What do you think?
Rate this book
Fall for You Again
Caroline Moor built her life on ambition, spreadsheets, and a reliable Wi-Fi signal. None of that helps when her car dies under the “Welcome to Sweetwater” sign and the tech job she worked so hard for is suddenly in the past tense.
Stranded in the Alabama town she once raced to escape, Caroline is confronted by everything she left behind. Including Leo Coleman, her former best friend who has grown into the kind of man who could make anyone forget why they ever ran in the first place.
Leo never left Sweetwater. When his family’s farm began to fail, he stepped in without hesitation. Coleman Acres is held together with grit, stubborn hope, and more cinnamon than he will ever admit. With the fall festival on the line and the farm’s future hanging by a thread, he needs help. Caroline needs something to take her mind off the wreckage of her career. The partnership is reluctant, but it works.
One project becomes two. One laugh becomes several. One spark becomes something harder to ignore.
As they rebuild the festival one hay bale at a time, Caroline begins to question the version of success she has been chasing. But a high-profile job offer is waiting for her in the city, and unspoken truths threaten to break the fragile new bond forming between them.
Caroline must choose what truly matters. Is Sweetwater just a temporary stop on the road back to her old life, or is Leo the future she never thought she deserved?
A story about second chances, small towns, and the love that catches you exactly where you fall.
Fall for You Again is a second chance, small town romance about finding your way back home.
Stranded in the Alabama town she once raced to escape, Caroline is confronted by everything she left behind. Including Leo Coleman, her former best friend who has grown into the kind of man who could make anyone forget why they ever ran in the first place.
Leo never left Sweetwater. When his family’s farm began to fail, he stepped in without hesitation. Coleman Acres is held together with grit, stubborn hope, and more cinnamon than he will ever admit. With the fall festival on the line and the farm’s future hanging by a thread, he needs help. Caroline needs something to take her mind off the wreckage of her career. The partnership is reluctant, but it works.
One project becomes two. One laugh becomes several. One spark becomes something harder to ignore.
As they rebuild the festival one hay bale at a time, Caroline begins to question the version of success she has been chasing. But a high-profile job offer is waiting for her in the city, and unspoken truths threaten to break the fragile new bond forming between them.
Caroline must choose what truly matters. Is Sweetwater just a temporary stop on the road back to her old life, or is Leo the future she never thought she deserved?
A story about second chances, small towns, and the love that catches you exactly where you fall.
Fall for You Again is a second chance, small town romance about finding your way back home.
- GenresSecond ChanceRomance
328 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 10, 2025
142 people are currently reading
211 people want to read
About the author
Sam Marshall
6 books34 followersHi! I'm Sam Marshall, and I write romantic comedies and contemporary love stories that blend laugh-out-loud moments with unexpected emotional depth.
My style? Snappy banter, slow-burn tension, and characters you’d absolutely text at midnight for life advice.
Inspired by the people I love—especially my wife and kids—I crafts stories that are as much about personal growth as they are about falling in love. If a book can make you laugh, ache, and immediately recommend it to your best friend, that’s the kind of story I want to tell.
My goal? To write the kind of romance that makes you feel seen, smile unexpectedly, and maybe believe in love all over again.
My style? Snappy banter, slow-burn tension, and characters you’d absolutely text at midnight for life advice.
Inspired by the people I love—especially my wife and kids—I crafts stories that are as much about personal growth as they are about falling in love. If a book can make you laugh, ache, and immediately recommend it to your best friend, that’s the kind of story I want to tell.
My goal? To write the kind of romance that makes you feel seen, smile unexpectedly, and maybe believe in love all over again.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews
October 13, 2025
3.5 ⭐️
leo deserved better. caroline had the emotional maturity of a pickle and had the audacity to blame it on anxiety and ambition. the fall vibes were super cute though!
leo deserved better. caroline had the emotional maturity of a pickle and had the audacity to blame it on anxiety and ambition. the fall vibes were super cute though!
September 21, 2025
Definitely worth the wait
When I opened this second chance love story I had no idea it would be something that would make a mark in my psyche. Caroline and her leaving tendency and Leo as the one who stayed really hit my heart. It was a love story I needed to see unfold. It was a truth we all need to capture at times, the truth of meant to be and the hope of one day finding it. That was this story in a nutshell. Definitely read it and be in awe at how it shows us all how to have faith in our life direction and how truths can be staring us right in the face.
When I opened this second chance love story I had no idea it would be something that would make a mark in my psyche. Caroline and her leaving tendency and Leo as the one who stayed really hit my heart. It was a love story I needed to see unfold. It was a truth we all need to capture at times, the truth of meant to be and the hope of one day finding it. That was this story in a nutshell. Definitely read it and be in awe at how it shows us all how to have faith in our life direction and how truths can be staring us right in the face.
October 15, 2025
A cute, wholesome, fall read
September 28, 2025
Caroline Moor was determined to get out of the small town of SweetWater, Alabama. She was going move to New York City and never look back until she was fired from her job and returned to the small town she swore she would never return to. She told everyone in town she wasn’t staying she was just visiting.
Leo her friend since they were kids never left SweetWater but his feeling for Caroline went away. Leo kept his feeling for Caroline to himself never wanting him to choose him for the wrong reasons. But, when Caroline offered to help run the Fall Festival at Leo’s farm. Slowly Caroline’s feelings for Leo came to surface and she tried to push them away knowing she was going to leave.
When a tornado tears through Leo’s farm and a rich developer tries to buy part of Leo’s farms. Caroline realizes that her feeling for Leo and leaving her hometown has changed. Now she must convince Leo that she can help it so he doesn’t have to sell and tell him how she really feels.
Leo her friend since they were kids never left SweetWater but his feeling for Caroline went away. Leo kept his feeling for Caroline to himself never wanting him to choose him for the wrong reasons. But, when Caroline offered to help run the Fall Festival at Leo’s farm. Slowly Caroline’s feelings for Leo came to surface and she tried to push them away knowing she was going to leave.
When a tornado tears through Leo’s farm and a rich developer tries to buy part of Leo’s farms. Caroline realizes that her feeling for Leo and leaving her hometown has changed. Now she must convince Leo that she can help it so he doesn’t have to sell and tell him how she really feels.
October 16, 2025
2.5⭐ this wasn't my favorite. it was very repetitive. there would be a page of an internal thought process and then the next paragraph was summarizing the thoughts I just read. it felt excessive. it also meant that the same two or three ideas compromised 75% of the entire book. we are well aware of the conflict and struggle for different characters but to have it reiterated so frequently made the story drag out. the book needed some good editing.
also, I found it ironic that the author uses very specific descriptive phrases for characters and their appearance and there would be entire sentences that were repeated multiple times in the book. it felt like some of the writing was copied and pasted, which felt a little lazy. a lot of the descriptions were very stereotypical, frequently when used to describe how the main male character appeared, what he wore, his freshly wet hair, etc blah blah blah.
also, I found it ironic that the author uses very specific descriptive phrases for characters and their appearance and there would be entire sentences that were repeated multiple times in the book. it felt like some of the writing was copied and pasted, which felt a little lazy. a lot of the descriptions were very stereotypical, frequently when used to describe how the main male character appeared, what he wore, his freshly wet hair, etc blah blah blah.
October 26, 2025
3.5 rounded up
October 31, 2025
A perfect fall read 🤎🍂
September 16, 2025
A Beautiful Second Chance Love Story
Fall for You Again is a heartfelt second chance romance about love, forgiveness, and finding your way back to someone who still matters. The characters feel genuine, and their emotions hope, regret, and longing are captured beautifully. I loved how the story balances romance with personal growth, making their journey feel real and deeply moving. The writing is warm and immersive, pulling you in from the first page. A touching, uplifting read that lingers long after the last chapter.
Fall for You Again is a heartfelt second chance romance about love, forgiveness, and finding your way back to someone who still matters. The characters feel genuine, and their emotions hope, regret, and longing are captured beautifully. I loved how the story balances romance with personal growth, making their journey feel real and deeply moving. The writing is warm and immersive, pulling you in from the first page. A touching, uplifting read that lingers long after the last chapter.
September 25, 2025
Really sweet
I have gotten to an age where I truly appreciate a sweet clean romance. I am not looking for excessive angst or spicy love scenes. I want a well written story that makes sense and does not play dumb. This story has personable characters who share their growth and adventures without any tropey negativity or belittling interactions. Will definitely be reading more of SM.
I have gotten to an age where I truly appreciate a sweet clean romance. I am not looking for excessive angst or spicy love scenes. I want a well written story that makes sense and does not play dumb. This story has personable characters who share their growth and adventures without any tropey negativity or belittling interactions. Will definitely be reading more of SM.
October 9, 2025
Wasn't impressive. I liked the plot but writing could have had more excitement and thrill. Words were misspelled in some places.... not too often do I see this. I was really hoping since the book is in suspense throughout its entirety the ending was subpar, for what my expectations were set for. Too flat for my liking.
October 9, 2025
cute.. a little sappy
October 9, 2025
3.5 if I could choose that number...
Fun, adorable read! I appreciated the business lingo. However, lots of repetitive phrases. Had to make sure I was not accidentally reading a page I already read over again here and there. Loved Leo's character. Was not a fan of Caroline.
Fun, adorable read! I appreciated the business lingo. However, lots of repetitive phrases. Had to make sure I was not accidentally reading a page I already read over again here and there. Loved Leo's character. Was not a fan of Caroline.
November 17, 2025
Worst Epilogue Ever
Fall for You Again had such promise for most of the book except for Caroline being mildly annoying throughout but that epilogue ruined the entire book. What do you mean Leo spent the book making Caroline realize she had feelings only to pull the rug on her?! "I spent 13 years waiting and now she must spend a year earning my trust." Ummm what?! That's not how relationships work in a book or life! Completely ruined the book and pissed me off.
Fall for You Again had such promise for most of the book except for Caroline being mildly annoying throughout but that epilogue ruined the entire book. What do you mean Leo spent the book making Caroline realize she had feelings only to pull the rug on her?! "I spent 13 years waiting and now she must spend a year earning my trust." Ummm what?! That's not how relationships work in a book or life! Completely ruined the book and pissed me off.
October 31, 2025
3.5⭐️This was a very sweet read. I could see it being made into a Hallmark movie. I wish it would’ve included a recipe for that special spice mixture or a pumpkin spice latte! 😅
October 10, 2025
There’s many reasons this book is a great story! First, it’s not just a small town romance; it has depth, character and world development and growth! Second, I loved the characters!! Our MFC is Caroline and she’s the small town girl who wants the big city life! She goes to NYU gets the fancy degree and works the high power job she’s dreamed of until one day it all goes bye bye!! Our MMC is Leo and he’s the loveable and humble Farm boy who’s always loved Caroline. He’s had the weight of his family farm on shoulders since before he even knew it! He’s added so much to their once small farm and has created a sustainable agriculture that will be around for generations!! It also has great side character that add fun and small town feel with all their busybody ways! lol
Third, I love where they live!! It reminds me of where I’m from so I could relate to all the nosy/gossipy people, the fall festivals and small town mom and pop places!!
This romance I would qualify as a friends to lovers without spice but it has fun banter and great kisses and with the character growth and history I didn’t miss any sexy times because I felt their love!!
Third, I love where they live!! It reminds me of where I’m from so I could relate to all the nosy/gossipy people, the fall festivals and small town mom and pop places!!
This romance I would qualify as a friends to lovers without spice but it has fun banter and great kisses and with the character growth and history I didn’t miss any sexy times because I felt their love!!
October 27, 2025
I mean. I've read worse. Definitely better than the last Sam Marshall book I read, if only because the FMC wasn't quite as much of a selfish basket case. Leo arguably still deserves better, but Caroline seems like she's teachable.
That said, it's still not a good book by any stretch. Cannot in good conscience recommend it. The inconsistencies are maddening, the pacing is tedious, the conflict tissue-thin. There's a serious anti-city bias, undertones of misogyny, and I'm not convinced Marshall could locate New York on a map. The state, let alone the city. I kept reading mostly because by the time I hit a good stopping point there was only an hour or so left to go. Do yourself a favour and pick up something else instead.
That said, it's still not a good book by any stretch. Cannot in good conscience recommend it. The inconsistencies are maddening, the pacing is tedious, the conflict tissue-thin. There's a serious anti-city bias, undertones of misogyny, and I'm not convinced Marshall could locate New York on a map. The state, let alone the city. I kept reading mostly because by the time I hit a good stopping point there was only an hour or so left to go. Do yourself a favour and pick up something else instead.
October 23, 2025
All the fall vibes + a friends to lovers/second chance love story. Caroline leaves her small town to chase her career goals in NY while leaving behind everything she’s ever known. Leo stays to take over his family farm business. They haven’t seen or talked to each other in 10 years until Caroline comes back to town after being let go from her job. She’s forced to stay longer than expected after her car breaks down and tells everyone she’s just visiting. Coming back to Sweetwater has given her a new perspective that she’s been defining success in all the wrong ways. This book is the epitome of fall in a book - pumpkins, apple cider, fall festivals, etc. Also available on kindle unlimited!
October 18, 2025
Fall for You Again is a charming small-town romance with just the right mix of second chances, fall vibes, and emotional depth. Caroline and Leo’s story is warm, witty, and totally relatable. I also like how the author didn’t rush the romance, If you love slow-burn love stories with heart and healing, this one’s a perfect cozy weekend read Caroline and Leo’s reconnection had that perfect mix of old friendship and new chemistry
November 30, 2025
I can’t recall a romance book where I hoped they didn’t end up together until now. I would’ve said the whole time that Leo deserved better than Caroline, but then the epilogue from hell struck.
Real talk- If you are in a position where someone needs time to decide if they’re going to choose you over a job or next best thing, and even goes as far as setting a calendar alarm to remind you to decide—- let them walk away!
Real talk- If you are in a position where someone needs time to decide if they’re going to choose you over a job or next best thing, and even goes as far as setting a calendar alarm to remind you to decide—- let them walk away!
October 29, 2025
Meh… cute? Sure. I feel like Leo deserves someone who didn’t have a light bulb of all his good qualities until after her own self absorbed life imploded. The writing was okay but she kept having the same thoughts at the end of every chapter, I feel like this book could have been several chapters shorter.
November 6, 2025
I liked the fall vibes and the pumpkin festival, especially the pumpkin boat races. Leo had genuine emotional depth from the start. Caroline was harder to connect with, because she lived in her head (instead of her heart) for such a long time. Be ready for lots of discussion about business plans.
This is very much a slow, slow, slow-burn.
This is very much a slow, slow, slow-burn.
November 24, 2025
3.5 stars. This is my second book by Sam and I enjoyed it! I loved Leo from the start. My only complaint with the writing style is the repetitiveness. If I had to read that Leo’s sleeved were rolled to his elbow one more time!!
All in all, this was a nice book. It did what I needed it to do- give me the warm and fuzzies. I’ll definitely read more of Sam’s writing.
All in all, this was a nice book. It did what I needed it to do- give me the warm and fuzzies. I’ll definitely read more of Sam’s writing.
October 5, 2025
It was a very sweet clean romance, very cute. My rating is based on how much business/marketing talk and description there was in the book. Most went well over my head, was just too indepth for the overall story, and had too much of it throughout the story. Otherwise, a truly sweet romance.
October 23, 2025
Fall Comfort Read
Reading this book felt like curling up on the sofa, with a soft blanket, fuzzy socks, and a cup of my favorite tea on a cool autumn day. It was comfortable and sweet and all the fall vibes that I needed
Reading this book felt like curling up on the sofa, with a soft blanket, fuzzy socks, and a cup of my favorite tea on a cool autumn day. It was comfortable and sweet and all the fall vibes that I needed
November 21, 2025
3.75 stars.
I SO appreciate a cute story with no bad language or descriptive spice. There were a few repetitive phrases/thoughts, but overall, I liked the story.
Random thought: Because of their hat colors, I kept picturing the triplets as The Chipmunks (Alvin, Theodore, and Simon)!
I SO appreciate a cute story with no bad language or descriptive spice. There were a few repetitive phrases/thoughts, but overall, I liked the story.
Random thought: Because of their hat colors, I kept picturing the triplets as The Chipmunks (Alvin, Theodore, and Simon)!
November 24, 2025
One of the sweetest fall romances I've read ever! It was perfect and just what I needed! There was something about both main characters that I absolutely loved and I'm so thankful they got their happily ever after!
December 11, 2025
⭐️2.5
🍂Fall vibes
🍁Small Town Romance
🍂Country boy
🍁Aspiring city girl?
🍂Second chance romance? I guess?
This book had its cute moments... but there was a lot of repetition. Leo deserved better and then the epilogue came... The book completely tanked for me after that.
🍂Fall vibes
🍁Small Town Romance
🍂Country boy
🍁Aspiring city girl?
🍂Second chance romance? I guess?
This book had its cute moments... but there was a lot of repetition. Leo deserved better and then the epilogue came... The book completely tanked for me after that.
January 22, 2026
Probably the best book I have read all year, kept me so interested right to the end, fantastic story and great character development. For all lovers of rural romance even the cedar soap kept me intrigued.(once you read you will understand
October 6, 2025
I flew through this book. It was such a cute clean romance, and I genuinely enjoyed watching Caroline and Leo find their way back to each other.
October 7, 2025
Great book! Loved every minute of it!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews