While reading this book, my most common thought was, "This would make a fabulous video game." Throw together a post-apocalyptic world set in a never-ending city, and you've got an adventure that feels like a mish-mash of Fallout, Kingdom Hearts, and Borderlands.
The action is non-stop in this book, and it's a lot of fun. At first, I was excited that my 11-yr old would be able to read this one. Based on the pacing and the voice, this would make a great middle-grades story. What tween wouldn't love a story about talking cats, chatty ghosts, crazy werewolves, sentient skeletons, and the scrappy orphan boy who has to try to survive on his own?
However, the scrappy orphan is an 18-yr old with ambiguous morals, and there are a lot of bloody deaths and an insinuated rape in this one. My boy will have to wait a few years. The addition of some of the heavier stuff means this falls firmly in young adult territory.
I was very satisfied with the ending of this one. Goldman puts a lot of pieces in play over the course of this story, and he keeps them all moving. I loved seeing how earlier elements were brought back for later fights. And there's just enough of a hint about the Fifth House and future story developments that I'm excited about reading the sequel.
There isn't a lot of heart or depth here, and I struggled to like the main character Allin. However, the action and adventure is imaginative and fun. I could visualize the locations and characters, adding to that feeling of playing a good video game. If you're looking for a great plot-based summer read, try this one.