⭐ Overall rating: 5/5
🌶️ Spice rating: 3/5
TW: childhood trauma, infertility, grief, on-page violence (not between MCs), Consensual Non-consent
Tuesday James, you have done it again. What I loved about These Jagged Edges (the found family, the healing, the deep emotional connections?) is all still here, but This Violent Reckoning dials everything in tighter and ramps it up to the next level. The focus of this book is choice. Two people choosing love, choosing healing, and most importantly, choosing each other every single day… even when it’s hard (even when you kinda hate them but love them anyway; that’s Henry and Lou in a nutshell). As a reader, I don't think you're supposed to love them, but fall in love with their story, which ultimately, I really do feel is beautiful.
Louisiana is a firecracker; stubborn, unyielding, and so frustrating that I wanted to shake her. Would I be her friend irl? Honestly, probably not. But that’s what makes her real. Watching her unpack her trauma and realize her past doesn’t define her was genuinely inspiring. She’s not perfect, she’s human, and I think that’s exactly what Tuesday wanted us to see. Did I agree with her choices? Absolutely not. I thought she was mean, punishing a man who was young and made a mistake. But did I also realize she was also young, and grieving? Yes. Of course someone in that mindset would act in ways that others wouldn't agree with. But that's what I genuinely think is Tuesday's superpower. She writes characters intentionally, where their flaws are there on purpose and by the end of it, we see a light at the end of the tunnel (whether we're close to the end or not).
Henry Wilder? My favorite Wilder brother (so far... Mercy might dethrone him, but time will tell). I am such a sucker for the older-brother type who takes on everyone’s burdens, has control issues, and still manages to be a total simp for the woman he loves. Sure, he makes some questionable “for the greater good” choices, but he also owns them. Accountability king, I'm here for it. Plus, his words of affirmation? Lou needed those, and I loved seeing him give them so freely. For a man so hardened by what's happened and the pressure he puts on himself, seeing him open up to Lou is beautiful.
As for the the rest of the book, I've got nothing but praise. There’s never a dull moment. I felt that the heavy emotional beats were balanced with just the right amount of humor and banter so it never feels overwhelming (banana hammocks, I'm looking at you). As a die-hard romantic comedy reader, this definitely leans heavier than my usual, but I was so invested I didn’t care. I wanted to know more, what is Lou going to do? How is Henry going to react? Ultimately that's the whole book in a nutshell, and yet, it is gripping. I just wanted to know how it would end.
That said… greedy me would’ve loved more from the fake dating subplot. It was very much a subplot but I thought it wrapped up fast, and I would’ve traded a toe for a few more domestic, fluffy moments between them. Still, it didn’t take away from how strong their development was.
I think it's no surprise to anyone, that the side characters in this one were on fire. Every single member of this found family has depth, heart, and purpose. Tuesday created a family in the previous book, so we knew who everyone was, but in this one? She actually made a family. Dallas is 100% the key to this book, the reason it all works, and the way that everyone heals. Sure, Lou heals (and that's the obvious one), but so does Henry. We see this in how he changes, and while I think it's more subtle, it's definitely there. It's one of those books where, on every re-read, I'd have a new favorite character. My heart still hurts.
Now what a lot of people were here for. The spice...
It was spicy in the best way!!! Not just the scenes themselves (flashlight scene? yes sir, please and thank you), but the teasing, the tension, the banter. They’ve got chemistry for days, and it made every intimate moment feel earned.
TL;DR
This book is completely a continuation of These Jagged Edges and like the title, its a lot more emotionally raw and well.... violent. It’s a story about choosing love even when it’s hard, healing even when it hurts, and holding on even when everything feels broken. Come for the Wilders, stay for the banter, cry for the found family, and prepare to be wrecked in the best way.
I absolutely cannot wait to see what Mercy's book is saying, because it's gonna be goooooood.