Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Returns and Exchanges

Rate this book
NATIONAL BESTSELLER A sweeping novel of one Kentucky family’s rise and fall throughout the 1980s—a tragicomic tour de force about love and marriage, parents and children, and the perils of mixing family with business, from the acclaimed author of The Animators

“This is the novel I’ve been a sprawling, emotional, and true family saga. I fell completely in love with the characters, the story, the setting. All of it. It’s damn near perfect.”—Ayelet Waldman, author of Love & Treasure

It’s December 24, 1979, just before closing at Baker-Taylor’s discount department store, and Fran (née Baker) is surveying her domain. Her husband, Fred, is charming customers in the front of the store, while last-minute shoppers in the toy aisle are fighting over the lone remaining Atari. The older Taylor kids are on register, while the younger ones’ chaos is contained to the stockroom. All is right in the world as the new decade approaches.

With four healthy children and financial stability their own parents could have only dreamed of, Fred and Fran are the picture of the American Dream—rags to riches—with a successful chain of family-owned stores built on years of hard work and long hours. Underneath the surface, however, the business is changing at a breakneck pace, and each member of the family is struggling to keep up.

Money is transforming Fred, and the extremes he will go to in order to fit in with the slicked-back high society crowd of Lexington, Kentucky, are embarrassing, if not downright dangerous. Josiah, the oldest son, wants nothing to do with the family business; Sam is seeing things that might not really be there; and Benny and Birdie are growing up with a fraction of the parenting that their older brothers had. Meanwhile, Fran, her family’s stable core, is falling for Wendy, a cashier at Baker-Taylor’s, risking everything along the way. While trying to maintain the facade of a perfect success story, Fred and Fran learn that in matters of love and money, once it’s gone, it’s gone—no returns, no exchanges.

Audible Audio

First published May 19, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Kayla Rae Whitaker

4 books524 followers
Kayla Rae Whitaker’s work has appeared in The Los Angeles Times, Buzzfeed, Literary Hub, Electric Literature, and others. Her debut novel, THE ANIMATORS, was named one of the best debut novels of 2017 by Entertainment Weekly and one of the best books of 2017 by NPR, Kirkus Reviews, and BookPage. Her second novel, RETURNS AND EXCHANGES, will be published by Random House in May 2026.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
255 (26%)
4 stars
401 (41%)
3 stars
247 (25%)
2 stars
53 (5%)
1 star
9 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 224 reviews
Profile Image for Donna  Davis.
2,006 reviews347 followers
May 31, 2026
Kayla Rae Whitaker is the author of The Animators, her 2017 debut which remains one of my favorites after 13 years and over a thousand reviews. Now she has returned with Returns and Exchanges, a more complex, ambitious novel, yet written with the same mastery of the language and the heart. My thanks go to NetGalley and Random House for the review copy; this book is for sale now.

Our story is set in Kentucky and begins on Christmas Eve in 1979. We have a hardworking family that owns and runs a good-sized store; think of something like a mom-and-pop version of Target. The Baker-Taylor store is hopping on Christmas Eve. The owners, Fred Taylor and Fran Taylor, nee Baker, are frazzled but satisfied. The two older sons are working registers; the two little kids are playing in the stockroom. They close up, clean up, and leave to celebrate the holiday.

During the recession of the 1980s they do well; theirs is an unpretentious business that bargain hunters love. As they succeed, they expand, and soon Fred is full of himself, trying to fit in with the local movers and shakers. He joins a rightwing fraternal organization and lives to impress. Fran, on the other hand, is doing most of the work. She knows what money is coming in, what’s going out; which stores are doing well, which are struggling. She is not trying to impress anyone, but falls hard for an employee named Wendy.

Nobody expected this!

And so the beginning of the book focuses primarily on Fran, and I begin to see her as the protagonist, but this is one of those epic family tales, and so as time moves forward, we begin to see different points of view. The elder sons begin to hate the business. It prevents the children from having social lives, and Fred is hard to please. Josiah, the eldest, decides to leave for college, and Baker-Taylor stores don’t loom large in his future plans. Sam, the second youngest, is an artist, and he suffers from mental health issues that Fred cannot accept. Fred thinks Sam is weak, and he doesn’t make the family or the business look good in the public eye. The two young children, Benny and Birdie, grow up largely cared for by others, because their parents are always working (or with Wendy.)

In many ways, it’s like watching a traffic accident in slow motion. I’m leaning forward, as if I might climb into the book itself and shout warnings.

The nearest thing we have to an objective observer is Fran’s brother-in-law, Jack. Jack is gay, but he keeps it quiet and hidden, and so does his loving, understanding wife. He catches onto the changes occurring within the family, including between Fran and Wendy. He tells Josiah privately,

Were your father to find out, God help us, it might break him. But it also might do something else…he’s running with a different crowd now. It’s made him a little rougher. But that’s not my big concern. It’s the board. It’s the shareholders. People who see all the fun family commercials. Do I have to elaborate on what could happen to her if folks caught wind of this?

Truer words were never spoken.

But the most critical aspect of this story, with all of its moving parts, is the way the characters are built. I feel as if I know them all deeply. Fred is the least developed character here, but I know that’s because not that much inward development happens when you’re shallow and not as smart as the rest of the family. And hopefully, that statement reveals how effective the alchemy is here: I’m not thinking about what Whitaker does with the characters. I’m thinking of the characters themselves, as if I might walk around the corner and bump into one of them.

Of course I won’t tell you how it ends, but it feels right to me, strangely satisfying.

For those that love epic family stories with deep, layered characters, this book is highly recommended. It’s one of the year’s best.
Profile Image for Lisa (NY).
2,380 reviews887 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
April 16, 2026
(3.5) “Returns and Exchanges” tells the story of a family and their retail business over several decades. It takes a bird’s-eye view, then swoops in on various family members. I found it difficult to settle into Whitaker’s style and wished that I had gotten to know the characters more deeply. I did gradually become invested in the family, but still felt that I was watching them from afar. Several days after finishing though, I find I am still thinking about the novel.
Profile Image for CarolG.
981 reviews571 followers
August 26, 2026
With four healthy children and financial stability, Fred and Fran Taylor are the picture of the American Dream with a successful chain of family-owned stores built on years of hard work and long hours. Underneath the surface, however, the business is changing and each member of the family is struggling to keep up.

To me this family saga seemed to go on and on. It begins in late 1979 and mostly takes place in the 80s I think with the final wrap-up taking place in 2015. The writing is really good and I did like the book but the pace was a bit too slow for my liking and it took me ages to finish it. I think it's a book that a person should try to concentrate on whereas I kept starting other books while I was reading this one. The book focuses on each of the four offspring at one point or another in their lives with updates on Fred and Fran's trials and tribulations. I didn't really warm to any of the characters, in fact some of them were downright nasty. Most reviewers liked the book more than I did and I recommend reading other reviews. I give it 3.5 stars, rounded down.

Thank you to Random House Publishing, via Netgalley, for approving my request to read an ARC of this novel. All opinions expressed are my own.
Publication Date: May 19, 2026
This review will be posted on Goodreads as of August 26, 2026 and on amazon.ca on or after August 26, 2026.
Profile Image for Miss Murder.
251 reviews57 followers
March 7, 2026
Real rating: 3.5 stars, rounded down

I was super into the first 200 pages of the book and was surprised I was only halfway through after all of the plot that happens that I figured would naturally come to a close soon. Instead, I got another 200 pages of what felt like very slow character development to make up for a very fast-paced beginning.

Unfortunately, that left me feeling bored at times and wondering what the meandering character vignettes meant to accomplish. I’m sure the purpose was to get that “second generation” feel from it, but it fell somewhat flat at times. Wish it would’ve started from the beginning without solely focusing on the children in the second half of the book.

Regardless, it was interesting to me and I liked the overall story & feel. The writing was a bit confusing at times in the beginning because it seemed as thought characters were thrown in without introduction and was very confusing.
Profile Image for Kristy.
1,495 reviews239 followers
Read
May 2, 2026
An absolutely excellent generational saga, chronicling the rise and fall of the Taylor family, headed by Fran (Baker) Taylor and her husband, Fred. The pair are expanding their chain of Baker-Taylor stores, while raising Josiah (their eldest, who wants little to do with his family); Sam (struggling with mental health issues); and their youngest, Benny and Birdie, who are enjoying the freedom that their newly distracted parents bring.

Following the family from the 1970s and beyond, this story is incredibly well-written, giving us well-drawn characters via a multi-POV tale. It's heartbreaking at times, exploring the concepts of motherhood, patriarchy, and money, money, money! Fred wants more of it while Fran finds herself falling for Wendy, a cashier in one of their stores.

The story highlights how different LGBT individuals were treated in the 1980s--Fran is the heart of her family, yet her heart is with a (forbidden) other. The relationships are nuanced, taunt, and fraught with emotion.

This story starts a bit slow, but it's incredibly compelling. I was completely caught up in the trials and tribulations of this family, and I think you will be, too.

I received a copy of this book from Netgalley and Random House in return for an unbiased review.
Profile Image for Kristine .
1,097 reviews361 followers
June 13, 2026
This Book was Excellent. It had so much depth and was absolutely engaged with the Taylor family. It pulled me in at the First Page and Didn’t want it to End at the Last Page. Set in Kentucky during the 1980’s, this is a family saga at its very best. Fran and Fred open Baker-Taylor’s Discount Store which sells upscale merchandise at low prices. Through years of hard work and innovative ideas the store does extremely well. More Stores open throughout the South East. Fran is the soul of the business and heart of raising 4 children. She discovers that loving someone is not always easy. She must make choices that can jeopardize her marriage, children, and business. Even though this family is seen as the ultimate success story, it is built on secrets and struggles. Loved the 80’s Pop Culture references with Atari and the Cabbage Patch Doll craze. Explores the true meaning of family, marriage, betrayal, loss and love. Beautiful Story and the writing is just superb.

Thank you NetGalley and Random House for a Copy of this Book. I leave reviews for all books I read.
Profile Image for Emily Poche.
371 reviews17 followers
February 10, 2026
Thank you to Random House for providing this ARC for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Returns and Exchanges by Kayla Rae Whitaker is an impressive, sprawling American family novel. Concerning the Taylor family, the owners and operators of Baker-Taylor discount store, it follows them through their rise and inevitable fall. The story is at once a portrait of the pitfalls of the American dream and of an evolving American family.

This book was absolutely captivating. Even though the pace of this book is slow and measured at times, it manages to maintain a high level of engagement as it skips from family member to family member. The way that the shifting focus and relatively leisurely pace manage to hold the reader’s attention is through absolutely meticulous character work. I thought that Whitaker did some of the most impressive character building I have recently read. Each of the Taylor family member, and many of the secondary characters, is distinctive and deeply detailed. They have speech patterns that are distinct, and unique emotional reactions that feel so natural to the characters the author has created. As the book progresses, each of the characters evolves and changes, in a way that is both interesting and realistic. There’s never a whiplash of choices or a complete 180 in terms of characterization. The ways that the players in this story evolve is so thoughtful and sensible. I also appreciated that there are very few true black-and-white characters in this story. Our main cast of six are given layered and complex attributes. Characters can be unfaithful wives but doting mothers, or driven businessmen who are out of touch and personally ineffectual.

I also loved the way that the American South plays its own character in this story. The economic and business climate is what underscores the story, including the looming threat of “the Beast,” a thinly veiled zeal-Mart clone. Whether it’s the attitudes of the established, moneyed, Lexington class or the reaction to the Taylor’s divorce, the role or the late 80’s Kentucky features heavily.

I was so happy to receive an ARC from NetGalley because this was a book that I really sunk my teeth into. I thought it was fascinating and yet not completely gut wrenching. I would recommend this as a book to both read and keep an eye on, 5/5 well-deserved stars.
Profile Image for Sheila The Reader.
644 reviews52 followers
May 20, 2026
I was really excited to start Returns and Exchanges by Kayla Rae Whitaker because everything about it sounded like something I would normally really enjoy. I loved the cover right away, the description hooked me immediately, and I was especially interested in the late 70s and 80s setting because this is basically the world I grew up in. Fred and Fran are around my parents age, so I really thought this was going to be one of those family stories that pulled me in emotionally.

And honestly, I did really enjoy the beginning. I liked the whole family-owned department store setting and the way the story starts out right before Christmas in 1979. It had a lot of potential for me.

But somewhere around the 30% mark, I realized I just wasn’t feeling much emotionally from the story itself, and I think that ended up being the biggest issue for me. I kept wanting to feel more connected to these people and more invested in what was happening to them, but I never really got there. The story moves around between a lot of different perspectives, and instead of making me feel closer to the family, it actually made me feel more disconnected from them.

I also think I wanted a little more nostalgia from the time period than I ended up getting. Since this is such a familiar era to me, I thought that alone would make me connect more deeply, but it just never fully clicked for me the way I hoped it would.

A lot of the book focuses on Fred and how frustrating everyone around him finds him, and after a while I just found myself losing interest instead of becoming more invested. By the end, I finished it mostly because I wanted to see it through.

I can definitely see this working better for readers who love big multi-generational family stories, but for me, I just never found that emotional connection I was hoping for.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for the complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Liz Hein.
552 reviews711 followers
May 7, 2026
Kirkus called this a blue collar Franzen novel, and…yes.
Profile Image for Jillian B.
828 reviews310 followers
May 3, 2026
This book is about a family undergoing constant change: rising and falling wealth, mental health crises, and marital tensions. Though they are, at times, cruel to one another, the Taylors remain connected. The complexity of the relationships feels realistic. Readers will enjoy following the deeply imperfect Taylor clan through all the messiness of life. Full review on BookBrowse: https://www.bookbrowse.com/reviews/in...
Profile Image for Tell.
272 reviews1,655 followers
June 16, 2026
A masterwork of queer expression and a family novel all rolled into one, "Returns and Exchanges" takes us into the heart of the Taylor family before, during, and after a crisis and before, during, and after they make a fortune.

This book is both about the acquisition and transformation process that happens as you're roiled by new circumstances and as you watch your family be pulled out from underneath you. Characters are expertly drawn, showing us flashes of who they will become as they're transformed by money.

This book is about a woman seeking to express herself, live in her truth, and trying not to buckle under the weight of a dozen expectations put upon her, and about her family members adapting (or failing to adapt) to a transformative circumstance. Whitaker writes short, sharp sentences that stick with the reader, and I loved the deep dive into the specificity of Midwestern family politics and class tensions. I loved her last novel and this one is filled with even more heart and even more barbs. Loved.
Profile Image for Gail.
1,362 reviews478 followers
September 23, 2026
When I read a Kayla Rae Whitaker novel, all I can think is, “WHY ISN’T THIS WOMAN ON THE NYT BEST SELLER LIST?” Truly, she belongs there—and that sentiment applies to my feelings both for her excellent debut, The Animators, and for her equally excellent follow-up, Returns and Exchanges, which released in May.

I love what Kirkus had to say about the book in its starred review, so I’m sharing a link to that review here along with my favorite closing snippet: “Superb. Like a blue-collar Franzen novel.”

On that note, I now need Adam Sandler and his family to get a hold of this title and create a movie or mini-series for Netflix. I can’t say why or when it happened, but at some point I pictured Adam as Fred Taylor and his daughter, the actress Sadie Sadler, as Birdie (Fred and Fran’s basketball playing daughter). And I’ve seen Sandler in enough stuff to know that, when he wants to do the serious thing, he can nail the serious thing. And I think he’d have a hell of a good time playing the patriarch of this 1980s nouveau riche family. (I mean, if you’ve read this book, can’t you SEE it?)

Related: Kayla was the featured author on this Book Gang podcast over the summer and it was such a wonderful listen — both because I enjoyed hearing her faint Kentucky accent shine through in the conversation and because she provided some great insights into her research and the writing of this book. (I, too, now want to watch YouTube clips of ‘80s commercials for the nostalgia of it all!)
Profile Image for Ellen Ross.
728 reviews95 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
February 17, 2026
As someone who was born in the 80s, I still felt a lot of nostalgia from this story. I love the characters and how well they were developed. Everyone is so complex with their life and their issues. I loved the plot and how it showcases struggles that are still relevant to this day. The book has a very easy flow to it and was very easy to follow. There was an endearing quality to the entire book, and it is one that I won’t soon forget. The writing was amazing and really made me consumed as I read. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Tess.
935 reviews
December 26, 2025
Completely blown away by this epic novel! I had just been wondering when her follow-up to her incredible THE ANIMATORS would be and I understand the wait. This sprawling family drama, which spans decades, is juicy, heartfelt, and quite the deep dive into a family business struggling to come of age, alongside the family itself. You are going to love this one, put it on the top of your 2026 reads NOW
Profile Image for Jessica.
721 reviews145 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
May 12, 2026
Won this in a giveaway from PRH on Instagram, and was so so happy because Kayla Rae Whitaker's novel The Animators is one of my favorite books!

I loved getting to know these characters and be so close to them in a way Whitaker always does so well. I'm still processing and will likely be back with a longer review soon. It's a long one and so different from her debut, and yet I recognized some of Whitaker's signature flourishes between the two. Loved being in this world.
Profile Image for Karin.
1,608 reviews56 followers
June 14, 2026
Just wonderful. Do you like family sagas? This is one, what makes it unique is the parents are co-founders of a department store chain in the 1970s. Examines the acceptance of queer people in Kentucky during that time, family legacies, gender, forgiveness. One of my best books of the year so far.
13 reviews
October 26, 2025
I received this arc form the publisher. This is an absolutely wonderful novel that will stay with you long after you have finished reading it. The characters are so finely drawn (especially Fred!) that you will start to recognize them as people from your own life.
Profile Image for Lauren.
844 reviews114 followers
Did Not Finish
May 24, 2026
Pains me to put this one aside! Been waiting on her sophomore release for a decade! This was really bland and felt similar to multiple other books I’ve read. DNF @ 10%
Profile Image for Katherine.
1,783 reviews
June 5, 2026
Kayla Rae Whitaker's first book, The Animators, was one of my top reads of 2017 when it was published. It felt almost criminal how long we had to wait for her follow up, but the wait was worth it. I devoured Returns and Exchanges and really enjoyed the good old fashioned family story.

Fran and Fred are a rags to riches story, growing their small discount store in Kentucky to a regional success. When we meet the Baker-Taylor family in the early 80s, things are rosy for Fran, Fred, and their four kids. Business is booming and life is good. However, a chance encounter for Fran turns out to be a life altering event, and will help drive the family arc in a different direction. And we all know what was waiting on the horizon for mom and pop stores in those days. As one character notes, the Baker-Taylor outsized success only lasted one generation.

The story is told in the different voices of the family - the characters are well drawn and it was easy to get lost in the story. I have to say, while Fred at first was annoying, I was infuriated with him by the end and I'm not sure how the other characters extended him so much grace (no spoilers, but there were some things that were unforgiveable to me). It did keep things interesting though by providing dramatic tension throughout the book.

It is weird to read a book set in a historical time you lived through. I think Whitaker captured this time well, not just some of the details, but also the prevailing attitudes at the time. And she didn't get too cutesy going overboard with cultural references of the time.

All in all, a solid five stars and I imagine this book will also be one of my top ten reads at the end of the year.
Profile Image for Kristen.
839 reviews72 followers
July 4, 2026
Whitaker is so, so good at doing a deep dive on a subject and people. I feel like I could run a discount store now. I loved this.
Profile Image for Maxine Springer.
551 reviews
June 3, 2026
5 | This is the type of book that’s 100% in my wheelhouse. I was SO excited to read another book from the author of The Animators (another 5-star read IMO). A family saga that focuses at times on each of the family members across the years, I loved and hated these characters, cheering or cursing them along the way (although there are no complete saints or total villains in this story). It’s so tough sometimes to read a story that unfolds over such a stretch of time, and although the book is a bit long, the pacing of this felt perfect (and honestly, I could have read more)! Loved it.
Profile Image for Aislinn.
157 reviews4 followers
May 24, 2026
[4.75⭐️] the rise and fall of a local store enterprise mirrored that of my heart rate throughout the expanse of this book. Holy.

I was initially intrigued by the blurb of this book, but I didn’t anticipate the level of page-turning hunger that the story gave me. It had been a hot minute since I had felt this way about a book.

Returns and Exchanges spans through decades and from varying perspectives of the members of the family, but in a very fluid and captivatingly blurry way. But despite the ever changing perspectives, nothing felt repetitive nor did I have a character that I felt disinterested in (there’s usually always one!!).

The characters were well formed, yet mysterious in ways, as some characters never got a full explanation into their “end” since the story perspective shifted. But the way these people were written, and in a highly specific scenario that is in no way relatable to my life story, felt authentic and heartbreakingly relatable.

I have to give Whitaker her flowers, as she is an excellent writer. Her story jumped off the page and enveloped me in no time and didn’t let go until the final word. Id happily read more of her work.

All that to say— I cried, I grew twitchy with anger, I smiled, I held my breath. I felt like I was one of the Baker-Taylors at certain points. This sad but endearingly compassionate story is one for the books.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for providing me with an ARC of this modern classic in exchange for my honest thoughts!
Profile Image for Kris V.
188 reviews75 followers
February 27, 2026
I read The Animators when it first came out and was blown away, so I knew that whatever Whitaker wrote next I had to read and I was *not* disappointed. What we have here is an epic tale that spans generations within a family line. What begins on Christmas Eve in 1979 in Kentucky, and ends in 2015 and told by the Matriarch of the family, is a story about a family’s journey with their line of discount stores and their evolution of each member as they change and grow and branch out into who they’re meant to be. It’s a whirlwind of a novel that was impossible to put down, writing that pulls you in and makes you laugh as hard as it makes you cry for their losses. I honestly found myself initially saddened by the ending only because I realized I hadn’t wanted it to be over, which is a sign of a really good book.

I thank Random House for providing this ARC for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

I have pre-ordered my own copy because I want this beautiful book on my shelves, and I highly recommend everyone else purchase a copy as well.

Kayla Rae Whitaker is a treasure.
Profile Image for Stephanie Dargusch Borders.
1,198 reviews29 followers
June 22, 2026
Overall, a disappointment. I’ve waited almost a decade for Kayla Rae Whitaker to release her sophomore novel. The Animators blew it out of the water for me and I thought it was phenomenal. I couldn’t wait to get my hands on this one. I wouldn’t necessarily say it started off strong but I like the sense of place—a 1980s setting. Clocking in at well over 400 pages though, it became a slog. I cared less and less as the book went on and by the end I just wanted it to be over. There was definitely potential here but it missed the mark.
Profile Image for Jenny.
2,545 reviews81 followers
July 15, 2026
Returns and Exchanges is Kayla Rae Whitaker's second book about the rise and fall of a Southern family and the effects on them. When Fran Baker and Fred Taylor married, they started the Baker-Taylor discount retail stores in their hometown, and it was doing very well. However, Fred Taylor wanted more and began setting up a chain of discount retail stores. Will they succeed or will they fail? Readers will continue to follow Fran, Fred Taylor, and family to discover what happens.

Reading this book did start me thinking about the consequences of greed when running a retail business. I also understand the importance of including the owner's children in a business if you want the business to survive.

Returns and Exchanges is the first book I have read by Kayla Rae Whitaker, and I enjoy the way she portrays his characters and their interactions. I found Kayla Rae Whitaker's writing style a little confusing, which did not help me engage with the characters or the plot of this book. My local bookstore's book club picked this book, and discussing it with others helped me understand the plot and what the author was trying to convey to her readers. The way Kayla Rae Whitaker described the settings did complement the book's plot.

I recommend this book.
61 reviews1 follower
May 28, 2026
I don’t have much to say about this one. Whitaker has written a good novel, one of my most anticipated releases of 2026, but I wish I could say it was a great one after finishing it.

At its core, Returns and Exchanges is a family saga with a queer spin, though that aspect feels somewhat shoehorned into the novel for extra plot points. I only say this because Whitaker never quite does enough work to make the reader fully buy into Fran and Wendy’s relationship. More specifically, the emotional foundation of their love story feels nearly absent.

As for the rest of the cast, Whitaker sets up the Taylor family with the potential for unique and compelling evolution, and each character gets moments to shine. Still, what held the book back for me was how little these characters actually change. Despite the story spanning decades, their voices and attitudes rarely mature in convincing ways.

The family patriarch comes across as a flat stereotype of the era’s domineering father figure, lacking the nuance I expected. That may partly explain the lack of depth surrounding Fran and Wendy’s affair-turned-relationship because, in theory, almost anything for Fran would seem preferable to a life spent with someone so small and singular.

There’s very strong writing, and the central idea of a family chasing the American Dream through the setting of a department store is kind of perfect. But in the end, the novel felt more like a missed opportunity than exceptional. I kept thinking about Franzen’s Crossroads while reading (blame the Kirkus Review for the comparison) and kept wishing Returns and Exchanges carried the same weight.
Profile Image for Lindsay.
315 reviews9 followers
June 1, 2026
I'm definitely in the minority on this one, but I could not connect with this book. I loved the concept - the tale of a midwestern family and their department store, all of the characters and happenings as the decades change, the family grows, and the stores expand.

This was a very long book. I almost stopped after the first 50-60 pages; the writing style was confusing and felt very fast. I could not wrap my head around who the characters were or what was happening. Then the story got better and I was intrigued for about 200 pages or so. The last 100 pages went back to the confusing style of the beginning. Sorry it all turned out that way but glad Fran found happiness in the end.
Profile Image for Izi Witt.
22 reviews1 follower
July 24, 2026
3.5 ⭐️ this is not what it was like when my parents owned discount stores around Lexington lol but shoutout Indy’s 🙂‍↕️
Profile Image for Stephanie Doyle.
885 reviews36 followers
March 15, 2026
This book. It will without a doubt be in my top three this year. I loved the characters, the story, the writing. It had grit and heart.

Thanks to Netgalley for the free advanced copy in exchange for an honest review
Profile Image for britt_brooke.
1,753 reviews145 followers
June 9, 2026
Been waiting several years for a follow up to The Animators, which I loved. I so wanted to, but just couldn’t get invested, nor connect. Didn’t feel the nostalgia. Regardless, I’ll still give this author from my home state another go when she writes her third.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 224 reviews