Lovecraft’s Dreamlands with a Difference
Barbara Cottrell has given us three books in her Shadows of Arkham Series. This review is focused on the third, Shadow Zone, but I recommend reading the three in chronological order for the best experience.
Cottrell describes her books as “Character Driven Lovecraft”, and this is an excellent description of Shadow Zone. All the elements of Lovecraft’s Dreamlands are present, but Lovecraft’s protagonists, including Randolph Carter, are only cardboard figures. Cottrell brings them to life through vivid dialogue and emotional stakes that Lovecraft himself never explored;
Thus Shadow Zone shows Randolph Carter, his son Robert and Grandson Andrew as real people, tied together in love and conflict. Their complicated relationship with Ellen Logan, a young student at Miskatonic University, is at the heart of the story, driving the plot and giving it the warmth, character depth and human drama so lacking in Lovecraft’s original vision of the Dreamlands. This is a worthy addition to the Lovecraft canon, a respectful but fresh take on the Mythos.