Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Tales of Khayaal - Aron

Rate this book
Set in the third epoch of the planet Ikleel, the arrival of a comet signifies the approach of the Final Standing, an apocalyptic end time when an ancient enemy of humanity, Mörtan, is set to return.

In Book One, Zorar and his apprentice Alifa, both Grand Conduits of Nur, urgently prepare for the coming time along with other Nurani Conduits. Meanwhile, Arön, their home, has fallen under the control of the Syndicate, a sinister organisation seeking to plunder centuries of imperial wealth.

Cataclysmic events, a fracturing of society, a loss of what was sacred, will all beg the question - what does it mean to be human in a time of relentless techno-scientific change.

366 pages, Paperback

Published September 26, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Rehan Khan

45 books55 followers
A keen observer of history and techno-science, Rehan Khan, has always been intrigued in how ideas and inventions move from one civilisation to the next, and how they change as they shift across different cultures.

He is the author of a Tomb of Empires (2024) a historical fiction set in 90BC in the Middle East, the Carnegie nominated A Tudor Turk trilogy (2019-2022) set in the Ottoman Empire and Tudor England, and the fantasy sci-fi series, Tales of Khayaal (2025) set on the Earth like planet of Ikleel. These gripping stories also ask readers to consider the role of virtue within the human story

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
49 (65%)
4 stars
18 (24%)
3 stars
3 (4%)
2 stars
3 (4%)
1 star
2 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
Profile Image for layan (semi-hiatus?).
331 reviews40 followers
Read
September 12, 2025
Hey, so… I really don’t want to say this, but I dnfed at 20%.

Let me start off by saying: I have been dreaming of reading this book forever - literally for months. I only recently began reading and discovering fantasy books with spiritual/islamic/abrahamic elements here and there, and it has quickly become one of my favorite genres. I just LOVE when a story is heavily influenced and inspired by religions and faiths. But unfortunately, this genre is almost nonexistent, and not many authors publish books within it. That being said, I was genuinely so, so, so excited to read this book. I bought it the moment the time felt right and immediately started reading. I was switching between the physical copy (which is absolutely gorgeous) and the audiobook (an absolute masterpiece).

That being said, I want to share my feelings about why I dnfed it :(

From the very start, I noticed the lack of world-building - and when I say lack, I mean it is genuinely barely there. The author jumps between telling and MORE telling, I was gagged and not in a good way. For instance, in the first chapter, we are supposedly in a tent where soldiers are being treated, yet we don’t know what it looks like, where it is, or anything about it at all, we are just told it’s just a… tent???
I’m someone who imagines things very vividly in my head - give me anything and I’ll turn it into a full movie - but I found it extremely hard to do so with this book.

When you’re introducing such an interesting and compelling world, I want to know about it. I want the words themselves to convince me so. I want to know what that tent is like, what it smells like, what the atmosphere feels like. I want to know what that forest looks like - is it lush and green? Is it different from the south? How quiet is it? How loud is it? And so on. If I don’t even have a basic canvas or outline of the setting, then I’m very unlikely to feel compelled or interested in what I’m sure is a well-crafted world - but one that seems to exist somewhere other than on the page.

What makes this miss hit even harder is that this world, in theory, is incredibly interesting. But, again, when you introduce a new world - especially one that’s meant to be complex, layered, and rich in history, politics, and belief - you have to convince me... I don’t need to be told that the world is important or dangerous or sacred, I NEED to see it reflected in the characters, in their reactions, in the settings they move through, and in the political and social tensions surrounding them. Instead, it feels like things are simply happening one after the other without any weight. There’s even an attempted assassination scene that should feel tense and shocking - but it comes and goes so quickly that it barely registers. Moments start out of nowhere and then end just as abruptly, with absolutely no buildup or aftermath OR emotional impact. Literally nothing 😭. Everything feels strangely flat, like I’m watching events unfold from a distance rather than experiencing them alongside the characters. At times, it honestly felt like I was reading about robots - characters moving from point A to point B, reacting because the plot requires it, not because they feel real.

The supposed big scene of the First Sign is also very… vague in its description. Sure, the sky turns black, there’s no sun, there’s thunder - and then everything goes back to normal… mind-blowing right? I honestly can’t even elaborate more because that’s exactly how it appears in the book. There is nothing more. I didn’t feel any emotion toward what is meant to be a huge sign of the end of time, which is unfortunate because this moment is supposed to be the core of the book and the series moving forward.

Then we move on to the scene where the southern knights with magical abilities, I assume, rescue Alifa from being killed. This entire scene happens within one page, and then it’s over. Zorar and his friends find her - we don’t know how, and the author doesn’t even attempt to build any mystery around it. It just happens out of the blue in a way that feels more annoying than shocking. They then offer Alifa a chance to go with them to the south because she’s special and has magical abilities like them, and she just… accepts. How am I supposed to feel anything when all of this is happening in such a shallow, one-dimensional way? Tell me, how did they find her? How did they KNOW she’s also like them? It’s just… disappointing.

Anyway, after that, Alifa travels with them, and the next chapter suddenly has her walking through the souqs of Urua. We don’t know where she slept, what house she stayed in, how the journey went… nothing. Absolutely nothing. Entire transitions are skipped, and with them, any opportunity for emotional development, tension, or bonding between the characters.

Spare me a moment to be angry - do you know what we get descriptions of for the first time? The hot Jamashi guy, who’s apparently so hot that even married women in the souq are drooling over him. I don’t even want to say anything else, that’s the only scene where any kind of descriptive language is actually used…

I could honestly go on, but it would all circle back to the same issue: the extremely shallow world-building that ends up weakening everything else, from the plot to the characters. I was so excited for this book, and I genuinely wanted to love it. I’ve been keeping up and know that the next book is currently in the works, and I really wish this one had convinced me enough to at least feel excited for what’s coming next.

———

PRE-READ

14/feb/2026
Okay let me be fair, I want to read this in Ramadan amidst all the vibes. I cannot wait!!!!!!!!!

-

9/dec/2025
I listened to the first chapter back in early October, and I genuinely haven’t been able to get this book out of my head since. I’m counting down to Christmas break so I can finally sit down and devour it properly 🥹.

-

12/sep/2025
This book can’t get to me fast enough. After hearing Rehan Khan’s trilogy introduction (@talesofkhayaal) IM INDEED SOLD.
2 reviews
September 8, 2025
Tales of Khayaal is a well-written, gripping novel that blends adventure, history, and strong characters into a story that’s both exciting and easy to get lost in.

Set in a vivid Islamic historical world that is brought to life with rich detail and energy. The historical setting isn’t just a backdrop - it adds real texture to the story, giving it weight and authenticity.

The writing is smooth and immersive - I could easily picture every scene, from ancient cities to secretive nighttime escapes. It reads almost like a movie, pulling you straight into the action.

The story moves at a great pace, keeping you hooked from start to finish without ever dragging.

One of the biggest highlights of Tales of Khayaal is the many strong characters. They’re bold, smart, and none of them are ever sidelined - actively shaping the story rather than being part of the background. It’s refreshing to see each character written with so much depth and purpose.

The plot is packed with adventure and tension, with twists that kept me guessing. It’s thrilling without being over-the-top, and there’s always something happening that kept me invested.

Overall, it is a fun, adventurous read with heart.

If you enjoy historical fiction with a fast-moving plot, strong female characters, and adventure, you’ll love this!
Profile Image for Seif Zaki.
27 reviews
November 27, 2025
The first entry in what I hope becomes a large and diverse new sci-fi/fantasy setting, Tales of Khayaal book 1 is a fun and thrilling read from start to finish, drawing on themes from Islamic theology and inspiration from other works of fiction to create a unique and original story.

The setting is great; a pseudo-steampunk/Arabian Nights world where technology and magic interweave. It's very distinctive while also feeling remarkably familiar to me, being of Arab descent and a Muslim too. Several parallels can be seen with Islam, from Quranic proverbs to the structure of some groups and castes among the characters.

Sometimes it's the little things, such as characters drawing elemental powers from prayer beads while uttering verses from their religion, to invoking the name of the Creator in every day conversation. Other times, the reference are more transparent, such as the use of other intelligent species like Djinn (given a slightly different name here). The technology is very cleverly thought out too, being of bio-organic origin such as using algae to power everything from lights to computer tablets to vehicles.

There is occasional action, largely reminiscent of swashbuckling tales found in 1001 Nights, with sword fights coupled with the use of magical abilities. The characters that use these are known as Conduits (because they channel energy from another divine or infernal plane) and there is a dichotomy of light vs dark, which, as a Star Wars fan, is right up my street. This makes action sequences very enjoyable and the powers on display are unique in their execution but also somewhat recognisable as things you might find in other media like manga and so on. For a fantasy geek like me, this is comfort food.

I'm not usually a fan of prose written in the presence tense, as is the case in this book, but I very soon got used to it and it made me feel present in the story. The plot never gets boring and I was always looking forward to developments. The characters and world-building are very well crafted and there is plenty of scope to enhance this further in subsequent books or, as is the plan, in other media hopefully. Some characters fall into archetypes which is not necessarily a bad thing, and there is very heavy influence from other media in some cases, where I may have preferred more originality but these are tropes typical of the genre and don't detract from my overall enjoyment.

The story ends on a cliffhanger to some degree, so I'm very much looking forward to the next instalment. So far, this world seems crafted with me in mind, and so I am very to dive in.
Profile Image for Ahmad Jomaa.
44 reviews3 followers
November 15, 2025
TOK: Aron is a fascinating and promising first installment in a series I’m genuinely excited to follow.

In this opening novel, we’re introduced to the world of Ikleel, a vibrant, culturally rich setting filled with layered motives, intriguing histories, and a cast of characters who quickly become memorable. It’s refreshing to see a fantasy narrative rooted in traditions and inspirations beyond the usual Western canon; that alone brings a sense of originality and breathes fresh air into the genre.

There is a great deal to learn in this universe, and a lot to take in... the exposition was a little heavy at times, but by the final chapters, I found myself deeply invested in several of the key characters, and eager to follow where their paths will lead next. The concepts introduced here are compelling, and it’s clear that the journey is only just beginning.

Overall, I’m truly excited to return to Ikleel, and I can’t wait to see how the story and its heroes grow in book two!
1 review
September 9, 2025
A fascinating fictional world provided an apt setting for this action thriller. The reader is pulled into this immersive journey of self discovery through love and hate, good and evil and is gripped till the end. The storytelling builds strong characters and an intriguing plot line of geo-politics and socio-economics cleverly intertwined with Islamic teachings and history encouraging the reader to look within themselves and their purpose in life.
Looking forward to the next instalment!
10 reviews
October 13, 2025
Wow! what a page turner .. and why does this story resonate so deeply? It's my world yet it's not my world. I love Alifa and her mentor Zorar. I'm now fully vested in willing these Conduits of Nur to have what it takes to face the mounting challenges of the imminent 'final standing'. Can't wait for book 2!
3 reviews
October 18, 2025
Now this was a wonderful discovery ❤️
1 review
November 7, 2025
An Excellent and Spiritually Rich Debut

Tales of Khayaal: Book 1 – Aron is an excellent debut entry that lays a dynamic and robust foundation for a planned series. While the book incorporates many familiar elements from other fantasy narratives, the author skillfully blends these inspirations into the distinct world of Ikleel. This is not a mere retread; the author has crafted an existence wholly its own, paying respectful homage to its influences.

The world-building is particularly strong, featuring a fantastic blend of high fantasy and techno-science. Ikleel feels like a believable, living world with its own intricate history, political systems, and varied factions, all while deftly hinting at the greater world and powers that future installments will explore.

Spiritual Depth and Accessibility
A remarkable element of this book is its nuanced approach to spirituality:

For readers of Islamic faith, the book provides a fantastic incorporation of Islamic concepts, virtues, and traditions without compromising Aqidah (creed) within its fictional setting.

For secular or non-Islamic readers, the narrative is wholesome and focuses on universal virtues and morals shared across many cultures. The handling of these themes is reminiscent of Tolkien's subtle infusion of Christian motifs — making the underlying morality resonant without being intrusive or demanding acceptance.

Compelling Characters
The story centers on two main characters who perfectly balance each other and serve as natural guides into the world:

Zorar is an excellent character—a seasoned mentor whose wisdom and established history anchor the story. He naturally introduces the world's lore through his role as a mentor and leader. His deep experience plays a pivotal role in shaping events and the development of the other characters, making his goals and actions compelling to follow.

Alifa is a youthful apprentice whose naïve perspective allows readers to discover the world organically. It is wonderful to follow her journey of learning, overcoming obstacles, and seeing her true nature shine through when facing difficult scenarios. Her challenges make her a highly relatable and compelling character.

The supporting characters are introduced with promise and good background stories, though their arcs remain lightly explored in this first entry—leaving ample room for development in future books.

Villains and Overarching Threat:
The primary antagonist of the first book, Brant, is a ruthless and cunning foil to the heroes, leading the Syndicate to sow chaos. He effectively foreshadows the ultimate evil, Mörtan, a figure reminiscent of overarching villains like Sauron (Lord of the Rings) or The Dark One (Wheel of Time) —a powerful, destructive force with a network of underlings weaving secret plots across the world.


World-Building and Mechanics
The author primarily focuses the events within the city of Arön, yet skillfully introduces other cultures, nations, and outside political factions. While these elements don't play a significant role immediately, they promise to be expanded upon and have a major impact in later entries.

The power system feels familiar but has a unique twist: the supernatural power afforded to the few must be accessed and nurtured through a deeper spiritual connection to its source, the creator of Ikleel. This gives the magic a unique depth and flavor, and the characters who wield this power use it in interesting and inventive ways.


Production and Sound
Finally, the Audiobook production is top-notch. The voice actors do a great job—providing distinct voices, excellent emotional range, and enough variety to keep the story engaging in audio form.

Final Verdict:
Tales of Khayaal: Book 1 – Aron is a promising start. It successfully blends familiar fantasy tropes with fresh cultural and spiritual layers, introduces characters worth following, and sets up a world that feels ready to grow exponentially in future installments. Highly recommended for fans of expansive world-building!

8.5/10
Profile Image for Lubna.
418 reviews26 followers
December 28, 2025
Beautifully written fantasy novel that is inspired by Islamic and Sufi themes. After having grown up reading books that draw so heavily on Christian themes & theology it was really enjoyable to read fiction that draws on Islamic theology while also being a fun read. Can’t wait for the next installments!!
Profile Image for Kirin.
832 reviews64 followers
November 10, 2026
I am so late to the party that is Tales of Khayaal, but alhumdulillah everything has a time, and I have been thoroughly swept away just in time for Book 2 to come out soon inshaAllah.  At 366 pages, this YA fantasy, sci-fi, adventure story is suitable for YA readers/listeners 13 and up with plot appropriate instances of violence, the end of the world, killing, torture, powers, drugs, politics, corruption, prejudice, and hints of romance.  Islam is not named, but it is more than just Muslim-coded, the world and the characters are heavily steeped in religious concepts, ideology, sunnahs, spirituality, morality, and culture.  I started reading the book and immediately loved that there is a map at the start and robust backmatter in the end that aids in the world building, fictional structures, power constructs, terminology, and that there is even a character list.  There is also a fully produced audio book that comes with the supplemental pdfs. So even if you are a fantasy newbie, whether you listen or read the book, you will have resources to make slipping into the third epoch on Ikleel smooth.  A bit of a heads up, initially the book feels a little simplistic and familiar in its world building, I reached out to more seasoned fantasy readers, and was told it has a term, derivative fantasy, it subsides well before the halfway point, when the action picks up, but it gave me a little pause early on, that maybe this book wouldn't have the layered plot lines and character arcs that I was hoping for.  If you feel it too, keep going, I couldn't stop reading/listening to the second half of the book and regret nothing.  

WHY I LOVE IT:

I loved all the hadith, not attributed, and ayats worked into the advice from smiling as an act of charity, to finding peace in the remembrance of the One creator.  I want to have a non Muslim read it and get their feedback, Muslims will love the terms, concepts and Islamic framing and structures.  The writing style is easy, I'm still not completely sure how I feel about the scroll lights feeling like Harry Potter's wand selection and the Isthmus giving vibes of the Ways from Wheel of Time, but I can think of other books that also take from those structures, and I don't read enough fantasy to know what came first, so I'll just suffice it to say that between the Islam and some key world building machinations, on top of the backmatter, and the book feels intuitive and familiar.

FLAGS:
mentioned above, but in addition there are assassins, and theft, and ensuring that a female prisoner has not been touched, nothing is detailed or sensationalized.  I am tempted to do the audio again with my 11 year old, I think anything "flag worthy" would be taken in the context intended and anything implying something more would fly under his radar, but even if it didn't it would be a teachable moment, and the way it is presented would not be too mature for him.

TOOLS FOR LEADING THE DISCUSSION

I would love to read this with a diverse group (ages, faith, gender, familiarity with the genre) and discuss.
Profile Image for Sayma Begum.
1 review
December 21, 2025
Premise: On the planet Ikleel, the infinite is closer to you than you think. The Conduits of Nur struggle with the forces of Dhulm, as the Final Standing approaches.

Main characters:
We begin with Alifa, one of our main characters. She is the traditional protagonist who is the newcomer and we see the world with fresh eyes through her. She is unsure of herself, the world and of her duties but she is very earnest. Her journey is propelled through the coming of the final standing – a signal for the end times. Then we meet Zorar, our 2nd main character who is the mentor / teacher of Alifa. He is wise, kind and calm and nurtures Alifa into the world of the conduits. Unlike many other characters we meet, he wholeheartedly believes in the final standing, believes in the creator and all of the signs that come with it. Others are hesitant but you have a deep feeling that Zorar is very wise and a learned but humble person.

The dynamic between student and mentor is done very well, they are able to quickly bond and be there for each other in times of need. We see their relationship develop from the beginning to the end of the story, as they trust each other and share their worries. Both are able to learn from each other, Alifa allows Zorar to open himself up about his own traumas, while Zorar acts like a father figure to Alifa. Their relationship is very sincere and honest and it’s very refreshing when they speak to each other with such kindness.In today’s modern anti-fantasy, nihilistic story trend we rarely see these types of dynamics play out. As someone who is writing my own story that has the mentor/master – student relationship at its centre Tales of Khayaal is a great inspiration for me. It makes me yearn for a mentor figure myself, and reminds me how the modern world has lost the value of apprenticeships.

World building:
Kha: The first half of the book we are introduced to a lot. We get introduced to the magic / Kha system in chapter one, with Alifa’s nurturing abilities. I’ve enjoyed learning about the system, I think it’s very unique, in the fact that it’s based on spiritual connections, but also has a tangible/ physical aspect in the use of sources and elements. There is a dichotomy between the Nur vs Dhulm, the plight is the same for both but the characters use their powers differently, Nurani or Dhulmi. Dhulm stems from Nafs (desires – both nafs ul lawwamah – blaming soul and nafs ul ammarah – commanding soul) whereas Nur is sober and level-headed (the 3rd nafs – Nafs ul Mutmainah – the soul is at peace). At first I thought the magic system was very overpowered especially for those who are not conduits but then I read examples where conduits were defeated using the sonic rifles (like Zorar’s scene near the end (which was one great scene!)). Threading is definitely my favourite, being a massive assassin’s creed fan (the older games), some scenes really came through the page. I was able to imagine the characters parkouring just like in the game. My all-time favourite scene in the book was when Zorar threads all the windows of the Nurani base then jumps out of the base and it shatters everything. I could vividly imagine that playing out in my head! That scene also reminded me of Kakyoin and Heirophant Green (my favourite character + stand) ‘threading’ the city to defeat Dio in the anime - JoJo’s Bizarre adventure! The Isthmus is a very unique creation too; I don’t think I have ever read a fantasy book which has an attainable spiritual world that characters can access

The Backdrop: We have the Arön Empire, perhaps on its last legs. We are introduced to Negin, the southern Sultana. She is loved by her people but she herself does not wield enough power to rival the North / Black Axe army, the Teutons or the Syndicate whom are quickly sucking dry the empire (this is evident by the fact that she does not control the prisons, but is aware of the harsh treatment in them). She is like a puppet in the regime. Added to that are the assassins who work for coin and thrive in political instability and the ultimate bad – Mortan along with his cronies (the Harbingers). The book discusses at length and detail the political dynamics at play and the disembodiment of an entire nation is essentially unravelled piece meal until the final chapter where it is completely undone. The Opius trade is also woven into the story, I think this is allegorical to the Opium wars that occurred under the British in China. Opius is an addicting drug and is used as a bargaining / trading tool by Arön’s Opposition.

Romance:
One of the sincerest, sensitive and touching parts of the novel were definitely with Zorar and Negin. I appreciate how their backstory with each other was drip fed to us. Their interactions with each other is fraught with love and hesitancy as it’s a forbidden love. At first, when the full backstory was not made clear, I assumed it was a generic forbidden love trop where the two families of the lovers had not agreed with the pair, it would have left me a bit disappointed but when I found out the real reason of the forbidden I was very surprised and even pleased. The fact that Tales of Khayaal draws from Islamic themes, adding the forbidden love between Zorar and Negin takes a lot of maturity. It’s quite brave and I really appreciate the honesty of depicting these types of feelings. The ending of the book made me super sad because of it!

Things that can be improved: I felt that Alifa learnt her grand-conduit abilities a bit too fast, she is a natural fast learner but I would’ve appreciated it more if she made some mistakes, it would be a bit more relatable.

There’s a lot to learn and a lot we are introduced to in the book (Kha, Nurani / Dhulmi, Isthmas, types of conduits etc), it is very complex, especially when everything is explained in a few short chapters. I had to get into the story and read what characters were doing in order to learn it, but when it ‘clicked,’ I found it very enjoyable to read about.

We are also introduced to the political landscape, there’s so many power structures at play and although it is very realistic, I found myself confused on who is aligned to what. After reading half the book, was when everything began to come together.

Conclusion:I am reminded of my passion for writing and world-building by Tales of Khayaal. It's great to see a story that is so influenced by Islamic concepts (that is, not a very young child's storybook, and it’s something that is definitely missing from our Ummah and one that needs to be tended towards! Tales of Khayaal excels in blending peaceful, intimate moments with intense action sequences. It’s Assassins’s Creed meets Tales of Earthsea (ironically) for me!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Shahrazad.
110 reviews50 followers
May 24, 2026
The genre you didn’t know you needed — until now. If you’re the kind of reader who’s always hungry for something fresh, this one’s for you.

In book one Aron we are introduced to Ikleel through the eyes of Alifa as she is slowly learning of her strengths and abilities. character discourse , description of the diverse city’s and nations all make this novel world feel lived-in and real.

Loved the parallels to earth both in worldly and metaphysical aspects, delivered through the epigraphs and the different character’s journey. Leaves us contemplating about our world’s givens .

Ends at a cliffhanger — can’t wait for book Two’s release!
Profile Image for Sister Sunny.
5 reviews
October 14, 2026
If Harry Potter, X-Men, Star Wars, Inception, and Monsanto were placed in an epic end of the world saga, this would be it.

The book was hard to get into in the beginning with the introduction of many names, it read more like a sci-fi movie than a book. I felt a bit of exposition in the first 3 chapters, and then after the world was explained by chapter 10, it became a relatively easy and fast-paced read. This is a very easy to read book other than the confusion at the start.

---

My Reading Experience

👍 What I liked (a lot): I loved the spiritual vibes and the light vs dark themes that is true of all heroic epics. But it just felt so beautiful from a sense that Arabian and South Asian culture was given a pleasurable focus in how the cities and governing systems work. I absolutely love love love the beautiful way in which The Creator/Source was written with such endearment into the magic and world systems of Ikleel. I loved the interesting world building when it came to the Conduit power systems and also found the Isthmus interesting but not explained enough. I look forward to the authors to build out the story in depth to explain why these systems are important and how they function in the greater Ikleel universe.

👎 What I didn’t like: I didn’t like the exposition in the beginning, I didn’t understand it in context of the whole story either. There is a reference to some characters/groups in the end, but they were not a focus in the story so I felt the book was trying to pack too much of the world without much clear explanation. Maybe there are readers more patient than me, but I find it more confusing than interesting. I also didn’t like that the female characters weren’t highlighted with many struggles or flaws, so they fell flat to me. Maybe because a male author wrote them, but the male leading and support characters felt more fleshed out than the female ones even though it opens with a female main character. The most interesting character was revealed near the last third of the book and I believe that will be what Book Two will be about.


🤩 Favorite element: I truly loved that this book was based in "spiritual systems" and not magic systems as Rehan Khan mentioned in an interview at Cambridge Muslim College. That was truly in depth and beautifully signified in how these Conduits worked, either for divine light or worldly oppression. Everything made so much more sense and had this feeling of awe and wonder that I could understand these systems in such a way that it made me really love the story and what the characters were fighting for. It also made me wonder what I'd have to develop in myself as Abdallah Rothman had said the point is when reading fantasy series like this and comparing it to the Islamic tie-ins within the Matrix and Star Wars. It's our duty as humans to develop our capacities, and while I can't thread or heft or imbue and reveal, in a metaphorical sense, I can. And I think that's the best part. It fulfills a childlike aspect of my spiritual journey, one that feels fresh as I'm learning about it as an adult rather than a child whom its rigidity was forced upon. The spiritual journey feels like it has more adventure and awe now.

😣 Worst element: I think the toughest part for me was the exposition and the lack of explanation of things like the Isthmus or the elements. Reading further, it was also the cliché feeling of some of the characters as they feel somewhat flat and lacking depth. I know this is book 1, I know you can either focus on the worldbuilding or the characters, and it's very often hard to do both. But I think it may have been too much worldbuilding and not enough character building, personally speaking.

🥰 Most memorable moment: I loved the part in Chapter 29 where

---

The Book Itself

🧭 Plot: I felt the plot was fast paced, but slightly disjointed in that some of the scenes made little sense, such as Hale looking for Alifa, as if it were to be an act of love and devotion to her or that some things feel predictable such as Alifa being Zorar's daughter or Kaivan being Negin's son. Kaivan agreeing to go to the dark side, even though he feels like it's a bad idea. I think all plot points felt predictable, there were only a couple that I was taken by surprise. But overall, there weren't many surprising twists, especially that favored for the Nurani team. There was a definite cliffhanger at the end of the book to get you interested in book 2, but I can only hope that the plot is more interesting and intentional come book 2, because it read a bit like a comic or manga series with very basic premises of good and evil and nothing complex or nuanced or innovative in what drives the story forward.

🦸‍♀️ Characters: There were a diverse array of characters, and mainly five "main" characters including Alifa, Zorar, Brant, Kaivan and Hale. From them all, there being only one female main character was unbalanced. And all characters felt a bit flat, specifically Alifa, as if she lacked a flaw. In all cases, both Alifa and Zorar lacked flaws that poked through their character that wasn't used to drive the plot forward as something lucky for them as if they're the chosen ones, or that Nurani Conduits don't have flaws or make mistakes as all can be forgiven or was part of the plan. Alifa herself felt flat and one-dimensional as a pristine and pure girl with powerful abilities she's always known she's had but couldn't explain. Aside from this, what flaw does she possess that makes her relatable? She's very good at what she does, she excels in training, she's pure-hearted. But she doesn't struggle at all with anything? No Dhulmi temptation? The only two relatable characters are both Hale and Kaivan, Alifa's love interests who are unknown to her. There wasn't much depth into the villain who clearly is Brant in this book at least, and we didn't get an understanding into anyone's past aside from it being a sentence long. So I felt like I was left wanting and unsatisfied when it came to the depth of characters. I'm hoping there's some character development and arc in book 2 and onwards.

✍️ Writing and prose: This might be Khan's portion, but I felt although the writing was simple, straightforward, descriptive but concise made for easy reading. The writing wasn't hard to understand, although there were a few words used that come from Arabic or Urdu that were explained or left as unique nouns, but beyond that, anyone could pick this book up and read it, even a 12 year old. But was it easy to get into that made it interesting and easy to relate to the characters outside of plot devices to progress this epic saga forward within the world that was built for them, no. Again, the writing felt atmospheric, it didn't feel juvenile, but it was easy to read and nothing that would make your grandmother bat an eyelash. Beside the fact that I felt this was written mainly for a young male audience and didn't really think about female readers and their desire for complexity in interpersonal relationships and character development, the reading was clean and cozy.

🗺️ Setting and worldbuilding: This was Gould's area of focus, as the concept rocked and was amazing to think about and to sit for hours later imagining myself as a character in this world of Ikleel. I loved that I could just get access to the way things worked as a Conduit and imagine how I'd fight, what I'd be good at, and what flaws would make me fall, and whether I'd be able to get back up again. This unique world made me want to go back and read and think about the depth of which this book is written and hope there was more intentionality, and I believe there was. With the symbolism behind the elements chosen, the colors, and the meaning of algae and scroll-lights and kamishes, there is so that can be expanded upon that you can learn about, even if the Khan and Gould didn't think too deeply on everything, there's that potential just because Islamic concepts hold a big part of the depth in it. In my book club, there were more than a few people who overlooked the intentionality behind ever single thing in this imaginary world of Ikleel.

💡 Themes and ideas: The book on the back cover begs to ask what humans would do in the face of techno-scientific change. If I read it straight through, I feel like the author didn't really address the allegorical question. But on second thought, I think the answer is more sinister and happens under our noses, as the loss of sacred knowledge when a whole continent with the richest cultures within it becomes colonized. The change is slow or unseeming, until it's upon you. There were many highlights and nods to history in this book such as the Syndicate being a direct remix of the East India Trading Company and Arön being too similar sounding to Iran in both name pronunciation, but also what had happened with the amount of coups staged by the British and Russians, and later Americans teamed with the Israelis. So there's a lot of overlap and parallels that point to what already has happened and what people do. Techno-scientific change is brought upon by people who wield it like it is the only thing keeping us from becoming savage barbarians, and that line of thinking has given every person with money and no moral values except to make more of it, the reason to desecrate nations and what has been held sacred. You lose your identity, your purpose, your power. This book just shows in an epic manga way, that this is how it starts... without you knowing when or how to stop it.

🎬 Ending: The ending left me on a huge cliffhanger. I do have my predictions and wonder what most of book 2 will be about allegorically. Because I think there's more to Kaivan and Hale we have yet to see, and I'd like Alifa to grow and develop more. Unfortunately, Other than this, I hope Alifa doesn't remain a flat character, but based on my predictions, she will be.

---

My Final Verdict

📶 Biggest strength: It's straightforward writing and easy prose to read, and it's quite a grand epic saga that we're just getting exposed to. I think the setup is going to lead to an even better book 2 and 3.

🪦 Biggest weakness: The exposition in the beginning and the multiple viewpoints without really feeling like the characters stick with you leave you feeling like, "what is the point of all this?" But I think there's a point and I'm willing to see where Gould and Khan will l take us in book 2.

🤯 What stayed with me: Overall, I loved the cozy vibes of the fantastical, heroic, Islamic cultural, and spiritual epicness of this book even though there are some very high stakes (end of the world, evil entity, drug kingpins, government takeover, usurpship, world war) .

⚠️ Would I recommend it? If you are Muslim or someone who appreciates the beauty of Islam, most definitely. If you are Arab or Desi or appreciate those cultures that have dense Muslim populations where the culture is rooted in Islam, I think you will enjoy this book.

🤓 Would I reread this? I think I would, it's definitely a comfort read for me and now that I know the worldbuilding elements, I know I'll be able to go back and enjoy it even more.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Hafsa Hasan.
23 reviews1 follower
June 24, 2026
Thoroughly enjoyable read, perfect for bringing out your inner sufic child. Looking forward to the rest of the series.
Profile Image for Kiran.
87 reviews
Read
June 15, 2026
Tales of Khayaal: Aron offers an ambitious entry into an Islamic-inspired fantasy universe, one with a vision that extends beyond the page. I enjoyed the illustrations and the broader world of Khayaal, and found myself wishing for even more of it within the story itself. I’m curious to see how the universe continues to evolve across future books and mediums.
Profile Image for Elfeeza Ehsan.
243 reviews5 followers
June 15, 2026
Enjoyed this story. Can't wait for the next one
15 reviews
December 12, 2025

The book takes you on a journey with the main character Alifa. The book is a wondrous fantasy and with intriguing stories unfolding with parallels to complex issues in history and world experience , the book offers the reader gentle nudges of self awareness. I found this aspect of the book to be quite profound … reading about the conduits and qualities , made me reflect and be more self aware. Illumined elements of one’s character and soul are made real in a clever way.
I look forward to book 2 !
779 reviews1 follower
June 9, 2026
This story is not even okay--simplistic action; much senseless dialogue; no real character development amongst the many, many introduced; unbelievable battles between monstrous villains, armed soldiers and magical good guys in ways that defy any sense even for fantasy. Religious overtones seem to power the reviews that include 4 and 5 stars, but the very limited numbers of readers suggests little interest in this swing and a miss tale.
2 reviews
January 26, 2026
I really enjoyed the read and the storyline. Sometimes it felt like the story was developing a bit too fast. Would have liked to see the character development more, see how they are growing throughout the story. How way of thinking is changing.
Profile Image for Warda Adeel.
116 reviews1 follower
May 30, 2026
Love the whole concept of conduits and grand conduits and oh tasbeehs and the final standing .
4 reviews1 follower
Read
October 14, 2026
Here’s why we chose *Tales of Khayaal* for our youth book club, and what the students enjoyed about it.

The combination of action, fantasy, and Muslim characters was a big draw. It felt different from the fantasy we usually read; more Islamic in the way the forces of good and evil clashed. The students enjoyed the power system and the idea of the good conduits drawing their abilities from the noor fueled by their dhikr. The virtual-reality-like world that conduits can enter was another cool concept.

We also really wanted to support this effort. A Muslim team creating Islam-inspired fantasy, and adding animation and a video game to it, is exactly the kind of creative work we want our youth to see. For Muslim youth interested in anime, video games, and other creative pursuits, this was an encouraging example of how you can pursue what you love while staying true to your faith and values.

And of course, the students are left with questions! What does Darrick look like under that hood? How do the Zulmi fuel their abilities? Will we meet all four Horsemen (or Horsewomen!) of the Apocalypse in the next book? They’re looking forward to finding out!
7 reviews
December 29, 2025
I am not a sci-fi fan but I thoroughly enjoyed this book and was so disappointed that it ended and book 2 isn't out.

Khan and Gould manage to tell a tale in a context Muslims will clearly recognise without needing to spell out Islam. Being the first book there is so much we don't know of the main characters but despite that I could see character development.

The commentary on modernity is very very clever.

I am hoping this is our version of the Lord of the Rings (yes, I have high hopes!).
Profile Image for Ameerah Langer.
2 reviews
August 12, 2026
I have been wanting this book for years, I just didn't have the title for it. Whole shelves of fantasy set in the Norse-medieval defaults and almost nothing to plunder myth and meaning from Islamic metafiction. Now, with Rehan Khan & Peter Gould at least one space has been filled.

I won't give you spoilers, let's just say that we need a hundred more books of this rigor and literary ability, for ourselves and our growing generations to come.
14 reviews5 followers
September 9, 2026
4.5!! Loveeee the concept!! So rare to see, I love the concept of fantasy inspired by Islamic history and the mysteries of the unseen. The grasp of language and the vivid vivid VIVID imagery, felt like I was watching an animated film.
Profile Image for Jörg Determann.
Author 7 books12 followers
September 8, 2025
In Tales of Khayaal, Assassin’s Creed meets Dune and The Lord of the Rings. Embark on an exciting spiritual adventure in fantastic lands inspired by Islamic history and cultures.
Profile Image for Maruf Yusuf.
Author 9 books
July 28, 2026
First of a kind in marvel level storytelling for Muslims by Muslims. Just finished reading the book 1.

Looking forward to Book 2 this October.
1 review
August 18, 2026
A fantastic read and I’m looking forward to reading book 2!
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews