A swashbuckling, high stakes queer romance set on the high seas between a man fallen through time and the pirate captain he's falling for.
Laszlo Morgenstern has watched his friends fall in love while he’s been off globetrotting. After being hurt a decade ago, he’s terrified of opening himself up to heartbreak again. Forced to return home after struggling to write his latest book, his sister Louise drags him aboard a replica of the renowned pirate ship She Deceitful that sank in 1718, and he can finally see all the pieces of his book knitting together.
Overcome with wonder, he’s drawn to the Captain’s cabin where he finds a blue wool coat. Curious, he pulls it on, only to travel 300 years in the past - this time with a knife to his throat at the hands of the handsome Captain Silas Night.
On a ship crawling with pirates and far from his own time, Laszlo must work for his place amongst them. Soon he’s surprised to not only make a few friends, but to find himself growing increasingly attracted to the stoic magnetism of Silas. Laszlo thinks the jacket might be his way home, but as he and the captain fall for each other, he must choose between returning alone but in one piece to his time, more heartbroken than before he arrived, or to stay with the love of his life, knowing how, when, and where it all ends.
If I Go Down with This Ship by Colby Wilkens is a daring adventure rom com about taking a chance on love to defy impossible odds.
Colby Wilkens is a USA Today bestelling author of romance. When she's not traveling, she can be found at home in the PNW stewing up some new sweet recipes with her partner, 2 cats, and a good audiobook.
I don't DNF ARCs; I usually force myself to finish them. However, after fifty ARCs read and reviewed, I have come to the difficult decision not to continue reading this book. When I initially requested this novel, I was unaware of the controversy surrounding the author; however, after being accepted, I saw some reviews from fellow readers that concerned me. Another book reviewer goes into much better detail; here's their link if you wish to inform yourself { https://www.goodreads.com/review/show... }
While I was given the ALC for free in exchange for an honest review and thus hadn't monetarily supported the author, my review could influence individuals to read and give support to an author whose actions I don't agree with. I hope you understand.
If you read the posts and still wish to read this story, more power to you! The premise seemed super fun, and I hope you enjoy it.
Thank you, NetGalley and Dreamscape Media, for providing me with this ALC in exchange for an honest review.
Lmao this is very much a "don't think, just read" kind of book but I enjoyed it a lot. It won't win any prizes in literature, that's for sure, but it's a cute read for a couple of hours.
The premise sounded interesting but the writing was so info-dumpy, a first draft at best, and the voice-acting over the top. I haven't DNF'd so quickly in quite some time. When I came on here to write a review, I came across a controversy about the author, which made me feel very good about my decision to abandon ship (no pun intended.)
Ugh I hate to write these, but I have to be honest. This is poorly written. It could have been 1/4 the length, as the same ideas and feelings are repeated over and over. The characters' motivations are unclear and lack depth. The two MMC act like they are 5 and do nothing but whine.
It took me a minute to into this book, but the story pulled me in, and I found myself invested in the characters and eager to keep listening. The narrator did a fantastic job bringing the characters to life as well, I would definitely recommend this cute romcom to lovers of historical MM romance.
This book was just ok, it was mostly telling and not much of showing, it didn’t really make me feel much, which is how I rate books, by how much them make me feel and this felt very impersonal in a way, I don’t know why.
I received this complimentary ALC from Dreamscape Media via NetGalley, providing me with the opportunity to share my voluntary thoughts and opinions.
I was unaware of the controversy surrounding the author when I requested this audiobook. After learning more about the situation, I cannot in good faith recommend or support this author’s work moving forward.
The story itself was okay. I enjoyed the time travel aspect, and the final 3% of the book was the only part that made me feel something emotionally. Outside of that, it never fully pulled me in. Even if I hadn’t learned about the controversy, this isn’t a book I would have personally recommended.
The standout for me was James Amherst’s narration. He did a great job bringing the characters to life, and his voice changes made it easy to tell who was speaking throughout the story. Even his female character voices worked well enough for the story. I’ll definitely be looking for more audiobooks narrated by him in the future.
Had a somewhat promising premise and a truly gorgeous cover. The execution was very, very bad. I didn’t DNF solely because I was on a cross country flight and this was the book I brought. So I rage/cringe finished it 😬
holy shit i cant believe this author is still being published in 2026 when she faked having cherokee ancestry to profit off and justify her weirdly racist "hunting for cherokee gold and its romantic" book LMFAOOOOOOO
i acquired a copy and began to read and its so crazy bad that im glad i have never read her other two works. i cannot believe there are real life people who praised her characters for representation before. i skimmed through and it was slop after slop (whitewashed our flag means death ripoff??????) and i deleted the ebook from my ipad very quickly lest it infect me
I was so excited to read a book that sounds like “Our Flag Means Death.” After learning more about this author (fraudulently claimed to be Native American and published books related to this subject) I will not be continuing to read this book.
I requested this ARC purely on vibes, which is honestly how I pick most of my NetGalley books. I don't really research authors beforehand because I like going in blind. Apparently that came back to bite me this time because I finished the book and then discovered there was a lot of controversy surrounding the author.
As far as the story itself goes, I enjoyed it. It was a solid read, but it never quite reached the level I wanted it to.
The biggest issue for me was the pacing. It took a while to get going, and while I ended up liking the romance, the chemistry between Laszlo and Silas felt like it appeared out of nowhere. I wanted more moments that showed them falling for each other instead of being told they had.
I also really wanted the time travel aspect to be explored more. If someone from the 1700s suddenly showed up in the present day(or vice-versa), I expected way more questions, confusion, and conversations than we got. There were several moments where I thought the story was about to dig deeper into the implications, but it just moved on.
The ending also didn't quite work for me. Personally, I think the story would have been stronger if Silas had gone down with the ship. I didn't need the happily ever after, especially since there isn't really an explanation for the magic or how any of it happened. I actually would have loved to see a version where Laszlo had learned to move forward while still carrying that love with him.
Regarding the author, I honestly don't know enough about the situation to speak on it, and I'm not interested in trying to sort through internet discourse. That's not what this review is about. I'm rating the book based on my reading experience.
That said, because of the controversy surrounding the author, I probably won't be recommending this book to friends. Similar to how I don't usually recommend Colleen Hoover books, I'd rather avoid books that come with a lot of baggage and debate. There are too many great books out there for me to spend my energy on that.
Overall, I thought this was a good read with an interesting premise that just needed more depth, stronger romantic development, and an ending that took a bigger emotional risk.
Okay, I’ve been waffling over this rating and review for about a week, so I’m just going with how I feel today and calling it my final answer.
What I liked: ⏳ The time-travel element 🔥 The slow burn ❤️ How the relationship developed 🏴☠️ The pirates and skirmishes ✨ The ending/resolution
What I needed more of: 🤔 A little more explanation around the time travel. If someone suddenly showed up from 2025 in 1718 (or vice versa), I feel like there would be A LOT more questions on both sides. 🥱 Lazlo was kind of an unsalted cracker for most of the book. He didn’t have much personality until the final third, which made it difficult for me to connect with him. 🔄 Honestly, Silas and Lazlo’s names should’ve been reversed. 😂 ❓ They never really explained where everyone thought Lazlo had been (or where he said he had been) for that entire week while he was “missing,” and I kept waiting for an explanation.
Overall, I really enjoyed the idea of this book, and Silas was easily my favorite part. I loved his character and the way his relationship with Lazlo developed. Unfortunately, Lazlo’s characterization and some of the execution kept pulling me out of the story. There were stretches that moved just a little too slowly for me.
James Amherst was a HUGE bright spot, though. 🎧 His narration elevated this book so much. He gave every character a distinct voice and personality, which was especially impressive considering how many pirates were aboard the ship, all from completely different walks of life. He made it incredibly easy to keep everyone straight and brought so much life to the story.
Thank you, NetGalley and Dreamscape Media, for the ALC!
EDIT: I was unaware of the drama surrounding the author when I requested and wrote this review. While my personal feelings toward the author have changed and I do not condone her actions or lack of apology, those feelings are not reflected in any way in this review. My review is solely based on my experience with the book and audiobook.
It took me a long time to get into it. I wasn’t expecting the time-travel element, but it ended up working out well. The chemistry between the main characters felt a little lacking for most of the book, though it grew stronger toward the end. I wish there was more depth to the characters, or even more personality.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of If I Go Down With this Ship. This was exactly what I was hoping it would be: it was sweet, funny, emotional, and I ended up listening to it pretty much in one go because I just didn’t want to stop. I loved the time travel aspect, the obvious yearning between the characters, and just how relatable the main character was. If you’re looking for a gay pirate romance that’s full of heart, humor, and laugh-out-loud moments, this one is definitely worth picking up.
Thank you to NetGalley and Dreamscape Media for an ALC in exchange for an honest review
I try not reading any reviews when i receive arcs, to be more impartial and not let any opinions sway me when reading them. However, after listening to a couple chapters of this book, I decided to check what others thought about it because I was not vibing with it, and what I found made me drop it completely.
I was completely unaware this author has been involved in controversies, and so when I read another reviewers research [Megan [Jaded AF]'s review], it took me no time to dnf it.
Normally, even when I don't really enjoy an arc, I still try an recommend it because what is not my cup of tea might be someone elses, but when you an author misbehaves and lies about aspects of their life, specially their heritage, just to sell book, I will never recommend anyone pick it up.
Gay pirates and time travel. Could this be more up my alley? The answer is no lol I loved this book. The characters were so perfect. Fantastic plot and action. It reminded me so much of one of my favorite shows “Our Flag Means Death”. Ugh I loved it. The ending was actual perfection. Definitely recommend!
Adventure, time travel, and pirates, oh my!! This took me a minute to get into, but by the end I was fully invested in this happily ever after. What a silly good time, narration was great, and the cover is just stunning!
Thank you Net Galley and Dreamscape Media for the ALC!
Je trouvais la couverture très jolie et j'avais hâte de découvrir l'histoire mais j'ai eu beaucoup de mal à rentrer dedans et à m'attacher aux personnages.
Dang, I haven’t DNF’d a book in almost three years. DNF’d at 63%.
I really tried with this book. The beginning really hooked me and I was loving the premise. But after that? I felt like it all just fell flat. I couldn’t bond with the characters and felt like they were all just so blah. But even when there was action happening, it all just felt…..boring. I was bored, and honestly, the narrator might’ve been the only reason I pushed this far. I just couldn’t do it anymore.
Want to thank Dreamscape Media for the ALC in exchange for my honest review. Just sad it’s not a good review for y’all this time. This is the first bad review I’ve ever had for an advanced copy. So this saddens me…..I was excited for this book.
Thank you to Net Galley and Dreamscape Media for the Review Copy
Laszlo has been wandering for some time. Trying to find his footing in the world, watching others build careers and happily ever afters, waiting on the sidelines of his life. Until the day his sister drags him along for a surprise she's sure will kick him out of his writing funk and maybe help him get past a childhood fear. Standing aboard a replica pirate ship, safely docked at harbor and not in the terrifying ocean, he starts to feel a trill of inspiration for the world he'd been working on.
When he recklessly ignores protocol and tries on a prop, he's not exiled from the ship. He's spiraled through time back to the early 1700s, no land in sight, and surrounded by people who are certainly not actors. If the blades and guns pointed at him mean anything. Luckily, they're short on crew. He's more useful as a cabin boy than dead.
Among these pirates he finds a sense of comradely he thought was lost to him. It seems there are many things Hollywood hasn't gotten right. It's hard to remember their fierce, blood thirsty, tactics when the crew his joking, singing together, and working as one. Or when a devilishly handsome captain has taken you under his wing. And, maybe, into his heart.
On the surface this book has things I quite like. Pirates go without saying. The narration was good. I'm always here for found family. I loved that Lazslo was close with his sibling. There was a lot of open communication with no misunderstandings dragging out conflict. The cast was varied in gender, origin, and age. The supporting characters and puns were fun. There was even a cat!
Sadly that was not enough to salvage its weak spots and make me invested. Repetitive cycles and conflicting choices kept dragging me out. There was a lack of commitment to a single vibe. One moment it was going for casual more contemporary romance. The next it was diving down just hard enough to show the research and look like it was turning into a more general adventure. The later moments showed signs of a novel I really would have dug into.
The flip flop made it harder to suspend belief on some of the red flags the crew surely would have had about Laszlo that they excused. For a protagonist claiming to have been working excessively on a novel about pirates, the balance of what Laszlo knew the difference of to what he was clueless about felt off. It made him lose some credibility.
Let me precede this by saying I know all too well what intrusive thoughts, self sabotage, and lack of closure can do to someone. I'm sympathetic to how constant doubt can lead to trouble trusting and forming bonds. However, by the reveal of what transpired in Laszlo's past came I had to stop and go back to make sure I had heard correctly.
What was done was completely wrong, yes. But I don't buy that it would create this particular trauma. It completely dropped what would be a perfect opportunity to give Silas and Lazlo a similar reference point. It only made hearing about his ex and the hint at this betrayal what felt like constantly even more irritating. It didn't even end there.
Which leads us into problem number two. I'm not sure there was any character progression until maybe the end. Even that would have been stronger if it had concluded differently. Laszlo would go one step forward, three steps back. Do I have a thing for pirates-- I think I have a thing for pirates. I don't fit in here-- this is just where I belong! I can't trust anyone-- I think I love him! There's no way we can do this – we will make this work! The later being the only which rang slightly true. Perpetually. Not occasionally, which is reasonable. Trust the reader. We don't need a point hammered in so much for the sentiment to carry.
If a reader just wants a somewhat cozy m/m romance in a setting that could be higher stakes, they'll probably really enjoy this. I wouldn't recommend it beyond that. Despite the net being cast wide, too many fish slipped through the slack for my taste.
Laszlo Morgenstern is dragged upon the replica pirate ship She Deceitful by his sister in hopes to reinvigorate his endeavor to write his pirate novel. Laszlo is a bit stubborn at first because he is in a rut with his writing but he joins in on exploring the ship and learning about the captain and the sinking of the ship in 1718. Wandering off to the Captain’s quarters, he finds a coat presumably to be the captain’s and tries it on. He is instantly whisked to the middle of the ocean on a fully functioning pirate ship captained by Silas Knight. A pirate captain wondering why a random weird looking man showed up on his ship wearing his jacket.
Laszlo must bide his time until he is able to figure out how to get back home. Back to his time. As he is put to work alongside the crew, he soon finds camaraderie with men he never would have guessed he would befriend. Not only does Laszlo earn the respect of the pirates but he starts falling for the roguishly handsome Captain Knight. Will Laszlo choose duty in love? Or will he find his way back to modern times where he belongs?
I received this audiobook from NetGalley and the author in return for my honest review. I knew this book was going to be right up my alley. When done correctly, a time travelling romance can be so good. For me, this was that book. Laszlo is forced out of his comfort zone by being forced into labor on a pirate ship by helping keep it sailing and afloat. But, then he finds he loves the simplicity of life without all the electronics and busy-ness of the modern world. He even gets to stop and appreciate the stars above that he doesn’t get to see in modern times because of all the city lights.
I know some might find the theme of time travel absurd, so if that is you, don’t read / listen and then give a bad review, just skip it. But the one thing I like about this story is the catalyst for time travel. A coat. That’s it. Nothing over the top. Nothing “unrealistic” or absurd. Just a coat worn by a Captain and soaked in his essence, his personality, his love for the sea. I was worried that this would not be a HEA so my only spoiler, if you can consider this one, is that as hard as it is to believe, this book does have a HEA. I will say this has been one of my favorites for this year.
James Amherst is the narrator for this audiobook. I loved his narration and voice acting. He was able to slip between accents flawlessly and was able to bring the life of a pirate captain and a modern day city boy to life.
If I Go Down With This Ship is a historical, time travel romance that follows the story of Laszlo, a struggling writer with a penchant for pirates, and Silas, the captain of the pirate ship She Deceitful. While touring a replica of the famous ship, Laszlo is hurled back in time 300 years to the golden age of piracy where he must fight for his life aboard a ship full of grumpy pirates and try to figure out how to get back home, all while fending off his ever growing feelings for the handsome captain.
The description sounds really good right? If you're a gay pirate romance (GPR) aficionado like me, this should be a white whale of a book, RIGHT? ...I'm not angry, I'm just disappointed. Because who am I to be picky and choosey when us connoisseurs of GPR are fed nothing but CRUMBS? I should be grateful, but I just can't make myself appreciate this book. The plot is *fine.* I like Silas. Laszlo, however, is insufferable. I imagine that slogging through his internal dialogue is more torturous than any threat of bodily harm Laszlo received on the ship. The absolute *constant* back and forth of "I'm finding my place with the pirates" and "but I have to go home" was miserable to read over and over...and over and over... I cannot stress to you enough how capricious Laszlo is. The book could probably have been at least 25% shorter without the incessant repetitions of the same internal conflict chapter after chapter. Speaking of conflict, other than Laszlo's unbearable monologuing, there was none. There was a glimmer of hope about 75% of the way through the book when a different mysterious pirate ship shows up, but no. They're just Silas's friends. There is, of course, the issue of Laszlo getting back to his time period, except wait no there isn't because he knows literally the whole time how to get back. But wait, you might say, what about the whole star crossed lovers from different centuries thing?? To which I say, it is also very easily resolved and in the exact same way that Laszlo returning was resolved, which, I will remind you, Laszlo was aware of quite literally the whole time. You can't advertise the book as high stakes if there's no substantial conflict. Honestly I think the book would have been better if the plot were Silas being transported to present day.
Anyway, this was a huge miss for me but I have to give the author a little bit of credit for at least attempting to feed us GPR-starved waifs. 2 stars.
Thank you to NetGalley and Dreamscape Media for the ALC.
I have so much to say about this book and none of it is good. I tried very hard to finish it and just couldn't get past all the inconsistencies.
Lazlo is returning home from somewhere to write a book he's been "researching". His sister takes him to a replica of a renowned pirate ship where he learns nothing about the crew. He is drawn to the captain's cabin and put on a coat that transports him into the past.
The premise of this book is very thin. Lazlo boards a replica ship and puts on a replica coat and is transported to the real ship in the past? Why? How? Once Lazlo is in the past, all problems are glossed over or ignored. Every character's decisions are unrealistic. Lazlo decides he needs to get rid of his keys but not his phone. The captain barely questions how Lazlo got on the ship. No one questions the modern clothes or accent.
I found this very hard to listen to when the author knows less than her character about a topic. Lazlo has supposedly been doing research for his book for a while but doesn't know sailing terms. He hasn't read about this crew that was significant enough to have a replica ship made.
Beyond the issues with the book itself are the problems with the author. When I requested this book I was unaware of the controversies surrounding Colby Wilkins. Now that I have read about what she's done I have one more reason to DNF this travesty of a book.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the copy in exchange for an honest review.
Y'all, we seriously need to talk about this book...
After my review of this author's first book (abusive MC, toxic relationship, the author was caught pretending to be native YIKES) I got some comments saying to leave politics out of books. Uh, no thank you, I will not, reading is political and always has been.
But I'm petty so okay, for this new book, I sat down to read it. Just read it, no politics on the brain. And let me tell you, this book is honestly one of the worst I've read in a long time. The biggest thing to me is how unbelievably lazy it felt, which as a reader, talk about a slap in the face. If the author doesn't care enough to put a single scrap of effort into their book, why should I care about it at all?
The plot makes zero sense and genuinely confused me multiple times. At a point, I just gave up and started skimming. There's weird uncomfortable insta-love obsession, so much whining and pining and flip-flopping emotional blah blah blah, characters with no personality or growth... it really feels like the author gave up on this one and just slapped the words down and said I guess this will do. READER, IT DID NOT DO. I only finished this book out of spite and I'm honestly a little disgusted with myself. I have serious regrets. Don't waste your time on a book this bad, a book with so little effort, and a book written by an author who tried to profit from pretending to be a POC.