For me, this is just somewhere between a 3 and a 4. I enjoyed it but maybe not enough to recommend it to everybody, because the drawbacks were significant. Maybe if there was a second edition with some tighter editing.
That said, I do think I’d personally read more from this author.
To explain how I got to this rating, I’ll offer ratings for the various measures of this book:
Pacing/ action: 5
Character development: 4
Scenery/ descriptions: 5
Dialogue/ character interaction: 2
Themes: 3 (meh, because it was really just dark fantasy romance. I was expecting horror, but there was nothing scary here, and the romance themes kinda made me roll my eyes).
Formatting: 1
Plot:4
Lore/ world building: 4
Plot holes: 2 (all relating to character motivations)
Most of these ratings are pretty self explanatory, but I’d like to elaborate on the low ratings.
Dialogue and character interactions: sometimes the interactions between the two main characters read like a cheesy romance. The sex scenes seemed gratuitous and their flirty banter just came across as annoying. To me, their dynamic felt superficial at best and for me this broke immersion. Additionally, sometimes the dialogue from the antagonists felt a little over the top and cliche.
I think if this were read as an audio book the dialogue in many cases might feel unnatural.
Formatting: really, this may be a problem with the printing rather than the writing. Scenes would shift between several different character perspectives, but there’d be no line breaks nor asterisk breaks nor any other indication that the perspective had shifted. If this was a deliberate style choice, it really didn’t work for me. I found the sudden, undeclared shifts jarring and disruptive and difficult to follow. Also, though the writing was good enough not to really grudge this, i don’t really think seeing full fight scenes rehashed from 3 different characters’ eyes actually added much to the flow of the story. I think some careful editing could have trimmed some of the redundancy.
Plot holes: character motivations made no sense.
Spoilers below!
Why the hell did the Hunter take his lover to hunt a mammoth alone in territory that would be especially hostile to her in every single way?? It’s obvious that pretty much every resident of this north county hates people of her background, to the point of religiously: politically sanctioned violence. It’s also a region which is tough to survive even for people raised there. So why bring a newbie into such a dangerous scenario, and then why try to solo a mammoth when that’s stated to be a high risk hunt?
What was his end game for the hunt? What the hell was he thinking? Either he dies or sustains a in killing the mammoth and elebratLt i really all for sport? Even with a pack horse he’s not salvaging much meat or valuables from the carcass. Then he has to lug them and guide her back to safer territory, where they could be accosted at any time by (the elements, evil spirits, roving cannibal tribes, or the sanctioned guards). seems high investment and low returns, even in the best case scenario.
So, mainly, why? Why even go on the hunt?