What do you think?
Rate this book
First Line
Riley Carter has one prove she belongs in the boys’ game—on the ice and beyond. But the faster she skates toward her dream, the more the cracks beneath her perfect routine begin to bruises she can’t explain, exhaustion she refuses to admit, and feelings for her best friend and team captain, Ethan Cole, that she’s buried for years.
As graduation looms and scouts take notice, Riley must decide how much she’s willing to risk to chase the future she’s fought for—and who she can trust when the truth threatens to break through the ice.
First Line is the opening novel in a heart-stirring sports-romance trilogy, where every victory on the scoreboard hides a deeper battle off the ice. This book ends on a cliffhanger, with Riley and Ethan’s story continuing in Book 2, Second Overtime, available now.
As graduation looms and scouts take notice, Riley must decide how much she’s willing to risk to chase the future she’s fought for—and who she can trust when the truth threatens to break through the ice.
First Line is the opening novel in a heart-stirring sports-romance trilogy, where every victory on the scoreboard hides a deeper battle off the ice. This book ends on a cliffhanger, with Riley and Ethan’s story continuing in Book 2, Second Overtime, available now.
142 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 14, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews
December 31, 2025
This was a fast-paced, entertaining short novel that kept me turning pages from start to finish. The story moved quickly, the characters were engaging, and it never dragged on, making it an easy and enjoyable read. That said, while the cover and general presentation to me suggest this is a young adult novel, the content tells a different story. There are some 'adult' scenes and themes that would not be appropriate for a younger audience. I’d recommend this book for adult readers looking for a brisk, compelling read rather than for teens or younger readers. Overall well-written and enjoyable read.
November 7, 2025
This was a short and sweet story, a blend of romance and hockey. Riley and Ethan are the main characters, and their slow-burn love grows beautifully over the high school years. Riley is strong-willed and determined to prove herself, while Ethan has his own challenges to face.
As the story unfolds, it explores heartfelt emotions, Riley’s struggles(with her guardian and her own health), found-family support, and all the ups and downs of high school life. At first, you might think, “Yeah, another high school story,” but this is cute in its own way. Also, there is a cliffhanger at the end, which makes you want to read the second book. I loved it!
As the story unfolds, it explores heartfelt emotions, Riley’s struggles(with her guardian and her own health), found-family support, and all the ups and downs of high school life. At first, you might think, “Yeah, another high school story,” but this is cute in its own way. Also, there is a cliffhanger at the end, which makes you want to read the second book. I loved it!
January 6, 2026
Cute but odd ending
So I read this quickly and it pulled me in early. The way Gracie writes characters makes you instantly fall for them and care about them and their wellbeing.
The heat between these two was the perfect high school attraction with an appropriately low level of heat/spicy (different than Gracies other books with older/ more mature characters.) And this was different in ALL the right ways. I love the subtle mentions of my favorite characters from Breaking the Ice Ceiling, so be sure to read that book first to catch all the little comments.
I'm ready for their story to continue in book 2, I just wish the ending of this part was a little more clear. Like, the cliffhanger was a little odd to me. I see and understand the setup for part two, im just wondering why all the secrecy. But maybe book 2 will explain. Let's dive in!
So I read this quickly and it pulled me in early. The way Gracie writes characters makes you instantly fall for them and care about them and their wellbeing.
The heat between these two was the perfect high school attraction with an appropriately low level of heat/spicy (different than Gracies other books with older/ more mature characters.) And this was different in ALL the right ways. I love the subtle mentions of my favorite characters from Breaking the Ice Ceiling, so be sure to read that book first to catch all the little comments.
I'm ready for their story to continue in book 2, I just wish the ending of this part was a little more clear. Like, the cliffhanger was a little odd to me. I see and understand the setup for part two, im just wondering why all the secrecy. But maybe book 2 will explain. Let's dive in!
November 11, 2025
Raw, emotional, and impossible to put down
This book hits harder than a slap shot. Riley’s story is fierce, vulnerable, and heartbreakingly real. The balance of ambition, pressure, and forbidden love is masterful. You don’t just read First Line, you feel every bruise, every heartbeat, every choice.
This book hits harder than a slap shot. Riley’s story is fierce, vulnerable, and heartbreakingly real. The balance of ambition, pressure, and forbidden love is masterful. You don’t just read First Line, you feel every bruise, every heartbeat, every choice.
January 7, 2026
nice quick read
I picked this up wanted a short sweet hockey romance but I got so much more. Riley and Ethan felt real in that messy, emotional, growing-up way, and I flew through it because I actually cared what happened to them. The hockey backdrop was fun, but it was the quieter moments and tension that really pulled me in. I’ll be reading book two soon.
I picked this up wanted a short sweet hockey romance but I got so much more. Riley and Ethan felt real in that messy, emotional, growing-up way, and I flew through it because I actually cared what happened to them. The hockey backdrop was fun, but it was the quieter moments and tension that really pulled me in. I’ll be reading book two soon.
December 6, 2025
A Tale of Two Young Hockey Players in Love
First, let me say that I *LOVE* the sport of hockey. In fact, I’m writing this review while watching my favorite team play the Anaheim Ducks (the Washington Capitals are my boys—yes, Ovi is great but my all-time dude, hands down is the one and only Tom Wilson… but I digress). ANYWAY, it makes sense that I would appreciate a good hockey romance story and this book is no exception.
It stars a girl named Riley and a sweet boy named Ethan, both of whom are talented high school hockey players.
Yes, there are several elements that readers will need to suspend their disbelief about. They are mentioned by other reviewers so I’ll refrain from rehashing them again.
All in all, this was a nice, wholesome read.
Aaand the Caps lost in the shootout. Boooo.
First, let me say that I *LOVE* the sport of hockey. In fact, I’m writing this review while watching my favorite team play the Anaheim Ducks (the Washington Capitals are my boys—yes, Ovi is great but my all-time dude, hands down is the one and only Tom Wilson… but I digress). ANYWAY, it makes sense that I would appreciate a good hockey romance story and this book is no exception.
It stars a girl named Riley and a sweet boy named Ethan, both of whom are talented high school hockey players.
Yes, there are several elements that readers will need to suspend their disbelief about. They are mentioned by other reviewers so I’ll refrain from rehashing them again.
All in all, this was a nice, wholesome read.
Aaand the Caps lost in the shootout. Boooo.
January 19, 2026
This book was short and sweet. I can't wait to read the other two books in this trilogy. There were moments when I would burst out laughing and moments when I was on the brink of tears. I was rooting for Riley and Ethan to finally admit their feelings for each other. My only complaint is that it ended too quickly.
October 27, 2025
Absolutely loved this book! First Line pulled me in from page one and never let go. Riley is such a strong, relatable heroine—you feel every victory and heartbreak right along with her. The story perfectly blends sports, emotion, and slow-burn romance. I couldn’t put it down and can’t wait for the next in the series!
October 27, 2025
Wow, this book hit me right in the heart. Riley’s story is powerful, emotional, and so easy to connect with. I loved how it tackled real challenges while still giving all the romance and hockey action I wanted. The writing is beautiful, and the chemistry between Riley and Ethan jumps off the page. I’m already obsessed with this series!
November 7, 2025
Gracie Monroe’s “First Line (The Riley & Ethan Trilogy Book 1)” is a nice start to what promises to be a successful trilogy about young hockey players in love. Did I just say that? I guess you had to be there and read the book to make sense of such a remark.
But it’s true. Riley is the Wonder Woman of the ice on her high school’s co-ed hockey team, and Ethan is the team’s Superman. Together, they’re the perfect match as teammates - in more ways than one.
On the ice, Riley and Ethan are unbeatable as they defeat one opponent after another, all the while both eyeing a Pennsylvania high school championship and scholarships to play ice hockey at Penn State. Underneath their pads, their largely secret love for each other smolders – so much so that it’s surprising their body heat hasn’t long since melted the ice and forced the writing of a different novel.
But alas, the author decided to throw the girl’s guardian into the mix – an alcoholic and abusive uncle who was a pro hockey star, and is now his niece’s spoil sport, main bruise contributor, and future ticket to a psychoanalyst’s couch. And then, there’s Ethan’s nurse mother and hip grandmother who recognize the love between the two kids, their individual and collective athletic dreams, and Riley’s apparent abuse and pattern of poor health.
On the surface of the ice, Gracie Monroe has written an interesting story that will be enjoyed and unquestioned by most readers. Beneath the ice, however, lurk informed critics who will eventually take exception to various and sundry elements of her tome.
Such elements that bear scrutiny include her handling of the college athletic recruitment process, strict child abuse reporting requirements in the state of Pennsylvania, and various elements of character and plot development. While these elements do not necessarily interfere with the book’s ebb and flow, they will be potential distractions for readers who carefully analyze what they read.
All in all, “First Line” is a well-written, interesting, and engaging book. It forms a solid basis for the remaining books in the trilogy, and should be well received by readers anxious to seeing Riley and Ethan scoring as much off the ice and they do on it.
But it’s true. Riley is the Wonder Woman of the ice on her high school’s co-ed hockey team, and Ethan is the team’s Superman. Together, they’re the perfect match as teammates - in more ways than one.
On the ice, Riley and Ethan are unbeatable as they defeat one opponent after another, all the while both eyeing a Pennsylvania high school championship and scholarships to play ice hockey at Penn State. Underneath their pads, their largely secret love for each other smolders – so much so that it’s surprising their body heat hasn’t long since melted the ice and forced the writing of a different novel.
But alas, the author decided to throw the girl’s guardian into the mix – an alcoholic and abusive uncle who was a pro hockey star, and is now his niece’s spoil sport, main bruise contributor, and future ticket to a psychoanalyst’s couch. And then, there’s Ethan’s nurse mother and hip grandmother who recognize the love between the two kids, their individual and collective athletic dreams, and Riley’s apparent abuse and pattern of poor health.
On the surface of the ice, Gracie Monroe has written an interesting story that will be enjoyed and unquestioned by most readers. Beneath the ice, however, lurk informed critics who will eventually take exception to various and sundry elements of her tome.
Such elements that bear scrutiny include her handling of the college athletic recruitment process, strict child abuse reporting requirements in the state of Pennsylvania, and various elements of character and plot development. While these elements do not necessarily interfere with the book’s ebb and flow, they will be potential distractions for readers who carefully analyze what they read.
All in all, “First Line” is a well-written, interesting, and engaging book. It forms a solid basis for the remaining books in the trilogy, and should be well received by readers anxious to seeing Riley and Ethan scoring as much off the ice and they do on it.
October 19, 2025
First Line is a powerhouse of a novel that seamlessly blends the world of hockey with a truly unforgettable romance. While the story delves deep into the often chaotic realities of life, love, and chasing dreams when ones foundation is fractured, the absolute heart of this book is the relationship between Riley and Ethan.
Riley's journey toward healing is difficult, as Gracie Monroe unflinchingly portrays difficult subjects like emotional neglect and the effects of alcoholism. However, it is Ethan that provides the necessary light in her darkness. Ethan is far more than a run-of-the-mill MMC; he’s an anchor, offering Riley a safe space to breathe and to finally believe she is worthy of kindness and devotion.
Their dynamic is masterful. The initial hesitation and slow build of their connection moving from tentative friendship to an undeniable, electric chemistry, is beautifully executed. Readers who love a hero who is patient, understanding, and fiercely loyal will swoon over Ethan. He respects Riley's boundaries while at the same time showing her what genuine support looks like. The payoff as their connection deepens and they finally give in to their feelings is incredibly satisfying and swoon-worthy, making this a true standout in the sports romance genre.
The dedication to the hockey element with vivid, accurate depictions is spot-on, creating a fantastic backdrop of fierce ambition and dedication with every beat expertly tied back to Riley's emotional journey and her burgeoning relationship with Ethan.
Keep the tissues handy but also be prepared for a beautiful payoff with Riley and Ethan. Highly recommend!
Riley's journey toward healing is difficult, as Gracie Monroe unflinchingly portrays difficult subjects like emotional neglect and the effects of alcoholism. However, it is Ethan that provides the necessary light in her darkness. Ethan is far more than a run-of-the-mill MMC; he’s an anchor, offering Riley a safe space to breathe and to finally believe she is worthy of kindness and devotion.
Their dynamic is masterful. The initial hesitation and slow build of their connection moving from tentative friendship to an undeniable, electric chemistry, is beautifully executed. Readers who love a hero who is patient, understanding, and fiercely loyal will swoon over Ethan. He respects Riley's boundaries while at the same time showing her what genuine support looks like. The payoff as their connection deepens and they finally give in to their feelings is incredibly satisfying and swoon-worthy, making this a true standout in the sports romance genre.
The dedication to the hockey element with vivid, accurate depictions is spot-on, creating a fantastic backdrop of fierce ambition and dedication with every beat expertly tied back to Riley's emotional journey and her burgeoning relationship with Ethan.
Keep the tissues handy but also be prepared for a beautiful payoff with Riley and Ethan. Highly recommend!
November 30, 2025
First Line is a young/new adult hockey romance laced with elements of physical and emotional abuse, alcoholism, neglect, serious health implications, etc.
Riley is a talented high school hockey player. She's determined to attend Penn State and eventually end up playing for the NHL. Ethan is the team captain, Riley's friend and next door neighbor.
The story moves quickly, with a fair amount of teasing from Riley's fellow (male) teammates, who regard her as their star player. Particularly endearing is the way Ethan's family treats Riley, warmly welcoming and supportive. His grandmother is a hoot, outspoken and sometimes raucous. She helps balance the grim reality of secret abuse in Riley's life.
Riley is strong, struggling to maintain the appearance of a normal life, and will do what it takes to ensure a real future for herself.
The writing is a first person and very pleasant. The story ends on a cliffhanger.
There are a few elements readers will need to suspend their disbelief about. The biggest for me is Riley's abuse. She blames her bruises on hockey, but most high schools don't have year round hockey. Street hockey is a possible explanation, but it sounds as if Riley hasn't seen a doctor since moving in with her uncle and high schools require annual physicals for students in sports programs. She would have encountered many mandated reporters. Plus, Ethan's mother, who lives next door, is a nurse.
Readers, particularly hockey fans, should enjoy this story.
Riley is a talented high school hockey player. She's determined to attend Penn State and eventually end up playing for the NHL. Ethan is the team captain, Riley's friend and next door neighbor.
The story moves quickly, with a fair amount of teasing from Riley's fellow (male) teammates, who regard her as their star player. Particularly endearing is the way Ethan's family treats Riley, warmly welcoming and supportive. His grandmother is a hoot, outspoken and sometimes raucous. She helps balance the grim reality of secret abuse in Riley's life.
Riley is strong, struggling to maintain the appearance of a normal life, and will do what it takes to ensure a real future for herself.
The writing is a first person and very pleasant. The story ends on a cliffhanger.
There are a few elements readers will need to suspend their disbelief about. The biggest for me is Riley's abuse. She blames her bruises on hockey, but most high schools don't have year round hockey. Street hockey is a possible explanation, but it sounds as if Riley hasn't seen a doctor since moving in with her uncle and high schools require annual physicals for students in sports programs. She would have encountered many mandated reporters. Plus, Ethan's mother, who lives next door, is a nurse.
Readers, particularly hockey fans, should enjoy this story.
Read
March 15, 2026Write a review
Gracie Monroe
4.62
50 ratings45 reviews
Want to read
Buy on Amazon
Rate this book
Edit my activity
Riley Carter has one prove she belongs in the boys’ game—on the ice and beyond. But the faster she skates toward her dream, the more the cracks beneath her perfect routine begin to bruises she can’t explain, exhaustion she refuses to admit, and feelings for her best friend and team captain, Ethan Cole, that she’s buried for years.
As graduation looms and scouts take notice, Riley must decide how much she’s willing to risk to chase the future she’s fought for—and who she can trust when the truth threatens to break through the ice.
First Line is the opening novel in a heart-stirring sports-romance trilogy, where every victory on the scoreboard hides a deeper battle off the ice. This book ends on a cliffhanger, with Riley and Ethan’s story continuing in Book 2, Second Overtime, available now.
Here’s a polished review you could use for First Line by Gracie Monroe:
Gracie Monroe’s First Line is a compelling blend of sports and romance, pulling readers into the high-stakes world of ice hockey while exploring the emotional challenges of growing up and chasing dreams. Riley Carter is a protagonist you can root for her determination on the ice mirrors the emotional resilience she must summon off it. Monroe does an excellent job balancing the thrill of competition with the vulnerability of Riley’s personal struggles, from mysterious bruises and exhaustion to long-buried feelings for her best friend and team captain, Ethan Cole.
October 20, 2025
First Line completely stole my heart. From the very first page, I was hooked by Riley Carter’s fierce determination and quiet vulnerability. This isn’t just a story about hockey it’s about resilience, identity, and the silent battles so many young athletes face behind the scenes.
Riley is a phenomenal protagonist. She’s strong, talented, and driven, but beneath that toughness are cracks that make her heartbreakingly human. The author captures her struggles both physical and emotional with such honesty that I often found myself holding my breath. The scenes on the ice are vivid and electric, perfectly balanced by the tender, complicated moments she shares with Ethan, her best friend and team captain. Their chemistry feels so natural and unforced that every look, every unspoken word, carries weight.
What really sets First Line apart is its emotional depth. It goes beyond the usual sports-romance tropes to explore pressure, trauma, and the cost of chasing perfection. Yet even in its darkest moments, the story pulses with hope. By the end, I was cheering for Riley not just to win, but to heal.
The writing is crisp, cinematic, and full of heart. Every chapter skates smoothly between action and emotion, leaving you fully invested in Riley’s journey. It’s the kind of book that makes you feel proud, heartbroken, and inspired all at once.
An unforgettable start to what promises to be an incredible trilogy. First Line scores a perfect five stars from me.
Riley is a phenomenal protagonist. She’s strong, talented, and driven, but beneath that toughness are cracks that make her heartbreakingly human. The author captures her struggles both physical and emotional with such honesty that I often found myself holding my breath. The scenes on the ice are vivid and electric, perfectly balanced by the tender, complicated moments she shares with Ethan, her best friend and team captain. Their chemistry feels so natural and unforced that every look, every unspoken word, carries weight.
What really sets First Line apart is its emotional depth. It goes beyond the usual sports-romance tropes to explore pressure, trauma, and the cost of chasing perfection. Yet even in its darkest moments, the story pulses with hope. By the end, I was cheering for Riley not just to win, but to heal.
The writing is crisp, cinematic, and full of heart. Every chapter skates smoothly between action and emotion, leaving you fully invested in Riley’s journey. It’s the kind of book that makes you feel proud, heartbroken, and inspired all at once.
An unforgettable start to what promises to be an incredible trilogy. First Line scores a perfect five stars from me.
January 29, 2026
First line by Gracie Monroe is the first of a planned trilogy that follows Riley Carter and Ethan Cole. In book 1, they meet and are on the same hockey team for Huntingdon High. Ethan is the captain and Riley has big dreams of being scouted to Penn State. I loved how they met at the beginning. Riley has lost her parents and is moving in with her uncle, when the boy across the street sees her firing a tennis ball at the garage and invites her to play a pick up game with him.
This book is competently written and is a quick read. I finished it in one sitting. I liked Riley and Ethan and his brash grandma as well as several of the other players. I found the uncle to be a bit one note and unrealistic. I would have liked a bit of a redemption arc there.
I also felt the ending was a little too abrupt for me, which is why I gave it 4 stars (I think it deserves 4.5 though). I liked what it was setting up, but I felt we needed a few more pages or another chapter to bring this to a close.
For fans of Heated Rivalry, I think you will find this teenage heterosexual romantic story to be a good fit. The descriptions of the hockey games feels earned and well written (though how many hat tricks can Riley really score in a season?!). Aside from the few nitpicks I've already listed here, I was invested in the story and enjoyed the build up to Riley and Ethan finally revealing their feelings for one another.
I look forward to reading #2 in the series!
This book is competently written and is a quick read. I finished it in one sitting. I liked Riley and Ethan and his brash grandma as well as several of the other players. I found the uncle to be a bit one note and unrealistic. I would have liked a bit of a redemption arc there.
I also felt the ending was a little too abrupt for me, which is why I gave it 4 stars (I think it deserves 4.5 though). I liked what it was setting up, but I felt we needed a few more pages or another chapter to bring this to a close.
For fans of Heated Rivalry, I think you will find this teenage heterosexual romantic story to be a good fit. The descriptions of the hockey games feels earned and well written (though how many hat tricks can Riley really score in a season?!). Aside from the few nitpicks I've already listed here, I was invested in the story and enjoyed the build up to Riley and Ethan finally revealing their feelings for one another.
I look forward to reading #2 in the series!
January 21, 2026
This is a sweet YA novel about ice hockey players who are both in love with each other, but who haven’t admitted they are in love with each other. The book is well written, well edited and nicely formatted. I enjoyed the story!!!
I felt for both of the main characters, but Riley especially. Ethan is a golden boy who seems to be happily skating his way to stardom while Riley, on the other hand, is working her tail off to keep up on the boy’s ice hockey team at her high school while attempting earn a scholarship in hockey from Penn State. Her tension over her hockey goals burns throughout the story, the fire fueled as well by an abusive uncle and her own failing body. Her only relief is her secret love for Ethan… and so the romance evolves from there.
The story kept me very involved, and I flew through it in one sitting. I didn’t take off a star because I did enjoy it, but I was tempted to. One reason: I felt the love scene was a little too heated for inexperienced lovers. Where are the normal feelings of people who haven’t done something before? The second: to me, novels in a series should each tell a complete section of the overall story—that being with a clear beginning, middle and end. I felt this one fell a little short on the complete end part.
I felt for both of the main characters, but Riley especially. Ethan is a golden boy who seems to be happily skating his way to stardom while Riley, on the other hand, is working her tail off to keep up on the boy’s ice hockey team at her high school while attempting earn a scholarship in hockey from Penn State. Her tension over her hockey goals burns throughout the story, the fire fueled as well by an abusive uncle and her own failing body. Her only relief is her secret love for Ethan… and so the romance evolves from there.
The story kept me very involved, and I flew through it in one sitting. I didn’t take off a star because I did enjoy it, but I was tempted to. One reason: I felt the love scene was a little too heated for inexperienced lovers. Where are the normal feelings of people who haven’t done something before? The second: to me, novels in a series should each tell a complete section of the overall story—that being with a clear beginning, middle and end. I felt this one fell a little short on the complete end part.
January 30, 2026
Wow. Just… wow. First Line by Gracie Monroe is an absolute masterpiece! From the very first page, I was completely swept into Riley Carter’s world, her fierce determination on the ice, the hidden struggles she refuses to admit, and the heart-tugging, slow-burn feelings for her best friend and team captain, Ethan. Gracie, you’ve created a character who feels so real, so inspiring, and so impossible not to root for!
This book isn’t just a sports romance, it’s about chasing your dreams, facing your fears, and learning who you can truly trust. Every goal, every bruise, every quiet moment of vulnerability hits right in the heart. The chemistry between Riley and Ethan is electric, and the emotional depth Gracie brings to the story will leave readers smiling, swooning, and sometimes tearing up.
If you love stories that mix heart-pounding sports action with romance, friendship, and life’s messy challenges, First Line is a must-read. I can’t recommend it enough, Gracie, you’ve made readers everywhere fall in love with Riley’s journey. I am beyond excited for the rest of the trilogy!
This book isn’t just a sports romance, it’s about chasing your dreams, facing your fears, and learning who you can truly trust. Every goal, every bruise, every quiet moment of vulnerability hits right in the heart. The chemistry between Riley and Ethan is electric, and the emotional depth Gracie brings to the story will leave readers smiling, swooning, and sometimes tearing up.
If you love stories that mix heart-pounding sports action with romance, friendship, and life’s messy challenges, First Line is a must-read. I can’t recommend it enough, Gracie, you’ve made readers everywhere fall in love with Riley’s journey. I am beyond excited for the rest of the trilogy!
February 7, 2026
Although First Line includes adult themes—first love, complicated family dynamics, and both physical & emotional abuse—they’re handled gently without much descriptive details
The story follows Riley, an orphan living with her uncle, who earns a spot on the high school hockey team. Her best friend and next‑door neighbor, Ethan, is the team captain. Riley works hard to keep up with the boys, but she never quite feels like she measures up.
The book moves quickly and has the potential for real emotional depth, but it often skims past the raw moments instead of letting them land. Some readers may prefer that lighter touch.
Just as the story gains momentum, it ends. Written as a trilogy, this installment feels more like a serial—stopping abruptly rather than concluding an arc.
I’ll read Book Two because I’m invested enough to want answers, but part of me feels a little let down by how suddenly this one wraps up. It cuts off right when things get interesting, leaving me to pick up the next book to find out what happens to Riley.
The story follows Riley, an orphan living with her uncle, who earns a spot on the high school hockey team. Her best friend and next‑door neighbor, Ethan, is the team captain. Riley works hard to keep up with the boys, but she never quite feels like she measures up.
The book moves quickly and has the potential for real emotional depth, but it often skims past the raw moments instead of letting them land. Some readers may prefer that lighter touch.
Just as the story gains momentum, it ends. Written as a trilogy, this installment feels more like a serial—stopping abruptly rather than concluding an arc.
I’ll read Book Two because I’m invested enough to want answers, but part of me feels a little let down by how suddenly this one wraps up. It cuts off right when things get interesting, leaving me to pick up the next book to find out what happens to Riley.
February 12, 2026
I read Second Overtime before First Line, not appreciating that there was a series here. So I went back to First Line. I really liked Second Overtime, and no surprise, I liked First Line too.
When I was in high school in the 1980s, there was a romance series called Couples that was all the rage, as it did a great job of capturing the intensity, awkwardness, and sweetness of young love. First Line gave me the same feeling I had when I read those Couples books; it is a classic, heartfelt high school romance, and it is a nice slow-burn.
Riley and Ethan are the main couple, and the story switches between their perspectives. Chapters revisit shared scenes from each character's perspective. Watching their relationship slowly develop over their high school years is genuinely satisfying. You see the misunderstandings, the quiet realizations, the hesitations, and the steady growth of something real.
If you like dual-POV romance and stories where relationships grow naturally over time, First Line is definitely worth reading.
When I was in high school in the 1980s, there was a romance series called Couples that was all the rage, as it did a great job of capturing the intensity, awkwardness, and sweetness of young love. First Line gave me the same feeling I had when I read those Couples books; it is a classic, heartfelt high school romance, and it is a nice slow-burn.
Riley and Ethan are the main couple, and the story switches between their perspectives. Chapters revisit shared scenes from each character's perspective. Watching their relationship slowly develop over their high school years is genuinely satisfying. You see the misunderstandings, the quiet realizations, the hesitations, and the steady growth of something real.
If you like dual-POV romance and stories where relationships grow naturally over time, First Line is definitely worth reading.
November 28, 2025
A good old-fashioned girl and boy next door romance
The teen romance of the girl and boy next door, Riley and Ethan, was a delight reminiscent of Joey and Dawson’s relationship from Dawson’s Creek. Add to the love stand-off angst, throw in an abusive uncle, never achieving star status as an ice hockey star, whose jealousy of his orphaned niece, Riley, who shows much more promise in the field that he ever did, causing him to torment her horribly, and we have a page turner.
I found the book well written and enjoyed most of it, but the ending seemed rushed, and along with Ethan’s mother’s ‘helpful’ actions, it left me with a ‘what the’ vibe. Can’t say much more without spoilers, other than I need an explanation for the strange withholding of certain important information from a particular lovesick party for apparently no good reason. Perhaps Monroe will reveal all in book two? Stay tuned.
The teen romance of the girl and boy next door, Riley and Ethan, was a delight reminiscent of Joey and Dawson’s relationship from Dawson’s Creek. Add to the love stand-off angst, throw in an abusive uncle, never achieving star status as an ice hockey star, whose jealousy of his orphaned niece, Riley, who shows much more promise in the field that he ever did, causing him to torment her horribly, and we have a page turner.
I found the book well written and enjoyed most of it, but the ending seemed rushed, and along with Ethan’s mother’s ‘helpful’ actions, it left me with a ‘what the’ vibe. Can’t say much more without spoilers, other than I need an explanation for the strange withholding of certain important information from a particular lovesick party for apparently no good reason. Perhaps Monroe will reveal all in book two? Stay tuned.
December 21, 2025
First Line is an enjoyable young adult story about best friends growing into love. It’s fast-paced as their connection deepens, and the writing has a warm, feel-good quality, much in the vein of a Hallmark-style romance. Its simplicity works well for a light, easy read, though there were moments moments where I questioned the logic, such as why no one intervened sooner when signs of the girl’s declining health and possible physical abuse seemed evident, or how an underage, non-sexually active girl was able to get an IUD when she couldn’t even attend a routine checkup.
Despite these minor issues, I was prepared to give the book five stars because I genuinely enjoyed reading it. That is, until it abruptly ended. The conclusion felt more like a tease for the next book, and given the short length of the story, it left me feeling a bit cheated. There was room to explore more and offer a more satisfying sense of closure.
Still, I do recommend this book, and I plan to read the next one.
Despite these minor issues, I was prepared to give the book five stars because I genuinely enjoyed reading it. That is, until it abruptly ended. The conclusion felt more like a tease for the next book, and given the short length of the story, it left me feeling a bit cheated. There was room to explore more and offer a more satisfying sense of closure.
Still, I do recommend this book, and I plan to read the next one.
April 13, 2026
Gripping, emotional, and impossible to put down
First Line completely pulled me in from the very first chapter. The story follows Riley, a determined female hockey player fighting to prove herself in a male-dominated sport, while navigating complicated feelings for her team captain, Ethan.
What I loved most was the tension—both on and off the ice. The slow-burn romance is done so well, full of longing, miscommunication, and those moments that make your heart ache in the best way. Riley’s strength and vulnerability made her incredibly relatable, and Ethan’s character adds just the right amount of emotional depth.
The pacing kept me hooked, and the mix of sports drama and romance felt fresh and addictive. If you love sports romance with strong female leads, emotional tension, and a “will-they-won’t-they” dynamic, this is definitely worth the read.
I’m already excited to see where the rest of the trilogy goes!
First Line completely pulled me in from the very first chapter. The story follows Riley, a determined female hockey player fighting to prove herself in a male-dominated sport, while navigating complicated feelings for her team captain, Ethan.
What I loved most was the tension—both on and off the ice. The slow-burn romance is done so well, full of longing, miscommunication, and those moments that make your heart ache in the best way. Riley’s strength and vulnerability made her incredibly relatable, and Ethan’s character adds just the right amount of emotional depth.
The pacing kept me hooked, and the mix of sports drama and romance felt fresh and addictive. If you love sports romance with strong female leads, emotional tension, and a “will-they-won’t-they” dynamic, this is definitely worth the read.
I’m already excited to see where the rest of the trilogy goes!
December 19, 2025
First Line is the kind of sports romance that actually respects the “sports” part. The hockey world feels competitive and high-stakes, not just window dressing, and the emotional tension builds in a way that kept me turning pages.
Riley is easy to root for—driven, stubborn, and trying to earn her place in a space that doesn’t automatically make room for her. The best-friend/team-captain dynamic with Ethan brings that slow-burn pressure where the smallest moments land hard, and the relationship never feels like random drama for drama’s sake.
What I liked most is the balance: game-day intensity, quieter character moments, and a steady build of chemistry. It’s not a “plot twist” book—it’s a momentum book. If you want sports romance with heart, loyalty, and that tight-chest feeling when everything’s on the line, this one hits.
Riley is easy to root for—driven, stubborn, and trying to earn her place in a space that doesn’t automatically make room for her. The best-friend/team-captain dynamic with Ethan brings that slow-burn pressure where the smallest moments land hard, and the relationship never feels like random drama for drama’s sake.
What I liked most is the balance: game-day intensity, quieter character moments, and a steady build of chemistry. It’s not a “plot twist” book—it’s a momentum book. If you want sports romance with heart, loyalty, and that tight-chest feeling when everything’s on the line, this one hits.
January 20, 2026
I'm a sucker for sports romance, and this one caught me off guard in the best way. Riley's not your typical "girl in a guys' sport" protagonist she's driven, flawed, and clearly hiding something darker beneath the surface. Those unexplained bruises? They add real tension beyond the usual will they won't they romance.
Monroe does a solid job balancing the hockey scenes (which feel authentic) with Riley's internal struggles. The slow burn with Ethan works because their friendship feels genuine first. My only gripe is that some of the "hidden feelings" trope felt predictable, but the heavier undertones the bruises, the exhaustion kept me invested.
Knowing this is book one of a trilogy, I'm frustrated it ends where it does, but also already queuing up the next one. If you like sports romance with actual stakes and a protagonist who's more than just lovesick, grab this.
Monroe does a solid job balancing the hockey scenes (which feel authentic) with Riley's internal struggles. The slow burn with Ethan works because their friendship feels genuine first. My only gripe is that some of the "hidden feelings" trope felt predictable, but the heavier undertones the bruises, the exhaustion kept me invested.
Knowing this is book one of a trilogy, I'm frustrated it ends where it does, but also already queuing up the next one. If you like sports romance with actual stakes and a protagonist who's more than just lovesick, grab this.
December 6, 2025
First Line is an addictive start to the Riley & Ethan Trilogy. The author pulls you in immediately with a strong emotional hook and compelling characters whose chemistry feels authentic from the very first chapters. Riley is particularly well-drawn and Ethan adds a tension that keeps the pages turning.
The writing is fast-paced and immersive, and the relationship dynamics are the standout strength of the book. While a few plot points felt slightly rushed and I occasionally wished for deeper development in secondary characters, the overall story is gripping and heartfelt.
A great choice for readers who enjoy romance with a touch of drama and a cliffhanger that guarantees you’ll want Book 2. I’m looking forward to seeing where this trilogy goes next!
The writing is fast-paced and immersive, and the relationship dynamics are the standout strength of the book. While a few plot points felt slightly rushed and I occasionally wished for deeper development in secondary characters, the overall story is gripping and heartfelt.
A great choice for readers who enjoy romance with a touch of drama and a cliffhanger that guarantees you’ll want Book 2. I’m looking forward to seeing where this trilogy goes next!
December 29, 2025
This was a quick read, young adult as the characters were in high school. I'd already read the second book in this series and wanted to see where it started. I wish there'd been more character development as everything happened very quickly and some more details in certain areas would've been nice. The end felt rushed - Ethan's mother had a whole plan for Riley before they'd even discussed the abuse by her uncle. I also felt like there wasn't really a reason for Riley to just cut Ethan off, but that's the main focus of the second book, so maybe that's why it went that way.
Overall, it was a good story. The teasing and banter between the team members, and the relationship between Riley and Ethan's family was endearing.
Overall, it was a good story. The teasing and banter between the team members, and the relationship between Riley and Ethan's family was endearing.
January 2, 2026
First Line by Gracie Monroe is a strong and engaging start to the Riley & Ethan trilogy. The story blends high school hockey, ambition, and young love in a way that’s easy to get invested in. Riley is a fierce and talented player, and Ethan complements her perfectly both on and off the ice. Their chemistry as teammates and as a couple feels genuine and heartfelt.
Beyond the sports aspect, the book also touches on heavier themes like family struggles and personal challenges, which adds emotional depth to the story. While some elements may feel simplified, the overall pacing and writing keep the story moving and enjoyable.
A solid first book that sets up the characters and their journey well. I’m curious to see how Riley and Ethan’s story continues in the next installments.
Beyond the sports aspect, the book also touches on heavier themes like family struggles and personal challenges, which adds emotional depth to the story. While some elements may feel simplified, the overall pacing and writing keep the story moving and enjoyable.
A solid first book that sets up the characters and their journey well. I’m curious to see how Riley and Ethan’s story continues in the next installments.
January 10, 2026
This is a very good love story with built-in suspense throughout until Chapter 26, when the first moments of passion manifested. After 4 years of being neighbors (Riley Carter and Ethan Cole), attending the same school, and playing in the same hockey team, the inevitable finally rushed in.
About midway of the story, Riley’s secret regarding her abusive uncle who was a drunk, was already tampering with her peace, the reason she preferred to spend time over at Ethan’s. Ethan seemed to be ignorant of this, though his mother became the primary rescuer of Riley at the end. The end is a little too abrupt in my opinion but I understand the continuum of a trilogy. It should make more sense in Book 2.
Good story overall!
About midway of the story, Riley’s secret regarding her abusive uncle who was a drunk, was already tampering with her peace, the reason she preferred to spend time over at Ethan’s. Ethan seemed to be ignorant of this, though his mother became the primary rescuer of Riley at the end. The end is a little too abrupt in my opinion but I understand the continuum of a trilogy. It should make more sense in Book 2.
Good story overall!
November 12, 2025
Fast, Emotional, and Full of Heart
First Line is a quick but powerful read that dives into the pressure, pain, and passion behind chasing a dream. Gracie Monroe captures what it feels like to fight for a place in a world that keeps testing your strength. Riley’s story feels raw and real, balancing her drive on the ice with everything she’s trying to hold together beneath the surface.
The friendship and tension between Riley and Ethan give the story warmth and depth, making it more than just a sports romance. It is about resilience, identity, and finding your voice even when it hurts.
A short, emotional read that lingers long after the last page.
First Line is a quick but powerful read that dives into the pressure, pain, and passion behind chasing a dream. Gracie Monroe captures what it feels like to fight for a place in a world that keeps testing your strength. Riley’s story feels raw and real, balancing her drive on the ice with everything she’s trying to hold together beneath the surface.
The friendship and tension between Riley and Ethan give the story warmth and depth, making it more than just a sports romance. It is about resilience, identity, and finding your voice even when it hurts.
A short, emotional read that lingers long after the last page.
December 16, 2025
“First Line (The Riley & Ethan Trilogy Book 1)” by Gracie Monroe, begins the friendship and budding romance of Riley and Ethan, both skilled hockey players on their high school team. This is part of a trilogy, not a complete story arc, and there is a spicy scene near the end. Riley has secrets that are wearing her down, and she doesn’t feel comfortable sharing them, not even with Ethan. Or perhaps especially with Ethan, since he thinks the world of her much-admired guardian, Uncle Don. Unbeknownst to her friends, including Ethan, Riley’s uncle is physically and verbally abusive. This is a well-written and compelling contemporary drama.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews