family have the "what might have happened" in their heads, they also have Sadie showing up in Lora's dreams begging her for help. Lot turns to her.mum and dad wanting them to magically fix things (as they usually do) and get Sadie back. Rowan and Quinn call on their friends for help in trying to track down Sadie and whoever it is that took her...........................
Profile Image for Tchipakkan.
565 reviews20 followers
June 29, 2026
I appreciate the mature series

While Hart is the mistress of the paranormal romance genre, and I thoroughly enjoyed the intertwined series, young women coming to terms with their inner power, and men coming to terms with that too can get repetitive. These stories show families dealing with the issues of trying to keep their kids safe, helping them not be hurt in a world not ready to accept magick, to try to help them not be hurt as they were hurt for simply being different in a world not ready for that.... It can be read as analogy for being gay, or even being psychic. I have no idea if Hart/ Lee has experience with pyschics and witches, or if she simply is writing speculative fiction. But the challenges work either way, and I find them more satisfying than the simple romance adventures. As Peter Pan said, living is a great adventure.
Profile Image for Linda Levine.
4,649 reviews25 followers
January 13, 2026
Great Series

I highly recommend this series.

I really enjoy the mixture of mystery and humor. The characters are very well developed and the relationships among them strengthens the storylines.

I really enjoy the mixture of mystery and humor. They’re are always laugh out loud moments.

The author used to write separate series for each group of characters but combined them into one series. She did a really good job of having their characters connect during their adventures.

I read all of this series by this author as well as those under the name Amanda Lee. I remember binge reading all of the book when I discovered the author quite a few years ago.

Profile Image for Perry Owler.
Author 4 books2 followers
January 15, 2026
There are no words that I haven't said before upon reading her works. I am always left wanting more, and yet I think this is the last in the series as I didn't get the typical "buy next book now" upon completing the book - but that's not really what you want to read for a review.

I love the suspense and twists and turns. I really thought it was 1 person then bam another came into play and thought it was the, and then surprised it to be someone that didn't come I to live play until the final battle.

If this is really the last hoorah for the series, it was definitely a great ending...
Profile Image for Kayan Sherrer.
146 reviews2 followers
January 13, 2026
Great Read

I am not one to spoil a book so all I'm going to say is if you like cozy mysteries, fun characters with personalities. I really think you're going to like this book. However this is book 11 in the series so start with book one. I really believe that you will fall in love with not only the characters, small town feel, and the storyline, but the paranormal aspect as well.
20 reviews3 followers
February 18, 2026
love love love

I love your stories so much! I laugh, I cry and laugh again. The characters are so awesome that I am a part of their word. I finish one book and can’t wait for the next. Thank you for writing such amazingly beautiful stories and characters that fill the world with love, hope and magic. Never stop being a true romantic at heart. We need more of this in the world!!
624 reviews2 followers
January 9, 2026
Great book

This book is one of the best in the series. Love the interactions between Rowan & Harper, Jared & Quinn, Rowan & her Dad. The story had great pacing and several twists. I stayed up to finish it which I didn’t expect but once I was about half way through I wanted to see how it would end.
376 reviews
January 10, 2026
Ouch

I couldn't think of a title for this review, I wanted it to be "why do people suck"? I guess drugs will make you do really bad things! I'm glad Sadie had Lana and het family looking for her. Lana gets a trip of a life time. Will we be going on this trip? On to the next adventure!💙💚😉
46 reviews1 follower
January 9, 2026
Maybe the best book in series so far!

I loved that Rowan got a chance to shine and expand her powers. I loved that the entire story could be REAL with exception of the magic in the kidnapped girl. The more realistic the story, the more the magic parts also become real.


Profile Image for Starla.
983 reviews
January 9, 2026
Fun Reading

I am obsessed with the characters in this series as they all had series of their own before this one. This book had a food cozy mystery about a topic that happens way more often in every community. I loved reading this and loved the end as well!
Profile Image for Jo Lynn Guillory.
66 reviews
January 11, 2026
Like Mother, Like Monster

Love all the characters. Missed the other characters in the book this time. Poe and Kai are so funny. Sander is too funny. Looking forward to the next book. Thank you for the entertainment.
397 reviews
January 17, 2026
Good book

The characters are engaging and interesting, they all continue to grow and develop. The plot lines came together well, with some suspense. I enjoy when multiple book characters are in the same story.
779 reviews2 followers
February 28, 2026
Really good story!!

I totally loved this story! How could I not? It was written by one of my favorite authors, Lily Harper Hart, and was filled with friendship and family, witches and magic, and good vs. bad. How could you not love a story like this?
Profile Image for Mari.
3,524 reviews2 followers
April 24, 2026
I enjoyed the story and I always like coming back to characters of my favourite series, but this isn’t my favourite series over all. The kid‘s angle is nice, but not on top of my list. Still a five stars for me, even if just for the nostalgia factor and an interesting story in a known universe.
3,642 reviews14 followers
January 7, 2026
Great read though it's different than many other stories in this series. The ending nicely sets up the next story...fingers crossed!
45 reviews
January 9, 2026
wow

Fast and furious story line. Excellent characters in ongoing saga always a delight. Such creative writing makes you see the story as it unfolds. Love this series, more please
2 reviews
January 19, 2026
I would have liked more on Sadie's ending

How the story ended with the girl's and if she kept her powers and had their dinner together for girls date
Profile Image for Nancy.
1,092 reviews12 followers
January 21, 2026
Bonding

Great read, love the characters and snarky wit a kidnapping bonds a mother and daughter and a fat and daughter while solving a mystery.
760 reviews3 followers
January 22, 2026
exciting

A good book in the series with plenty of magic, mystery, suspense, terror, drama, humor, violence, and romance. Eager for next book.
Profile Image for JANE VAN HORN.
2,152 reviews12 followers
February 7, 2026
Great book

This is a great series. I love when everyone works together to win the fight. And now Rowan can dreamwalk too.
Profile Image for Diane Gates.
405 reviews1 follower
February 12, 2026
Great read

I love this series. Rowan and crew are amazing when they work together. Lily Harper Hart is a wonderful writer and storyteller. All her books are amazing.
1,034 reviews3 followers
February 23, 2026
A Return to Magic #11

The author has done it again! What a great story in the series, the characters are dynamic and the storytelling is just so attention grabbing.
312 reviews1 follower
November 12, 2026
Too

Long-winded, I got bored a third of the way through. Normally like these books but this one had too much extra unrequired reading in it.
3 reviews
January 11, 2026
Another exciting ride

LHH is one of my favorite authors and this newest book does not disappoint. Although the name of the book doesn’t quite fit to me lol. But don’t judge a book by its cover lol.
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews