Who’s Watching Shorty by Reshona Landfair is a heavy, necessary read. This memoir is an account of the author’s abusive connection with R. Kelly & her firsthand experience as the Jane Doe in his 2008 trial. The sharing of her perspective takes a level of bravery & candor that can’t be overstated. Landfair’s story is raw, painful, & riddled with abuse, manipulation, & the long-term damage that comes from adults choosing convenience, access, or money over protection. The book powerfully reinforces one uncomfortable truth: turning a blind eye never really helps anybody, fr fr.
That said, my main disappointment lies in what the author skirts around. There’s minimal accountability given to the role her family played in her proximity to Kelly. No matter how it’s framed, her access to him stemmed from adults chasing clout, glitz, & proximity to fame. Even if the abuse wasn’t known initially, once it was known, the silence was compensated—financially & otherwise. That complicates the narrative in a way the book doesn’t fully reckon with. There’s also a broader conversation missing about victims who stay not solely out of fear, but because leaving threatens financial stability—at some point blurring the line between coercion & choice. That’s uncomfortable to say, & I know not everyone is ready for that convo. Please know that I am referring to once she became an adult.
Another throughline that’s impossible to ignore is the parallel between Landfair’s story & another well-known singer: relatives acting as gatekeepers who effectively delivered young girls to predatory power structures. In this case, Landfair’s aunt, Sparkle, served as that access point. For that, she is culpable too—just as much as Kelly, in my opinion. Silence, facilitation, & benefiting from abuse are not neutral acts.
Which let me say this, sis seemed like she had more smoke for Sparkle than her own parents, which is bizarre to me. Plus I don't like the narrative that Landfair attempts to paint about her fam being torn apart by the revelation of her abuse. The fracture had less to do with her abuse & more to do with who among the fam was willing to take the payoff or be aligned with someone of Kelly's celebrity stature.
All in all, Who’s Watching Shorty is important, painful, & worth reading, even with its omissions. I truly hope this memoir provides the author with the healing she needs. Accountability & compassion can—& should—exist in the same space.
*I received an advance review copy for free & I am leaving this review voluntarily.*
#ThankGodForARCs