Actual rating: 3.5
First off, the world-building, because I truly enjoyed it. Not only is it interesting, but it's also well-done: even if at the beginning the high volume of specifically invented vocabulary might slow down the reading, everything takes its place pretty fast, and it's easy to come to appreciate the rich world that the Three Scribes have created. While it winks to consolidate magic systems like element-based magic, familiars, and others, such concepts are interpreted under a new light, and there's the added element of action happening in the dream world, where everyone can go, even though some are more aware (and thus skilled) than others. I found everything about the world and the magic in it really intriguing and would definitely like to learn more about it.
The characters are a heterogeneous bunch, well-rounded and all interesting in their own ways. Unfortunately, I found their characterization a bit on the surface and would have love to learn more about each of them, also through more interaction among them, something I felt I missed and would have helped me to be ever more emotionally invested — I still found myself drawn to them and I really like each character, which speaks to the ability of the writers make a connection happen even if the characters are not presented in depth. Yet, more focus on the interactions among them would also help witnessing the creation of the found family that is the core of this story — I like destined-like relationships, but I need to see such bonds backed by something more concrete to actually care on a Deep level about the characters. Like to when it the world and the magic, I hope this not-in-depth descriptions are due to this being the first book in a series, thus working as an introduction, and we'll see more details about the world and the magic and read more about the characters' background and their interactions in the following books.
Last, the plot. This book is quest-based fantasy that is strongly event-based, resulting in a fast-paced story with a plot that plays out nicely and pulls different threads well until they all come together. I did, however, hope to read more about the wycche, because I felt her storyline a bit weak, more like a villain that's there because a fantasy need one, but who doesn't feel indispensabile — I believe, and hope, this is due to the book generally remaining of the surface as an introduction to a saga.
Oh, the writing is good, with a style that delivers the different perspectives depending on what character the focus is on, and makes you feel like you're going with this found family on their quest.
My thanks to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for allowing me to read the arc of this new adventure!