Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement

Rate this book
Thinking about early retirement? Learn saving and drawdown strategies to guide you to and through early retirement with confidence.

Cody Garrett, CFP®, and Sean Mullaney, CPA, cut through the jargon to share strategies and tactics to reduce total lifetime taxes and accelerate the path to early retirement.

Too often, we "Taxes will crush your retirement!" Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement tackles those concerns head-on. The book explains how to build retirement savings and lower taxes during the working years, then explores drawdown approaches designed to help minimize taxes throughout retirement.

You'll learn how
- Navigate IRAs, 401(k)s, and other key retirement accounts
- Apply the "Compelling Three" tactics to build retirement savings during your working years
- Implement drawdown tactics for all phases of retirement, including Roth conversions and qualified charitable distributions
- Avoid or minimize the 10% early withdrawal penalty before age 591/2
- Adjust for the new 2025 tax laws for retirees from the One Big Beautiful Bill
- Plan for uncertainty around future tax law changes
- Handle RMDs and the dreaded Widow's Tax Trap

Inside, you'll
- 100+ realistic examples with detailed walkthroughs of both accumulation and drawdown tactics
- Clear explanations of early retirement distribution rules and advanced tax strategies
- Cody's Takes and Sean's Takes - two perspectives to sharpen your own judgment

Whether you're a do-it-yourself investor or a financial professional, this book equips you with the clarity and confidence to make informed tax planning decisions-without fear.

358 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 23, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Cody Garrett

1 book5 followers
Cody Garrett is an advice-only financial planner, educator, and founder of Measure Twice® Money, where he helps DIY investors make informed financial decisions aligned with their values. He also leads Measure Twice® Planners, an educational community for financial planners. Cody's insights have been featured by The Wall Street Journal, Barron's, Forbes, and CNBC. He's a frequent guest on personal finance podcasts, including ChooseFI, The Long View (Morningstar), and Bogleheads on Investing.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
199 (66%)
4 stars
78 (26%)
3 stars
20 (6%)
2 stars
2 (<1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
Profile Image for Scott.
246 reviews
September 28, 2025
This is a great book for anyone (USA) who is seriously interested in planning their financial future, regardless of what stage of life you are at. From beginning your career to mid-career to late career to entering early retirement, you will find straightforward explanations and sound advice to apply to your own circumstances. The authors do an excellent job of simplifying tax planning as much as humanly possible and the numerous practical examples (with numbers) help to illustrate the concepts and outcomes. I have not seen a better book at laying out the broad concepts and then diving into the specific tax rules before wrapping up with practical examples showing the math that demonstrates the consequences of different treatments/choices. I highly recommend this book for all those who are serious about financial planning for their retirement as an American or tax resident of the USA.

Full disclosure: I am a CPA with almost 30 years in finance and accounting, so I am starting from a heavy finance/accounting perspective. That said, I really think the authors have laid it out as clearly as possible in a way that will allow a serious-but-determined novice to get their head around the vocabulary, tax regulations, and scenarios applicable to their own life. It will not be easy going, but the payoff will be huge regardless of whether you are leveraging the book to better understand what your tax accountant is telling you OR if you are managing your own finances and trying to prepare your household for eventual retirement. You can do this, but if you're just starting out, be patient with yourself and give your brain time to master the terms/concepts and use the practical examples to reinforce the tax treatment approaches.
7 reviews
Read
August 28, 2026
Standard retirement planning advice holds that, when contemplating whether to make traditional or Roth contributions, a rational taxpayer ought to consider when his income is subject to a lower marginal tax rate—during his working life or during retirement. If the former, make a traditional contribution, receive a tax break now, and defer the tax to retirement; if the latter, make a Roth contribution, take the tax hit now, but enjoy tax-free distribution later.

Garrett and Mullaney agree with this general framework, and they explain why, for most taxpayers, traditional contributions are advisable. Their arguments below:

First, traditional contributions are deducted at the top marginal rate, while distributions are favorably taxed—first being absorbed by the standard deduction, then the senior deduction, then taxed progressively at 10%, 12%, 22%, etc. Notice that while traditional distributions are taxable, they are not always taxed, in whole or in part, because of the standard and senior deductions. The authors call this a “hidden Roth IRA”.

Second, retirees generally have less income during retirement than during their working life, meaning their income is subject to lower tax rates, and the character of the income they do have matters: income from SSI, dividends, and LTCGs is taxed more favorably than W2 income. And retirees receive an expanded standard deduction and an additional senior deduction (under OBBBA).

Third, to the argument that tax rates are historically low and must rise to converge with fiscal realities, Garrett and Mullaney reply: the more salient question is whether rates will rise, specifically, on retirees. As the voting population is disproportionately elderly, they maintain that such a risk is overstated. And their models show that, even under material tax hike scenarios, traditional contributions still result in positive tax rate arbitrage (working life vs retirement).

Fourth, there is an embedded optionality in traditional contributions. That is, traditional can later be converted to Roth, such as during a low-income year, but a Roth cannot be converted into a traditional.

Fifth, the tax savings from traditional contributions may be invested in a Roth IRA, taxable brokerage account, or used otherwise. Said differently, Roth contributions require more funds: the contribution plus the marginal income tax on the contributed funds. The opportunity cost of the marginal tax can be significant when compounded over a lifetime. (That last point, omitted by the authors, I added for you, dear reader.)

The book has 37 chapters on various tax topics, most of which are ancillary to the thesis above, but are nevertheless informative. Wisely, they hedge their thesis in two respects: first, it’s impossible to give categorical advice that is universally applicable to all taxpayers; there are circumstances where Roth contributions are advisable, such as if a taxpayer’s income is entirely or in large part offset by the standard deduction. Second, it’s prudent to diversify asset location—meaning that assets are spread over traditional, Roth, and taxable accounts. But all tax analysis happens on the margin, and on the margin, for the generic taxpayer, traditional contributions are advisable.
Profile Image for Leah.
224 reviews4 followers
December 10, 2025
I've been reading about this subject for a while, and I didn't encounter anything truly revelatory in this book, but I do feel like I have a better grasp on the big picture of tax planning than I did before. Even the information in chapter 1 laying out how the federal income tax formula works was useful from a big-picture perspective. I appreciate the authors weighing in on how to balance the Affordable Care Act premium tax credit vs Roth conversions in early retirement, and plan to take their advice by converting less than I'd originally intended to. Hopefully others will be able to read this book at an earlier point in their early retirement planning than I did!
9 reviews
March 30, 2026
These authors have created arguably the only financial guide one needs to follow to live a life full of financial freedom. Get a physical copy, grab a highlighter, and get to work.

Very useful read, especially considering the two differing perspectives (financial planning vs tax planning). The authors are effective at making a “dull” topic engaging. They also do a great job of showing how many common fears are actually irrelevant and hardly worth worrying about.

I would recommend this read to anyone, not just someone pursuing “early retirement” as the title suggests. The sooner this book is absorbed and actually put into personal practice, the sooner you will reach a life full of real freedom.
Profile Image for Krithika.
170 reviews5 followers
October 10, 2025
ok this is THE personal finance book for anyone that manages their own finances / taxes (you do not need to be thinking about early retirement!) but I think if you’re starting out in personal finance maybe read a more accessible intro first (I’m thinking Ramit Sethi, Vivian Tu, etc) and then come here.

Also very timely to read this during the government shut down over premium tax credits for healthcare
Profile Image for David.
812 reviews40 followers
June 23, 2026
Written by two self-described "advice-only financial planners", this book is both informative and comprehensive. While it will be a useful resource for anyone negotiating taxes and drawdown strategies in the post-work years, it is geared more toward those beginning retirement in the pre-Medicare phase. It also emphasizes planning for married couples filing jointly, although it isn't terribly hard to modify the examples given to apply to single taxpayer circumstances.

Be aware that the text is pretty busy. The authors use multiple fonts, bold typeset, italics, bullet points, tables, lists, sublists, etc. It is also very repetitive, however the fringe benefit is that readers will not reach the end having missed any of the important underlying principles (Pay Tax When You Pay Less Tax, for example). There is a densely printed, 20-page Bibliography at the back that is nearly 100% hyperlinks to specific topic pages at websites like Investopedia, NerdWallet, The White Coat Investor, and some YouTube videos and podcasts. Some readers may prefer to access those rather than wade through the text.
Profile Image for Jay.
28 reviews
August 8, 2026
Unless you have a pension or are willing to work until the government steps in to save you, this book covers many crucial topics and provides concrete examples of implementation. Is it like reading the tax code? Maybe, but if you have any interest in financial independence leading to early retirement, this is a great resource.
Profile Image for Bonnie Barrilleaux.
23 reviews2 followers
October 15, 2026
I intended to just flip through this, but I ended up reading it cover to cover. Surprisingly fun(??) and insightful treatment of tax planning topics, and very current since it was just published last year and contains info about 2025 and 2026 tax changes.
Profile Image for Christopher Herbert.
86 reviews4 followers
August 26, 2026
If you’re interested in retiring early (and honestly, who isn’t?), this book is for you. Well, not exactly. You also need to be a massive financial DIY’er. And probably a huge nerd.
Profile Image for Gene Neyer.
51 reviews1 follower
May 3, 2026
I found the book to be practical, easy to follow, and comprehensive. The arguments are logical, mathematical and persuasive.
11 reviews1 follower
November 5, 2025
This book is really really good!! It has many examples of showing tax treatment for early retirement…. it was comforting to read through the examples of retires being taxed through retirement w/the traditional 401k vs. Roth.
Profile Image for Brian Herriot.
Author 1 book20 followers
July 17, 2026
"Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement" by Sean Mullaney and Cody Garrett is an important read if you’re serious about approaching retirement with a tax-efficient strategy. It isn’t a textbook (thankfully) but it is for the analytical reader...don’t be surprised when Chapter 1 discusses line items from Form 1040! At the end of the day, it’s a book about tax planning. What else would you expect? :-)

Here are some of the insights that stood out to me, with page references:

* Page 9: “Tactics used during our working years must be evaluated based on their eventual tax impact in the drawdown years.” This idea that you can’t look at tax planning year-by-year in isolation, when I first learned it, completely reframed how I think about retirement savings. I had never truly considered the back end of withdrawing from IRAs and how differently assets are taxed in retirement.

* Page 74: Example showing that in retirement, you only pay tax on the income you actually spend. That usually means a lower effective rate than people expect, because your working years included savings on top of spending.

* Pages 77–78: Pros and cons of maxing out workplace retirement accounts. I feel this is important for people interested in early time freedom who can’t just assume “max it out” is always optimal.

* Pages 109–112: Drawdown principles. Start with taxable accounts first (with exceptions like inherited IRAs). Keep ordinary income low by strategically withdrawing from traditional IRAs up to the standard deduction, or by using Roth conversions within that threshold.

* Chapters 12 & 13: Strategies for avoiding the 10% early withdrawal penalty (I counted 10) and options for health insurance (I counted 7) before Medicare.

  ***If you are an early retiree, these two chapters alone justify the price of the book.***

* Chapter 22: Ah, Health Savings Accounts (HSAs). The book confirmed lessons I first picked up from JL Collins where I learned my HSA is not my FSA. Since first realizing that (and no longer depleting my HSA each year!), I’ve built mine up to $75,000. This chapter is as another reminder of how powerful HSAs are in retirement planning.

* Several Chapters on special situations: The authors don’t ignore edge cases by covering self-employed workers, real estate investors, late starters, sudden job loss, inheritances, charitable giving, 529s, and estate planning.

* Chapter 36 & Chapter 38: Strong implementation advice and a concise summary of key lessons. These are helpful for orienting yourself to the big picture after all the detail.

Overall, this book combines technical depth with practical application and the unifying principle is simple: pay your tax when you pay less tax. If you’re looking for fluff, this isn’t it. But if you’re ready to seriously plan for retirement taxes on your own or with help this book is an excellent resource.
Profile Image for Jason.
31 reviews
April 1, 2026
Certainly not the most thrilling subject matter (to most, anyway), but I found this book to be incredibly interesting and informative. I've been a (non-tax) CPA for 20+ years, and I found a lot of this to be new and insightful. A few thoughts and takeaways:

- I love how the authors really debunk a lot of fear around "common wisdom" of taxes in retirement. They use easy-to-follow examples to demonstrate their cases along the way.
- It hits home how important it is to understand and have some basic knowledge around taxes in retirement. Your investments now become your income and there are a whole new set of strategies for managing the tax load.
- The book is a coherent read, start to finish, but it's also organized in chapter-topics, so that it can serve as a reference guide later if you need to refer back to a specific topic.
- There really isn't much that isn't covered. It's as comprehensive as it needs to be for most people with reasonably straightforward financial situations.
- It's updated through the end of 2025, and includes all of the current impacts from the OBBBA.

A super read for anyone who's within even 10 years of their retirement.
Profile Image for Hien.
86 reviews
September 17, 2026
An excellent, and long overdue book on tax planning for early retirement. I’ve generally been interested in this idea of scaling down work some time in my 50s instead of waiting until the traditional retirement age; given the vast and maze-like tax landscape in the US, along with its looming healthcare burden in old age, I was quite at ease when it came to sorting out the financial aspect of this process until I came upon this book.

The authors provide a detailed, and carefully curated picture of tax decisions pertinent to early retirement, including asset locations re qualified retirement plans (401k; 403k; 457b) and IRAs, Roth conversions, 72(t) plans, etc.

The central argument put forth is to prioritize traditional accounts over Roths during working/accumulation years, so that one may be able to capitalize on tax arbitrage later on during retirement. They manage to demonstrate this with specific numbers and figures of tax obligations unfolding for various scenarios, including MFJ couples as well as widows with the conventional “tax trap.”

The sections on the benefits on long-term capital gains are helpful and reinforce my current approach to taxable brokerage accounts. But I most appreciate the timeline breakdown for early retirement, beginning with pre-Medicare years, passing the Golden years (66-69), leading to post-RMD years, with particular strategies and tactics to optimize tax situations.

On a more philosophical note, I align heartily with the authors that while some planning is needed to ensure financial stability during old age, we should not get buried too deep in the tumbleweed of efficiency-maximization at the expense of losing sight of the most important things in life: health, personal relationships, and memories with loved ones.

And now to put on my sociologist’s hat for a brief moment… Knowledge is power, and knowing what opportunities exist, how to navigate, access, and utilize those play a major role in shaping one’s life chances and outcomes. The intricacies of the current set-up of the tax system that reward educated individuals with the mental bandwidth to do their own research on loopholes and special strategies (such as those found in this book), and with financial resources to co-opt consultation from experts (CPAs, etc) would therefore only serve to further widen the already large gaps in wealth among Americans.
Profile Image for Robert Sutherland.
339 reviews15 followers
February 17, 2026
If you are a regular listener to the "Choose FI" podcast or hang out in that space, Cody Garrett and Sean Mullaney are frequent guests and are knowledgeable about taxation aspects of financial independence. After the OBBB, they published this guide to tax planning around retirement. It is for a niche audience.

I consider myself an enthusiastic amateur in financial matters, well-read, pretty sophisticated, and a person that people come to for financial advice--though I never give advice, (always seek the advice of a professional). That said, I learned a lot from this book. Much of it was familiar territory, but they covered the vast majority of topics of interest to potential early (or normal aged) retirees.

There are a lot of numbers, and the topic isn't exactly riveting, but it is well done, well organized, and, I think, optimistic, despite it being primarily about taxes. It successfully removes fear and replaces it with knowledge. Whether you follow all or part of their framework, you will no doubt save significant money on your future tax bills.
Profile Image for Kathryn Davidson.
420 reviews3 followers
November 2, 2026
Although the authors try very diligently to make this book accessible, it is still very dense. To distill the essence (which is consistent with JL Collins book “The Simple Path to Wealth”): 1) The best investment strategy is the one you actually use. Don’t try to maximize for everything (consider the Return on Hassle). 2) It’s good to pay taxes when taxes are lower (i.e., lower income years). 3) Only need 2 investment vehicles: (a) retirement accounts, i.e., traditional and/or Roth, maximize these first, invested in a mix of index funds and bonds, with bonds only being invested in retirement accounts to minimize taxable income, and (b) taxable brokerage accounts invested in index funds. 4) Work to keep ordinary income low in retirement. While there is the potential for taxes later on (RMDs, widow’s tax trap, etc), these are nominal if assets are managed right and mean that you’ve been blessed with good returns. 5) The biggest difference in financial considerations between early retirement and later retirement is paying for health care.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
2 reviews
December 24, 2025
Exceptionally useful!

Found very helpful nuggets of practical advice and concepts I can use now throughout this book. Well written and engaging. Perfect blend of explanation and technical detail. I will definitely review and circle back to key sections. Very well organized. One of the most useful books I've encountered in this general space. Kudos and thanks to the authors for sharing this.

If I have one critique, it's that this book is not aimed at the wealthy. They often reference those who are very financially successful possibly considering other options or advice. But their examples tend to be more upper middle class retirees. That's presumably the sweet spot of the market, but worth considering for someone who is say Fat fired... Still, this doesn't detract from the excellent wisdom and learning on offer here. I will be recommending this excellent book to several in my network. So glad I came across it on Amazon!
Profile Image for Annette Arach.
58 reviews
June 19, 2026
The thing that impressed me the most about the book is the way it brought complex topics on tax into lay man terms and approachable. The authors guide readers through retirement accounts, roth conversions, distribution strategies, and options for withdrawals below the age of 59 1/2 through practical and realistic examples to help readers understand and apply the information. There are many case studies that illustrate the application of the theory into everyday decision making.

One of the best features of the book is that it deals with both the retirement downs and the retirement ups. While most financial books get heavily into saving and investing, the particular focus of this book is on strategic withdrawals and tax planning. The discussions on avoiding unnecessary taxes, managing required minimum distributions, and preparing for future tax law changes provide valuable insights for long-term financial success.
1 review
July 17, 2026
What sets this book apart are the examples, and the fact that we get two often different opinions and perspectives from both Cody Garrett and Sean Mullaney.

The examples stand out because in a field where generalities and rules of thumb are the best that you get, Tax Planning To and Through... provides examples that are specific and intentionally extreme, to dispel a lot of the unfounded fears about being "crushed by taxes" in this or that situation.

Seeing these fearmongering scenarios dispelled time and again is where the fun really came in for me in reading this book.

The tax experience of the early retiree really is different from traditional retirees, and it's a huge help to have so many examples to draw on in navigating my own financial independence as well as helping others with theirs.

Thank you Cody and Sean for putting in the work to make this book not only super useful, but actually fun to read! I didn't see that one coming!
Profile Image for Katie Brooke.
4 reviews1 follower
July 2, 2026
Honestly, not as useful as I had hoped. The big advice I took was “max your traditional 401k and Roth IRA” and then after that - basically save in brokerage for early retirement. So nothing new there.

I did learn a bit about draw-down strategies, and 72(t) option... and I appreciated the mathematical breakdown of different scenarios like the widows tax pitfall, etc, etc.

The biggest letdown for me was how it had almost nothing about planning for retirement with a pension plan. I guess maybe they consider that outside the scope of “early” retirement.... (even when MRA for pensions is only 55-57 years old?) Disappointed.

So 3/5. It's fine. It does okay at what it tries to do.
5 reviews
August 18, 2026
excellent content, highly competent authors

excellent content, highly competent authors; fairly nuance, but content, that’s my jam as a personal finance enthusiast. Definitely recommended. It’s a very important subject, and this is useful information that would steer you towards pretax over Roth contributions, which could be substantial for your long-term outcome; Ed Slott’s Book the retirement tax bomb ticks louder would be the counter argument. This book has a more solid footing in my opinion; and fights off the tax “bomb” fear mongering you hear from authors such as Slott.
1,645 reviews22 followers
March 30, 2026
A 3.5

Aptly titled. I found it refreshing that the book is not trying to sell some perfect plan or strategy. Instead, it is trying to paint a broad understanding of options and tools. I walk away feeling like I have a better understanding of tax rules and how to use them to my advantage. It helped alleviate some of my concerns.

However! I couldn't help but notice a few things about the scenarios. The “less desirable" scenarios all have non-European names. Are we living in the Goofus & Gallant days still? Additionally, all scenarios feature married couples, no singles.
25 reviews
January 22, 2026
As an early (and lean) retiree this wasn’t as helpful for my situation. None of the examples reflected anything close to my situation. A lot of time is spent explaining edge cases for the over accumulators. I know I’m in a small minority of situations and it isn’t as complex as when you have over saved, which is why I still gave it a good 4 star rating.
Profile Image for Frieda Sewald Weigle.
47 reviews
January 28, 2026
Highly recommend - Cody and Sean take a difficult and taxing (pun intended) subject and make it easy to understand and digest with concise descriptions and plenty of examples. I learned about HSA spousal catch-up contributions that I was not aware of, which was an instant value add to our family's bottom line.
Profile Image for Reid.
176 reviews10 followers
April 14, 2026
My favorite things about this book were the topic-driven, digestible chapters and the examples. When breaking down the finances of a fictitious couple, the methodical parsing of their income, assets, and taxes was really helpful. I also appreciated some of the FIRE community Easter eggs included in these hypothetical case studies.
Profile Image for Heather Vaughan.
26 reviews
July 10, 2026
Excellent resource on tax planning with a focus on early retirement. It is a bit dense at the beginning. I was fortunate to take it one chapter at a time with a book club, which made for terrific discussion. I finally understand the 1040 form! And I'm well equipped to make tax planning decisions ahead of time.
1 review
October 18, 2026
amazing! anybody who needs to go deeper into understanding how to save for retirement needs to read this. They strike an amazing balance between thoroughness and presenting it in an easy to understand manner. Even if you don't care about retiring early, they provide a plethora of examples and scenarios that demonstrate these concepts for all different types of retirement planners.
814 reviews18 followers
January 11, 2026
Excellent, well written, clear understandable advice. Took the authors advice & read through first without worrying about the charts too much. A book to refer to & go back over as needed. Thanks to Cody Garrett & Sean Mullaney for the information
15 reviews5 followers
April 23, 2026
Changed my mind on Roth vs traditional 401k. Favorite chapters: 10 - Drawdown Principles, 13 - Health Insurance before Medicare and the Premium Tax Credit, 20 - Planning for Uncertain, 24 - Tax gain Harvesting, 29 - Return on Hassle
,
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews