What do you think?
Rate this book
Stars of Chaos: Sha Po Lang (Novel) #4
ฆ่าหมาป่า เล่ม 4
ในแคว้นต้าเหลียงอันยิ่งใหญ่ ซึ่งเจริญรุ่งเรืองด้วยสิ่งอำนวยความสะดวก
อย่างหุ่นจักรกลและเครื่องจักรไอน้ำที่ใช้ถ่านหิน
รวมถึงเชื้อเพลิงหายากอย่างทองคำเหลวม่วงในการขับเคลื่อน
เด็กหนุ่มนาม ‘ฉางเกิง’ อาศัยอยู่ในเมืองเล็ก ๆ ตรงชายแดน
เมื่อครั้งฉางเกิงยังเยาว์วัยได้ลอบหนีออกไปเที่ยวเล่น
นอกประตูเมืองตามลำพัง ทำให้พบเข้ากับฝูงหมาป่าจนเกือบเอาชีวิตไม่รอด
ดีที่ ‘เสิ่นสือลิ่ว’ ผ่านมาช่วยไว้ทัน
จึงกราบเป็นพ่อบุญธรรมเพื่อทดแทนบุญคุณช่วยชีวิต
แต่แล้ววันหนึ่งกองทัพอนารยชนนอกด่านลอบบุกเข้ามาโจมตีเมือง
ชีวิตของฉางเกิงเกิดการเปลี่ยนแปลงอย่างใหญ่หลวงภายในค่ำคืนเดียว
ราวกับว่าชีวิตในเมืองเล็ก ๆ แห่งนี้เป็นเพียงภาพลวงตา
ยามนี้เขาไม่ได้เป็นเพียงเด็กหนุ่มที่มีชาติกำเนิดธรรมดาอีกแล้ว
กระทั่งมารดา หรือแม้แต่พ่อบุญธรรมน้อยของเขาเองก็มีสถานะเปลี่ยนไป...
อย่างหุ่นจักรกลและเครื่องจักรไอน้ำที่ใช้ถ่านหิน
รวมถึงเชื้อเพลิงหายากอย่างทองคำเหลวม่วงในการขับเคลื่อน
เด็กหนุ่มนาม ‘ฉางเกิง’ อาศัยอยู่ในเมืองเล็ก ๆ ตรงชายแดน
เมื่อครั้งฉางเกิงยังเยาว์วัยได้ลอบหนีออกไปเที่ยวเล่น
นอกประตูเมืองตามลำพัง ทำให้พบเข้ากับฝูงหมาป่าจนเกือบเอาชีวิตไม่รอด
ดีที่ ‘เสิ่นสือลิ่ว’ ผ่านมาช่วยไว้ทัน
จึงกราบเป็นพ่อบุญธรรมเพื่อทดแทนบุญคุณช่วยชีวิต
แต่แล้ววันหนึ่งกองทัพอนารยชนนอกด่านลอบบุกเข้ามาโจมตีเมือง
ชีวิตของฉางเกิงเกิดการเปลี่ยนแปลงอย่างใหญ่หลวงภายในค่ำคืนเดียว
ราวกับว่าชีวิตในเมืองเล็ก ๆ แห่งนี้เป็นเพียงภาพลวงตา
ยามนี้เขาไม่ได้เป็นเพียงเด็กหนุ่มที่มีชาติกำเนิดธรรมดาอีกแล้ว
กระทั่งมารดา หรือแม้แต่พ่อบุญธรรมน้อยของเขาเองก็มีสถานะเปลี่ยนไป...
330 pages, Paperback
Published September 15, 2025
82 people are currently reading
1554 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 121 reviews
December 29, 2024
Love is finding the person who allows you to be vulnerable. In the fourth volume of “Stars of Chaos” by Priest both Chang Geng and Gu Yun let their guard down and so deepen their relationship. The book is dominated by court intrigue and foreign invasions, so the main couple is separated for long stretches of time, but when they come together their relationship is solidified.
The book opens with a palace coup that is the culmination of intrigues carried over from volume 3 which culminate in a scheme with a fake Prince Yan that tricks the court rebels, allowing Gu Yun to save the emperor, Li Feng. Some doubt is sown about Chang Geng’s true identity as the emperor’s brother but ultimately this changes nothing since Chang Geng’s success is based on his achievements rather than on his heredity. He, himself, is entirely unbothered as well, ironically showing his suitability for power.
The relationship between Chang Geng and Gu Yun is hardly kept a secret anymore although it is not exactly public. Shen Yi, Gu Yun’s oldest confidante, understands that, “Finding true love and conjugal bliss was a stroke of luck as rare as a blind cat running across a dead mouse,” because “a pair like Prince Yan and Gu Yun were truly a rare sight” (p. 78). Shen Yi is himself struggling with his feelings for the miracle doctor, Chen Qingxu, whose medical skills allow her to carve out a life that is independent of traditional family expectations. So while Shen Yi is dreaming of a quiet family life, Chen Qingxu is off saving soldiers’ lives and looking for a cure for Chang Geng’s wu’ergu curse.
Chang Geng is the capable and highly strategic Prince Yan who can carry out intricate strategies with immense determination and strength but in the arms of Gu Yun, “The calm and confident king of beasts became a delicate and sickly kitten.” He feels safe enough to let his guard down and sink into the safety of his lover’s embrace. There is therefore a great intimacy when Chang Geng whispers, “Zixi, it hurts…” (p. 93) after he has been wounded. This scene works so well because of the contrast of the powerful prince turning into the weak kitten. However, Chang Geng is perfectly aware of his effect on Gu Yun so in the days after his initial collapse, he knowingly exploits his weakness in a fishing expedition for kisses and caresses. Gu Yun finds himself checkmate in the face of this strategy and allows himself to be manipulated, because he too understands that this relationship is real. As he says, “I really don’t have the strength to … let another person into my heart” (p. 111).
Later on, their roles are reversed when Gu Yun falls into Chang Geng’s arms before the battle at Jiangbei Garrison. Gu Yun has been keeping his many injuries hidden from Chang Geng but is forced to admit the truth just before a naval battle. Chang Geng has known all along that Gu Yun has been poisoned and that he is battle weary, but this is the first time that Gu Yun is literally put out of commission because of his physical weakness. The relationship shifts significantly when Gu Yun surrenders command of the army to Chang Geng, trusting him to fight in his place on the battlefield. This is forced on Gu Yun by circumstances but it is most definitely also a declaration of trust and thereby also of love. When Chang Geng returns victorious, he understands what Gu Yun has been facing all this time and says, “I don’t want you to go to war again” (p. 279).
The book ends in a fiery climax at the northern border, where Shen Yi rushes in to save Chen Qingxu from a burning building and both of them are saved by Gu Yun and his Black Iron Battalion. Shen Yi may be tongue-tied when he tries to express his love for Chen Qingxu, but there is no doubt about his feelings when he plunges into a burning building to save her. Chen Qingxu is there in a desperate attempt to find a cure for Chang Geng’s wu’ergu poisoning and so disregards her own safety in the pursuit of an antidote. So when Gu Yun saves both of them, he is not just doing it because they are his friends or because he is the great leader of the battalion; he is doing it in the hope that the curse on the love of his life can be lifted.
The book opens with a palace coup that is the culmination of intrigues carried over from volume 3 which culminate in a scheme with a fake Prince Yan that tricks the court rebels, allowing Gu Yun to save the emperor, Li Feng. Some doubt is sown about Chang Geng’s true identity as the emperor’s brother but ultimately this changes nothing since Chang Geng’s success is based on his achievements rather than on his heredity. He, himself, is entirely unbothered as well, ironically showing his suitability for power.
The relationship between Chang Geng and Gu Yun is hardly kept a secret anymore although it is not exactly public. Shen Yi, Gu Yun’s oldest confidante, understands that, “Finding true love and conjugal bliss was a stroke of luck as rare as a blind cat running across a dead mouse,” because “a pair like Prince Yan and Gu Yun were truly a rare sight” (p. 78). Shen Yi is himself struggling with his feelings for the miracle doctor, Chen Qingxu, whose medical skills allow her to carve out a life that is independent of traditional family expectations. So while Shen Yi is dreaming of a quiet family life, Chen Qingxu is off saving soldiers’ lives and looking for a cure for Chang Geng’s wu’ergu curse.
Chang Geng is the capable and highly strategic Prince Yan who can carry out intricate strategies with immense determination and strength but in the arms of Gu Yun, “The calm and confident king of beasts became a delicate and sickly kitten.” He feels safe enough to let his guard down and sink into the safety of his lover’s embrace. There is therefore a great intimacy when Chang Geng whispers, “Zixi, it hurts…” (p. 93) after he has been wounded. This scene works so well because of the contrast of the powerful prince turning into the weak kitten. However, Chang Geng is perfectly aware of his effect on Gu Yun so in the days after his initial collapse, he knowingly exploits his weakness in a fishing expedition for kisses and caresses. Gu Yun finds himself checkmate in the face of this strategy and allows himself to be manipulated, because he too understands that this relationship is real. As he says, “I really don’t have the strength to … let another person into my heart” (p. 111).
Later on, their roles are reversed when Gu Yun falls into Chang Geng’s arms before the battle at Jiangbei Garrison. Gu Yun has been keeping his many injuries hidden from Chang Geng but is forced to admit the truth just before a naval battle. Chang Geng has known all along that Gu Yun has been poisoned and that he is battle weary, but this is the first time that Gu Yun is literally put out of commission because of his physical weakness. The relationship shifts significantly when Gu Yun surrenders command of the army to Chang Geng, trusting him to fight in his place on the battlefield. This is forced on Gu Yun by circumstances but it is most definitely also a declaration of trust and thereby also of love. When Chang Geng returns victorious, he understands what Gu Yun has been facing all this time and says, “I don’t want you to go to war again” (p. 279).
The book ends in a fiery climax at the northern border, where Shen Yi rushes in to save Chen Qingxu from a burning building and both of them are saved by Gu Yun and his Black Iron Battalion. Shen Yi may be tongue-tied when he tries to express his love for Chen Qingxu, but there is no doubt about his feelings when he plunges into a burning building to save her. Chen Qingxu is there in a desperate attempt to find a cure for Chang Geng’s wu’ergu poisoning and so disregards her own safety in the pursuit of an antidote. So when Gu Yun saves both of them, he is not just doing it because they are his friends or because he is the great leader of the battalion; he is doing it in the hope that the curse on the love of his life can be lifted.
October 17, 2024
I love Shen Yi so much- he BETTER get a HE. I did not re-read Vol 3 like I wanted to before starting this but surprisingly I wasn’t confused at all. Politics, war, and sprinkles of relationship stuff 🥰. Might not be a popular opinion but I really enjoyed the pacing in this volume. I loved seeing Gu Yun a little bit more vulnerable and I’m excited to see how the story ends in the next volume!
Bummed Seven Seas decided not to do a Special Edition of the final volume.
Bummed Seven Seas decided not to do a Special Edition of the final volume.
November 11, 2024
I just want Gu Yun and Chang Geng to take a year-long holiday, so they can rest and recover from all the injuries they suffered in this book XD
May 13, 2025
4 'War and love' stars
I don't have much to say about this vol plotwise. The war is still ongoing and everyone in court still wants to get rid of each other. So, you know, usual politics. And, of course, a lot of people still wants to kill Gu Yun and Chang Geng, which means that for a good portion of this vol they are either half dead or recovering. So, also usual stuff, haha. However, there were a lot of changgu moments to make me happy, and therefore, I have no complaints.
Aren't they the most precious! 🥰🥰 Chang Geng becoming totally spoiled by Gu Yun, which he absolutely deserves after everything he went through. And, Gu Yun... who could have thought, he's such a romantic deep inisde. Smooth talker - yes, but 'fetch him stars in the sky' is on another level *swoon* ✨✨✨
I love to see them so playfull together. With everything that is happening and their important roles in war/court politics, there really aren't many chances for them to enjoy some peacefull time away from danger. Especially because even when they do manage to steal some time to be together, half the time they had to first settle some scores about why one or the other is injured.
My favourite part of this vol was the progress in their relationship, or more likely Gu Yun's understanding of his feelings. Let's face it, Chang Geng has always been sure about his feelings toward Gu Yun - from his teenage infatuation with his young yifu, to later lustfull crush, interwined with wu-ergu, and then finally deep and confident love, when Gu Yun started to reciprocate his affection. However, Gu Yun only began to see Chang Geng in different light in the previous vol, when he realized his godson is not a child anymore and that his feelings are sincere and permanent. For Chang Geng, Gu Yun has been THE ONE for years - that one person for whom he's prepared to change the world. As for Gu Yun, that realization has been recent. Only now he's allowed himself to believe he can actually has this - someone to love, who loves him in return.
Fanart by Fenek
They are so in love, your honor!! This was such a special moment that meant so much more, than simply saying 'I love you'.
Fanart by 域说的年记丶
I'm glad that Chang Geng's kinky prepositions are still making Gu Yun all flustered, lol. Also, I wonder how many people suspects they are together becuse they aren't really being subtle about it. At least away from court, they are not.
For the end, I have to mention how happy I am to see some development on Shen Yi's crush on Chen Qingxu. My poor man has been pinning after a certain miricale doctor for too long. He deserves to be happy as well!
And, of course, I can't leave without this badass moment.
5 'His little yifu' stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
5 'Gu Yun needs all the hugs' stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
5 'All is fair in love and war' stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
4 'War and love' stars
5 'changgu in love' stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I don't have much to say about this vol plotwise. The war is still ongoing and everyone in court still wants to get rid of each other. So, you know, usual politics. And, of course, a lot of people still wants to kill Gu Yun and Chang Geng, which means that for a good portion of this vol they are either half dead or recovering. So, also usual stuff, haha. However, there were a lot of changgu moments to make me happy, and therefore, I have no complaints.
Gu Yun stepped inside and hung the flowering branch in Chang Geng's bed curtain. "The osmanthus are blooming. I didn't want you to feel too cooped up lying inside - is the scent okay?"
Chang Geng's gaze attached itself to Gu Yun and refused to tear itself away.
Gu Yun met his eyes. "What are you looking at?"
Chang Geng reached out to tug at his clothes.
Worried he'd strain his wounds, Gu Yun hurriedly cooperated and leaned down. "Don't flail around!"
Chang Geng's pull was insistent, gripping Gu Yun's robes and drawing him close. "Zixi, it hurts."
After a lenghty pause, Gu Yun said expressionlessly, "Get out of here; I'm not falling for that anymore."
Since his injury, it seemed Prince Yan had no intention of preserving any dignity around Gu Yun. Whenever they were alone, he'd pipe up with an It hurst, kiss me any chance he got.
In his youth, Chang Geng had been adept at acting spoiled. Now he clearly wasn't just adept, he had practically perfected the art. Gu Yun was helpless against him. If Chang Geng kept looking at him like that for another incense stick's of time, he might actually climb up and fetch him stars in the sky. Resigned, he wrapped his fingers around Chang Geng's and tugged him further into his embrace.
Aren't they the most precious! 🥰🥰 Chang Geng becoming totally spoiled by Gu Yun, which he absolutely deserves after everything he went through. And, Gu Yun... who could have thought, he's such a romantic deep inisde. Smooth talker - yes, but 'fetch him stars in the sky' is on another level *swoon* ✨✨✨
"Give me the details."
Chang Geng paused and beckoned Gu Yun close, as if planned to whisper into his ear. Gu Yun urged his horse forward, drawing level with the window, and leaned over. "What, are there things you can't reveal yet?"
"It's not that I can't say it, but..." Chang Geng hesitated.
Gu Yun was bemused. He had just begun to wonder what reason there was for such secrecy when Chang Geng leaned out of the carriage and stole a kiss.
Gu Yun was at a loss for words.
The first time Prince Yan spoke, Gu Yun rapped him across the back of the hand, forcing him to release his sleeve. Prince Yan refused to give up and spoke up again. This time Gu Yun pulled down the curtain of his carriage, as if to put him out of sight and out of mind. When Prince Yan pulled the curtain aside to poke his head out and speak a third time, Gu Yun finally broke and began to laugh.
[...]
Shen Yi sighed. "Thank goodness that the marshal has no children of his own. He'd have spoiled them into absolute terrors to rival even himself. Just look how incapable he is of saying no three times in a row to His Highness. Even if he denies Prince Yan's first two requests, he's guaranteed to agree to the third time."
I love to see them so playfull together. With everything that is happening and their important roles in war/court politics, there really aren't many chances for them to enjoy some peacefull time away from danger. Especially because even when they do manage to steal some time to be together, half the time they had to first settle some scores about why one or the other is injured.
"Tell me," Gu Yun said, "precisely what were you thinking when you decided to bravely charge into a bandit's nest with a hopless scholar like Commissioner Xu for company?"
"Zixi..."
"No need to Zixi me," Gu Yun said blandly. "You can keep saying Yifu."
Chang Geng laughed uneasily and offered an apologetic kiss. He had recently discovered that Gu Yun liked these sorts of clingy kisses. If he pecked him a few times, the stered at him with that beseeching gaze, Gu Yun would agree to practically any request... but today, this trick seemed to have lost its efficacy.
[...]
"[...] I didn't think they would choose that time..."
"Oh," Gu Yun nodded. "Then you thought, 'Look, a one-in-a-million opportunity to seek my own death', and off you went."
There was a note of danger in Gu Yun's voice. Chang Geng sensed the conversation was veering in the wrong direction; he immediately wised up and admitted the error of his way: "I was wrong."
Tugging his hand weakly out from beneath the blankets, Gu Yun reached out and laid a hand on the back of Chang Geng's neck. After gently kneading his nape a few times, he ran a finger down the line of Chang Geng's jaw. "You've just seen me and you're already pulling a long face? Has your yifu's beauty faded so fast?"
Struck by a sudden, perverse urge to see how long Gu Yun could keep up his act, Chang Geng asked icily, "And what exactly is the matter with you?"
My favourite part of this vol was the progress in their relationship, or more likely Gu Yun's understanding of his feelings. Let's face it, Chang Geng has always been sure about his feelings toward Gu Yun - from his teenage infatuation with his young yifu, to later lustfull crush, interwined with wu-ergu, and then finally deep and confident love, when Gu Yun started to reciprocate his affection. However, Gu Yun only began to see Chang Geng in different light in the previous vol, when he realized his godson is not a child anymore and that his feelings are sincere and permanent. For Chang Geng, Gu Yun has been THE ONE for years - that one person for whom he's prepared to change the world. As for Gu Yun, that realization has been recent. Only now he's allowed himself to believe he can actually has this - someone to love, who loves him in return.
Gu Yun had likely never spoken words so difficult in his entire life. He nearly lost his courage.
Holding his breath, Chang Geng prompted, "On the way here... you what?"
"...I was scared to death."
Chang Geng stared blankly.
When the Jiangan Navy had been wiped out, when the Black Iron Battalion lost over half its numbers, when Li Feng summoned Gu Yun from imperial dungeons, had Gu Yun ever said he was 'scared to death'?
Fanart by Fenek
These first few words seemed to open a long-sealed floodgate. The rest came in a rush. "If something had really happened to you this time... what would I do?"
Listening, Chang Geng hardly dared to breath.
Gu Yun's voice was low. "Chang Geng, I really don't have the strenght to...let another person into my heart."
They are so in love, your honor!! This was such a special moment that meant so much more, than simply saying 'I love you'.
Fanart by 域说的年记丶
Chang Geng leaned in. "How will you reward me if I succeed?"
"What do you want?" asked Gu Yun, ever magnanimous.
After a moment of consideration, Chang Geng pressed closer and whispered something into Gu Yun's ear. One could only guess what shameless filth Prince Yan relayed in secret; even the half-deaf Gu Yun couldn't bear to listen after a time. Laughing, he cursed at him, "Fuck off."
This obsenity landed directly on the ears of Governor Yao, who had come to report on the battlefield. Utterly bewildered, he asked, "Where would the marshal like this lower official to fuck off to?"
I'm glad that Chang Geng's kinky prepositions are still making Gu Yun all flustered, lol. Also, I wonder how many people suspects they are together becuse they aren't really being subtle about it. At least away from court, they are not.
For the end, I have to mention how happy I am to see some development on Shen Yi's crush on Chen Qingxu. My poor man has been pinning after a certain miricale doctor for too long. He deserves to be happy as well!
And, of course, I can't leave without this badass moment.
"In that case," he sneered, "I would be much obliged if the general would allow me to test his skills!"
[...]
Shen Yi pulled Li Feng behind him and yanked the wrist of a lunging assassin downward. With a tug, and crack, he broke the assassin's arm and seized the oddly shaped Dongyin sword in the blink of an eye. The heavy blade sprang lightly from Shen Yi's hand and sliced through the air, aiming straight for Liu Chongshan's face.
"Test my skills?" Shen Yi looked benign and inoffensive as he shook his head with a sigh. "I'm afraid Captain Liu isn't worthy."
5 'His little yifu' stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
5 'Gu Yun needs all the hugs' stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
5 'All is fair in love and war' stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
4 'War and love' stars
5 'changgu in love' stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
December 27, 2025
“All of a sudden, he realized perhaps it wasn’t that Gu Yun was the one good thing in his life worth looking forward to. Instead, it was as if everything he has suffered since birth was all to gather enough good fortune to meet this person.”
On my second read of Stars of Chaos: Sha Po Lang, Vol. 4, I found myself even more engrossed in the way Priest builds tension and deepens character relationships. This is the volume where everything becomes even more gripping, especially with the growing conflict and shifting alliances. We see more of Cao Chunhua’s role, adding another layer of intrigue, while the emperor’s isolation is laid bare—he has no family, no true friends, and everyone around him either wants to use him or see him dead. In contrast, Chang Geng continues to balance his ruthless political mind with the way he softens around Gu Yun. He can stand unshaken before the court, yet the moment he’s alone with Gu Yun, he becomes something entirely different.
Gu Yun remains as incredible as ever, relying on the tremors of the ground to navigate battles despite being blind and partially deaf. Even the enemy seems obsessed with him, which isn’t surprising at this point. Meanwhile, Shen Yi—normally strong and capable—becomes a complete mess when dealing with his own love life, turning into an awkward wreck in front of the person he likes. But what really stood out in this volume was Shen Yi’s understanding of Gu Yun. He knows Gu Yun has never been serious about anyone except Chang Geng. If he could have let go, he would have, but the fact that he didn’t means he can’t. That realization adds even more weight to their already complicated relationship.
The war between the north and south against the central forces is intense, and Priest masterfully balances large-scale battles with deeply personal struggles. Every moment feels important, whether it’s a military maneuver or a quiet conversation between two characters. Gu Yun and Chang Geng’s relationship continues to evolve, filled with moments of tension, understanding, and unspoken emotions. This volume has everything—political intrigue, heart-wrenching moments, humor, and expertly written action.
Date Read: 2024.10.08
Re-read: 2025.02.21
On my second read of Stars of Chaos: Sha Po Lang, Vol. 4, I found myself even more engrossed in the way Priest builds tension and deepens character relationships. This is the volume where everything becomes even more gripping, especially with the growing conflict and shifting alliances. We see more of Cao Chunhua’s role, adding another layer of intrigue, while the emperor’s isolation is laid bare—he has no family, no true friends, and everyone around him either wants to use him or see him dead. In contrast, Chang Geng continues to balance his ruthless political mind with the way he softens around Gu Yun. He can stand unshaken before the court, yet the moment he’s alone with Gu Yun, he becomes something entirely different.
Gu Yun remains as incredible as ever, relying on the tremors of the ground to navigate battles despite being blind and partially deaf. Even the enemy seems obsessed with him, which isn’t surprising at this point. Meanwhile, Shen Yi—normally strong and capable—becomes a complete mess when dealing with his own love life, turning into an awkward wreck in front of the person he likes. But what really stood out in this volume was Shen Yi’s understanding of Gu Yun. He knows Gu Yun has never been serious about anyone except Chang Geng. If he could have let go, he would have, but the fact that he didn’t means he can’t. That realization adds even more weight to their already complicated relationship.
The war between the north and south against the central forces is intense, and Priest masterfully balances large-scale battles with deeply personal struggles. Every moment feels important, whether it’s a military maneuver or a quiet conversation between two characters. Gu Yun and Chang Geng’s relationship continues to evolve, filled with moments of tension, understanding, and unspoken emotions. This volume has everything—political intrigue, heart-wrenching moments, humor, and expertly written action.
Date Read: 2024.10.08
Re-read: 2025.02.21
February 1, 2025
A lot of things happened in this volume. Countless court schemes, battles, Cao Chunhua showing his mettle, while Shen Yi the old hen became tongue-tied in front of a woman. Yet, the most important things for me were these:
All of a sudden, he realized perhaps it wasn’t that Gu Yun was the one good thing in his life worth looking forward to. Instead, it was as if everything he had suffered since birth was all to gather enough good fortune to meet this person. ~ Chang Geng
Little Chang Geng with his childish appeals for affection was pathetically adorable, but it was Prince Yan, shaping the state through the power of his pen, who truly moved him. ~ Gu Yun
September 30, 2024
“If Chang Geng kept looking at him like that for another incense stick’s time, he might actually climb up and fetch him the stars in the sky.”
March 9, 2025
if i had gu yun man… if i had gu yun
December 24, 2025
Once again, this volume manages to surpass its predecessor. The story continues to grow ever more fraught and tense with intrigue. Although, I will admit that I’m becoming somewhat fatigued by continuous scenes of warfare, this story is nevertheless epic. I also feel that this is one of the more tightly structured danmei that I’ve personally read. I suppose it remains to be seen whether Priest manages to pull off the ending with the final volume. However, it seems as though she definitely knew where she wanted to go with the story of Stars of Chaos and had it more or less planned out from the beginning.
Prior to picking this novel up for myself, I had heard many people claiming that Stars of Chaos either had no romance or very little of it. Personally, I really don’t understand this criticism. How could anyone possibly make that claim after having read the novel? The connection between Chang Geng and Gu Yun is so deep, heartfelt and profound. It’s evident in their every thought and action just how intensely they care for one another. Chang Geng in particular is so devoted to Gu Yun that it’s hard not to be moved. While it is true that a large portion of the novel is dedicated to warfare and political machinations, the love story is still a huge part of the plot. There is certainly no shortage of sweet, tender moments or displays of physical affection. Albeit, any sexual content is fade to black. However, that is hardly an unusual occurrence in danmei given the strictness Chinese censorship. I really can’t imagine how anyone could say that this isn’t a romantic novel.
One of the most interesting aspects of this story to me, aside from the relationship between the two main characters, is the wu’ergu. I won’t spoil it, but there was one scene in this volume in particular involving Chang Geng’s affliction with this rare shamanistic poison that I found particularly exciting and fascinating. Chang Geng is an incredibly strong willed person. His ability to resist the wu’ergu’s influence is amazing. I also deeply admire his grand, altruistic aspirations for Great Liang. It seems like Chang Geng is one of the few people in power who actually has the best interests of the nation and, more importantly, the common people at heart.
I also really enjoyed the fact that some of the side characters were given more time to shine in this volume. I really love both Shen Yi and Chen Qingxu, so it was nice to see both of them get a little more time in the spotlight. I also think that they make an adorable side couple. The way Shen Yi gets all flustered and tongue tied around Chen Qingxu is so cute. I’m really rooting for them to get together.
This was another exceptional installment in an already excellent series. The climax of this volume was quite literally explosive! I’m to definitely eager to read the ultimate conclusion in the next and final volume.
Prior to picking this novel up for myself, I had heard many people claiming that Stars of Chaos either had no romance or very little of it. Personally, I really don’t understand this criticism. How could anyone possibly make that claim after having read the novel? The connection between Chang Geng and Gu Yun is so deep, heartfelt and profound. It’s evident in their every thought and action just how intensely they care for one another. Chang Geng in particular is so devoted to Gu Yun that it’s hard not to be moved. While it is true that a large portion of the novel is dedicated to warfare and political machinations, the love story is still a huge part of the plot. There is certainly no shortage of sweet, tender moments or displays of physical affection. Albeit, any sexual content is fade to black. However, that is hardly an unusual occurrence in danmei given the strictness Chinese censorship. I really can’t imagine how anyone could say that this isn’t a romantic novel.
One of the most interesting aspects of this story to me, aside from the relationship between the two main characters, is the wu’ergu. I won’t spoil it, but there was one scene in this volume in particular involving Chang Geng’s affliction with this rare shamanistic poison that I found particularly exciting and fascinating. Chang Geng is an incredibly strong willed person. His ability to resist the wu’ergu’s influence is amazing. I also deeply admire his grand, altruistic aspirations for Great Liang. It seems like Chang Geng is one of the few people in power who actually has the best interests of the nation and, more importantly, the common people at heart.
I also really enjoyed the fact that some of the side characters were given more time to shine in this volume. I really love both Shen Yi and Chen Qingxu, so it was nice to see both of them get a little more time in the spotlight. I also think that they make an adorable side couple. The way Shen Yi gets all flustered and tongue tied around Chen Qingxu is so cute. I’m really rooting for them to get together.
This was another exceptional installment in an already excellent series. The climax of this volume was quite literally explosive! I’m to definitely eager to read the ultimate conclusion in the next and final volume.
March 28, 2025
I’m starting to feel like I don’t understand these books as well as I used to or as other people might.
Nothing happens in 2/3rds of the book. As usual, because another volume is coming, everything worth mentioning happens in the last 5 or so chapters to set you up for what will probably be another book where nothing happens until the end.
Because Chang Geng and Gu Yun are already together, there’s no build-up, no excitement. Their relationship is kept away from the page, and you get one-liners every now and again to remind you that they’re the focus of the story.
The war would be interesting if it weren’t repeated, but I felt like we ended one war, started another, and nothing had changed. Same story. Prince Yan trying to curb the Wu’ergu, and Gu Yun hiding his ailments from Prince Yan.
I’m not saying I don’t enjoy these books. The writing is incredible, but I feel like if you pick out the main points of these books and remove the filler, you could squeeze it into 1/2 volumes, not 5-8 as they usually run. I think this is made worse because you’re waiting months for the new volume and you forget what came before so it takes you at least a few chapters just to pick up where you were!
I do love this quote, it reminds me of how my partner always winds me up 😂
“How would I dare play with anyone else? Gu Yun thought. I’ve got one at home who’s more than enough.”
I do love their relationship. I love the fact that we get a story separate to their relationship too. I just think sometimes it feels like it just goes on and on.
Nothing happens in 2/3rds of the book. As usual, because another volume is coming, everything worth mentioning happens in the last 5 or so chapters to set you up for what will probably be another book where nothing happens until the end.
Because Chang Geng and Gu Yun are already together, there’s no build-up, no excitement. Their relationship is kept away from the page, and you get one-liners every now and again to remind you that they’re the focus of the story.
The war would be interesting if it weren’t repeated, but I felt like we ended one war, started another, and nothing had changed. Same story. Prince Yan trying to curb the Wu’ergu, and Gu Yun hiding his ailments from Prince Yan.
I’m not saying I don’t enjoy these books. The writing is incredible, but I feel like if you pick out the main points of these books and remove the filler, you could squeeze it into 1/2 volumes, not 5-8 as they usually run. I think this is made worse because you’re waiting months for the new volume and you forget what came before so it takes you at least a few chapters just to pick up where you were!
I do love this quote, it reminds me of how my partner always winds me up 😂
“How would I dare play with anyone else? Gu Yun thought. I’ve got one at home who’s more than enough.”
I do love their relationship. I love the fact that we get a story separate to their relationship too. I just think sometimes it feels like it just goes on and on.
November 8, 2025
"Perhaps it wasn’t that Gu Yun was the one good thing in his life worth looking forward to. Instead, it was as if everything he had suffered since birth was all to gather enough good fortune to meet this person."
Volume 4 is really short, but it feels the heaviest because everything finally converges: the years of conflict, politics, and emotional restraint explode into this quiet desperation. You can sense how finite the time together for everyone has become, especially to Gu Yun and Chang Geng. You can literally feel the sense of urgency from both of them.
"Would you believe it if I said that the fate of Great Liang rises and falls with me?" Chang Geng’s drive to build a peaceful Great Liang isn’t just ambition anymore, it’s his desperate attempt to free Gu Yun from duty, to create a world where Gu Yun doesn’t have to bleed anymore. The railways, the new government, the reformation—they’re all love letters disguised as national plans.
"Chang Geng, I really don’t have the strength to... let another person into my heart." Gu Yun, meanwhile, is haunted by his mortality. His every breath feels like a rebellion against time itself. His body is failing, and every moment with Chang Geng feels like a countdown. But his spirit is still made of iron, bound by duty, love, and the ache of wanting to live long enough to see Chang Geng safe.
Even the pacing of this volume mirrors that urgency: short chapters, abrupt transitions, flashes of memory and pain. It’s like the novel itself is gasping for breath, trying to hold everything together before the inevitable collapse. There's so much desperation in this volume not only from our main couple but also from a lot of parties. The westerners, barbarians, central plains people, and everyone else. The candle is burning on all ends. This is really the final stretch.
Volume 4 is really short, but it feels the heaviest because everything finally converges: the years of conflict, politics, and emotional restraint explode into this quiet desperation. You can sense how finite the time together for everyone has become, especially to Gu Yun and Chang Geng. You can literally feel the sense of urgency from both of them.
"Would you believe it if I said that the fate of Great Liang rises and falls with me?" Chang Geng’s drive to build a peaceful Great Liang isn’t just ambition anymore, it’s his desperate attempt to free Gu Yun from duty, to create a world where Gu Yun doesn’t have to bleed anymore. The railways, the new government, the reformation—they’re all love letters disguised as national plans.
"Chang Geng, I really don’t have the strength to... let another person into my heart." Gu Yun, meanwhile, is haunted by his mortality. His every breath feels like a rebellion against time itself. His body is failing, and every moment with Chang Geng feels like a countdown. But his spirit is still made of iron, bound by duty, love, and the ache of wanting to live long enough to see Chang Geng safe.
Even the pacing of this volume mirrors that urgency: short chapters, abrupt transitions, flashes of memory and pain. It’s like the novel itself is gasping for breath, trying to hold everything together before the inevitable collapse. There's so much desperation in this volume not only from our main couple but also from a lot of parties. The westerners, barbarians, central plains people, and everyone else. The candle is burning on all ends. This is really the final stretch.
March 2, 2025
5 stars
Forgive me for being brief today. I’ve written an elaborate review when I first read Sha Po Lang/ Stars of Chaos which you can find here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
I’m actually in a hurry to continue reading right now. My love for these two and their surrounding cast has once again skyrocketed during this volume..
I don’t even care about the weird cover any longer because I think the one of the last volume turned out very pretty.
Forgive me for being brief today. I’ve written an elaborate review when I first read Sha Po Lang/ Stars of Chaos which you can find here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
I’m actually in a hurry to continue reading right now. My love for these two and their surrounding cast has once again skyrocketed during this volume..
I don’t even care about the weird cover any longer because I think the one of the last volume turned out very pretty.
May 18, 2025
₊⊹♡ 5 stars ⋆˙⟡
my favorite quote ↓
‘’All of a sudden, he realized perhaps it wasn't that Gu Yun was the one good thing in his life worth looking forward to. Instead, it was as if everything he had suffered since birth was all to gather enough good fortune to meet this person.’’
this is my favorite book of the whole series🥲🥲🥲🥲
my favorite quote ↓
‘’All of a sudden, he realized perhaps it wasn't that Gu Yun was the one good thing in his life worth looking forward to. Instead, it was as if everything he had suffered since birth was all to gather enough good fortune to meet this person.’’
this is my favorite book of the whole series🥲🥲🥲🥲
July 24, 2025
Accidentally posted my review as an update and I'm too lazy to change that. Lol this was a 3.5 star book just as the others in the series were. There's something about it just not clicking with me, but I think that's more on me. The story is alright, it just goes over my head. 😅
October 28, 2024
Didn't know this was possible but I loved it even more than the first time
March 24, 2025
It’s like I’m being brainwashed. I should be creeped out by the nature of Gu Yun and Chang Geng’s relationship, but somehow, both of them are doing better than ever. They’re both healthier and happier than they have been in any of the previous books.
“How would I dare play with anyone else? I’ve got one at home who’s more than enough.” -Gu Yun (31)
Also, the plot is at its peak. I finished this book in one sitting, and now I’m desperate for the next one. As soon as it’s possible, I’m heading to Barnes and Noble for the finale.
Plus, you know an author’s good when you ship the straight couple. Shen Yi and Chen Qingxu were a surprise, but it definitely works. Maybe it’s because there’s nothing more entertaining than the pathetic husband and badass wife dynamic (I’m aware that Shen Yi is a general— but he’s pathetic in the way he interacts with her).
“How would I dare play with anyone else? I’ve got one at home who’s more than enough.” -Gu Yun (31)
Also, the plot is at its peak. I finished this book in one sitting, and now I’m desperate for the next one. As soon as it’s possible, I’m heading to Barnes and Noble for the finale.
Plus, you know an author’s good when you ship the straight couple. Shen Yi and Chen Qingxu were a surprise, but it definitely works. Maybe it’s because there’s nothing more entertaining than the pathetic husband and badass wife dynamic (I’m aware that Shen Yi is a general— but he’s pathetic in the way he interacts with her).
December 8, 2024
I went back and forth between 4-5 but I love Chang Geng so much that it’s a 5/5
There’s a lack of dialogue at certain points that felt arduous to read, so if you’re not a fan of plot… not the series for you!
I loved it, I don’t have much to say in this review (because it took me two months to finish this because of being busy) but I will miss them when the story ends.
I’m looking forward to Gu Yun and Chang Geng finally having peace..
There’s a lack of dialogue at certain points that felt arduous to read, so if you’re not a fan of plot… not the series for you!
I loved it, I don’t have much to say in this review (because it took me two months to finish this because of being busy) but I will miss them when the story ends.
I’m looking forward to Gu Yun and Chang Geng finally having peace..
March 14, 2025
4 stars. Plot picked up again in this volume. Lots of action and political intrigue. Really good lead-up to the final volume.
June 30, 2025
The two first volumes were a bit slow, but these last two are full of action. Sometimes there're too many things going on and the action becomes confusing (and after four volumes I'm still confused about some names and places), but finally things are moving forward and I'm excited to see how Great Liang is shaped after everything finish.
I'm still not too fond of the main couple. I'm not convinced by their romance, and I wish Ge Chen and Cao Chunhua would have more time on page. I think that's a lot of potential wasted with the little we see of them. Also .
I'm still not too fond of the main couple. I'm not convinced by their romance, and I wish Ge Chen and Cao Chunhua would have more time on page. I think that's a lot of potential wasted with the little we see of them. Also .
March 8, 2025
“If Chang Geng kept looking at him like that for another incense stick’s time, he might actually climb up and fetch him the stars in the sky.”
Chang Geng and Gu Yun’s dynamic is so special to me. They don’t need dramatic displays of affection for everyone in the room to know how much they love and want to protect each other😭💔💔
Chang Geng and Gu Yun’s dynamic is so special to me. They don’t need dramatic displays of affection for everyone in the room to know how much they love and want to protect each other😭💔💔
September 30, 2024
"Zixi," he began quietly, "I'm not trying to curse you. But have you considered what you'll do if something comes between the two of you in the future?"
Gu Yun was silent for a long while. This time, he didn't dodge the subject. Not until they had nearly reached the rear courtyard did Gu Yun finally speak, his voice so low as to be nearly inaudible. “I have. I don't know."
For once, Shen Yi didn't know what to say.
The grandest declaration of love in the world would have been less shocking to him than these five words.
Izabella using an unnecessarily long quote to start off the review? Obviously. I wish I can go forward in time to January when the fifth (and final!) volume will be released. Methinks that if there was ever a valid and justified occasion to use a time machine to travel through time, the release of the final installment of Sha Po Lang would be it. (And 7s, please tell me there is going to be a special edition! It is not yet available at my bookstore website and best believe I am willing to pay ridiculous prices for the little goodies!)
In his youth, Chang Geng had been adept at acting spoiled. Now he clearly wasn't just adept, he had practically perfected the art. Gu Yun was helpless against him. If Chang Geng kept looking at him like that for another incense stick's time, he might actually climb up and fetch him the stars in the sky.
Goodness, I love Changgu with my whole being. They are actually so perfect. And I’m usually all for a slow slow burn, but the fact that they have already established their relationship and put it in the context of this war and these political events makes for the best flavour of angst and pining. I can’t tell which I love more; when they’re together, being all domestic and cute and shit, or when they’re apart hopelessly pining and worrying about the other. Because. It’s. Just. Too. Good.
Little Chang Geng with his childish appeals for affection was pathetically adorable, but it was Prince Yan, shaping the state through the power of his pen, who truly moved him.
But these two got their own personal agendas concerning the other and it’s so great to read. Chang Geng wants nothing more than to heal Gu Yun’s affliction and ensure his health. He out here making plans to alter Great Liang to better benefit his man, and that is peak simp behaviour. And of course, Gu Yun wants nothing more than to find a cure for Chang Geng’s curse and ensure he lives a long life.
This kiss was as earnest as it was devoted, nearly reverent.
And of course, my sadistic self loves to see either of these two in pain because that sweet sweet comfort and concern and love they have for each other is a balm for the soul. Sue me! I enjoy those hurt/comfort moments. As long as these two get a happy ending, I am more than satisfied (please please please have a happy ending or I can’t guarantee I won’t lay down on the highway).
All of a sudden, he realized perhaps it wasn't that Gu Yun was the one good thing in his life worth looking forward to. Instead, it was as if everything he had suffered since birth was all to gather enough good fortune to meet this person.
Not to mention, their “secret relationship” is quickly becoming a not-so-secret relationship haha. These two are about as subtle as that explosion that the northern tribes set off. I pray for the sanities of Shen Yi, Chen Qingxu, and Liao Ran who have to be subjected to their sickeningly adorable flirting/teasing.
AND speaking of Shen Yi and Chen Qingxu! They are so so so cute. Shen Yi, that sweet, traditional gentleman is so smitten and awkward around Chen Qingxu. I love it. I hope that they too have their happy ending, but I know better than to get my hopes up for a side couple so I’m going to be tentatively hopeful about them.
Tensions in the plot are definitely building up. And I for one am so excited and saddened that it’s all coming to a close. I eagerly look forward to the next volume <3
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 18, 2025
I feel like this volume had a really good balance of romantic development and great plot. Am I sometimes like wtf is going on… why yes, yes I am. I’ve really loved the vulnerability of Gu Yun in this volume and also SHEN YI!!! I’ve loved him so much from the start and it’s so special seeing him so awkward and in his feels. I swear danmei gets me feeling all the feels and I’ve really liked how this volume kept me on my toes.
December 17, 2024
I feel like I’m somewhat alone in this, but I wish we got more info about the the crown princes of the 18 Barbarian Tribes because I think they were interesting.
January 9, 2025
This series picked up for the most part in the 4th installment where there is also A LOT more to learn about the Wu'ergu and the disaster it might cause if unleashed. I enjoyed seeing Chang Geng and Gu Yun grow in their intimate bond and unconditional love. It feels that Priest finally manages to portray their relationship accurately.
There could be romance in Priest's works! And a good one for that matter!
Thoroughly enjoyed that Cao Chunhua and Shen Yi caught some of the spotlight as they are up there in my favorites and deserved it.
Probably the best novel in the series. Looking forward to the final this upcoming Tuesday.
There could be romance in Priest's works! And a good one for that matter!
Thoroughly enjoyed that Cao Chunhua and Shen Yi caught some of the spotlight as they are up there in my favorites and deserved it.
Probably the best novel in the series. Looking forward to the final this upcoming Tuesday.
August 18, 2025
I must say I kind of grudgingly respect Jialai Yinghuo's insanity.
November 1, 2025
I was bored. :(
October 20, 2025
I just love on the cover the C in Chaos is Gu Yun's monocle and shiny.
Little lackluster ending for the Northern climax. Now to see how the South ends.
Little lackluster ending for the Northern climax. Now to see how the South ends.
October 24, 2024
If I want to be completely honest, I was drawing a blank at where the story left off. I mean, I obviously checked my previous reviews to get an idea of where we are and..ah. Yes. Court intrigue, cunning plans, sneaky Changgeng, got it.
We start with some light treason, followed by a promise of a bloody rebellion, and some stabbing, and then the court scheming amps up to eleventy with XXX and XXX which, WOW. Okay. Sheesh. And just when it seems like Changgeng and Gu Yun can take a breather, Great Liang is drawn to a desperate war on two fronts, and losing would mean losing everything. With everything at stake, Changgeng and Gu Yun (and Shen Yi and Doctor Chen) take a gamble that ends with a bang–literally.
Changgeng and Gu Yun’s relationship has settled: they both know they love each other and aren't afraid to show it (even though Gu Yun is grumpy about it). When Changgeng gets himself nearly stabbed to death and says he was afraid he was going to die with Gu Yun’s last word being “Out!”, Gu Yun makes sure to kiss him while still being furious at Changgeng’s recklessness (such Luo Wenzhou vibes!). And when Gu Yun finally pushes himself too far and breaks down, Changgeng kisses him (on the forehead) in front of other people. They’re not out out but their relationship feels like an open secret: the few who need to know, know about them and those who don’t need to know, refrain from thinking about it too closely. I’m also fond of the secondary ship that starts to take shape because d’aww.
The themes of disability and mental health are present throughout the book as Changgeng deals with his curse and Gu Yun is forced to face his “loneliness” (aka depression) as well as his deteriorating condition. Doctor Chen and Changgeng figure out something new about the wu’ergu curse and in the end (of the book) she has something that might change everything. *shivers in antici…pation!*
All in all, this was a thrilling read, my favorite volume of the story so far! The final book will be out in January, can’t wait to see how priest wraps this up!
We start with some light treason, followed by a promise of a bloody rebellion, and some stabbing, and then the court scheming amps up to eleventy with XXX and XXX which, WOW. Okay. Sheesh. And just when it seems like Changgeng and Gu Yun can take a breather, Great Liang is drawn to a desperate war on two fronts, and losing would mean losing everything. With everything at stake, Changgeng and Gu Yun (and Shen Yi and Doctor Chen) take a gamble that ends with a bang–literally.
Changgeng and Gu Yun’s relationship has settled: they both know they love each other and aren't afraid to show it (even though Gu Yun is grumpy about it). When Changgeng gets himself nearly stabbed to death and says he was afraid he was going to die with Gu Yun’s last word being “Out!”, Gu Yun makes sure to kiss him while still being furious at Changgeng’s recklessness (such Luo Wenzhou vibes!). And when Gu Yun finally pushes himself too far and breaks down, Changgeng kisses him (on the forehead) in front of other people. They’re not out out but their relationship feels like an open secret: the few who need to know, know about them and those who don’t need to know, refrain from thinking about it too closely. I’m also fond of the secondary ship that starts to take shape because d’aww.
The themes of disability and mental health are present throughout the book as Changgeng deals with his curse and Gu Yun is forced to face his “loneliness” (aka depression) as well as his deteriorating condition. Doctor Chen and Changgeng figure out something new about the wu’ergu curse and in the end (of the book) she has something that might change everything. *shivers in antici…pation!*
All in all, this was a thrilling read, my favorite volume of the story so far! The final book will be out in January, can’t wait to see how priest wraps this up!
October 28, 2025
Vol. 4 was such a ride & I loved every minute of it. This vol. dives even deeper into the political turmoil of Great Liang, and I’ll admit it took me a bit to follow all the factions, court drama, and military strategies (it definitely leans heavier on the politics this time around). But "Priest" balances that complexity with the same emotional tension & character depth that make this series so addictive.
I really enjoyed how the story expands the world while keeping the relationships front & center. Shen Yi and Chen Qingxu’s slow-burn dynamic continues to be one of my favorite parts 🥹 their moments together are understated but genuinely sweet. And Cao Chunhua? The little devil, absolutely adorable! He brings such lightness and humor to balance out all the scheming and chaos swirling around everyone else. Definitely enjoyed reading his parts.
Chang Geng and Gu Yun’s arcs remain intense and heartfelt, especially as the stakes keep rising and the curse subplot grows more dangerous. The mix of loyalty, love, and impending disaster had me glued to every page. It was so nice to see them being so accepting of each other too 🥹🥹
Overall, this felt a little more intricate and political than the previous ones, but it also made the emotional payoffs hit harder. I found it complex, beautiful, and full of those quiet character moments that stay with you long after you close the book.
I honestly can't wait to see how it all comes together in the final volume! Can't believe I am already reaching the end of this journey 🥲🥲
I really enjoyed how the story expands the world while keeping the relationships front & center. Shen Yi and Chen Qingxu’s slow-burn dynamic continues to be one of my favorite parts 🥹 their moments together are understated but genuinely sweet. And Cao Chunhua? The little devil, absolutely adorable! He brings such lightness and humor to balance out all the scheming and chaos swirling around everyone else. Definitely enjoyed reading his parts.
Chang Geng and Gu Yun’s arcs remain intense and heartfelt, especially as the stakes keep rising and the curse subplot grows more dangerous. The mix of loyalty, love, and impending disaster had me glued to every page. It was so nice to see them being so accepting of each other too 🥹🥹
Overall, this felt a little more intricate and political than the previous ones, but it also made the emotional payoffs hit harder. I found it complex, beautiful, and full of those quiet character moments that stay with you long after you close the book.
I honestly can't wait to see how it all comes together in the final volume! Can't believe I am already reaching the end of this journey 🥲🥲
August 10, 2025
4 ⭐️
I’ve read somewhere that this series is considered sad and angsty.
Mmm. I don’t see it.
It’s pretty lighthearted.
I mean yes there are battles. Yes, there is pain. And court intrigues and squabbling and other things.
But it’s like a bedtime story. A fun one. Only with battles 😀
I’ve read somewhere that this series is considered sad and angsty.
Mmm. I don’t see it.
It’s pretty lighthearted.
I mean yes there are battles. Yes, there is pain. And court intrigues and squabbling and other things.
But it’s like a bedtime story. A fun one. Only with battles 😀
Displaying 1 - 30 of 121 reviews