3.5/5
Thank you to Riverfolk Books and Etgoma for this ARC!
Characters: ★★★☆☆
Agnieszka and Carmina are 14 and couldn't be more different. Agnieszka is a rule follower and cares very much about fashion. Carmina is all about being a warrior like her father who fights against the Russians, she cares nothing for school or fashion unless it'll get a gun in her hand and out on the field blowing up Russians. The girls share a love for their country and an end to the war.
I found Agnieszka very annoying in her views, she was too materialistic for me to relate to her. Her constant use of Spanish words was bizarre and took me out of the story every time. Carmina is very passionate about joining the war and I related to her a bit better because why do we need a Scottish purse when there's a war going on, Agnieszka?? She's a bit much, but there are plenty of children who were just like this during the Iraq War, albeit slightly different because it wasn't on their own soil.
Mara has been taught to be Baba Yaga and guide the death into the afterlife. Mara is vastly different from her cat Aidan, she doesn't understand humans and prefers being alone and Aidan adores them. He can turn into a human and is an absolute peach.
Overall, the characters are good. I preferred Mara's chapters, probably because I couldn't get into the 14 year olds' POV's and how they were written like diaries/letters.
Atmosphere:★★★★☆
It's war in Ukraine, it's not uber depressing, but the start of the book is Agnieszka telling how the days went through the beginning of the war. She mentions the news footage, the sounds of the bombs and air raid sirens, the stores being packed even though there was nothing to get. It's bleak but there's hope. Etgoma does a good job of showing the patriotism of the Ukrainian people with their songs and greetings. It's those little things that help bring you through the tough times.
Mara's parts are a bit more positive but she is shepherding people into the afterlife and by doing so she sees all of their memories. It explains her feelings on human beings and it changes through her friendship with the girls (and a goose!).
Plot, Pacing, and Premise: ★★★☆☆
The plot and pacing were okay. Agnieszka's POV is always in a diary format so there is A LOT of telling and not so much showing. Carmina's POV is always a letter to her father, so it's similar to Agnieszka's and I felt like that really slowed things down. Mara's POV is told more like a linear story and so it felt faster and more enjoyable for me. The premise is amazing and along with the cover is what hooked me, but I wish I had known how the teen's POVs were going to be written. I still would have read the book, but I remember starting Agnieszka's POV and wondering what happened to the story. So because of that, I felt like the actual story didn't live up to the premise in a way that I expected.
Tone: ★★★★☆
Etgoma handles tone well as each character has their own outlook and inner feelings that shape how they handle situations (positive, pessimistic, indifferent). Overall, the unite in the love of Ukraine.
Intrigue: ★★★★★
Ace characters, Slavic folklore, Baba Yaga, and the Ukraine war? Count me in!
Versus (Strengths & Weaknesses): ★★★☆☆
Strengths is capturing the war from Etgoma's experiences. The two authors wrote this during the war and so you can expect truth and honesty, they didn't shy from anything. I loved Mara/Baba Yaga and found it so interesting and fun. The asexual representation was wonderful and I loved seeing it.
However, as the authors are two asexuals themselves, I really expected to relate a bit more. I think having the characters as 14 year old asexuals hindered that as 16+ is more of the age range where asexuality might be seen as a problem. Although, there was plenty I did understand and enjoyed having been put out there. The random Spanish was so jarring and I wish another language was used. Agnieszka's father is half Polish so even using Polish over Ukrainian would have felt more connected to the story. It just seemed like she was using Spanish as kids use French in North America to seem uber mature. The random swearing was weird too, we can't say the F word but we can say bastards and shit and rape while wanting Russian's to be blown up? I don't think I'll ever understand where one draws the line with swearing in books, but seeing "eff"/"effing" and bastard and shit on the same page felt weird.
Audience: ★★★☆☆
If you edit the swearing and somehow address the atrocities of war in a way that works, I think this would be the perfect middle grade novel. As it stands, I don't think two 14 year olds and how they act make it a very good Young Adult book, it won't capture the 16+ readers because they sometimes think 14 year olds are babies and lame. Clearly, two teens living through the war are anything but lame, but kids are weird sometimes.
Themes: ★★★★☆
The passion, love, and fight for Ukraine is so beautiful and intense. Etgoma touch on how social media helps and hinders their fight and how draining it can be. The simple lines of "Gotta go hide in the bathtub again!" are almost poignant. Readers will definitely feel the deep pain and trauma that these people are going through, and although heavy, makes this book stand out from any other.
Ending: ★★★★★
The ending is good, it's hopeful and wonderful, it reminds us to fight for what we believe in and never forget what it is we fight for.
Overall, the book is a story of war that reaches all of us. It has representation that is necessary and needed, by authors who are living through these things. It shows light and hope through darkness that you think might be endless, but remember that light and it will stay with you. I think it misses the mark for YA, but this would be a wonderful Juvenile novel. I was surprised with how many WWII J FIC books there were until I started working at the library, so I think this would find it's readership perfectly among those war stories.