What do you think?
Rate this book
Spring Melt
As a doctor’s wife in a thriving Adirondack village in the 1920s, Ella Devine seems to have an ideal life. Her husband grew rich catering to New York City socialites who wanted to hide their TB diagnoses from their friends. Their marriage is devoid of emotion, but so is she, having learned long ago to quietly accept whatever life offers. But all that changes when three men are charged with a nineteen-year-old murder, and the long-buried crime that shaped Ella’s childhood is exposed.
Spring Melt draws on the rich and fascinating history of the Adirondacks, where hikers who see only low hills and lush vegetation fail to perceive the hidden dangers and lose their lives by stepping two feet off the trail. Since the late 1800s, the wilderness that is the Adirondacks has been both a frontier to be conquered only by the hardiest of humans and a playland for the wealthy. When these two worlds collide, the resulting explosion can be fatal.
Spring Melt draws on the rich and fascinating history of the Adirondacks, where hikers who see only low hills and lush vegetation fail to perceive the hidden dangers and lose their lives by stepping two feet off the trail. Since the late 1800s, the wilderness that is the Adirondacks has been both a frontier to be conquered only by the hardiest of humans and a playland for the wealthy. When these two worlds collide, the resulting explosion can be fatal.
268 pages, Paperback
Published March 10, 2026
7 people are currently reading
1427 people want to read
About the author
Lori Duffy Foster
10 books149 followersA former crime reporter, Lori Duffy Foster was born and raised in the Adirondack Mountains of New York State, where a piece of her heart remains. Her previous novels include NEVER LET GO, a thriller, and the Lisa Jamison Mystery Series. Her books have been nominees or finalists for Agatha, Silver Falchion and Shamus awards. Lori is a member of Mystery Writers of America, Sisters in Crime, The Historical Novel Society, International Thriller Writers, The Finger Lakes Authors & Readers Experience and Pennwriters. After several moves about the country with her family, Lori now lives and writes in the hills of Northern Pennsylvania. Look out for two new novels in 2026 and 2027 from Speaking Volumes LLC, SPRING MELT, an historical courtroom drama, and NO STRANGER HERE, a thriller.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
November 22, 2025
I enjoyed Spring Melt. It’s one of those books that sticks with you because of all emotions it pulls out of you. Ella’s childhood story made me feel angry and heartbroken —-especially the way she was treated after what she went through.
As a young adult, 19 years later, she is forced to face her past again. At this point, the tone shifts, and I found myself feeling hopeful. Watching her find her strength and really begin to thrive is uplifting. Her development of true, meaningful relationships was especially heart warming.
The setting is another huge highlight. The Adirondack Mountains aren’t just scenery —they shape the whole mood of the story. The descriptions are so vivid they made me want to dig into the history of the area and the events surrounding that time period.
As the trial begins, I found myself genuinely rooting for the defendants. The way the story build up to that point makes the outcome feel so personal.
Overall, Spring Melt is engaging, beautifully set, and full of heart. I am really glad I read it.
As a young adult, 19 years later, she is forced to face her past again. At this point, the tone shifts, and I found myself feeling hopeful. Watching her find her strength and really begin to thrive is uplifting. Her development of true, meaningful relationships was especially heart warming.
The setting is another huge highlight. The Adirondack Mountains aren’t just scenery —they shape the whole mood of the story. The descriptions are so vivid they made me want to dig into the history of the area and the events surrounding that time period.
As the trial begins, I found myself genuinely rooting for the defendants. The way the story build up to that point makes the outcome feel so personal.
Overall, Spring Melt is engaging, beautifully set, and full of heart. I am really glad I read it.
December 7, 2025
Spring Melt is a riveting story of justice, forgiveness, and redemption, in which revelations about past crimes and long-buried secrets unfold with nail-biting intensity. The layered narrative is a high-stakes courtroom drama that is also a thriller, as well as a coming-of-age story for the woman at the center of the conflict. As evidence piles up, for and against three men accused of murder, the personal bumps up against the political in ways that surprise, and yet, at the same time, feel inevitable.
Spring Melt is not merely set in the Adirondacks. It’s that rare work in which the place and time are inextricably woven into the fabric of the tale. The descriptions are so vivid, I felt as if I knew, as well as the author, the landscape.
Though the conclusion is deeply satisfying, I was sorry to turn the last page. It was that good.
Spring Melt is not merely set in the Adirondacks. It’s that rare work in which the place and time are inextricably woven into the fabric of the tale. The descriptions are so vivid, I felt as if I knew, as well as the author, the landscape.
Though the conclusion is deeply satisfying, I was sorry to turn the last page. It was that good.
November 19, 2025
Spring Melt is the 5th book I’ve read by author Lori Duffy Foster. Just as I have with her previous books, I enjoyed reading this very much. It’s a historical fiction story that centers around the legal proceedings of 3 men who are accused of murder. But was it murder or just an accident that they had no control over? I myself enjoy reading this author because she writes of areas that I am very familiar with. This book takes place in the Adirondacks, which is in New York State and I don’t live very far from there. I personally seem to connect more with stories that take place or mention areas that I know because for me they seem more real. Spring Melt is about the rape of a very young girl named Ella Devine and the effects it had on her and on her fathers 3 friends who were lumberjacks in the area. It goes on to show of the police corruption that occurred in that area due to greed and selfishness. Social class really made a difference in how people were treated and it just wasn’t fair or right. Besides the authors mention of local towns and cities that I am very familiar with, her descriptions of the Adirondack Mountains was spot on. It’s plain to see that she writes what she knows and she does it well. I was very satisfied with the way the story and verdict turned out in the end and I appreciated that the author included an epilogue that gave us a peek into Ella’s future life along with some of the other characters. I enjoyed reading this story so much and it’s a book I will be recommending to others. If you’ve never read this author, she is definitely one you should be checking out. I’m giving this story a 5 star rating!
February 23, 2026
Let me start by saying that I’m a big fan of courtroom dramas, as evidenced by my extensive collection of Grisham novels and countless hours spent watching Perry Mason and Matlock. However, if you’re seeking courtroom drama in Spring Melt, be prepared for a wait, as the trial itself doesn’t commence until the book’s midpoint.
The central crime in this book revolves around an alleged murder that occurred many years ago at a logging camp in the Adirondack Mountains of upstate New York. The author’s characterizations of the attorneys, defendants, and the deceased are intriguing and well-developed. In my opinion, the author’s vivid descriptions of the various settings are the standout feature of this book. They allowed me to easily imagine myself in the courtroom, by the lake, or around the town.
However, I must point out that there were several lengthy passages that didn’t directly contribute to the main plot. For instance, George and Marianne’s son, Sammy, was irrelevant to the story, as were the two children that Ella encountered by the river and the boy lost in the woods. While these sidelined stories served to humanize the characters, the author’s descriptive prowess could have easily stood alone.
As a warning, this book has a subplot depicting the devastating emotional impact of child sexual assault
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving my honest review voluntarily.
The central crime in this book revolves around an alleged murder that occurred many years ago at a logging camp in the Adirondack Mountains of upstate New York. The author’s characterizations of the attorneys, defendants, and the deceased are intriguing and well-developed. In my opinion, the author’s vivid descriptions of the various settings are the standout feature of this book. They allowed me to easily imagine myself in the courtroom, by the lake, or around the town.
However, I must point out that there were several lengthy passages that didn’t directly contribute to the main plot. For instance, George and Marianne’s son, Sammy, was irrelevant to the story, as were the two children that Ella encountered by the river and the boy lost in the woods. While these sidelined stories served to humanize the characters, the author’s descriptive prowess could have easily stood alone.
As a warning, this book has a subplot depicting the devastating emotional impact of child sexual assault
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving my honest review voluntarily.
March 10, 2026
SPRING MELT takes us to an Adirondack village during the 1920s, where the criminal trial of a decades-old murder tied to the assault of a young girl is causing tumult within the community.
Lori Duffy Foster excels at creating setting and atmosphere. I felt what it was like to live in a remote town, surrounded by wilderness and rough-edged men.
This story is part mystery and part courtroom drama, posting thoughtful questions about vengeance, punishment, and justice.
*Thanks to the author and publisher for the free eARC, provided via NetGalley!*
Lori Duffy Foster excels at creating setting and atmosphere. I felt what it was like to live in a remote town, surrounded by wilderness and rough-edged men.
This story is part mystery and part courtroom drama, posting thoughtful questions about vengeance, punishment, and justice.
*Thanks to the author and publisher for the free eARC, provided via NetGalley!*
Review of advance copy received from Author
If you are looking for a historical fiction novel that will really tug at your heart strings then you need to check out Spring Melt. I must admit there is so much drama and mystery you are going to be on your toes the whole time. Despite all that I found this book to be very uplifting and makes for a very good second chance story.
When Ella was a little girl she suffered a horrible assault. At the time nothing was done about it and she was sent away. She went through life never really talking about what happened and figured no one needed to know. Although years later in the 1920's after her abuser is found dead the secrets of her childhood trauma come to light. Will she have the courage to move on?
I have to say despite all the sadness she endured. She did move on. Her first husband actually left her because of her past but she managed to find a another love and make a better life for herself. This is a story you do not want to miss.
When Ella was a little girl she suffered a horrible assault. At the time nothing was done about it and she was sent away. She went through life never really talking about what happened and figured no one needed to know. Although years later in the 1920's after her abuser is found dead the secrets of her childhood trauma come to light. Will she have the courage to move on?
I have to say despite all the sadness she endured. She did move on. Her first husband actually left her because of her past but she managed to find a another love and make a better life for herself. This is a story you do not want to miss.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Picture this: 1920's. Adirondack. rural New York. A 9 year old girl who was the apple of her dead lumberjack father's eye is brutally raped by her mother's employer's son.
What transpires over the next 20 years is heartbreaking, evil, devious, and eventually promising.
Having read the prologue, I just want to commend the author for her persistence in getting this work published. Yes, it was worth the wait.
There are a lot of characters in this book. Too many, with a lot of different storylines. I felt I needed an outline to keep some of the characters straight. And sadly, it meant I really felt no depth from any of them.
There was a lot of description in the beginning of the book "George heard the heavy door shut as his clerk headed down the dimly lit staircase to the street below." You can hear and see yourself there, right? Throughout the novel intricate descriptions are used to evoke reader senses in different scenes as we finalize the thriller that started over 20 years ago. I felt a parent's anxiety. Smelled the sweat of an overcrowded courtroom.
This was a historical thriller set in a different era and different part of the country for me. I enjoyed the descriptive writing.
I had a really hard time with quiet, anxious Ella going from super introverted to hiking in the mountains alone with a man in less than two weeks. Some outcomes just seemed beyond realistic.
I received an advanced copy of this book for free. I am writing this review voluntarily.
.
What transpires over the next 20 years is heartbreaking, evil, devious, and eventually promising.
Having read the prologue, I just want to commend the author for her persistence in getting this work published. Yes, it was worth the wait.
There are a lot of characters in this book. Too many, with a lot of different storylines. I felt I needed an outline to keep some of the characters straight. And sadly, it meant I really felt no depth from any of them.
There was a lot of description in the beginning of the book "George heard the heavy door shut as his clerk headed down the dimly lit staircase to the street below." You can hear and see yourself there, right? Throughout the novel intricate descriptions are used to evoke reader senses in different scenes as we finalize the thriller that started over 20 years ago. I felt a parent's anxiety. Smelled the sweat of an overcrowded courtroom.
This was a historical thriller set in a different era and different part of the country for me. I enjoyed the descriptive writing.
I had a really hard time with quiet, anxious Ella going from super introverted to hiking in the mountains alone with a man in less than two weeks. Some outcomes just seemed beyond realistic.
I received an advanced copy of this book for free. I am writing this review voluntarily.
.
November 17, 2025
When the winter is over and the snow melts, what has been hidden is revealed. In ‘Spring Melt’, Lori Duffy Foster introduces us to an intriguing scenario. Ella Devine, now 28 years of age, was raped by Henry Roth when she was nine. The crime was covered up, money exchanged hands, and the victim was raised by an older couple, after her mother deserted her. Shortly after, Roth dies ‘accidentally’. Years later, three lumberjacks go on trial for murdering Roth, after evidence surfaces of their crime. They are seen as delivering justice to the young woman whose rapist never faced court. Now, Ella must now face the brutal reality of what she experienced at the hands of the dead man as she testifies in court.
The first half of the book introduces us to the character and viewpoints of the main actors in the drama: Ella Devine, the prosecutor, the defence attorney, the defendants and so on. The second half involves the court case, which is portrayed really well. Each chapter presents the point of view of one of the characters, giving a nuanced and comprehensive interpretation of the trial and their place in it.
The strength of the writing is in the portrayal of the natural beauty of the Adirondack mountains, the setting of the novel. Foster’s prose is a delight, poetic even, as she portrays Ella’s response to her surroundings. Her character is finely drawn; the effects of childhood trauma having a lasting effect on her interaction with family and neighbours. Will Ella emerge from her hibernation, as she confronts her past and finally finds her voice?
‘Spring Melt’ is life-affirming, presenting a protagonist who is given a second chance to experience and enjoy life. Foster writes with sensitivity and maturity. This is a thoughtful and nuanced story, encouraging the reader’s engagement with the issues it raises. It also presents us with an ethical question: Can murder be justified when the perpetrator has escaped justice himself?
Lori Duffy Foster has excelled herself. I loved this book!
The first half of the book introduces us to the character and viewpoints of the main actors in the drama: Ella Devine, the prosecutor, the defence attorney, the defendants and so on. The second half involves the court case, which is portrayed really well. Each chapter presents the point of view of one of the characters, giving a nuanced and comprehensive interpretation of the trial and their place in it.
The strength of the writing is in the portrayal of the natural beauty of the Adirondack mountains, the setting of the novel. Foster’s prose is a delight, poetic even, as she portrays Ella’s response to her surroundings. Her character is finely drawn; the effects of childhood trauma having a lasting effect on her interaction with family and neighbours. Will Ella emerge from her hibernation, as she confronts her past and finally finds her voice?
‘Spring Melt’ is life-affirming, presenting a protagonist who is given a second chance to experience and enjoy life. Foster writes with sensitivity and maturity. This is a thoughtful and nuanced story, encouraging the reader’s engagement with the issues it raises. It also presents us with an ethical question: Can murder be justified when the perpetrator has escaped justice himself?
Lori Duffy Foster has excelled herself. I loved this book!
December 9, 2025
Once the story started playing out with what happened to nine-year-old Ella to the trial of the three men who killed her attacker nineteen years after the murder I couldn't put the book down. The characters came to life for me in a short period of time. I wanted to protect Ella while advocating for the innocence of the three accused men. It became a real argument in my mind between the law and legal justice versus morality and moral justice. Which one is better, and should we have to give up one to impose the other? This was such a good book, and I loved the historical aspect of the story being it's in small town 1920's when a "not guilty" verdict could be bought if you had the means to do so and the local government was just corrupt enough to do it for you. Very interesting, exceedingly compelling and a wonderful story. I look forward to more from this author. Happy Reading!
November 2, 2025
Set in the 1920s Adirondacks, Spring Melt blends historical fiction, mystery, and emotional depth. The story follows Ella Devine, the wife of a successful doctor catering to wealthy New York City patients. Though her life appears perfect, her marriage lacks warmth and love until the past resurfaces with the discovery of a nineteen-year-old murder that reopens old wounds and secrets.
Foster crafts a vivid sense of time and place, painting the Adirondacks not just as a backdrop but as a living, breathing character both beautiful and perilous. The novel promises rich historical detail, complex female perspective, and an exploration of how social class, secrecy, and survival intersect in a world where appearances mean everything.
Thank you to BookSirens for an ARC
Foster crafts a vivid sense of time and place, painting the Adirondacks not just as a backdrop but as a living, breathing character both beautiful and perilous. The novel promises rich historical detail, complex female perspective, and an exploration of how social class, secrecy, and survival intersect in a world where appearances mean everything.
Thank you to BookSirens for an ARC
November 23, 2025
I’ve enjoyed Lori Duffy’s previous novels, so I was excited to dive into Spring Melt - and it did not disappoint. Stylistically, it highlights the author’s versatility and strength as a storyteller.
Spring Melt is a courtroom-drama-meets-crime novel that keeps you guessing until the very last page. It explores the harsh realities of life alongside the beauty of friendship and love. You see how ego can cloud judgment, and how staying true to yourself can lead to meaningful outcomes. The story unfolds through multiple characters and perspectives, each adding depth and dimension to the narrative.
November 5, 2025
This was a wonderful historical novel, drawing examples of corrupt police, prejudices against native Americans and even a woman who was raped as a child…. the sensitivity of the subject matter may be upsetting to some, but this is a beautifully written novel, that the author should be proud of.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
April 23, 2026
In Spring Melt, the Adirondacks serve as a lethal intersection of class and geography. The novel juxtaposes the region as both a gruelling, unforgiving frontier for locals and an opulent "sanatorium" for NYC elites fleeing the shame of Tuberculosis (TB). This collision is fatal; the wealthy view the landscape as a backdrop for their convenience, ignoring the reality that, like the thin ice of the title, the wilderness—and the social order—can shatter instantly. The author masterfully uses the metaphor of the trail: step two feet off, and the "lush vegetation" reveals ravines and death. Similarly, the characters' lives are fragile surfaces masking deep, dark secrets.
Ella’s "survival mode"—quietly accepting her hollow marriage—is portrayed as a dangerous stagnation. While it preserves her safety in the short term, it leaves her unprepared when the past resurfaces. Silence is not protection; it is a pressurized vessel waiting to explode. The novel argues that true survival requires confronting the "crack" in the ice rather than skating over it.
Historically, this is hauntingly accurate. During the 1920s, TB was a profound social stigma, often equated with moral failing or "tainted" bloodlines. NYC socialites flocked to the Adirondacks (like Saranac Lake) to seek treatment in private "cures," desperate to keep their diagnoses from ruining their social standing or marriage prospects.
Ultimately, Spring Melt posits that truth is never buried; it is merely waiting for the thaw. When the nineteen-year-old murder case forces the past into the light, the motivations—greed, shame, and survival—collide, proving that the most dangerous terrain in the Adirondacks isn't the forest, but the secrets people keep.
Ella’s "survival mode"—quietly accepting her hollow marriage—is portrayed as a dangerous stagnation. While it preserves her safety in the short term, it leaves her unprepared when the past resurfaces. Silence is not protection; it is a pressurized vessel waiting to explode. The novel argues that true survival requires confronting the "crack" in the ice rather than skating over it.
Historically, this is hauntingly accurate. During the 1920s, TB was a profound social stigma, often equated with moral failing or "tainted" bloodlines. NYC socialites flocked to the Adirondacks (like Saranac Lake) to seek treatment in private "cures," desperate to keep their diagnoses from ruining their social standing or marriage prospects.
Ultimately, Spring Melt posits that truth is never buried; it is merely waiting for the thaw. When the nineteen-year-old murder case forces the past into the light, the motivations—greed, shame, and survival—collide, proving that the most dangerous terrain in the Adirondacks isn't the forest, but the secrets people keep.
March 11, 2026
Lori Duffy Foster
Spring Melt
Lori did a fantastic job writing Spring Melt. I enjoyed the characters that she had matched up. I also thought the book was one you couldn't put down.
Ella I loved her place in the book even if it was bad what happened to her. Her mother showed no love for her daughter. But every bit was interesting the life she went through.
George the lawyer was very compassionate to Ella.
Her husband David was not what she deserved. He was mean to her and treated her badly.
Then when she met Will he was compassionate, understanding and showed her how she should be treated.
Henry Roth was a very mean and drunken man and treated Ella at young age was not good. The three men looked out for Ella and didn't like what happened to her.
This is a book I recommend to and book lovers.
Spring Melt
Lori did a fantastic job writing Spring Melt. I enjoyed the characters that she had matched up. I also thought the book was one you couldn't put down.
Ella I loved her place in the book even if it was bad what happened to her. Her mother showed no love for her daughter. But every bit was interesting the life she went through.
George the lawyer was very compassionate to Ella.
Her husband David was not what she deserved. He was mean to her and treated her badly.
Then when she met Will he was compassionate, understanding and showed her how she should be treated.
Henry Roth was a very mean and drunken man and treated Ella at young age was not good. The three men looked out for Ella and didn't like what happened to her.
This is a book I recommend to and book lovers.
March 9, 2026
Rounded up from 3.5
In 1920s New York, Ella finds her hollow social life shattered when three local men are charged with a nineteen-year-old murder linked to her own childhood trauma. The men were accused of serving up justice vigilante-style.
This was an interesting courtroom drama with a few too many side stories going on. A few of them could have been cut without messing up the story. Ella's trauma is horrific, though handled quite delicately. The relationships were well written and interesting. I especially loved the scene where George's wife comes to support him in the courtroom...tender and sweet.
This was an enjoyable read. I am interested in her other books.
Thank you to Book Sirens and Lori Duffy Foster for the ARC. My opinions are given freely.
In 1920s New York, Ella finds her hollow social life shattered when three local men are charged with a nineteen-year-old murder linked to her own childhood trauma. The men were accused of serving up justice vigilante-style.
This was an interesting courtroom drama with a few too many side stories going on. A few of them could have been cut without messing up the story. Ella's trauma is horrific, though handled quite delicately. The relationships were well written and interesting. I especially loved the scene where George's wife comes to support him in the courtroom...tender and sweet.
This was an enjoyable read. I am interested in her other books.
Thank you to Book Sirens and Lori Duffy Foster for the ARC. My opinions are given freely.
April 14, 2026
I saved this book to read just as we were finally experiencing our Spring Melt in my part of the world, just to be on theme!
A nice and slightly unusual story due to some more modern takes being blended in with rigid traditional mindsets. I do wish that some of the characters had been more developed though.
Thanks to both the author and BookSirens for the ARC copy of this book.
A nice and slightly unusual story due to some more modern takes being blended in with rigid traditional mindsets. I do wish that some of the characters had been more developed though.
Thanks to both the author and BookSirens for the ARC copy of this book.
Review of advance copy received from Author
In the lush, beautiful Adirondacks of New York, in the 1920s, many TB patients came to recover in “the crisp, cold, dry air.” “Fiscally desperate people were not among Dr. David Devine’s patients…Unlike his colleagues, he only accepted those patients who could pay…catering to a breed of wealthy who preferred not to mix with the poor.” David made all the decisions in his stilted marriage to Ella.
George Alberts, defense attorney, welcomed the opportunity to live in “God’s country with just enough wealthy tourists in need of lawyers to keep a good solid roof over their heads.” His wife, Marianne was a member of the Onondaga Nation, an Indian territory south of Syracuse. Their son had recently chosen to live among his Indian family.
After nineteen years, a guilt ridden lumberjack employed by the Roth family business, came forward informing prosecutor Jim Maddox about a plan three lumberjacks hatched to kill Henry Roth, the son/heir of the business. A different party remembered a drunk Henry bragging in a bar while giving a detailed description of his rape of nine year old, Ella. In alternating chapters the victims, the accused, prosecution and defense teams are introduced as three lumberjacks face charges of murder.
Ella Ward’s father, deemed a hero by fellow lumberjacks, died while trying to save a fellow logger. Ella, three years old at the time, was taught to fish, hunt and swim by her three fathers; Cyril Cole, Paul McDonald and John LeRoche. When each logging season ended with the spring melt, Ella and her mother Katherine, a camp cook, would spend the off season cooking at Roth’s Great Camp on Big Tupper Lake. One day while Ella was exploring, seventeen year old Henry Roth raped her.
After a quick investigation, Sheriff John O’Malley announced a payment plan. Ella’s mother would leave town permanently and relinquish Ella’s care to “Aunt Audrey and Uncle Ronald” Kurtz who lived in Saranac Lake. O’Malley supplemented his salary through bribery. Wealthy city families were willing to pay him to have pending charges dropped. The lumberjacks disliked O’Malley.
The re-opened case of Henry Roth’s death awakened painful memories for Ella. Although George Alberts was an experienced lawyer, he had never tried a murder case. He would be called upon to defend the three lumberjacks who killed or might have killed on behalf of Ella Devine, a victim of rape. He would need Ella’s input to help frame the case. The lumberjacks were not helpful in their own defense.
Jim Maddox, the prosecutor, wanted to run for State Senate. “It wouldn’t be easy to convince a jury and the voting public that three seemingly harmless old lumberjacks were cold-hearted killers…”. Jim would claim that Cyril Cole killed for money and status-upon Henry’s demise, he ran the Roth Lumber Camp. Cyril had strict rules thus providing safe working conditions. There were no injuries during his watch. Cyril was respected and highly regarded unlike Henry who always came to work drunk and showed no interest in his employees. Each of the defendants recounted the same story of Henry’s death. With no forensic evidence, would the jury condemn or condone the actions of the accused?
A fascinating read that combines trauma, mystery and court procedural. Kudos to author Lori Duffy Foster.
Thank you Lori Duffy Foster for the print ARC in exchange for an honest review.
George Alberts, defense attorney, welcomed the opportunity to live in “God’s country with just enough wealthy tourists in need of lawyers to keep a good solid roof over their heads.” His wife, Marianne was a member of the Onondaga Nation, an Indian territory south of Syracuse. Their son had recently chosen to live among his Indian family.
After nineteen years, a guilt ridden lumberjack employed by the Roth family business, came forward informing prosecutor Jim Maddox about a plan three lumberjacks hatched to kill Henry Roth, the son/heir of the business. A different party remembered a drunk Henry bragging in a bar while giving a detailed description of his rape of nine year old, Ella. In alternating chapters the victims, the accused, prosecution and defense teams are introduced as three lumberjacks face charges of murder.
Ella Ward’s father, deemed a hero by fellow lumberjacks, died while trying to save a fellow logger. Ella, three years old at the time, was taught to fish, hunt and swim by her three fathers; Cyril Cole, Paul McDonald and John LeRoche. When each logging season ended with the spring melt, Ella and her mother Katherine, a camp cook, would spend the off season cooking at Roth’s Great Camp on Big Tupper Lake. One day while Ella was exploring, seventeen year old Henry Roth raped her.
After a quick investigation, Sheriff John O’Malley announced a payment plan. Ella’s mother would leave town permanently and relinquish Ella’s care to “Aunt Audrey and Uncle Ronald” Kurtz who lived in Saranac Lake. O’Malley supplemented his salary through bribery. Wealthy city families were willing to pay him to have pending charges dropped. The lumberjacks disliked O’Malley.
The re-opened case of Henry Roth’s death awakened painful memories for Ella. Although George Alberts was an experienced lawyer, he had never tried a murder case. He would be called upon to defend the three lumberjacks who killed or might have killed on behalf of Ella Devine, a victim of rape. He would need Ella’s input to help frame the case. The lumberjacks were not helpful in their own defense.
Jim Maddox, the prosecutor, wanted to run for State Senate. “It wouldn’t be easy to convince a jury and the voting public that three seemingly harmless old lumberjacks were cold-hearted killers…”. Jim would claim that Cyril Cole killed for money and status-upon Henry’s demise, he ran the Roth Lumber Camp. Cyril had strict rules thus providing safe working conditions. There were no injuries during his watch. Cyril was respected and highly regarded unlike Henry who always came to work drunk and showed no interest in his employees. Each of the defendants recounted the same story of Henry’s death. With no forensic evidence, would the jury condemn or condone the actions of the accused?
A fascinating read that combines trauma, mystery and court procedural. Kudos to author Lori Duffy Foster.
Thank you Lori Duffy Foster for the print ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
📚Spring Melt
✍🏻Lori Duffy Foster
Blurb:
As a doctor’s wife in a thriving Adirondack village in the 1920s, Ella Devine seems to have an ideal life. Her husband grew rich catering to New York City socialites who wanted to hide their TB diagnoses from their friends. Their marriage is devoid of emotion, but so is she, having learned long ago to quietly accept whatever life offers. But all that changes when three men are charged with a nineteen-year-old murder, and the long-buried crime that shaped Ella’s childhood is exposed.
Spring Melt draws on the rich and fascinating history of the Adirondacks, where hikers who see only low hills and lush vegetation fail to perceive the hidden dangers and lose their lives by stepping two feet off the trail. Since the late 1800s, the wilderness that is the Adirondacks has been both a frontier to be conquered only by the hardiest of humans and a playland for the wealthy. When these two worlds collide, the resulting explosion can be fatal.
My Thoughts:
This historical court case story was so well written! Ella is married and even though the trauma of a terrible event during her childhood still haunts her, she has lived a pretty decent life.I enjoyed Spring Melt. It’s one of those books that sticks with you because of all emotions it pulls out of you. Ella’s childhood story made me feel angry and heartbroken —-especially the way she was treated after what she went through.
When Ella was a little girl she suffered a horrible assault. At the time nothing was done about it and she was sent away. She went through life never really talking about what happened and figured no one needed to know. Although years later in the 1920's after her abuser is found dead the secrets of her childhood trauma come to light.Spring Melt is a riveting story of justice, forgiveness, and redemption, in which revelations about past crimes and long-buried secrets unfold with nail-biting intensity.
Thanks NetGalley, Speaking Volumes Publisher and Author Lori Duffy Foster for the complimentary copy of "Spring Melt" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#NetGalley
#SpeakingVolumesPublisher
#LoriDuffyFoster
#SpringMelt
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
⚠️Trigger Warning: Rape
✍🏻Lori Duffy Foster
Blurb:
As a doctor’s wife in a thriving Adirondack village in the 1920s, Ella Devine seems to have an ideal life. Her husband grew rich catering to New York City socialites who wanted to hide their TB diagnoses from their friends. Their marriage is devoid of emotion, but so is she, having learned long ago to quietly accept whatever life offers. But all that changes when three men are charged with a nineteen-year-old murder, and the long-buried crime that shaped Ella’s childhood is exposed.
Spring Melt draws on the rich and fascinating history of the Adirondacks, where hikers who see only low hills and lush vegetation fail to perceive the hidden dangers and lose their lives by stepping two feet off the trail. Since the late 1800s, the wilderness that is the Adirondacks has been both a frontier to be conquered only by the hardiest of humans and a playland for the wealthy. When these two worlds collide, the resulting explosion can be fatal.
My Thoughts:
This historical court case story was so well written! Ella is married and even though the trauma of a terrible event during her childhood still haunts her, she has lived a pretty decent life.I enjoyed Spring Melt. It’s one of those books that sticks with you because of all emotions it pulls out of you. Ella’s childhood story made me feel angry and heartbroken —-especially the way she was treated after what she went through.
When Ella was a little girl she suffered a horrible assault. At the time nothing was done about it and she was sent away. She went through life never really talking about what happened and figured no one needed to know. Although years later in the 1920's after her abuser is found dead the secrets of her childhood trauma come to light.Spring Melt is a riveting story of justice, forgiveness, and redemption, in which revelations about past crimes and long-buried secrets unfold with nail-biting intensity.
Thanks NetGalley, Speaking Volumes Publisher and Author Lori Duffy Foster for the complimentary copy of "Spring Melt" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#NetGalley
#SpeakingVolumesPublisher
#LoriDuffyFoster
#SpringMelt
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
⚠️Trigger Warning: Rape
March 18, 2026
This is my second book by Lori Duffy Foster and I can now say rather unequivocally that I am a huge fan of her work. Ms. Duffy Foster has a beautiful writing style and clear strong prose that skillfully develops characters, their environment/community, and bring the events of the story to life. My TBR list grows longer by the week, yet I will find time to read her previous murder mystery series later this year and hope I can get my hands on an advanced reader copy of her upcoming title arriving in 2027.
I am not an avid mystery or thriller reader, which is the primary genre Ms. Duffy Foster writes. I often find mysteries do not fully deliver on their promise, are overly formulaic, require significant suspension of belief or worse yet betray their own characters to make the plot work. Generally, I will gladly read any genre that is well written and can transport me into the author’s creation. Ms. Duffy Foster gift is to fully immerse the reader, bringing them to the heart of the action and into the inner-worlds of her characters. Her mysteries are well developed, thoughtful and deliver on the promise of the book summary without sacrificing characters.
This book is a much softer, gentler story, than Never Let Go. Despite the horrific and violent actions that set the story in motion (child rape), the story finds the light and goodness that makes it overall a satisfying and uplifting read. It is much more of a historical fiction, courtroom drama, and/or redemption story, than it is pure mystery, although it does not lack for twists and turns. I also greatly appreciate the use of the Adirondacks and the lush wilderness as an additional character in the novel. The forest shapes and defines the lives of those in the small town; it is a love-letter to the nature and beauty of the region.
I am grateful to BookSirens and to the author for providing me with this free advance review copy of this book; I have read and honestly reviewed this book voluntarily.
I am not an avid mystery or thriller reader, which is the primary genre Ms. Duffy Foster writes. I often find mysteries do not fully deliver on their promise, are overly formulaic, require significant suspension of belief or worse yet betray their own characters to make the plot work. Generally, I will gladly read any genre that is well written and can transport me into the author’s creation. Ms. Duffy Foster gift is to fully immerse the reader, bringing them to the heart of the action and into the inner-worlds of her characters. Her mysteries are well developed, thoughtful and deliver on the promise of the book summary without sacrificing characters.
This book is a much softer, gentler story, than Never Let Go. Despite the horrific and violent actions that set the story in motion (child rape), the story finds the light and goodness that makes it overall a satisfying and uplifting read. It is much more of a historical fiction, courtroom drama, and/or redemption story, than it is pure mystery, although it does not lack for twists and turns. I also greatly appreciate the use of the Adirondacks and the lush wilderness as an additional character in the novel. The forest shapes and defines the lives of those in the small town; it is a love-letter to the nature and beauty of the region.
I am grateful to BookSirens and to the author for providing me with this free advance review copy of this book; I have read and honestly reviewed this book voluntarily.
Review of advance copy
Spring Melt is set in the Adirondacks in the early 1920s and features Ella Devine, a quiet woman faced with a resurfacing reality she thought was buried nineteen years ago: the murder of Henry Roth, the only son of wealthy owners of the Roth Lumber Camp. Three loggers are charged with killing Roth after a confession reopens the previously closed case. Ella finds herself at a crossroads: either face head-on the traumatic event of her childhood or crawl back into the painful safety of her present life.
The narrative dives into the trial of the three lumberjacks, examining their motives, actions, and intent at the time of the murder, as well as their present reality and thoughts about what happened years ago. Spring Melt exposes the state of the jury system: its strengths, its ties to the wealthy of the Adirondack Mountains, and the corruption that flows from those connections.
Foster's background as a crime reporter shapes how Spring Melt is written. She shows both the past and present world of a rape survivor, exploring society's view of rape, the perpetrator, and the victim. Foster uses the Adirondack setting to depict the stark contrast between the elite who summer in the mountains and the working class that serves them.
Spring Melt is a tough read about a painful event that happened to a nine-year-old and followed her into adulthood. Though it's difficult material, readers can still enjoy the drama of the courtroom, the thrill of an unsolved murder case, and even find a rekindled trust in the jury system. Lori Duffy Foster crafted a beautiful but intense journey with Spring Melt. I received an advance review copy of this book via BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The narrative dives into the trial of the three lumberjacks, examining their motives, actions, and intent at the time of the murder, as well as their present reality and thoughts about what happened years ago. Spring Melt exposes the state of the jury system: its strengths, its ties to the wealthy of the Adirondack Mountains, and the corruption that flows from those connections.
Foster's background as a crime reporter shapes how Spring Melt is written. She shows both the past and present world of a rape survivor, exploring society's view of rape, the perpetrator, and the victim. Foster uses the Adirondack setting to depict the stark contrast between the elite who summer in the mountains and the working class that serves them.
Spring Melt is a tough read about a painful event that happened to a nine-year-old and followed her into adulthood. Though it's difficult material, readers can still enjoy the drama of the courtroom, the thrill of an unsolved murder case, and even find a rekindled trust in the jury system. Lori Duffy Foster crafted a beautiful but intense journey with Spring Melt. I received an advance review copy of this book via BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
SPRING MELT is a standalone historical crime story that tells you about Ella and the horrific act forced upon her at 9-years-old. Nineteen years later, three men are being held accountable for the murder of her r@pist. Was it really planned, or did fate play a part?
This was an amazing story that drew me in and kept my attention from the very first chapter. Normally, I wouldn't say anything about being happy with a divorce/separation in the first few pages, but this one I celebrated! Not only that, but I was with Ella every step of the way as she found herself and the peace needed to move on with her life.
The glimpse into the 1920s social system, the job of a lumberjack, plus how if you had money, you could even buy a Not Guilty verdict (if it even got that far!) was so incredibly written, I was completely engrossed.
Ella is surrounded by an amazing supporting cast of characters, including but not limited to the wonderful Will. Hooper, although not around too much, was also a firm favourite. I thoroughly enjoyed the scenes with Maddox, as he made me question what was right and wrong, both morally and legally. The epilogue at the end made my eyes leak in the best way.
Told from multiple perspectives, this was outstanding in every way. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this book, and although I have no personal knowledge of the Adirondacks, I can honestly say I feel as though I've now been there.
** Same worded review will appear elsewhere. **
* A copy of this book was provided to me with no requirements for a review. I voluntarily read this book; the comments here are my honest opinion. *
Merissa
Archaeolibrarian - I Dig Good Books!
Feb 11, 2026
This was an amazing story that drew me in and kept my attention from the very first chapter. Normally, I wouldn't say anything about being happy with a divorce/separation in the first few pages, but this one I celebrated! Not only that, but I was with Ella every step of the way as she found herself and the peace needed to move on with her life.
The glimpse into the 1920s social system, the job of a lumberjack, plus how if you had money, you could even buy a Not Guilty verdict (if it even got that far!) was so incredibly written, I was completely engrossed.
Ella is surrounded by an amazing supporting cast of characters, including but not limited to the wonderful Will. Hooper, although not around too much, was also a firm favourite. I thoroughly enjoyed the scenes with Maddox, as he made me question what was right and wrong, both morally and legally. The epilogue at the end made my eyes leak in the best way.
Told from multiple perspectives, this was outstanding in every way. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this book, and although I have no personal knowledge of the Adirondacks, I can honestly say I feel as though I've now been there.
** Same worded review will appear elsewhere. **
* A copy of this book was provided to me with no requirements for a review. I voluntarily read this book; the comments here are my honest opinion. *
Merissa
Archaeolibrarian - I Dig Good Books!
Feb 11, 2026
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Spring Melt
Laura Duffy Foster
March 10, 2026
As a young girl living in the Adirondacks, Ella lost her father at a young age. Her mother was overcome by the need to raise Ella and keep a job; although cooking at the logging camp and living in the small cabin was never easy. In the summer they switched to another camp both run by the wealthy Roth family. The loggers would leave their families to live in the camps and work. In summers rich society members came to cure their TB and enjoy the beautiful areas.
At the age of nine, all of Ella’s life in the forests came to an end when she was raped by Henry Roth. No one was charged, she was sent to live with a couple in a town nearby who had no children. Ella’s mother had to agree with the Roth’s settlement. The sheriff maintained that it was an Indian who attacked the girl, the Roth family would not allow their son to be charged.
Spring Melt will be published by Speaking Volumes LLC on March 10, 2026. I was able to read Foster’s latest novel via NetGalley. This historical fiction piece was a thorough and technical study of Ella’s story. When she became an adult it was decided to charge the three men who were on a mission to rid the camp of Henry, who frequently arrived drunk and irritable. As the only son he would own the business when his parents passed on or decided to retire. The second half of this novel gives the readers a journal of the events leading up to the trial and the hearing. Readers will be given intricate knowledge of incidents that followed throughout the 20 years that passed before the case began. It’s interesting and in-depth. An excellent literal documentary story.
Laura Duffy Foster
March 10, 2026
As a young girl living in the Adirondacks, Ella lost her father at a young age. Her mother was overcome by the need to raise Ella and keep a job; although cooking at the logging camp and living in the small cabin was never easy. In the summer they switched to another camp both run by the wealthy Roth family. The loggers would leave their families to live in the camps and work. In summers rich society members came to cure their TB and enjoy the beautiful areas.
At the age of nine, all of Ella’s life in the forests came to an end when she was raped by Henry Roth. No one was charged, she was sent to live with a couple in a town nearby who had no children. Ella’s mother had to agree with the Roth’s settlement. The sheriff maintained that it was an Indian who attacked the girl, the Roth family would not allow their son to be charged.
Spring Melt will be published by Speaking Volumes LLC on March 10, 2026. I was able to read Foster’s latest novel via NetGalley. This historical fiction piece was a thorough and technical study of Ella’s story. When she became an adult it was decided to charge the three men who were on a mission to rid the camp of Henry, who frequently arrived drunk and irritable. As the only son he would own the business when his parents passed on or decided to retire. The second half of this novel gives the readers a journal of the events leading up to the trial and the hearing. Readers will be given intricate knowledge of incidents that followed throughout the 20 years that passed before the case began. It’s interesting and in-depth. An excellent literal documentary story.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This historical court case story was so well written! Ella is married and even though the trauma of a terrible event during her childhood still haunts her, she has lived a pretty decent life. Her husband is a well known TB doctor, she does various community events with the ladies and even though the marriage feels pretty loveless, she has a large house and has want for nothing. The guilt of what really happened twenty years ago eats away at a man who has known about it since it happened. Although ruled as an accident many rumors have traversed lips that it wasn't an accident after all. Three well known men in the community in a shock are put on trial for murder. The murder of a man that almost everyone knew was no good, so why dredge up the past, wasn't it ruled an accident? As the attorney's on both sides start digging into things, they realize this might just be bigger than they each thought and this is more than just a terrible accident. Corruption from the highest level, erroneous arrests and the truth of what really happened and what led up to it all comes to light in this novel, and it all leads back to Ella's childhood and what happened in those woods. This was so good and I couldn't put it down, it was so realistic it could easily have been based on a true story. I loved that it was told through the various different characters and we get to see their feelings on the various things that happened. Thank you to the publisher and author for the complementary ebook. This review is of my own opinion and accord.
Review of advance copy
The book Spring Melt, by Lori Duffy Foster, is classified as historical fiction. Not only is the story is historical fiction but a courtroom and a layered narrative. The title is symbolic because as things which are buried in ice and snow in the winter they come to be revealed at the spring melt. This is true in this story as well. The center point of the story is when a secret of nineteen years is uncovered like the spring melt. As the rays of the sun melt the layers of snow, this light shines in the darkness unearthing a tragic secret impacting the lives of the characters.
The author has done a masterful writing job of taking a formula story into a very brilliant piece of writing. By utilizing the layered narrative, she has invited her readers to interact with the story. Not only are the readers pro-active but are intellectually stimulated. She treats her readers as well versed literary aficionados. The technique allows the reader to empathize with the main character, Ella Divine.
A reader who desires to be challenged in one's reading must read this book. The story is filled nuggets of gold. As with any story, the concept of good and evil is examined. Also, the idea of justice and injustice is introduced in the courtroom scenes. Do not miss reading this very complex but entertaining story.
The author has done a masterful writing job of taking a formula story into a very brilliant piece of writing. By utilizing the layered narrative, she has invited her readers to interact with the story. Not only are the readers pro-active but are intellectually stimulated. She treats her readers as well versed literary aficionados. The technique allows the reader to empathize with the main character, Ella Divine.
A reader who desires to be challenged in one's reading must read this book. The story is filled nuggets of gold. As with any story, the concept of good and evil is examined. Also, the idea of justice and injustice is introduced in the courtroom scenes. Do not miss reading this very complex but entertaining story.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This well written historical mystery set in the Adirondacks in the 1920s tells a story of dishonor and dishonesty brought to light through a trial for a murder 20 years in the past. Atmospheric in a subtle way, the book elicits a range of emotions but in the end becomes a life-affirming story.
The book starts with a lawyer, George, trying to get Ella Devine, a young married woman who was raped by one of the town’s wealthy scions as a young girl , to speak about that crime. As we soon learn she has been traumatized, sent away by her mother, made to feel victimized, having sublimated it tightly away. As a trial for the murder of the rapist by several local men who worked with her father in the logging industry is set to begin, buried secrets come to light.
The trial is the most compelling part of the book. The contest between George, defending the alleged murderers, and Jim, the prosecuting attorney, has a lot of interesting twists. The characters of Ella and George were my favorites. And the budding romance between Ella and Will was sweet (Ella desperately needed someone to love her and it felt refreshing to have this happen).
This is a must read for lovers of historical mysteries. And, as I am one, I really enjoyed this book.
I’d like to thank NetGalley and Speaking Volumes to allowing me to read this fine ARC.
The book starts with a lawyer, George, trying to get Ella Devine, a young married woman who was raped by one of the town’s wealthy scions as a young girl , to speak about that crime. As we soon learn she has been traumatized, sent away by her mother, made to feel victimized, having sublimated it tightly away. As a trial for the murder of the rapist by several local men who worked with her father in the logging industry is set to begin, buried secrets come to light.
The trial is the most compelling part of the book. The contest between George, defending the alleged murderers, and Jim, the prosecuting attorney, has a lot of interesting twists. The characters of Ella and George were my favorites. And the budding romance between Ella and Will was sweet (Ella desperately needed someone to love her and it felt refreshing to have this happen).
This is a must read for lovers of historical mysteries. And, as I am one, I really enjoyed this book.
I’d like to thank NetGalley and Speaking Volumes to allowing me to read this fine ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This novel started out a little slow but by the end, I was fully engaged. I was surprised that the novel ultimately elicited emotion in me. The first half of the book sets the stage and records the preparation the attorneys make. About half way through the courtroom scenes begin and the novel takes off.
The writing style is mostly prose with not much action or dialogue. Foster explains the action rather than having it happen. Her prose is well crafted, however. It almost seems personal, making one fall in love with the Adirondacks and easily relate to the characters. I really like how she revealed inner character by how people responded to the forest areas. Lumberjacks were tough men making a living in the forest. Ella felt peace and freedom surrounded by trees while the lawyer Casey felt they drained him of his energy. There is also a well crafted romance with a second chance at love and new life.
This is a good historical novel of courtroom drama. Foster says this was her first novel, put away for years. I am glad it is now available with a final revision. Potential readers should know a possible trigger situation is a rape. While it did not happen within this plot, it is remembered and plays a vital role in the courtroom drama.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book through the author. My comments are an independent and honest review.
The writing style is mostly prose with not much action or dialogue. Foster explains the action rather than having it happen. Her prose is well crafted, however. It almost seems personal, making one fall in love with the Adirondacks and easily relate to the characters. I really like how she revealed inner character by how people responded to the forest areas. Lumberjacks were tough men making a living in the forest. Ella felt peace and freedom surrounded by trees while the lawyer Casey felt they drained him of his energy. There is also a well crafted romance with a second chance at love and new life.
This is a good historical novel of courtroom drama. Foster says this was her first novel, put away for years. I am glad it is now available with a final revision. Potential readers should know a possible trigger situation is a rape. While it did not happen within this plot, it is remembered and plays a vital role in the courtroom drama.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book through the author. My comments are an independent and honest review.
March 13, 2026
In the early 20th Century in rural America, Ella Devine must deal with the trauma of being raped as a child, having her marriage annulled, and facing a legal battle to bring those responsible for her rape and the murder of another man to justice.
This novel is a legal thriller where lawyer George Alberts deals with a local community that wants to forget the crimes of the past. Still, George continues to pursue justice, facing animosity from the community around him.
Meanwhile, Ella, raped more than ten years earlier, feels she’s responsible for the crime and the failure of her marriage. But Ella transforms from a woman under men’s control into one controlling her own future. It starts with her bringing food to a search party looking for a lost boy. Her second encounter is helping an injured child. Then she is encouraged to start writing articles for a local publication. Along the way, she learns she is not responsible for the crimes of the men who violated her and killed another.
This story is about a struggle for justice and a woman discovering she controls her own destiny in a society that is determined to deny them self-determination and success.
Review by Mark Zeid, author of Media Murder Mysteries.
This novel is a legal thriller where lawyer George Alberts deals with a local community that wants to forget the crimes of the past. Still, George continues to pursue justice, facing animosity from the community around him.
Meanwhile, Ella, raped more than ten years earlier, feels she’s responsible for the crime and the failure of her marriage. But Ella transforms from a woman under men’s control into one controlling her own future. It starts with her bringing food to a search party looking for a lost boy. Her second encounter is helping an injured child. Then she is encouraged to start writing articles for a local publication. Along the way, she learns she is not responsible for the crimes of the men who violated her and killed another.
This story is about a struggle for justice and a woman discovering she controls her own destiny in a society that is determined to deny them self-determination and success.
Review by Mark Zeid, author of Media Murder Mysteries.
November 7, 2025
Ella Devine has spent her life trying to forget the horrible crime that shaped her childhood. When three of her father’s friends are charged with murder, her entire world is turned upside down. Her marriage falls apart, and not only is Ella called to testify at the trial, but she must also confront the trauma of her past.
Told from multiple perspectives, the story reveals more about Ella and raises the question: will she ever be able to move beyond this painful chapter of her life?
I really enjoyed the premise of this story. I was immediately drawn in and connected with many of the characters. The multiple points of view helped provide a well-rounded perspective on the trial, and I also appreciated the vivid descriptions of the Adirondacks. However, I felt that Ella’s life wrapped up too neatly and too quickly. It feels unrealistic when people meet someone new and immediately fall in love. I would have preferred for Ella’s new relationship to develop from a friendship first.
The language was clean and there were only hints of spice.
Rating: 3.5 stars, rounded down to 3.
Thanks to NetGalley for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
Told from multiple perspectives, the story reveals more about Ella and raises the question: will she ever be able to move beyond this painful chapter of her life?
I really enjoyed the premise of this story. I was immediately drawn in and connected with many of the characters. The multiple points of view helped provide a well-rounded perspective on the trial, and I also appreciated the vivid descriptions of the Adirondacks. However, I felt that Ella’s life wrapped up too neatly and too quickly. It feels unrealistic when people meet someone new and immediately fall in love. I would have preferred for Ella’s new relationship to develop from a friendship first.
The language was clean and there were only hints of spice.
Rating: 3.5 stars, rounded down to 3.
Thanks to NetGalley for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
A quiet novel about how buried truths resurface slowly, altering lives not through drama, but through reckoning.
Spring Melt moves with a deliberate stillness, attentive to the small fractures that appear when long held silences begin to loosen. The writing resists drama. There are no grand declarations, only the steady accumulation of moments that suggest how people endure rather than transform.
What stands out is the emotional economy. The author does not instruct us how to feel. Feelings surface indirectly through gesture, through what is left unsaid, through the spaces between scenes. The restraint is purposeful. It mirrors the interior lives of the characters who carry more than they articulate.
The prose is clean, almost austere. It values clarity over ornament. At times this distance may feel withholding, especially for readers who seek catharsis. But the strength of the book lies precisely there. It understands that meaning is not always found in resolution but in observation.
Spring Melt is less concerned with answers than with attention. It watches carefully. And in doing so, it tells the truth it is willing to tell.
Spring Melt moves with a deliberate stillness, attentive to the small fractures that appear when long held silences begin to loosen. The writing resists drama. There are no grand declarations, only the steady accumulation of moments that suggest how people endure rather than transform.
What stands out is the emotional economy. The author does not instruct us how to feel. Feelings surface indirectly through gesture, through what is left unsaid, through the spaces between scenes. The restraint is purposeful. It mirrors the interior lives of the characters who carry more than they articulate.
The prose is clean, almost austere. It values clarity over ornament. At times this distance may feel withholding, especially for readers who seek catharsis. But the strength of the book lies precisely there. It understands that meaning is not always found in resolution but in observation.
Spring Melt is less concerned with answers than with attention. It watches carefully. And in doing so, it tells the truth it is willing to tell.
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
This novel has multiple viewpoints, but the standout is the woman around whom the drama takes place. Set in the Adirondacks of the early 20th century, three men murdered Henry Roth many years before the story starts. But another crime, the rape of 9-year-old Ella Devine by spoiled rich boy Henry Roth, had been committed before that.
The story feels like a legal historical suspense novel, as we know who committed the crimes and why. But the repercussions from the crimes affect the lives of all the characters who have a voice here. The lawyers, the lawyers’ assistants, the victim. When one of the men comes forward and confesses, Ella’s life is completely changed, though eventually for the better. This is a captivating, steady telling of a trial, from the confession to the bitter end. It’s so well done, the prose is hypnotic in that I was totally immersed in the lives of these characters. The Adirondacks are a beautiful setting for the story, and I felt nostalgic for a time long gone by.
I highly recommend this historical legal mystery/suspense novel.
The story feels like a legal historical suspense novel, as we know who committed the crimes and why. But the repercussions from the crimes affect the lives of all the characters who have a voice here. The lawyers, the lawyers’ assistants, the victim. When one of the men comes forward and confesses, Ella’s life is completely changed, though eventually for the better. This is a captivating, steady telling of a trial, from the confession to the bitter end. It’s so well done, the prose is hypnotic in that I was totally immersed in the lives of these characters. The Adirondacks are a beautiful setting for the story, and I felt nostalgic for a time long gone by.
I highly recommend this historical legal mystery/suspense novel.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews