How a Quartet of American Musicians Outwitted the KGB – The Untold History of a Daring Cold War Spy Mission
In 1985, while the United States engaged in a battle of nuclear brinkmanship, four Americans landed in Moscow on a mission to smuggle secret information in and out using music as their cipher. Under the watchful eye of the KGB, the group faced countless challenges and risks—because they weren’t trained in espionage. In fact, they were musicians with the New England-based Yiddish-music focused Klezmer Conservatory Band (KCB).
Now, the quartet’s saxophonist, Merryl Goldberg, together with Vince Houghton, the Director of the National Security Agency’s National Cryptologic Museum, tell the harrowing story of how Goldberg devised an ingenious plan to encode the intelligence within the group’s sheet music.
FEATURED People.com The Mark Thompson ShowNow I’ve Heard EverythingA Way with WordsIncludes 16 pages of archival photos
Thank you to Hanover Square Press and Harlequin Audio for the opportunity to read and listen to Notes of Deception: How a Quartet of American Musicians Outwitted the KGB – The Untold Russian History of a Daring Cold War Mission. That’s a long title! I was fascinated by this story of four musicians who went to the then-USSR to meet with refuseniks in 1985 and how they got away with their activities.
Merryl Goldberg tells the story of how she and her three colleagues, band members of the Klezmer Conservatory Band, went to the USSR in 1985. They brought their musical instruments (electric keyboard, saxophones, etc.), sheet music which Merryl had encoded to record important information without it being seized by the KGB or other agents of the USSR government, clothing, medicines, and other items thought needed by some of the people they were hoping to meet up with.
I’m of a certain age and definitely knew about the Jewish (and non-Jewish) refuseniks being kept in the USSR against their will in the waning days of the Cold War (of course no one knew they were the waning days at the time!). But for others, this may be completely new information. I was fascinated to read about their varied experiences in Moscow, Tbilisi (now part of Georgia), and Yerevan (Armenia). Each place was very different in atmosphere for the musicians and the people they were there to meet up with. I longed to hear the music they played with the Phantom Orchestra in an apartment in Tbilisi!
After some introductory information to make sure the reader understands what was going on and what they were facing, the book reads almost like a novel! But it’s all true. And the last part of the book is a kind of “where are they now” chapter, which held a couple of surprises for me. One I won’t give away, because the author treated it as a surprise and I’ll keep it that way. The other one was my realization that I knew one of the four musicians a little bit. He had been the cantor at my New Jersey synagogue for a while not all that long ago! The name had sounded familiar but I didn’t connect it until I read that last chapter.
Each chapter is named after a musical term, a cute idea. I did a mix of the ebook and the audiobook. I was hoping for a few photos but I didn’t see them in the advance copy I had. Perhaps there are some in the published version.
Notes of Deception takes an inside look at Jewish people in the Soviet Union and the United States and how connected they were at a time of deep turmoil. It follow the KCB (Klezmer Conservatory Band) while under the watch of the KGB. It was an exciting peak behind the Iron Curtain and the highlights the power of music in many ways.
The book starts off with some context and history about Jewish people in the Soviet Union and Jewish customs and traditions. The first half of the book is pretty content dense but interesting. Once the musicians head to the USSR, the excitement turns up in the book. It follows their wild customs adventures, their translator Kevin, and the oddities of being a US tourist in the Soviet Union at the peak of the Cold War. The final chapter updates you on where everyone is now, almost 40 years later.
I enjoyed the content of the book a lot, and I feel like I learned a lot about a history that is often skipped. I wish I could say the same for the narrator. I was not the biggest fan of this narrator, and it should be noted that she uses accents and voices for different characters. Some people may like that, but I felt as though I was pulled out of the seriousness of some moments when she starts doing a Russian accent. It is not enough for me to not recommend, but I think listeners should be aware.
Overall, I give this 4 stars, and it is very engaging for anyone who loves history. Thank you Net Galley and the publisher for the Advanced Listener Copy.
It's such a thrilling and important book that reads like a novel. I thought the very end was so chilling because at any point the Soviet Jews could have been stopped from emigrating. Goldberg shows through her trip across the Soviet Union in 1985 how awful it was for Jews in the USSR. And the lengths that the KGB and other parts of the Soviet government went to torment their Jewish population was absolutely pathological. I recommend this book for anyone who enjoys spy thrillers (even though this one is true and not fiction like most thrillers) or Jewish history. I listened to the audio, which was done very well!
The KGB could search their luggage, interrogate them, and shadow their movements. What it failed to read was the music. In “Notes of Deception,” Merryl Goldberg and Vince Houghton turn an audacious 1985 journey into a Cold War adventure whose most effective weapon is neither a pistol nor a diplomatic passport, but a page of apparently innocent musical notation. Goldberg and three fellow members of Boston’s Klezmer Conservatory Band entered the Soviet Union to contact refuseniks: people denied permission to emigrate, often punished simply for applying. Their mission required carrying names, addresses, and testimony across borders. Their solution was ingenious: conceal information within written music, making the very material that established their identities as performers double as clandestine correspondence. The premise has the irresistible appeal of a spy thriller, but its emotional center lies elsewhere. These were not intelligence professionals playing an elaborate geopolitical game. They were musicians trying to puncture the isolation of people whom an authoritarian state had rendered vulnerable and nearly invisible. Music served simultaneously as camouflage, communication, and an affirmation of shared identity. The encounters with Tbilisi’s Phantom Orchestra give that idea its fullest expression. Here, performance becomes something more consequential than entertainment: a meeting between people separated by borders but joined by cultural memory. Against the machinery of surveillance, the simple act of making music together acquires extraordinary moral force. Goldberg’s conversational, sometimes comic storytelling provides an effective counterpoint to the menace. Bureaucratic absurdity and amateur improvisation keep the adventure buoyant. Yet the lightness carries a tension: the Americans could eventually leave; their Soviet hosts remained exposed. Some subsequently endured imprisonment. That imbalance prevents the escapade from becoming merely a satisfying story about clever visitors embarrassing the secret police. Readers seeking an exhaustive geopolitical history should expect something more intimate: a participant’s account of solidarity under surveillance, rather than a comprehensive anatomy of Soviet repression. Its power comes from that human scale. Ultimately, this is a book about solidarity made practical: carrying information, showing up, listening, and refusing to let strangers disappear. The concealed notes supply the suspense; the people behind them supply the reason to care.
I got the audiobook from NetGalley. Before reading this book, I knew nothing of the Jews persecution in Russia or that students were sent over during the Cold War to try and help. I don’t remember learning about this at all it was eye opening. The book takes you through the history of the Jews persecution in Russia, which started well before World War II. I appreciate the history lesson since it highlights the plight and suffering of those that the students met with in the 1980s. The author also talks about the activism by other countries trying to help the Jews due to human rights violations. Once Merryl, the author, starts the talking about their preparation and trip to Russia the pace really picks up. You can tell how much Jewish music means to the Russian Jews and to the 4 students that traveled over. I loved hearing about how they bonded, shared meals, sang, talked and just existed with those that they were there to help. At the end of the book, she does explain what happened to some of the people that they met along their travels and I needed that closure. Like another Reviewer said, I know that it is only a matter of time until it is adapted for either film or tv. I think a miniseries would be best; there was quite a bit that happened in the 10 days that they were in Russia.
Fascinating read. Living through the cold war and its end, you knew bits and pieces f this cold war but this is a real inside story of being in Russia when communism ruled and the KGB followed everything you did. It's hard to believe they were able to get the information out of Russia regarding Jews who were trapped their and sometimes tortured and imprisoned for wanting to leave. Lesson here for people who forgot or ignore history.
Audiobook. 3.5. Interesting story and I learned a lot about Russia in the 1980’s and their terrible human rights violations against those wanting to emigrate. Such a clever way to cipher information in the music to tell the Russian Jews’ story to the west. Lots of bravery. But there was a little too much detail that bogged down the story- like what each person was wearing, what was eaten at each meal, etc.
What I liked: The author’s description of the covert mission to 1980’s USSR as a quartet of musicians was fascinating. They were very brave dealing with KGB surveillance while also rendezvousing with Refuseniks.
What I disliked: The beginning portion, covering the historical saga of persecution of Russian Jews, was very dry. The rest of the book was excellent.
A really interesting book about four young Americans who visited the USSR in 1985 to visit and support Jewish and a family of Catholic refuseniks. They brought instruments with them and used musical notes as a cipher to keep their notes from possible destruction by the KGB.
Listened to the audiobook. Narration was good. At times I struggled to stay focused and interested in this book. There was a lot of history to get through.
A timely and engaging read! Easy to follow in conversational tone, but not too casual, telling a truly compelling story of the courage of these musicians resisting authoritarianism.
The US and Russia engaged for years in intense surveillance of each other for everything from nuclear brinksmanship to training cats to record conversations, including watching their own citizens. This is the story of four young Americans whofound a way to smuggle information into and out of Russia right under the noses of the KGB and the US intelligence community. They carried lists of Russian citizens who were willing and in a position to gather information. They were even able to train U.S. intelligence agents. The way they managed was to embed information into their musical scores.
I was intrigued with this event and with the young woman, Merryl Goldberg, who developed the code and used it to help their Russian friends. The Americans were both expert musicians and teachers. They held classes for the young Russians while also touring and performing. This was well written, researched and informative. I am a reader of nonfiction and narrative nonfiction. I enjoyed this one and recommend to readers of nonfiction, Jewish history, history, Cold War politics, and young people who exhibit courage under pressure.