What do you think?
The Return of the Oystercatcher: Saving Birds to Save the Planet
From the New York Times best-selling author of A World on the Wing, an exploration of the efforts led by scientists, conservationists, and Indigenous peoples to save birds around the world.
As populations fall and once-great migration multitudes wither away, the future of birds may seem grim. But surprisingly, around the world, bird conservation is making things better. From the hyperlocal to the hemispherically immense, The Return of the Oystercatcher explores the recovery efforts that are not only preventing declines in bird populations but are helping them to thrive. Scott Weidensaul compiles amazing stories of hope and progress in some of the most unlikely places—from the resurgence of ducks in North America to the return of ospreys nesting in Southern Britain—to provide a road map of breathtaking environmental resilience. Because birds are so diverse, so ubiquitous, and cover virtually every square mile of the Earth’s surface, Weidensaul argues that by saving the birds we can also save the world. The result is an inspiring story of what’s working in bird conservation, recovery, and reintroduction, and what can work for the rest of the planet.
As populations fall and once-great migration multitudes wither away, the future of birds may seem grim. But surprisingly, around the world, bird conservation is making things better. From the hyperlocal to the hemispherically immense, The Return of the Oystercatcher explores the recovery efforts that are not only preventing declines in bird populations but are helping them to thrive. Scott Weidensaul compiles amazing stories of hope and progress in some of the most unlikely places—from the resurgence of ducks in North America to the return of ospreys nesting in Southern Britain—to provide a road map of breathtaking environmental resilience. Because birds are so diverse, so ubiquitous, and cover virtually every square mile of the Earth’s surface, Weidensaul argues that by saving the birds we can also save the world. The result is an inspiring story of what’s working in bird conservation, recovery, and reintroduction, and what can work for the rest of the planet.
368 pages, Hardcover
Published April 21, 2026
About the author
Scott Weidensaul
46 books150 followersBorn in 1959, Scott Weidensaul (pronounced "Why-densaul") has lived almost all of his life among the long ridges and endless valleys of eastern Pennsylvania, in the heart of the central Appalachians, a landscape that has defined much of his work.
His writing career began in 1978 with a weekly natural history column in the local newspaper, the Pottsville Republican in Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania, where he grew up. The column soon led a fulltime reporting job, which he held until 1988, when he left to become a freelance writer specializing in nature and wildlife. (He continued to write about nature for newspapers, however, including long-running columns for the Philadelphia Inquirer and Harrisburg Patriot-News.)
Weidensaul has written more than two dozen books, including his widely acclaimed Living on the Wind: Across the Hemisphere with Migratory Birds (North Point 1999), which was a finalist for the 2000 Pulitzer Prize.
Weidensaul's writing has appeared in dozens of publications, including Audubon (for which he is a contributing editor), Nature Conservancy and National Wildlife, among many others. He lectures widely on conservation and nature, and directs the ornithological programs for National Audubon's famed Hog Island Center on the coast of Maine.
In addition to writing about wildlife, Weidensaul is an active field researcher whose work focuses on bird migration. Besides banding hawks each fall (something he's done for nearly 25 years), he directs a major effort to study the movements of northern saw-whet owls, one of the smallest and least-understood raptors in North America. He is also part of a continental effort to understand the rapid evolution, by several species of western hummingbirds, of a new migratory route and wintering range in the East.
- excerpted from his website
His writing career began in 1978 with a weekly natural history column in the local newspaper, the Pottsville Republican in Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania, where he grew up. The column soon led a fulltime reporting job, which he held until 1988, when he left to become a freelance writer specializing in nature and wildlife. (He continued to write about nature for newspapers, however, including long-running columns for the Philadelphia Inquirer and Harrisburg Patriot-News.)
Weidensaul has written more than two dozen books, including his widely acclaimed Living on the Wind: Across the Hemisphere with Migratory Birds (North Point 1999), which was a finalist for the 2000 Pulitzer Prize.
Weidensaul's writing has appeared in dozens of publications, including Audubon (for which he is a contributing editor), Nature Conservancy and National Wildlife, among many others. He lectures widely on conservation and nature, and directs the ornithological programs for National Audubon's famed Hog Island Center on the coast of Maine.
In addition to writing about wildlife, Weidensaul is an active field researcher whose work focuses on bird migration. Besides banding hawks each fall (something he's done for nearly 25 years), he directs a major effort to study the movements of northern saw-whet owls, one of the smallest and least-understood raptors in North America. He is also part of a continental effort to understand the rapid evolution, by several species of western hummingbirds, of a new migratory route and wintering range in the East.
- excerpted from his website
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews
July 11, 2026
The Return of the Oystercatcher
Scott Weidensaul
#gifted by @w.w.norton - thank you!
More on my foray into birding. I loved this book. A brilliant, lengthy yet pertinent overview of birding conservation efforts over the last century or so, mostly focused on North America, but, as is necessary in birding, migratory over the entire world, offering glimpses of some of our best naturalists at work over the globe and the work that’s been done to help preserve birds and the wildness of nature as a whole.
This book offers pointed, sharp criticism of capitalist practices and specifically the Trump administration’s immeasurable harm on ecological systems at home and globally. The sheer amount of undoing and active harm the man and his following has done and is doing to wildlife is near incomprehension. He has brainwashed many of the people I know who love their land the best into allowing him to lay the groundwork to their continued, progressive separation from it as they know it.
This book is overtly positive, and says so. It claims to be a book of optimism, and it is. It’s refreshing, light spirited, and even funny detailing Weidensaul’s adventures as he lays the history of conservation for us to see. He’s able to outline the problems by shining light on success, and I find that to be a unique type of genius not encountered much lately.
Highly recommended for those interested in the natural world around them and invested in protecting it from the destruction of greed. If that isn’t you, please explain why not in the comments 🙂.
Scott Weidensaul
#gifted by @w.w.norton - thank you!
More on my foray into birding. I loved this book. A brilliant, lengthy yet pertinent overview of birding conservation efforts over the last century or so, mostly focused on North America, but, as is necessary in birding, migratory over the entire world, offering glimpses of some of our best naturalists at work over the globe and the work that’s been done to help preserve birds and the wildness of nature as a whole.
This book offers pointed, sharp criticism of capitalist practices and specifically the Trump administration’s immeasurable harm on ecological systems at home and globally. The sheer amount of undoing and active harm the man and his following has done and is doing to wildlife is near incomprehension. He has brainwashed many of the people I know who love their land the best into allowing him to lay the groundwork to their continued, progressive separation from it as they know it.
This book is overtly positive, and says so. It claims to be a book of optimism, and it is. It’s refreshing, light spirited, and even funny detailing Weidensaul’s adventures as he lays the history of conservation for us to see. He’s able to outline the problems by shining light on success, and I find that to be a unique type of genius not encountered much lately.
Highly recommended for those interested in the natural world around them and invested in protecting it from the destruction of greed. If that isn’t you, please explain why not in the comments 🙂.
May 5, 2026
Another treasure from Scott Weidensaul.
July 24, 2026
A great book for learning about the history and current state of bird conservation. The book is described by the author as being a hopeful take on conservation. While I was very inspired by the people dedicating their lives to these conservation efforts, I actually found much of the book to be quite depressing. The sad things I learned, though, are extremely important for all of us to know. He does a great job of storytelling and showing what has worked for avian conservation. The biggest takeaway I had was that nature is not, and has not been for millennia, a state in which humans are absent.
July 4, 2026
The chapters of the book that focused on a specific bird and region of the world were most interesting, whereas the parts that were mainly focused on land conservation were significantly less interesting. I also wish there was a chapter about what people can do to help birds locally; it seems like it would fit well as an epilogue.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
As populations fall, the future of birds may often seem grim. However, The Return of the Oystercatcher: Saving Birds to Save the Planet by Scott Weidensaul reveals that around the world, bird conservation is making things better. From the hyperlocal to the hemispherically immense, Scott Weidensaul explores recovery efforts that are not only preventing declines but helping species thrive. He compiles amazing stories of hope and progress in unlikely places—from tiny Pacific islands and the Canadian boreal forest to a rewilding estate in England and the wilderness on the edge of a Ukrainian war zone—to provide a roadmap of breathtaking environmental resilience. Weidensaul argues that because birds are so ubiquitous, covering virtually every square mile of the Earth, saving them is a vital step toward saving the world. The result is an inspiring look at what is working in conservation and how these successes can be applied to the rest of the planet.
I listened to the audiobook version of this title, narrated excellently by Joel Richards. As a terrestrial ecologist and amateur birder, I found this book to be an absolute "bible" of information. Weidensaul takes readers on various global expeditions, following experts on the ground to understand the evolution and recovery of numerous bird species.
The book is deeply rooted in scientific study, providing essential facts regarding population declines (numbers and reasons), human impacts and the specific human interventions helping these species recover. My favourite chapters explored the evolution of raptors in the UK, the Knepp rewilding project in England, the Danube Delta at the border of Romania and Ukraine, and the conservation of puffins and mountain plovers in the US Great Plains. The sheer volume of data on human impacts, restoration projects and rewilding is impressive. While the narrator truly brings these stories to life, as a "visual learner," I found myself wishing for a physical copy to better absorb the dense facts and figures shared throughout the chapters.
My only minor critique is the title; I felt slightly misled as oystercatchers are only discussed briefly (roughly 20 minutes of the audiobook). However, I was pleasantly surprised by the global scope. I initially worried the focus would be strictly on the US, but the inclusion of migratory species and conservation efforts worldwide was enlightening. It is incredibly comforting and hopeful to read so many success stories in one volume. This is an ecologist's 'bible' and an essential read for conservationists, ecologists, ornithologists and any citizen looking to advocate for birds and for the environment.
Thank you to NetGalley, Highbridge and Scott Weidensaul for the opportunity to review this inspiring work.
I listened to the audiobook version of this title, narrated excellently by Joel Richards. As a terrestrial ecologist and amateur birder, I found this book to be an absolute "bible" of information. Weidensaul takes readers on various global expeditions, following experts on the ground to understand the evolution and recovery of numerous bird species.
The book is deeply rooted in scientific study, providing essential facts regarding population declines (numbers and reasons), human impacts and the specific human interventions helping these species recover. My favourite chapters explored the evolution of raptors in the UK, the Knepp rewilding project in England, the Danube Delta at the border of Romania and Ukraine, and the conservation of puffins and mountain plovers in the US Great Plains. The sheer volume of data on human impacts, restoration projects and rewilding is impressive. While the narrator truly brings these stories to life, as a "visual learner," I found myself wishing for a physical copy to better absorb the dense facts and figures shared throughout the chapters.
My only minor critique is the title; I felt slightly misled as oystercatchers are only discussed briefly (roughly 20 minutes of the audiobook). However, I was pleasantly surprised by the global scope. I initially worried the focus would be strictly on the US, but the inclusion of migratory species and conservation efforts worldwide was enlightening. It is incredibly comforting and hopeful to read so many success stories in one volume. This is an ecologist's 'bible' and an essential read for conservationists, ecologists, ornithologists and any citizen looking to advocate for birds and for the environment.
Thank you to NetGalley, Highbridge and Scott Weidensaul for the opportunity to review this inspiring work.
July 2, 2026
The Return of the Oystercatcher: Saving Birds to Save the Planet is an inspiring and deeply hopeful exploration of one of the most encouraging stories in modern conservation. Scott Weidensaul demonstrates that while environmental challenges remain immense, determined collaboration between scientists, conservationists, Indigenous communities, and local citizens is producing remarkable recoveries that deserve far greater attention.
One of the book's greatest strengths is its refusal to surrender to environmental pessimism. Rather than focusing exclusively on loss and decline, Weidensaul shines a light on genuine conservation successes from the recovery of duck populations across North America to the return of ospreys in Britain and numerous other inspiring examples. These stories never minimize the seriousness of today's ecological crises; instead, they remind readers that dedicated action can and does produce meaningful results.
Equally compelling is the book's emphasis on birds as indicators of planetary health. Because birds occupy virtually every ecosystem on Earth, their fortunes reflect the condition of the habitats upon which countless other species including humans depend. Weidensaul makes a persuasive case that protecting birds ultimately means protecting forests, wetlands, coastlines, grasslands, oceans, and the intricate ecological relationships that sustain life itself.
The breadth of the narrative is particularly impressive. Moving seamlessly between continents and conservation projects, the book reveals how local initiatives often contribute to global environmental resilience. Whether highlighting scientific research, habitat restoration, migration protection, or Indigenous stewardship, every chapter reinforces the importance of cooperation and long-term commitment.
Another remarkable quality is the balance between scientific rigor and engaging storytelling. Weidensaul presents complex ecological issues with clarity and warmth, introducing readers to the dedicated individuals working tirelessly to reverse decades of environmental decline. Their passion and perseverance transform conservation from an abstract concept into a profoundly human story of hope, resilience, and responsibility.
Beautifully written and filled with optimism grounded in evidence, The Return of the Oystercatcher is essential reading for bird enthusiasts, conservationists, naturalists, environmental advocates, educators, and anyone seeking reassurance that positive environmental change remains possible. It is a powerful reminder that saving birds is not simply about protecting wildlife it is about safeguarding the future of the planet we all share.
One of the book's greatest strengths is its refusal to surrender to environmental pessimism. Rather than focusing exclusively on loss and decline, Weidensaul shines a light on genuine conservation successes from the recovery of duck populations across North America to the return of ospreys in Britain and numerous other inspiring examples. These stories never minimize the seriousness of today's ecological crises; instead, they remind readers that dedicated action can and does produce meaningful results.
Equally compelling is the book's emphasis on birds as indicators of planetary health. Because birds occupy virtually every ecosystem on Earth, their fortunes reflect the condition of the habitats upon which countless other species including humans depend. Weidensaul makes a persuasive case that protecting birds ultimately means protecting forests, wetlands, coastlines, grasslands, oceans, and the intricate ecological relationships that sustain life itself.
The breadth of the narrative is particularly impressive. Moving seamlessly between continents and conservation projects, the book reveals how local initiatives often contribute to global environmental resilience. Whether highlighting scientific research, habitat restoration, migration protection, or Indigenous stewardship, every chapter reinforces the importance of cooperation and long-term commitment.
Another remarkable quality is the balance between scientific rigor and engaging storytelling. Weidensaul presents complex ecological issues with clarity and warmth, introducing readers to the dedicated individuals working tirelessly to reverse decades of environmental decline. Their passion and perseverance transform conservation from an abstract concept into a profoundly human story of hope, resilience, and responsibility.
Beautifully written and filled with optimism grounded in evidence, The Return of the Oystercatcher is essential reading for bird enthusiasts, conservationists, naturalists, environmental advocates, educators, and anyone seeking reassurance that positive environmental change remains possible. It is a powerful reminder that saving birds is not simply about protecting wildlife it is about safeguarding the future of the planet we all share.
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
I am a fan of oystercatchers-they move in packs across the beach and graze at the ocean's edge while calling their distinctive "beep beep" as they land. That's why I had to read a book that heralded their return.
According to the author, a noted ornithologist and author of several books on the natural world, Weidensaul's friend gave him a challenge. Since his last book described the vanishing of so many bird species, could he write another one describing the good news about their return. This book describes the hopes and efforts for making this a reality. Bird diversity is essential to our ecosystem, and therefore essential to us. Before the sixties, however, birds were considered a nuisance-if they weren't just wholesale slaughtered, their environment was stripped making their existence impossible. Things began slowly changing in the sixties, especially after the publication of Silent Spring by Carson. She recognized that eliminating birds of prey, including the American Bald Eagle, as a consequence of DDT use, would cause a catastrophe. It was one of the first wakeup calls on the way to the policy of conservation.
The author describes his travels all over the world to find the places that have become central to bringing their birds back. We follow him from Hawk Mountain in Pennsylvania to England, Cape Cod, the coast of Maine, Rumania, the prairies of Wyoming and the boreal of Canada to see how different groups of concerned citizens work together to conquer impossible obstacles. When the priority is regrowing the bird population, it butts up against the wants and needs of ranchers, hunters, and people who don't want to be restricted when they are used to enjoying driving their dune buggies on the beach or walking unleashed dogs.
The author ends on a very hopeful note-an extremely large holding on Canadian land has been co-managed by the government and the indigenous people who have always lived there. It has now been handed over to the native people with the support and financial assistance of the Canadian government. This will be a great test of a good future for saving the world's bird populations.
According to the author, a noted ornithologist and author of several books on the natural world, Weidensaul's friend gave him a challenge. Since his last book described the vanishing of so many bird species, could he write another one describing the good news about their return. This book describes the hopes and efforts for making this a reality. Bird diversity is essential to our ecosystem, and therefore essential to us. Before the sixties, however, birds were considered a nuisance-if they weren't just wholesale slaughtered, their environment was stripped making their existence impossible. Things began slowly changing in the sixties, especially after the publication of Silent Spring by Carson. She recognized that eliminating birds of prey, including the American Bald Eagle, as a consequence of DDT use, would cause a catastrophe. It was one of the first wakeup calls on the way to the policy of conservation.
The author describes his travels all over the world to find the places that have become central to bringing their birds back. We follow him from Hawk Mountain in Pennsylvania to England, Cape Cod, the coast of Maine, Rumania, the prairies of Wyoming and the boreal of Canada to see how different groups of concerned citizens work together to conquer impossible obstacles. When the priority is regrowing the bird population, it butts up against the wants and needs of ranchers, hunters, and people who don't want to be restricted when they are used to enjoying driving their dune buggies on the beach or walking unleashed dogs.
The author ends on a very hopeful note-an extremely large holding on Canadian land has been co-managed by the government and the indigenous people who have always lived there. It has now been handed over to the native people with the support and financial assistance of the Canadian government. This will be a great test of a good future for saving the world's bird populations.
April 21, 2026
This book, written by experienced ornithologist and naturalist Scott Weidensaul, offers a balanced discussion of what is and isn’t working in bird conservation. He discusses conservation efforts around the world, but primarily in the United States, Canada, and Europe. Weidensaul provides enough to detail to be useful to those with professional or academic interest, while keeping it light and entertaining enough to appeal to those with a casual interest in birds and ecology like me.
The text really shines when Weidensaul discusses his time out in the field. I also loved his explanation of how conservation efforts can benefit more than just the targeted species. While I strongly support legislation such as the Endangered Species Act, laws are only as good as the effort to enforce them. Whenever possible, it’s more effective to convince people that conservation projects are in their own best interests. A great example is the discussion of persuading ranchers to improve sage-grouse habitat, because “What’s good for the bird is good for the herd.”
The back matter in the hardcover and ebook editions includes an illustrations insert, acknowledgments, references, and an index.
The audiobook production was good, and I enjoyed Joel Richards’s narration. He has a pleasant voice, and his narration suited the material, with good pacing and clear pronunciation. I think those with a serious interest in this content will likely want a hardcover or ebook that includes the back matter and allows for highlighting and notes, but for casual listeners like me, the audiobook is a wonderful choice.
This well-written book will likely appeal to anyone interested in birds, ecology, field research, and conservation efforts. I appreciate that the book left me feeling hopeful, although it didn’t gloss over the many challenges we face.
Thanks to Highbridge Audio for providing me with a free advanced review copy of the audiobook through NetGalley. I volunteered to provide an honest review.
The text really shines when Weidensaul discusses his time out in the field. I also loved his explanation of how conservation efforts can benefit more than just the targeted species. While I strongly support legislation such as the Endangered Species Act, laws are only as good as the effort to enforce them. Whenever possible, it’s more effective to convince people that conservation projects are in their own best interests. A great example is the discussion of persuading ranchers to improve sage-grouse habitat, because “What’s good for the bird is good for the herd.”
The back matter in the hardcover and ebook editions includes an illustrations insert, acknowledgments, references, and an index.
The audiobook production was good, and I enjoyed Joel Richards’s narration. He has a pleasant voice, and his narration suited the material, with good pacing and clear pronunciation. I think those with a serious interest in this content will likely want a hardcover or ebook that includes the back matter and allows for highlighting and notes, but for casual listeners like me, the audiobook is a wonderful choice.
This well-written book will likely appeal to anyone interested in birds, ecology, field research, and conservation efforts. I appreciate that the book left me feeling hopeful, although it didn’t gloss over the many challenges we face.
Thanks to Highbridge Audio for providing me with a free advanced review copy of the audiobook through NetGalley. I volunteered to provide an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
4 Stars
I am a huge bird lover, have studied and worked within wildlife conservation and so this book instantly caught my eye. Especially because I really enjoyed Scott Weidensaul's book A World on the Wing which was about issues facing migratory birds. So a book about what is going well for bird conservation?! Sign me up!
Unsurprisingly, I really enjoyed this book and thought it was a well thought out, well written and interesting book. It is split into 12 sections which look into different bird species or issues that bird conservation has overcome. Some of these include:
- The rebound of snow geese in North America
- Peregrine falcon reintroduction success post DDT bans
- Osprey and Hen Harrier success in the UK
- The rebound of vultures in Asia post NSAID poisoning (yes...anti inflammatory drugs used by Vets for livestock killed off millions of vultures, reducing their numbers by 99% and as a result increasing disease transmission in humans and a huge increase in rats. You'll have to buy the book to learn more!)
plus many many many other case studies and stories.
I thought it was a really well done book, although felt the title a little misleading since there wasn't actually much information on Oystercatchers! And I absolutely adore them so was looking forward to their section.
However, there was such a variety of bird and countries covered that I didn't feel cheated.
The writing was super interesting and engaging and held my attention. As with most nature books, I had sections that I found more interesting than others but that is normal. I would have liked some artwork of the birds featured or even a case study like summary as well. I was glad for the maps which helped me picture the scale of some of the environments spoken about.
Overall, a very good book that I highly recommend to bird lovers and conservationists. It was nice to read a book of success stories!
Please note that I was given this book in exchange for an honest review.
I am a huge bird lover, have studied and worked within wildlife conservation and so this book instantly caught my eye. Especially because I really enjoyed Scott Weidensaul's book A World on the Wing which was about issues facing migratory birds. So a book about what is going well for bird conservation?! Sign me up!
Unsurprisingly, I really enjoyed this book and thought it was a well thought out, well written and interesting book. It is split into 12 sections which look into different bird species or issues that bird conservation has overcome. Some of these include:
- The rebound of snow geese in North America
- Peregrine falcon reintroduction success post DDT bans
- Osprey and Hen Harrier success in the UK
- The rebound of vultures in Asia post NSAID poisoning (yes...anti inflammatory drugs used by Vets for livestock killed off millions of vultures, reducing their numbers by 99% and as a result increasing disease transmission in humans and a huge increase in rats. You'll have to buy the book to learn more!)
plus many many many other case studies and stories.
I thought it was a really well done book, although felt the title a little misleading since there wasn't actually much information on Oystercatchers! And I absolutely adore them so was looking forward to their section.
However, there was such a variety of bird and countries covered that I didn't feel cheated.
The writing was super interesting and engaging and held my attention. As with most nature books, I had sections that I found more interesting than others but that is normal. I would have liked some artwork of the birds featured or even a case study like summary as well. I was glad for the maps which helped me picture the scale of some of the environments spoken about.
Overall, a very good book that I highly recommend to bird lovers and conservationists. It was nice to read a book of success stories!
Please note that I was given this book in exchange for an honest review.
July 1, 2026
I picked this one up because of its title and was pleasantly surprised to discover that it was about far more than oystercatchers. As an amateur birder who has watched the number of migratory birds decline where I live as green spaces have disappeared, I am drawn to books that offer reasons for hope rather than despair.
Scott Weidensaul takes readers around the world, highlighting conservation efforts that range from local grassroots projects to international collaborations. One of the things I appreciated most was that he doesn't present these initiatives as uncomplicated success stories. He is candid about the setbacks, unintended consequences, and difficult decisions that often accompany wildlife conservation
As much as I enjoyed reading about the return of oystercatchers and the resurgence of puffin populations—these latter are birds that have brought me immense joy on two separate trips to see them in the wild—the story that stayed with me was that of the mountain plover festival in Karval, Colorado. There was something incredibly hopeful about watching a ranching community, whose livelihood has long been tied to practices that often prioritize nonnative cattle over native ecosystems, come together to celebrate and protect a bird whose survival is intertwined with their much-maligned prairie dog. It reminded me that conservation succeeds not only because habitats are restored, but because people's hearts and priorities can change.
In a time when environmental news is often discouraging, this book serves as a welcome reminder that dedicated scientists, conservationists, Indigenous communities, and ordinary citizens are making a tangible difference. It left me hopeful that saving birds can indeed become a catalyst for protecting the ecosystems on which we all depend.
Scott Weidensaul takes readers around the world, highlighting conservation efforts that range from local grassroots projects to international collaborations. One of the things I appreciated most was that he doesn't present these initiatives as uncomplicated success stories. He is candid about the setbacks, unintended consequences, and difficult decisions that often accompany wildlife conservation
As much as I enjoyed reading about the return of oystercatchers and the resurgence of puffin populations—these latter are birds that have brought me immense joy on two separate trips to see them in the wild—the story that stayed with me was that of the mountain plover festival in Karval, Colorado. There was something incredibly hopeful about watching a ranching community, whose livelihood has long been tied to practices that often prioritize nonnative cattle over native ecosystems, come together to celebrate and protect a bird whose survival is intertwined with their much-maligned prairie dog. It reminded me that conservation succeeds not only because habitats are restored, but because people's hearts and priorities can change.
In a time when environmental news is often discouraging, this book serves as a welcome reminder that dedicated scientists, conservationists, Indigenous communities, and ordinary citizens are making a tangible difference. It left me hopeful that saving birds can indeed become a catalyst for protecting the ecosystems on which we all depend.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I don’t want to be overly critical of this book because 1) I went in with unwarranted expectations and 2) it is very clear the author cares about and loves birds a great deal. Indeed, he’s successfully gotten me to care about and understand more about species I’ve never heard of or think about rarely.
That said, I don’t understand why this book is titled the way it is. Oystercatchers take up, no joke, less than five pages. The 12 chapters (the middle ones I enjoyed the most as they aligned most closely to my marine interests) focus on policy and individual or community level approaches to protecting various bird species around the world and much of that focus is on land conservation and rehabilitating ecosystem functioning. It is fascinating stuff but often I found myself, after tens of pages of reading about land conservation policy, wondering what exactly that had to do with birds (these two are, of course, closely linked, a bit more organization within the chapters and book as a whole would have guided my expectations).
I’m not a bird person, so this was going to be out of my comfort zone from the get go. For ornithologists, professionals or amateur, though this is probably an excellent survey of critical bird species. I deeply appreciated how Weidensaul tied in domestic and international policy throughout as again, that is closer to my interests and what I look to get out of nonfiction.
While I did find chunks of the book challenging to get through, others I raced through and even found prose that beautifully rendered the conversation in emphatic and moving ways.
That said, I don’t understand why this book is titled the way it is. Oystercatchers take up, no joke, less than five pages. The 12 chapters (the middle ones I enjoyed the most as they aligned most closely to my marine interests) focus on policy and individual or community level approaches to protecting various bird species around the world and much of that focus is on land conservation and rehabilitating ecosystem functioning. It is fascinating stuff but often I found myself, after tens of pages of reading about land conservation policy, wondering what exactly that had to do with birds (these two are, of course, closely linked, a bit more organization within the chapters and book as a whole would have guided my expectations).
I’m not a bird person, so this was going to be out of my comfort zone from the get go. For ornithologists, professionals or amateur, though this is probably an excellent survey of critical bird species. I deeply appreciated how Weidensaul tied in domestic and international policy throughout as again, that is closer to my interests and what I look to get out of nonfiction.
While I did find chunks of the book challenging to get through, others I raced through and even found prose that beautifully rendered the conversation in emphatic and moving ways.
July 30, 2026
Review: The Return of the Oystercatcher: Saving Birds to Save the Planet (Scott Weidensaul) I thoroughly enjoyed Scott Weidensaul's presentation of this book at the Music Hall lounge some months ago and have been reading it bit by bit at work during breaks. The amount of research, and travel, and meetings he put into the creation of this work is formidable, and it is sometimes overwhelming with details of bird names, place names and so forth... but I feel I have learned an enormous amount on so many levels... I love birds but am not a birder myself (other than feeding them every day on my porch railing and enjoying admiring them), but, as this book makes abundantly clear, birds are only one integral part of conservation efforts throughout the world. There is a lot of history here, too, and it spans large portions of the globe; the globetrotting itself was fascinating and described in detail. The author took care to include the name of everybody he came in contact with. So of course, it is all about reversing decades if not centuries of degrading our beautiful planet by destroying habitats and species for our own selfish and often unneeded entitled pleasures, but mostly about the rising consciousness of how dependent our planet is on activism around conservation...and on dialogue to help others understand that (one of my favorite phrases in the book) "what is good for the birds is good for the land."
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thoroughly enjoyable and compelling. I sped through it! Very interesting but sometimes depressing stories. I enjoyed the stories of the authors adventures more than politics or policy.
BUT, I think with a title and cover like this the book should be focus on Oystercatchers! They only get some attention nearly 80% of the way through. I was looking forward to learning more about them and comparing to our Oystercatchers.
It should've been named something like Adventures in Bird Conservation or The Rewards of Rewilding.
The audiobook was very easy to listen to but the narrator should check the pronunciation of foreign/overseas people and place names. Eg since I'm from NZ: Our previous prime minister was John Key not kay. (also the book makes it sound like Macquarie Island belongs to NZ when it's Australian. The author should've visited Tiritiri Matangi Island! It's an amazing predator free offshore island you can visit. Bird paradise!).
The American pronunciation was at times a bit jarring eg : Fecund, quarry.
Recommended for any nature lovers!
Thank you to Netgalley for the advance audiobook copy.
BUT, I think with a title and cover like this the book should be focus on Oystercatchers! They only get some attention nearly 80% of the way through. I was looking forward to learning more about them and comparing to our Oystercatchers.
It should've been named something like Adventures in Bird Conservation or The Rewards of Rewilding.
The audiobook was very easy to listen to but the narrator should check the pronunciation of foreign/overseas people and place names. Eg since I'm from NZ: Our previous prime minister was John Key not kay. (also the book makes it sound like Macquarie Island belongs to NZ when it's Australian. The author should've visited Tiritiri Matangi Island! It's an amazing predator free offshore island you can visit. Bird paradise!).
The American pronunciation was at times a bit jarring eg : Fecund, quarry.
Recommended for any nature lovers!
Thank you to Netgalley for the advance audiobook copy.
April 22, 2026
The Return of the Oystercatcher by Scott Weidensaul distinguishes itself by doing what most environmental narratives fail to achieve, it presents credible, evidence-based optimism without diluting the urgency of ecological decline.
Rather than centering loss, the book systematically highlights recovery. Through rigorously reported case studies, Weidensaul demonstrates that targeted conservation efforts, spanning scientific innovation, policy alignment, and Indigenous stewardship, are not only slowing decline but actively reversing it. This reframes conservation from a defensive effort into a strategic, results-driven discipline.
The broader implication is clear: birds function as both indicators and leverage points within global ecosystems. By focusing on their recovery, the book presents a scalable model for environmental restoration, positioning it as both a compelling narrative and a practical blueprint for planetary resilience.
Rather than centering loss, the book systematically highlights recovery. Through rigorously reported case studies, Weidensaul demonstrates that targeted conservation efforts, spanning scientific innovation, policy alignment, and Indigenous stewardship, are not only slowing decline but actively reversing it. This reframes conservation from a defensive effort into a strategic, results-driven discipline.
The broader implication is clear: birds function as both indicators and leverage points within global ecosystems. By focusing on their recovery, the book presents a scalable model for environmental restoration, positioning it as both a compelling narrative and a practical blueprint for planetary resilience.
July 20, 2026
What a delight to read a book that talks about both the challenges and the successes in conservation -- optimism throughout, but with an honest assessment of the large amount of bad news alongside. The audiobook is also superbly read -- it's a remarkably soothing thing to listen to, and just packed full of interesting stuff: people, ideas and attempts, politics, places in the world, movements and their fallout. I'm fascinated by the rewilding work, and what that looks like in vastly different parts of the world. I love that Scott is talking to so many people in different roles and with different ideas. I love that there are some good news stories in the world, and that so many of them are about improving everything for everyone, and the birds also benefit. Would read a sequel, would love to hear more. Weidensaul's passion for birds and for wild spaces flows throughout.
Advanced Listening copy provided by Libro.fm.
Advanced Listening copy provided by Libro.fm.
September 13, 2026
At a time when the impacts of climate change are seen every day, from the latest deadly flooding event to the next out of control wildfire burning hundreds of acres, optimism about slowing, or even reversing, the impacts may be little to none. But in Scott Weidensaul’s book, there is optimism in the persons he introduces the reader to.
From the east coast of the United States to Great Britain, Ukraine and Canada, Weidensaul interviews people working to increase the numbers of vulnerable bird species. From the oystercatcher to the sage grouse, puffins and plovers to vultures, there are many whose optimism isn’t gone. While saving the birds, these people are also doing something else - rewilding the land that houses more than just these winged creatures.
While there’s a lot to be worried about regarding the climate and the impacts the changes are bringing… as Scott said in the first line, “this book is about optimism”.
From the east coast of the United States to Great Britain, Ukraine and Canada, Weidensaul interviews people working to increase the numbers of vulnerable bird species. From the oystercatcher to the sage grouse, puffins and plovers to vultures, there are many whose optimism isn’t gone. While saving the birds, these people are also doing something else - rewilding the land that houses more than just these winged creatures.
While there’s a lot to be worried about regarding the climate and the impacts the changes are bringing… as Scott said in the first line, “this book is about optimism”.
May 30, 2026
An absolutely excellent book! I've been a bird watcher for about 7 years now so a book with the word Oystercatcher immediately got my attention. But this book is about so much more than just a unique looking shorebird; it's about many other species (bird and non-bird) and the interconnected relationship between the health of our land (and the health of people) and the biodiversity of species needed to maintain that health. The author pulled no punches in describing the stark devastation species have endured at the hands of people. However, his descriptions of the hard work of conservationists around the world gave me hope of a better future for us all
June 1, 2026
Scott Weidensaul takes you on a world wide tour from Romania to Hawaii to learn about so many efforts to keep bird species from going extinct and to reintroduce them to areas from which they have disappeared. I loved visiting Knepp, of course, and was totally thrilled learning about rewilding but also learning about greater sage grouse and its remarkable ecosystem in the Western states. Ending elegantly with the remarkable work first nations are doing in Canada, this is a hopeful and joy filled book about how to make change happen.
May 11, 2026
While I loved this book, the easy to understand information presented, and was excited with how much I got to learn about bird conservation (which didn’t know much about) and how that interacts with the planet, the ending part and the historical section was so devastating that it kind of overshadowed the bird aspect, though I’m not complaining too much about it. I didn’t know national parks had such a dark history. I’m glad this book explained it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 7, 2026
As someone who is deep in their bird era, I loved this book so much. It was great to hear all about rewilding as a means to bring endangered or nearly extinct birds back to better populations. I loved the variety of birds that were discussed and all of the unique challenges each one faces, as well as the different strategies taken by scientist to help them!
The narrator was well paced and had a nice voice to listen to!
Thank you NetGalley and HighBridge Audio for this ARC!
The narrator was well paced and had a nice voice to listen to!
Thank you NetGalley and HighBridge Audio for this ARC!
June 19, 2026
Excellent book that opened my eyes to the sheer necessity of bird conservation for the well-being of our planet, in a critical time when human actions are causing the planet to heat up and upsetting the ecosystem. It inspired me to check out the National Audubon Society and actively be in the loop about ways to contribute to bird conservation efforts across the country. Thanks to the publisher for this giveaway copy!
May 15, 2026
Weidensaul is an excellent nature author, and it's great that he's written about some success stories for various species in the face of so much bad news (as he wrote about in A World On The Wing).
Be prepared for lots of detail and analysis. As a book nerd I appreciated it, but as a reader it slowed me down sometimes. His descriptions of the people in the book offsets that.
Be prepared for lots of detail and analysis. As a book nerd I appreciated it, but as a reader it slowed me down sometimes. His descriptions of the people in the book offsets that.
August 15, 2026
Not actually a ton about oystercatchers, but a lot about different models of conservation and protecting public lands, with enough personal experience narrative to keep the book interesting.
I listened to the audiobook, which was generally well done albeit with a mispronunciation here and there ("wigguns"??).
I listened to the audiobook, which was generally well done albeit with a mispronunciation here and there ("wigguns"??).
June 20, 2026
A surprisingly readable worldwide coverage of threats to birds of all ilk and the inventive, difficult, and various measures being taken to turn those threats around. I recommend it to birders and non birders alike.
September 4, 2026
I really enjoyed the travel and adventure aspects of this book, and the stories of how the fates of some bird species have been turned around by humans. However, there were a lot of statistics included and this got tiresome.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Review will be forthcoming in Audubon Magazine!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Beautifully written and thought-provoking especially in terms of human attitudes and relationships towards animals and land.
June 11, 2026
Fantastic, as always with Scott Weidensaul. Historical, engaging, optimistic.
August 1, 2026
Let's hear it for birds and wildlife in general.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews