Мрачни Места

by Gillian Flynn, Џилијан Флин

Во мало мирно гратче каде сите луѓе се познаваат и фино си живеат, се случува грозоморен масакр. Убиена е мајка заедно со своите две мали ќерки. Најмалата ќерка, Либи Деј, успева да побегне низ прозорецот, а братот, Бен Деј, е обвинет за убиството на своето семејство и осуден на доживотен затвор. Либи Деј тогаш имала само седум години и била клучен сведок за затворањето на нејзиниот брат.

Сега, после дваесет и пет години, Либи живурка и си ги исполнува деновите со постојано размислување за самоубиство. Таа сè уште го нема надминато масакрот, а и кој би можел? Но, баш кога мисли дека не може да биде полошо, се појавува група на луѓе кои се убедени дека таа го сместила погрешниот човек во затвор со нејзиното збунето, детско сведочење. Таа сепак не го видела убиецот, само го слушнала неговиот глас. Дали е можно Бен да е невин? Дали постои некоја семејна тајна што Либи би можела да ја открие или таа само се залажува затоа што сака братот да ѝ се врати?

Либи почнува да истражува и сфаќа дека сите во семејството имале по некоја тајна тој ден… а особено Бен.

Кој го извршил масакрот?

Genres: Mystery, Thriller, Fiction, Mystery Thriller, Crime, Suspense, Book Club

345 pages, Paperback

First published April 25, 2009

About the author

Gillian Flynn is an American author and television critic for Entertainment Weekly. She has so far written three novels, Sharp Objects, for which she won the 2007 Ian Fleming Steel Dagger for the best thriller; Dark Places; and her best-selling third novel Gone Girl.

Her book has received wide praise, including from authors such as Stephen King. The dark plot revolves around a serial killer in a Missouri town, and the reporter who has returned from Chicago to cover the event. Themes include dysfunctional families,violence and self-harm.

In 2007 the novel was shortlisted for the Mystery Writers of America Edgar for Best First Novel by an American Writer, Crime Writers' Association Duncan Lawrie, CWA New Blood and Ian Fleming Steel Daggers, winning in the last two categories.

Flynn, who lives in Chicago, grew up in Kansas City, Missouri. She graduated at the University of Kansas, and qualified for a Master's degree from Northwestern University.

Review Quotes:
"Gillian Flynn is the real deal, a sharp, acerbic, and compelling storyteller with a knack for the macabre."
–Stephen King

Reviews

[Emily May · Rating 5 out of 5]

“I have a meanness inside me, real as an organ. Slit me at my belly and it might slide out, meaty and dark, drop on the floor so you could stomp on it.”

I highly recommend reading this whilst sitting in the sun with plenty of happy people around you (as I did) - that way you can avoid contracting something evil and nasty from its pages, and also avoid losing any hope you had for humanity.

Okay, sorry, I make it sound so negative when actually this book is pretty fantastic if you can stomach the horrors within. I ate this up in a couple of days, finding every opportunity to read that I could... Flynn certainly has a talent for dragging you into her stories and having them take you over until you find out just what the hell is going on.

As much as I enjoyed its dark predecessor - Sharp Objects - I think Dark Places was, for me, a more complex and well-developed mystery.

I had many theories as to what was going on and all of them were wrong. You know, I honestly think that writing a mystery story must be the most difficult of all, because the reader is your enemy. Most readers of mystery stories will analyse the information they're given, pull it apart, and try desperately to solve the mystery before the characters do - and yet, if they are successful, they feel disappointed. For an author to manage to pull out something both surprising and convincingly real at the end of all this, they have to have a talent for it.

Dark Places alternates between the present day and 1985 when Ben Day allegedly massacred three members of his family, his sister - Libby - being the only one to escape and testify as a witness, sending Ben to a life in prison. Now, after years of living on the donations made by concerned members of the public, Libby Day has finally run out of money and is forced to earn some cash by making an appearance at a group meeting where the members believe Ben is innocent. At first, Libby is willing to write them off as crazy fanatics with a grisly obsession... but as more information is presented to her, she starts to question what really happened all those years ago.

The story is told from three main points of view and, to say I'm not a fan of multiple perspectives, I thought it was done excellently. Patty Day is an exhausted mother-of-four who starts to fear her son is becoming involved in satanic rituals; torn between wanting to protect him and being a little afraid of what his behaviour means, we begin to question through her eyes whether the heavy metal-loving loner could really have it in him to become a murderer.

Then we have Ben Day's point of view. Being inside his mind is a little frightening - we see how his thoughts become increasingly dark, how just wanting to have something normal can lead to the most abnormal behaviour... but does that mean he would really murder his family?

And, of course, there is Libby Day. Libby Day is the reason I think I enjoy Flynn's novels so much. She is so imperfect, complex, selfish, violent... but somehow you manage to stay on her side. I have no idea how the author manages this, but I've always loved a protagonist with issues, the kind of issues that make them lash out in ways that would make you hate them if you weren't inside their head, understanding them. She does some horrible things and, though you don't necessarily forgive her for them, you are able to see why.

If you're okay reading about filth, gore, and underage sex, then you should dive into this mystery straight away and immerse yourself in the disturbing but awesome mental workings of Gillian Flynn.

Last updated: April 2016

Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Youtube | Store

[karen · Rating 4 out of 5]

i was not a lovable child, and i'd grown into a deeply unlovable adult. draw a picture of my soul, and it'd be a scribble with fangs.

gillian flynn sure does love writing about horrible people doing horrible things.and i sure do love reading about them. especially because she isn't one of those writers coasting on shock value and "can you belieeeeeve a delicate flower of a woman is writing this??" but she can really tell a story and i, for one, was completely surprised and pleased by the ending of this one.

libby's mother and two older sisters were murdered when she was seven years old, apparently in some sort of satanic bloodbath masterminded by her older brother ben. she escaped and was instrumental in getting him put behind bars, in one of those "lean on the kid and make them say what needs to be said to convict someone" situations. twenty-five years later, she is a mess - a flat broke kleptomaniac, pissed off at the world, and terrible at any social expectations, until she is approached by a group whose specialty is studying violent crimes, trading memorabilia, constructing alternate scenarios of horrorshows; criminal tourists. and libby pumps them for cash while promising to look into the crime she lived through, and reconnect with her brother and father in order to solve a crime she believes has already been solved.

but it is far from over, man. there are all kinds of things she is going to learn about that night, and about her family, and about her own self.

and it's going to get creepy.

it is great, great, great. it is not perfect - i personally had some difficulties with character motivation and behavior, but it doesn't matter because it all works within flynn's dirty little world, and she manages to convince you that these characters are going to do what they are going to do within their need-spheres, and just because it doesn't make sense to youuuuu, just be thankful for that, yeah?

it is really chilling stuff - oh, god - remember the frenzy of satanic finger-pointing of the 80's? there were cults everywhere, right? all the animal sacrifices and the heavy metal music and the teenage killers under the spell of the dark one? and even though none of it ever panned out into anything, that frenzy, that imagined threat was so convincing to so many pearl-clutching mothers. it would be adorable now, except for reading this book, and remembering that actual people were accused and convicted because of half-whispered urban legends. oops.

it's a great bloody crime story. its pacing is sublime; she always knows just how far to take the reader before switching up the focus to cause the maximum amount of anticipatory distress, she knows how to cover her tracks and how to deliver the most effective kaboom of an ending. and you might not like any of these characters, but you will still sympathize with them, despite your better instincts.

i seem to have run out of gillian flynn books.
more, please.

come to my blog!

[NickReads · Rating 3 out of 5]

yo this book freaky, Ben real creepy and Libby kinda dumb

[Kristin (KC) · Rating 5 out of 5]

*4.5 Stars*

Gillian Flynn scares me.

But it’s a good scare! A keep-you-up-all-night-anxiously-reading-because-closing-the-book-is-not-an-option kinda scare.

If you thought Gone Girl was twisted, make room for Dark Places because this suspenseful thriller takes “freaky” to a whole *nuther* level.

I went in thinking I was fully prepared.

I wasn’t.

This book is so astoundingly demented, it truly makes me wonder exactly how Miss Flynn thinks up such bold scenarios. The plot is so “out-there”, yet way too close - creating a palpable level of discomfort for the reader—but I, for one, could not look away.

This author knows how to stretch the creep-factor to its limits, just short of over-the-top, delivering a crazy, yet still fathomable plot. She masters the art of description until the details begin materializing, and suddenly you're visualizing them whether you’re trying to or not.

Libby Day. What a truly unique, unforgettable character. So mentally and emotionally deranged, you cant help but want to reach out to her…(with a six foot pole, of course;)

Because she feels so damn real. Her thoughts, her actions—so cynical and bitter. But who wouldn't be after experiencing the torment she has.

I assumed everything bad in the world could happen, because everything bad in the world already did happen.

Libby’s family was brutally murdered in their home, but little seven-year old Libby somehow survived the gruesome massacre. Largely due to Libby’s testimony, her wallflower brother becomes tried and convicted for these satanic murders.

Now Libby is a grown woman who is beginning to question the details of that fateful night long ago. A night she has buried deep inside, desperate to forget. But there are things that refuse to be forgotten…

And so begins the suspenseful journey, as the plot glides through past and present, alternating between a first and third person perspective—Libby serving as the story’s narrator.

And her unhappy, defeated voice is one I will not forget.

With this particular story, I think the writing won me over even more so than the plot. Although I was completely sucked into the mystery, marathon-guessing like it was my job, the ending somehow left me ever-so-slightly disappointed. It’s difficult to place my finger on why. I wanted BIG, but maybe this was a little too big? I’m still unsure. In any case, this author has a genius grasp on storytelling, and I will gladly read anything she writes.

But for now, I’m off to read something happy(ish)…

Book Stats:
▪  Genre/Category: Mystery/Thriller
▪  Graphic Nature: Racy and bold
▪ Romance: Twisted
▪  Characters: Unlovable but unforgettable
▪  Plot: A twisty and suspenseful murder mystery
▪ Writing: Flawless, poetic, bold, and edgy
▪ POV: Switches between 3rd and 1st person: heroine
▪  Cliffhanger: None/Standalone

[Miranda Reads · Rating 4 out of 5]

"I was raised feral, and I mostly stayed that way."

Libby Day is famous for all the wrong reasons.

When she was seven years old when her mother and two sisters were murdered at the height of the Satanic Panic in her small town in Kansas.

All the evidence pointed to Ben, Libby's older brother. The same older brother that Libby adored and idolized.

And with that, Libby's life came crashing down, and it hasn't stopped falling since.

"I was not a lovable child, and I'd grown into a deeply unlovable adult."

And now, 25 years later, Libby is scraping down rock bottom.

And just when life seems bleakest, the Kill Club approaches her.

"I felt something loosen in me, that shouldn't have loosened. A stitch come undone."

The Kill Club goes chasing after unsolved murders and are obsessed with notorious crimes. They're willing pay Libby to look into her own past.

They're convinced that her brother is innocent and the more she talks to them, the more she sees their point...but...if that's truly the case, why did he go so willingly into prison?

Whewww....this book was wild.

Each of Gillian's books are so unsettling in their unique way - and this one was no exception.

We follow several different perspectives - modern-day Libby, Ben on the day-of the murder and Libby's mom (also on the murder-day).

Despite the book having so many different narrators, each one of them felt so distinct and I was wholly engrossed.

They were really well balanced, with each jump in perspective giving a slightly different piece to the puzzle and watching the mystery unravel was crazy.

This book truly was amazing - highly recommended for the Flynn Fan!

Audiobook Comments
Rebecca Lowman read this one and wow, she brought this book to life. Her timing, her pacing, her tone and inflection - it was all so spot on. Loved it!

YouTube | Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Facebook | Snapchat @miranda_reads

[Tatiana · Rating 4 out of 5]

As seen on The Readventurer

Seriously, what goes on in Gillian Flynn's head? She writes the freakiest stuff. Sharp Objects was nasty enough, and Dark Places is just as vile. Luckily for her, I (along with millions of people) like vile now and then.

Libby Day is a sole survivor of a horrendous massacre. Her mother and two sisters were brutally killed one winter night and, mostly thanks to Libby's testimony, the murders were attributed to Libby's older brother Ben, an alleged active Satan worshiper. Now, almost 25 years later, 32-year old Libby is out of money that had been donated to her by well-wishers over the years and must look for a new source of income. She settles on helping the Kill Club (a group of obsessed women who believe in Ben's innocence) to re-investigate the murders, for money of course. As Libby starts talking to various people involved in the original investigation at the Kill Club's request, her strong belief in Ben's guilt starts wavering...

I am fairly certain now that Gillian Flynn's "schtick" is writing about VERY BAD women. We are presented with an array of them in Dark Places - they lie to get attention, they abuse, they blackmail, they mooch, they kill, they are weak and pathetic. It is, no doubt, a novel approach to women empowerment. If women are equal to men, they can be equally despicable, right? The men are no better - they are good-for-nothing losers mostly. What I am getting at is that you can hardly find any likable characters in this book, which for many readers is a must (not me though).

The story itself is gruesome. Prepare yourself for brutal killings, molestation, bullying, Satan worshiping, drugs and underage sex. Some parts are so tough to read, I had to put the book aside for awhile.

But underneath the filth, there is a great mystery - well-paced, suspenseful, full of red herrings, it keeps you guessing until the very last moment who the perpetrator is.

Just like Sharp Objects, this book is absolutely not for everybody. But I thoroughly enjoyed this freaky thriller and will wait with anticipation for the release of Gillian Flynn's next macabre mystery.

[Kavita · Rating 1 out of 5]

Wow, I am flabbergasted! Is this what people are reading in the name of 'mystery' these days? A boring book, with unpleasant and unrealistic characters and an unbelievable resolution. The protagonist is Libby Day, a woman whose family was murdered when she was a child, and she was the one who gave evidence that put her brother behind bars for these murders. Twenty four years later, when she is contacted by a murder club, which offers to pay money to her to help them investigate, she accepts the assignment. So starts a dangerous journey back into the past. An interesting premise, but very, very badly executed.

First, the protagonist is not someone I was rooting for. I didn't need her to be likeable, but she wasn't just unlikeable, she was positively annoying. She is without a single redeeming feature, which would make a dark character interesting and realistic. And is she a whiner! I can't stand whiners. She makes her way through the book, consistently whining from one situation to the other. And not just her, ALL the other characters in the book are also consistently vile, nasty and caricature villains. It's like the author thinks that making people completely nasty is being realistic. It's not. Ever read A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier? It's about a young boy in a war-torn country taking up arms, but it's not relentlessly dark. There are light moments when good things happen, and it's a TRUE story. This is where Flynn really fails in making her novel realistic.

Second, I am not really a fan of graphic violence and nastiness, described in unnecessary detail. Especially, when it's only fiction. I mean, there are 4-5 descriptions of vomiting in the book. would people look at vomit in such detail in real life? It's hardly realistic from any point of view. The author adds scene after scene of violence and depravity merely for shock value. That's just lazy writing. There was a completely unnecessary chapter consisting almost entirely of butchering a cow. Which did not add to the plot at all. Neither did the entire Satanism angle make any sense. Though there was a panic at this time about Satanic ritual abuse, it did not really exist !

The resolution takes place in two parts since there are two murderers. One of them follows to a logical, if uninteresting, conclusion, while the other just appears out of nowhere, just tacked on for even more shock value. I am really disappointed that after wading through pages of reading about people throwing up, taking drugs and cleaning up refuse in great detail, this flimsy, unrealistic, tacky ending is what I got!

And my final, but really my most important grouse, what's with Flynn and women making false allegations of sexual abuse? There is a side plot that is tacked on for no reason - a young girl makes false allegations of abuse against Ben. Considering that she did pretty much the same with Gone Girl and is an incredibly popular author for some reason, it's worrying what message she is consistently sending across. With ALL the depravity and nastiness among the characters, surely it could have been a real case of abuse? Or is the author one of those who think that 'most' cases of molestation are false? Is she a member of MRA?

There are a couple of positive things. For one thing, the research is so detailed that in a different book, it would have been a real pleasure. She makes plenty of references to real murders that took place, and as someone interested in True Crime, I found that a great addition. Another is that you can see that Flynn has a talent for writing and has great ideas. Too bad, she chose to tell a boring story with uninteresting characters.

I really wouldn't recommend this book, but considering it's such a huge success, maybe I am the odd one out? I certainly think it has some major concerns, and I completely call bullshit on the 'it's realistic!' viewpoint. It's not.

[Sue Bridehead (A Pseudonym) · Rating 5 out of 5]

Normally I wouldn't give a genre book like this a 5-star review, because I'm picky and controlling about handing out major praise. How could a crime/mystery be as good as, say, Thomas Hardy or Alice Munro? Apples and oranges.

But I just finished this about five minutes ago, and it made me gasp. It's so good -- a well-paced page-turner, beautifully wrought. I literally couldn't put it down for longer than a couple hours at a time once I picked it up (with the exception of sleep).

According to her Acknowledgements, Flynn did significant research to write this, and it shows -- it's assured, detailed, and often heart-wrenching. There are no loose ends, and when they tie up, they tie up so naturally, unfolding at such a realistic pace, that you feel like this could really have happened. Nothing -- except maybe for the Kill Club, the ball that gets the narrator Libby's investigation rolling -- is farfetched.

For what this is -- a genre novel echoing In Cold Blood, crossed with southern gothic -- it's superior. But even outside the mystery/crime genre, this book is a better, more skillful, funnier, more emotional and more fascinating read than most of the literary fiction I've read lately.

Libby Day is a fantastic heroine/anti-heroine; real, three dimensional, funny, dark, bent and broken, but not beyond repair. I so enjoyed taking this ride with her and am sorry the book had to end. This is very high praise coming from me, because I read constantly and I hardly ever have this feeling about anything. I can't wait to read "Sharp Objects," though I'm dreading it at the same time, because I really can't afford to let another book usurp all my time for three straight days.

[chan ☆ · Rating 4 out of 5]

i do NOT like the ending of this book. maybe that's just me and thrillers, idk.

but otherwise this was fantastically told.

[Kemper · Rating 3 out of 5]

As someone who grew up in rural Kansas and has lived in the suburbs of Kansas City for the last fourteen years, I made my peace long ago with the fact that I don’t reside in one of the hip places on the map. The only Kansas based things that have worked their way into popular culture are In Cold Blood and that goddamn Wizard of Oz. (As a Kansan, I listen to everyone I’ve met from somewhere else do the “I guess you’re not in Kansas anymore! Ha ha!” thing and can barely resist the urge to punch them in the throat.)

But it seems like every book, film or tv show is set in either New York or L.A. with a few other places like Miami, Chicago or Boston thrown in now and then. I think half the reason I’m such a huge fan of John Sandford is that most of his books are set in Minneapolis, and he’s shown that there actually is life in the Midwest. I know that the folks who run the various entertainment industries like to talk about getting us off our tractors long enough to sample their wares, but it seems like the only attempts to include us in the stories either mock us as morons or sentimentalize small town life to vomit inducing degrees.

Gillian Flynn is originally from Kansas City, and her first book was very well received so I was excited to hear that Dark Places was set in both rural Kansas and K.C. Of course, it involved the slaughter of a family on the prairie, going back to the In Cold Blood thing, but I’ll take what I can get. I was excited to get one of the rare chances to read a story set in the place I live.

Unfortunately, Flynn didn’t do her old hometown any favors because it seems like she singled out every depressing aspect like the run down old stockyards and warehouse district that’s got some of the worst urban decay in the area. Or I-70 between K.C. and St. Louis that is filled with tacky billboards and low rent strip clubs. One restaurant that she uses as a location recently burned to the ground, and its owner is charged with arson. I know she was telling a story about the aftermath of a brutal crime and how it screwed up the sole survivor, but damn! Would it have killed her to have a character pop down to Power & Light for a drink? The K.C. tourism board would have thanked her for it.

Enough of my bitching. About the book: Back in 1985 on a rundown Kansas farm, a mother and two daughters are brutally killed. Young Libby Day manages to survive by fleeing the house, and it’s her testimony that convicts her fifteen year old brother Ben of the crime. Supposedly, Ben was a Satan worshipping freak who went shotgun and axe happy one winter night.

In the present, thirty-one year old Libby is a freaking mess. She doesn’t make it out of bed some days, she’s a kleptomaniac, she has no friends, and she usually can’t even manage to take care of simple things like remembering to buy cat food, wash her sheets or fill her ice cube trays.

Libby has been living off the trust fund that started when donations poured in after the murders, but the money is about to run out. Desperate, Libby agrees to a paid appearance for the Kill Club, a group of amateur investigators who think that her brother is innocent. Libby doesn’t even want to think about her brother, but offers of more cash get her motivated to start visiting people connected to the murders. Suddenly, Libby isn’t so sure that Ben was the killer after all.

The story is told in two parallel ways. We get Libby’s first person account of her activities in the present, while a third person narrative of the last day of her family gives us the background of what happened in 1985.

This is a character based mystery, and Flynn does a great job with both the struggling Libby in the present and the family in 1985. The stark reality of a poor farm family in the mid-’80s along with Libby’s pathetic life as an adult makes for a pretty depressing story, but Flynn really sucks the reader into the plight of everyone involved. I was somewhat let down by the ending, but I can’t say much about that without spoilers.

While this book probably won’t convince anyone to move to Kansas, it’s a good read for those who don’t mind a raw story about just how much life can sometimes suck, even if you don’t get chopped to bits with an axe.

[jessica yeung · Rating 4 out of 5]

my first experience with gillian flynn was a minor disaster. i had no idea how dark and disturbing her stories would be, so i was nowhere close to being in the right mental state for that kind of thing. now knowing the twisted things she is capable of writing, i found this book to be quite thrilling!

ive also found GF has quite a slow paced style of writing but, with this particular story, i thought it worked really well. it helps develop the characters, establish a timeline of day of the crime, and provide little clues and hints along the way. the ending isnt quite as shocking as i may have liked - with the slow pace and good details, its easy to see where things are headed - but i thought it was an ending suitable for the story.

overall, im so relieved i didnt dislike this as much as ‘sharp objects’ and now im even more excited to pick up ‘gone girl!’

↠ 3.5 stars

[Nataliya · Rating 3 out of 5]

Lesson learned # 1: Gillian Flynn is excellent at creating unpleasant characters and disturbing situations.

“I was not a lovable child, and I'd grown into a deeply unlovable adult. Draw a picture of my soul, and it'd be a scribble with fangs.”

Lesson learned # 2: Reading her books in a dark apartment at 3 am is a big making-skin-crawl mistake.

Dark Places is a book capable of leaving a nasty aftertaste and vague uncomfortable feeling for days after finishing it. I strongly suspect it is its intended effect. For which I almost grudgingly¹ have to say to Flynn - nice work there.

¹Why grudgingly? Because this book made me feel torn. When I think of it, it's almost like I think of two separate books: a bit contrived and shoddily resolved murder mystery as well as an excellently disturbing voyage into the unpleasant recesses of human mind.

These two impressions of mine seem to be split almost exclusively along the framework of the story: the unsatisfying bit being mostly the story of present-day Libby Day, told in the first person as she struggles to find the answers to the worst thing that happened in her life; and the unpleasant but good parts of the story set a quarter of the century prior, seen through the eyes of Libby's mother and brother.



Libby Day's family was brutally slaughtered 25 years ago, and it was Libby's testimony - a confused, clearly coached recollection of a seven-year-old child - that landed her fifteen-year-old brother behind bars for life. Except that now Libby - adult and aimlessly floating through life in a quite unpleasantly pathetic fashion - has reasons to doubt her brother's guilt, and, shaken up from her stupor by a plot contrivance, is on a search to unearth old well-hidden ghosts and uncover what actually happened on a cold January day 25 years ago in a middle-of-nowhere town, Missouri.

Yes, the murders themselves, regardless of how gruesome they may be, are not the disturbing part, not at all. The nastiness comes from the people involved - Libby herself, her maybe-innocent-maybe-not brother, her repulsive good-for-nothing father, and a few more key players of that fateful, as it turned out, day.

Libby's story - unfortunately, it's not that great. Mind it, the actual character of Libby Day is quite interesting. She is pathetic in her almost parasitic existence, and knows her own unlikability very well. But the storyline itself - it does not stand out that much, and Libby's inevitable waking up from her couple of decades of stupor feels a bit contrived. The interactions between Libby and everyone else around her are uninspired. It's mediocre, and gets not even a second thought from me. Bleh.



Where the story shines is Ben Day's sections. The maybe-innocent then fifteen-year-old boy from a poor farm family, confused and dangerously naive on some things, longing to be accepted and be somebody to such an extent that he's dangerously balanced on a sharp edge, willing to passively drift somewhere borne along in the stronger current of those around him, and getting progressively and disturbingly angrier with each page.

It's Ben's downward dangerous slide that kept me awake in the wee hours of the night, turning pages, feeling the empty hollowness deep in my stomach as the events were taking their merciless turn, and making me feel torn and unsettled. Ben Day, dangerous in how lost he is, frightening in how far into darkness his mind slides, surrounded by unhealthy twisted horrible creepy nastiness all around him. His story made me want to have my faith in humanity somehow reaffirmed, preferably in the bright sunshine with a cocktail in my hand, maybe by the poolside - anything to take the nasty darkness away.

Overall, thanks to Ben's story, it was a memorable read. It's far from ideal, yes, but memorable nevertheless. Now I do feel compelled to get my hands on the one remaining Gillian Flynn book I haven't read, and check out her future literary offerings. She has such potential, and I'm looking forward to one day seeing it fully realized.

3.5/5 stars.

------------------
Old 'review':

Still unsure about the rating.
Reason: brain still a bit disturbed and shorted out.
Decision to finish this book in the dark apartment at 3 am was, well, questionable.

[zuza_zaksiazkowane · Rating 1 out of 5]

Nie potrafię wyrazić słowami, jak bardzo mi się ta książka nie podobała xd
Czuję, że straciłam ostatnie komórki w mózgu czytając ją. Zagadka kryminalna - bezsensowna i nieistniejąca koniec końców. Bohaterowie - nie było ani jednego, który byłby dobrze wykreowany. Może Libby, ona była najciekawsza, ale jest tak naprawdę tylko tłem w swojej własnej historii.
Wymyślcie najbardziej absurdalne zakończenie kryminału, a i tak będzie bardziej wiarygodne, niż to co się tu działo 🫠
I okropnie wulgarna. Nie mam problemu z wulgaryzmami, ale to była przesada.
Ehhh a chciałam tylko drugie „Ostre przedmioty”

[Alejandro · Rating 5 out of 5]

Gripping and entertained!


DAYS GO BY

You gotta believe in something, right? Everyone has their thing.

This is my second novel by Gillian Flynn, and now I am realizing that I have been reading them backwards, I mean in the opposite publishing order, but this has been due mainly the order of film adaptations. However, I won’t wait until having any film adaptation of Sharp Objects, to read that one. I do hope to read it in the following months.

My reading experience with Gone Girl wasn’t any good as I would expect, BUT I have to admit that it has a really unique narration style making it worhty to be in anyone’s TBR book list. And odd enough I enjoyed A LOT the film adaptation of that one, while I watched after reading the book and taking in account that it’s basically the same story, but I enjoyed it better in the movie format.

I wasn’t sure how much I’d enjoy this book, Dark Places, but happily I can say that the reading experience with this novel was truly wonderful. Maybe it lacks of more intense action at the climax (I won't spoil it, don't worry), but definitely I enjoy a lot the whole reading experience of the book.

I am truly glad of deciding to read it. I still have to watch the movie (at the moment that I am writing this review) but I hope to be able to watch it soon.


HAVE A NICE DAY

And every single person in this case lies, is lying, did lie.

Dark Places is the tragic and grim story of the Day Family, told in the voices of Libby Day (main character), Patty Day (her mother) and Ben Day (his brother).

Libby’s family had just the opposite a nice day, like 25 years ago...

...her mother and her two other sisters were murdered and Ben, his brother was charged with the killings, getting a conviction where Libby’s testimony was a key factor for it.

Now, Libby is an adult woman, and very soon she will be totally penniless. She got many donations around the country (United States), mainly at the momento of the tragedy, and she has been able to dispose of the money too good. She never studied, never worked, never did anything.

Libby is exposed to a singular kind of fans about unsolved murders or cases where the convictions have something wrong. A Killing Club, reuniting former cops, former detectives and even regular people interested about police cases. She is shocked to know that there are too many people believing that his brother is innocent, and her own doubts about what really happened that terrible night, 25 years ago, are starting to increase big.

Between her personal reasons of wanting to know what really happened that dark night and her current struggling economic status, Libby thinks that she can kill two birds with one stone, since this “Killing Club” is willing to pay her enough money to go and interview the people involved in the case and since she is Libby Day, there is a high potential that that people would open in an easier way to her than strangers.

Readers will get to know, slowly but methodically, exactly what happened that terrible day, having chapters with the voice of Libby right now, but also the voices of Patty and Ben, but those two set back in the past, on that fateful day. Present and past will be intermixed offering the pieces of the puzzle that the readers want to put together, BUT it won’t be easy since human beings are natural liars and the Day Family isn’t better if not worse.


MAKE MY DAY

That’s what they were: a home past the expiration date.

It’s obvious that the case of the Day Family’s murders wasn’t handle as it should, but it’s amazing how easy an alibi can be stated. Unless there is some evidence putting you in the crime scene, it seems that basically you only need to convince somebody else to say that you were with him/her at the moment of the crime, and bam! You’re off the hook!

Nobody is perfect, but certainly the Day Family never tried any hard to be one. You will have an unique access to the minds and feeling of three of the main members of the family, but also, thanks to them, you will get to know the rest of members of this broken kindred.

You won’t have heroes here. Only survivors. And certainly when money is scarse, the Day Family doesn’t hesitate to make crazy hard calls.
Blood is thicker than water, so families’ bonds are strong to smash, but also, families aren’t a static things but in constant evolution, and due that bloods can become even more thicker, specially if something isn’t quite right (to say the least) in your head.


SEIZE THE DAY

Everyone who keeps a secret itches to tell it.

A mystery is something great, it’s something wonderful, since a mystery always is screaming to be solved. A mystery exists to be solved...

...but a secret?

A secret is something intimidating, it’s something maddening, since a secret always is silently screaming to remain unspoken, hidden. Knowing about the existence of a secret is a contradiction itself.

Therefore, people do their best to keep the secrets, but it’s something too heavy, so, to lighten some of the burden, people become crafty to “expose” the secret at plain sight, but in a clever way.

Even dark places aren’t enough to keep a secret.

Meet the Day Family...

...at your own risk!

[Dan · Rating 5 out of 5]

When person or persons unknown murdered her entire family, seven year old Libby Day managed to escape and fingered her brother Ben as the killer. Now, decades later, she's dysfunctional and nearly penniless, and after meeting some true crime enthusiasts, isn't so sure her brother was the murderer after all. Can Libby discover the truth?

After dodging Gillian Flynn for years in the wake of Gone Girl, I finally caved it when this showed up in one of my daily cheap ebook emails. Gillian Flynn, where have you been all my life?

Dark Places is a mystery but it's one of those mysteries that also happens to be brutal and very well written, like Winter's Bone or something along those lines. Libby Day is a broken adult, having never recovered from her mother and sisters being murdered by her brother. Or were they? Libby cracks open the past like a pinata and takes a look at what falls out: not candy but a lot of ugliness, more like a brood of cockroaches.

Since I live very near nowhere's asshole, rural settings always resonate with me because I understand living miles from everywhere and what could happen in the dark of night. Libby wakes up to the sounds of her family being slaughtered. Not exactly your feel-good read.

I love that instead of some notion of heroism, Libby gets involved in her family's murder because she's nearly run out of money and has no idea how to function as a normal adult. She's a kleptomaniac and has burned every familial bridge she ever trod upon. Lyle and the Kill Club light the spark but it's the lack of money that provides the fuel, at first, anyway.

Gillian Flynn crafts one hell of a mystery yarn but it's her characters that show she's more than just another mystery lover. Ben and Libby are sympathetic figures, despite both being deeply flawed. Still, she makes you understand their motivations, making them seem all too realistic. The parallel structure of the book builds the suspense. I had no idea what actually happened that night until it was pretty much spelled out for me, which I love in a mystery.

There's not much else I want to say for fear of giving something away. Dark Places. Five stars. Read it!

[Rincey · Rating 3 out of 5]

Nothing like reading Gillian Flynn during the holidays to make you feel significantly better about your own family

Watch me discuss this book in my December wrap up: https://youtu.be/ReIV4UHlHCI

[Jln · Rating 3 out of 5]

Meh.

Well, unfortunately this wasn't the page turner Gone Girl was for me. The most interesting thing about this book in my opinion was Libby's character. Where Gone Girl started out slow and then got really good, this one started out amazing and then went flat. I do like that Gillian Flynn creates these screwed up characters and I found Libby to be somewhat entertaining. Ms. Flynn isn't known for writing likable characters to be inspired by, but Libby was interesting. Her emotional growth was kind of stunted because of an event in her childhood, and she just sort of drifts through life and survives, but doesn't really live.



I can't really say anything about the story because it's a mystery and I don't want to spoil anything. I felt like a lot of this book was filler, so that the mystery could be drug out until the end. There were so many things that were unnecessarily overly described. At one point there was a whole page dedicated to describing fox tail weeds. This is why for some of this book I was bored out of my mind. While reading this, I seemed to spend a lot of time thinking about my Christmas to do list, or wondering what I should have for lunch.

Overall, it was just Ok. I didn't hate it, but it didn't blow my mind either.

[Baba · Rating 4 out of 5]

2021 read: When Libby Day was seven, she provided the damning testimony that put her brother, Ben, in prison for life, for the brutal Satanic(!) ritual murders of their mother and sisters. Today, barely eking out a living, Libby is approached by a 'True Crime' community who are convinced that Ben is innocent of the often in the public eye murders. Having run out of her 'tell-all memoir' money, Libby has no choice but to start investigating the murders at the behest of this club... and very quickly begins to see that every single person involved is an unreliable source and possible suspect or accessory!

This was a nicely balanced read of alternating chapters set in the present going forward, and set in the past a few days before the murders leading up to them; which allowed me to reach the truth not only at the same time as Libby, but also at the same time as the backstory being told. A very likeable read that fully engaged me with an interesting off-beat main protagonists in Libby and her 'True Crime' club ally. Lots of triggering issues are written about in detail, from child abuse through to Satanic rituals, so be warned! It's always nice to see a mega best selling writer who actually can tell a good story from beginning to end; 8 out of 12, Four Star read.

[Andrew Smith · Rating 4 out of 5]

I didn’t like Gone Girl, which I though started quite well but went rapidly down hill from half way. So I approached this one with caution. I shouldn’t have worried, though. I could tell from the start that this was going to be right up my alley. Libby is a lazy kleptomaniac who is living off the inherited life insurance from her hideously slaughtered family – well, who wouldn’t warm to a character like that!

Libby’s brother Ben is the only other survivor of the massacre, and he is in prison, having already been convicted of the murders. When we meet out heroine she’s living in a dump and just about to reach the bottom of the money barrel. She’s got a few dollars left and an offer to meet up with a ghoulish collection of Kill Club members who want to pick over her memories of the tragedy for a fee of $500. She meets with them, hating the experience but is tempted to help one of the members who is intent on delving deeper into the history of the case – as long as he keeps the cash flowing.

The narrative is told primarily first person, through the eyes of Libby, but is interspersed with flash back third party accounts that focus on Libby’s mother and on Ben. As we learn more about both characters, the plot thickens. I loved the characterisation and pacing of the story. It wasn’t hurried, and the author lingered over details that served to deepen the reader’s knowledge of and appreciation for the characters. I like that kind of focus. It draws me into a story. And I was drawn in. I was enjoying the journey too much to worry about the destination, which is just as well as it turned out to be the best bit.

In Gone Girl, Flynn threw in twist after twist to the point it became akin to a Brian Rix farce. As a result, I lost all belief in that tale. Here, she doesn’t complicate a simple story until we’ve got nine tenths of the way through it, at which point she chucks in an over-engineered and highly improbable ending. It’s as if she’s lost faith in the value of the tale as she was telling it and felt she needed a big finish. Or maybe she had eyes on a big movie deal and thought a surprise ending would seal it. Either way, I feel she’d have been better served to have finished the book in a manner more suited to the feel of the rest of the book. Less would have most definitely been more.

That said, I still feel this book is well worth reading if only to enjoy the brilliant way Libby is brought to life. My favourite line? Well, it’s delivered as she goes ‘souvenir’ hunting whist visiting a house. As she spots and pockets a thermometer (the items she stole were always a random collection of useless tat) she muses that she’d always wanted one: when I take to my bed it’s good to know whether I’m sick or just lazy. I’ll miss you, Libby.

[Anne · Rating 4 out of 5]

Gillian Flynn excels in telling stories about awful people.
And Libby Day is...less than likable.



Partially because her emotional growth seemingly stopped in early childhood when her mother and sisters were brutally murdered by an intruder. To add insult to injury, the intruder convicted of the crime was her teenage brother.
CONVICTED ON HER (somewhat coached) TESTIMONY.
Supposedly, her brother had gotten in with some high school Satanists, started listening to heavy metal music, dyed his hair black, and then savagely murdered his mother and younger sisters.
As you do.



Libby has been sloshing through life ever since, living off the funds donated to her by do-gooders.
And now those funds have dried up.
What's a bitter, anxiety-riddled gal to do? Get a job? <--not likely!
Well, luckily for her, there is a group of special weirdos who will pay for her to show up and talk about her experience as the only survivor of that night's violent crime. People who collect murder memorabilia instead of baseball cards or comic books.



And now they've offered to pay her to track down and interview the people who were close to the action the night her family was slaughtered, because they don't believe her brother did it.
The little girl who accused her brother of molesting her had a father with a bad temper. Could he have been looking for revenge? Her drunken father was always trying to squeeze money out of her mother. Did he squeeze too hard that night? What about the sleezy loan manager who was always threatening to take their farm? Did the cops get it right the first time, and her angry, sullen brother was exactly who she thought he was all along?
Or were there players on the board that no one was aware of, who might just have gotten away with murder?



In an effort to drum up a bit of cash and not face the rigors of a real job, she goes on a journey through the past that reignites the danger in the present.
And maybe changes everything she thought she knew about that night.



A batshit ride with a cast of damaged outcasts. What's not to love?
Recommended.

[Brooke · Rating 4 out of 5]

Well. I can't really say that I liked this book. None of the characters are likable, including the main character. Libby Day's family was killed by her brother when she was 7. By the time she hits 30, she's still 7 inside, her inner growth stunted by the tragedy. She can barely take care of herself, has never had a job, and suddenly the money that strangers donated out of charity over the years is down to about $900. To replenish her bank account, Libby grudgingly agrees to pimp herself out to a group of people obsessed with the Day murders and with proving that her brother isn't really guilty. Along the way, she starts to have doubts herself and the real story unfolds between her present-day sleuthing and flashbacks to her mother's and brother's point-of-view from the day of the killings.

As I said, no one is likable. I wanted to slap everyone, and I found it impossible to feel any sympathy towards Libby despite her trauma. Gillian Flynn is disturbingly good at creating characters who are beyond messed up and irritating, to the point where you start to wonder what sort of inner darkness she harbors (on the contrary, her Author's Notes always make her sound very well adjusted. At the end of this book, she charmingly promises her mom that she will someday write a book where the mother is neither evil nor killed). Nothing about the dark story that's filled with hopelessness and screw-ups made me feel good about reading it. To use a well-worn phrase, it was almost like a train wreck.

I will hasten to add though, a very well-written train wreck, one with fabulous pacing that rushes along at a breakneck speed and refuses to let you take a breather. It gripped me, kept me guessing, and totally sucked me in with the great voice that Flynn gave the unlikable Libby. I almost felt like I WAS Libby, and it reminded me of the single-minded focus that Tana French's books inspired, where I had to almost physically extract myself from the book once I was finished. I think I liked French's books much better, but I'm very glad to keep coming across such talented women in the mystery genre.

Not a beach book. Not a feel-good story of the year. But damn highly recommended.

[Mandy · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is by far my favorite book ever! I started this knowing how much I enjoyed Gone Girl and when I got started with this I couldn't put it down. My soul bonded to this book from the first word. Page turner and an unforgettable ride. A hell of a ride. The movie is just as good and I can rarely say that about books and movies. Ugh, great, spectacular, amazing, eventful, mind-blowing, utterly fantastic. Read this book!!!!!! After reading Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl I knew I had to read her other novels. I AM SO GLAD I DID! Out of her three novels, Dark Places is by far my favorite. This book had that dark element to it that made me want to read and read and read. I had a very hard time putting it down to deal with reality. My mother read it at the same time as I did and she kept calling me throughout the book and telling me about it. We both enjoyed it. I love books like this one, where the main character has a skewed idea of what really happened and then goes on a journey to learn the real fate of that horrible night... and it was indeed a horrible night. I truly felt for this family and the fates they all suffered. I think a part of every one of them died that night. Superb novel!!!! Read and watch movie if you haven't! Both are spectacular.

[EmBibliophile · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars

I love Gillian Flynn. I love her creepy characters, disgusting stories, and scary writing. This might be not be my favorite book by her, but it was still an enjoyable creepy book to read.

As all of her books it got that slow beginning, a good disturbing mystery, and messed up unlikable characters that always make me feel so uncomfortable. However, this one was really slow and I didn’t like the ending at all. After all of that, it was just so..underwhelming. So meh. So “that’s it?”

[Katie · Rating 2 out of 5]

Oh, Gillian Flynn. Reading her books always makes me feel like I need to get in the tub and scrub myself clean. That's not exactly a complaint, but nor is it a compliment. Her novels are dark, disturbing, dirty, disgusting...yet also total page-turners you can't put down.

She excels at creating grim, memorable characters and settings that leap out from the page. Flynn also consistently creates a mood in her books that has you checking out your window every now and then just to remind yourself that you're not actually in the creepy, depressing Kansas of her creation anymore!

That said, Dark Places is my least favourite of her twisted trifecta. I thought the end was hastily written and disappointingly tidy. The reliance on shock value - from sex to the gory description of animal sacrifice (strengthened my commitment to vegetarianism!)- felt like it was getting a little old too, but maybe that's because I went from Sharp Objects right into Dark Places, so I could just need a different style of book to cleanse my palate with, so to speak. I also found some of the things characters did unrealistic based on the way they were portrayed throughout the rest of the novel.

Like Patty Day deciding to hire someone to kill herself, so her kids could claim her life insurance after her family farm bankrupts her. Yes, Patty probably wouldn't win any Mother of the Year awards, but Flynn portrays her as a mother who fiercely loves her kids. Choosing to die and leaving four kids pretty much orphaned (Runner doesn't exactly count as a dependable father figure) just didn't jive with the woman we got to know. And she decided it all so quickly! Not sure I'd meet some strange guy in the snow, accept his offer to kill me by STABBING ME IN THE CHEST - surely there's a less painful way to go?! - make plans for said stabbing to occur just a few hours from now, then peacefully go to sleep after casually checking in on your sleeping daughters. Meanwhile, your son is still missing and is being wanted for questioning about molesting little girls. Yep, seems like a great time to kick the bucket! Sorry, just didn't seem realistic at all.

I had problems too with the Kill Club, as other reviewers have mentioned, although I totally believe groups like that exist. I just have to look at how obsessed my sister is with those kind of true crime television shows to know there is an audience out there that eagerly soaks up tales of blood and gore, and almost form a cult about it. But would the Kill Club's money really be enough of an incentive for Libby to delve into her family history after 25 years of ignoring it? If she needed money that badly, wouldn't she just...I don't know, get a job at McDonald's or something? We're made to believe that the Kinnakee Devil murders have made Libby who she is today - spoiled, a kleptomaniac, friendless, lazy, entitled, angry, bitter, and deeply, deeply psychologically scarred from her experience. I understand though that it was Flynn's way of getting the ball rolling.

The big thing that weighs on my mind about this book is an interview another GoodReads reviewer linked to with Gillian Flynn, where she explains her penchant for seriously bad, unlikeable, and yes, evil female characters.

"Libraries are filled with stories on generations of brutal men, trapped in a cycle of aggression. I wanted to write about the violence of women," she says.

Flynn adds: "I particularly mourn the lack of female villains — good, potent female villains. Not ill-tempered women who scheme about landing good men and better shoes (as if we had nothing more interesting to war over), not chilly WASP mothers (emotionally distant isn't necessarily evil), not soapy vixens (merely bitchy doesn't qualify either). I'm talking violent, wicked women. Scary women. Don't tell me you don't know some. The point is, women have spent so many years girl-powering ourselves — to the point of almost parodic encouragement — we've left no room to acknowledge our dark side. Dark sides are important. They should be nurtured like nasty black orchids." Therefore, Flynn's books, she says, are her "creepy little bouquets."

Look, on the one hand, I can see that Flynn is trying to make a feminist point - that if women are equal to men, women can be equal in "bad-ness" too. Definitely.

But does she really think there's a lack of female villains in literature? I mean, off the top of my head women like Lady MacBeth, Nurse Ratchet (One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest), Annie Wilkes (Misery), Cathy Ames (East of Eden), Abigail Williams (The Crucible - I felt there was an eerie nod to the Crucible in Dark Places with Krissi Cates and the witch hunt against Ben), Clytemnestra from ancient Greek mythology, and Dolores Umbridge (Harry Potter)are examples of evil women in literature that come to mind.

These women aren't scheming about getting better shoes and they certainly aren't "merely bitchy". So I don't think Flynn is doing anything stunningly original here with her own female villains. The truth is, libraries are FULL of stories about brutal, nasty women.

Flynn isn't the first. She just might be the most explicit.

[Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5 stars . *breathes deeply* What a ride! Finally a mystery that keeps its appeal intact after the first 50% and does not make me roll my eyes all duh! like in the end. Let's see why, shall we?













► Highly recommended if you can stomach the depression. *whispers* In the end, I even rooted for Libby. Don't ask me why. I just did. Nobody's perfect, okay? I said that the characters made me sick, but oh, the sadness. The despair. The misunderstandings. The loneliness. My heart aches from lack of hope.

For more of my reviews, please visit:

_______________________

PRE-REVIEW
This is me being all contradictory : Once a year, Romance week is coming and finds me waving from a distance. As much as I love my fluffy reads, everything Valentine's Day related tends to annoy me greatly. Cynical, me? Nope. Try being born on February 14th and getting an indecent amount of heart shaped cards, gifts, stuff over the years. I can assure you that it does get old. I resist as I can, okay?

Strike one.

Nb. I made my dark week banner with the free label found here from http://lilac-n-lavender.blogspot.fr/2... (lilac and lavender)

[j e w e l s · Rating 5 out of 5]

“I was not a lovable child, and I'd grown into a deeply unlovable adult. Draw a picture of my soul, and it'd be a scribble with fangs.” Gillian Flynn, Dark Places

Gillian Flynn is the MUTHA of all domestic noir. She's my spirit animal. I feel defensive about her books, I think sometimes she gets a bad rap because her novels are so dark. Her characters unlikeable. Her plots are crazy. True, true, true.

Underneath it all, it is impossible to overlook her talent in characterization. Every book I read in this genre, I cannot help but compare the writing to Flynn's.

She can craft a character out of thin air that is as real to a reader as the book they are holding. She doesn't just tell about a character, she SHOWS us characters. The mannerisms, the habits, the insecurities, the tics and tells of their face. How they walk, talk, eat, drink, drive a car. As a reader, you are whisked into her novels for the plot and get so much more in return. My favorite kind of book!

Libby Day, our flawed protagonist, is one carefully constructed character. She is the sole survivor of a Kansas massacre. Final Girls, anyone? The story begins 25 years after the murders and Libby Day is being dragged into resolving the mystery by a group of true crime aficionados (even though she fingered her own brother as the killer). The setting is rural, impoverished America; a stark contrast with most of the urban London-ish settings in this genre.

This is my least favorite of Flynn's books, mainly because the plot is too crazy and contrived even for me. However, the writing is so first rate, I gladly give it full 5 stars.

[Roxane · Rating 3 out of 5]

A fun book, though not as well conceived as Sharp Objects or Gone Girl. The last third veers into absurdity in ways that are a bit unpleasant and unsatisfying. Still, Libby Day is a really enjoyable protagonist.

[Jenny (slowly getting back from a reading slump) · Rating 2 out of 5]

It was my first book from Gillian Flynn and I dont quite know what to say about Dark places. I wasn’t capable of being emotionally involve with the story or the characters. I thought this book was really long, I was bored during most of it.

The mystery drags on right up until the end, it got a bit better for me at about 85% as everything unraveled. There were some unpredictable parts in the big reveal but a segment related to Patty’s decision was very unrealistic and it threw me off.

I cant say I liked it but I would give the author another chance and read some of her other books.

[Ferdy · Rating 2 out of 5]

2.5 stars - Spoilers

I didn't like this as much as Sharp Objects, it paled in comparison. The characters were all unlikeable, which would have been fine if they'd at least been somewhat interesting but sadly, most of them were dull. The murder mystery/investigation was mildly engrossing, but the reveal at the end was majorly disappointing.

-What's what: Libby Day has been living off the money donated to her after her family was killed by her brother (Ben) in a satanic ritual 25 years earlier. Unfortunately for Libby that money has run out, so when Libby gets an offer to speak about the murders at a 'kill club' (a group of people obsessed with murders) for money, she agrees. The 'kill club' believe Ben is innocent, and Libby begins having doubts too, so she agrees to talk to other suspects (as long as she gets paid) for them. That leads to Libby meeting/interviewing various people from her/Ben's past.

-I disliked Libby intensely. She was lazy, self-pitying, bitter, jealous, constantly in denial, and stuck in the past. She hadn't worked a day in her life, and instead lived off the money that was donated to her as a child/teen. Apparently she was too depressed to work, but it seemed more like she was too lazy and bone idle to have a job. She wanted to live off hand outs and have no responsibility whatsoever for the rest of her life, she was an entitled cow and expected people to donate money to her even though she was an adult. Yea, her family were killed but it was 25 flipping years ago — why would anyone donate money to a healthy adult who should be more than capable of looking after herself? They only gave her money in the first place because she was young and alone. Why did she expect people to carry on giving her money when her tragedy was so long ago? How did she not realise that they'd rather give money to more recent tragedies and more desperate people? It was like she thought she was the only person ever to have suffered, ugh. She didn't try to work or sort her life out, she did nothing for 13 years, she was a lazy little git.
The most despicable thing about Libby was that she lied in court and told everyone that she saw her brother kill her family, she didn't. At the time she was only around 7 years of age, and she was more or less forced by lawyers/psychiatrists/whatnot to say those things because they wanted a conviction, she went through with it because they convinced her that Ben was guilty… I don't blame her for that. But when she was older she carried on with the lie and refused to entertain the possibility that her brother was innocent. He only got sent down because of her evidence, and she knew that but she still thought it was a-okay to let him rot in prison when he could have been innocent. When she was old enough, she should have taken action especially when she realised that her evidence was based on what other people told her and made her believe. But the silly cow was too selfish to do that, and she found it too hard to face up to reality. Never mind, that her brother could have been wrongly imprisoned, she was fine with that… But what she wasn't fine with was facing up to the truth and dealing with the past. Ugh, Libby was horrible, she didn't have one redeeming quality about her.

-Young Ben was a wimpy perverted loser. All he did was moan about being poor, which would have been fine if he wasn't moaning about it ALL the time. I hated him.
He deserved to be in jail, he was just as responsible for his sister's murder as his girlfriend, Diondra. He let his 11 year old sister get killed, he stood by and watched his psycho girlfriend strangle her to death. He didn't even want her dead but he was so weak he didn't even try to stop his girlfriend. He was to blame for his sister's death more than her actual murderer, he was her big brother, he should have protected her, instead he bought a psycho into their lives, if he wasn't involved with her she would have still been alive. Him being in jail for 25 years wasn't long enough.
Also, him making out with a 11 year old girl was fucked up, he was a paedo in the making.
Older Ben was a fool, why was he protecting Diondra for all those years? He was such an idiot. Did he not realise that she wouldn't go to prison for him? But she was cool with him going to prison for her?
Oh and him acting like he was wronged pissed me off, he had no right to make Libby feel guilty when he knew full well that he was to blame for his other sister's death. He could have saved her but he chose to watch her be brutally killed, he was irredeemable.

-Patty was a fucking idiot. She was a bloody rubbish mum — her kids practically lived in poverty all because she was too proud to sell her failing farm. If she really gave a fuck about them she would have put them first and started afresh somewhere else. She cared more about her farm than the well being of her kids.
How could she possibly think that getting a hit-man for herself would help her children?! She had four kids, they needed her, especially because their dad was a drunk, violent, uncaring, alcoholic loser. Why would them having their mum die be a good thing?! No-one else would love them like she would, she knew that but the silly cow still went ahead with her dumb plan. She was a selfish idiot.
Also, Patty agreed to let someone kill her in her own home but it never crossed her mind that it could be dangerous for her kids, did she not think her kids could end up seeing or hearing something and thus cause the assassin to target them to? What a thicko.

-Patty's sister, Diane, pissed me off. She took Libby in after her mum and sisters died but when she got sick of her she palmed her off on other relatives. It was disgusting. Sure, Libby did a lot of messed up things but she had a fucked up childhood and needed love and support. When she took on Libby, she should have stuck by her. What kind of person abandons a traumatised child they promised to look after just because said child is hard work? What a cow.

-Runner was a bastard and a half. His kids die, his other kid ends up in jail, and his other surviving kid needs looking after… But does he do the right thing? No, the fucker couldn't even clean up his act to help his youngest child get through the loss of her family.
He didn't even feel upset or guilty about what happened to his family, he didn't stop to think that if he'd been a better father, his children could have been healthy and happy. Instead he blamed everyone else, and thought that he was hard done by, and acted like he was some sort of martyr. Ugh. He was a hypocritical, abusive, mother-fucking bastard. He was responsible for his family's death just as much as their actual murderers.

-It was ridiculous that at all the 'evidence' against Ben just so happened to coincide perfectly with his family's murder — like Diondra scratching his face before sex, him hanging around Krissy's bin/locker at school, Krissy accusing him of rape, Diondra putting animal meat in his locker and Ben not cleaning it out, him claiming he was into satan/satanic rites the day before the murders just so he could seem cool. Yea, it all seemed rather improbable.

-The reveal was unbelievably far fetched. I didn't believe for a second that the Day family happened to be killed by two unconnected/different murderers not just on the same day but at the exact same time. And then there was more ridiculousness, with both the killers of the Day family being outed on the same day 25 years later. One killer (Diondra) was discovered by Libby, and the other (the professional assassin) happened to screw up one of his jobs, get caught by the police, and admit his many crimes (including the Day murders). Yea right, after years of nothing, the experienced assassin who's always managed to avoid the police gets caught and admits everything on the very day that the other Day murderer is found out. Bullshit.

-I thought it was dumb that Diondra resorted to murdering Ben's sister just because she found out about her pregnancy. She was planning to run away anyway so who cares if everyone found out she was pregnant.

-It was laughable that Diondra's daughter also turned out to be a wannabe psychotic murderer with no remorse. I just didn't believe that both mother and daughter would so easily kill people just so they could avoid trouble. It was weird how BOTH of them had no conscious or morals.

-The 'Free Ben' women were nuts. Why were they so obsessed with men in jail? Did they think they could fix them or some bullshit? Ugh, the way they treated Libby was disgusting.

-WTF?! Since when do a bunch of ten year old girls cry rape?! Why are ALL the female characters (no matter what age) in Gillian Flynn's books liars, cruel fuckers, attention seekers, and manipulative bitches?!

All in all, I wasn't impressed. The characters were all unlikeable and dull, and everything about the murders/murderers was far fetched and hard to believe.

[A Mac (on hiatus) · Rating 4 out of 5]

Actual Rating 3.5

Libby is the sole survivor of the night her older brother brutally slaughtered the rest of her family. Years later, her life changes again when she finds out that the money she’s been living off of is close to drying up. When she is contacted by an odd murder fan-group who is interested in having her as a special guest, she decides to take them up on their offer with the hope of making some money. But when they aggressively confront her about the events of that night, her testimony, and her conclusions, she finds her entire worldview turned on its head. Desperate for both money and answers, Libby decides to try to find the truth of what actually happened that night, once and for all.

This story is told through dual timelines, one following Libby in the present day and the other following the background of the family and the day of the murders in 1985. I really liked how well the author released information throughout the story even with the slower beginning. There were enough moving parts, red herrings, and connections, to keep the story moving and interesting. The overall tone of the book was rather depressing and dark, which added to the atmosphere and immersion of the story.

I also enjoyed how character-driven this mystery is. The author did a great job writing an unlikeable protagonist, and Libby’s representation as an adult was interesting. The way the family was portrayed in the 1980s was realistic and well written, making both timelines immersive and engaging.

This character-driven mystery is perfect if you’re in the mood for a darker read with unlikeable characters and a somewhat depressing atmosphere.