Jessica Taylor is a perfectionist, making steady strides to reach the top. With a tendency to burn the candle at both ends, she doesn’t have much time for a social life. When her boss challenges her to organize a charity event outside her normal responsibilities, she’ll have to make room in her busy schedule. Success at the event will enhance the PR firm's reputation and significantly improve her position within the company. But when sparks fly at the first planning meeting, making room for community and companionship may be just the right thing to change her life forever.
Perfectly Unscripted is a short romance novella with plenty of Hallmark vibes. With a cozy cast of characters and a predictably charming happily ever after, this book made for a quick holiday read. The story features a message of hope, organizing priorities, and the importance of finding the right perspective in life. The romance is sweet and simple, perfect for readers who prefer no spice. The narrative also features a faith element as Jessica works alongside the community outreach coordinator and local pastor to organize a spectacular fundraiser for the expansion of the homeless shelter.
While the story has enormous potential, this version reads like a polished outline. The third-person narrative remains engaging, but the details, backstory, and emotions are lacking throughout the novella. The framework exists, but many of the important details seem to be tacked on as afterthoughts in parenthetical add-ons when the need arises. For example, the author doesn’t go into much detail about either of Jessica’s parents, but there is a sense that she is not close to her father. This becomes especially clear when Jessica falls ill, and all the reader is told is “Her father, though he loved her, was far away and not really aware she was ill (she hadn’t told him).” Not only is this vague, but it feels a bit cold and distant in a book that would benefit from the emotional details surrounding the main character’s relationship with her dad.
The ending of the book started to fall apart as topics that hadn’t been fully addressed throughout the story were suddenly fixed in a single line. Or important events were shared in a couple of lines as an afterthought. For example, even the expected proposal was shared in an awkward, “Oh yes, that had happened a month ago.” It’s described as “wonderfully romantic,” and friends took photos, but it was a major let-down to be told what happened instead of getting to see the characters live out that moment.
Unfortunately, the faith element also left something to be desired. The quick transition from unbeliever to believer with a perfect “messy” life ended up feeling a bit shallow and cliché because it happened so rapidly and with little to no actual change in the character. In the final chapter, minor characters with little to no connection to the story, due to a lack of details shared about them earlier, were suddenly going to church and finding faith, too. It all felt a little too easy with no real struggles to make the story matter to the reader. Still, with additional development to the plot, this novella could shape up to be a solid inspirational story. For now, readers may just want to skip over to the Hallmark channel to catch a more perfectly scripted movie.
I received a copy of the book from Reedsy Discovery.