Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Broken Legacy: A Riveting New Non-Fiction Account of a Family Secret with Terrible Consequences

Rate this book
A dream honeymoon. A shocking discovery. A secret that refuses to stay buried.Will the shadows of the past haunt her forever?Newlyweds Cathy and Matt Slater can’t wait to start married life together. Planning their honeymoon to Australia, Matt wants to retrace the mysterious life of his family who settled there.

Their trip is everything they dreamed of, but the day before they are due to return home, they make a discovery that will have terrible consequences for them both.

Have they brought more back with them than happy memories, and have they unlocked a terrible secret from the past?

The Broken Legacy was first published as The Tallow Image by Josephine Cox writing as Jane Brindle.

378 pages, Kindle Edition

Published June 4, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Josephine Cox

157 books348 followers
Josephine Cox was born in Blackburn, one of ten children. At the age of sixteen, Josephine met and married her husband Ken, and had two sons. When the boys started school, she decided to go to college and eventually gained a place at university but was unable to take this up as it would have meant living away from home. Instead, she went into teaching – and started to write her first full-length novel. She won the ‘Superwoman of Great Britain’ Award, for which her family had secretly entered her, at the same time as her novel was accepted for publication. She is now a No.1 bestselling author with over 40 books to her name.

She wrote dark psychological thrillers under the name Jane Brindle.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
19 (47%)
4 stars
9 (22%)
3 stars
8 (20%)
2 stars
3 (7%)
1 star
1 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
101 reviews
June 28, 2026
The Broken Legacy by Josephine Cox is a well-written novel with an intriguing premise, but unfortunately, it proved to be a frustrating reading experience for me. Although there are many strengths to the book, they are overshadowed by pacing issues and storytelling choices that prevented me from fully enjoying what could have been a much more compelling story.
The central theme of the novel revolves around a family curse, and this is undoubtedly the driving force behind the narrative. The atmosphere is heavy with sadness from beginning to end, creating a sense of emotional weight that rarely lets up. While this certainly reinforces the impact of the curse and the hardships endured by the characters, I found that the relentless melancholy became emotionally exhausting. A few lighter moments or glimpses of hope throughout the story would have provided a better balance and made the emotional journey more rewarding.
One aspect I found particularly interesting is that the author explains the historical framework of the story is based on real events, while the characters and much of the narrative have been fictionalized. This blending of fact and fiction works well in establishing the setting and provides an interesting backdrop for the story. However, I felt the execution could have been much stronger.
My greatest criticism concerns the pacing. Throughout the first part of the novel, the author spends an extraordinary amount of time describing events, conversations, and daily activities in minute detail—sometimes almost hour by hour. While detailed descriptions can certainly help immerse the reader and bring characters to life, I felt that in this case they often slowed the story unnecessarily. There were several occasions where I found myself waiting for the plot to move forward.
Ironically, after taking so much time to describe relatively ordinary events, the narrative then jumps forward, glossing over significant periods and important developments that deserved far more attention. This uneven pacing created an imbalance that became increasingly noticeable as the novel progressed. I would much rather the story had unfolded at a more consistent pace from beginning to end. Whether that resulted in a longer or shorter novel would not have mattered to me; what matters is giving every important part of the story the attention it deserves.
This is something I have encountered in several novels by different authors. Rich descriptions are valuable when they deepen the reader's emotional connection to the story, build suspense, or enhance the atmosphere. However, they become counterproductive when they consume pages that could have been better spent developing the plot or expanding on key moments. Unfortunately, I felt The Broken Legacy occasionally fell into this trap.
Another weakness was the reliance on misunderstandings and poor communication between characters to sustain the plot. Time and again, situations escalated simply because characters failed to have honest conversations or made assumptions about one another's motives. While misunderstandings can be an effective literary device when used sparingly, here they became repetitive and at times felt like a convenient way of preventing the story from reaching its natural conclusion too early. As a reader, I found this increasingly frustrating because many of the conflicts could have been resolved with a simple conversation.
The ending, sadly, was perhaps the book's greatest disappointment. After investing so much time in the detailed early chapters, I expected the conclusion to fully develop the resolution of the story and provide satisfying closure for the characters. Instead, the ending felt rushed and lacked the depth and detail that the earlier parts of the novel had received. It left me with the impression that the balance between the beginning and the end had not been managed particularly well.
Despite these criticisms, I do acknowledge Josephine Cox's ability to create believable characters and evoke strong emotions. Her writing style is engaging, and there are moments throughout the novel that demonstrate why she remains such a popular author. Unfortunately, for me, the pacing issues and the overuse of miscommunication as a plot device prevented the story from reaching its full potential.
Overall, The Broken Legacy is a decent read with an interesting premise, but one that ultimately left me disappointed. Readers who enjoy slower, character-driven stories with detailed descriptions may appreciate it more than I did. However, if you prefer a consistently paced narrative with a well-developed conclusion, this novel may not be the best choice.
For those reasons, I award The Broken Legacy 3 out of 5 stars. While it has moments of genuine quality and emotional depth, I felt its structural weaknesses prevented it from becoming the memorable novel it could have been.
★★★☆☆ (3/5 Stars)
Profile Image for Julie Homer.
321 reviews6 followers
October 19, 2026
Definitely a 5* from me , this is my favourite of Josephine cox books and I’ve read a few 🤣
Storyline just had me from the beginning brilliant 👏🏻👏🏻😍
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews