Kassia St Clair's second book, The Golden Thread: How Fabric Changed History, has been variously called 'extraordinary' (The Sunday Times), 'beautiful' (Nature), and 'extremely good' (Times Literary Supplement). In it, St Clair - a scholar of women's dress in the eighteenth century - explores '... our continuing reinventions of cloth [which] offer an unexpected history of human ingenuity'.
First published in 2018, The Golden Thread is split into thirteen separate sections, each of which focus on a particular type of fabric or fabric production. These chapters are loosely chronological, and span from 'The Origins of Weaving' and 'Silk in Ancient China' to 'Suits Suitable for Space' and 'Record-Breaking Sports Fabrics'. The tome also includes some rather extensive notes, and a thorough bibliography. St Clair sets out in her introduction that this book is not 'an exhaustive history of textiles', but rather includes 'thirteen very different stories that help illustrate the vastness of their significance.'
Our lives are surrounded by cloth - the clothes we wear, the chairs we sit upon every day, the bedding we sleep beneath, the shoes on our feet - but how many of us actually devote much time to considering how these fabrics were produced, and where they came from? Throughout history, clothing has been used as a tool to denote power, and also one which can show such things as abject poverty.
The book begins with humour, but this is not something which has been threaded throughout the book. In her introduction, St Clair writes: 'If you take your eyes off this page and look down, you will see that your body is encased in cloth. (I am assuming here, dear Reader, that you are not naked).' This is not to say that the rest of the tome is entirely serious; rather, the jokes which St Clair makes at times fall rather flat, and add little to the book as a whole.
St Clair explores a lot of elements within The Golden Thread: the point at which it is thought humans began to wear clothing; the tools used to produce fabrics throughout antiquity; the weaving process; and the farming methods used to produce the crops used in textile production. St Clair goes on to discuss the cultivation of silk and how different communities have forced its production for higher yields. Fabric is also written about throughout as a commodity. In China, for instance, between AD 9 and 23, 'a plain bolt of silk could be exchanged for around sixty kilograms of rice, while finer silk might be exchanged for eighty'. This detail all feels quite thorough, and the book has clearly been well informed and well researched.
Some of the facts which I learnt from The Golden Thread are quite astonishing. The most complicated patterns of handmade lace, for instance, required up to six hundred different bobbins to make. Another which caught my attention is that in 1216, when an inventory of King John of England's possessions was carried out, he owned 185 silk shirts (!). Like many readers, I am sure, I found some sections of the book more interesting than others. I very much enjoyed the later chapters - particularly those on clothing suitable for polar exploration and sports - but not so much those at the beginning at the book, which largely seemed obvious, and which I already knew the majority of.
The Golden Thread feels rather fragmented overall. This feeling starts in the book's introduction, which is comprised of several vignettes. These seem to have been placed entirely randomly, and there is no cohesion whatsoever to be found here. This structure is then followed into each separate chapter, and whilst a few of the subsections do lead nicely into the next, most are not connected at all.
I did find this volume fascinating in terms of its content, but its execution did not work that well for me as a reader. I found the narration rather dry. The somewhat unsuitable structure given to The Golden Thread felt quite journalistic. As already mentioned, St Clair's absence in linking different subsections together makes the reading process somewhat jarring.
St Clair also makes unhelpful assumptions at times; she thinks that consumers have little knowledge of synthetic fabrics and the process of creating them. Had she given more attention to fast fashion and the growing demand for eco-friendly fabrics, I feel that my opinions of the book would have been a little different. As it is, the fast fashion industry is mentioned, but is largely glossed over, as are other interesting details. Some of the less engaging sections of the book have been written about at length, and do tend to feel a little overdone.
In her preface to The Golden Thread, St Clair comments: 'Fabrics - man-made and natural - have changed, defined, advanced and shaped the world we live in.' However, this claim has not been thoroughly investigated, as St Clair focuses far more upon adaptations of fabrics used for various purposes. Its subtitle is a little misleading; 'How Fabric Changed History' would be more suitable if amended to 'How History Changed Fabric'. Whilst advances in fabric production throughout the centuries have had an effect upon how we live, nothing which St Clair explores has been quite big enough to be described as changing history.
Overall, The Golden Thread did not hold my attention anywhere near as much as I expected it to. With a different structure, and the use of illustrations and photographs which would have been very useful at points, such fascinating source material could have been made a lot more engaging. I have been reassured by other reviews that her first book is far more consistent, so despite having some reservations about The Golden Thread, St Clair's first book, The Secret Lives of Colour, is still firmly upon my wishlist.