What do you think?
Rate this book
The Marlow Murder Club #5
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts
A killer is on the loose. The bodies are piling up. And Judith is hiding a deadly secret …
Someone from Judith’s past has turned up in Marlow and is stirring up trouble. With all the murders that the Marlow Murder Club have had to solve and her work setting crosswords, Judith’s been too busy to give her old life much thought. But now it’s knocking on her door and won’t go away.
On top of that, Marlow’s celebrities are getting murdered! When a footballer and a thriller writer are found dead, Judith, Suzie, and Becks must untangle a web of scandal to find the killer. But with Judith keeping secrets, the Marlow Murder Club find themselves drifting apart.
The pressure is on in more ways than one …
Can they find the killer and help Judith in time, or could this be the end of the Marlow Murder Club?
Someone from Judith’s past has turned up in Marlow and is stirring up trouble. With all the murders that the Marlow Murder Club have had to solve and her work setting crosswords, Judith’s been too busy to give her old life much thought. But now it’s knocking on her door and won’t go away.
On top of that, Marlow’s celebrities are getting murdered! When a footballer and a thriller writer are found dead, Judith, Suzie, and Becks must untangle a web of scandal to find the killer. But with Judith keeping secrets, the Marlow Murder Club find themselves drifting apart.
The pressure is on in more ways than one …
Can they find the killer and help Judith in time, or could this be the end of the Marlow Murder Club?
256 pages, Paperback
First published January 15, 2026
About the author
Robert Thorogood
24 books2,574 followersRobert Thorogood is an English screenwriter. He is best known as the creator of the BBC 1 Murder Mystery Series, Death in Paradise.
Robert was educated at Uppingham School in Rutland and read History at Downing College, Cambridge. While at Cambridge, he toured with the university's student comedy troupe Footlights in 1993 and was elected President in 1994. Soon after leaving Cambridge, Robert set up a theatre company that toured small theatres and schools, the highlight of which was a production of Molière's The Miser that he directed and acted in alongside Robert Webb, David Mitchell and Olivia Colman.
Robert wrote for many years - selling scripts to the BBC, ITV and independent film companies - but before 2011 the only script of his that was actually broadcast was a Radio 4 afternoon play called From Abstraction about the life of Paul Wolfskehl.
In 2008, Robert entered the inaugural Red Planet Prize and was a chosen finalist, where he was able to pitch his 'Copper in the Caribbean' idea to Tony Jordan. By 2011, when the show was finally broadcast - making it Robert's first TV broadcast credit at the age of 39 - Robert had become something of a poster boy for 'never giving up on the dream'.
In January 2014, it was announced that Robert had signed a deal with MIRA Harlequin to write three Richard Poole Murder Mystery novels, with the first being published in hardback in January 2015.
Robert was educated at Uppingham School in Rutland and read History at Downing College, Cambridge. While at Cambridge, he toured with the university's student comedy troupe Footlights in 1993 and was elected President in 1994. Soon after leaving Cambridge, Robert set up a theatre company that toured small theatres and schools, the highlight of which was a production of Molière's The Miser that he directed and acted in alongside Robert Webb, David Mitchell and Olivia Colman.
Robert wrote for many years - selling scripts to the BBC, ITV and independent film companies - but before 2011 the only script of his that was actually broadcast was a Radio 4 afternoon play called From Abstraction about the life of Paul Wolfskehl.
In 2008, Robert entered the inaugural Red Planet Prize and was a chosen finalist, where he was able to pitch his 'Copper in the Caribbean' idea to Tony Jordan. By 2011, when the show was finally broadcast - making it Robert's first TV broadcast credit at the age of 39 - Robert had become something of a poster boy for 'never giving up on the dream'.
In January 2014, it was announced that Robert had signed a deal with MIRA Harlequin to write three Richard Poole Murder Mystery novels, with the first being published in hardback in January 2015.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 595 reviews
July 4, 2026
The fifth book in the Marlow Murder Club series is full of surprises and we find out a lot about Judith's past life. D.I. Malik is suspended and the team have to solve some murders without their usual amount of assistance. In fact most of the leg work is down to Suzie and Becks as Judith is rather occupied with her own train of events.
The biggest and best surprise of all was the identity of the murderer. I never imagined the author would do what he does but it was an excellent move. No spoilers though - you will have to read it to find out. Unless they use this book as a script for the TV show. It is a good one. Five stars.
The biggest and best surprise of all was the identity of the murderer. I never imagined the author would do what he does but it was an excellent move. No spoilers though - you will have to read it to find out. Unless they use this book as a script for the TV show. It is a good one. Five stars.
July 15, 2026
**4.5-stars rounded up**
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts is the 5th-book in Robert Thorogood's The Marlow Murder Club series. I've enjoyed the previous books tremendously, so had been anxiously awaiting this 5th-release.
If you aren't aware, these books follow Judith Potts, a widow in her 70s, and her two BFFs, Suzie and Becks, as they tackle mysteries in their local Marlow community.
This installment involves the deaths of two local celebrities, who although they don't initially seem connected, the women decide to investigate nonetheless, because it certainly can't be coincidence. But why would a killer be targeting such high profile locals?
Judith, Becks and Suzie, never ones to turn away from a truly puzzling mystery, are sure that the two cases must have a link, but finding it will be a challenge.
With all of this going on, it's not a great time for Judith's past to come back and haunt her, but that's exactly what happens. Judith's distracted, are her dark secrets finally going to come to light, or will she be able to put out that fire and solve the murders all at the same time?
I'm so happy to report that this ended up being my favorite book of the series thus far. I loved the growth displayed by all four of our main ladies, I'm including Tanika, their friend and police contact, with this statement, and I feel like they are all truly coming into their own.
There was something so 'final' feeling about this ending though. I'm actually nervous about it. I really hope this isn't the last mystery we get with this fabulous cast of characters.
When I first started with this series, I liked it, but I wasn't in love, but as the series has progressed, each installment seems to get stronger, or perhaps it's that I've become so attached to the ladies. Either way, I feel like Thorogood has done an excellent job leaning into their personalities and allowing the series to grow.
I love the dynamic between Judith, Suzie and Becks. They support each other so well, and where one of them may have a weakness, the others can provide their own strengths, making them a fantastic team.
I really enjoyed learning more about Judith's past in this one as well. Thorogood has been alluding to something potentially shady in Judith's past that she's been hiding from, but we never got the full scope of that. I feel like I have a much deeper understanding of her now.
As usual though, there's also a great amount of humor in the story, particularly when the ladies are in full investigation mode. They're so funny, the hi-jinks they get themselves into, even dangerous ones, all to solve the crimes. Now that's dedication to a goal.
I would highly recommend this series to all Cozy Mystery fans, in particular if you enjoy friendship groups solving mysteries together, or elderly amateur sleuths. The small town vibes are on point as well, as is the humor and heart.
Thank you to the publisher, Poisoned Pen Press, for providing me with a copy to read and review. As mentioned above, I truly hope we get more installments in this wonderful Cozy series!
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts is the 5th-book in Robert Thorogood's The Marlow Murder Club series. I've enjoyed the previous books tremendously, so had been anxiously awaiting this 5th-release.
If you aren't aware, these books follow Judith Potts, a widow in her 70s, and her two BFFs, Suzie and Becks, as they tackle mysteries in their local Marlow community.
This installment involves the deaths of two local celebrities, who although they don't initially seem connected, the women decide to investigate nonetheless, because it certainly can't be coincidence. But why would a killer be targeting such high profile locals?
Judith, Becks and Suzie, never ones to turn away from a truly puzzling mystery, are sure that the two cases must have a link, but finding it will be a challenge.
With all of this going on, it's not a great time for Judith's past to come back and haunt her, but that's exactly what happens. Judith's distracted, are her dark secrets finally going to come to light, or will she be able to put out that fire and solve the murders all at the same time?
I'm so happy to report that this ended up being my favorite book of the series thus far. I loved the growth displayed by all four of our main ladies, I'm including Tanika, their friend and police contact, with this statement, and I feel like they are all truly coming into their own.
There was something so 'final' feeling about this ending though. I'm actually nervous about it. I really hope this isn't the last mystery we get with this fabulous cast of characters.
When I first started with this series, I liked it, but I wasn't in love, but as the series has progressed, each installment seems to get stronger, or perhaps it's that I've become so attached to the ladies. Either way, I feel like Thorogood has done an excellent job leaning into their personalities and allowing the series to grow.
I love the dynamic between Judith, Suzie and Becks. They support each other so well, and where one of them may have a weakness, the others can provide their own strengths, making them a fantastic team.
I really enjoyed learning more about Judith's past in this one as well. Thorogood has been alluding to something potentially shady in Judith's past that she's been hiding from, but we never got the full scope of that. I feel like I have a much deeper understanding of her now.
As usual though, there's also a great amount of humor in the story, particularly when the ladies are in full investigation mode. They're so funny, the hi-jinks they get themselves into, even dangerous ones, all to solve the crimes. Now that's dedication to a goal.
I would highly recommend this series to all Cozy Mystery fans, in particular if you enjoy friendship groups solving mysteries together, or elderly amateur sleuths. The small town vibes are on point as well, as is the humor and heart.
Thank you to the publisher, Poisoned Pen Press, for providing me with a copy to read and review. As mentioned above, I truly hope we get more installments in this wonderful Cozy series!
April 17, 2026
When Judith’s Greek husband, Philippos Demetriou, drowned off Corfu 49 years ago, the police looked very closely at Philippos’ English wife, despised by the Demetriou family. But the case was deemed an accident resulting from a stubborn man misjudging his own abilities and going sailing in a storm.
Those who’ve been along since the series’ debut, The Marlow Murder Club, know quite a bit about that accident. And while longtime fans will love being reunited with Judith, Suzie Harris and Becks Starling, The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts works beautifully as a standalone, as well.
In addition, two D-list celebrities, a footballer (soccer player for the Yanks) and a Mickey Spillane-type mystery writer, are shot to death, and, naturally, Judith, Suzie and Becks investigate. The threesome can’t get their usual support from the Maidenhead Police Station’s Detective Inspector Tanika Malik, who’s been sidelined, but Judith, as usual, finds a way around that. But not even knowing how clever Judith Potts is prepared me for the shocking ending! Such a great addition to a fabulous series.
In the interest of full disclosure, I received this book from NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press in exchange for an honest review.
Those who’ve been along since the series’ debut, The Marlow Murder Club, know quite a bit about that accident. And while longtime fans will love being reunited with Judith, Suzie Harris and Becks Starling, The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts works beautifully as a standalone, as well.
In addition, two D-list celebrities, a footballer (soccer player for the Yanks) and a Mickey Spillane-type mystery writer, are shot to death, and, naturally, Judith, Suzie and Becks investigate. The threesome can’t get their usual support from the Maidenhead Police Station’s Detective Inspector Tanika Malik, who’s been sidelined, but Judith, as usual, finds a way around that. But not even knowing how clever Judith Potts is prepared me for the shocking ending! Such a great addition to a fabulous series.
In the interest of full disclosure, I received this book from NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
When Gary Best, local footballing legend, is found dead the Marlow Murder Club want to be on the case but before they can get to the bottom of this death, another local celebrity is killed. The gang should be on the case but with their police contact, Tanika, suspended from duty and Judith hiding some dark secret, will they get to the truth before another famous Marlow resident is targeted?
This is the first of the series that I've read and while I found the plot and relationships easy to follow, it didn't particularly resonate with me. The plot felt quite forced at times and a lot of the dialogue was extremely clunky.
I'd watched a couple of the adaptations and enjoyed the cosy feel but the book simply wasn't for me. I didn't particularly warm to any of the characters - they all felt like caricatures. Its a shame, because the adaptation was really quite enjoyable.
However, since I'm coming at this without having read previous books I think it's only fair to try an earlier book in the series to get more perspective.
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts is certainly a cosy crime novel and I should imagine that if you are a fan, then you will enjoy this latest episode. I'll go and try a few of the previous novels.
Thankyou to Netgalley and HQ for the advance review copy.
This is the first of the series that I've read and while I found the plot and relationships easy to follow, it didn't particularly resonate with me. The plot felt quite forced at times and a lot of the dialogue was extremely clunky.
I'd watched a couple of the adaptations and enjoyed the cosy feel but the book simply wasn't for me. I didn't particularly warm to any of the characters - they all felt like caricatures. Its a shame, because the adaptation was really quite enjoyable.
However, since I'm coming at this without having read previous books I think it's only fair to try an earlier book in the series to get more perspective.
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts is certainly a cosy crime novel and I should imagine that if you are a fan, then you will enjoy this latest episode. I'll go and try a few of the previous novels.
Thankyou to Netgalley and HQ for the advance review copy.
January 16, 2026
Not my favourite 🥲 but enjoyable enough
November 22, 2025
It was lovely returning to these feisty women. Their relationship with each other is so entertaining and the way they solve murders and work with the police is funny at times. They get their man eventually but, I love the way they manipulate people to get information. My thanks to netgalley and the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Full review on my blog: https://www.pagetostagereviews.com/20...
The last Marlow Murder Club book ended on the cliffhanger of all cliffhangers, and we dive straight back into the action in The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts. Our puzzle-whizz protagonist Judith is the key suspect in a murder this time around, bringing the action much closer to home than the characters are comfortable with.
And, despite this new development understandably taking up a lot of Judith's time in this book, there's also a brand-new case to solve alongside it as another prominent Marlow resident bites the dust. However, her friends Becks and Suzie have to do more of the heavy lifting this time around as their inside woman in the police, Tameka, is also out of action. This change in direction gives Judith's friends more agency and depth, shaping them as individuals instead of as an extension of Judith.
While Judith will forever remain my favourite of the friendship group, it's great to see Becks and Suzie's personalities shine through as they take over the sleuthing reigns. Becks in particular is a force to be reckoned with and I'm glad she's finally breaking free from her label as "the vicar's wife" as she is a kick-ass investigator in her own right with great ideas and unafraid to put them into action. After four books (and two series on TV) this development was much-needed and so appreciated! I also absolutely adored that they've been pulled brought into Judith's puzzling world and I'm excited about future puzzles and wordplays in the books already.
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts will immensely satisfy fans of the Marlow Murder Club series as, aside from centring on another strong, local whodunnit story, it really moves our characters forward. We get to learn so much more about Judith's past (the good and the bad) alongside seeing Becks and Suzie shine. The only main character that was sidelined more in this book was Tameka, but it served the plot and I have a feeling we'll get to see a lot more of her again in the next book.
One of the things I love so much about Robert Thorogood's writing is that it's both gripping and fast-paced; he doesn't waffle on with unnecessary plot points or background information but gets straight to the point (save the occasional red herring, of course, to keep everyone on their toes). This is the perfect formula for readers to don their own investigative hats as they follow along on the adventures with Becks, Suzie, and Judith. And makes the inevitable conclusion – whatever it may be – immensely satisfying as you feel a part of the action. It's a very clever strategy and one that has me hooked on the Marlow Murder Club for however long Thorogood will release new stories!
The last Marlow Murder Club book ended on the cliffhanger of all cliffhangers, and we dive straight back into the action in The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts. Our puzzle-whizz protagonist Judith is the key suspect in a murder this time around, bringing the action much closer to home than the characters are comfortable with.
And, despite this new development understandably taking up a lot of Judith's time in this book, there's also a brand-new case to solve alongside it as another prominent Marlow resident bites the dust. However, her friends Becks and Suzie have to do more of the heavy lifting this time around as their inside woman in the police, Tameka, is also out of action. This change in direction gives Judith's friends more agency and depth, shaping them as individuals instead of as an extension of Judith.
While Judith will forever remain my favourite of the friendship group, it's great to see Becks and Suzie's personalities shine through as they take over the sleuthing reigns. Becks in particular is a force to be reckoned with and I'm glad she's finally breaking free from her label as "the vicar's wife" as she is a kick-ass investigator in her own right with great ideas and unafraid to put them into action. After four books (and two series on TV) this development was much-needed and so appreciated! I also absolutely adored that they've been pulled brought into Judith's puzzling world and I'm excited about future puzzles and wordplays in the books already.
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts will immensely satisfy fans of the Marlow Murder Club series as, aside from centring on another strong, local whodunnit story, it really moves our characters forward. We get to learn so much more about Judith's past (the good and the bad) alongside seeing Becks and Suzie shine. The only main character that was sidelined more in this book was Tameka, but it served the plot and I have a feeling we'll get to see a lot more of her again in the next book.
One of the things I love so much about Robert Thorogood's writing is that it's both gripping and fast-paced; he doesn't waffle on with unnecessary plot points or background information but gets straight to the point (save the occasional red herring, of course, to keep everyone on their toes). This is the perfect formula for readers to don their own investigative hats as they follow along on the adventures with Becks, Suzie, and Judith. And makes the inevitable conclusion – whatever it may be – immensely satisfying as you feel a part of the action. It's a very clever strategy and one that has me hooked on the Marlow Murder Club for however long Thorogood will release new stories!
February 25, 2026
I love these 3 ladies and every year wait eagerly for the release of next installment in the series. But, it took me 15+ days to finish this one and if this book was not part of ' A marlow murder club' , I would have definitely DNFed it.
July 7, 2026
Marlow is really out here treating murder like a community event, and at this point I’m starting to think the town council is just… not addressing it. Because why are local celebrities getting picked off one by one while everyone’s still politely going to lunch? And naturally, right in the middle of this escalating chaos, Judith Potts is having the worst possible week of her extremely eccentric life.
We’re talking dead footballers. Dead authors. Blackmail flying around like it’s a group hobby. And then, just to really keep things spicy, someone shows up to basically say, “Hey Judith, remember your dead husband? What if… you murdered him?” which is, objectively, a rude way to start anyone’s morning.
So now we’ve got two full-blown murders to solve AND Judith’s deeply buried past clawing its way into the present like it’s been waiting for this exact moment to ruin her day. And here’s where this book gets sneaky in the best way. Because while The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts absolutely delivers on the whodunit chaos, it’s also quietly dismantling Judith’s whole “unflappable crossword queen who drinks whisky before noon and fears nothing” persona. Suddenly she’s shaken. Distracted. Human. It’s illegal, honestly. I did not sign up to have feelings about Judith Potts but here we are.
Meanwhile, Becks and Suzie are like, “Cool, mom’s going through it, guess we run the investigation now,” and I LOVED this for them. Becks is out here sharpening into this quietly brilliant, slightly terrifying force, and Suzie continues to operate like she’s powered by vibes, loyalty, and a complete disregard for rules. Watching them take the lead felt like when the side characters in a heist movie realize they’re actually the heist.
And the mystery? Oh, it’s messy messy. Everyone is being blackmailed, which means everyone is lying, which means every single conversation feels like a performance where someone is about to crack. The suspect list isn’t even a list anymore, it’s just… Marlow. The whole town. Lock it down.
There are twists stacked on twists, red herrings doing cardio in the background, and at least three moments where I was fully convinced I had it figured out, only to be immediately humbled. It’s giving “you thought you were the detective? That’s adorable.”
What really got me, though, is how much heart is buried under all the chaos. This series has always been about the friendship, but here it hits harder. Judith, Becks, and Suzie don’t just solve crimes, they carry each other through the mess. And with Judith spiraling a bit under the weight of her past, you really feel how much these women anchor each other. It’s ride-or-die, but make it tea and trespassing.
Also, the tone continues to do that wild balancing act where we’re dealing with genuinely heavy themes, abuse, survival, manipulation, but it never loses that cozy, slightly absurd charm. It’s like, yes, this is dark… but also someone is about to solve it using logic that sounds like a crossword clue and I will accept that without question.
I will say, it takes a minute to find its footing. There’s a lot happening right out of the gate, and for a second it feels like you’ve been dropped into the middle of five different problems with no map. But once everything clicks into place, it’s game over. You’re in. You’re invested. You’re side-eyeing every character like you’ve personally been wronged.
And the reveal? Offensive. Disrespectful. Completely satisfying. I love being wrong when it’s done this well. Four stars, easily. This series continues to be that perfect mix of clever, chaotic, and weirdly emotional, like if a crossword puzzle and a therapy session teamed up to solve crimes.
Whodunity Award: For Making Me Suspect an Entire Town Full of People Who All Absolutely Deserved to Be Investigated
Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for the ARC. I would trust Judith Potts with my life, my secrets, and probably my browser history, but only because she’d solve the crime before judging me.
We’re talking dead footballers. Dead authors. Blackmail flying around like it’s a group hobby. And then, just to really keep things spicy, someone shows up to basically say, “Hey Judith, remember your dead husband? What if… you murdered him?” which is, objectively, a rude way to start anyone’s morning.
So now we’ve got two full-blown murders to solve AND Judith’s deeply buried past clawing its way into the present like it’s been waiting for this exact moment to ruin her day. And here’s where this book gets sneaky in the best way. Because while The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts absolutely delivers on the whodunit chaos, it’s also quietly dismantling Judith’s whole “unflappable crossword queen who drinks whisky before noon and fears nothing” persona. Suddenly she’s shaken. Distracted. Human. It’s illegal, honestly. I did not sign up to have feelings about Judith Potts but here we are.
Meanwhile, Becks and Suzie are like, “Cool, mom’s going through it, guess we run the investigation now,” and I LOVED this for them. Becks is out here sharpening into this quietly brilliant, slightly terrifying force, and Suzie continues to operate like she’s powered by vibes, loyalty, and a complete disregard for rules. Watching them take the lead felt like when the side characters in a heist movie realize they’re actually the heist.
And the mystery? Oh, it’s messy messy. Everyone is being blackmailed, which means everyone is lying, which means every single conversation feels like a performance where someone is about to crack. The suspect list isn’t even a list anymore, it’s just… Marlow. The whole town. Lock it down.
There are twists stacked on twists, red herrings doing cardio in the background, and at least three moments where I was fully convinced I had it figured out, only to be immediately humbled. It’s giving “you thought you were the detective? That’s adorable.”
What really got me, though, is how much heart is buried under all the chaos. This series has always been about the friendship, but here it hits harder. Judith, Becks, and Suzie don’t just solve crimes, they carry each other through the mess. And with Judith spiraling a bit under the weight of her past, you really feel how much these women anchor each other. It’s ride-or-die, but make it tea and trespassing.
Also, the tone continues to do that wild balancing act where we’re dealing with genuinely heavy themes, abuse, survival, manipulation, but it never loses that cozy, slightly absurd charm. It’s like, yes, this is dark… but also someone is about to solve it using logic that sounds like a crossword clue and I will accept that without question.
I will say, it takes a minute to find its footing. There’s a lot happening right out of the gate, and for a second it feels like you’ve been dropped into the middle of five different problems with no map. But once everything clicks into place, it’s game over. You’re in. You’re invested. You’re side-eyeing every character like you’ve personally been wronged.
And the reveal? Offensive. Disrespectful. Completely satisfying. I love being wrong when it’s done this well. Four stars, easily. This series continues to be that perfect mix of clever, chaotic, and weirdly emotional, like if a crossword puzzle and a therapy session teamed up to solve crimes.
Whodunity Award: For Making Me Suspect an Entire Town Full of People Who All Absolutely Deserved to Be Investigated
Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for the ARC. I would trust Judith Potts with my life, my secrets, and probably my browser history, but only because she’d solve the crime before judging me.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4.25*
'The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts' is another great addition to the Marlow Murder Club series (and potentially the series closer). As always with this series it has a clever mystery, humour, emotion and our ever present loveable core cast of characters. I really enjoyed central mystery in this one but there was also added intrigue with us finally being promised the backstory about Judith and what happened to her husband all those years ago.
As always there are plenty of twists and red herrings and a reveal that I genuinely didn't see coming. I'm glad we've also had a resolution to the story around Judith's past that has been hinted at in all the previous books and if this is the series closer it gives us a great sense of finality in that respect. The friendships at the heart of this book add warmth and heart and whilst Judith's side quest took away from that a little we were well rewarded in the end and it was great to see Becks and Suzie get more time to shine.
While it took a little time to fully settle into the rhythm of the story, once it did it was hugely enjoyable and yet again gave me a fun and satisfying read that delivers exactly what I look for in this series. If this is the end I'll be sad to say goodbye but from start to finish this series has been an absolute delight.
Thank you to NetGalley and HQ for inviting me to review a digital review copy of "The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts" in exchange for my honest and voluntary review.
'The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts' is another great addition to the Marlow Murder Club series (and potentially the series closer). As always with this series it has a clever mystery, humour, emotion and our ever present loveable core cast of characters. I really enjoyed central mystery in this one but there was also added intrigue with us finally being promised the backstory about Judith and what happened to her husband all those years ago.
As always there are plenty of twists and red herrings and a reveal that I genuinely didn't see coming. I'm glad we've also had a resolution to the story around Judith's past that has been hinted at in all the previous books and if this is the series closer it gives us a great sense of finality in that respect. The friendships at the heart of this book add warmth and heart and whilst Judith's side quest took away from that a little we were well rewarded in the end and it was great to see Becks and Suzie get more time to shine.
While it took a little time to fully settle into the rhythm of the story, once it did it was hugely enjoyable and yet again gave me a fun and satisfying read that delivers exactly what I look for in this series. If this is the end I'll be sad to say goodbye but from start to finish this series has been an absolute delight.
Thank you to NetGalley and HQ for inviting me to review a digital review copy of "The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts" in exchange for my honest and voluntary review.
January 15, 2026
I love this series it’s like meeting up with friends everytime I open the book.
This was full of suspense waiting to find out what was happening with Judith’s mysterious visitor accusing her of murder.
I love these characters, the writing brings them alive and a realism to their lives.
A twisty tale for our intrepid ladies to solve another great instalment from Robert Thorogood I can’t wait to see what happens next.
This was full of suspense waiting to find out what was happening with Judith’s mysterious visitor accusing her of murder.
I love these characters, the writing brings them alive and a realism to their lives.
A twisty tale for our intrepid ladies to solve another great instalment from Robert Thorogood I can’t wait to see what happens next.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This is the fifth book in The Marlow Murder Club series and I do recommend reading the series in order. Until now I have listened to the series on audiobook. I prefer reading on my Kindle vs audiobooks because I retain the details better when I see the words with my eyes. Boy am I glad I read this one!
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts is layered in mystery. Judith has been accused of killing her late husband Philippos, by Philippos's daughter, almost 50 years after he died. Eleni has come all the way from Corfu to accuse Judith of murder, saying she has definitive evidence that she'll take to the police if Judith does not willingly confess. While Judith is dealing with her personal demons there is also a killer on the loose. First a famous footballer (that's soccer for us Americans) is found shot dead and then a popular novelist the day after. With DI Tanika Malik suspended from the force it's up to Judith, Suzie, and Becks alone to find the link between the deaths and catch the killer.
I've come to love this group of women throughout the years, especially Becks. She's really come into her own due to the support of her friends. Who doesn't want to see women empowering other women? She's become a force to be reckoned with! I also enjoyed seeing Judith's softer side. She was much more relatable in this book, yet as intelligent as ever. As far as the story goes, this one is my favorite in the series so far. The stakes were much higher this time and the way all the pieces came together felt natural yet creative. I only wish we got to see more of Suzie and Becks solving Judith's puzzles before the final reveal.
Thank you Poisoned Press for providing me with an advanced reader copy.
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts is layered in mystery. Judith has been accused of killing her late husband Philippos, by Philippos's daughter, almost 50 years after he died. Eleni has come all the way from Corfu to accuse Judith of murder, saying she has definitive evidence that she'll take to the police if Judith does not willingly confess. While Judith is dealing with her personal demons there is also a killer on the loose. First a famous footballer (that's soccer for us Americans) is found shot dead and then a popular novelist the day after. With DI Tanika Malik suspended from the force it's up to Judith, Suzie, and Becks alone to find the link between the deaths and catch the killer.
I've come to love this group of women throughout the years, especially Becks. She's really come into her own due to the support of her friends. Who doesn't want to see women empowering other women? She's become a force to be reckoned with! I also enjoyed seeing Judith's softer side. She was much more relatable in this book, yet as intelligent as ever. As far as the story goes, this one is my favorite in the series so far. The stakes were much higher this time and the way all the pieces came together felt natural yet creative. I only wish we got to see more of Suzie and Becks solving Judith's puzzles before the final reveal.
Thank you Poisoned Press for providing me with an advanced reader copy.
July 13, 2026
I love that we finally learn a bit more about Judith's past and the things she's been hiding! Especially after the cliffhanger ending of the book befoew. This was really well done and I loved seeing a new side of Judith.
The friendship between the women and the whole dynamic continues to be the series' strongest point for me, I always enjoy returning for more.
So far, this is definitely my favorite in the series!
*I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*
The friendship between the women and the whole dynamic continues to be the series' strongest point for me, I always enjoy returning for more.
So far, this is definitely my favorite in the series!
*I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*
Read
July 11, 2026I'm a huge fan of this series! The good news: if you remember nothing about the last book, don't worry. If you do want a recap, you can check out my Readers Guide to Murder on the Marlow Belle
What I did like about the Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts: seeing the women continue to gel more as a group and getting to know more about Judith's past. I found her plotline the most compelling. I wish this drama in the past had taken place in the UK rather than out of the country and that the whole book had been focused on it. (I can't remember if the book addresses the jurisdiction issue.) And the ending was fantastic!
I found the celebrity murder plot less compelling and a little too confusing at times. How many celebrities can be in the small village of Marlow, I ask?? (Well, since they are being murdered in this book, a lot less than there used to be!)
Thanks to the publisher for providing an advance copy for review!
What I did like about the Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts: seeing the women continue to gel more as a group and getting to know more about Judith's past. I found her plotline the most compelling. I wish this drama in the past had taken place in the UK rather than out of the country and that the whole book had been focused on it. (I can't remember if the book addresses the jurisdiction issue.) And the ending was fantastic!
I found the celebrity murder plot less compelling and a little too confusing at times. How many celebrities can be in the small village of Marlow, I ask?? (Well, since they are being murdered in this book, a lot less than there used to be!)
Thanks to the publisher for providing an advance copy for review!
July 8, 2026
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts is the latest addition to Robert Thorogood’s Marlow Murder Club series and it is my favorite so far.
Thorogood writes the most wonderful fun books. They’re like boxes of chocolates. I feel almost guilty reading them—they are simply fun, an indulgence for me.
They’re all enjoyable but with each book I become increasingly attached to the characters. I love our trio of amateur detectives. Suzi, the flighty dog walker; Becks the seemingly conformist wife of the village vicar, and (my favorite) the elderly but dynamic and ornery Judith Potts. I’m also attached to their connection to the police force, Tanika. And I like that this book is dominated by a variety of female voices.
In Mysterious Affair, Judith’s past is the central mystery of the book. It is the heart of the book although there is the murders that surround her story. Judith is preoccupied with the appearance of Eleni—a young woman threatening to unveil a past Judith wants to keep in the past. Beck and Suzy rise to the occasion as Judith is not always paying her usual careful attention and unquestioned leadership of the three women.
The major difference for me in this book was that I experienced some moments of intense anxiety about the future of our heroes. I can’t say more than that other than this book is in some significant ways more suspenseful than the previous ones.
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts will be published by Poisoned Pen Press on July 7, 2026.
Thorogood writes the most wonderful fun books. They’re like boxes of chocolates. I feel almost guilty reading them—they are simply fun, an indulgence for me.
They’re all enjoyable but with each book I become increasingly attached to the characters. I love our trio of amateur detectives. Suzi, the flighty dog walker; Becks the seemingly conformist wife of the village vicar, and (my favorite) the elderly but dynamic and ornery Judith Potts. I’m also attached to their connection to the police force, Tanika. And I like that this book is dominated by a variety of female voices.
In Mysterious Affair, Judith’s past is the central mystery of the book. It is the heart of the book although there is the murders that surround her story. Judith is preoccupied with the appearance of Eleni—a young woman threatening to unveil a past Judith wants to keep in the past. Beck and Suzy rise to the occasion as Judith is not always paying her usual careful attention and unquestioned leadership of the three women.
The major difference for me in this book was that I experienced some moments of intense anxiety about the future of our heroes. I can’t say more than that other than this book is in some significant ways more suspenseful than the previous ones.
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts will be published by Poisoned Pen Press on July 7, 2026.
February 15, 2026
Unbelievable story, but good escapism suitable for insomnia.
April 9, 2026
A murder mystery too far. Rather far fetched. Enough said.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
My favourite cosy crime series is back with its fifth entry! Anyone who has been following the series will know there’s been an ongoing background storyline surrounding the ambiguity of the fate of Judith’s late husband. The previous book, Murder on the Marlow Belle, concluded with Judith receiving a visitor who would raise more questions about this…
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts takes place a day after the events of Murder on the Marlow Belle. As well as the visitor at Judith’s door, our unlikely trio, consisting of the puzzle setter and her dog walker and vicar’s wife friends, have more murders to solve!
The celebrities of Marlow are dropping like flies, so it’s down to Judith, Suzie and Becks to investigate and expose who’s behind the deaths. With ringleader Judith preoccupied with her personal predicament, it’s great to see Suzie and Becks take charge and come into their own with all the sleuthing skills they have learnt over the years. I love how their friendship is written.
As mentioned, this is part of a series and due to the particular storyline and the way it follows on timeline-wise from the last book, I really do think it’s worth investing the time to get up to speed. It’s cosy in the sense of the characters and the fact that the murders are not dark, but the series isn’t twee. The puzzles and mysteries are fun and well written. Plus if you’re a fan of the TV series Death in Paradise then you will be pleased to know it’s the same writer!
Thank you to Rachel Quin and HQ Stories for the proof.
The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts takes place a day after the events of Murder on the Marlow Belle. As well as the visitor at Judith’s door, our unlikely trio, consisting of the puzzle setter and her dog walker and vicar’s wife friends, have more murders to solve!
The celebrities of Marlow are dropping like flies, so it’s down to Judith, Suzie and Becks to investigate and expose who’s behind the deaths. With ringleader Judith preoccupied with her personal predicament, it’s great to see Suzie and Becks take charge and come into their own with all the sleuthing skills they have learnt over the years. I love how their friendship is written.
As mentioned, this is part of a series and due to the particular storyline and the way it follows on timeline-wise from the last book, I really do think it’s worth investing the time to get up to speed. It’s cosy in the sense of the characters and the fact that the murders are not dark, but the series isn’t twee. The puzzles and mysteries are fun and well written. Plus if you’re a fan of the TV series Death in Paradise then you will be pleased to know it’s the same writer!
Thank you to Rachel Quin and HQ Stories for the proof.
January 2, 2026
Another successful book in the cozy crime series featuring the Marlow Detective Agency. I very much enjoyed this outing for the ladies, which sees them acting mainly without their police force friend Tamika, who has been suspended and replaced by another officer.
The replacement, Brendan, very much disapproves of the ladies being involved in police business and when two deaths occur of famous Marlow residents he warns them to stay away. In addition to this storyline, a woman appears from Judith’s past to uncover some secrets that have previously been hinted at involving the death of her husband many years ago.
The storyline is fun, witty, full of crossword puzzle elements and features some characters who have become like friends. I particularly enjoyed this book and the view into Judith’s history which gives her character more depth and understanding.
I would highly recommend reading this book and the others in the series for a great cozy crime thriller.
Thanks to Netgalley, the author and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
The replacement, Brendan, very much disapproves of the ladies being involved in police business and when two deaths occur of famous Marlow residents he warns them to stay away. In addition to this storyline, a woman appears from Judith’s past to uncover some secrets that have previously been hinted at involving the death of her husband many years ago.
The storyline is fun, witty, full of crossword puzzle elements and features some characters who have become like friends. I particularly enjoyed this book and the view into Judith’s history which gives her character more depth and understanding.
I would highly recommend reading this book and the others in the series for a great cozy crime thriller.
Thanks to Netgalley, the author and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
February 8, 2026
Judith’s past life has caught up with her so when Tanika approaches the 3 ladies asking for help to solve famous footballer, Gary’s, murder she’s too preoccupied to be her usual nosy problem solving self. When another a celebrity is murdered and Tanika is suspended the women realise they need to act quickly. Will Judith be able to put her past ghosts to bed to be able to help? Will Suzy and Becks cope without her? Will they catch their murderer?
I didn’t enjoy this one quite as much as previous ones. It felt a bit forced at times, and also a little daft at others. I still think the women are cracking and without question will read the next instalment 🤣
I didn’t enjoy this one quite as much as previous ones. It felt a bit forced at times, and also a little daft at others. I still think the women are cracking and without question will read the next instalment 🤣
November 22, 2025
This book, as always in this series, did what it says on the tin. A little intrigue in a bucolic setting, female friendships, a rogues gallery of characters, some surprises (but nothing too jarring - of course). Love me a cosy crime and this series is one of my top choices of the genre. Didn’t 100% love the very end (no spoilers..) and think the reactions around it could’ve been developed further. Still a solid cosy crime read. Thanks for the ARC!
March 2, 2026
Fun. It's not as good as the first or fourth book in this series but fun nonetheless. I loved the extra insight we were given to Judith in this book and wanted more. A prequel spin-off of young Judith in Greece by any chance??
Would I recommend this novel? Yes, for fans of the series, it is a must. In places, it feels just a little too lightweight, but it's a good read
Would I recommend this novel? Yes, for fans of the series, it is a must. In places, it feels just a little too lightweight, but it's a good read
July 11, 2026
One more book and one more time, I will say "I just love the Marlow Murder Club mysteries!" Robert Thorogood's most recent book, The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts is a fine addition to the series.
Haven't we all wondered if Judith Potts did indeed murder her husband as was hinted in the first of the series? We may get to find out as a Greek woman attempts to blackmail Judith.
There is plenty of blackmail and murder in the book to keep us all interested and when you throw in a few twists, turns and interesting characters, it is sure to grab you.
While I had the culprit spotted early on, I appreciate the book for the deepening friendship between the ladies of the club and I look forward to the next installment.
Haven't we all wondered if Judith Potts did indeed murder her husband as was hinted in the first of the series? We may get to find out as a Greek woman attempts to blackmail Judith.
There is plenty of blackmail and murder in the book to keep us all interested and when you throw in a few twists, turns and interesting characters, it is sure to grab you.
While I had the culprit spotted early on, I appreciate the book for the deepening friendship between the ladies of the club and I look forward to the next installment.
June 21, 2026
The three amateur sleuths are back at it but this time around Suzie and Becks have to step up, ‘cause Judith is distracted and even Tanika has been sidelined. Amusing and quirky as always, with fun and puzzling murders and blackmail, and more questions than answers.
A great multitude of suspects pop up, each one looking more and more guilty, and nothing to go on but their word. Who’s lying and are they little lies or big lies? But someone who is definitely under scrutiny is Judith, ‘cause her friends know she’s keeping secrets… and we’re all finally going to get the truth at the end.
I enjoyed the drama throughout, how it all connects eventually. But if I had one big criticism, it’s that the explanation is too large. The denouement, laying out all the answers, was so long and wordy that it started to feel very unrealistic and take me out of the story.
Still, this series is always a fun and easy adventure. I love the characters and am always eager to return to Marlow.
* I received a free early ecopy from the publisher
A great multitude of suspects pop up, each one looking more and more guilty, and nothing to go on but their word. Who’s lying and are they little lies or big lies? But someone who is definitely under scrutiny is Judith, ‘cause her friends know she’s keeping secrets… and we’re all finally going to get the truth at the end.
I enjoyed the drama throughout, how it all connects eventually. But if I had one big criticism, it’s that the explanation is too large. The denouement, laying out all the answers, was so long and wordy that it started to feel very unrealistic and take me out of the story.
Still, this series is always a fun and easy adventure. I love the characters and am always eager to return to Marlow.
* I received a free early ecopy from the publisher
July 3, 2026
This fifth installment is probably my favorite in the Marlow Murder Club series! 🙌
It not only kept me guessing, but the twist was great! And we get to learn more about Judith’s past…🫢 If you haven’t checked this series out, it’s time to, book peeps! 👏
Thank you partner Poisoned Pen Press for the gifted finished paperback copy and eARC in exchange for my honest review! ❤️
It not only kept me guessing, but the twist was great! And we get to learn more about Judith’s past…🫢 If you haven’t checked this series out, it’s time to, book peeps! 👏
Thank you partner Poisoned Pen Press for the gifted finished paperback copy and eARC in exchange for my honest review! ❤️
March 8, 2026
This book finds amateur sleuths, Judith Potts, Becks Starling and Susie Harris involved in discovering who is behind the blackmail and killing of two deceased men.
Without the help of their police contact, they must go it alone.
For Judith, this is a difficult time as an unexpected visitor arrives bringing up unwanted memories.
I found this book brings together many outstanding questions from the previous books about the main characters.
Even after watching the TV series The Marlow Murder Club I still thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel.
Without the help of their police contact, they must go it alone.
For Judith, this is a difficult time as an unexpected visitor arrives bringing up unwanted memories.
I found this book brings together many outstanding questions from the previous books about the main characters.
Even after watching the TV series The Marlow Murder Club I still thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel.
July 2, 2026
thoroughly enjoyed as always and guessed the ‘who dun it’
March 11, 2026
Lots of antics and what a gag
June 23, 2026
Visiting with Judith, Suzie, and Becks is always a trip, but this one is a serious roller-coaster! The morning after, they helped nail down Oliver Beresfords killer, Judith is greeted with a blast from her past, when her husband's illegitimate daughter shows up at her door, claiming she has proof that Judith killed her father 49 years ago. While Judith dismisses her, she is definitely thrown off, so when Tanika contacts her to let her know that a local football player, a Marlow celebrity has been murdered she is surprised by the reception she gets! It's only when Suzie and Becks get involved that Judith get dragged into the investigation, only to have Tanika be suspended and the ladies find themselves working around Detective Brendan Perry. When a second celebrity, this a well-known author, is murdered can the ladies figure out if there is a connection? Who wanted these famous men dead and why? Can the ladies find answers without any police help? As well as with Judith so obviously off her game? Come along for one of those really crazy journeys we have come to expect from this group. Trust me, you will not be disappointed! Thanks to #NetGalley, #PoisonPenPress, and the author for the opportunity to join the madness! #TheMysteriousAffairofJudithPotts #TheMarlowMurderClub #RobertThorogood #bookreview #bookideas #retiredreader
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I really enjoy spending time with the characters in the Marlow Murder Club. I love how each of the women are different, but work so well together and how each are strong in their own way.
The mystery surrounding the murders in this book definitely kept me guessing, although I did have an inkling at one point.
This is a great series and I really want to watch the TV show now to see it come to life more.
The mystery surrounding the murders in this book definitely kept me guessing, although I did have an inkling at one point.
This is a great series and I really want to watch the TV show now to see it come to life more.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 595 reviews