An extremely dark, YA novel which should be considered R-rated for torture and murder
This young adult novel has a depressing and frequently horrifying setup. In this paranormal world, there are people called Nobodies who are so energetically distorted that ordinary people rarely notice them at all, and if they do catch even the slightest impression of a Nobody, they forget it within seconds. If trained properly, Nobodies can literally become invisible by entering a state called the “fade.” This makes them the perfect assassins.
Nobodies are usually discovered young and then trained by a secret organization called the Institute. It is run by people called Sensors, who can detect energy, which allows them to locate Nobodies and Nulls. Nulls, in contrast to Nobodies, have so much energy that they overwhelm others, compelling loyalty and adoration, but caring nothing for anyone. They are highly effective criminals. Normals are simply ordinary people.
Sixteen-year-old Claire has lived her life completely unnoticed. A huge portion of the book is spent watching her desperately try to get someone, anyone, to notice her. Even her own parents often forget she exists. She has no idea that she is a Nobody.
Seventeen-year-old Nix, a Nobody raised by the Institute since he was four, has been trained as their top assassin. When Sensors finally detect Claire, the Institute sends Nix to eliminate her. (It is never explained why they want her dead. I can only guess that perhaps they already have all the Nobodies they need, so they murder any excess?) However, the moment Nix sees Claire, he cannot kill her. Claire and Nix are both shocked as they stare into each other’s eyes, unable to look away. For each of them, the other is the only person who has ever fully seen and interacted with them in a positive way. Before long, Nix realizes his handler at the Institute lied. He was told Claire is a sociopathic Null, but she is actually a Nobody like him.
From there, the story turns into a violent, chaotic, and continuously angst-ridden tale. These two damaged teens go on the run, uncover dark secrets about the Institute, and fall desperately in love, largely because they are the only ones in the world who could possibly care about each other.
For me, this was barely a 2-star read. I could not suspend disbelief enough to accept the frustrating inconsistencies of the magical world building. The concept of Nobodies is interesting in theory, but it completely falls apart under even the most superficial scrutiny. For example:
If Nobodies are unnoticeable to the point of being functionally invisible to everyone, including their parents, how does a baby Nobody survive? Who feeds and cares for an infant that no one is able to pay attention to? The people who train young Nobodies to "fade," a process by which they magically become insubstantial and truly invisible to the real world, achieve this through torture. Nobodies as young as four or five are nearly drowned and buried alive in shallow graves in order to make them so terrified that they instinctively fade to a state where physical matter cannot touch them. But how do the brutal trainers consistently hold a focus on a Nobody sufficient to physically restrain them and remember to keep them imprisoned, given that they are supposed to be impossible to perceive or physically interact with? Supposedly, all this torture has turned Nix into a completely devoted and obedient assassin for the Institute. But why would he feel loyalty to his torturers? In the magic of this world, only a Null could compel a Nobody to obey, yet Nix’s evil overlords are all Sensors.
There are other aspects of Nix that I also found hard to swallow. Nix is so depressed by his Nobody status that he cuts himself, leaving scars. Somehow, he also has tattoos, one for every person he has assassinated. It is never explained who is tattooing an invisible boy. Nix constantly tells himself he is nothing and nobody, which is something he only needs to do in order to fade, not to sit alone in his prison cell at the Institute where he does nothing to amuse himself. He just sits and waits until he is summoned, like some kind of robot in a state of stasis. He does not read, study, or learn anything. I do not think any human being, and there is no indication that Nix is not human, could survive that kind of sensory and intellectual deprivation.
As for Claire, she has spent her life trying to get someone, anyone, especially her parents, to notice she exists. But again, if her parents have forgotten she exists, how would they even know they have a daughter? Why would their household be set up so that Claire has her own room, clothing, and food?
The relationship between Nix and Claire did not feel like a romance to me. It seemed more like trauma bonding. Within twenty-four hours of Nix trying to kill her, they are kissing. It is the kind of instant, desperate attachment that makes me cringe, especially given the violent circumstances.
Because the entire tone of the book is relentlessly grim, the supposedly upbeat ending consists of Nix declaring that they are living happily ever after. However, the means by which this so-called HEA is achieved continues to involve magical rules that make little sense.
In short, I found this major downer of a story illogical, repetitive, and emotionally exhausting. The characters often seemed impulsive and inconsistent, and the romance felt forced. The idea of people who are quite literally overlooked by everyone else had potential, but the execution did not hold together for me.
I obtained free access to this novel in ebook format via Hoopla.