What do you think?
Rate this book
Lighthouse Library Mystery #13
Whose Body in the Library
Not yet published
Expected 9 Jun 26A new librarian’s first day goes terribly wrong when she finds a dead body on the front steps of the library.
While Lucy McNeil is enjoying her new job as the mother of twin boys and library director, new librarian Nichelle Gilchrest has just arrived at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library, reporting for duty. But life throws a wrench on Nichelle’s first day when she finds a body on the steps–a body that bears a startling resemblance to her father who disappeared on a fishing trip to the Outer Banks thirty-eight years ago.
Fingerprints confirm the dead body is indeed Nichelle’s father, now living in Nags Head under the name Brian Saunders. Brian had been befriending older lonely women in exchange for money, but was he working alone?
Detective Rhonda Thomas is on the case and the suspect list is only getting longer. Sorting through the wronged women and their relatives, Detective Thomas discovers Nichelle’s own brother Brad had been in Nags Head a few days before the murder happened and has been lying about his whereabouts.
Hoping to clear her brother’s name, Nichelle decides to investigate what happened. With seasoned sleuth Lucy’s gentle encouragement for the amateur, Nichelle is in for an exciting and dangerous first week at the library.
While Lucy McNeil is enjoying her new job as the mother of twin boys and library director, new librarian Nichelle Gilchrest has just arrived at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library, reporting for duty. But life throws a wrench on Nichelle’s first day when she finds a body on the steps–a body that bears a startling resemblance to her father who disappeared on a fishing trip to the Outer Banks thirty-eight years ago.
Fingerprints confirm the dead body is indeed Nichelle’s father, now living in Nags Head under the name Brian Saunders. Brian had been befriending older lonely women in exchange for money, but was he working alone?
Detective Rhonda Thomas is on the case and the suspect list is only getting longer. Sorting through the wronged women and their relatives, Detective Thomas discovers Nichelle’s own brother Brad had been in Nags Head a few days before the murder happened and has been lying about his whereabouts.
Hoping to clear her brother’s name, Nichelle decides to investigate what happened. With seasoned sleuth Lucy’s gentle encouragement for the amateur, Nichelle is in for an exciting and dangerous first week at the library.
304 pages, Hardcover
Expected publication June 9, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews
March 29, 2026
Whose Body in the Library is the 13th installment the Lighthouse Library Mysteries written by Eva Gates AKA Vicki Delany? I'm a fan of all her work and grab the latest release whenever possible, this time thanks to NetGalley. This book marks a notable change in the way the author tells the story, as we see a focus on a newcomer to the library, who just like our usual protagonist, Lucy, finds a body on the steps her first day. Lucy just gave birth to twins, so she has a lot more on her plate than usual, including taking over for the retiring Library Director. I enjoyed the change of pace and the new character who learns a lot about her mysterious, disappearing father, as well as the rest of her family. Good plot, interesting connections to the North Carolina town setting, and it sets the stage for a duo of amateur detectives, perhaps, in future installments to come.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
In this installment of the Lighthouse Library mystery series, we're introduced to the new assistant director of the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library, Nichelle Gilchrest. The story is told primarily through Nichelle's perspective, which I found to be a fun change of pace as Lucy is busy as a new mom to twin boys. Divorced, with grown children and a newly minted college degree, relocating to the beautiful Outer Banks of North Carolina is just the fresh start Nichelle has been hoping for. Unfortunately, on the first morning of her new job, she discovers a dead body on the steps of the library that bears a startling resemblance to her father who disappeared thirty-eight years earlier. With series regulars helping Nichelle get aquainted with this charming seaside town, and a deftly plotted mystery, this was a fun read from beginning to end. Looking forward to what comes next for this likeable new protagonist!
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me the opportunity to read an eARC. All thoughts are my own.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me the opportunity to read an eARC. All thoughts are my own.
April 14, 2026
"Whose Body in the Library (A Lighthouse Library Mystery #13)" by Eva Gates is a great example of how to transition a series that was starting to feel played out. I have renewed interest in this series. For purposes of the transition from the original POV/main character, this book is split POV/main character.
Lucy McNeil is back to work after her maternity leave with her identical twin boys. She's now the boss and looking forward to what the library's new assistant director will offer. Lucy still has a couple chapters of her point of view sprinkled throughout the book. However, she has a smaller role for the first time in the series.
Introducing, Nichelle Gilchrest! Yes, Nichelle, like the Star Trek actress. She is a divorced mother to adult, identical twin girls and she recently went back to college for her library sciences degree. She's wanting to start her life fresh by moving into the Lighthouse Library apartment and be it's newest assistant head librarian. Lucky for her, the library cat approves and moves back into the apartment with her.
Nichelle's first day starts out about the same as Lucy's did. A body at the front steps of the lighthouse. Could it be a long thought dead relative? This pulls Nichelle in as the primary point of view but with many of the characters we've become familiar with. By the end of the book I had almost forgotten it transitioned to a new main character.
Lucy McNeil is back to work after her maternity leave with her identical twin boys. She's now the boss and looking forward to what the library's new assistant director will offer. Lucy still has a couple chapters of her point of view sprinkled throughout the book. However, she has a smaller role for the first time in the series.
Introducing, Nichelle Gilchrest! Yes, Nichelle, like the Star Trek actress. She is a divorced mother to adult, identical twin girls and she recently went back to college for her library sciences degree. She's wanting to start her life fresh by moving into the Lighthouse Library apartment and be it's newest assistant head librarian. Lucky for her, the library cat approves and moves back into the apartment with her.
Nichelle's first day starts out about the same as Lucy's did. A body at the front steps of the lighthouse. Could it be a long thought dead relative? This pulls Nichelle in as the primary point of view but with many of the characters we've become familiar with. By the end of the book I had almost forgotten it transitioned to a new main character.
May 5, 2026
Whose Body in the Library is the 13th (!) novel in the Lighthouse Library series, a favourite cozy mystery series of mine. This book marks a departure in our protagonist, as Lucy now has family commitments and a new position at the library. Eva Gates introduces us to Nichelle Gilchrist, a middle-aged recently graduated librarian starting a new life for herself. She procures the job of assistant director, moves to Nags Head and the lighthouse aerie apartment, and promptly finds herself solving a murder.
I was a little nervous about the change of protagonist, but it works! I enjoyed getting to know Nichelle while Lucy and our library regulars were in the background. This is a well-written mystery, typical of the series, and as always, I appreciated the book club read tie-in with the novel.
Another fantastic novel with a positive protagonist shift.
Thank you to Netgalley and Crooked Lane Books for an eARC in exchange for honest review.
I was a little nervous about the change of protagonist, but it works! I enjoyed getting to know Nichelle while Lucy and our library regulars were in the background. This is a well-written mystery, typical of the series, and as always, I appreciated the book club read tie-in with the novel.
Another fantastic novel with a positive protagonist shift.
Thank you to Netgalley and Crooked Lane Books for an eARC in exchange for honest review.
March 26, 2026
*2.5 stars ✨
December 27, 2025
As someone who usually reads thriller, intense fast-paced mysteries, this cozy mystery was a refreshing change of pace.
I loved the set up: Nichelle’s first day as a librarian was hectic as she found a dead body— who was later revealed to be her long lost father which made the situation more personal and crazier. The charming setting, at a small town near the beach and library, is perfect.
Though I did wish the reveal was less predictable, but I understand this is as an aspect that differed from what I usually read rather than a flaw in the writing. Other than this, I’d say the book was executed wonderfully and hits all the right notes for its genre.
For readers who want to read a cozy, chill, easy-going mystery, this is perfect for you.
Thank you Netgalley and Crooked Lane Books for the eARC!
I loved the set up: Nichelle’s first day as a librarian was hectic as she found a dead body— who was later revealed to be her long lost father which made the situation more personal and crazier. The charming setting, at a small town near the beach and library, is perfect.
Though I did wish the reveal was less predictable, but I understand this is as an aspect that differed from what I usually read rather than a flaw in the writing. Other than this, I’d say the book was executed wonderfully and hits all the right notes for its genre.
For readers who want to read a cozy, chill, easy-going mystery, this is perfect for you.
Thank you Netgalley and Crooked Lane Books for the eARC!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Lucy McNeil is beginning her new job as library director and new hire, Nichelle Gilchrest has arrived to fill her usual spot. Nichelle is excited, having upended her old life to move here but her first day doesn't go as planned. As she opens the doors of the lighthouse library to welcome her first day library users, she finds a dead body on the steps. Lucy arrives at about the same time and knows the routine, so it isn't as disruptive as it might be, but there's another issue. Nichelle sees a startling resemblance in the dead man to her father who disappeared many years ago and has been thought dead. There's also a new detective in town, Detective Rhonda Thomas, who is very by the book and regularly tells Nichelle not to get involved. I bet you can guess how much good that did her, huh?
Long time series fans, don't despair. Lucy is still there, just playing a diminished, backup role. Let's face it. She's now the mother of very young twins and sleuthing isn't exactly on her priority list. She's there for Nichelle (yes, her name has a Star Trek connection) but really isn't involved in the investigation. Nichelle's initial interest is really as much on what brought the man she suspects might be her father to her new doorstep only to be murdered as on who did it. Oh, of course, that changes when she learns who the chief suspect is. Nope, not telling. You'll have to read the book. I'm not going to give away any more of the plot but it's a solid one that does offer an occasional chapter from Lucy's viewpoint. The usual cast of characters isn't showcased as much as long time fans might wisht, well, except for, sigh, the one character that has always grated on me while I must still admit she adds a certain touch of quirkiness to the plots. Even Lucy still hasn't quite sorted out how best to deal with her, which I'm sure will add a few laughs as the series continues with Nichelle as the focus. Oh, and least I forget, Charles the library cat is definitely on hand.
Bottom line, Eva Gates had me wondering when I read the initial news about Lucy stepping back but this one works nicely. I liked Nichelle, even when she was making some very rookie sleuth mistakes. Hey, they all have to start somewhere. As always, the lighthouse itself is practically a character and Gates descriptions of its history and the surrounding area are excellent. While we didn't get to meet all of Nichelle's family this go-round, we've been at least introduced and I'm sure it's no accident that she, like Lucy, has twins, albeit grown daughters. It was also subtle but I think we may come to like the new detective, too, although I'm sure Rhonda and Nichelle will butt heads more than a few times in the process although the likable, but retired Sam Watson is still around. Thanks #CrookedLaneBooks for introducing me initially to Lucy and allowing me this early peek at the arrival of Nichelle to take over some of the work load, probably both work and sleuthing. I do hope Lucy will find time for not just get some sleep but to pop in-and-out as the series continues. We do want to get to know Isaac and Lucas, too, hint, hint. Grin.
Long time series fans, don't despair. Lucy is still there, just playing a diminished, backup role. Let's face it. She's now the mother of very young twins and sleuthing isn't exactly on her priority list. She's there for Nichelle (yes, her name has a Star Trek connection) but really isn't involved in the investigation. Nichelle's initial interest is really as much on what brought the man she suspects might be her father to her new doorstep only to be murdered as on who did it. Oh, of course, that changes when she learns who the chief suspect is. Nope, not telling. You'll have to read the book. I'm not going to give away any more of the plot but it's a solid one that does offer an occasional chapter from Lucy's viewpoint. The usual cast of characters isn't showcased as much as long time fans might wisht, well, except for, sigh, the one character that has always grated on me while I must still admit she adds a certain touch of quirkiness to the plots. Even Lucy still hasn't quite sorted out how best to deal with her, which I'm sure will add a few laughs as the series continues with Nichelle as the focus. Oh, and least I forget, Charles the library cat is definitely on hand.
Bottom line, Eva Gates had me wondering when I read the initial news about Lucy stepping back but this one works nicely. I liked Nichelle, even when she was making some very rookie sleuth mistakes. Hey, they all have to start somewhere. As always, the lighthouse itself is practically a character and Gates descriptions of its history and the surrounding area are excellent. While we didn't get to meet all of Nichelle's family this go-round, we've been at least introduced and I'm sure it's no accident that she, like Lucy, has twins, albeit grown daughters. It was also subtle but I think we may come to like the new detective, too, although I'm sure Rhonda and Nichelle will butt heads more than a few times in the process although the likable, but retired Sam Watson is still around. Thanks #CrookedLaneBooks for introducing me initially to Lucy and allowing me this early peek at the arrival of Nichelle to take over some of the work load, probably both work and sleuthing. I do hope Lucy will find time for not just get some sleep but to pop in-and-out as the series continues. We do want to get to know Isaac and Lucas, too, hint, hint. Grin.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
📱📖 Read on Kindle | 📃 304 pages
⏱ Approx. 4 hours reading time
🏷️ Publisher: Crooked Lane Books
📅 Release Date: June 9, 2026
📘 ARC provided by NetGalley
🔍 Genre: Cozy Mystery
Eva Gates shakes things up in Whose Body in the Library, and longtime fans like me definitely feel it. Swapping out Lucy’s familiar first-person narration for a dual POV approach, mostly following newcomer Nichelle, makes this entry feel like walking through your own house but finding the furniture rearranged. Everything’s recognizable, yet slightly off-kilter. Lucy’s still around, juggling motherhood and library management, but the emotional center shifts to Nichelle’s family drama and her rocky first week surrounded by suspicious small-town secrets.
For longtime readers, that shift is jarring. We know the town, the people, and their secrets, but Nichelle doesn’t, and those gaps aren’t filled in. Familiar characters feel oddly distant, and the emotional shorthand that usually makes this series so cozy just isn’t there. Nichelle’s arc is intriguing. A woman confronting a past she thought was buried thirty-eight years ago, but the pacing and investigative beats don’t quite land with the same cozy confidence as previous installments. The addition of Detective Rhonda Thomas, who is rigid and rule-bound in contrast to the easygoing Sam Watson, further unsettles the balance. Her treatment of Lucy, in particular, left me uneasy and not especially excited to see her stick around.
The mystery itself, centered on Nichelle’s long-estranged father and the unsettling legacy he left behind, has solid bones, but the execution felt rough. Nichelle’s lack of sleuthing experience is understandable, yet the investigation and resolution never fully clicked. It’s like driving a familiar road and suddenly realizing the seat’s been adjusted just enough to throw everything off. I wanted to love this one more than I did, but it didn’t quite settle into place. Still, Eva Gates’ atmospheric details and character warmth shine through. Even when the mystery falters, the Outer Banks charm and community affection keep you turning pages. And one slightly off installment in a long-running series as consistent as this? Hardly a dealbreaker.
Would I recommend it?
A solid, if uneven, addition to the Lighthouse Library Mysteries. As a standalone or a transitional book, it works, but as a longtime fan of this series, it felt off in ways I couldn’t ignore. That said, one uneven entry won’t shake my loyalty to Eva Gates (aka Vicki Delany). I’ll absolutely be back for the next installment, hopeful that Lucy returns to center stage and the series finds its familiar rhythm again. If you’re curious to see life at the library through fresh eyes, add this to your TBR. Longtime fans may feel conflicted, but I’m not giving up on this lighthouse just yet.
⏱ Approx. 4 hours reading time
🏷️ Publisher: Crooked Lane Books
📅 Release Date: June 9, 2026
📘 ARC provided by NetGalley
🔍 Genre: Cozy Mystery
Eva Gates shakes things up in Whose Body in the Library, and longtime fans like me definitely feel it. Swapping out Lucy’s familiar first-person narration for a dual POV approach, mostly following newcomer Nichelle, makes this entry feel like walking through your own house but finding the furniture rearranged. Everything’s recognizable, yet slightly off-kilter. Lucy’s still around, juggling motherhood and library management, but the emotional center shifts to Nichelle’s family drama and her rocky first week surrounded by suspicious small-town secrets.
For longtime readers, that shift is jarring. We know the town, the people, and their secrets, but Nichelle doesn’t, and those gaps aren’t filled in. Familiar characters feel oddly distant, and the emotional shorthand that usually makes this series so cozy just isn’t there. Nichelle’s arc is intriguing. A woman confronting a past she thought was buried thirty-eight years ago, but the pacing and investigative beats don’t quite land with the same cozy confidence as previous installments. The addition of Detective Rhonda Thomas, who is rigid and rule-bound in contrast to the easygoing Sam Watson, further unsettles the balance. Her treatment of Lucy, in particular, left me uneasy and not especially excited to see her stick around.
The mystery itself, centered on Nichelle’s long-estranged father and the unsettling legacy he left behind, has solid bones, but the execution felt rough. Nichelle’s lack of sleuthing experience is understandable, yet the investigation and resolution never fully clicked. It’s like driving a familiar road and suddenly realizing the seat’s been adjusted just enough to throw everything off. I wanted to love this one more than I did, but it didn’t quite settle into place. Still, Eva Gates’ atmospheric details and character warmth shine through. Even when the mystery falters, the Outer Banks charm and community affection keep you turning pages. And one slightly off installment in a long-running series as consistent as this? Hardly a dealbreaker.
Would I recommend it?
A solid, if uneven, addition to the Lighthouse Library Mysteries. As a standalone or a transitional book, it works, but as a longtime fan of this series, it felt off in ways I couldn’t ignore. That said, one uneven entry won’t shake my loyalty to Eva Gates (aka Vicki Delany). I’ll absolutely be back for the next installment, hopeful that Lucy returns to center stage and the series finds its familiar rhythm again. If you’re curious to see life at the library through fresh eyes, add this to your TBR. Longtime fans may feel conflicted, but I’m not giving up on this lighthouse just yet.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Once again we venture back to Nags Head, North Carolina and the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library. This time out, Lucy McNeil has a new job as director of the library, and there is a new librarian, Nichelle Gilchrest.
Nichelle is in her 50's and starting over with a degree in her pocket and her nerves on edge as to whether she'll fit in or not. That feeling doesn't change when she opens the library doors the next morning and finds a body on the doorstep. Moreover, that body could be her long-long father, who deserted the family thirty-eight years ago and presumed drowned at sea during a fishing trip.
Now the new detective, Rhonda Thomas, is warning Nichelle to stay out of it, and Lucy is trying not to get involved, with her new job and new twins taking over her life. But when Nichelle's brother becomes a sudden suspect, she's determined to find the truth, but doesn't know how to go about it.
With the help of Louise Jane, whose never-ending 'knowledge' of people and things in the Outer Banks, Nichelle is learning who might be responsible. But can she keep herself safe or will she walk into the arms of a killer?...
This is the latest book in the series, and I have enjoyed them. I love every time I get to visit the Outer Banks, and with Lucy and her friends. But this time out is different. Lucy is a side character, and the mystery seems to focus on Nichelle (as it should, since she is the new character) and Louise Jane (whom I have never been fond of). But I have to say that I cannot warm up to Detective Thomas. She's not likable, and doesn't seem to want to make friends of the residents, which I think she should do since it's a small community. You can be professional and still have friends that you deal with. Sam Watson proved that.
There is very little of the other characters that we've grown to love as well, so we're in new territory all around here. The way we keep Lucy in the story is the difference in which it is written. First person for Nichelle, third person for Lucy.
The mystery is written well, as always; and I enjoy Ms. Gates so much that I read her books straight through. This one is no different. The plot keeps you guessing, although I did figure out the murderer before Nichelle; but when she figures it out herself, there's more work to be done before the murderer can be apprehended.
There are clues throughout, and descriptions of the area aplenty which always add to the story. When the ending comes it is put together well, and I will read the next in the series. Recommended.
I was given an advance copy of this book from the publisher and NetGalley but this in no way influenced my review.
Nichelle is in her 50's and starting over with a degree in her pocket and her nerves on edge as to whether she'll fit in or not. That feeling doesn't change when she opens the library doors the next morning and finds a body on the doorstep. Moreover, that body could be her long-long father, who deserted the family thirty-eight years ago and presumed drowned at sea during a fishing trip.
Now the new detective, Rhonda Thomas, is warning Nichelle to stay out of it, and Lucy is trying not to get involved, with her new job and new twins taking over her life. But when Nichelle's brother becomes a sudden suspect, she's determined to find the truth, but doesn't know how to go about it.
With the help of Louise Jane, whose never-ending 'knowledge' of people and things in the Outer Banks, Nichelle is learning who might be responsible. But can she keep herself safe or will she walk into the arms of a killer?...
This is the latest book in the series, and I have enjoyed them. I love every time I get to visit the Outer Banks, and with Lucy and her friends. But this time out is different. Lucy is a side character, and the mystery seems to focus on Nichelle (as it should, since she is the new character) and Louise Jane (whom I have never been fond of). But I have to say that I cannot warm up to Detective Thomas. She's not likable, and doesn't seem to want to make friends of the residents, which I think she should do since it's a small community. You can be professional and still have friends that you deal with. Sam Watson proved that.
There is very little of the other characters that we've grown to love as well, so we're in new territory all around here. The way we keep Lucy in the story is the difference in which it is written. First person for Nichelle, third person for Lucy.
The mystery is written well, as always; and I enjoy Ms. Gates so much that I read her books straight through. This one is no different. The plot keeps you guessing, although I did figure out the murderer before Nichelle; but when she figures it out herself, there's more work to be done before the murderer can be apprehended.
There are clues throughout, and descriptions of the area aplenty which always add to the story. When the ending comes it is put together well, and I will read the next in the series. Recommended.
I was given an advance copy of this book from the publisher and NetGalley but this in no way influenced my review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Whose Body in the Library
Review without spoilers
3⭐
I got the ARC through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to Eva Gates, the publisher and NetGalley for this ARC. All thoughts are my own.
This story follows Nichelle (yes, Star Trek!!) as she starts a new job as a librarian. However, on the first day of the job, she finds her (lost-long) dad dead in the doorway of the library. Her brother, Brad (named after the father), is one of the suspects of this murder! With Nichelle, we try to understand who and for what reason killed Brian Saunders.
To be honest, I pretty much love anything with a library or a bookstore setting. It’s an instant +1. I felt the coziness of being surrounded by books in this book despite the lack of descriptions of the time spent or just the library itself.
The book is quite interesting. However, for the majority of the book we don’t find out anything at all. No mid-plot twists to keep the readers on their toes. Therefore, the pace of the book was really slow. And the thing is, the ending wasn’t surprising. It was pretty guessable and cliché. I wish there was an unexpected, jaw-dropping twist that made all the slow-paced reading worth the time.
The writing was okay, nothing special. Depending on your level of course, I think the English was pretty easy to understand. If the writing was bad, I would have definitely DNF'd the book.
I’d recommend this book to anyone who wants a quick, no-brainer mystery and def someone who doesn’t mind the slow pacing.
P.s. could’ve named the title ‘Whose Bodie in the Library’ and the best character was def the cat!! ♡
Thank you again for the ARC!
Review without spoilers
3⭐
I got the ARC through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to Eva Gates, the publisher and NetGalley for this ARC. All thoughts are my own.
This story follows Nichelle (yes, Star Trek!!) as she starts a new job as a librarian. However, on the first day of the job, she finds her (lost-long) dad dead in the doorway of the library. Her brother, Brad (named after the father), is one of the suspects of this murder! With Nichelle, we try to understand who and for what reason killed Brian Saunders.
To be honest, I pretty much love anything with a library or a bookstore setting. It’s an instant +1. I felt the coziness of being surrounded by books in this book despite the lack of descriptions of the time spent or just the library itself.
The book is quite interesting. However, for the majority of the book we don’t find out anything at all. No mid-plot twists to keep the readers on their toes. Therefore, the pace of the book was really slow. And the thing is, the ending wasn’t surprising. It was pretty guessable and cliché. I wish there was an unexpected, jaw-dropping twist that made all the slow-paced reading worth the time.
The writing was okay, nothing special. Depending on your level of course, I think the English was pretty easy to understand. If the writing was bad, I would have definitely DNF'd the book.
I’d recommend this book to anyone who wants a quick, no-brainer mystery and def someone who doesn’t mind the slow pacing.
P.s. could’ve named the title ‘Whose Bodie in the Library’ and the best character was def the cat!! ♡
Thank you again for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This may come across as shallow, but there was a cat on a beach reading a book on the cover — that was it. I had to read it. His name is Charles!
Nichelle, a newcomer starting over in life, got a good bit more than she bargained for when she accepted a position at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library. Luckily, she has plenty of help to straighten things out.
The setting is the quiet star of Whose Body in the Library — Jake’s Seafood Bar, Josie’s Cozy Bakery, and, of course, the library in the lighthouse. The story skirts the edge of the Cozy genre, but is a touch too realistic to settle there. Still, it has that warmth, strong vacay vibes, and a lovely aesthetic. This is an ideal beach read! The characters, too, while eccentric and distinct, feel like real people. I don’t know if Louise Jane would drive me up the wall or amuse me in real life, but I enjoy her on the page. I love characters that are allowed to breathe; this cast isn’t made up of angels or villains, but folks that fall in between.
The plot is solid, although I do find Nichelle’s conviction a little premature. That said, I also felt that the events that followed were inevitable. Thematically, the ending fit, but I would have liked just a little something more — maybe the second meeting of the book club, full of gossip and Harris tweed jackets, or a big scene for Charles, who absolutely deserves one.
Whose Body in the Library is suitable for mystery lovers who don’t want their whodunits too grisly, while maintaining depth and style.
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books for the opportunity to read Whose Body in the Library. I received a complimentary copy through NetGalley and wrote this review voluntarily.
Nichelle, a newcomer starting over in life, got a good bit more than she bargained for when she accepted a position at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library. Luckily, she has plenty of help to straighten things out.
The setting is the quiet star of Whose Body in the Library — Jake’s Seafood Bar, Josie’s Cozy Bakery, and, of course, the library in the lighthouse. The story skirts the edge of the Cozy genre, but is a touch too realistic to settle there. Still, it has that warmth, strong vacay vibes, and a lovely aesthetic. This is an ideal beach read! The characters, too, while eccentric and distinct, feel like real people. I don’t know if Louise Jane would drive me up the wall or amuse me in real life, but I enjoy her on the page. I love characters that are allowed to breathe; this cast isn’t made up of angels or villains, but folks that fall in between.
The plot is solid, although I do find Nichelle’s conviction a little premature. That said, I also felt that the events that followed were inevitable. Thematically, the ending fit, but I would have liked just a little something more — maybe the second meeting of the book club, full of gossip and Harris tweed jackets, or a big scene for Charles, who absolutely deserves one.
Whose Body in the Library is suitable for mystery lovers who don’t want their whodunits too grisly, while maintaining depth and style.
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books for the opportunity to read Whose Body in the Library. I received a complimentary copy through NetGalley and wrote this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is a disappointing book in what has been a very enjoyable series.
One of the biggest changes in this book is the shift in narrative structure. Instead of Lucy as the main perspective, the story is told primarily through a new character, Nichelle. Lucy’s sections feel almost backstory. This change did not work for me. It created a distance that made Lucy feel less like the central character. And Nichelle is not an established character, so being placed so prominently in the narrative feels jarring rather than refreshing, especially for a long running series that uses character familiarity and interactions as a strength.
I understand why the author may have made this change. Lucy is now a new mother and has a new job as library director. This limits her time for day-to-day sleuthing. However, this could have been handled in a different way. Maybe moving the timeline forward slightly instead of changing the narrative voice of the series.
As a result, the tone of the book felt different. The characters do not feel the same, the usual interactions are changed, and even the atmosphere of the town seems different. Much of what makes this series so enjoyable, such as the familiar perspective, the strong sense of community, and the established dynamics are all missing or diminished.
The mystery itself is fairly ordinary and did not fully engage me. Combined with the narrative changes, it never quite managed to pull me in.
Overall, this feels like a risky experiment that did not pay off. I will continue to read the series because it's been a favourite of mine since reading book 1, but I hope future books return to the original narrative style.
Thanks to Netgalley for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
One of the biggest changes in this book is the shift in narrative structure. Instead of Lucy as the main perspective, the story is told primarily through a new character, Nichelle. Lucy’s sections feel almost backstory. This change did not work for me. It created a distance that made Lucy feel less like the central character. And Nichelle is not an established character, so being placed so prominently in the narrative feels jarring rather than refreshing, especially for a long running series that uses character familiarity and interactions as a strength.
I understand why the author may have made this change. Lucy is now a new mother and has a new job as library director. This limits her time for day-to-day sleuthing. However, this could have been handled in a different way. Maybe moving the timeline forward slightly instead of changing the narrative voice of the series.
As a result, the tone of the book felt different. The characters do not feel the same, the usual interactions are changed, and even the atmosphere of the town seems different. Much of what makes this series so enjoyable, such as the familiar perspective, the strong sense of community, and the established dynamics are all missing or diminished.
The mystery itself is fairly ordinary and did not fully engage me. Combined with the narrative changes, it never quite managed to pull me in.
Overall, this feels like a risky experiment that did not pay off. I will continue to read the series because it's been a favourite of mine since reading book 1, but I hope future books return to the original narrative style.
Thanks to Netgalley for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Lots of changes in this latest entry to a long-running series, all good! The main protagonist for the first 12 books in the series, Lucy McNeil finds herself in a couple of new roles, mother to identical twin boys and director of the Lighthouse Library. She has hired her replacement as Assistant Director. Nichelle Gilcrest is a newly minted librarian from upstate New York. She has a background as an bookkeeper and is also the mother of identical twins, twenty-something daughters. On her first day at her new job, Nichelle unlocks the door to the library only to find the body of an older man lying dead on the steps to the library. As she gets over her initial shock, she realizes he looks a bit familiar. As Lucy arrives, she contacts the police and our next change in the series, Detective Sam Watson has retired and his replacement, Detective Rhonda Thomas will be leading the investigation. She has been abundantly clear with Lucy about staying out of her investigations and is equally clear with Nichelle. Lucy finds herself in the position of supporting as opposed to investigating. Nichelle simply wants answers for reasons that go beyond finding the body. After all, this man might be her long-missing father.
I was surprised at how much I enjoyed these changes in the series. It is refreshing to find a main character in a series realize that motherhood requires changes in previous risky behaviors and acts on those needs. The addition of two new key characters gives the series the possibility of some great story lines, new backstories to discover, new relationships to explore. I am excited to see where the author takes them.
My thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the chance to read an early copy of the book in exchange for my honest thoughts.
I was surprised at how much I enjoyed these changes in the series. It is refreshing to find a main character in a series realize that motherhood requires changes in previous risky behaviors and acts on those needs. The addition of two new key characters gives the series the possibility of some great story lines, new backstories to discover, new relationships to explore. I am excited to see where the author takes them.
My thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the chance to read an early copy of the book in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
5/5 stars: This is Gates' twelfth entry in the Lighthouse Library Mystery series, which is a Literary Cozy Mystery set in North Carolina. Featuring a new later-in-life librarian and assistant director finds herself turning sleuth after she discovers a dead body on the library steps – a body that bears a startling resemblance her father who disappeared thirty-eight years ago – on her first day. After fingerprints confirm the dead body is indeed her father, who's been living in town under a different name and befriending older lonely women in exchange for money. With a growing suspect list of wronged women, their relatives and her own brother, who arrived in town a few days before the murder and has been lying about his whereabouts. If she's going to clear her brother’s name and find the real killer, she'll need all encouragement she can get from her new boss, the library's director and a seasoned sleuth.
With plenty of twists and turns, Gates has masterfully crafted a mystery that deftly balances the suspects, clues and red herrings and will leave you pondering the whodunit until the final reveal. Heartfelt and humorous, Gates' writing and character work are stellar; the characters are well-rounded and complex while remaining incredibly likable with a secondary cast that's well crafted and uniquely voiced.
• Main POV's new: a fifty-something MC. Although the original series MC is still present.
• For Animal Lovers: there's a great cat who deigns to live with the MC when not “working” at the library.
While you could read this as a stand-alone, you'll gain so much more by reading the series from the beginning; so be sure to pick up book one, By Book or By Crook.
I received this eARC thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books in exchange for an honest review. Publishing dates are subject to change.
With plenty of twists and turns, Gates has masterfully crafted a mystery that deftly balances the suspects, clues and red herrings and will leave you pondering the whodunit until the final reveal. Heartfelt and humorous, Gates' writing and character work are stellar; the characters are well-rounded and complex while remaining incredibly likable with a secondary cast that's well crafted and uniquely voiced.
• Main POV's new: a fifty-something MC. Although the original series MC is still present.
• For Animal Lovers: there's a great cat who deigns to live with the MC when not “working” at the library.
While you could read this as a stand-alone, you'll gain so much more by reading the series from the beginning; so be sure to pick up book one, By Book or By Crook.
I received this eARC thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books in exchange for an honest review. Publishing dates are subject to change.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I thoroughly enjoyed Whose Body in the Library by Eva Gates. Even though this was my first time reading the Lighthouse Library series, I never felt out of the loop because the book seamlessly introduces a new main character. While we get a few chapters from the original protagonist, Lucy, the story is primarily driven by Nichelle's perspective—a middle-aged woman looking for a fresh start in life.
This is the perfect read for fans of Hallmark mystery movies. It’s a very clean, cozy mystery that handles themes of family dysfunction well, acknowledging the challenges without ever getting too gritty or dark. The plot offers a fair number of twists and turns, but they are laid out in a way that allows the reader to play detective and figure things out alongside the characters. It’s a fast-paced story, and I found myself wanting to keep reading. Plus, the cover is absolutely adorable, and I loved the inclusion of a feline friend!
My reason for giving it 4 stars instead of 5 is that there were a few elements that felt a bit cheesy. Some of the supporting characters came across as slightly forced and unbelievable. Additionally, there was a running bit with the main character’s name that was overused: it felt like every time Nichelle met someone new, they either mistakenly called her "Michelle" or asked, "Like the Star Trek actress?" It quickly reached a point where I thought, okay, we get it. Despite those minor gripes, it is a delightful, quick mystery. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a light, clean beach or poolside read!
Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
This is the perfect read for fans of Hallmark mystery movies. It’s a very clean, cozy mystery that handles themes of family dysfunction well, acknowledging the challenges without ever getting too gritty or dark. The plot offers a fair number of twists and turns, but they are laid out in a way that allows the reader to play detective and figure things out alongside the characters. It’s a fast-paced story, and I found myself wanting to keep reading. Plus, the cover is absolutely adorable, and I loved the inclusion of a feline friend!
My reason for giving it 4 stars instead of 5 is that there were a few elements that felt a bit cheesy. Some of the supporting characters came across as slightly forced and unbelievable. Additionally, there was a running bit with the main character’s name that was overused: it felt like every time Nichelle met someone new, they either mistakenly called her "Michelle" or asked, "Like the Star Trek actress?" It quickly reached a point where I thought, okay, we get it. Despite those minor gripes, it is a delightful, quick mystery. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a light, clean beach or poolside read!
Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
It's not often we are surprised by a well loved long-running series, but Eva Gates manages to do that here. In this adventure, we are introduced to Nichelle Gilcrest, who is taking over as the assistant director at the Bodie Island Lighthouse library and moving into the upstairs apartment. Before anyone panics Lucy McNeil newly promoted director has experienced major life changes that require she pulls back on some of her extracurricular activities but she is happy to welcome Nichelle, a woman in her early 50's who after becoming an empty nester went back to school to get her library degree. Excited about a new start and new home, she has moved from Rochester, New York. Nichelle is excited to start her first day until she opens the library door to find a dead body! Fortunately, Lucy is arriving just as Nichelle finds the body and knows the ropes. This is definitely an interesting mystery, Nichelle finds herself unexpectedly involved with this murder investigation as she learns her new job, discovers her new town, and even discovers some long forgotten family history. I really enjoyed how Ms. Gates breathed some new life into this series while letting us still stay comfortable with what we love about it. Thanks to #Netgally #CrookedLaneBooks and the author for an opportunity to read. #WhoseBodyInTheLibrary #ALighthouseLibraryMystery #EvaGates #bookreview #bookideas #retiredreader
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The body on the steps of the library looks awfully familiar... Whose body?
Lucy is out and Nichelle is in. Lucy is back from maternity leave and she's taken over for Bertie as the new library director and Nichelle, from Rochester, NY, is replacing her as assistant director. Nichelle is, no surprise, greeted on her first day of work at the library by a dead body on the front stops and he looks oddly like someone from Nichelle's past.
Lots of things have changed in this series. Lucy is a mom now and she's taken over the library. Louise Jane is out? I don't remember if something happened with her in the last book but she doesn't work at the library anymore, though she still plays a major role in the book. And now the story is being told by Nichelle and Lucy is a peripheral character. I honestly didn't care for that. Nichelle is not interesting and while I didn't dislike her I didn't like her either. The series has definitely lost its appeal for me, and I hate that because I really enjoy the setting and this series has always been a reliably good one. Not to say that this book wasn't good, it was just not the same.
Good series, I hope that future books go back to Lucy being the main character!
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
Lucy is out and Nichelle is in. Lucy is back from maternity leave and she's taken over for Bertie as the new library director and Nichelle, from Rochester, NY, is replacing her as assistant director. Nichelle is, no surprise, greeted on her first day of work at the library by a dead body on the front stops and he looks oddly like someone from Nichelle's past.
Lots of things have changed in this series. Lucy is a mom now and she's taken over the library. Louise Jane is out? I don't remember if something happened with her in the last book but she doesn't work at the library anymore, though she still plays a major role in the book. And now the story is being told by Nichelle and Lucy is a peripheral character. I honestly didn't care for that. Nichelle is not interesting and while I didn't dislike her I didn't like her either. The series has definitely lost its appeal for me, and I hate that because I really enjoy the setting and this series has always been a reliably good one. Not to say that this book wasn't good, it was just not the same.
Good series, I hope that future books go back to Lucy being the main character!
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
It's all change at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library in the Outer Banks, Lucy and Connor McNeil have welcomed their new twins and she has taken over as the library director now Bertie has retired. The recently recruited assistant director, Nichelle Gilchrest, is looking forward to starting work and already feels right at home in the tiny fourth floor apartment with library cat Charles and is delighted when her first day at work dawns, or at least she is until she finds a body she recognises on her doorstep! With the police on the case Nichelle is sure that's her involvement over with. But this is the Bodie and before she knows it Nichelle, along with Lucy, and Louise Jane are investigating as well! Gradually, as the clues come together, she's sure she knows the killer’s identity but confronting them could make her first week at the library her last!
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Crooked Lane Books, but the opinions expressed are my own. Although this is a book full of changes it is still set around the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library and is, as always, a pleasure to read. Nichelle has an interesting backstory which gave her immediate depth and she fitted in well with everyone, even going out investigating with Louise Jane! I'm looking forward to seeing what else happens to her in future outings.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Crooked Lane Books, but the opinions expressed are my own. Although this is a book full of changes it is still set around the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library and is, as always, a pleasure to read. Nichelle has an interesting backstory which gave her immediate depth and she fitted in well with everyone, even going out investigating with Louise Jane! I'm looking forward to seeing what else happens to her in future outings.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The 13th book of the Lighthouse Library mysteries opens with a new character, Nichelle.(not a misspelling), the new Assistant Librarian, arrives of the Bodie Island from Boston to begin a new career. She will be living on the top floor of the lighthouse library as have others in the past just starting moving from another location. Opening the doors of the library the first day, she finds the body of a deceased man which has a faint resemblance to her missing father for 38 years. Detective Rhonda tells Nichelle not to get involved with solving this murder, but, true to form, Lucy, is available to guide and encourage her search for clues. Could the murderer turn out to be her brother who has been visiting the area for several years? What I found missing with this particular book was I couldn’t relate to any character. Even Lucy wasn’t her normal self: sleep deprivation from her new twins and duties as head librarian could be a factor but the patrons were particularly rude and noisy about Nichelle’s troubles. I have enjoyed this series in the past and look forward to Nichelle becoming a truly welcome addition to this series and the tales that evolve. Thanks to author #EvaGates, #NetGalley, and #CrookedLaneBooks for a complimentary e-digital copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3.5 stars
This long-running series featuring Lighthouse Librarian Lucy adds a new character with this book, Nichelle, who takes over Lucy's job when she gets promoted.
There's a lot happening: Lucy and Connor have twin baby boys and their life is crazy. Nichelle is a great characters. She is in her 50s and starting over after a divorce and a career change. She is new to the Outer Banks and looking forward to settling in.
Nichelle has some background sadness - her father disappeared 38 years ago, presumed drowned after a late night swim in the same town Nichelle has moved to. And in that curious coincidence world common to cozies, guess whose dead body turns up on the steps of the library on Nichelle's first day of work? Nichelle struggles to figure out who her absent father really was, even though she finds out some unpleasant things. She is clearly a strong and resilient character.
It remains to be seen how Nichelle will integrate into the series, whether Lucy will step into the background or they will co-sleuth. But all the issues are handled calmly and sensitively and it made for a good read. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This long-running series featuring Lighthouse Librarian Lucy adds a new character with this book, Nichelle, who takes over Lucy's job when she gets promoted.
There's a lot happening: Lucy and Connor have twin baby boys and their life is crazy. Nichelle is a great characters. She is in her 50s and starting over after a divorce and a career change. She is new to the Outer Banks and looking forward to settling in.
Nichelle has some background sadness - her father disappeared 38 years ago, presumed drowned after a late night swim in the same town Nichelle has moved to. And in that curious coincidence world common to cozies, guess whose dead body turns up on the steps of the library on Nichelle's first day of work? Nichelle struggles to figure out who her absent father really was, even though she finds out some unpleasant things. She is clearly a strong and resilient character.
It remains to be seen how Nichelle will integrate into the series, whether Lucy will step into the background or they will co-sleuth. But all the issues are handled calmly and sensitively and it made for a good read. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Nichelle Gilcrest has traded Rochester, New York, for the salty air of the Outer Banks, North Carolina, stepping into the role of Assistant Director at the local library. While her predecessor, Lucy, is busy balancing life as the new Director and a mom to newborn twins, Nichelle is trying to find her footing—until she finds a body on her very first day.
The victim looks eerily familiar, and for good reason: it’s Nichelle’s father, who vanished on a fishing trip in this very town 38 years ago. When she calls her brother, Brad, to the coast, he arrives carrying secrets of his own—secrets that quickly land him on the new detective’s shortlist of suspects. With Lucy’s help, Nichelle begins digging into the past to find out why her father really disappeared all those years ago and who wanted him dead.
It’s been a while since I picked up this series, so I loved that this book offered a fresh start with a new protagonist. It was great to reconnect with the familiar faces at the library while diving into the mystery of Nichelle’s family. The plot kept me on my toes and guessing until the very end. I’m so happy this series is getting a "refresh" and I can’t wait to see what’s next!
The victim looks eerily familiar, and for good reason: it’s Nichelle’s father, who vanished on a fishing trip in this very town 38 years ago. When she calls her brother, Brad, to the coast, he arrives carrying secrets of his own—secrets that quickly land him on the new detective’s shortlist of suspects. With Lucy’s help, Nichelle begins digging into the past to find out why her father really disappeared all those years ago and who wanted him dead.
It’s been a while since I picked up this series, so I loved that this book offered a fresh start with a new protagonist. It was great to reconnect with the familiar faces at the library while diving into the mystery of Nichelle’s family. The plot kept me on my toes and guessing until the very end. I’m so happy this series is getting a "refresh" and I can’t wait to see what’s next!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Whose Body in the Library, a Lighthouse Library Mystery by Eva Gates, is the 13th book in the series, and the addition of a new main character with her own skills, quirks, and issues ensures that this wonderful series will never continue to be fresh and fun.
Lucy McNeil is the new librarian at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library, and almost from the start, things start to go wrong. On her first morning of opening the library, she opens the door to find a dead man who looks eerily familiar. The mystery of who the man is, what brought him to the library, and his mysterious background sweeps the reader towards the conclusion. Suspects are plenty, and a taciturn detective insistent that no one interfere with her investigation adds tension.
Gates provides all you would expect from a cozy - a quaint location, quirky characters, an intriguing mystery, and even a library cat.
I did find some of the descriptions of locations and people too long for my taste, and ended up skipping over them to keep the story flowing.
I am happy to have been able to read an ARC of #WhoseBodyintheLibrary courtesy of #NetGalley.
Lucy McNeil is the new librarian at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library, and almost from the start, things start to go wrong. On her first morning of opening the library, she opens the door to find a dead man who looks eerily familiar. The mystery of who the man is, what brought him to the library, and his mysterious background sweeps the reader towards the conclusion. Suspects are plenty, and a taciturn detective insistent that no one interfere with her investigation adds tension.
Gates provides all you would expect from a cozy - a quaint location, quirky characters, an intriguing mystery, and even a library cat.
I did find some of the descriptions of locations and people too long for my taste, and ended up skipping over them to keep the story flowing.
I am happy to have been able to read an ARC of #WhoseBodyintheLibrary courtesy of #NetGalley.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to the publisher for this eARC copy.
I'm a huge fan of Eva Gates and her Lighthouse Library Mystery series, and this was no different. In this book, we meet Nichelle, a newcomer to town, coming into the series to be the Assistant Director to Lucy. At first, I thought I missed something because the story jumped right into Nichelle's point of view, but after a quick Google search, I realized I was right on target. I love the way we transitioned the point of view in this book, as with many cozy mystery series, if we have the same people doing the same things, the whole book and concept gets kind of stale.
Nichelle is a great character, and I love her backstory of a woman in her 50s reclaiming her passion in work and starting her life over now that her kids are grown.
With this being a cozy mystery, I don't want to spoil anything, but know that yes, someone dies, there are a lot of suspects, and there's a mystery within a mystery in this book. By the end, Nichelle is now intrical part of our little family and series.
Four stars for this amazing edition to the series.
I'm a huge fan of Eva Gates and her Lighthouse Library Mystery series, and this was no different. In this book, we meet Nichelle, a newcomer to town, coming into the series to be the Assistant Director to Lucy. At first, I thought I missed something because the story jumped right into Nichelle's point of view, but after a quick Google search, I realized I was right on target. I love the way we transitioned the point of view in this book, as with many cozy mystery series, if we have the same people doing the same things, the whole book and concept gets kind of stale.
Nichelle is a great character, and I love her backstory of a woman in her 50s reclaiming her passion in work and starting her life over now that her kids are grown.
With this being a cozy mystery, I don't want to spoil anything, but know that yes, someone dies, there are a lot of suspects, and there's a mystery within a mystery in this book. By the end, Nichelle is now intrical part of our little family and series.
Four stars for this amazing edition to the series.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I love this series and this is a great addition! While the beginning was slightly jarring, I understand why the story had to happen that way. That's all I'll say so there aren't spoilers.
This newest addition to the series is one of the better ones in the series! I read it in one setting as I just could not put it down! The additional characters and the plot line were intriguing and attention-grabbing. The mystery had plenty of twists and turns and it did not unfold precisely how I thought it would, which I always like and enjoy.
If you're new to the series, this is not the book to start with. I would highly suggest reading from the beginning, By Book or By Crook. There are way too many interpersonal connections in this particular volume to start reading the series from here.
I thoroughly enjoyed this new book and I hope others do as well!
This newest addition to the series is one of the better ones in the series! I read it in one setting as I just could not put it down! The additional characters and the plot line were intriguing and attention-grabbing. The mystery had plenty of twists and turns and it did not unfold precisely how I thought it would, which I always like and enjoy.
If you're new to the series, this is not the book to start with. I would highly suggest reading from the beginning, By Book or By Crook. There are way too many interpersonal connections in this particular volume to start reading the series from here.
I thoroughly enjoyed this new book and I hope others do as well!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I went into this one excited to be back at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library… and I think that’s part of why the shift in perspective didn’t quite work for me.
This book is told primarily from Nichelle’s POV instead of Lucy’s, and while I understand the reasoning, it changes the feel of the story in a noticeable way. Nichelle is still new to the library and the town, so as a reader you’re essentially relearning a world you already know which creates a bit of distance that the earlier books didn’t have.
Lucy is still present, but not being in her head takes away some of that familiar rhythm and connection that has always made this series so enjoyable for me.
That said, the book does settle as it goes on. The mystery itself is solid, and once the story finds its footing, it becomes a more engaging read. It just never quite reaches the same level as previous installments for me.
Overall, this wasn’t a bad addition to the series, it just didn’t feel like the same series in places. I’ll definitely keep reading, but I’m hoping future books return to Lucy as the primary POV.
This book is told primarily from Nichelle’s POV instead of Lucy’s, and while I understand the reasoning, it changes the feel of the story in a noticeable way. Nichelle is still new to the library and the town, so as a reader you’re essentially relearning a world you already know which creates a bit of distance that the earlier books didn’t have.
Lucy is still present, but not being in her head takes away some of that familiar rhythm and connection that has always made this series so enjoyable for me.
That said, the book does settle as it goes on. The mystery itself is solid, and once the story finds its footing, it becomes a more engaging read. It just never quite reaches the same level as previous installments for me.
Overall, this wasn’t a bad addition to the series, it just didn’t feel like the same series in places. I’ll definitely keep reading, but I’m hoping future books return to Lucy as the primary POV.
March 28, 2026
This book marks a big shift in the Lighthouse Library series, as we get a new main character playing center stage now that Lucy’s story has shifted considerably, following the end of the previous book in the series. I was apprehensive at first of a change this big since I’ve absolutely fallen in love with this series & big changes can make or break it. There was absolutely no reason at all to be worried! Nichelle’s character is a breath of fresh air & a welcome addition to the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library. It feels a bit like starting over in a way, as we see the characters we’ve come to know through a new set of eyes. Nichelle is thrown right into chaos when a man, who might be her father, ends up dead outside the library. There’s lots of secrets to uncover & family drama to hash out in order to solve this one. I can’t wait to see what’s next for Nichelle.
Thank you to NetGalley & Crooked Lane Books for the arc.
Thank you to NetGalley & Crooked Lane Books for the arc.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Having read every title in this series, it was exciting to have a new narrator. Eva Gates was so smart to have new Assistant Librarian NIchelle Gilcrest be immediately thrown into a mystery with ties, unknown to her, to the community while allowing Lucy McNeill to focus on her twin baby boys and new role as Head Librarian. Lucy serves more as a guide and that allows the other new major series character, Detective Rhonda Thomas, to take on the investigation without the baggage built between Lucy and Sam in previous novels. A quick and delightful narrative, I highly recommend it to all who have enjoyed the series thus far and also as a place to jump into the series as it moves possibly to a different protagonist.
My sincere thanks to Crooked Lane Books and Netgalley for the opportunity to read this arc in return for an honest opinion.
My sincere thanks to Crooked Lane Books and Netgalley for the opportunity to read this arc in return for an honest opinion.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
While I ended up enjoying this book by the end, I was really thrown off through the first few chapters because the series took such a turn with a new main character and a big time jump. I kept feeling like I missed a book and stopped to go look if I had. It would have helped to have had some heads up so that I could jump right in with an understanding of what was going on. Once I was able to accept this was the new path of the series (or is it?), then I was curious about Nichelle and her family and their mystery. I understand that series get stale, and so a new viewpoint helps to keep things fresh, and I appreciate it. The character of Nishelle is in a very different stage of life than Lucy, and it will be interesting to see her relationships with other characters develop.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for selecting me to read an advanced copy of this book.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for selecting me to read an advanced copy of this book.
February 2, 2026
Thank you NetGalley for the free ARC. All opinions are my own.
This is one of my favorite series ever, all genres included. I am always looking forward to the next installement. This time I was just a little bit disappointed.
I'll say first that I absolutely love Nichelle as a protagonist. Her complexe family history was interesting to read about. Unfortunately, I am not sure how I feel about this change of main character after 12 books. Because of that, we are introduced over and over again to characters that we have read about for 12 books. I also feel that there was too many changes at the same time. Finally, I felt like the end was a bit rushed.
No matter how I felt about this installment, it was good to be back in Nags Head, just like meeting old friends and I am excited to follow the gang and our new protagonist in the next book.
This is one of my favorite series ever, all genres included. I am always looking forward to the next installement. This time I was just a little bit disappointed.
I'll say first that I absolutely love Nichelle as a protagonist. Her complexe family history was interesting to read about. Unfortunately, I am not sure how I feel about this change of main character after 12 books. Because of that, we are introduced over and over again to characters that we have read about for 12 books. I also feel that there was too many changes at the same time. Finally, I felt like the end was a bit rushed.
No matter how I felt about this installment, it was good to be back in Nags Head, just like meeting old friends and I am excited to follow the gang and our new protagonist in the next book.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Big fan of this series of the library lighthouse! A new character and assistant librarian is introduced and she relates the story as it revolves around her. Or dear Lucy is now library director with identical twin sons. The reader will find that Nichelle, the new librarian, is starting a new life at age fifty. Her daughters are grown and settled, her marriage has ended, and she's gained her library degree. She will be staying in the lighthouse library apartment. On her first day, she discovers a body on the library step. The body looks familiar and that's where the mystery begins and develops. Will Nichelle be the next Lucy solving the murders in this small library town? We will just wait and see what the next book brings. Thanks to Net Galley for the arc.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews