I broke the heart of the only man I've ever loved.
I had it a job that I adored, in the only city that ever felt like home, and a steadfast unshakable love.
After the worst decision of my life, I'm forced to return to the UK where I'm left to deal with the wreckage I've created. Healing is anything but linear and I don't know where to begin.
Darí
Losing him was like losing a vital piece of myself.
Picking up the pieces of a life that was always supposed to include Harlan seems impossible. He is woven into every corner of the place we called home. I'm learning that time doesn't heal all wounds and sometimes the heart wants what it wants. Even if it's the very thing that destroyed you.
The road to new beginnings starts with the sunrise.
In the past, cheating, especially by one character on another, was a hard "nope" for me. Childhood trauma and all that jazz. However, after loads of good ol' therapy, I found I could read stories with tropes that would normally trigger me. Therefore, cheating in books or movies became doable again as long as it was written well. This story of cheating and redemption kept showing up, with the highest of praise, in my various book groups, so I thought "why not give it a go?" Maybe I should have just...not.
Here's the thing. I have to be invested in the characters and their love story if the author expects me to forgive a cheating MC. To put it simply, I was not. I tried. I promise. I truly tried. I just could not really invest in the romance between Dare and Lan. First, there is literally no look or flashbacks of their 3-year romance. Just a quick back story and then we are thrown straight into the cheating scene. I have no reason to invest in their romance when we spend no time with them in the beginning of said romance.
As previously mentioned, the cheating happens extremely early in the book and for the stupidest of reasons. So ridiculous that I cannot find it in my heart to find an ounce of sympathy for Lan. I mean, Lan describes how horny the random makes him feel before he cheats on his long-term "soulmate" and feels no remorse until after the rando is done down his throat. On a positive, at least Lan confesses and Dare gets mad for maybe 2 minutes and says they're over. But, wait! Dare still wants Lan to know he is a perfect little flower and that he forgives Lan for the cheating. Dude only found out a day ago and already found forgiveness in his heart for a massive betrayal. What a saint. Or an idiot. Definitely an idiot.
Moving forward, Lan moves back to London and, after a few months of self pity, is living a lovely new life with a lovely new man. Basically, 6 months after destroying Dare, Lan meets Oliver. Lan gets all squishy and lovey with Oliver while allowing the dude to raw dog it after only being with him a short bit. Lan stays with Oliver for almost the rest of the time he and Dare are separated aka most of the book. I truly think Lan would still be with Oliver if the dude hadn't dumped him first. Me thinks Lan's "it is only ever that way with Dare because Dare is true lurve" is all cockamamie. Yet, Dare tries on one relationship after Lan's betrayal and it falls apart faster than a New Year's resolution. Its okay though, because he really just wants Lan to be happy.
Oh, don't get me started on San Fran when Dare and his friends come across Lan and Oliver. Dare's "closest friends" being all happy and sappy to see Lan with his new man while Dare is right there. Ya. No.
Better yet, when Lanyboo moves back to Brooklyn, one of Dare's "great friends" wants to have his party at Dare's house and the man invites Lan and Oliver. Oh, but even though he already invited the dynamic duo, he will tell them no if Dare is uncomfortable. Of course Dare says its okay, because for one, he will be the douche canoe if he says "no" and two that is what doormats do. Doormats let so-called true loves and friends wipe their crap feet all over them. Also, why the hell would Lan and Oliver accept other than to rub their relationship in Dare's face even more. Seriously selfish.
Oh, but don't worry, after Lan gets dumped by Oliver, Dare decides his friends are right and he needs to get over it and give Lan a chance because he is the most perfect ever Gary Sue who ever Sued and he will otherwise die alone if he doesn't love and take Lan back. I just can't with this book. Obviously.
Here is my conundrum. When I lean towards a low score, I tend to not rate a book unless the writing is atrocious. The writing in this book is actually, for the most parts, well done. For me, its the way the cheating character is well-loved while the cheated upon character gets dumped on over and over that drives me over the edge. Lets just say that the balance between betrayal and grovel is not to scale. Therefore, while I loathe this book, I can't fault the writing nor score a book low, especially a debut, because I don't like how a cruddy character is well-loved by the author. Ya. No rating, but no love. That's where I am at with this book.
Watching the damage one partner can cause - not just to the person they love, but to themselves and everyone around them - was genuinely heartbreaking.
I really, truly hated Harlan at first. My heart ached for Darío. No one deserves to be cheated on, especially not by the person they believe is their soulmate. That kind of betrayal cuts deep, and this book does not soften that blow.
But as the story unfolded, I found myself slowly starting to understand Lan. You can feel how much he’s struggling, how lost he is, how deeply he hates himself for what he’s done. And Dare is struggling just as much...if not more. It becomes painfully clear that neither of them is whole without the other...even though they’re both broken.
What I appreciated most was that their healing wasn’t rushed. They didn’t just fall back into bed together and pretend everything was fine. They rebuilt from the ground up. Friendship first. Trust slowly earned back. It felt real, and it felt earned.
I hated watching them try to find love and happiness with other people - it hurt - but I also understood it. They both needed space to heal on their own, to learn how to exist again without leaning entirely on each other.
Somewhere along the way, just like Darío, I found myself forgiving Harlan. He fucked up. Badly. But they were both so deeply miserable without each other for so long. And in the end, seeing them finally find their way back to one another felt incredibly cathartic.
Here’s to second chances, sunrises, and new beginnings.
Stealing Hoodies Cheating Lingerie Model / Baseball Player Found family Anxiety rep Second chance Redemption
So this was unique. This is my first book about cheating amongst the MMC’s.
There is real on page cheating.
After the “incident” they are separated distance wise for reasons … During this time, they are both hurting but also trying to move forward with their lives as they feel they will never be together again.
They were both broken men, I think in very different ways, Harlan carrying serious guilt and shame for his choices, and Dario, pain over losing the love of his life and the betrayal.
Both MC’s try to get new partners and move forward with their lives. It doesn't work out, their hearts still belong to each other.
I think this was done well, it does come full circle. I do feel they earned each other again and were able to get past the “incident”.
I appreciate how they took their time to rebuild their relationship again and didn't just jump right in.
They still have so much love, and care and concern for each other. Aside from the hurt and pain, their well-being truly mattered.
Shout out to Dario's family too.
It’s absolutely a unique story for sure.
I am glad they found their way back to each other
So thankful for this arc
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
D.N.F. 39% I just can't. My triggers are screaming at me. I cannot consciously go through this.
Thoughts as reading: Heart wrenching torture. I had to skim through parts cause with stories like this, you protect your heart. I'm aware this says more about me than this great book.
⚠️ fair warning to all my reader friends this has infidelity.
Wow this one hurts right off the bat. The good thing is that I didn't get too invested in them because it was too soon and since Harlan was absolutely at fault I couldn't feel bad for him. He was obviously too comfortable in what he had and let his immaturity and selfishness take the wheel. Sucked for him😒
-mm romance -second chance -lingerie model x baseball player -found family -redemption
oooffff this was ROUGHHHH!!! it does have the cheating trope...like on the mc not with...but holyyy shit was that redemption sooo good!! i loved these two & their story so much, it was raw & real & showed how you really need to go thru things separately sometimes to find out how you can be with each other again & dario just deserves everything good in the world!!!
Starting off with a sex scene during after an unresolved and stressful conversation was interesting. I'm not a prude but it felt like it set the tone more for an erotica than romance tbh.
The expo dumps at the start were too wordy and boring. I don't think we needed to read about how Harlan and Darío met through Darío's sister that early (we could've gotten a scene showing us how Harlan and Darío's sister got along rather than having it told to us, etc) Same goes for Harlan internal monologuing about how he came to America and lived out his dream (could've gotten that from seeing his reaction upon landing back in the UK).
Something didn't make sense to me in Harlan's first POV chapter. He says that "Lust & Lace knew I'd walk away from their employment offer if I couldn't work from out New York offices" then he waxes poetic about how great it was to work for a queer owned, inclusive brand. I think the implication was that he specifically stipulated that he wanted to be placed in the New York office when he was first hired, but the paragraph hadn't been properly set up to indicate that he was talking about when he first got the job, so it made it feel like he accepted the offer contradictory to the situation since he was leaving the US. Very nitpicky, but something like "When I applied to L&L, I demanded that I be placed in the New York office" would've helped a lot on placing that particular sentence in the past (especially considering the following sentences imply that Harlan was presently being scouted).
The short paragraph where Harlan worries about how little time they'd spend together if he moves back to the UK AND Darío's team makes it to the world series didn't really make much sense considering Darío would have needed to focus on training regardless of whether or not Harlan was in the UK or US. I mean, they already barely saw each other during the regular season while he was in the states still, so I'm not sure him being in the UK while Darío was training for the series would've been a significant difference since they didn't live together. It still would've been four months a year regardless of the continent he was in.
Yeah, I knew about the cheating but that doesn't save this from being a 1 star rating for me. I thought it would be more complicated and maybe even have some justification to make it palatable, but no. It's just Harlan gets drunk because he has to leave the country and has sex with a rando without even thinking about Darío at the beginning. What a great way to start off a romance. 😒
The worst part of it is Darío and Harlan never even talk about the possibility of long distance before Harlan just up and cheats. Yeah he was drunk, but that doesn't magically make it ok (nor does it justify it in the writing because seriously? That's the lamest and laziest excuse for committing one of the biggest sins in romance novels).
Ok listen. I had this book on my TBR for AGES because I knew it had some pretty sweet soup scenes….. but I also knew it had on page cheating (it’s pretty much what the entire story revolves around). I can tell you now, if cheating isn’t a TW for you, this book is SO GOOD. Soulmates level second chance romance, where even when the MMCs are apart, you KNOW they are meant to find their way back to each other. It’s emotional and intense. There is groveling and men sobbing and it’s HEARTBREAKING, but you really are rooting for them to make things work the entire time.
In addition to the incredibly angsty romance, Sunrises has even more exciting draws. I didn’t realize for the longest time that it’s a baseball romance - MMC Dario is a baseball player. And if you love men in lingerie, Harlan is a designer and model for a men’s lingerie company. There IS caretaking with soup (and tons of food as a love language), I LOVED it. And there’s the cutest little corgi puppy (part of Dario’s healing journey) that honestly might’ve been my favorite character 🫣😂.
I listened to this one as an audiobook and IT IS PHENOMENAL. The narrators really took the emotional scenes to the next level….. you can FEEL Harlan’s pain in @nathanwolfe79’s narration and omg when @kieranreganva’s voice breaks I could’ve sworn he was actually crying? Just incredible, bravo @mj_sivilo on your debut and I can’t wait to read more (does Oliver get a book 👀)!
This debut novel by MJ Sivilo is stunning, but I’ll be honest, my heart still hasn’t recovered yet.
I loved Darío and Harlan as a couple immediately. I couldn’t get enough of how they spoke to each other with such tenderness and love. There was no doubt in my mind that these two were meant to be together, which made me extra nervous for what I knew was coming. And boy, did it HURT. After receiving devastating news while Darío’s away, Harlan goes out with his friend, feeling disorientated, and commits the unthinkable.
I thought I’d hate Harlan after that, or at least dislike him, but – credit to the author for how well she introduced this character – I found I couldn’t, even though I knew I should. As he admits what happened to a shocked Darío, further shattering the life they’d built, he didn’t just break their hearts, he broke mine too. After feeling Darío’s pain – the disbelief, the betrayal, the distrust – I watched in dismay as these two said goodbye and put thousands of miles between them.
They both do their best to move on. Live their lives, have new relationships, even though they both feel a part of them is missing. They heal, grow in their own ways, in ways that they both needed. But it’s clear that their hearts are elsewhere. They belong to each other, and their worlds don’t seem to align properly without their other half.
What I loved about how they come back together is that they don’t just fall back into a relationship. They get to know each other again, as friends, before things evolve into more. I so enjoyed watching them starting their relationship afresh, rebuilding the trust, and seeing how their feelings only seem to grow even more. They seem more at peace this time, more secure in themselves, and that makes the separation mean something, even though I hated it. I relished seeing all those little things they noticed about each other this time around, like they’re relearning each other.
These two leave a lasting impression. Harlan doesn’t hide from his mistake, he owns up to it, and carries the guilt and pain from that, not truly living until his loyal bestie arrives, forcing him to do better. And Darío, well, he’s the ultimate keeper. His ability to forgive and move forward speaks of the amazing person he is. He’s fair and sees beyond his own hurt to be empathetic to what Harlan was feeling, even if it understandably takes him some time to get there.
This book did wreck me for a while – the raw emotion affected me deeply – but in the end, it felt like Darío and Harlan came back even stronger. Forgiveness is a powerful thing.
What made me love this book even more is that their family and friends were massively supportive of them too, though they’re not afraid of calling them out when they’re being idiots. These amazing friends knew, accepted and forgave Harlan for his mistake and loved him despite it, welcoming him home with open arms. Big love for this!
Oh, and did I mention, there’s a cute corgi too…
I can’t wait to see what comes next from this author.
----
I received an ARC copy of this book by the author and The Author Agency and this is my honest review.
----
Some of my favourite quotes
And how do you say goodbye to your heart? To your home? That’s what Dare is. My heart. My home.
“Sometimes, good people make bad decisions. It’s part of being human. You’re young. You’re resilient, and you are so much more to people than just that decision.”
“You can do hard things, Harlan.”
“That’s what best friends do. They love you even when you’re hard to love.”
“I don’t know how to love anyone else the way I love you,”
“You’re so beautiful, sweetness. I miss you so much it hurts. I haven’t felt whole since you left, you know?”
“I know I told you this in San Francisco, but I’m so proud of you. Things haven’t been easy, but you always find a way to shine,”
“Sitting here with you all makes me realize just how lucky I am. That even at my worst, you still loved me through it. I’m thankful to be back home.”
“I love your heart, Harlan James. The way that you care for others is a gift.”
“Darío, you are my home. There are a lot of things I may be unsure about, but you are not one of them. My heart is whole when I’m with you.”
“Harlan James, loving you has been the greatest privilege of my life.”
“Before you, I had no idea that I had the capacity to love someone the way that I love you. You make it feel easy, even when things are intense. Even when they’re hard.”
I've read a lot of cheating books before. Ones where the MC's cheat with each other and ones where, like in this one, there is cheating between the MC's. Sometimes, if I'm in the right mood, a cheating book can be so good, and I can get really emotionally invested because it's heavy, there's angst and yearning, and it just makes me feel.
And, for a little bit with this book, I felt that. I mean, I'll be honest, sometimes reading a book with an already existing couple can make me less emotionally invested anyway, because we are just being told about the relationship and the feelings, but we were never shown how they got there. Lan and Dare were a sweet couple in the beginning, though.
At least there was that.
I do think Harlans reason for cheating was a bit weak, and I felt so fucking sorry for Dare. Cheating is awful as it is, but the fact he had once been cheated on in the past and Lan was still selfish enough to cheat on him anyway. Shake my damn head. But I carried on, wanting to see how their story continued.
Now to my main issue, which came in the second half when we see them dating other people. It was understandable that they'd try and move on, but it got to the point where we were getting well over half way, and I was hoping for a little more interaction from our main characters, you know, finding their way back together, the longing, the pain of being without each other. That kind of thing. Yet we, as readers, were treated to reading explicit sex scenes of them with the guys they were dating. I don't want to read basically the same repeated sex scene between Lan and Oliver (the other guy) as we saw in the beginning between Lan and Dare. It was almost copy and paste.
I was pretty much out at that point, but I was definitely out when I realised Lan wasn't using condoms with the other guy. Couldn't that level of intimacy have been saved for just Lan and Dare?
After that, I was questioning why I would still route for the main couple to get back together? What were we seeing that would lead me to believe that Lan and Dare were the love of each other's lives?
Well, maybe from Dare I could feel it. But dear God, don't get me started on Lans character. As if the cheating wasn't bad enough. Please tell me, in what world should it be the guy that was cheated on be the one to try and get back together?
Lan should have been on his knees, grovelling for the love of his life back. Sure, it was great he went to therapy and attempted to work on himself. But he was such a selfish character imo. His reason for cheating was all about him, as was everything else in the book. Did he even care about Dare at all?
Because sure, he may not have been as happy with Oliver, but Lan seemed pretty okay being with him. In fact, if Oliver hadn't called things off, I think Lan would've just stayed in that relationship because he didn't want to be alone. Putting into perspective that Lan made this huge mistake (granted he owned upto it straight away, and respected Dare enough to give him space when he asked for it) but there wasn't nearly enough yearning and grovelling from him in the long run.
Ugh, we see no real effort from him, really. In fact, we saw him putting more effort into doing better in his relationship with Oliver than we did with the supposed 'love of his life'. Yeah, yeah, he had learned his lesson from that mistake. But how about putting that effort into trying to make things right with Dare? Even just basic communication would've been fine. I know Dare initially asked for no contact but it had been a year.
I don't know, I'm ranting because he annoyed me.
The book was annoying me.
I didn't care about that relationship, and there was far too much focus on them, and it dragged for too long. Maybe if Lan had been the one to call things off with Oliver, it might have made things a bit better. Or maybe if Lan had actually really tried to get back together with Dare. Tried to communicate after a year apart, tried to see where Dare was at, just...attempted something.
I would've loved Dare to actually move on and fall in love with someone else. So the fact that it was Dare who initiated getting back together and proposed was 🤯
I initially found this author when I finished the resilience of stars yesterday. Xara Kenley thanked this author in her acknowledgements. Looks like they are besties. This book was absolutely gorgeous. I'm a sucker for a second chance and this delivered. Darío and Harlan were yet another great couple. Mr. Harlan and his love for Darío. Even after his little mess up (yes that trope but it felt way different than a full blown cheating trope, i promise.) He accepts his fate and goes on. I mean....this is without a doubt a full fledged kind of book I enjoy deep into my soul. I loved it. Yet another author I will read every word of.
“This way, you’ll never miss another Brooklyn sunrise.”
….
First and foremost I want to say that I applaud for the bravery to bring out a book in such format. This is what I wish for more authors to do while writing second chances… to have the in between even if it hurts so damn much. Because we hurt but then we heal. It’s not only black and white, there’s so much growth in between and people that teach us lessons so we can be better and do better - be better to the ones that’s meant to be in the end.
This book hurt. It’s about one’s actions that leads to damaging someone else’s heart to the point of no return but hurting yourself the most. About moving on, growing up and what it means to be truly meant to be. Healing slowly, separate and then together. About second chances, sunrises and new beginnings.
….
“I love you most.” // “And how do you say goodbye to your heart? To your home? That’s what Dare is. My heart. My home.” // “I see the man I fell in love with under the layers of sadness, but I’ve never felt more disconnected from him.” // “It’s funny how food, music, and smells can take you to a moment in the past.” // “In the back of my mind, I wonder if there will ever be a time when I don’t physically respond to the sound of his voice.” // “The fact that we’re both still healing means that we had something worthy of breaking over, right?” // “I live for the still moments right as the sun crests the horizon, where it feels like I’m the only one in the universe.” // “He still smells like summer to me, and it brings me inexplicable comfort that this has remained the same.” // “A lot has changed, but so much has remained the same. Namely, our chemistry. It’s incendiary, and I’m afraid that if we ignite it again, nothing will remain of either of us…” …
….
*I reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.
When I saw that Nathan Wolfe narrates this book, I picked it up immediately. I went for it because of Nathan, but Kieran Regan?? Amazing. I need him to do more MM. It didn't even bother me at all that it wasn't a duet because they both did such a great job.
Now, about the book itself. I get that this might not be for everyone and could be triggering for some, but I loved it. Did I understand or condone Harlan’s decision to cheat? Hell no. Did that detract from the reading experience at all? Not in the slightest. And the author made me love him too. But Darío.. the man that you are. I could just shout from the rooftops about how much I love him. The way he loved Harlan, his patience, his understanding, his overall demeanor, and his words. The way he treated Harlan, no matter what, from start to finish. Talk about perfection.
This spoke to me on an emotional level, and I was able to empathize with both MMCs’ feelings. The first 40% of the book was really depressing—and I loved it. It was heartbreaking to read about the emotional turmoil both Dare and Harlan went through. The narrators really brought out Harlan and Dare’s emotions and emphasized that melancholy.
I was surprised that I didn't even feel the need to read the story of how they met and their past (the book starts when they have dated for three years already). This still managed to get me invested and convince me of their love and the depth of their relationship.
I didn't even mind that there were some OP scenes in here. It did feel a bit sad or even wrong, but both of their new relationships were beautifully woven into the story. The author navigated the whole situation really well, considering that it isn't easy thing to do.
When Harlan went back to New York, I was actually nervous and excited. I was on the edge of my seat following how they dealt with the situation and seeing each other again.
The remaining 30-40% of the book didn't offer as much on an emotional level, but it was lovely to watch Harlan and Dare find their way back to each other and see how they rebuilt their relationship, first through friendship. The ending was perhaps a little rushed. Edit: The audiobook is missing the final chapter, but this should be fixed soon. Edit 2: Okay, I read that on Kindle, much better. I love the HEA for them🧡
This was a realistic portrayal of relationship, love, and how it can be broken but not necessarily lost forever. The plot and events moved along at a good pace. There were also well-developed supporting characters. For a debut, this was so good -I would definitely read more from this author.
🌇🌇🌇
”I can't be friends with you, sweetness. Not now. I already miss you. I feel like I'm missing a vital part of me, but I can't be that for you. I'm not mad at you. Perhaps that's one of my biggest downfalls. I can never stay angry with you. I'm so fucking hurt, though. I need to learn who I am without you. Being friends will feel like picking at a scab, so the wound doesn't heal. We both have to heal, baby.”
’I have nothing left that you haven't tainted. Everything that matters to me includes you. Your pillows don't smell like you and I hate that too. I can't look at a sunrise without crying. I wish I knew when this would get easier. It all feels so hopeless and dark right now. You took my heart with you, Harlan. I hate you. I love you. More than anything, I fucking miss you. Please come home. I can't do this without you.’
I was unsure about this book at the beginning. It had my anxiety high and I needed to finish. Cheating in books isn’t a hard limit for me. I just need a good story for how it’s resolved.
The way the book is written you go the journey with the characters and we were in the gutter for a minute.
What kept me invested is the characters felt real. They are complex and not perfect. They try to communicate effectively and they do. They also are self aware and continuously growing.
This book won’t be for everyone but it was for me.
Darí and Harlan are happily together for a few years when Harlan unexpectedly has to go back home due to issues with his work visa.
Harlan is so distraught and one drunken night he does the unthinkable and cheats on the love of his life. This book goes through their breakup and their reconciliation.
It’s heartbreaking and raw, life isn’t always perfect, decent people make horrible mistakes and this book does a great job of showing that.
I do think Harlan could have groveled a tad more for my taste but that’s just me.
Normally I'm not a fan of the cheathing trope, but I heard such good things about this book that I wanted to give it a try. And I am do happy I did.
It was messy, emotional and heartbreaking, but the ending was soooo worth it. Loved both main characters and their chemistry was insane. Beautifull story with a well deserved HEA.
❤️ Second change ❤️ MM romance ❤️ It was always you ❤️ Heartbreak and grief ❤️ Insane chemistry ❤️ Found family ❤️ Friendship
I don’t know how to explain how I feel about this book. Darío, sweet and lovely, perfect man: you deserve so much better. I’m sorry, but what Harlan did was unforgivable, and maybe I’m not a good person, but I honestly think that he didn’t suffer enough.
*Spoiler alert*
I wished that at least, he was the one pursuing Dare after everything. But no, he was living his best life with that Oliver guy. FTS.
This book took me back to having my heart broken for the first time and I literally felt every emotion! Highly Recommend reading the tw before reading because I can imagine this not being for everyone. Without going into much it was a hard read but it was also a sweet and spicy read too.. a second chance romance because they really were never gonna stay away from each other. A nice redemption and learning to become friends again before jumping back into to anything after such a betrayal of trust! Really enjoyed and my first read by this author… Quote** This is different. It feels like no matter what words I say, they will sound like goodbye. And how do you say goodbye to your heart? To your home? That’s what Dare is. My heart. My home.
The story felt so REAL. How imperfect us humans can be. The heartbreak, the guilt, the healing, and rebuilding was done so well 🥹 Its definitely a hard read and I know this trope isn’t for everyone but I recommend giving it a try. 🩷
I had the pleasure of reading this early and I can honestly say I think about these boys so often. A stunning debut novel 💙
Harlan and Dario are everything. They broke me and put me back together again.
There is cheating on page between Harlan and Dario- so know that going in! I never thought I would like reading cheating on page like this, but wow. The writing, the story, the characters. It was all so real and raw and set up the perfect redemption story. You could feel the self sabotaging tendencies through the page.
Both characters made mistakes and learned from them. There was no lying about what happened. And I think that’s huge.
Beautiful writing from MJ. I fell in love and was invested with these boys so fast. And the side characters are everything! *wink wink* I need the next book!
This story is unique to anything I’ve ever read before and that is special.
Did I think a book that included cheating would ever get a 5 star review from me? No. But this book is something special.
Anyone who knows me, know's that while I love the broken boys its always the men who love the broken boys who steal my heart. In this book, that was Dario. I read this on audio and let me tell you chapter 5 about broke me.
The capacity for love that Dario has even after such a painful betrayal is truly something we need more of in this world.
And what about Harlan? Harlan is a brat. He's spoiled. He's selfish. But you know what... he's human.
I found the reasons for Harlan cheating to be a little hard to understand but then I've never been in that situation. What I could fully understand though, is doing something in the moment knowing full well you are self sabotaging and doing it anyway.
He cheats because he feels like his world is falling apart, and he is out of control. In his mind, as far as I see it, he cheats because if he destroys his relationship himself, then he is in control of that and isn't the one left behind when, what he sees as the inevitable, happens.
Is this misguided? Yes. Is it selfish? Also, yes. Is it thoughtless, damaging, and hurtful? Yes, yes, and yes.
But show me a character who regrets his actions more. I'll wait.
I think Harlan has a lot of growth still to do... for example I think he is lucky that Dario loves him as much as he does because I would have made that boy work a lot harder. But the realness of their love, and the taking someone back even though you're scared, the doing something even though you know its not right... its all so human! We've all been there.
I think this book does a great job of exploring what happens after... and it doesn't shy away from the fact that yeah, after a break up people are angry. People self destruct. People start dating other people.
But it also does a great job of showing how working on yourself and being honest about how you feel can ultimately bring you back what was lost.
I loved this book, and the audio was such a treat.
This was a good read! Harlan and Dario definitely had to put in the work to find their way back to each other and it was nice to see that they both wanted to do what was necessary to better themselves. Neither of them were in the best of head spaces when they parted but as time went on they managed to find things that helped get them to betters places. They both had friends that cared about them and did their best to support them, they had work and even therapy. I liked seeing them relearn each other as the healthier versions of themselves. The cooking, mornings runs and holiday gatherings were sweet!
5 stars This is definitely one of the most beautiful second chance romances I've ever read so far!
Darìo, baseball player, lives in Brooklyn with his longtime boyfriend Harlan, a British lingerie model and designer, who’s been living in the States for 6 years.
Their relationship is solid, they love each other very deeply and have a tight group of friends who have become their family. Harlan also has a very good relationship with Darìo’s family, who love him unconditionally.
All is perfect until Harlan’s visa is revoked and he has to leave the States within a month. This unexpected problem cause a huge distress for both of them, but, while Darìo is ready to commit to a long distance relationship and to work hard to make things work, Harlan starts to spiral and to push his boyfriend away, until he takes the worst decision in history and cheats on him with a meaningless man in a club.
There’s literally no justification for what Harlan did: he had everyone on his side, from his boyfriend, to his siblings in law, to his bestie Penny and Aj and Jules (Darìo’s teammates and friends to them both), who were all ready to support him anyway he needed. And yet threw all away for nothing.
I really really appreciated that the author didn’t make any excuses for him nor did she try to blame the stress or Darìo. It was completely Harlan’s fault.
The aftermath is devastating and heartbreaking: Darìo’s feelings from disbelief to disappointment to rage and hurt were beautifully written, I could feel all his emotions and the literal crack of his heart.
The days and the first months after their break up are very hard and, again, the author didn’t spare us anything: Harlan is miserable and depressed in London, while Darìo is angry and heartbroken in New York. Neither of them is able to face the grief and the loss of their love.
There were a couple of moments where Harlan and Darìo could have reconnected, but I’m so very glad that the author gave them more time: they weren’t ready to be together and the additional long months were absolutely necessary for both of them to get better. Their journeys needed to be made separately.
During this long time apart, both Harlan and Dario have other relationships. I know that this will be a deal breaker for some readers, but I think that is what happens in everyday life, people break up and move on. Or try to.
I feel bad for Jasper and Oliver who were nice men and they tried hard to make their relationships work. But Harlan and Darìo were soulmates and even if they knew they couldn’t be together again, they still inevitably loved each other .
Their reconnection is perfect: slow, tentative, not rushed. They went back to the origins, when they were friends before lovers and were able to rebuild a life together.
If I should point out the only thing that bothered me a bit, I would address the fact that during their “goodbye” intercourse, neither of them thought of using condoms, they just went bare like they were used to. And I get that the risk of having caught some STDs for Harlan was very low, but the hookup was still a disruption of their dynamic, something external that inserted itself into their relationship and I feel like maybe Darìo would have needed that “barrier” between them.
The side characters of this story are all amazing and they all loved the two MCs very much. I loved that, while they acknowledged that what Harlan did was wrong, they didn’t forget him, but they all offered him support.
I also hope that the author will consider writing a story for Aj and Jules because those two are something else.
The epilogue is absolute perfection!
I’m so happy I got to read this book, a very fantastic read that I absolutely recommend.
I received an ARC of this book from The Author Agency and this is my honest review.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I never thought I'd say this, but I love a good cheating trope. Surprisingly, this is the first MM romance I've read where the couple cheats on each other rather than cheating to be together. And let me tell you...I struggled at certain points in the story. This book was painful in the best way.
Harlan and Dario shared such a beautiful relationship, and you could feel the depth of their love through the author's gorgeous storytelling. So when Harlan makes one incredibly selfish mistake, it absolutely wrecked me. Watching him wrestle with his regret while seeing the hurt he caused Dario was heartbreaking. Even through all of the pain, it was obvious these two never stopped loving each other. Dario just wasn't in a place where he could forgive Harlan yet, and honestly, I couldn't blame him.
Reading about each of them trying to move on with other people—especially what felt like so soon after their breakup—was like a knife to the heart. As difficult as it was to read, I think their time apart was exactly what they both needed. Harlan had to grow, heal, and learn to forgive himself, while Dario needed the space to truly understand the depth of what they had together and what he was risking by letting it go.
These two are the definition of soulmates—completely destined to find their way back to each other. When Harlan moved back to Brooklyn, I loved how naturally their second chance unfolded. There wasn't a grand, over-the-top reunion. Instead, it felt earned. They had both matured, especially Harlan, and it was clear they finally understood just how much they meant to one another. Watching Dario's family continue to love and support Harlan was incredibly heartwarming, and let's be honest...Craig the Corgi knew the entire time that Harlan belonged with Dario. 😉
I also adored the cast of friends and family surrounding them. The found family dynamic added so much warmth to an otherwise emotionally heavy story, and now I'm crossing my fingers that AJ and Julian get a book of their own someday! I will definitely be looking forward to more from this author.
If you're comfortable with the cheating trope and love emotionally angsty second-chance romances with soulmates, found family, and a hard-earned happily ever after, I would definitely recommend adding this one to your TBR.
Tropes: Cheating Second chance romance Lace and Lingerie Model/Baseball Player Soulmates Found family Emotional angst Breakup and reconciliation Healing and redemption "Right person, wrong time" Hard-earned HEA
This book was beautiful and raw and so painful but in the most satisfying ways. I knew from the start that I was going to have some trouble with this book as cheating is a big factor and catalyst in this book. Harlan's betrayal and the way it happened when he knows Dare is his soulmate gave me the ick and made me hate Harlan so much. Especially for someone he doesn't remember and that betrayal ran deep for Dare especially because trust is big for him as he was cheated on before and because the careers they both have that causes them to travel and be away from each other for periods of time. So to have that trust broken and reading it had me bawling throughout the whole book. But this book is also about time, healing and doing the work. Yes, Harlan messed up in the worst way but seeing what he went through and how deeply ashamed and guilty he was for hurting Dare and even wanting him to be happy and loved even if he wasn't the one doing it shows you how sorry he really is and that he'd NEVER make the same choices again. He hated himself for a long time but he pulled himself together and worked on himself and Dare did the same. Just because he ended things doesn't mean he wasn't still in love with Harlan because he was but he was so hurt and didn't think they could get past it at the time. Even when he tried to move on and date he only had Harlan in his heart. He didn't hate him and he forgave him but it isn't always that easy. I did hate and didn't really feel it was necessary to even have Oliver and Harlan be together let alone have to read intimate scenes between them which kind of put me off since the author didn't give Dare that right which he rightfully deserved so that ran a bit too long for me. But the author did an amazing job at both Dare and Harlan starting over as friends and building that foundation. But these two are soulmates and friends was never all they really were meant to be but they still took their time and put in the work with all the little things that make a life so big and full. Their journey back to each other was heartbreaking but so freaking beautiful too. This book also had some amazing supporting characters that really make a big difference for both men. I so hope this isn't the last we'll see of this crew.
My heart😭 This story was all kinds of painful. From their separation to the healing, it was such an emotional roller coaster.
Harlan was a lingerie model and designer who was living in New York on a visa. When his visa is denied, he’s forced to go back to England leaving not only his job behind but he’d also be leaving Darío, the man he loved.
Darío was a pro baseball player who loved Harlan with all his heart. Having to say goodbye to the love of his life was gonna to be the hardest thing he ever had to do.
Little did he know that saying goodbye wouldn’t be as painful as Harlan’s decision in a moment of grief and despair. That decision can only be classified as the most heartbreaking before and after to ever exist.
To say that I was angry, hurt and disappointed in Harlan is an understatement. But I also grieved with him and felt his pain and despair. I FELT his desperation to get Darío back. Knowing he lost him had me crying and hurting for him.
But I also felt Darío’s betrayal and anger for his world crumbling down. He had all the right to be angry and not want to be close to Harlan. After all, he never expected that from him.
Them being miserable and hurting was too much to bear. Knowing how much they loved each other but not being able to get past what happened was completely understandable but also frustrating.
Sometimes loving someone isn’t enough to forgive them, so I understood both points of view. But seeing them suffer was so hard and all I wanted was for them to make up.
It took some serious self forgiveness and healing for them both to find themselves together again. They both needed to grow as people in order to make things work for good.
In the end, they realized that their love for each other was stronger than the mistakes made. Darío knew that being without Harlan was more painful than his mistake. And Harlan knew that he would never do anything again that would hurt Darío in any way.
I can’t explain how my heart felt when they finally got back together. I cried tears of joy and felt so relieved that they were able to work things out. I’m seriously not cut out for this 😅 My poor heart can’t take all these emotional stress!
Wow, what can I say about this book? This is an amazing debut novel and the first I’ve read with cheating between the MCs. Cheating is always my favorite trope but most romance novels have one (or both) MC cheating with the other, not on the other. Sunrises and New Beginnings features the latter and it is one of the best cheating books I have read!
Harlan and Dario are very much in love, but Harlan makes a terrible choice on a day that he is emotionally devastated and alone. That choice breaks both Dario’s heart and his own and reverberates throughout the rest of the book.
If on-page cheating between MC or on-page sex with other characters (while the MCs are not together) is a hard line for you, then be aware that this book contains both. But if you are open minded to it, I would highly encourage you to pick up Sunrises and New Beginnings.
Cheating on can be a really tough trope to do well and this author has hit it out of the park. It was incredible how much care was given to each of the characters, and how she was able to take this difficult subject matter and make the reader love BOTH Harlan and Dario.
I always love a sassy, bratty MC, and Harlan (maybe surprisingly?) has launched himself into my list of all-time favorite MCs. I also love love love sweet Dario, but Harlan has my whole heart just as much as he has Dario’s.
I absolutely ACHED for both of these characters throughout the entire book. There was so much hurt, yearning, chemistry and love between them that it was palpable. They had such a hard journey away from each other and eventually back together again.
I liked that the author did not shy away from giving Harlan and Dario other intimate relationships while they were apart and healing from their break up. Those relationships were an important part of the healing process for both of them and without those other people in their lives, they may not have made it back to each other, especially Harlan.
This book also has amazing found family. I suspect that some of these side characters will ultimately get their own books, and I will be feral to read more from this author. Harlan and Dario have wonderfully supportive friends, who are there for both them during the darkest events and year of their lives. (And Craig was such an important part of Dario’s healing journey — iykyk 😉). They help them find their way out of the dark and start the healing process that both need to be able to move past what happened between them and come back together.
I don’t know that I have ever read a more satisfying reunion and HEA!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The way this book eviscerated my heart just to slowly weave its pieces back together is astonishing.
This is one of those books that sits in your heart and mind and pops back up over and over again. Which funny enough is how I even found it. It popped up on feeds a handful of time before I finally investigated on it. I’m not a trigger warning reader but when I was informed there was cheating I’m always hesitant but I never been more thankful I took the leap and dove in once it was released.
M.J. Silvio took a very real direction with this book. Harlan and Dario are so in love and ingrained into each other that you can’t help but truly break when they break. I had a cold sweat, tears, anxiety and laughs through this reading experience. It’s not often you find an author that can allow you to fill so lost in the dynamics of two character that you feel raw as you consume it.
Real life is hard, it’s scary and as a human a being you make mistakes that you can’t take back. Harlan loves life so loudly and is so authentically himself that when things fall apart it isn’t small but world shattering as he tries to pick up the pieces. Dario is this is strong protector that wants to love and care for his people with such a fierce passion and watching him fall apart was so real. Sometimes life happens and we hurt those we care about. It takes looking in the mirror and realizing we all have work we have to do to be our best selves. It takes hard conversation and circumstances to be able to grow and become someone we are proud of. And this book shows you that. As Dario says “You can do hard things” and love while being beautiful and wonderful is so hard.
Everyone should take a chance on this outstanding debut novel. It’s everything you didn’t even expect you’d need. With strong raw emotions you can feel these characters love wholly, fall apart and absolutely wrecked and realistically put themselves back together stronger, softer and with more love and devotion than ever.
To Dario and Harlan I hope everyone finds a love life theirs.
*ARC Review* Thank you to M.J. Sivilo for sending me a copy!
Intro: This book is an MM romance between Harlan, a designer and model for Lust&Lace and Dario, a baseball player
Tropes/Highlights: -Dual POV -MM -Open Door -Found Family -Second Chance -Hurt/Comfort -Cheating (Between MCs) -Lingerie Model/Baseball Player -HEA
Likes: -Set in Brooklyn NY -Established couple -Supportive friends -Well developed characters -Lace Jock straps, need I say more -Kasper & Oliver -Sweet family moments -Cute doggo -Thoughtful gifts -World building -Different settings -Emotional Turmoil -How deep their love is
Quotes: -"Jobs, the government, a fucking ocean–none of it matters–he's fucking mine" -"He has become my biggest cheerleader and he loves me so loudly and unapologetically that I often don't feel worthy of him" -"Leave it to the US government to ruin a good thing" -"You don't have to earn me, Harlan" -"I don't know how to love anyone else the way I love you" -"This way, you'll never miss another Brooklyn sunrise" -"I had fun, despite the pie homicide" -"You've no problem eating arse, but a turkey is your limit" -"That even at my worst, you still loved me through it" -"He's meant to be yours. He's meant to be ours."
This is the first book I have read from this author and I really liked it. I was hesitant to read about cheating, its not usually my thing, but Sivilo had a way of portraying it in a less harsh light. None of the MCs are malicious and at their core are such sweethearts. I loved the journey both MCs took and the rollercoaster of emotions that was this book. This book is filled with hurt, but has so much love to offer and I can see the beauty in Harlan and Dario's story. Please read the trigger warnings before you read, but if you are looking for a book about two characters devastated by one drunken mistake who overcome grief and life's obstacles, then this book is for you.