Brahms, a theater critic and ballet specialist, has clearly read the Baily book and seems to paraphrase it frequently. However, this work goes much further as we are presented with more detail, longer quotations and many photos and illustrations. It is an opinionated work which is not amiss from a critic such as Brahms, but laced throughout there are sometimes juvenile, sometimes merely indulgent, interjections sure to delight some and quickly tire others. For example, a quote from Sullivan's diary will be provided: "Opera went very well. Call for Gilbert and self. We went on together but did not speak to each other." To the end of this, the author cannot help appending "('Oh, the pity of it, Iago, the pity of it.')".