WOWZERS! Intensely nail-biting and simmering with a pot-boiling-level of mounting pressure, Don’t Let Him In had me mesmerized from the very first page. You see, beyond the compelling characters and twisty, twisty plot, there was a despicable villain who I loved to hate straight off the block. A gaslighter supreme with no sense of morals, he pulled me in deep as I got to hear the story via his very own words. But, of course, this tale wouldn’t be a complete without dual timelines and a couple of other POVs, showing all sides of this tangled web of secrets. Through their eyes, this story was everything I wanted and more, and even ended with an epilogue that had me fist-pumping the air and shouting out loud.
Let me back up just a bit, though, and cover the basics. With an onion-like plot that had layers of deftly employed secrets and lies, it was a joy to uncover them one by one with each well-timed reveal. And let me tell you, this was one intricate storyline full of plot charging drama and complex group dynamics. I do have to say, though, that while it was a tiny bit of a slow burn at the start, the multiple families and their individual crises caused the simmering start to quickly explode into an addictive game of expert mind games when they began to interweave. It was so addictive, in fact, that I binged this 450+ page novel in just under forty-eight hours. After all, I simply could not put this book down, despite the many chores that were calling my name.
All said and done, I think we should start calling Ms. Jewell the Queen of Suspense. With palpable tension, teasing plot twists, and a perfectly plotted, smile-inducing conclusion, this tale of domestic suspense demonstrated why this author is one of my all-time favorites. What blew me away the most, though, was how utterly plausible everything actually was. From the devious manipulation to the unbridled deceit, I could truly see this book instigating my own side-eye-worthy suspicion in a partner or spouse. One small warning before I sign off, though. You’re going to need to be on your game while reading this book. As long as you pay close attention, however, the complex plot is sure to win you over in spades. Rating of 5 stars.
SPOILER-FREE SYNOPSIS: Please, please, please go into this one as blind as possible! All you need to know is that this book is about Nina, who has recently lost her husband, Paddy. After receiving a note from Paddy’s long-lost friend, they strike up a romance. Nina’s daughter, Ash, isn’t quite so taken by him, though, and finds his suave ways suspicious. Without telling her mother, she starts digging into his past. What she finds sets their lives on a collision course with another woman fighting her own domestic troubles. As long-buried secrets emerge and their worlds implode, the three women are left with the haunting question of how well anyone can really know the people they let into their lives.
Thank you to Lisa Jewell, Atria Books, and NetGalley for my complimentary digital and physical copies. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: June 24, 2025
Content warning: infidelity, gaslighting, emotional abuse, violence, murder, sexual harassment, mention of: stalking