Every once in a while, a book comes along that just clicks with you—and The Arrow and the Alder was that book for me. A strong 4 star read that gave me characters to fall in love with, a romance to root for, and a world I didn’t want to leave. It isn’t the most groundbreaking fantasy ever, but it has that something special that completely drew me in and made me love it!
First off: the romance! It's a little fast at the beginning, almost insta-love adjacent, but not quite. There's definitely still a building of feelings, but Seph and Alder are clearly attached and attracted to each other from the very start. Their banter was adorable and felt so natural; you could really tell they were well-matched and suited. They just made sense in the best possible way. And Alder’s pet name for Seph?? SO CUTE, though I get when some people find it cringe.
Speaking of Seph; I really liked her! She's a bit of the classic "strong, bold, stubborn" fantasy heroine, but what set her apart for me is that she fails. She struggles. She isn't instantly good at everything she tries, and she’s not badass 24/7 (thank goodness), no one is strong all the time. She felt raw and human and real, which made her so easy to root for. I get so tired of "perfect" protagonists, and Seph is anything but. She makes mistakes, she learns, she grows.
And then there's Alder. Oh, Alder. I adored him when he first shows up. But once certain things happen (no spoilers!), he changes a bit. Not necessarily in a bad way, but some of his behavior did rub me the wrong way for a while. Still, when he finally opens up to Seph, he becomes his best, most vulnerable, most lovable self. His POV chapters were a highlight! He’s so sarcastic and yet so soft toward Seph once he lets himself be. He's a deeply flawed character who’s made a lot of mistakes and owns them, trying to do better without making excuses. Plus, he’s so obviously obsessed with Seph, and honestly? I loved every second of it. Definitely adding him to my growing list of book boyfriends!
Also, quick note: this isn’t really enemies-to-lovers. It's more like reluctant allies-to-lovers, with a brief phase where Seph isn’t his biggest fan.
Were there a few clichés? Sure. Seph is small while Alder is giant and powerful; there’s a “reluctant to wear the pretty dress, rather staying in my dirty clothes" moment (though Seph does have a good reason for that); the inexperienced mortal woman with the centuries-old fae man. But honestly? They didn’t bother me. They actually made sense in the world and the story, and were handled in a way that felt authentic instead of overused.
The worldbuilding was also really well done, revealed naturally through the story rather than dumped all at once. I loved learning about the Kith (the fae/elf-like race), the magic, the enchantments and curses, and the whole history with the Rift and the depraved. You could tell the author put a lot of thought into it, and while the politics aren’t super heavy, they added a compelling layer to the plot.
My only real complaint is that some of the villains could have been fleshed out a little more. One in particular was really well done, but a few others left me wishing for more motive and backstory. Also, some of the plot points were a bit predictable, especially early on. But there were still twists that genuinely caught me off guard (especially the ending), and honestly, the heart of the story—the characters, the romance, the world—made up for any predictability.
All in all, The Arrow and the Alder might not be the most "unique" fantasy novel ever, but it had that something for me. Sometimes a book doesn’t need to reinvent the genre to be incredibly enjoyable—it just needs to make you feel something. And this one absolutely did!
Thank you to NetGalley for the eARC!