Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Hard Luck Jenny

Rate this book
“You should pay your respects to Jenny.”

On a quiet road in the Scottish Highlands, Dennis Norris stops to use the bathroom in a quaint country inn. It’s been a long weekend, and all he wants is to use the facilities before continuing the five-hour drive home to his loving wife. But something seems off in The Rockarn Inn. The people there won’t let him leave.

Why is everyone so hostile towards him? What strange ritual has Dennis accidentally stumbled into? And just who is the mysterious Hard Luck Jenny everyone keeps talking about?

Soon, Dennis will find out. And the grim events of that long, desperate night will change his life… forever.

From David Sodergren, author of The Haar and Maggie’s Grave, comes a darkly comic anxiety-drenched folk-horror nightmare.

Hard Luck Jenny.

Love her. Worship her.

Die for her.

124 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 3, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

David Sodergren

26 books4,306 followers
David Sodergren lives in Scotland with his wife Heather.

Growing up, he was the kind of kid who collected rubber skeletons and lived for horror movies. Not much has changed since then.

His best known books include the gory and romantic fairy tale The Haar, the blood-drenched folk-horror Maggie’s Grave, and the analog-horror fever dream Rotten Tommy. David also writes under the pseudonym Carl John Lee, publishing splatterpunk
novels such as Psychic Teenage Bloodbath and Cannibal Vengeance.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
479 (22%)
4 stars
936 (44%)
3 stars
526 (24%)
2 stars
139 (6%)
1 star
43 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 394 reviews
Profile Image for Youssra {very busy-review slumping}.
971 reviews529 followers
August 30, 2025
omg this book gave me the best kind of anxiety!!!! This was insane and had some seriously funny moments too😅 That ending broke my heart though💔 poor Dennis 💔

David never misses and I hope he never does💖 My fav horror author for a reason 🙌
Profile Image for David Sodergren.
Author 26 books4,306 followers
Read
August 28, 2025
My new novella Hard Luck Jenny is out October 3rd 2025! It's pure awkward anxiety wrapped up in a darkly comic folk-horror cocoon. I hope you enjoy it.
Profile Image for JJtheBookNerd.
253 reviews356 followers
March 31, 2026
Once a month Dennis Norris makes the six-hour drive to spend the weekend with his elderly mother. On his way home on one of those weekends, a fallen tree in the road forces him to make a diversion. Having a weak bladder and desperate to use the bathroom, he comes across a small isolated village; the only place with any sign of life is the pub—The Rockarn Inn.

Shortly after entering to use the facilities, Dennis notices he has stumbled into the wake of a man named Colin; the pub is packed with people claiming to know Colin. Also present is the oddly attired widow Jenny, who Dennis learns from mourners is known as Hard Luck Jenny due to her recent bout of bad luck. It isn't long before he realises everyone seems a bit... weird. Not only that, but they won't let him leave.

This was pretty funny; I found myself chuckling quite a lot in the first half. It was a little bit silly and didn't take itself too seriously. Poor Dennis just wanted to go home; at the beginning he does the very British thing of trying to be really polite about it all and then tries a different tactic of playing along for a while. You can feel his patience, anxiety and fear building up to snapping point.

Maybe we could have been given some background regarding why Jenny and the villagers were like they were, which was all shrouded in mystery. That said, sometimes things are more ominous and eerie being left unknown—in this regard, it worked quite well in its novella form; any longer, probably not so much. It was short, punchy and had a little hint of foreshadowing together with a good dose of gory horror. The ending was utterly bleak, which my horror-addled brain liked. A decent enough quick read with snippets of dark humour woven throughout.

Rating it 3.5/5.
Profile Image for Haly Hoards Books.
372 reviews62 followers
July 21, 2026
4☆
David Sondergren has become an author who I really like reading. This novella was great!

The way Sondergren eases us into the overall creepy in this story is like slowly starting a descent down a steep hill on rollerskates! The thrill starts slowly until you are careening down the slope at speeds too fast to stop without severely injuring yourself!

The ending made me think about a more depraved Harvest Home. It was so so cringe worthy, and I loved it!
Profile Image for Brandon Baker.
Author 2 books11.8k followers
January 27, 2026
A quick, entertaining read with a dark as hell ending! It kind of reminded me of the movie Dead End in a way.
Profile Image for The Pastel Bookshelf.
390 reviews1,486 followers
July 20, 2026
Another one added to the “most unhinged books I’ve ever read” list 😳
Profile Image for Peter Topside.
Author 7 books1,565 followers
October 7, 2025
Ooh, this was a skeevy affair. Our lead, Dennis, has some awfully shit luck. Like some of the worst I’ve seen. Just wanted to get home to his wife. And, by God, he was pulled into all sorts of horrific shenanigans. Our antagonist, Hard Luck Jenny, is nuttier than squirrel shit, too. The whole situation went from bad to worse, leaving the reader wondering what the bloody hell was going on. Plenty of intrigue, with some purposeful loose ends left open, but enough tightened up to bring this story full-circle. David Sodergren is one of my favorite authors. And the way he develops his stories, each unique in its own way, perfectly balancing the horror elements, character development, and each plot point is a sight to behold. Not an easy feat, but he always manages to do it. This is yet another strong showing from the author.
Profile Image for Jan Agaton.
1,615 reviews1,737 followers
May 20, 2026
that ending is cruuuueellllll. oh Dennis, you should've just peed in a water bottle
Profile Image for Angyl.
721 reviews74 followers
July 16, 2026
nahhh this was crazy LMAO one of those stories where you scream 'what the fuck' in disgust a million times

I do wish there was more to it and we got a better understanding of the village and the people that live there and more lore on Jenny! I was expecting more folk horror from this tbh

anyway don't read this if you can't handle gore
Profile Image for Steph.
1,089 reviews517 followers
May 25, 2026
an anxious horror novella about a man who passes through the scottish countryside, stops at the wrong pub at the wrong time, and finds himself unable to leave.

there's a nightmarish feeling to much of the book - that sensation of needing to move, to leave, to get somewhere, but facing obstacle after inexplicable obstacle.

if this book were about a female protagonist, it would hit very differently. i love the way sodergren subverts tropes of women in peril, here putting a man in distress with only his wife to come to his rescue.



this is my third from him, and i'm becoming a fan of sodergren's work. i love the rural scotland setting, the gnarly gore, and the way he inserts moments of irreverent humor into an otherwise dark and dread-inducing story.
Profile Image for Leslye❇.
382 reviews130 followers
October 14, 2026
3.75* ... Look, Dennis just needed to pee. That's it. But he makes the BIG mistake of pulling over to a sketchy-ass pub in the Scottish Highlands and walks right into a bizarre funeral rite gathering there. Suddenly, the hostile, cult-vibe villagers won't let him leave.

That's the setup here, and honestly, it was kind of a blast if you like your horror stories fast, mean and deeply unhinged. The chaos seemed to go from zero to a hundred immediately. The author packs the whole thing with brutal gore and a weirdly funny, dark humor and it kept me turning the pages. ... The downside? It's super short, so you get absolutely zero explanation about what the hell is actually going on with the village or who "Jenny" even is. Also, Dennis makes some incredibly stupid horror-movie decisions that make you literally want to scream into the pages at him.🙄 But if you want a quick, nasty little folk-horror ride for spooky season, this one delivers for the most part.

The takeaway here is simple: Guys, if you're on a road trip and nature calls, just pull over and find a bush. It just might save your soul.🫣
Profile Image for Sjgomzi.
419 reviews172 followers
October 14, 2025
This gets five stars for making me feel dirty and disgusted , and for the great slam bang writing that Sodergren always delivers in his work. Turning that last page, mouth agape, I kept thinking to myself- what the fuck did I just read, and why, oh why, did I enjoy it so much! All kidding aside, David Sodergren is always a must buy, and he remains the only horror author who has ever received 5 stars from me for every book I’ve read by him. This is a sick, nasty tale that made me laugh out loud more than once, and I’m really not sure what that says about me. Lessons learned from this story- don’t go into strange countryside pubs to take a piss; take the wife’s advice and use the woods. And secondly, people are fucking crazy!
Profile Image for Jada Reads Horror.
109 reviews6 followers
April 13, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Well, this is why my boyfriend and I have each other’s locations shared.
Profile Image for Kev Ruiz.
220 reviews11 followers
November 12, 2025
★★★
A strange and anxious story that captures discomfort better than most. From the opening scene there is a steady sense of unease, helped by the claustrophobic setting of a remote Highland inn and the unsettling behaviour of the people inside it. Sodergren is good at writing that creeping awkwardness where every conversation feels slightly wrong, and there are flashes of dark humour that make the tension worse in the best way.

It does lose its footing in the second half. The ritual and the town’s behaviour never feel properly explained, and the ending comes without much weight. Still, it moves quickly and has some sharp moments of panic and absurdity that stay with you. Not one of his best, but still recognisably his.
Profile Image for ♡ retrovvitches ♡.
1,015 reviews70 followers
January 2, 2026
what a nasty book, i really enjoyed it!! it was genuinely disgusting and actually made me a little stomach sick by the end there. like what a sequence of events 😭
Profile Image for Niki.
1,072 reviews175 followers
March 22, 2026
Not what I expected, and sadly what I got was really underwhelming. It's like , but duller, and the author himself mentions the former in the afterword.

It's a very frustrating read, and though a lot of it is very much on purpose to mirror the protagonist being royally fucked over, some of it just comes out of nowhere (no idea what any of the Nigel scenes were, he never amounted to anything. There was also another guy that I thought was Nigel, but nope, it's two different "bully" aggressive characters) The writing is very vague and confusing, and most of it just feels amateurish instead of deliberate.

Things just keep escalating but I couldn't bring myself to care about any of it, because I didn't really care about the main character. His only character traits are needing to pee a lot and being a people pleaser who's afraid to ever be assertive. I didn't feel anything for him. Of course there's pity, as is for every character that ends up in a horrible fate, but that's about it. We didn't really know him.

The ending was pretty good, However, I really disliked one aspect of it, and that was

Go read David Sodergren's Night Shoot, The Forgotten Island, Rotten Tommy. Not this.
Profile Image for Horror Sickness .
944 reviews386 followers
May 13, 2026
4,5*

Between this novella and Rest Stop by Nat Cassidy, there is no more pleasure to be found on road trips for me, just fear.

Dennis is on his way home and he also has a very small bladder that makes him pee way too often. He can also not pee just anywhere and is desperate to find a place to pee before his bladder explodes.

He thinks himself lucky when he finds a quaint country inn and decides to quickly go in to use their facilities. Just a quick pit stop and back on the road…. or so he thought.

Once he entered the inn, he noticed a really weird atmosphere and the place was full of people that look at him, talk to him and will not let him leave.

If this was your first David Sodergren book I am so sorry for all the nightmares you are about to have. This novella was straight up anxiety inducing, gory and disturbing in the best possible way.

This is peak folk horror. Think Midsommar. It was supposed to be a full length novel and I can see why the author decided to keep it a novella. The intensity and the reveals would have lost too much fuel if this story kept going.

The only thing I missed was knowing more about Jenny and get into her mind a little bit more.
Profile Image for Shannon.
279 reviews4 followers
October 8, 2025
This is a an odd and grisly little gem. Loved it!
Profile Image for Holly Eustace.
256 reviews11 followers
September 26, 2026
O…M…mothereffinG!

Dennis just haaaad to stop somewhere to pee. Why couldn’t he piss outside like a real man is beyond me! This shorty of a book is well worth your time.

"Ignoring the pain in his exposed, bloody soles, Dennis ran alongside the cottage, his cock bouncing with each frenzied step."
That line alone should let you know how wheels off this books is.
Profile Image for Matty.
286 reviews37 followers
January 1, 2026
This was my first book of the new year and it did not disappoint. Short, gory, and funny story about a man with some really bad luck after an encounter with “Hard Luck Jenny”after stopping at a bar for a quick pee. Fantastic Sodergren short story, well worth the read!
Profile Image for Kevin.
Author 214 books354 followers
December 28, 2025
Another winner from Sodergren. Really tense up until the point it goes mental. Loved it! Much shorter than his usual books but I do love a novella.
Profile Image for Alex | | findingmontauk1.
1,673 reviews90 followers
January 14, 2026
Quick, quirky, and gritty! Oh this makes me never want to pull over for a bathroom break ever again... that ENDING though... yikes! Love some folk horror with these comedic elements interspersed throughout as well.
Profile Image for Kate Victoria RescueandReading.
2,258 reviews134 followers
August 18, 2026
Oh man, this short story was an absolute nightmare. I can’t even, I feel sick thinking about being trapped in that community. I never thought I’d feel claustrophobic about a town, but this story proved me wrong. So, so good! Eff you Jenny!!!
Profile Image for Adrienne L.
451 reviews173 followers
May 13, 2026
This is my 7th David Sodergren book, and at this point, I pretty much know what I'm in for when I start one: a competently-written, gory, Scottish village set (usually), batshit crazy and guffaw-inspiring romp. Hard Luck Jenny started out as all of those things, and I enjoyed the beginning with the increasingly uncomfortably awkward situation the MC finds himself in when he stops to use the facilities at a sketchy pub on his way home to Edinburgh. Awkward and sketchy are really too tame as descriptors in this case, but sometimes with Sodergren, there really are no words. The situation quickly escalates into absolute insanity and bloody depravity, and, to be entirely honest, the closing pages were a step (leap) too far for me.

In the author's note at the end, Sodegren writes that he initially conceived Hard Luck Jenny as a longer work than the 100-odd page novella it turned into, and I think with more story and character development, that would have worked better for my personal enjoyment. Still, I got what I came for. And then some.
Profile Image for Ryan.
27 reviews4 followers
September 4, 2025
First, I want to thank David for an advance copy!

What can I say? Another 5 star book from Sodergren. This is just seeping with anxiety and dread and touched on so many of my own anxieties (and maybe made them even worse!)

Seriously a great and quick read that anyone that has ever experienced anxiety before should read!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 394 reviews