What do you think?
Rate this book
Descent into Darkness #3
The Shadow That Finds Us
The breathtaking third installment in the bestselling* found-fantasy series by BookTok sensation, Andy Darcy Theo.
Alexis, Blaise, Caeli and Demi return to the Haven, carrying scars both on the surface and beneath. Distrust mounts steadily, and the autumn equinox approaches, forcing them to confront the true nature of their destiny, before it’s too late and they are lost to the shadows forever.
Masterfully intertwines themes of mental health and the bonds of found familyFeaturing BookTok's favourite friends-to-lovers, love triangle, touch her and you dieFor readers aged 12+ and perfect for fans of Percy Jackson and Legendborn
PRAISE FOR THE SERIES
"Explosive, action packed and full of twists" - Bea Fitzgerald, author of Girl, Goddess, Queen
"Absolutely enchanting and nothing short of epic" - Bill Wood, author of Let's Split Up
"Truly thrilling" - Juno Dawson, author of Her Majesty's Royal Coven
"One of the freshest voices in YA literature, and one of the most vital” - Sasha Peyton Smith, author of The Rose Bargain
*Both The Light That Blinds Us and The Dark That Hides Us were instant bestsellers, debuting in the top 10 of the YA chart TCM
Alexis, Blaise, Caeli and Demi return to the Haven, carrying scars both on the surface and beneath. Distrust mounts steadily, and the autumn equinox approaches, forcing them to confront the true nature of their destiny, before it’s too late and they are lost to the shadows forever.
Masterfully intertwines themes of mental health and the bonds of found familyFeaturing BookTok's favourite friends-to-lovers, love triangle, touch her and you dieFor readers aged 12+ and perfect for fans of Percy Jackson and Legendborn
PRAISE FOR THE SERIES
"Explosive, action packed and full of twists" - Bea Fitzgerald, author of Girl, Goddess, Queen
"Absolutely enchanting and nothing short of epic" - Bill Wood, author of Let's Split Up
"Truly thrilling" - Juno Dawson, author of Her Majesty's Royal Coven
"One of the freshest voices in YA literature, and one of the most vital” - Sasha Peyton Smith, author of The Rose Bargain
*Both The Light That Blinds Us and The Dark That Hides Us were instant bestsellers, debuting in the top 10 of the YA chart TCM
- GenresFantasy
464 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 23, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews
June 7, 2026
In the author’s note Andy Darcy Theo alludes to the fact that this book may be his favourite and honestly to begin with I couldn’t see why. Oh boy oh boy was I a FOOL do ever doubt this man!
The portrayal of grief is so beautifully depicted, honest and raw. The journey of learning self-love and self-worth feels real and true even within this story of elemental magic. These two points alone make this book a 5⭐️ read.
But then we have the actual story and plot. The ups, the downs, every twist and turn, I had whiplash.
I felt every emotion under the sun while reading this book and can see why this would be Andy’s favourite, it’s mine too.
YA Fiction is my favourite genre and this series is a tip top example of why. I have rated every book in this series a 5⭐️ but this latest instalment was something else. Amazing work once again, 2027 can’t come soon enough
The portrayal of grief is so beautifully depicted, honest and raw. The journey of learning self-love and self-worth feels real and true even within this story of elemental magic. These two points alone make this book a 5⭐️ read.
But then we have the actual story and plot. The ups, the downs, every twist and turn, I had whiplash.
I felt every emotion under the sun while reading this book and can see why this would be Andy’s favourite, it’s mine too.
YA Fiction is my favourite genre and this series is a tip top example of why. I have rated every book in this series a 5⭐️ but this latest instalment was something else. Amazing work once again, 2027 can’t come soon enough
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 25, 2026
"There had only ever been the two sides of him: the one who dared to step into the light even if it blinded him, and the one who hid in the dark."
4.25⭐
Pheww this was an intense book, Andy did warn me and I still wasn't fully prepared. This installment picks up a few weeks after the solstice as they head into the autumn equinox, training is back on schedule and the four Elementals need to pick which focus their studies will take, fighter, scholar or healer. Mortem is defeated, The High Order are taking care of the remaining Shadowless and everything should be getting back to normal, right? Well, what if I told you they may have misunderstood the prophecy... The Shadow That Finds Us weaves together discussions about mental health, connection and found friendship, deals with tough subjects like grief, loss and trauma, and explores sexuality, disability and betrayal, all handled with empathy and care. These are exactly the type of books that young adults need, a mix of action, romance and important messaging. I thoroughly enjoyed this book, it really got into my feelings but I did find it didn't hold my focus at points, unfortunately.
I truly think Andy Darcy Theo's writing has improved in leaps and bounds as this series has progressed, the depth and intricacy of his prose and plotting are beautiful. His knowledge and care surrounding the character's personal issues, from Demi's trauma, to Caeli handling her new disability, to Blaise's abandonment fears, to Alexis's psychosis, is a real standout in this series. We explore the strength needed to get through these trials, but the writing doesn't shy away from touching on the toxic and problematic sides of this as well. With each of the characters having to grapple with the darkness inside of them and the ways this is poisoning their thoughts and feelings, it shows just how easy it can be for those thoughts to win but also that falling on hard and dark times doesn't define who you are as a person. There was a quote towards the end of the book:
I thought this was absolutely incredible! Getting yourself out of the darkness takes persistence, hard work and a lot of learning along the way, it's no easy task and can feel like you're battling a horde of shadow demons at times but it is absolutely worth it.
There was so much action packed into this book as well, and a lot of heartbreak too. We are thrown from one traumatic event to another and then back to relative normalcy again multiple times and the whiplash can be a bit shocking. I think this is where my focus slipped a bit. There is some steady build up throughout this book, and throughout this series so far, towards Alexis's basically losing himself to his psychosis but I think it is in the quiet moments where this should've stood out the most. Alexis notes that when he's in the Haven and around Incantus or the other Elementals, especially Demi, the Shadow Man becomes quieter but I would've really loved to see these dark thoughts poisoning more of the touching moments. We get a bit of this with Dr Dash and Incantus, and even with the four of them bickering constantly, but I think this could've been pushed ever further to really grip me as reader and have me on the edge of my seat truly doubting what is real and what isn't. Although I will say the last 25% of this book was very tense and just about made up for that small criticism!
Overall, I really love this series and if I had read it when I was younger I could see this being all consuming, I just think as an older reader that perhaps I am slightly more critical and want just a little bit more, which may tip this book too far out of the YA genre. I laughed and cried while reading this, though, so that always signals a good book to me, something that can make you feel is always going to be a winner for me and this book has that in spades. I also really related to Caeli a lot, as someone who realised they are bisexual later on in life, it was really poignant to watch her finding her identity and learning to accept herself, even when she was making mistakes along the way. I still think there is a bit too much "convenience" about how some of the things manage to be resolved, but honestly I'm having way to much fun with all the twists and turns in this series to even care about that. I cannot wait until book four comes out next year, and after those bombs dropped at the end of this book, I know we are in store for an absolute banger of a finale and I am so excited!
"We can't escape the shadow that finds us...But we can face it together."
4.25⭐
Pheww this was an intense book, Andy did warn me and I still wasn't fully prepared. This installment picks up a few weeks after the solstice as they head into the autumn equinox, training is back on schedule and the four Elementals need to pick which focus their studies will take, fighter, scholar or healer. Mortem is defeated, The High Order are taking care of the remaining Shadowless and everything should be getting back to normal, right? Well, what if I told you they may have misunderstood the prophecy... The Shadow That Finds Us weaves together discussions about mental health, connection and found friendship, deals with tough subjects like grief, loss and trauma, and explores sexuality, disability and betrayal, all handled with empathy and care. These are exactly the type of books that young adults need, a mix of action, romance and important messaging. I thoroughly enjoyed this book, it really got into my feelings but I did find it didn't hold my focus at points, unfortunately.
I truly think Andy Darcy Theo's writing has improved in leaps and bounds as this series has progressed, the depth and intricacy of his prose and plotting are beautiful. His knowledge and care surrounding the character's personal issues, from Demi's trauma, to Caeli handling her new disability, to Blaise's abandonment fears, to Alexis's psychosis, is a real standout in this series. We explore the strength needed to get through these trials, but the writing doesn't shy away from touching on the toxic and problematic sides of this as well. With each of the characters having to grapple with the darkness inside of them and the ways this is poisoning their thoughts and feelings, it shows just how easy it can be for those thoughts to win but also that falling on hard and dark times doesn't define who you are as a person. There was a quote towards the end of the book:
"He was a person with mental illness. A sufferer. A survivor.
But he was not weak.
Every day he got up and tried again. That made him a fighter.
Every day he chose to stay on the long road of recovery. That made him a healer.
And every day he learned that it was OK to falter, to lose his footing, so long as he figured out how to find it again. That made him a scholar.
It was something no shadow could take away from him.
Not anymore.
Not ever again."
I thought this was absolutely incredible! Getting yourself out of the darkness takes persistence, hard work and a lot of learning along the way, it's no easy task and can feel like you're battling a horde of shadow demons at times but it is absolutely worth it.
There was so much action packed into this book as well, and a lot of heartbreak too. We are thrown from one traumatic event to another and then back to relative normalcy again multiple times and the whiplash can be a bit shocking. I think this is where my focus slipped a bit. There is some steady build up throughout this book, and throughout this series so far, towards Alexis's basically losing himself to his psychosis but I think it is in the quiet moments where this should've stood out the most. Alexis notes that when he's in the Haven and around Incantus or the other Elementals, especially Demi, the Shadow Man becomes quieter but I would've really loved to see these dark thoughts poisoning more of the touching moments. We get a bit of this with Dr Dash and Incantus, and even with the four of them bickering constantly, but I think this could've been pushed ever further to really grip me as reader and have me on the edge of my seat truly doubting what is real and what isn't. Although I will say the last 25% of this book was very tense and just about made up for that small criticism!
Overall, I really love this series and if I had read it when I was younger I could see this being all consuming, I just think as an older reader that perhaps I am slightly more critical and want just a little bit more, which may tip this book too far out of the YA genre. I laughed and cried while reading this, though, so that always signals a good book to me, something that can make you feel is always going to be a winner for me and this book has that in spades. I also really related to Caeli a lot, as someone who realised they are bisexual later on in life, it was really poignant to watch her finding her identity and learning to accept herself, even when she was making mistakes along the way. I still think there is a bit too much "convenience" about how some of the things manage to be resolved, but honestly I'm having way to much fun with all the twists and turns in this series to even care about that. I cannot wait until book four comes out next year, and after those bombs dropped at the end of this book, I know we are in store for an absolute banger of a finale and I am so excited!
"We can't escape the shadow that finds us...But we can face it together."
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy
Wow. What to say? This is one of the strongest installments I've read in YA fiction, if not in fantasy in its entirety.
First off. Caeli. What a character. Her entire arc through this book from how she deals with when something about her drastically changes to the small moments that change who she is over time. Her learning curve and the way she has to search inward to find her true path forward. It's amazingly done and feels very realistic.
Alexis has his darkest moments yet which also reveals just how little both he and me as a reader actually knew about what had been going on in the two books preceeding this one. The darkness within him is stronger than ever throughout this story and it sometimes sent spine-chilling sensations through me; almost horror like at its core. The pillar of strength that Alexis is is slowly deteriorating under the immense pressure he experiences, and the way we see that in even the small details of this book is just so well done.
Although the rest of our main four, Demi and Blaise, have their 'page time' hewn down, it doesn't diminish their arcs in any way. We're still guided through many scenes where Andy does enough, and more, to make sure the characters remain round and don't fall flat. We see how the main four's relationships to different characters - and eachother, most of all - are put to the test. It brings forth the elements of loneliness and insecurities very well, when done like Andy has done it.
Beware the plottwists in this book though, it might give you whiplash with how many times you're taken by surprise.
Mental health struggles take the wheel in this story, which also means that the 'fantasy' element takes a backseat. But I don't mind that's the case. Andy still leaves ample words for both the world to unfold at a good, unrushed pace and there's still moments where the fantastical elements of the book have their time to flourish. Bear in mind that this is a YA book and therefore it's perfect when the world doesn't get too intricate and the magic too prominent. And if we circle back to the mental health aspect of the book I have to clarify how well written and true-to-life it is. As someone who have struggled with mental adversities I'd like you to trust me when I say how accurately depicted it is in this book. A subject like psychological health and stability can be a swing and a miss in some books. But Andy has hit a home run.
It's also important to note that this is a well written book with very accessible prose for most audiences.
All in all, if you're looking for something like Brandon Sanderson, Robin Hobb, John Gwynne and so on, you won't find it here. I hope you already knew that before thinking of buying this book, because it has never boasted that a story like that was what you were gonna get. This book is in the upper-echelon of YA, but only in small part because of the fantasy you will witness. The major reason why I think it's there is because it does something like we see in T.J. Klune's 'House on the Cerulean Sea'. It takes difficult themes that in some ways can be impossible to describe and weave it into the story - and characters - in a way that explains it better than an analysis or expository paragraph could ever do. You get to live vicariously through the characters WHILE reading about badass people with interesting superpowers in an even more captivating world. What is there not to like?
First off. Caeli. What a character. Her entire arc through this book from how she deals with when something about her drastically changes to the small moments that change who she is over time. Her learning curve and the way she has to search inward to find her true path forward. It's amazingly done and feels very realistic.
Alexis has his darkest moments yet which also reveals just how little both he and me as a reader actually knew about what had been going on in the two books preceeding this one. The darkness within him is stronger than ever throughout this story and it sometimes sent spine-chilling sensations through me; almost horror like at its core. The pillar of strength that Alexis is is slowly deteriorating under the immense pressure he experiences, and the way we see that in even the small details of this book is just so well done.
Although the rest of our main four, Demi and Blaise, have their 'page time' hewn down, it doesn't diminish their arcs in any way. We're still guided through many scenes where Andy does enough, and more, to make sure the characters remain round and don't fall flat. We see how the main four's relationships to different characters - and eachother, most of all - are put to the test. It brings forth the elements of loneliness and insecurities very well, when done like Andy has done it.
Beware the plottwists in this book though, it might give you whiplash with how many times you're taken by surprise.
Mental health struggles take the wheel in this story, which also means that the 'fantasy' element takes a backseat. But I don't mind that's the case. Andy still leaves ample words for both the world to unfold at a good, unrushed pace and there's still moments where the fantastical elements of the book have their time to flourish. Bear in mind that this is a YA book and therefore it's perfect when the world doesn't get too intricate and the magic too prominent. And if we circle back to the mental health aspect of the book I have to clarify how well written and true-to-life it is. As someone who have struggled with mental adversities I'd like you to trust me when I say how accurately depicted it is in this book. A subject like psychological health and stability can be a swing and a miss in some books. But Andy has hit a home run.
It's also important to note that this is a well written book with very accessible prose for most audiences.
All in all, if you're looking for something like Brandon Sanderson, Robin Hobb, John Gwynne and so on, you won't find it here. I hope you already knew that before thinking of buying this book, because it has never boasted that a story like that was what you were gonna get. This book is in the upper-echelon of YA, but only in small part because of the fantasy you will witness. The major reason why I think it's there is because it does something like we see in T.J. Klune's 'House on the Cerulean Sea'. It takes difficult themes that in some ways can be impossible to describe and weave it into the story - and characters - in a way that explains it better than an analysis or expository paragraph could ever do. You get to live vicariously through the characters WHILE reading about badass people with interesting superpowers in an even more captivating world. What is there not to like?
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I have been thrown across the wall, given a crazy amount of whiplash, a whole lot of swooning, then sobbed my eyes out, and shoved out the window.
The best book out of the three ✨️💕
First of all, I was given no hints or spoilers for this one so I was scared to bone with this one. All I knew was that Andy was ready to break hearts ( edit: and he in fact did! Start drafting those screaming, crying, and throwing up dm’s.) From the prologue to the very end of the book, I had constant whiplash! I was thrown against the wall, swooned off my feet, and then staring at the abyss.
I have said it again and will keep repeating myself but the pacing of the book is incredible. The way Andy navigates different types of grief, be it your past self, or even losing a loved one, was done with great sensitivity and with so much love and attention. I was in awe throughout, and everything hit so close to home. You can really tell the vulnerability of it all was intertwined within this book and will tug at every heartstring (I urge everyone to read the author's note!).
Caeli’s perspective was one that had me so emotional throughout and I well and truly felt for her. I just honestly wanted to give her a hug. The way her story has been written truly made me love her so much, and I love that we get to see a vulnerable side of hers while still being an absolute baddie. Her relationship, her friendship, and self love is truly tested and it's such a chaotic, emotional, and incredible journey.
Alexis’ story is darker than ever in this one and at one point it felt like a horror story! That Shadow-Man will forever be nightmare fuel (ngl, The Shadow Man voice lowkey felt like Joe Goldberg's inner monologues). However, my favourite sunset sluts rizz was to the max in this one. Like again, the quotes in this one are forehead tattoo worthy (Andy Darcy Theo the romance writer he is!). There were tons of smooth talking, heart racing, and grinning romance. I had to stop reading this book at work and on the train, because I could not hold in my reactions!
Talking about reactions, the amount of twists and turns in this one…you better buckle up because it's going to be one hell of a bumpy ride! I was shook to my very core with a lot of them and for the others I was straight up sobbing and staring at the ceiling, drafting my therapy bill. Andy (+editor), did not hold back on this one. Brutal I tell ya! Brutal! My heart was pounding throughout the book because I lost all trust in happiness, redemption, and light at the end of the tunnel, because when I tell you this book is dark it is DARK!
Overall, this book is a masterpiece and the favourite out of the three! I ate this book up and honestly, did not want it to end for a single second. I have said this before and say it again, these characters and the world feels like coming home, yes it's chaotic, therapy inducing, but what home isn't!? This book is a great deep dive in the dark psyche and navigating it while there are trials and tribulations meandering in their friendship, love, and mindset.
The best book out of the three ✨️💕
First of all, I was given no hints or spoilers for this one so I was scared to bone with this one. All I knew was that Andy was ready to break hearts ( edit: and he in fact did! Start drafting those screaming, crying, and throwing up dm’s.) From the prologue to the very end of the book, I had constant whiplash! I was thrown against the wall, swooned off my feet, and then staring at the abyss.
I have said it again and will keep repeating myself but the pacing of the book is incredible. The way Andy navigates different types of grief, be it your past self, or even losing a loved one, was done with great sensitivity and with so much love and attention. I was in awe throughout, and everything hit so close to home. You can really tell the vulnerability of it all was intertwined within this book and will tug at every heartstring (I urge everyone to read the author's note!).
Caeli’s perspective was one that had me so emotional throughout and I well and truly felt for her. I just honestly wanted to give her a hug. The way her story has been written truly made me love her so much, and I love that we get to see a vulnerable side of hers while still being an absolute baddie. Her relationship, her friendship, and self love is truly tested and it's such a chaotic, emotional, and incredible journey.
Alexis’ story is darker than ever in this one and at one point it felt like a horror story! That Shadow-Man will forever be nightmare fuel (ngl, The Shadow Man voice lowkey felt like Joe Goldberg's inner monologues). However, my favourite sunset sluts rizz was to the max in this one. Like again, the quotes in this one are forehead tattoo worthy (Andy Darcy Theo the romance writer he is!). There were tons of smooth talking, heart racing, and grinning romance. I had to stop reading this book at work and on the train, because I could not hold in my reactions!
Talking about reactions, the amount of twists and turns in this one…you better buckle up because it's going to be one hell of a bumpy ride! I was shook to my very core with a lot of them and for the others I was straight up sobbing and staring at the ceiling, drafting my therapy bill. Andy (+editor), did not hold back on this one. Brutal I tell ya! Brutal! My heart was pounding throughout the book because I lost all trust in happiness, redemption, and light at the end of the tunnel, because when I tell you this book is dark it is DARK!
Overall, this book is a masterpiece and the favourite out of the three! I ate this book up and honestly, did not want it to end for a single second. I have said this before and say it again, these characters and the world feels like coming home, yes it's chaotic, therapy inducing, but what home isn't!? This book is a great deep dive in the dark psyche and navigating it while there are trials and tribulations meandering in their friendship, love, and mindset.
June 24, 2026
The Shadow That Finds Us, No.3 in D.I.D Series by Andy Darcy Theo
With the third instalment, I wasn’t expecting realistic disability representation, even more intense mental health recognition and near enough SMUT??? But then again, you can never really tell with (tag here) and what masterful work you’ve to expect from him.
This one however, (yes I keep saying this with every book in the Descent Into Darkness series, and no I don’t care) has defo got to be my FAVOURITE. ADT incredulously gives us more into the look of Alexis, Demi, Caeli and Blaise’s lives as they’ve just vanquished Mortem (who, if we’re allowed favourite villains, is probably mine!) and now are left to deal with the shadows that were imprinted with.
The romance in this book was bloody ROMANCING. I especially loved Caeli in this book; her trying to come to terms and accept her newfound disabled body was something I majorly related to. Also, Alexis’s mental health struggles touched a nerve and at some parts, I thought I was being written about purely because ADT just gets it, like truly gets it without the wishy-washy commercialisation of everyday struggles.
Some of my reading notes include:
* Holy mother of Nature was that an opener! Wow! So dark and beautiful, it set the tone for how serious and epic this book is about to be. [edit: it REALLY WAS!]
* Incantus’s brother, Apex is a fresh, new storyline I’ve never read anything similar to (bar my inexperience in Fantasy unfortunately… but still!).
* THAT REVEAL WITH INCANTUS. AHHHHHHH-[this goes on for many sentences..]
But had to be limited as most of them consisted of swearing and repetitions of the same letters to AHHH!
I honestly cannot wait for the final instalment next year and am already falling into the pit of depression knowing that this universe is coming to its end 😭 I did however get overly excited and order a signed version (mine) and a version from Waterstones (also mine for now..). But didn’t realise that whilst I was in Neuro-Rehab, Theo’s agency sent out a book for me to review!! So ultimately: GIVEAWAY COMING SOON 👀
Written for ig: @brownfont ✨
With the third instalment, I wasn’t expecting realistic disability representation, even more intense mental health recognition and near enough SMUT??? But then again, you can never really tell with (tag here) and what masterful work you’ve to expect from him.
This one however, (yes I keep saying this with every book in the Descent Into Darkness series, and no I don’t care) has defo got to be my FAVOURITE. ADT incredulously gives us more into the look of Alexis, Demi, Caeli and Blaise’s lives as they’ve just vanquished Mortem (who, if we’re allowed favourite villains, is probably mine!) and now are left to deal with the shadows that were imprinted with.
The romance in this book was bloody ROMANCING. I especially loved Caeli in this book; her trying to come to terms and accept her newfound disabled body was something I majorly related to. Also, Alexis’s mental health struggles touched a nerve and at some parts, I thought I was being written about purely because ADT just gets it, like truly gets it without the wishy-washy commercialisation of everyday struggles.
Some of my reading notes include:
* Holy mother of Nature was that an opener! Wow! So dark and beautiful, it set the tone for how serious and epic this book is about to be. [edit: it REALLY WAS!]
* Incantus’s brother, Apex is a fresh, new storyline I’ve never read anything similar to (bar my inexperience in Fantasy unfortunately… but still!).
* THAT REVEAL WITH INCANTUS. AHHHHHHH-[this goes on for many sentences..]
But had to be limited as most of them consisted of swearing and repetitions of the same letters to AHHH!
I honestly cannot wait for the final instalment next year and am already falling into the pit of depression knowing that this universe is coming to its end 😭 I did however get overly excited and order a signed version (mine) and a version from Waterstones (also mine for now..). But didn’t realise that whilst I was in Neuro-Rehab, Theo’s agency sent out a book for me to review!! So ultimately: GIVEAWAY COMING SOON 👀
Written for ig: @brownfont ✨
June 2, 2026
This book has to be the worst form of bullying I've ever experienced 😭. It sent me into a state of emotional distress and that's only by reading about the characters going through their own.
Every chapter is so beautifully written and the hints throughout to the twists are perfect. I went on several rants about my theories and when you start talking to a fictional audience just to get your ideas out that's how you know a book truly has you hooked. I love it when you can work out a mystery for yourself without it being obvious and this book definitely delivered 😍.
So many parts had my hopes rising just to be devastated a moment later, specifically when it came to Alexis revealing the full return of his psychosis to his mother, only for her to get killed when he needed her most 😭 (still traumatised). As well as the autumn-equinox party reviving morale and joy just to end in full scale betrayal. (Neither were nice by the way, they had me distraught. Definitely not more than the characters though. They *suffered* this book 🥹).
Alexis' psychosis was so interesting to follow and I thought the way it was written was excellent in conveying his experience and emotions. I was rooting for him the whole time! Caeli's journey was intriguing as well, especially with Valentina (did not expect that), and the overall process of reclaiming her life was precious as well as heart-breaking.
I can't help but love the fight scenes, they're always gripping. Especially in this book when they're up against their friends and literal shadows, it just added an exhilarating twists to them. That's probably why part 4 is my favourite. But overall the entirety of the book had me entertained, rarely ever finding the content boring or dragging.
Can't wait to see how Jason becomes significant within the elemental world as well as Jackson's powers 👀. Hoping for the world to go easy on them is obviously too much to ask 😔.
Every chapter is so beautifully written and the hints throughout to the twists are perfect. I went on several rants about my theories and when you start talking to a fictional audience just to get your ideas out that's how you know a book truly has you hooked. I love it when you can work out a mystery for yourself without it being obvious and this book definitely delivered 😍.
So many parts had my hopes rising just to be devastated a moment later, specifically when it came to Alexis revealing the full return of his psychosis to his mother, only for her to get killed when he needed her most 😭 (still traumatised). As well as the autumn-equinox party reviving morale and joy just to end in full scale betrayal. (Neither were nice by the way, they had me distraught. Definitely not more than the characters though. They *suffered* this book 🥹).
Alexis' psychosis was so interesting to follow and I thought the way it was written was excellent in conveying his experience and emotions. I was rooting for him the whole time! Caeli's journey was intriguing as well, especially with Valentina (did not expect that), and the overall process of reclaiming her life was precious as well as heart-breaking.
I can't help but love the fight scenes, they're always gripping. Especially in this book when they're up against their friends and literal shadows, it just added an exhilarating twists to them. That's probably why part 4 is my favourite. But overall the entirety of the book had me entertained, rarely ever finding the content boring or dragging.
Can't wait to see how Jason becomes significant within the elemental world as well as Jackson's powers 👀. Hoping for the world to go easy on them is obviously too much to ask 😔.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy
This book is actually out in my country but on here it says it isn’t published. But anyways!
The Shadow That Finds Us was a fun, action-packed third book in the Children of the Elements series and I ate it up! We’re back with the familiar core four as they battle a darkness not just around them but in themselves.
One of my favourite parts of this novel was the exploration of Caeli’s character. Since this book was the one she co-starred in alongside Alexis, we got to read through her perspective and I think it added so much to the overall story. I felt like I was getting to know her better and I love when authors are able to do that with their characters. The talk not just about her disability but about her sexuality was really touching and Andy wrote and handled it so well. Kudos to him!
Another element I enjoyed was the deeper perspective we got on Alexis’s mental health. This book really shone a spotlight on his struggles. And as someone who has experienced disorders of the mind like him, I felt that kinship to him. I could sympathise with him and I was so invested in his emotional journey. I’m glad he found peace away from his darkness at the end, even if it’s only for a little while (judging by that epilogue. Give the man a break omg)
One criticism I have is that I feel the general ending was a little anticlimactic. As in, I expected something terrible to have happened to make way for the fourth and final book in the series, but it was relatively tamer than I had thought it would be. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing but I’m just wondering what the stakes will be in the fourth book and how they will be fit in to a single novel. Does that make sense? Not sure but again, this didn’t affect much of my view of this story! Still a banger, always a banger.
Can’t wait for the final book next year!
The Shadow That Finds Us was a fun, action-packed third book in the Children of the Elements series and I ate it up! We’re back with the familiar core four as they battle a darkness not just around them but in themselves.
One of my favourite parts of this novel was the exploration of Caeli’s character. Since this book was the one she co-starred in alongside Alexis, we got to read through her perspective and I think it added so much to the overall story. I felt like I was getting to know her better and I love when authors are able to do that with their characters. The talk not just about her disability but about her sexuality was really touching and Andy wrote and handled it so well. Kudos to him!
Another element I enjoyed was the deeper perspective we got on Alexis’s mental health. This book really shone a spotlight on his struggles. And as someone who has experienced disorders of the mind like him, I felt that kinship to him. I could sympathise with him and I was so invested in his emotional journey. I’m glad he found peace away from his darkness at the end, even if it’s only for a little while (judging by that epilogue. Give the man a break omg)
One criticism I have is that I feel the general ending was a little anticlimactic. As in, I expected something terrible to have happened to make way for the fourth and final book in the series, but it was relatively tamer than I had thought it would be. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing but I’m just wondering what the stakes will be in the fourth book and how they will be fit in to a single novel. Does that make sense? Not sure but again, this didn’t affect much of my view of this story! Still a banger, always a banger.
Can’t wait for the final book next year!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Alexis, Demi, Blaise & Caeli carry scars that run deeper than their skin. Upon retuning to the Haven as the Autumn Equinox approaches the 4 children of the Elements have to face their destiny. As the trust between them is steadily eroding they each need to confront their fears & one another otherwise the shadows will take over.
This was bloody explosive. Fast paced, action packed with enough twists to leave you with whiplash. I was here for it all.
The core four remain the heart of the story, the tension never eases, every chapter delivers a blow. Wether its moments of tenderness, emotional devastation or one of those whiplashing twists. The characters continue to be outstanding. I truly felt so much more vulnerabilities & rawness from each of them really drawing me in.
As per the other 2 books mental health representation is prominent, again relatable & makes the characters feel so much more real. My heart is on my sleeve for Alexis & his strength knows no bounds that much is obvious.
Theo was always going to break hearts with this installment & I was waiting for it but damn that tidal wave of emotion hit me like a ton of bricks. The navigation of coping with grief was incredible, dealt with, with such sensitivity.
One thing I know I haven't mentioned yet is how lyrical Theos writing is. It's accessible & breathtaking even simple descriptions feel vivid & emotional. Theo manages to write with such intensity that made me feel every fear, every loss but also every win.
This is an absolutely addictive series that I will rave about for a long time to come. A novel that explores deep human themes alongside a wild fantasy making it impossible to put down.
Thank you to Novel Tours, Simon & Schuster & the author for a copy of the book.
This was bloody explosive. Fast paced, action packed with enough twists to leave you with whiplash. I was here for it all.
The core four remain the heart of the story, the tension never eases, every chapter delivers a blow. Wether its moments of tenderness, emotional devastation or one of those whiplashing twists. The characters continue to be outstanding. I truly felt so much more vulnerabilities & rawness from each of them really drawing me in.
As per the other 2 books mental health representation is prominent, again relatable & makes the characters feel so much more real. My heart is on my sleeve for Alexis & his strength knows no bounds that much is obvious.
Theo was always going to break hearts with this installment & I was waiting for it but damn that tidal wave of emotion hit me like a ton of bricks. The navigation of coping with grief was incredible, dealt with, with such sensitivity.
One thing I know I haven't mentioned yet is how lyrical Theos writing is. It's accessible & breathtaking even simple descriptions feel vivid & emotional. Theo manages to write with such intensity that made me feel every fear, every loss but also every win.
This is an absolutely addictive series that I will rave about for a long time to come. A novel that explores deep human themes alongside a wild fantasy making it impossible to put down.
Thank you to Novel Tours, Simon & Schuster & the author for a copy of the book.
June 23, 2026
The Shadow That Finds us is the third instalment to this amazing series. I absolutely adore Andy Darcy Theo's writing as his story is very character driven and this is one of the strongest elements in it. Alexis, Blaise, Caeli, and Demi return to the Haven carrying visible and invisible scars, and Andy Darcy Theo writes them with a tenderness that feels incredibly genuine. The story balances magic, mythology and mental health. The characters aren’t magically “fixed” by adventure or friendship; instead, they navigate fear, distrust, and grief in ways that feel painfully real. Their bond is messy and imperfect, but it’s also the thing that keeps pulling them back from the edge. The found‑family dynamic is easily the heart of the book.
The magic system continues to expand in interesting ways, and the world feels richer and more lived in than before. The magic system evolves alongside the characters. The series has always blended supernatural power with emotional and psychological depth, but this book pushes that connection even further. Each ability reflects the wielder’s internal struggles, fears, and strengths, which makes every spell or surge of power feel meaningful.
I cannot wait for book 4 as this series has me addicted. As a huge fan of Percy Jackson, I can see elements of where themes of that books are influenced from that franchise, so if you are anything like me and loved that franchise then you MUST read this one.
Thank you so much to Novel Tours for gifting me a copy of the book in exchange for a review and to the author for writing a brilliant story that had me up until silly o'clock, gripped to the end.
The magic system continues to expand in interesting ways, and the world feels richer and more lived in than before. The magic system evolves alongside the characters. The series has always blended supernatural power with emotional and psychological depth, but this book pushes that connection even further. Each ability reflects the wielder’s internal struggles, fears, and strengths, which makes every spell or surge of power feel meaningful.
I cannot wait for book 4 as this series has me addicted. As a huge fan of Percy Jackson, I can see elements of where themes of that books are influenced from that franchise, so if you are anything like me and loved that franchise then you MUST read this one.
Thank you so much to Novel Tours for gifting me a copy of the book in exchange for a review and to the author for writing a brilliant story that had me up until silly o'clock, gripped to the end.
June 25, 2026
🌊 🌱 🔥 🌪️
“Grief is nothing if not an artefact of love. It exists to remind us how deeply we can love. Despite what comes at us, shadow, darkness, death, it can never take away what makes us human. So keep your head up, Alexis, because you won’t find any angels on the ground.”
Before this book was published, I tried so hard to convince Andy to keep all these characters safe and let them be happy. Well, knowing him, he did the exact opposite. I thought I was prepared. He had in fact warned me before but somehow I still hadn’t learned my lesson there. This book was so emotionally devastating, Andy really knows how to torment the characters and us 💔
I devoured this book in less than two days as I stayed up all night reading this. This book made me cry and sob (thank you very much Andy), but it also made me smile and laugh at times. The way this story represented mental health, grief and disability and coping with it all was nothing but incredible. I’ve said this before, but the way he writes, his talent, it will be something I’ll ALWAYS be admiring 🥹
Every time I thought I had some kind of idea what was going to happen, a twist came and left me just gasping for air. Let me tell you, this happened more than once.
The way we got to know Caeli more, it was everything 🩶 I found so many similarities between Caeli and me, and that was one reason this book felt so personal. While The Light That Blinds Us holds the place of the most important book for me, this was the best one so far! 🙌🏼
Review of advance copy
An absolute unbelievable third instalment to the Descent into Darkness series. This book ramps up the emotions and action even further--you thought that might not be possible, but it truly is.
This book resonates with me on a personal level. As a sufferer and survivor of depression, I read this with tears in my eyes because I finally felt seen. Felt understood. The grieving, the love, the friendship, the family echoed my own life, and I truly appreciate how difficult it must've been to write. Also, huge admiration for writing a main character with a limb difference (which my brother has). The reflections of this book may not be the same for everyone, but for me it was truly remarkable to have a life similar to my own written on paper. And for those who do not suffer or understand depression, I truly hope reading this series aids you to understand the illness better, to guide us and not hate us for our own mind attacking us.
Andy, your writing is constantly magnetic, and my heart was consistently in my mouth. Twists and turns endlessly throughout, my mind is STILL reeling and will be for another year until I get my hands on the final book in this series! I can't wait for the conclusion and to see where these characters end up (HOPEFULLY HAPPILY, OR THERE WILL BE WORDS HAD!!!)
And remember to keep your head up, you won't find any angels on the ground 😉
This book resonates with me on a personal level. As a sufferer and survivor of depression, I read this with tears in my eyes because I finally felt seen. Felt understood. The grieving, the love, the friendship, the family echoed my own life, and I truly appreciate how difficult it must've been to write. Also, huge admiration for writing a main character with a limb difference (which my brother has). The reflections of this book may not be the same for everyone, but for me it was truly remarkable to have a life similar to my own written on paper. And for those who do not suffer or understand depression, I truly hope reading this series aids you to understand the illness better, to guide us and not hate us for our own mind attacking us.
Andy, your writing is constantly magnetic, and my heart was consistently in my mouth. Twists and turns endlessly throughout, my mind is STILL reeling and will be for another year until I get my hands on the final book in this series! I can't wait for the conclusion and to see where these characters end up (HOPEFULLY HAPPILY, OR THERE WILL BE WORDS HAD!!!)
And remember to keep your head up, you won't find any angels on the ground 😉
Review of advance copy
I thought the previous book was fab, but this one is even better!! The amount of emotions, tension and whiplash from plot twists in this was mental!
I wont lie, Caeli isn't my favourite character so I wasn't sure how I'd get on with her narration in this but because it is so balanced between her and Alexis's narration, I actually really enjoyed it. I liked finding out more about Caeli's story and seeing her character development through this book alone was really good and did make soften towards her and understand her character more.
Alexis went through his darkest time yet in this book and it shocked me because I really thought us as readers knew everything about Alexis so I enjoyed how actually things were much worse than we were lead to believe. It was unexpected and thats what I liked.
There was just so much happening in this book; fantastic fight scenes, great self-discovery, friendship, love, sadness and hope, tension, drama and adventure. Literally not a single second of dullness and I cannot think of anything negative to say. Now to patiently (read: impatiently) wait for the next in the series!
I wont lie, Caeli isn't my favourite character so I wasn't sure how I'd get on with her narration in this but because it is so balanced between her and Alexis's narration, I actually really enjoyed it. I liked finding out more about Caeli's story and seeing her character development through this book alone was really good and did make soften towards her and understand her character more.
Alexis went through his darkest time yet in this book and it shocked me because I really thought us as readers knew everything about Alexis so I enjoyed how actually things were much worse than we were lead to believe. It was unexpected and thats what I liked.
There was just so much happening in this book; fantastic fight scenes, great self-discovery, friendship, love, sadness and hope, tension, drama and adventure. Literally not a single second of dullness and I cannot think of anything negative to say. Now to patiently (read: impatiently) wait for the next in the series!
June 19, 2026
🖤 Found Family
⚔️ High Stakes Fantasy
🌙 Slow Burn Romance
💔 Heartbreak
🫂 Ride or Die Friendships
🔥 Emotional Damage
✨ Character Growth
I swear this series has a permanent hold on me.
Every time I think Andy Darcy Theo can’t possibly raise the bar any higher, another book proves me wrong. The Shadow That Finds Us had me completely hooked from start to finish. I laughed, I stressed, I got emotional, and I spent a ridiculous amount of time yelling at fictional characters because I care about them so much.
What keeps me coming back to this series is the characters. Their relationships feel so genuine, and every book makes me even more attached to them. The emotional moments hit hard, the stakes feel real, and the character growth is everything I want from a fantasy series.
And the plot? Absolutely addictive. Every time I thought I knew where things were going, something happened that had me needing “just one more chapter” especially immersive reading it.
This series has become one of my all time favourites, and The Shadow That Finds Us might honestly be my favourite instalment yet. I’m obsessed with this world, obsessed with these characters, and already desperate for the next book.
If you’re not reading this series yet, consider this your sign.
⭐️ 5/5 another book added to the list of stories I will never stop thinking about.
⚔️ High Stakes Fantasy
🌙 Slow Burn Romance
💔 Heartbreak
🫂 Ride or Die Friendships
🔥 Emotional Damage
✨ Character Growth
I swear this series has a permanent hold on me.
Every time I think Andy Darcy Theo can’t possibly raise the bar any higher, another book proves me wrong. The Shadow That Finds Us had me completely hooked from start to finish. I laughed, I stressed, I got emotional, and I spent a ridiculous amount of time yelling at fictional characters because I care about them so much.
What keeps me coming back to this series is the characters. Their relationships feel so genuine, and every book makes me even more attached to them. The emotional moments hit hard, the stakes feel real, and the character growth is everything I want from a fantasy series.
And the plot? Absolutely addictive. Every time I thought I knew where things were going, something happened that had me needing “just one more chapter” especially immersive reading it.
This series has become one of my all time favourites, and The Shadow That Finds Us might honestly be my favourite instalment yet. I’m obsessed with this world, obsessed with these characters, and already desperate for the next book.
If you’re not reading this series yet, consider this your sign.
⭐️ 5/5 another book added to the list of stories I will never stop thinking about.
June 16, 2026
4.5⭐
1🌶️ (some tension, kissing and suggestions of things)
This is definitely my favourite from the series so far, I felt like it slowed down a bit, gave things the attention they deserved more than the previous books.
I loved the development we saw of the characters coming face to face with their deepest fears and how real life illnesses and issues were woven into the world respectfully but weren't sugar coated.
The relationships were definitely further explored in this book too, however I am sad to see my favourite couple not being together (yes I know they were a bit toxic and clashed but they had more passion that I think got me)
There were still a few things I wish to have seen a bit more of, like training, just to make things a bit more cohesive. They seem to just become naturals at things quite quickly rather than seeing them struggle with their powers.
I have enjoyed the little twists and unexpected things pop up in this book like the last ones, it has definitely set up the next book very well and I can't wait to see how it concludes!
1🌶️ (some tension, kissing and suggestions of things)
This is definitely my favourite from the series so far, I felt like it slowed down a bit, gave things the attention they deserved more than the previous books.
I loved the development we saw of the characters coming face to face with their deepest fears and how real life illnesses and issues were woven into the world respectfully but weren't sugar coated.
The relationships were definitely further explored in this book too, however I am sad to see my favourite couple not being together (yes I know they were a bit toxic and clashed but they had more passion that I think got me)
There were still a few things I wish to have seen a bit more of, like training, just to make things a bit more cohesive. They seem to just become naturals at things quite quickly rather than seeing them struggle with their powers.
I have enjoyed the little twists and unexpected things pop up in this book like the last ones, it has definitely set up the next book very well and I can't wait to see how it concludes!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 21, 2026
This is one of those series that gets better with every installment! A group of young people discover their fate, their Elemental powers and that they're also a part of a larger Prophecy against the dark.
There is definitely a darker feel to the latest book, which I loved and this was needed after the epic battles of book 2. Andy has a fantastic way of broaching difficult subjects such as psychosis and questions around sexuality and I felt this was done incredibly well within this book, The Shadow That Finds Us.
I loved seeing the relationships develop with the foursome and all the side characters! I also love that no-one is safe, Andy is definitely not afraid to tug those heartstrings!
If you love YA with Prophecy and Elemental magic then you will love this!
I'm really looking forward to book 4 now!!
There is definitely a darker feel to the latest book, which I loved and this was needed after the epic battles of book 2. Andy has a fantastic way of broaching difficult subjects such as psychosis and questions around sexuality and I felt this was done incredibly well within this book, The Shadow That Finds Us.
I loved seeing the relationships develop with the foursome and all the side characters! I also love that no-one is safe, Andy is definitely not afraid to tug those heartstrings!
If you love YA with Prophecy and Elemental magic then you will love this!
I'm really looking forward to book 4 now!!
June 7, 2026
𝒮𝒽𝑒 𝓌𝒶𝓈 𝑒𝓃𝑜𝓊𝑔𝒽. 𝒩𝑜𝓉 𝓅𝑒𝓇𝒻𝑒𝒸𝓉, 𝒷𝓊𝓉 𝒸𝑜𝓂𝓅𝓁𝑒𝓉𝑒.
Well, Andy has done it again! The Shadow That Finds Us - one of my most anticipated reads for 2026 is out in the world and it did not disappoint!!
I love Caeli so much and her story being further explored in this book and it was tragically beautiful. I mean that opening prologue says it all.
I really enjoyed the way things progressed from The Dark That Hides Us and that it was such an adventure once again.
This book took me on an emotional rollercoaster and since it’s only been out for one day consider this my spoiler free review.
What just happened? Umm what??? I love this world so much! Alexis and Demi ugh my heart. Caeli is still as badass as ever and Blaise he just makes me smile.
Well, Andy has done it again! The Shadow That Finds Us - one of my most anticipated reads for 2026 is out in the world and it did not disappoint!!
I love Caeli so much and her story being further explored in this book and it was tragically beautiful. I mean that opening prologue says it all.
I really enjoyed the way things progressed from The Dark That Hides Us and that it was such an adventure once again.
This book took me on an emotional rollercoaster and since it’s only been out for one day consider this my spoiler free review.
What just happened? Umm what??? I love this world so much! Alexis and Demi ugh my heart. Caeli is still as badass as ever and Blaise he just makes me smile.
May 11, 2026
Oh, my heart. This book was a ride and a half - shadows, inner conflict, tough choices and true love. Saying that, water is the element of my heart, it makes me feel calm and carefree but earth is the element of my soul and I need to know Demi’s story! She’s been my favourite from book one and I can’t wait for the last book.
June 2, 2026
Book 3 of the TLTBU series stressed me out (in a good way)!!! The story just keeps getting better and better! The revelations and twists in this book took me out!! Jfc!!! Andy, what is that ending?!?!?!?! I can’t believe I have to wait for another year for book 4!! A 4.5 read!!
April 22, 2026
HOLY. SHIT. i really didn’t think this series could get any better, and somehow it did?! i need the fourth book IMMEDIATELY.😭
April 28, 2026
4.5! The twists are great. So fun when everything connects. The ending was so good! Can’t wait for book 4!
May 3, 2026
His growth as a writer is just amazing! This so good, I have emotional whiplash but I loved every second. 4.5 stars.
Review of advance copy
and she said with a roar "MORE!!"
May 11, 2026
4.5– a slow start for sure and there were some plot lines that felt dragged on, but parts iii and iv were amazing!! nervous for book 4!
June 2, 2026
So good I cried more than once. 😭
June 8, 2026
Best book so far in the series
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews