What do you think?
Rate this book
بحيرة القصائد الخمس
بعد اثني عشر عامًا، وفي بحيرة القصائد الخمس، لا تزال أجزاء من الشمس تختفي، ولا يزال الأشخاص يختفون ويموتون، ففي اللحظة التي انتحرت فيها سيدة حامل، تدفق النور من فم شخص متيّم بها واختفى.
بعد أيّام ازداد عدد الأشخاص الذين يتدفق النور من أفواهم ليحلّ محل رؤوسهم. وكثر السؤال عن الرابط بين اختفاء الأشخاص وتدفق النور من أفواه آخرين؟ هل الإخلاص هو السبب وراء الاختفاء أم الخيانة أم الطموح أم الحبّ أم التضحية أم أن هناك سببًا أكثر أهمية.
فهل لاختفاء الشمس علاقة باختفاء الأشخاص؟ أم أن الأشخاص يختفون من أجل حماية من يحبّون؟
بعد أيّام ازداد عدد الأشخاص الذين يتدفق النور من أفواهم ليحلّ محل رؤوسهم. وكثر السؤال عن الرابط بين اختفاء الأشخاص وتدفق النور من أفواه آخرين؟ هل الإخلاص هو السبب وراء الاختفاء أم الخيانة أم الطموح أم الحبّ أم التضحية أم أن هناك سببًا أكثر أهمية.
فهل لاختفاء الشمس علاقة باختفاء الأشخاص؟ أم أن الأشخاص يختفون من أجل حماية من يحبّون؟
280 pages, Paperback
First published August 5, 2025
59 people are currently reading
8449 people want to read
About the author
An Yu
10 books258 followersAn Yu (安於) was born and raised in Beijing, and spent parts of her life studying and working in London, New York, and Paris. She received her MFA from New York University and writes her fiction in English. She is the author of the novels Braised Pork (2020), Ghost Music (2022), and Sunbirth (2025). Her writing has also appeared in The Sunday Times Style, Freeman’s, Literary Hub, The Wall Street Journal, among other publications.
She currently lives in Hong Kong and teaches creative writing at City University Hong Kong.
She currently lives in Hong Kong and teaches creative writing at City University Hong Kong.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 201 reviews
June 23, 2025
My first An Yu novel and surely not my last! Thank you to Grove Atlantic for the early review copy. I was completely absorbed and compelled by this strange and thought-provoking story, exploring themes of hope, survival, family and home.
Five Poems Lake is an isolated community surrounded by desert, from which no one really leaves, and if they do they are never heard from again. The sun is disappearing sliver by sliver, and at a seemingly more rapid pace as of late. Our unnamed narrator lives in the family home behind their pharmacy from which she dispenses cures for ailments to the townspeople, while across town her elder sister works at a wellness spa providing treatments to the rich. As the sun continues to dim and the temperature drops, the community members adapt to their surroundings and go on living their lives. But as the sun reaches its end, strange events start to occur in which people's heads burst into their own miniature suns. These Beacons begin appearing all over town and draw a connection to the events surrounding the death of the the sisters' father a dozen year ago.
This was a beautifully written novel that explored the themes in this almost surreal setting. The characters developed slowly on the page and came to seem so realistic in their conflicting attitudes with each other and even at times within themselves.
This, at its heart, for me was a novel of paradoxes: of knowledge versus ignorance, of optimism and pessimism, the resignation towards fate versus free will, of empiricism versus superstition, and the collective mindset versus individualism.
There are no answers. This isn't a mystery that when solved reveals WHY but only WHAT and HOW. In the face of 'unprecedented times' (a phrase anyone alive for the last 5, 10, heck 30 years has heard enough) what do we do? Can we do anything? Is it worth trying to change or better to accept 'what is'? Sometimes even the desire for knowledge is presented as altruistic but is inherently selfish. We want to KNOW so badly about things we simply can never know, and in that struggle, that back and forth seeking to know, we miss what's right in front of us. It doesn't mean we don't try but only rethink how we go about it so as not to alienate ourselves from the things we need most. What those things are, ironically, are up for every individual to decide.
What I love about this story is how it can be interpreted in so many ways. These were only my thoughts that came about while reading this story. It's strange and enchanting and dark and surreal, and one that showcases a fine talent for crafting thematic and character driven stories with a unique flair.
Five Poems Lake is an isolated community surrounded by desert, from which no one really leaves, and if they do they are never heard from again. The sun is disappearing sliver by sliver, and at a seemingly more rapid pace as of late. Our unnamed narrator lives in the family home behind their pharmacy from which she dispenses cures for ailments to the townspeople, while across town her elder sister works at a wellness spa providing treatments to the rich. As the sun continues to dim and the temperature drops, the community members adapt to their surroundings and go on living their lives. But as the sun reaches its end, strange events start to occur in which people's heads burst into their own miniature suns. These Beacons begin appearing all over town and draw a connection to the events surrounding the death of the the sisters' father a dozen year ago.
This was a beautifully written novel that explored the themes in this almost surreal setting. The characters developed slowly on the page and came to seem so realistic in their conflicting attitudes with each other and even at times within themselves.
This, at its heart, for me was a novel of paradoxes: of knowledge versus ignorance, of optimism and pessimism, the resignation towards fate versus free will, of empiricism versus superstition, and the collective mindset versus individualism.
There are no answers. This isn't a mystery that when solved reveals WHY but only WHAT and HOW. In the face of 'unprecedented times' (a phrase anyone alive for the last 5, 10, heck 30 years has heard enough) what do we do? Can we do anything? Is it worth trying to change or better to accept 'what is'? Sometimes even the desire for knowledge is presented as altruistic but is inherently selfish. We want to KNOW so badly about things we simply can never know, and in that struggle, that back and forth seeking to know, we miss what's right in front of us. It doesn't mean we don't try but only rethink how we go about it so as not to alienate ourselves from the things we need most. What those things are, ironically, are up for every individual to decide.
What I love about this story is how it can be interpreted in so many ways. These were only my thoughts that came about while reading this story. It's strange and enchanting and dark and surreal, and one that showcases a fine talent for crafting thematic and character driven stories with a unique flair.
did-not-finish
November 3, 2025All my anticipated releases of August are letting me down. Sunbirth promises a dystopian setting where the sun is slow disappearing, but fails to build off the premise in any meaningful way. What one reader may call ambiguity could easily be coined as an utter lack of world building — we know the village is isolated from the rest of civilization, yet the citizens are able to be fully self sufficient. They somehow have fuel, livestock, imports and an independent economy that somehow, despite the sun going away, has survived the last dozen years without much issue. There’s still a thriving wellness industry and wealth differential between characters which also is not explained in any way.
I read the first 55% of this and felt no momentum or direction behind the plot. The characters are bland, the mystery doesn’t have high stakes, and the dystopian premise ultimately feels like an afterthought. It’s easy to explain away every narrative element as a symbol or metaphor, but there’s nothing for the reader to grab onto. It boils down to hopeful speculation and trying to assign meaning to a story devoid of anything concrete.
Admittedly the last 45% might offer some more intrigue, but based on the reviews I don’t think it’s personally worth me sticking around for. If you’ve finished this, you’re welcome to DM me and spoil the ending xoxo
I read the first 55% of this and felt no momentum or direction behind the plot. The characters are bland, the mystery doesn’t have high stakes, and the dystopian premise ultimately feels like an afterthought. It’s easy to explain away every narrative element as a symbol or metaphor, but there’s nothing for the reader to grab onto. It boils down to hopeful speculation and trying to assign meaning to a story devoid of anything concrete.
Admittedly the last 45% might offer some more intrigue, but based on the reviews I don’t think it’s personally worth me sticking around for. If you’ve finished this, you’re welcome to DM me and spoil the ending xoxo
August 6, 2025
I liked author An Yu's book "Ghost Music" quite a bit, and I really enjoyed this one, too. It was very strange, just the right amount of weird. Yu didn’t explain everything, but she also didn’t leave me frustrated and wanting answers at the end, either. The basic gist of the story is that for the last twelve years, the Sun has gradually been disappearing. Recently, this phenomenon has started to accelerate. The days are growing darker and colder. No one knows why, and now some people are turning into Beacons, meaning that their heads are replaced by balls of light. The description of how this transformation happened was pretty unsettling.
There were some pretty long chapters, but I didn't mind that since the writing was good. I was invested in the story and the mysteries that unfolded, and I loved the relationship between the two sisters. Yu writes excellent dialogue and beautiful prose. Reading this felt dreamlike and oddly cozy even though the actual story was kind of bleak and had some depressing moments. I thought it was so intriguing! I know this review is short, but I don't have a whole lot to say other than I liked it and I plan to read Yu's "Braised Pork" soon.
A few lovely passages:
“The familiarity of his voice was like the comfort of an orange light at night.”
“What a paradoxical state of existence we’re in, where our minds can stretch across dimensions, deep into reality and far into fiction, assign meaning to everything, yet our bodies are so small and limited that I can’t touch the roof of my room. Even a marble could kill us if it hit the right spot.”
“Perhaps we can only be whole when we can stop feeling responsible for another person’s happiness. Until then, we will continue to rip ourselves into shreds and give those shreds away in the name of love.”
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own and all quotes could have changed between my copy and the book's release.
4.5 stars. Just published on 8/5!
Biggest TW: Death of Family Member, Stalking/Harrassment, Suicide
There were some pretty long chapters, but I didn't mind that since the writing was good. I was invested in the story and the mysteries that unfolded, and I loved the relationship between the two sisters. Yu writes excellent dialogue and beautiful prose. Reading this felt dreamlike and oddly cozy even though the actual story was kind of bleak and had some depressing moments. I thought it was so intriguing! I know this review is short, but I don't have a whole lot to say other than I liked it and I plan to read Yu's "Braised Pork" soon.
A few lovely passages:
“The familiarity of his voice was like the comfort of an orange light at night.”
“What a paradoxical state of existence we’re in, where our minds can stretch across dimensions, deep into reality and far into fiction, assign meaning to everything, yet our bodies are so small and limited that I can’t touch the roof of my room. Even a marble could kill us if it hit the right spot.”
“Perhaps we can only be whole when we can stop feeling responsible for another person’s happiness. Until then, we will continue to rip ourselves into shreds and give those shreds away in the name of love.”
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own and all quotes could have changed between my copy and the book's release.
4.5 stars. Just published on 8/5!
Biggest TW: Death of Family Member, Stalking/Harrassment, Suicide
July 11, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.
In Sunbirth, the reader is drawn into a world quietly unraveling under the weight of an impossible reality: the sun is vanishing. Not in a sudden, apocalyptic burst, but in gradual, unnerving increments; 5%, then 10%, then 20%; until, inevitably, it disappears completely. It is this slow erosion of light, and the psychological toll it exacts on a town left to witness it, that gives the novel its haunting power.
What makes Sunbirth remarkable is not the scale of its premise but its restraint. There is no hero’s journey, no scientific solution, no divine intervention. The townspeople, trapped under a dimming sky, respond not with rebellion but with the quiet, desperate gestures of people trying to preserve normalcy against a tide of cosmic indifference. They adjust their lives each time the sun weakens—changing routines, revising rituals, hoping that order can withstand entropy. But as light recedes, so too does reason, structure, and cohesion. People panic. Some vanish. Those who leave the town are never heard from again, swallowed by an uncertainty more terrifying than death.
The novel’s metaphysical response to this disintegration comes in the form of the “beacons,” people who, in a desperate bid for meaning, choose to become suns themselves. These “sunbirths” burn brightly, briefly, and are never seen again. Whether their act is one of transcendence or annihilation remains unclear. But their emergence reveals something deeply human: a longing to reclaim agency in a world that denies it. In fearing immortality beneath a dying sky, they chase mortality as a kind of rebirth. The paradox is chilling: to seek light through burning.
The writing itself mirrors the novel’s emotional and philosophical terrain. It is poetic, even elegiac, but never overwrought. The prose moves with the rhythms of twilight; measured, melancholy, intimate. Magical realism is not an aesthetic flourish here but a natural expression of the story’s inner logic. The boundary between the magical and the real is fluid and seamless, evoking a world where the impossible is not questioned but absorbed into daily life.
Sunbirth does not offer closure. It does not promise renewal or redemption. Instead, it gives us something rarer: a quiet meditation on helplessness, on waiting for an end that cannot be avoided, and on the fragile, flickering ways people try to make sense of that darkness. In a literary landscape saturated with spectacle and salvation, Sunbirth dares to dwell in stillness, and that is its most luminous achievement.
In Sunbirth, the reader is drawn into a world quietly unraveling under the weight of an impossible reality: the sun is vanishing. Not in a sudden, apocalyptic burst, but in gradual, unnerving increments; 5%, then 10%, then 20%; until, inevitably, it disappears completely. It is this slow erosion of light, and the psychological toll it exacts on a town left to witness it, that gives the novel its haunting power.
What makes Sunbirth remarkable is not the scale of its premise but its restraint. There is no hero’s journey, no scientific solution, no divine intervention. The townspeople, trapped under a dimming sky, respond not with rebellion but with the quiet, desperate gestures of people trying to preserve normalcy against a tide of cosmic indifference. They adjust their lives each time the sun weakens—changing routines, revising rituals, hoping that order can withstand entropy. But as light recedes, so too does reason, structure, and cohesion. People panic. Some vanish. Those who leave the town are never heard from again, swallowed by an uncertainty more terrifying than death.
The novel’s metaphysical response to this disintegration comes in the form of the “beacons,” people who, in a desperate bid for meaning, choose to become suns themselves. These “sunbirths” burn brightly, briefly, and are never seen again. Whether their act is one of transcendence or annihilation remains unclear. But their emergence reveals something deeply human: a longing to reclaim agency in a world that denies it. In fearing immortality beneath a dying sky, they chase mortality as a kind of rebirth. The paradox is chilling: to seek light through burning.
The writing itself mirrors the novel’s emotional and philosophical terrain. It is poetic, even elegiac, but never overwrought. The prose moves with the rhythms of twilight; measured, melancholy, intimate. Magical realism is not an aesthetic flourish here but a natural expression of the story’s inner logic. The boundary between the magical and the real is fluid and seamless, evoking a world where the impossible is not questioned but absorbed into daily life.
Sunbirth does not offer closure. It does not promise renewal or redemption. Instead, it gives us something rarer: a quiet meditation on helplessness, on waiting for an end that cannot be avoided, and on the fragile, flickering ways people try to make sense of that darkness. In a literary landscape saturated with spectacle and salvation, Sunbirth dares to dwell in stillness, and that is its most luminous achievement.
August 15, 2025
Sunbirth is the story of Five Poems Lake and its inhabitants as the sun begins to disappear, leaving two sisters to wonder what will happen when the sun is gone and whether an old photograph of their late father holds the key to the mysterious beacons who begin to appear.
Sunbirth is a strange, surreal novel that explores the bonds of family along with trying to come to terms with death of self, family and world.
I found this book quite fascinating although the end seems to tail off into ambiguity and I wasn't clear on what message (other than family and home are important) I was supposed to glean from it.
The writing is good and it certainly kept my interest for most of the novel. The characters are all quite sympathetic, drawn with a very light touch.
It felt, by the end, that you were simply left to make your own mind up about what each significant event meant.
An interesting novel that would appeal to fans of Murakami or Kawakami.
Thanks to Netgalley and Vintage Digital for the advance review copy.
Sunbirth is a strange, surreal novel that explores the bonds of family along with trying to come to terms with death of self, family and world.
I found this book quite fascinating although the end seems to tail off into ambiguity and I wasn't clear on what message (other than family and home are important) I was supposed to glean from it.
The writing is good and it certainly kept my interest for most of the novel. The characters are all quite sympathetic, drawn with a very light touch.
It felt, by the end, that you were simply left to make your own mind up about what each significant event meant.
An interesting novel that would appeal to fans of Murakami or Kawakami.
Thanks to Netgalley and Vintage Digital for the advance review copy.
August 10, 2025
5/5 stars
‘Sometimes,’ I said, ‘goodbye isn’t something you say out loud.’
An Yu cemented her place in my list of official favourite authors with her third novel: a brilliantly lyrical, magical realist story of the lives of an isolated village community in the dimming light of a vanishing sun. Part quiet apocalypse, part deeply personal exploration of grief and longing; all together a masterpiece that I adored.
The Story:
“Of everything that had vanished over the past twelve years, I did not miss much. Five Poems Lake had been in decay long before the sun began to disappear.”
In Five Poems Lake, a small village surrounded by impenetrable deserts, the sun is slowly disappearing overhead. It started slowly, 12 years ago; a dragged-out apocalypse that has grown into disastrous shape incrementally. A young woman keeps one apprehensive eye on the sky above as she tends the pharmacy of traditional medicine that belonged to her great grandfather. Together with her last living relative -her sister-, she grieves the loss of her dad, who disappeared mysteriously twelve years ago. Their stories of grief and desire for illumination and enlightenment, join with those of the other town-inhabitants, against the backdrop of an ever-darkening world.
What I loved:
An Yu is a master of magical realism and quietly melancholic atmosphere. The small town of Five Poems, lit by the light of a dying sun, forms such a visceral backdrop to the personal stories that play out beneath it. Although this is by no means a horror-story, or even your typical apocalyptic tale, the image of this isolated twilight-town haunted by people spilling light from their open mouths is absolutely haunting in itself.
I have to admit that it took me a little bit to grasp what the author was going for with the metaphors, but once it clicked it felt its effects in my bones. When it comes to the true meaning: Yu leaves much up to interpretation, yet not for a lack of clarity on her part. Rather, she weaves so many themes into her narrative that all tie into each other, and make for a valid interpretation for the reader to pick from. She balances themes of grief, desire, generational secrets, the desire for answers and understanding (regardless of the pain to yourself and others this might cause), and a desperate search for legacy and the divine at the end of the world.
It creates a nesting-doll of small, intertwining apocalypses; the end of a life, the end of a community, and the ultimate isolation that brings, even when all of it is happening at the same time.
I want to highlight a single line, that to me perfectly encapsulates the meaning of the Beacons, and how they tie in to overwhelming grief and fear. It’s this line that made a lot of the story click for me, because I’ve felt this feeling before.
I just had to sit with that one for a little bit…
I can see how some readers might be frustrated by the ending. If you’re primarily focused on the mystery aspect (which clearly is there, but takes the backseat), you might not come away fully satisfied. Although some answers are found, there’s no clear climax or resolution to the things that truly matter. The story flickers out like a candle, not with a bang, but with a whimper. And frankly, I feel that’s the only way a story like this could have ended.
I highly recommend this book, specifically for fans of Emily St. John Mandel or An Yu’s previous works. Expect this one to make an reappearance on my favourites-list at the end of the year.
Many thanks to Grove Press for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
‘Sometimes,’ I said, ‘goodbye isn’t something you say out loud.’
An Yu cemented her place in my list of official favourite authors with her third novel: a brilliantly lyrical, magical realist story of the lives of an isolated village community in the dimming light of a vanishing sun. Part quiet apocalypse, part deeply personal exploration of grief and longing; all together a masterpiece that I adored.
The Story:
“Of everything that had vanished over the past twelve years, I did not miss much. Five Poems Lake had been in decay long before the sun began to disappear.”
In Five Poems Lake, a small village surrounded by impenetrable deserts, the sun is slowly disappearing overhead. It started slowly, 12 years ago; a dragged-out apocalypse that has grown into disastrous shape incrementally. A young woman keeps one apprehensive eye on the sky above as she tends the pharmacy of traditional medicine that belonged to her great grandfather. Together with her last living relative -her sister-, she grieves the loss of her dad, who disappeared mysteriously twelve years ago. Their stories of grief and desire for illumination and enlightenment, join with those of the other town-inhabitants, against the backdrop of an ever-darkening world.
What I loved:
An Yu is a master of magical realism and quietly melancholic atmosphere. The small town of Five Poems, lit by the light of a dying sun, forms such a visceral backdrop to the personal stories that play out beneath it. Although this is by no means a horror-story, or even your typical apocalyptic tale, the image of this isolated twilight-town haunted by people spilling light from their open mouths is absolutely haunting in itself.
I have to admit that it took me a little bit to grasp what the author was going for with the metaphors, but once it clicked it felt its effects in my bones. When it comes to the true meaning: Yu leaves much up to interpretation, yet not for a lack of clarity on her part. Rather, she weaves so many themes into her narrative that all tie into each other, and make for a valid interpretation for the reader to pick from. She balances themes of grief, desire, generational secrets, the desire for answers and understanding (regardless of the pain to yourself and others this might cause), and a desperate search for legacy and the divine at the end of the world.
It creates a nesting-doll of small, intertwining apocalypses; the end of a life, the end of a community, and the ultimate isolation that brings, even when all of it is happening at the same time.
I want to highlight a single line, that to me perfectly encapsulates the meaning of the Beacons, and how they tie in to overwhelming grief and fear. It’s this line that made a lot of the story click for me, because I’ve felt this feeling before.
I just had to sit with that one for a little bit…
I can see how some readers might be frustrated by the ending. If you’re primarily focused on the mystery aspect (which clearly is there, but takes the backseat), you might not come away fully satisfied. Although some answers are found, there’s no clear climax or resolution to the things that truly matter. The story flickers out like a candle, not with a bang, but with a whimper. And frankly, I feel that’s the only way a story like this could have ended.
I highly recommend this book, specifically for fans of Emily St. John Mandel or An Yu’s previous works. Expect this one to make an reappearance on my favourites-list at the end of the year.
Many thanks to Grove Press for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
May 1, 2025
2.0 ⭐
This book wasn't really for me but I can definitely see that it will be for others. I read and loved Ghost Music so I was really looking forward to Sunbirth, but unfortunately I found myself on the edge of DNFing the whole time and kind of wish I had.
Sunbirth is set in a fictional village near a lake called Five Poems Lake. Our main character is a pharmacist and her only other living relative is her older sister. Small pieces of the sun have been disappearing for 12 years a little at a time, until suddenly they are on the verge of the sun disappearing completely.
The prose is uncomplicated but beautiful - something I also loved about Ghost Music.
I love the premise of this story but just didn't find myself wanting to pick it up. I felt very disconnected from the characters and the plot and there wasn't really much driving us forward. It all felt very hopeless (which I realize is kind of the point), but I don't think I was in the headspace to appreciate it.
Maybe this would've worked better for me as an audiobook?
*Thank you to Grove Press and Netgalley for the free digital ARC in exchange for an honest review*
This book wasn't really for me but I can definitely see that it will be for others. I read and loved Ghost Music so I was really looking forward to Sunbirth, but unfortunately I found myself on the edge of DNFing the whole time and kind of wish I had.
Sunbirth is set in a fictional village near a lake called Five Poems Lake. Our main character is a pharmacist and her only other living relative is her older sister. Small pieces of the sun have been disappearing for 12 years a little at a time, until suddenly they are on the verge of the sun disappearing completely.
The prose is uncomplicated but beautiful - something I also loved about Ghost Music.
I love the premise of this story but just didn't find myself wanting to pick it up. I felt very disconnected from the characters and the plot and there wasn't really much driving us forward. It all felt very hopeless (which I realize is kind of the point), but I don't think I was in the headspace to appreciate it.
Maybe this would've worked better for me as an audiobook?
*Thank you to Grove Press and Netgalley for the free digital ARC in exchange for an honest review*
June 12, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley and Grove Atlantic for providing a free ARC of this book.
Sunbirth paints the picture of a world where over the course of a decade, piece by piece, the sun has been disappearing. Set in Five Poems Lake, cut off from the rest of the world by surrounding desert and circumstance, it follows the life of a young woman trying to run the pharmacy she inherited from her grandfather. Things take a turn when more of the sun disappears, and townspeople with lights for head start showing up.
The real strength of this novel is its premise and setting. An Yu adeptly and vividly describes the daily life of someone living through the mundane and yet inexplicable, the end of a world that's taking its sweet, sweet time. You get a look at people of all different creeds and walks of life, and how they've managed to cling to some level of normalcy - or not - when the sky itself is a constant reminder that nothing is the same.
Unfortunately, I don't think that the setting and premise of this book were utilized to anywhere near their potentials. This was a struggle for me to get through, and I was frankly bored for the majority of this novel. The pacing really struggled throughout - I would be begging for anything to happen for a long stretch, then a huge plot point would come out of nowhere, and then nothing impactful would happen for another long while. It felt to me that a lot of the interesting developments in the plot were left to the wayside to instead focus on inane conversations between one dimensional characters.
Character development was lacking throughout. As the overall situation gets worse, people do seem to change, but it's hard to get a sense of this since they didn't have much personality to begin with. Throughout the story, and even in flashbacks, people act erratically and in ways that seem to go against what was written about them previously. This could be seen as some commentary on human nature and reactions to otherworldly events, but to me it was just sloppy and jarring.
The biggest issue I had was that the plot of the disappearing sun really took a back seat to the relationship between the protagonist and her sister. I have no issue with exploring relationship dynamics like this, but given that the title, the cover, and the description all promised an intriguing mystery about the disappearing sun, I hoped that I would at least get that. Instead, there’s no rhyme or reason to the environmental catastrophe taking place, or the strange phenomenon of people with lights for heads. Nothing is explained, or even really hinted at, and the majority of questions asked throughout remain open and unsatisfied.
Some readers may find comfort in the descriptions of little parts of the day, or beauty in the dynamics of a relationship between two sisters who were both separated and brought closer by loss, or some interesting observations about the nature of humanity in desperation. At the end of Sunbirth, I was just left wanting.
Sunbirth paints the picture of a world where over the course of a decade, piece by piece, the sun has been disappearing. Set in Five Poems Lake, cut off from the rest of the world by surrounding desert and circumstance, it follows the life of a young woman trying to run the pharmacy she inherited from her grandfather. Things take a turn when more of the sun disappears, and townspeople with lights for head start showing up.
The real strength of this novel is its premise and setting. An Yu adeptly and vividly describes the daily life of someone living through the mundane and yet inexplicable, the end of a world that's taking its sweet, sweet time. You get a look at people of all different creeds and walks of life, and how they've managed to cling to some level of normalcy - or not - when the sky itself is a constant reminder that nothing is the same.
Unfortunately, I don't think that the setting and premise of this book were utilized to anywhere near their potentials. This was a struggle for me to get through, and I was frankly bored for the majority of this novel. The pacing really struggled throughout - I would be begging for anything to happen for a long stretch, then a huge plot point would come out of nowhere, and then nothing impactful would happen for another long while. It felt to me that a lot of the interesting developments in the plot were left to the wayside to instead focus on inane conversations between one dimensional characters.
Character development was lacking throughout. As the overall situation gets worse, people do seem to change, but it's hard to get a sense of this since they didn't have much personality to begin with. Throughout the story, and even in flashbacks, people act erratically and in ways that seem to go against what was written about them previously. This could be seen as some commentary on human nature and reactions to otherworldly events, but to me it was just sloppy and jarring.
The biggest issue I had was that the plot of the disappearing sun really took a back seat to the relationship between the protagonist and her sister. I have no issue with exploring relationship dynamics like this, but given that the title, the cover, and the description all promised an intriguing mystery about the disappearing sun, I hoped that I would at least get that. Instead, there’s no rhyme or reason to the environmental catastrophe taking place, or the strange phenomenon of people with lights for heads. Nothing is explained, or even really hinted at, and the majority of questions asked throughout remain open and unsatisfied.
Some readers may find comfort in the descriptions of little parts of the day, or beauty in the dynamics of a relationship between two sisters who were both separated and brought closer by loss, or some interesting observations about the nature of humanity in desperation. At the end of Sunbirth, I was just left wanting.
August 20, 2025
I hate to say I was so bored by this and I just “didn’t get it”.
November 25, 2025
My third novel by An Yu and out of the three this is definitely my favorite.
The novel's set-up is very intriguing. It is set in a city named Five Poems Lake, a place sort of detached from the outside world. Surrounded by a desert that people don't really know much about and are scared to cross, they eventually find themselves confronted with an unexplainable problem: slowly, parts of the sun start to disappear and there seems no discernable reason why. Additionally, some people start undergoing a bizarre transformation, which I don't want to spoil. All I will say is, that I loved the presentation of it all.
The main characters of the novel are two sisters, who own a pharmacy. They have lost their father, who was a police officer and whose death still remains a mystery to them. The relationship between the sisters is a huge part of the book, and is maybe even more the focus than the happenings in their environment.
One thing has to be mentioned: this is one of those books that is pretty open for interpretation. You won't get a satisfying explanation for everything, and if you hate that, I'd say this book is probably not for you. If you don't mind an open and slow plot and like to read a book with a more unusual setting, I highly recommend it. I loved the vibe and thought it was super cool and creative.
The novel's set-up is very intriguing. It is set in a city named Five Poems Lake, a place sort of detached from the outside world. Surrounded by a desert that people don't really know much about and are scared to cross, they eventually find themselves confronted with an unexplainable problem: slowly, parts of the sun start to disappear and there seems no discernable reason why. Additionally, some people start undergoing a bizarre transformation, which I don't want to spoil. All I will say is, that I loved the presentation of it all.
The main characters of the novel are two sisters, who own a pharmacy. They have lost their father, who was a police officer and whose death still remains a mystery to them. The relationship between the sisters is a huge part of the book, and is maybe even more the focus than the happenings in their environment.
One thing has to be mentioned: this is one of those books that is pretty open for interpretation. You won't get a satisfying explanation for everything, and if you hate that, I'd say this book is probably not for you. If you don't mind an open and slow plot and like to read a book with a more unusual setting, I highly recommend it. I loved the vibe and thought it was super cool and creative.
March 21, 2025
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC!
I have read An Yu’s two other novels (Braised Pork and Ghost Music) and I feel like with each book she’s getting better. Sunbirth blew me away. It is the right mix of atmospheric, surreal and fast-paced.
*
The sun is disappearing. Days are getting darker and colder, but nobody knows why the sun shrinks. There won’t be coming any help either. Beyond the city limits of Five Poems Lake is nothing but a vast, unforgiving desert. The few who dared to venture into it are never to be seen again.
The protagonist, a young pharmacist, tries to live her life under the disappearing sun as well as she manages to. One night, she gets attacked by one of her delivery drivers. Before the attack gets physical, the driver’s head turns into a miniature sun: a beacon. Scared and bewildered, the protagonist confides to her sister and a family friend, a young police officer who worked with her deceased father, who was also a police officer. As strange things keep on happening, she tries to find out the truth about her father’s death many years ago and how it might be connected to the beacons.
*
In her third novel, An Yu manages again to suck me into one of her strange worlds. The story heavily relies on the three dimensional characters and their relationships to each other, but is plot-driven at the same time, which is not an easy feat. The descent into surrealism is slow at first, but then accelerates. While sometimes surrealism seems to be a tool to appear “artistic”, this is not the case here. As proven with this and her two other novels, An Yu is a master of the surreal. It is playful at times, atmospheric at others, but always effortless. Yes, not everything is happening logically, but it moves with the narrative so fluidly that it becomes addictive.
*
Overall, I loved this book. Go read it!
I have read An Yu’s two other novels (Braised Pork and Ghost Music) and I feel like with each book she’s getting better. Sunbirth blew me away. It is the right mix of atmospheric, surreal and fast-paced.
*
The sun is disappearing. Days are getting darker and colder, but nobody knows why the sun shrinks. There won’t be coming any help either. Beyond the city limits of Five Poems Lake is nothing but a vast, unforgiving desert. The few who dared to venture into it are never to be seen again.
The protagonist, a young pharmacist, tries to live her life under the disappearing sun as well as she manages to. One night, she gets attacked by one of her delivery drivers. Before the attack gets physical, the driver’s head turns into a miniature sun: a beacon. Scared and bewildered, the protagonist confides to her sister and a family friend, a young police officer who worked with her deceased father, who was also a police officer. As strange things keep on happening, she tries to find out the truth about her father’s death many years ago and how it might be connected to the beacons.
*
In her third novel, An Yu manages again to suck me into one of her strange worlds. The story heavily relies on the three dimensional characters and their relationships to each other, but is plot-driven at the same time, which is not an easy feat. The descent into surrealism is slow at first, but then accelerates. While sometimes surrealism seems to be a tool to appear “artistic”, this is not the case here. As proven with this and her two other novels, An Yu is a master of the surreal. It is playful at times, atmospheric at others, but always effortless. Yes, not everything is happening logically, but it moves with the narrative so fluidly that it becomes addictive.
*
Overall, I loved this book. Go read it!
August 4, 2025
A very odd story but strangely compelling. I wasn’t sure if I overly liked the plot, but was drawn back by the prose and characters.
I wish there was a bit more world building and history. It seems kind of like a future earth with a large self sustaining community cut off from the world by desert surrounding the Lake District.
We never find out if there are others beyond the wasteland, and as the story progresses, it isn’t clear why the sun is disappearing, or why the Beacons are appearing.
By the end, I was still left with a lot of questions, but the mysteries kind of added to the story I suppose.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and Grove Atlantic for a copy!
I wish there was a bit more world building and history. It seems kind of like a future earth with a large self sustaining community cut off from the world by desert surrounding the Lake District.
We never find out if there are others beyond the wasteland, and as the story progresses, it isn’t clear why the sun is disappearing, or why the Beacons are appearing.
By the end, I was still left with a lot of questions, but the mysteries kind of added to the story I suppose.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and Grove Atlantic for a copy!
Read
March 28, 2025What a strange novel. Did I get a story of environmental collapse? Nope, but at one point, with all the disappearing sun and decay of the built environment, I thought I did. Did I get a story about a family and grief? Nope. But at one point, it certainly seemed like it was. Did I get a whodunnit? No, but there's a narrative thread dedicated to discovering the cause of death of one character. Did I get a bizarre, magical realist set-up? I did, but what it actually meant and what was its function in the novel remains a mystery to me. I'm very curious about other An Yu's novels now.
August 13, 2025
3.5-4 Stars, still thinking about it, but leaning towards the lower end. Very beautifully written, definitely more character driven although there were definite tense plot moments. Some plot points that were presented were lacking or underdeveloped in my opinion. I think maybe it would not have been as much of a disappointment towards the end for me if there wasn't so much tense escalating build up that disenchantingly to me, then fell short in the follow through. Definite strong themes of sibling relationships throughout the book, the importance of home and family, and the questioning of individualism vs socialism and our obligations to not just ourselves but to each other.
More thoughts to come!
More thoughts to come!
August 25, 2025
A strange and surreal that left me wondering what it all meant but at the same time I enjoyed the read. A town isolated and cut off from the rest of the world (although there’s no way of knowing if there is anything out there!). It has a lake and is surrounded by desert and people do try and leave by walking off into it. But the main weird thing happening is the sun is gradually disappearing and now some people’s heads are turning into beacons of light….
Yeah it’s weird but it also focuses on two sisters and their relationship, family and memories.
Yeah it’s weird but it also focuses on two sisters and their relationship, family and memories.
February 20, 2025
Thanks to the Publisher and NetGalley for the eARC.
In the small town of Five Poems Lake that nobody seems to be able to leave, the sun has been disappearing slowly for years. And now, as the sun is about to vanish completely, people’s heads all over town turn into miniature suns, leaving the human underneath some kind of mindless zombie. A young pharmacist and her sister have to figure out what to do and what their late father might have had to do with what is happening now.
What an interesting book! Where do I even begin? The story started out very slow, this was somehow helped by the very straight forward, almost plain but very deliberate writing style. Which also really fit the unnamed MC, in whose POV most of the story is told . It only picked up at around 40% when we were introduced to the girl’s father and what happened before he passed and what that might have had to do with what is happening in the story’s present. Then things started to happen in quick succession before we slow down for the last few pages and slightly abrupt, weirdly but delightfully hopeful end…
At no point while reading this did I have any idea what could be happening next, at no point did I feel like I knew this story and the characters. It was a ride! Very unique story with heavy themes of grief, sibling bonds, the connection of guilt and a sense of duty, environmentalism, home and identity… All well done, I thought, and with fresh thoughts on them.
I have to say, the sisters that raised each other, same same but different, and were not able to let each other go hit way too close to home for me.
I might not be sure what it all meant, what really was going on, but I enjoyed this book a lot. I loved the writing style, the subtle but effective world building and the human connections. There was no character I didn’t like and root for or whose motivations I did not understand. In a story where nothing is as expected, this is quite an accomplishment.
I might come back to this and edit after some more thought. Thought is needed.
In the small town of Five Poems Lake that nobody seems to be able to leave, the sun has been disappearing slowly for years. And now, as the sun is about to vanish completely, people’s heads all over town turn into miniature suns, leaving the human underneath some kind of mindless zombie. A young pharmacist and her sister have to figure out what to do and what their late father might have had to do with what is happening now.
What an interesting book! Where do I even begin? The story started out very slow, this was somehow helped by the very straight forward, almost plain but very deliberate writing style. Which also really fit the unnamed MC, in whose POV most of the story is told . It only picked up at around 40% when we were introduced to the girl’s father and what happened before he passed and what that might have had to do with what is happening in the story’s present. Then things started to happen in quick succession before we slow down for the last few pages and slightly abrupt, weirdly but delightfully hopeful end…
At no point while reading this did I have any idea what could be happening next, at no point did I feel like I knew this story and the characters. It was a ride! Very unique story with heavy themes of grief, sibling bonds, the connection of guilt and a sense of duty, environmentalism, home and identity… All well done, I thought, and with fresh thoughts on them.
I have to say, the sisters that raised each other, same same but different, and were not able to let each other go hit way too close to home for me.
I might not be sure what it all meant, what really was going on, but I enjoyed this book a lot. I loved the writing style, the subtle but effective world building and the human connections. There was no character I didn’t like and root for or whose motivations I did not understand. In a story where nothing is as expected, this is quite an accomplishment.
I might come back to this and edit after some more thought. Thought is needed.
March 27, 2025
First, thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the E-ARC. *5 STARS*
Let's get this out of the way: I adored this book so consider this review biased.
In SUNBIRTH, the residents of Five Poems Lake are really just trying to get by. Only, the Sun seemingly disappears overhead, and the already-inhospitable desert that isolates the village becomes a snowy wasteland. Residents grapple with realities like crop failure and plummeting temperatures with no choice but to continue on; work their jobs, go home. At the same time, our protagonist and her sister, Dong Ji, become entangled in the mystery that has unfolded in parallel (or contrast) to the disappearing sun: the emergence of "Beacons," people whose heads are overtaken by small, roaring blazes.
What unfolds is a multi-POV account that weaves past and present beautifully. The dynamic between sisters is convincing, and the love between them is so complicated, at times messy. The protagonist is almost painfully self-aware, and has the ability to see intense things with a great distance while experiencing them. This, in contrast to her strong-headed sister, creates a dynamic main cast full of small idiosyncrasies that feel like their own. Set against the backdrop of magical realism imagining of an apocalypse scenario, it is all very hypnotic.
The writing is just so great. Just really pared down and intentional use of language. The descriptions of light were just so luscious. I scribbled down so many quotes and took so many pictures of passages. Once the book is published, I will come back and share some favorites. Anyway, I am a huge fan of An Yu now, which gives me a couple more books to read!
Let's get this out of the way: I adored this book so consider this review biased.
In SUNBIRTH, the residents of Five Poems Lake are really just trying to get by. Only, the Sun seemingly disappears overhead, and the already-inhospitable desert that isolates the village becomes a snowy wasteland. Residents grapple with realities like crop failure and plummeting temperatures with no choice but to continue on; work their jobs, go home. At the same time, our protagonist and her sister, Dong Ji, become entangled in the mystery that has unfolded in parallel (or contrast) to the disappearing sun: the emergence of "Beacons," people whose heads are overtaken by small, roaring blazes.
What unfolds is a multi-POV account that weaves past and present beautifully. The dynamic between sisters is convincing, and the love between them is so complicated, at times messy. The protagonist is almost painfully self-aware, and has the ability to see intense things with a great distance while experiencing them. This, in contrast to her strong-headed sister, creates a dynamic main cast full of small idiosyncrasies that feel like their own. Set against the backdrop of magical realism imagining of an apocalypse scenario, it is all very hypnotic.
The writing is just so great. Just really pared down and intentional use of language. The descriptions of light were just so luscious. I scribbled down so many quotes and took so many pictures of passages. Once the book is published, I will come back and share some favorites. Anyway, I am a huge fan of An Yu now, which gives me a couple more books to read!
August 7, 2025
In the middle of the desert, in the desolate and indiscriminate town of Five Poems Lake, live two sisters of Chinese ancestry. Surrounded by sand and without roads out, the local people fear the looming threat of their sun’s complete disappearance. The first sliver vanished 12 years ago, and the residents do their best to continue resiliently living their normal lives, maybe to a fault.
But the younger sister, the unnamed main character narrating the novel (let’s call her 妹妹), recognizes the untenable belief that their future, livelihood, and perception of reality itself should not warrant more attention. Perhaps 妹妹, who runs her family’s pharmacy, demonstrates a particular care about the sun’s absence because the girls also mourn their Ba’s absence. Soon after the sun began to lose its wholeness, Dong Yiyao died unexpectedly, and his fellow police officers couldn’t figure out the cause (efficient cause) of his death in the lake. 10 at the time, 妹妹 remains inquisitive towards her respectable Ba’s and the sun’s life.
One evening, Driver Hua catches 妹妹 on the street and begins disputing with her. She’s trapped, and he’s over-served. When he intends to assault her, 妹妹 witnesses the most curious phenomenon: light pours out of Driver Hua, alighting his face, and his head becomes a sun. At first a random occurrence, soon more townsfolk transform into Beacons. Together, 妹妹, Dong Ji, and their long-time friend, Gao Shuang, try to solve the case concerning Dong Yiyao’s untimely death and how it’s linked to the Beacon activity. However, time may not be on their side; the increase in Beacons causes (material? final?) the sun’s decrease.
The gang eventually discovers that Dong Yiyao witnessed an emotionally distraught man and a girl seeking freedom transform into beacons 12 years ago. To protect his family and his people from this fate, Ba drowns in the lake with the beacon girl. But when 妹妹 and Dong Ji find the buried photograph Ba took of the beacon man, the idea resurfaces as well, and reality follows.
Sunbirth is a sci-fi, mysterious, and maybe dystopian sister story with perhaps more themes than I’ve been able to puzzle out. I limit my listed ruminations: (1) What does the sun (whole and partial) symbolize? (2) What’s the significance of one’s ties to home in the story (i.e., no roads out, no one who leaves returns)? (3) Are the ideas of transcendence and reincarnation in this world? (4) Does the author critique (a) our (the reader’s) stewardship of the environment or (b) how society can look away from dire circumstances?
I may have more questions than answers, even after finishing and sitting with the novel. But I appreciate the lingering uncertainty that Yu uses to keep readers’ attention. And, to keep the story approachable, the author smartly creates a likable character in 妹妹. The chapters written to give Dong Yiyao’s perspective caught me off guard; I wondered if there could’ve been a smoother way to insert the needed information he offers, such as through YeYe instead. I haven’t decided if the town’s arid setting stifles in a welcome way or not. I rate Sunbirth 3.5 stars.
My thanks to Grove Press and NetGalley for an ARC.
But the younger sister, the unnamed main character narrating the novel (let’s call her 妹妹), recognizes the untenable belief that their future, livelihood, and perception of reality itself should not warrant more attention. Perhaps 妹妹, who runs her family’s pharmacy, demonstrates a particular care about the sun’s absence because the girls also mourn their Ba’s absence. Soon after the sun began to lose its wholeness, Dong Yiyao died unexpectedly, and his fellow police officers couldn’t figure out the cause (efficient cause) of his death in the lake. 10 at the time, 妹妹 remains inquisitive towards her respectable Ba’s and the sun’s life.
One evening, Driver Hua catches 妹妹 on the street and begins disputing with her. She’s trapped, and he’s over-served. When he intends to assault her, 妹妹 witnesses the most curious phenomenon: light pours out of Driver Hua, alighting his face, and his head becomes a sun. At first a random occurrence, soon more townsfolk transform into Beacons. Together, 妹妹, Dong Ji, and their long-time friend, Gao Shuang, try to solve the case concerning Dong Yiyao’s untimely death and how it’s linked to the Beacon activity. However, time may not be on their side; the increase in Beacons causes (material? final?) the sun’s decrease.
The gang eventually discovers that Dong Yiyao witnessed an emotionally distraught man and a girl seeking freedom transform into beacons 12 years ago. To protect his family and his people from this fate, Ba drowns in the lake with the beacon girl. But when 妹妹 and Dong Ji find the buried photograph Ba took of the beacon man, the idea resurfaces as well, and reality follows.
Sunbirth is a sci-fi, mysterious, and maybe dystopian sister story with perhaps more themes than I’ve been able to puzzle out. I limit my listed ruminations: (1) What does the sun (whole and partial) symbolize? (2) What’s the significance of one’s ties to home in the story (i.e., no roads out, no one who leaves returns)? (3) Are the ideas of transcendence and reincarnation in this world? (4) Does the author critique (a) our (the reader’s) stewardship of the environment or (b) how society can look away from dire circumstances?
I may have more questions than answers, even after finishing and sitting with the novel. But I appreciate the lingering uncertainty that Yu uses to keep readers’ attention. And, to keep the story approachable, the author smartly creates a likable character in 妹妹. The chapters written to give Dong Yiyao’s perspective caught me off guard; I wondered if there could’ve been a smoother way to insert the needed information he offers, such as through YeYe instead. I haven’t decided if the town’s arid setting stifles in a welcome way or not. I rate Sunbirth 3.5 stars.
My thanks to Grove Press and NetGalley for an ARC.
October 30, 2025
I requested this book after reading a friend's rave review of his advanced copy and I am very glad that I was also able to read it. It is a compelling story of family and survival in a fictional town where the sun is slowly disappearing.
We follow two sisters who are adapting to the disappearance of the sun and the resulting temperature changes. While the sun was stable for about a decade, it is now rapidly disappearing again. Their town of Five Poems Lake is completely isolated from the rest of the world, surrounded by impenetrable deserts. Anyone who tries to leave completely disappears. As the sun shrinks more and more, strange things begin to happen around the town. Among the most strange is the appearance of the Beacons, people whose heads have been replaced by blinding lights. Our narrator and her sister try to learn to navigate this new world together. At the same time, the Beacons resurrect questions surrounding their father's death back when the sun first started to disappear.
The characters in this book was so richly developed. I felt like I really knew the two sisters by the end of this book, with all of their past and present complexities. The world that An Yu has built for them was also rich. Do not go into this book expecting answers about WHY the sun is disappearing. By the end of the story, you still do not know why, but that is not important. The story of the sisters' resilience is what is most important here. Through the metaphor of the disappearing sun, An Yu explores some of the very real changes happening in our own world. Though we are (hopefully) safe from the sun vanishing right now, there are other climate change issues that are very real. The sisters are a model for her to explore how we might react as humans to the unprecedented changes as they become more and more extreme.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and can't wait to read more by An Yu!
We follow two sisters who are adapting to the disappearance of the sun and the resulting temperature changes. While the sun was stable for about a decade, it is now rapidly disappearing again. Their town of Five Poems Lake is completely isolated from the rest of the world, surrounded by impenetrable deserts. Anyone who tries to leave completely disappears. As the sun shrinks more and more, strange things begin to happen around the town. Among the most strange is the appearance of the Beacons, people whose heads have been replaced by blinding lights. Our narrator and her sister try to learn to navigate this new world together. At the same time, the Beacons resurrect questions surrounding their father's death back when the sun first started to disappear.
The characters in this book was so richly developed. I felt like I really knew the two sisters by the end of this book, with all of their past and present complexities. The world that An Yu has built for them was also rich. Do not go into this book expecting answers about WHY the sun is disappearing. By the end of the story, you still do not know why, but that is not important. The story of the sisters' resilience is what is most important here. Through the metaphor of the disappearing sun, An Yu explores some of the very real changes happening in our own world. Though we are (hopefully) safe from the sun vanishing right now, there are other climate change issues that are very real. The sisters are a model for her to explore how we might react as humans to the unprecedented changes as they become more and more extreme.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and can't wait to read more by An Yu!
October 29, 2025
The sun is vanishing, and everything’s falling apart. Two sisters (one stuck in a dying pharmacy, the other working at a failing spa) try to survive as strange glowing people appear in town (their heads are made of light, like miniature suns). When they find an old photo, they begin to uncover what really happened to their father, and maybe the truth behind the fading sun.
Sunbirth is a quiet story about sisterhood, grief, and light disappearing in more ways than one. I found the story too quiet and slow for my taste. The dystopian/creepy elements felt more like devices for the writing and dialogue to explore allegories and allusions, but I tend to care more about those elements than about pretty writing.
In short, it was too slow for me. I didn’t find it very engaging or interesting, despite how creative the story was. Very pretty writing, if you’re into that. I’d recommend this to anyone who liked Memory Police or who enjoys Emily St John Mandel.
Sunbirth is a quiet story about sisterhood, grief, and light disappearing in more ways than one. I found the story too quiet and slow for my taste. The dystopian/creepy elements felt more like devices for the writing and dialogue to explore allegories and allusions, but I tend to care more about those elements than about pretty writing.
In short, it was too slow for me. I didn’t find it very engaging or interesting, despite how creative the story was. Very pretty writing, if you’re into that. I’d recommend this to anyone who liked Memory Police or who enjoys Emily St John Mandel.
November 11, 2025
actual rating: 4.5 stars 💫
August 7, 2025
Genre: Literary
Sub-genre:: Surrealism, Magical Realism
Rating: 4.5/5 (rounded to 5)
With its unfamiliar premise of the sun disappearing a fraction at a time, juxtaposed against the universal themes of sisterhood and family bonds, this sparse novel of 256 pages delivers a strange combination of a very powerful yet gentle reading.
Since An Yu's first novel (this is her third), I have been a fan. In my opinion, this is her best work till date, though I have immensely enjoyed her Braised Pork and Ghost Music as well.
All her works till now have been strongly rooted in magical realism and surrealism. This infuses an uncertainty or uniqueness to the plot as well as in the life of the protagonists, in An Yu's novels, which provides the impetus to the protagonist to steer through their existential crisis.
In Sunbirth, we meet two sisters—one runs a family apothecary and the other works at a massage centre. They live in a village called Five Poems Lake (what a beautiful name, right? There is a backstory for this nomenclature). It's not easy to leave this village. The sun is disappearing from their sky, one sliver at a time, at an uncertain speed and with it is receding the sustainability of life under this sky. This leads the novel towards the traces of a dystopia as well, but only mildly so. However, the author has more in store for her readers; the uncertainty in the lives of the sisters multiply as they tumble upon facts that hint at their father's involvement in the bizzare happenings of the town—which the readers will discover by and by.
What do we hold on to at the time of uncertainty? Hope for the future? Love? Family?
How is a family born?
Sunbirth will make a reader dwell on these questions.
For some readers, the ending may leave a bit wanting if their focus is more on the setting of the novel instead of on its emotional landscape. My take is that the speculative setting of this novel is not an end in itself but a means to navigate the emotional landscape of its characters and in that, the ending is perfect.
I am a huge fan of Haruki Murakami's works, and in An Yu's earlier works, I could see a lot of Murakami-esque elements; comparison with Murakami is almost inevitable when a novel embraces magical realism or surrealism to a heightened degree. Of course, this didn't not take away anything from the richness or the originality of An Yu's books or talent, but personally I have always been hoping that An Yu would ultimately create a niche COMPLETELY unique to herself in the realm of literature infused with magical realism and surrealism—because a very few can have such an easy yet skilful command on these genres, and she's one of those few. Sunbirth seems like a firm step towards An Yu's own niche of literature.
With the end of Sunbirth, now I await her next novel.
Let me end this review with gratitude to publisher Grove Press and Net Galley for the happiness that came my way in the shape of the early and free copy of Sunbirth they made available in exchange for a honest review. To be noted that this super-enthusaistic review of mine is unbiased and is a reflection of my reading experience and love for this author.
Q: Do I recommend Sunbirth to my fellow readers?
A: Yes! ❤️
Sub-genre:: Surrealism, Magical Realism
Rating: 4.5/5 (rounded to 5)
With its unfamiliar premise of the sun disappearing a fraction at a time, juxtaposed against the universal themes of sisterhood and family bonds, this sparse novel of 256 pages delivers a strange combination of a very powerful yet gentle reading.
Since An Yu's first novel (this is her third), I have been a fan. In my opinion, this is her best work till date, though I have immensely enjoyed her Braised Pork and Ghost Music as well.
All her works till now have been strongly rooted in magical realism and surrealism. This infuses an uncertainty or uniqueness to the plot as well as in the life of the protagonists, in An Yu's novels, which provides the impetus to the protagonist to steer through their existential crisis.
In Sunbirth, we meet two sisters—one runs a family apothecary and the other works at a massage centre. They live in a village called Five Poems Lake (what a beautiful name, right? There is a backstory for this nomenclature). It's not easy to leave this village. The sun is disappearing from their sky, one sliver at a time, at an uncertain speed and with it is receding the sustainability of life under this sky. This leads the novel towards the traces of a dystopia as well, but only mildly so. However, the author has more in store for her readers; the uncertainty in the lives of the sisters multiply as they tumble upon facts that hint at their father's involvement in the bizzare happenings of the town—which the readers will discover by and by.
What do we hold on to at the time of uncertainty? Hope for the future? Love? Family?
How is a family born?
Sunbirth will make a reader dwell on these questions.
For some readers, the ending may leave a bit wanting if their focus is more on the setting of the novel instead of on its emotional landscape. My take is that the speculative setting of this novel is not an end in itself but a means to navigate the emotional landscape of its characters and in that, the ending is perfect.
I am a huge fan of Haruki Murakami's works, and in An Yu's earlier works, I could see a lot of Murakami-esque elements; comparison with Murakami is almost inevitable when a novel embraces magical realism or surrealism to a heightened degree. Of course, this didn't not take away anything from the richness or the originality of An Yu's books or talent, but personally I have always been hoping that An Yu would ultimately create a niche COMPLETELY unique to herself in the realm of literature infused with magical realism and surrealism—because a very few can have such an easy yet skilful command on these genres, and she's one of those few. Sunbirth seems like a firm step towards An Yu's own niche of literature.
With the end of Sunbirth, now I await her next novel.
Let me end this review with gratitude to publisher Grove Press and Net Galley for the happiness that came my way in the shape of the early and free copy of Sunbirth they made available in exchange for a honest review. To be noted that this super-enthusaistic review of mine is unbiased and is a reflection of my reading experience and love for this author.
Q: Do I recommend Sunbirth to my fellow readers?
A: Yes! ❤️
February 15, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Grove Atlantic | Grove Press for providing me with the ARC.
For a book called Five Poems Lake you expect there to be some poetic writing, but it was so dry and mundane. The magical realism is so minimal, the characters had a little development, but not enough to keep me invested. I’m basically the most disappointed by the writing; it was a torture reading this. Endless conversations, dull and meaningless. I guess it’s a ME problem, I just don’t like that type of writing; the plot moves very slowly with a lot of fillers. I love a dystopian story, but just didn’t vibe with that one.
For a book called Five Poems Lake you expect there to be some poetic writing, but it was so dry and mundane. The magical realism is so minimal, the characters had a little development, but not enough to keep me invested. I’m basically the most disappointed by the writing; it was a torture reading this. Endless conversations, dull and meaningless. I guess it’s a ME problem, I just don’t like that type of writing; the plot moves very slowly with a lot of fillers. I love a dystopian story, but just didn’t vibe with that one.
March 27, 2025
3.5/5 stars.
Thank you to NetGalley for the arc! This book is pretty character driven, so if you're expecting a lot of action, maybe go elsewhere. The main thing that kept me from rating this book 4 stars are the plot holes and unanswered questions. I love ambiguous endings and questions in some books, but not when it's the important plot points that are not being addressed or explained. Rather than being left open to interpretation or things that can't be explained, these just felt like abandoned plot lines. The concept itself was pretty interesting though, and it kept my interest for the most part.
Thank you to NetGalley for the arc! This book is pretty character driven, so if you're expecting a lot of action, maybe go elsewhere. The main thing that kept me from rating this book 4 stars are the plot holes and unanswered questions. I love ambiguous endings and questions in some books, but not when it's the important plot points that are not being addressed or explained. Rather than being left open to interpretation or things that can't be explained, these just felt like abandoned plot lines. The concept itself was pretty interesting though, and it kept my interest for the most part.
dnf
August 2, 2025dnf p. 134
Thank you to Grove and NetGalley for providing me an eARC to review!
After enjoying Ghost Music more than I was expecting to, I was interested to pick up something else from the author and this really seemed up my alley. Unfortunately I just had a really hard time getting into it - the concept of the sun disappearing and how that affected the Earth and humanity was interesting, but I feel we didn't get enough out of it to keep that interest going.
Similarly with the Beacons - objectively a cool concept but I just didn't feel compelled to learn more about them. Everything felt like it was happening at a distance or in the background so I didn't feel connected enough to the characters or the events, and when we changed perspective to the father what interest I had pretty much completely dropped off.
I would maybe recommend to someone looking for a book that leans more literary/contemporary but with some dystopian elements informing the setting, otherwise it didn't quite live up to what I was hoping.
Thank you to Grove and NetGalley for providing me an eARC to review!
After enjoying Ghost Music more than I was expecting to, I was interested to pick up something else from the author and this really seemed up my alley. Unfortunately I just had a really hard time getting into it - the concept of the sun disappearing and how that affected the Earth and humanity was interesting, but I feel we didn't get enough out of it to keep that interest going.
Similarly with the Beacons - objectively a cool concept but I just didn't feel compelled to learn more about them. Everything felt like it was happening at a distance or in the background so I didn't feel connected enough to the characters or the events, and when we changed perspective to the father what interest I had pretty much completely dropped off.
I would maybe recommend to someone looking for a book that leans more literary/contemporary but with some dystopian elements informing the setting, otherwise it didn't quite live up to what I was hoping.
October 31, 2025
I loved this! A unique concept with just enough world-building.
August 26, 2025
Closer to literary magical realism than sci-fi, this is an interesting character study of people at the end of hope.
October 9, 2025
3.5 ⭐️
July 28, 2025
4.5 stars
August 6, 2025
I’m a sucker for speculative fiction with a sci-fi twist, and Sunbirth’s concept immediately hooked me. A world where the sun is slowly disappearing? Yep right up my alley.
An Yu absolutely nailed the atmospheric world-building here. Five Poems Lake becomes this haunting, almost living thing throughout the story. The sun, the mysterious Beacons, they all felt more real and interesting than the actual human characters, which is both impressive and kind of a problem.
Where this book lost me was in making me care about the people living through this whole situation. Despite the story focusing a lot on the two sisters and their family mystery, I just wasn’t that invested in it.
The pacing felt on and off, and while the book set up some really intriguing mysteries, the payoff didn’t quite hit the spot for me.
That said, the atmosphere alone is worth it. If you’re more into mood and concept than getting emotionally attached to characters, this will probably work way better for you than it did for me. Sometimes a really well-crafted world can carry a story even when the people in it don’t quite work.
An Yu absolutely nailed the atmospheric world-building here. Five Poems Lake becomes this haunting, almost living thing throughout the story. The sun, the mysterious Beacons, they all felt more real and interesting than the actual human characters, which is both impressive and kind of a problem.
Where this book lost me was in making me care about the people living through this whole situation. Despite the story focusing a lot on the two sisters and their family mystery, I just wasn’t that invested in it.
The pacing felt on and off, and while the book set up some really intriguing mysteries, the payoff didn’t quite hit the spot for me.
That said, the atmosphere alone is worth it. If you’re more into mood and concept than getting emotionally attached to characters, this will probably work way better for you than it did for me. Sometimes a really well-crafted world can carry a story even when the people in it don’t quite work.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 201 reviews