What do you think?
Rate this book
Silver Springs Mysteries #1
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival
When cheese becomes deadly business, one woman must slice through lies to uncover the truth.
Laura Evans thought trading her high-stress Boston restaurant career for small-town Vermont charm would bring peace.
Instead, she finds herself knee-deep in cheddar and conspiracy when a body turns up at the General Store after a pre-festival cheese tasting ahead of the Summer Cheese Festival. And her boss Maggie is made the prime suspect.
The festival is less than two weeks away and with the store's reputation threatened, Laura can't stand by and watch her new life crumble like aged parmesan.
With the help of her observant landlady, Evelyn Chan, she discovers beneath the town's picture-perfect surface lies a complex web of rivalries, family secrets, and scandals.
And when there's an entire festival's worth of suspects, she must separate friend from foe before it's too late...
Perfect for fans of cozy mysteries who crave:
- A relatable amateur sleuth with real-world experience
- Authentic small-town atmosphere that feels like home
- Food-focused mysteries with mouthwatering details
- Gentle suspense with satisfying plot twists
- Strong community bonds and found family themes
- Just enough danger to keep you turning pages
This engaging book serves up the perfect blend of mystery and comfort. Every clue unfolds at just the right place, and justice is as satisfying as a perfectly aged Vermont cheddar.
Laura Evans thought trading her high-stress Boston restaurant career for small-town Vermont charm would bring peace.
Instead, she finds herself knee-deep in cheddar and conspiracy when a body turns up at the General Store after a pre-festival cheese tasting ahead of the Summer Cheese Festival. And her boss Maggie is made the prime suspect.
The festival is less than two weeks away and with the store's reputation threatened, Laura can't stand by and watch her new life crumble like aged parmesan.
With the help of her observant landlady, Evelyn Chan, she discovers beneath the town's picture-perfect surface lies a complex web of rivalries, family secrets, and scandals.
And when there's an entire festival's worth of suspects, she must separate friend from foe before it's too late...
Perfect for fans of cozy mysteries who crave:
- A relatable amateur sleuth with real-world experience
- Authentic small-town atmosphere that feels like home
- Food-focused mysteries with mouthwatering details
- Gentle suspense with satisfying plot twists
- Strong community bonds and found family themes
- Just enough danger to keep you turning pages
This engaging book serves up the perfect blend of mystery and comfort. Every clue unfolds at just the right place, and justice is as satisfying as a perfectly aged Vermont cheddar.
246 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 18, 2025
2 people are currently reading
15 people want to read
About the author
Jodie Morgan
8 books9 followersJodie Morgan is an author and knitting blogger, and her books welcome readers into the charming world of the Silver Springs Mysteries set in Vermont, filled with intriguing puzzles, memorable characters, and the satisfying solutions cozy mystery readers love.
When she’s not plotting her next book, you’ll find her reading, savoring a coffee (with cream, always!) or working on her latest knitting or crochet project. She loves to travel as this sparks ideas for her stories. Her most satisfying creative moments come from quiet evenings at home with her supportive family.
Author photo taken by Tal at the Granny Square in Sydney, Australia.
When she’s not plotting her next book, you’ll find her reading, savoring a coffee (with cream, always!) or working on her latest knitting or crochet project. She loves to travel as this sparks ideas for her stories. Her most satisfying creative moments come from quiet evenings at home with her supportive family.
Author photo taken by Tal at the Granny Square in Sydney, Australia.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews
November 12, 2025
The setting for this murder mystery, Silver Springs, is depicted as a fabulously cozy-feeling Vermont town, where everyone knows each other’s business. This can be a bit intrusive at times, but to new cafe manager, and main character, Laura, the contrast with busier and more formal Boston is exactly what she is looking for. I live in New England in the vicinity of Boston and Morgan’s wonderfully atmospheric descriptions of a small town in Vermont feel authentic and its characters believable.
“The sky stretched forever above the dairy as Laura parked her car. A gust of warm evening air brushed her face as she and Evelyn trudged up Mountain Valley Dairy’s drive, muddy from the recent rains. Three dogs sprinted across the field. Laura bent to pet them, struggling to find a head to scratch amidst the furry blur.”
Once the scene has been set, the story properly kicks off when Laura discovers the body of Jeremy Lockwood, a famous restaurant critic. He has previously given the cafe Laura manages a scathing review, and his murder occurs right before he is due to be the keynote speaker at the town’s esteemed Summer Cheese Festival. Amateur sleuthing abounds, with Laura teaming up with her landlady Evelyn to lead the charge.
A lot of research into the subject of cheese-making clearly went into this story, as can be seen during the tour of Diana’s cheese factory and the festival itself. The author is obviously an expert in cheese production techniques and the different types of cheeses that can be made.
I loved how deliciously tasty this book was! It really was an enjoyable treat for all the senses with an atmosphere built through flavours, fragrances, and even soft textures described – all adding to the coziness of the novel. The attention to detail in the scene-setting was expertly aided by Jodie Morgan’s descriptive turn of phrase, making it very easy to imagine yourself in the locations she is describing, tasting the food and breathing in the fragrances:
“Laura delivered Jeremy’s lunch: a summer squash and herb frittata, sharp cheddar slices, and walnut flour flatbread. It was an elegant presentation, even if Jeremy was predisposed to find more fault than flavor. He picked up a forkful of frittata, tasting it like a detective gathering evidence.”
“The fresh smell of lime enveloped Laura as she entered Evelyn’s apartment. Her breathing steadied, her muscles relaxing as her landlady welcomed her. “Come sit in the living room. I’ll only be a moment,” Evelyn said. Laura sank into a plush armchair, and Oscar, Evelyn’s dark-brown Burmese cat, padded over. He circled her ankles, then settled on her lap, purring as she ran a hand over his soft back.”
The murder mystery is a lot of fun as clues are uncovered bit by bit by the amateur sleuths. I found myself speculating about each of the clues and trying to figure out whodunnit.
Officer Ramirez, the police officer assigned to the case, is often frustrated by the methods used by the amateurs, but you get the feeling she appreciates their help and eagerness in solving the case despite her protestations.
There was a very large cast of characters in this novel, what with committee members and suppliers to the general store, a large number of staff, the crafting group and other secondary characters, and I appreciated the cast list included at the back of the book.
This book is highly recommended by me for fans of Richard Osman’s Thursday Murder Club books and other cozy mysteries.
I am reviewing ‘Murder At The Summer Cheese Festival (Silver Springs Mysteries 1)’ on behalf of Rosie Amber’s review team (#RBRT). I received a complimentary review copy, but my opinions are my own and my review is honest.
“The sky stretched forever above the dairy as Laura parked her car. A gust of warm evening air brushed her face as she and Evelyn trudged up Mountain Valley Dairy’s drive, muddy from the recent rains. Three dogs sprinted across the field. Laura bent to pet them, struggling to find a head to scratch amidst the furry blur.”
Once the scene has been set, the story properly kicks off when Laura discovers the body of Jeremy Lockwood, a famous restaurant critic. He has previously given the cafe Laura manages a scathing review, and his murder occurs right before he is due to be the keynote speaker at the town’s esteemed Summer Cheese Festival. Amateur sleuthing abounds, with Laura teaming up with her landlady Evelyn to lead the charge.
A lot of research into the subject of cheese-making clearly went into this story, as can be seen during the tour of Diana’s cheese factory and the festival itself. The author is obviously an expert in cheese production techniques and the different types of cheeses that can be made.
I loved how deliciously tasty this book was! It really was an enjoyable treat for all the senses with an atmosphere built through flavours, fragrances, and even soft textures described – all adding to the coziness of the novel. The attention to detail in the scene-setting was expertly aided by Jodie Morgan’s descriptive turn of phrase, making it very easy to imagine yourself in the locations she is describing, tasting the food and breathing in the fragrances:
“Laura delivered Jeremy’s lunch: a summer squash and herb frittata, sharp cheddar slices, and walnut flour flatbread. It was an elegant presentation, even if Jeremy was predisposed to find more fault than flavor. He picked up a forkful of frittata, tasting it like a detective gathering evidence.”
“The fresh smell of lime enveloped Laura as she entered Evelyn’s apartment. Her breathing steadied, her muscles relaxing as her landlady welcomed her. “Come sit in the living room. I’ll only be a moment,” Evelyn said. Laura sank into a plush armchair, and Oscar, Evelyn’s dark-brown Burmese cat, padded over. He circled her ankles, then settled on her lap, purring as she ran a hand over his soft back.”
The murder mystery is a lot of fun as clues are uncovered bit by bit by the amateur sleuths. I found myself speculating about each of the clues and trying to figure out whodunnit.
Officer Ramirez, the police officer assigned to the case, is often frustrated by the methods used by the amateurs, but you get the feeling she appreciates their help and eagerness in solving the case despite her protestations.
There was a very large cast of characters in this novel, what with committee members and suppliers to the general store, a large number of staff, the crafting group and other secondary characters, and I appreciated the cast list included at the back of the book.
This book is highly recommended by me for fans of Richard Osman’s Thursday Murder Club books and other cozy mysteries.
I am reviewing ‘Murder At The Summer Cheese Festival (Silver Springs Mysteries 1)’ on behalf of Rosie Amber’s review team (#RBRT). I received a complimentary review copy, but my opinions are my own and my review is honest.
December 1, 2025
Originally posted on Dreaming With Open Eyes
A murder that proves even the cheesiest festival can turn deadly.
🕵️♀️ Café Manager Turned Sleuth | 🔑 A Tight-Knit Community with Big Secrets | 🧀 Food Descriptions That Make You Hungry | Vermont (New England), USA
A cozy mystery set during a Summer Cheese festival? That concept alone had me hooked. So when Jodie Morgan reached out and asked if I’d like to review the first book in her Silver Springs Mystery series, I couldn’t resist. The timing was perfect—caught between books and wondering what to pick up next, I dove straight into Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival and found myself pleasantly surprised.
Laura Evans leaves behind the chaos of her fast-paced Boston restaurant job in Boston and heads to Vermont for a fresh start, managing the café at the Silver Springs General Store. She wants peace, quiet, and maybe even a chance to breathe. But life has other plans. With the Summer Cheese Festival approaching and a notoriously harsh food critic back in town, tension is already thick. Then a body is discovered after a private tasting, and suddenly Laura’s boss, Maggie, becomes the prime suspect. Wanting to protect her job and the people she’s quickly grown to care about, Laura teams up with her wonderfully perceptive landlady, Evelyn Chan. As they begin to peel back the layers of Silver Springs, it becomes clear that this seemingly idyllic town has secrets—thorny, dangerous secrets.
💛 What I Loved
• A fresh and engaging premise. A cheese-festival mystery? It felt fresh, fun, and unlike anything I’ve read before, which made the plot instantly appealing.
• Accessible, smooth writing. Jodie’s writing style made it easy to sink into the story from page one.
• A warm small-town setting. I’m a sucker for cozy communities, and Silver Springs delivers that atmosphere beautifully.
• The delicious food descriptions. Seriously, don’t read this on an empty stomach. The food descriptions were so vivid, so mouth-watering, they made me hungry more than just once.
• Impressive research. The author clearly invested time into understanding cheese production, and those details enriched the story.
• A mystery that kept me guessing. I didn’t guess the murderer until the reveal, which is always a win for me.
• A satisfying wrap-up. All loose ends were tied up in a clear and thoughtful way.
💛 What Didn’t Work for Me ((This is purely personal taste))
• Third-person POV. While well written, third person isn’t my preferred point of view. I tend to enjoy first person more.
• Too many characters introduced too quickly. After the lovely café opening scene, I suddenly felt overwhelmed by a rapid influx of names. I even started taking notes, only to discover a character compendium at the end of the book. I really wish I had known about it earlier!
• Difficulty connecting with Laura. Although she’s the protagonist, but we learn very little about her emotionally or personally. Just hints about her grandmother, her move from Boston, and a few family dynamics. I wanted more depth to truly understand her.
• The town felt like the main character. At times, it seemed like everyone was involved in solving the mystery, which diluted Laura’s role as the sleuth.
⭐ Final Thoughts
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival is a warm, inviting cozy mystery with a charming setting, mouth-watering food descriptions, and a mystery that kept me guessing. If you enjoy your cozies sprinkled with culinary flair, this one will hit the spot. Would I recommend it? Absolutely! If you love small-town cozies, food-centered mysteries, and stories filled with community spirit, this book is absolutely worth picking up.
I kindly received this book via the author in exchange for an honest review. Thank you so much Jodie Morgan and Cozy Cozies.
((rating 3.75 rounded to 4))
A murder that proves even the cheesiest festival can turn deadly.
🕵️♀️ Café Manager Turned Sleuth | 🔑 A Tight-Knit Community with Big Secrets | 🧀 Food Descriptions That Make You Hungry | Vermont (New England), USA
A cozy mystery set during a Summer Cheese festival? That concept alone had me hooked. So when Jodie Morgan reached out and asked if I’d like to review the first book in her Silver Springs Mystery series, I couldn’t resist. The timing was perfect—caught between books and wondering what to pick up next, I dove straight into Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival and found myself pleasantly surprised.
Laura Evans leaves behind the chaos of her fast-paced Boston restaurant job in Boston and heads to Vermont for a fresh start, managing the café at the Silver Springs General Store. She wants peace, quiet, and maybe even a chance to breathe. But life has other plans. With the Summer Cheese Festival approaching and a notoriously harsh food critic back in town, tension is already thick. Then a body is discovered after a private tasting, and suddenly Laura’s boss, Maggie, becomes the prime suspect. Wanting to protect her job and the people she’s quickly grown to care about, Laura teams up with her wonderfully perceptive landlady, Evelyn Chan. As they begin to peel back the layers of Silver Springs, it becomes clear that this seemingly idyllic town has secrets—thorny, dangerous secrets.
💛 What I Loved
• A fresh and engaging premise. A cheese-festival mystery? It felt fresh, fun, and unlike anything I’ve read before, which made the plot instantly appealing.
• Accessible, smooth writing. Jodie’s writing style made it easy to sink into the story from page one.
• A warm small-town setting. I’m a sucker for cozy communities, and Silver Springs delivers that atmosphere beautifully.
• The delicious food descriptions. Seriously, don’t read this on an empty stomach. The food descriptions were so vivid, so mouth-watering, they made me hungry more than just once.
• Impressive research. The author clearly invested time into understanding cheese production, and those details enriched the story.
• A mystery that kept me guessing. I didn’t guess the murderer until the reveal, which is always a win for me.
• A satisfying wrap-up. All loose ends were tied up in a clear and thoughtful way.
💛 What Didn’t Work for Me ((This is purely personal taste))
• Third-person POV. While well written, third person isn’t my preferred point of view. I tend to enjoy first person more.
• Too many characters introduced too quickly. After the lovely café opening scene, I suddenly felt overwhelmed by a rapid influx of names. I even started taking notes, only to discover a character compendium at the end of the book. I really wish I had known about it earlier!
• Difficulty connecting with Laura. Although she’s the protagonist, but we learn very little about her emotionally or personally. Just hints about her grandmother, her move from Boston, and a few family dynamics. I wanted more depth to truly understand her.
• The town felt like the main character. At times, it seemed like everyone was involved in solving the mystery, which diluted Laura’s role as the sleuth.
⭐ Final Thoughts
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival is a warm, inviting cozy mystery with a charming setting, mouth-watering food descriptions, and a mystery that kept me guessing. If you enjoy your cozies sprinkled with culinary flair, this one will hit the spot. Would I recommend it? Absolutely! If you love small-town cozies, food-centered mysteries, and stories filled with community spirit, this book is absolutely worth picking up.
I kindly received this book via the author in exchange for an honest review. Thank you so much Jodie Morgan and Cozy Cozies.
((rating 3.75 rounded to 4))
December 29, 2025
DNF at 56% | ★★☆☆☆ (2/5)
I went into Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival expecting cozy mystery comfort, and while the book has many of the ingredients of a cozy, it never quite came together to make a cohesive story.
One of my biggest struggles started in the very first chapter. Laura sits down to talk with her boss about the cafe being reviewed (an important enough moment to actually sit down to have a conversation), but it never actually happens on the page. The scene shifts inward, Laura doubts herself, and then the story moves on without returning to that conversation. Sitting down signals narrative weight; if it's not going to unfold, it feels like it should have been mentioned in passing instead. The moment made me feel like I was missing something, and unfortunately, that feeling lingered.
There's also repetition early on that stalls momentum. The book states at the end of chapter one that Jeremy's last review nearly ruined the cafe, then repeats the same information just four paragraphs into chapter two. Rather than reinforcing the tension, it flattened it.
Tone-wise, this book sits near cozy but never quite lands on it. It has the small town setting, the food-centric hook, and a broad cast of characters, but I never felt that warm, inviting "curl up and sink in" feeling. Instead, the pacing felt slow without being leisurely. The best way I can describe it is like dragging a dog who doesn't want to walk: forward movement exists within, but nothing is really happening.
At nearly 50% in, the mystery hadn’t meaningfully progressed, the emotional stakes felt thin, and even the “finding connection” aspect of the story was underdeveloped. Laura, as a protagonist, came across as too soft—not in a bad way inherently, but to the point where she bends herself in half to accommodate others over the smallest things. Rather than endearing, it became frustrating.
The writing itself often felt uncertain, like a debut where the author hasn’t fully found their footing yet. Some phrasing felt awkward, and the time period felt inconsistent. I couldn’t quite tell whether the story was meant to feel modern or nostalgic—references like “Jeepers” and paninis aren’t inherently tied to one era, but the overall effect was disorienting rather than intentional.
That said, the characters aren’t poorly written. They’re not deeply layered, but they aren’t flat either, and I appreciated the diversity within the cast. Thomas, in particular, stood out as my favorite character and the one I felt most connected to.
Ultimately, I had to DNF at 56%. And that’s the real issue for me: what you don’t want in a cozy mystery—or any mystery—is to feel like you’re slogging through it. By the time I stopped, I honestly didn’t care who committed the murder or why, and once that curiosity is gone, there’s nothing left to carry the story forward.
I went into Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival expecting cozy mystery comfort, and while the book has many of the ingredients of a cozy, it never quite came together to make a cohesive story.
One of my biggest struggles started in the very first chapter. Laura sits down to talk with her boss about the cafe being reviewed (an important enough moment to actually sit down to have a conversation), but it never actually happens on the page. The scene shifts inward, Laura doubts herself, and then the story moves on without returning to that conversation. Sitting down signals narrative weight; if it's not going to unfold, it feels like it should have been mentioned in passing instead. The moment made me feel like I was missing something, and unfortunately, that feeling lingered.
There's also repetition early on that stalls momentum. The book states at the end of chapter one that Jeremy's last review nearly ruined the cafe, then repeats the same information just four paragraphs into chapter two. Rather than reinforcing the tension, it flattened it.
Tone-wise, this book sits near cozy but never quite lands on it. It has the small town setting, the food-centric hook, and a broad cast of characters, but I never felt that warm, inviting "curl up and sink in" feeling. Instead, the pacing felt slow without being leisurely. The best way I can describe it is like dragging a dog who doesn't want to walk: forward movement exists within, but nothing is really happening.
At nearly 50% in, the mystery hadn’t meaningfully progressed, the emotional stakes felt thin, and even the “finding connection” aspect of the story was underdeveloped. Laura, as a protagonist, came across as too soft—not in a bad way inherently, but to the point where she bends herself in half to accommodate others over the smallest things. Rather than endearing, it became frustrating.
The writing itself often felt uncertain, like a debut where the author hasn’t fully found their footing yet. Some phrasing felt awkward, and the time period felt inconsistent. I couldn’t quite tell whether the story was meant to feel modern or nostalgic—references like “Jeepers” and paninis aren’t inherently tied to one era, but the overall effect was disorienting rather than intentional.
That said, the characters aren’t poorly written. They’re not deeply layered, but they aren’t flat either, and I appreciated the diversity within the cast. Thomas, in particular, stood out as my favorite character and the one I felt most connected to.
Ultimately, I had to DNF at 56%. And that’s the real issue for me: what you don’t want in a cozy mystery—or any mystery—is to feel like you’re slogging through it. By the time I stopped, I honestly didn’t care who committed the murder or why, and once that curiosity is gone, there’s nothing left to carry the story forward.
December 10, 2025
"Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival" by Jodie Morgan is a charming cozy mystery set in the picturesque town of Silver Springs, Vermont, where a summer cheese festival becomes the unlikely backdrop for murder. The novel immediately stands out for its warm, small-town atmosphere: bustling stalls, artisan cheese boards, and community traditions create a vivid sense of place that feels both idyllic and lived-in. Against this inviting backdrop, the discovery of a body injects an undercurrent of tension that keeps the pages turning without ever tipping into grim territory. The balance between comfort and crime is finely handled, making the book ideal for readers who want intrigue without graphic darkness.
The focal point of the story is a protagonist who feels relatable rather than larger-than-life, navigating family, friendships, and community obligations even as she’s pulled deeper into the investigation. The relationships in Silver Springs are one of the book’s biggest strengths: neighbors, shopkeepers, and festival organizers all have distinct personalities that contribute to a believable network of loyalties, secrets, and long-held grudges. Morgan uses the festival setting cleverly to bring suspects together in organic ways, whether around tastings, demonstrations, or behind-the-scenes prep. These interactions give the mystery a social richness and a sense of emotional stakes beyond simply “whodunit.”
The mystery itself is classic cozy fare: clues are sprinkled steadily, red herrings are convincing without feeling gimmicky, and the final reveal is satisfying in both motive and method. Morgan plays fair with the reader—observant fans of the genre will enjoy piecing together the trail of hints woven into conversations, local gossip, and festival mishaps. Thematically, the book also touches lightly on belonging and identity: what it means to be a “lifelong local,” how communities decide who is welcomed in, and how a town’s public image can mask more complicated truths. Those layers give the story just enough depth to linger after the solution is revealed.
Stylistically, the prose is warm and inviting, with sensory details that make the food and setting especially vivid—this is the kind of mystery that will make readers crave cheese plates and cozy evenings. Dialogue feels natural and often gently humorous, helping to keep the tone buoyant even as the investigation escalates. Overall, Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival delivers exactly what a cozy mystery promises: a lovingly drawn community, a clever but comforting puzzle, and the pleasure of seeing order restored. It is a delightful series entry (or starting point) for readers who enjoy small-town mysteries anchored by heart, atmosphere, and a strong sense of place.
The focal point of the story is a protagonist who feels relatable rather than larger-than-life, navigating family, friendships, and community obligations even as she’s pulled deeper into the investigation. The relationships in Silver Springs are one of the book’s biggest strengths: neighbors, shopkeepers, and festival organizers all have distinct personalities that contribute to a believable network of loyalties, secrets, and long-held grudges. Morgan uses the festival setting cleverly to bring suspects together in organic ways, whether around tastings, demonstrations, or behind-the-scenes prep. These interactions give the mystery a social richness and a sense of emotional stakes beyond simply “whodunit.”
The mystery itself is classic cozy fare: clues are sprinkled steadily, red herrings are convincing without feeling gimmicky, and the final reveal is satisfying in both motive and method. Morgan plays fair with the reader—observant fans of the genre will enjoy piecing together the trail of hints woven into conversations, local gossip, and festival mishaps. Thematically, the book also touches lightly on belonging and identity: what it means to be a “lifelong local,” how communities decide who is welcomed in, and how a town’s public image can mask more complicated truths. Those layers give the story just enough depth to linger after the solution is revealed.
Stylistically, the prose is warm and inviting, with sensory details that make the food and setting especially vivid—this is the kind of mystery that will make readers crave cheese plates and cozy evenings. Dialogue feels natural and often gently humorous, helping to keep the tone buoyant even as the investigation escalates. Overall, Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival delivers exactly what a cozy mystery promises: a lovingly drawn community, a clever but comforting puzzle, and the pleasure of seeing order restored. It is a delightful series entry (or starting point) for readers who enjoy small-town mysteries anchored by heart, atmosphere, and a strong sense of place.
October 21, 2025
Sometimes you just need a good cozy mystery to snuggle up with and enjoy. A book you can solve along with some fun and friendly characters in a place that takes you away from wherever you are.
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival did just that for me. It welcomed me to Silver Springs with open arms, and I am really excited to see where people of this town take me next!
But back to the story at hand.
Laura Evans Moves from Boston to the small town of Silver Springs to try a slower pace of life after a high stress career in high-end restaurants. Everything is going great, as the town prepares for its annual cheese festival, but tensions are high as one of the annual judges, a surly formerly highly respected food critic hence he has secrets that could take down several people in the town. The next day, Laura finds his dead body, and everyone suspects her boss, Maggie, as the culprit with the help of her landlady, Laura sets out to prove that Maggie is innocent, but she finds that the town is full of suspects and that there’s plenty of secrets in this charming small town.
I loved getting to know everyone in Silver Springs because there was a great cast of characters around Laura and the author really nailed what it was like to live in a small town, having grown up in one just like Silver Springs. I definitely liked how there were plenty of suspects in red herrings, so I did not solve the mystery before it was revealed. And when it was, I was pretty surprised because, again, there were some red herrings that had led me astray. I’ll admit to falling for them!
Laura was a great protagonist and I can totally relate to the feeling of wanting to start over, even if people will question your choices (in Laura’s case her mom!). Also, the secondary cast really added to the story, with plenty of characters to keep you laughing and intrigued throughout the entire book. I’m intrigued to see where some of them are going and where they will end up in some of the mysteries to come.
As hinted above, this is the beginning of a series, so there’s definitely plenty of room for more to be revealed and more sleuthing for Laura and her landlady Evelyn to do and I really can’t wait!
If you’re looking for a good cozy to snuggle in with this fall, pick this one up, you won’t be disappointed!
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival did just that for me. It welcomed me to Silver Springs with open arms, and I am really excited to see where people of this town take me next!
But back to the story at hand.
Laura Evans Moves from Boston to the small town of Silver Springs to try a slower pace of life after a high stress career in high-end restaurants. Everything is going great, as the town prepares for its annual cheese festival, but tensions are high as one of the annual judges, a surly formerly highly respected food critic hence he has secrets that could take down several people in the town. The next day, Laura finds his dead body, and everyone suspects her boss, Maggie, as the culprit with the help of her landlady, Laura sets out to prove that Maggie is innocent, but she finds that the town is full of suspects and that there’s plenty of secrets in this charming small town.
I loved getting to know everyone in Silver Springs because there was a great cast of characters around Laura and the author really nailed what it was like to live in a small town, having grown up in one just like Silver Springs. I definitely liked how there were plenty of suspects in red herrings, so I did not solve the mystery before it was revealed. And when it was, I was pretty surprised because, again, there were some red herrings that had led me astray. I’ll admit to falling for them!
Laura was a great protagonist and I can totally relate to the feeling of wanting to start over, even if people will question your choices (in Laura’s case her mom!). Also, the secondary cast really added to the story, with plenty of characters to keep you laughing and intrigued throughout the entire book. I’m intrigued to see where some of them are going and where they will end up in some of the mysteries to come.
As hinted above, this is the beginning of a series, so there’s definitely plenty of room for more to be revealed and more sleuthing for Laura and her landlady Evelyn to do and I really can’t wait!
If you’re looking for a good cozy to snuggle in with this fall, pick this one up, you won’t be disappointed!
October 24, 2025
This cozy mystery was a treat for both my mystery-loving heart and my cheese-loving brain. Think small-town charm, quirky cheese vendors, and a murder that doesn't skimp on the gouda puns. From triple cremes to tangy Gouda, the cheese facts alone could make anyone a connoisseur.
Laura Evans made for an intriguing amateur sleuth. Despite being new to town, her loyalty to her community shines through, even when it means clashing with her mother. A newcomer with heart, grit, and a growing sense of belonging in her quirky town. Her loyalty to those she barely knows struck a chord. That theme of belonging and found family really resonated with me. The idea that home isn’t where you come from, but where you’re truly seen and valued, is so true and close to heart.
Laura’s connection with her boss Maggie and landlady Evelyn Chan felt genuine and warm, even when the murder mystery itself took a few abrupt turns. Sure, character arcs felt a tad patchy in spots, and some clues wrapped up quicker than a cheese platter vanishes at a party. But the warmth and witty banter kept me flipping pages, forgiving the minor hiccups in this delightful cozy mystery read.
Would I recommend it?
As a cozy mystery, it hits all the right notes: food, friendship, and just enough danger to make you keep the lights on a little longer. The sense of belonging Laura feels is something I could personally relate to. Once you find your place, it’s yours to defend, fiercely and lovingly. Perfect for fans of light suspense and dairy dreams
Feeling Cheesy Yet? 🧀
If you could create your own festival mystery, what would the theme be — wine, chocolate, or books? Tell me in the comments!
📱📖 Read on Kindle
⏱ Duration: 4 hours
🏷️ Self-published
📚 Genre: Cozy Mystery
Laura Evans made for an intriguing amateur sleuth. Despite being new to town, her loyalty to her community shines through, even when it means clashing with her mother. A newcomer with heart, grit, and a growing sense of belonging in her quirky town. Her loyalty to those she barely knows struck a chord. That theme of belonging and found family really resonated with me. The idea that home isn’t where you come from, but where you’re truly seen and valued, is so true and close to heart.
Laura’s connection with her boss Maggie and landlady Evelyn Chan felt genuine and warm, even when the murder mystery itself took a few abrupt turns. Sure, character arcs felt a tad patchy in spots, and some clues wrapped up quicker than a cheese platter vanishes at a party. But the warmth and witty banter kept me flipping pages, forgiving the minor hiccups in this delightful cozy mystery read.
Would I recommend it?
As a cozy mystery, it hits all the right notes: food, friendship, and just enough danger to make you keep the lights on a little longer. The sense of belonging Laura feels is something I could personally relate to. Once you find your place, it’s yours to defend, fiercely and lovingly. Perfect for fans of light suspense and dairy dreams
Feeling Cheesy Yet? 🧀
If you could create your own festival mystery, what would the theme be — wine, chocolate, or books? Tell me in the comments!
📱📖 Read on Kindle
⏱ Duration: 4 hours
🏷️ Self-published
📚 Genre: Cozy Mystery
December 20, 2025
The first in a new series set in a quaint little town in Vermont offered a picturesque setting with affable characters... and murder.
Laura is new to town, having taken over running a cafe. She is well-versed in the restaurant world, having left Boston and perhaps a not-so-ideal situation. However, she seems to have found her niche and after only a few days, has taken to the people and her position. Perhaps because her grandparents lived there, and she is familiar with the town. Things are going smoothly until she discovers the body of a food critic, and the police believe her boss is to blame. This sets her on the path to uncovering the truth, along with her landlady.
This mystery is well written, and I did not suspect the killer until the name was revealed. I honestly couldn't figure out who it might be since there were many with a motive to want him dead. I like how Laura was methodical about deciphering the information provided to her, but she also didn't hide anything from the police. Granted, they did not want her involved, but then what police force wants an amateur sleuth on the case?
There are a few mysteries sprinkled throughout the book besides the murder, all tied to the cheese festival. Seems like many people are hiding secrets. All is revealed in the end.
While I am not a cheese connoisseur, I enjoyed the descriptions and other cheese details. The book is a culinary feast for the imagination, from the menus to the varieties of cheese available.
There is even a philanthropic angle with the craft group that Laura is invited to join. You'll have to read the book to find out what I mean.
This book is well written, and I can't wait to see what else the author has in store for Laura and the gang. We give the book 4 paws up.
Laura is new to town, having taken over running a cafe. She is well-versed in the restaurant world, having left Boston and perhaps a not-so-ideal situation. However, she seems to have found her niche and after only a few days, has taken to the people and her position. Perhaps because her grandparents lived there, and she is familiar with the town. Things are going smoothly until she discovers the body of a food critic, and the police believe her boss is to blame. This sets her on the path to uncovering the truth, along with her landlady.
This mystery is well written, and I did not suspect the killer until the name was revealed. I honestly couldn't figure out who it might be since there were many with a motive to want him dead. I like how Laura was methodical about deciphering the information provided to her, but she also didn't hide anything from the police. Granted, they did not want her involved, but then what police force wants an amateur sleuth on the case?
There are a few mysteries sprinkled throughout the book besides the murder, all tied to the cheese festival. Seems like many people are hiding secrets. All is revealed in the end.
While I am not a cheese connoisseur, I enjoyed the descriptions and other cheese details. The book is a culinary feast for the imagination, from the menus to the varieties of cheese available.
There is even a philanthropic angle with the craft group that Laura is invited to join. You'll have to read the book to find out what I mean.
This book is well written, and I can't wait to see what else the author has in store for Laura and the gang. We give the book 4 paws up.
December 17, 2025
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival (Silver Springs Mysteries Book 1) by Jodie Morgan
4 Stars
246 Pages
Publisher: Cozy Cozies
Release Date: September 18, 2025
Fiction, Mystery, Cozy Mystery, Small Town, Amateur Detective, Vermont, Cheese
Laura Evans has recently relocated from her life in Boston to the small town of Silver Springs, Vermont. She is the new café manager of the Silver Springs General Store. They are preparing for one of the biggest events of the year, the Cheese Festival. Jeremy Blackstone, a food journalist arrives and brushes too many people the wrong way. He is threatening to uncover the town’s secrets. Someone does not want a secret to be known, and Jeremy is found dead in the stables of the Silver Springs General Store. Maggie Brooks, one of the owners, is the main suspect. Laura steps into action and begins investigating with the help of Evelyn, her landlady. Together they visit potential suspects and put themselves in the middle of the investigation.
The story has a quick pace, the characters are well developed, and it is written in the third person point of view. I found the crew at the café to be quirky and would love to sit in on a staff meeting. They range from young hard working to retired. They even have a craft club if you want to be creative. If you enjoy cozy mysteries, I believe you would like this book. I look forward to reading more from this author.
4 Stars
246 Pages
Publisher: Cozy Cozies
Release Date: September 18, 2025
Fiction, Mystery, Cozy Mystery, Small Town, Amateur Detective, Vermont, Cheese
Laura Evans has recently relocated from her life in Boston to the small town of Silver Springs, Vermont. She is the new café manager of the Silver Springs General Store. They are preparing for one of the biggest events of the year, the Cheese Festival. Jeremy Blackstone, a food journalist arrives and brushes too many people the wrong way. He is threatening to uncover the town’s secrets. Someone does not want a secret to be known, and Jeremy is found dead in the stables of the Silver Springs General Store. Maggie Brooks, one of the owners, is the main suspect. Laura steps into action and begins investigating with the help of Evelyn, her landlady. Together they visit potential suspects and put themselves in the middle of the investigation.
The story has a quick pace, the characters are well developed, and it is written in the third person point of view. I found the crew at the café to be quirky and would love to sit in on a staff meeting. They range from young hard working to retired. They even have a craft club if you want to be creative. If you enjoy cozy mysteries, I believe you would like this book. I look forward to reading more from this author.
January 12, 2026
I chose to read Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival as a member of Rosie’s Book Review Team. I received a copy from the author, but that doesn’t alter my review in any way.
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival is the first whodunnit in a new cosy mystery series set in a lovely small town in Vermont. Laura Evans has escaped her life in Boston to become the manager of a café, where she swiftly and enthusiastically settles into small town life. The cheese festival is looming just as a food critic is found dead, and Laura, worried for her boss, Maggie, who appears to be being framed, sets out to discover who the murderer is.
I didn’t guess who the murderer was, but then I tend not to turn amateur detective when I’m reading, relying instead on the author to reveal who did what and why in their own good time. Which is exactly what happened, leaving none of those pesky loose ends.
This is a well-written cosy mystery, which follows all the rules of such mysteries and is therefore a comfortable read. There are a lot of characters to keep track of and much information about cheese, which was informative, although I kept feeling a little peckish as I read as I do love cheese! If you enjoy whodunnits, then this new series might well be one you can get your teeth into. I can certainly recommend it.
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival is the first whodunnit in a new cosy mystery series set in a lovely small town in Vermont. Laura Evans has escaped her life in Boston to become the manager of a café, where she swiftly and enthusiastically settles into small town life. The cheese festival is looming just as a food critic is found dead, and Laura, worried for her boss, Maggie, who appears to be being framed, sets out to discover who the murderer is.
I didn’t guess who the murderer was, but then I tend not to turn amateur detective when I’m reading, relying instead on the author to reveal who did what and why in their own good time. Which is exactly what happened, leaving none of those pesky loose ends.
This is a well-written cosy mystery, which follows all the rules of such mysteries and is therefore a comfortable read. There are a lot of characters to keep track of and much information about cheese, which was informative, although I kept feeling a little peckish as I read as I do love cheese! If you enjoy whodunnits, then this new series might well be one you can get your teeth into. I can certainly recommend it.
December 2, 2025
Murder mystery, small town setting and Cheese - three of my favourite things all in one book!
Silver Springs is a small town in Vermont town. You know, the kind where everyone knows everyone else, you can't toot in public without it doing the rounds on the town grapevine? Laura wants somewhere the complete opposite of Boston and it looks like shoe's found the new start she was looking for.
Finding the body of a restaurant reviewer, Jeremy Lockwood, in her restaurant is NOT a great start to her new life. He had given Laura a bad review, so needless to say she's now on the suspect list too!
I loved the found family vibes Laura has with Evelyn, they were partners in crime from the off. I got an education in all things cheese - no bad thing for me! Oscar the cat was a great wee addition to their family vibes - everyone needs a pet. I did feel sorry for Officer Ramirez - the woman is just trying to do her job and these amateurs keep getting all up in her business, lol. But even she has to admit that Laura and Co make a few great finds.
I loved the descriptive settings for the various scenes and having never visited the USA myself, I felt like it matched what I know of the New England area from various books and movies set there and I felt instantly at home in Silver Springs.
A shoe-in for all cosy mystery lovers!
Silver Springs is a small town in Vermont town. You know, the kind where everyone knows everyone else, you can't toot in public without it doing the rounds on the town grapevine? Laura wants somewhere the complete opposite of Boston and it looks like shoe's found the new start she was looking for.
Finding the body of a restaurant reviewer, Jeremy Lockwood, in her restaurant is NOT a great start to her new life. He had given Laura a bad review, so needless to say she's now on the suspect list too!
I loved the found family vibes Laura has with Evelyn, they were partners in crime from the off. I got an education in all things cheese - no bad thing for me! Oscar the cat was a great wee addition to their family vibes - everyone needs a pet. I did feel sorry for Officer Ramirez - the woman is just trying to do her job and these amateurs keep getting all up in her business, lol. But even she has to admit that Laura and Co make a few great finds.
I loved the descriptive settings for the various scenes and having never visited the USA myself, I felt like it matched what I know of the New England area from various books and movies set there and I felt instantly at home in Silver Springs.
A shoe-in for all cosy mystery lovers!
October 6, 2025
Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival by Jodie
Morgan is the kind of cozy mystery that wraps around you like a warm blanket on a rainy day. Set against the charming backdrop of a small-town cheese festival (yes, please!), this story is packed with quirky characters, delicious atmosphere, and a mystery that's both clever and satisfying. Jodie Morgan's writing is sharp yet comforting, with just the right amount of humor and heart. I laughed, I guessed (wrong), and I didn't want it to end.
If you love cozy mysteries with food, fun, and just a touch of murder-this is one book you absolutely need on your shelf.
Morgan is the kind of cozy mystery that wraps around you like a warm blanket on a rainy day. Set against the charming backdrop of a small-town cheese festival (yes, please!), this story is packed with quirky characters, delicious atmosphere, and a mystery that's both clever and satisfying. Jodie Morgan's writing is sharp yet comforting, with just the right amount of humor and heart. I laughed, I guessed (wrong), and I didn't want it to end.
If you love cozy mysteries with food, fun, and just a touch of murder-this is one book you absolutely need on your shelf.
November 27, 2025
Although I don’t have much experience living in small towns like the one where this took place, I have enough experience to recognize the accuracy of the town depicted here with the small-town vibe, both positive and negative qualities being involved. These qualities add color and in some ways expands the viable theories in getting to the solution of the mystery. A likeable protagonist who is learning about the town along with the reader also helps the reader relate well to the story. If you like cozy mysteries, this should definitely do the trick.
**Originally written for "Books and Pals" book blog. May have received a free review copy. **
**Originally written for "Books and Pals" book blog. May have received a free review copy. **
February 1, 2026
A cozy mystery indeed.
If you enjoy a good Hallmark movie now and then, this fun and easy read will not disappoint. Laura is a likeable protagonist and the mystery is not as predictable as those movies often are.
Its a who-done-it about small-town life and artisanal cheese, but its also about starting over and found family.
If you enjoy a good Hallmark movie now and then, this fun and easy read will not disappoint. Laura is a likeable protagonist and the mystery is not as predictable as those movies often are.
Its a who-done-it about small-town life and artisanal cheese, but its also about starting over and found family.
September 23, 2025
Enjoyable read, lots of interesting characters. I liked how the author knew what she was talking about in the different craft projects, not like someone saying she was knitting with one crochet hook! I think as kept guessing until the very end
February 9, 2026
I'm biased, of course, because I wrote this! But if you like cozy mysteries with culinary and craft themes, justice being served, secrets aplenty, strong friendships, found family, authentic characters, fresh starts, and welcoming communities...you might enjoy reading it!
------------------
Frequently Asked Questions About The Silver Springs Mysteries
Q: Do I Need To Read The Books In Order?
A: I'd recommend it, but I've written them so you don't have to! You can read each book and short story as standalones without any prior knowledge.
Q: Do The Books Contain Any Explicit/Graphic Content Or Profanity?
A: No, none of my books have any explicit or graphic content, and nor do they have any profanity.
Q: Do The Books Contain Paranormal Elements?
A: No, they don’t. No talking cats and dogs or sleuths with psychic abilities. They’re just regular cozies.
Q: Does Each Book Have A Complete Mystery?
A: Yes, always! Every book I write is a complete, standalone mystery, with justice served and all loose ends tied up.
Q: How Long Are The Books?
A: The novels are usually 50-70 thousand words long, and the short stories are 3-15 thousand words.
Q: How Many Books Are In The Series?
A: So far, there are two novels and six accompanying short stories published. I'm currently editing Book 3, and I've got twelve planned, with more to come!
Q: What Else Do These Books Contain?
A: They contain queer/lgbt+ characters, including ones who use they/them/their pronouns.
Q: What Formats Are The Books Available In?
A: You can get them in eBook and print format (paperback and hardcover) in dyslexic, large, and regular print editions. No box sets, bookstacks, or bundles yet, but they're coming!
Q: What Kind Of Mysteries Are Featured?
A: All novels in the series feature mysteries with culinary and crafts themes. The short stories are a little more varied, with everything from a botanical mystery to a bookstore mystery, but there's always good food and crafting involved.
Q: What Language/Version Of English Are The Books Written In?
A: The books are written in American English, with American spelling and terminology.
Q: What Perspective Is It Written In?
A: All books in the Silver Springs Mysteries are written in limited third-person point-of-view, from the main character's perspective.
Q: Where Is The Series Set?
A: The series takes place in the fictional town of Silver Springs, in Maplewood County, Vermont, in the United States.
Q: Who's The Main Character?
A: The main character is Laura Evans, a former restaurant manager from Boston turned café manager in a small town in Vermont. She's kind, loyal, observant, empathetic, and always willing to lend a hand.
------------------
Frequently Asked Questions About The Silver Springs Mysteries
Q: Do I Need To Read The Books In Order?
A: I'd recommend it, but I've written them so you don't have to! You can read each book and short story as standalones without any prior knowledge.
Q: Do The Books Contain Any Explicit/Graphic Content Or Profanity?
A: No, none of my books have any explicit or graphic content, and nor do they have any profanity.
Q: Do The Books Contain Paranormal Elements?
A: No, they don’t. No talking cats and dogs or sleuths with psychic abilities. They’re just regular cozies.
Q: Does Each Book Have A Complete Mystery?
A: Yes, always! Every book I write is a complete, standalone mystery, with justice served and all loose ends tied up.
Q: How Long Are The Books?
A: The novels are usually 50-70 thousand words long, and the short stories are 3-15 thousand words.
Q: How Many Books Are In The Series?
A: So far, there are two novels and six accompanying short stories published. I'm currently editing Book 3, and I've got twelve planned, with more to come!
Q: What Else Do These Books Contain?
A: They contain queer/lgbt+ characters, including ones who use they/them/their pronouns.
Q: What Formats Are The Books Available In?
A: You can get them in eBook and print format (paperback and hardcover) in dyslexic, large, and regular print editions. No box sets, bookstacks, or bundles yet, but they're coming!
Q: What Kind Of Mysteries Are Featured?
A: All novels in the series feature mysteries with culinary and crafts themes. The short stories are a little more varied, with everything from a botanical mystery to a bookstore mystery, but there's always good food and crafting involved.
Q: What Language/Version Of English Are The Books Written In?
A: The books are written in American English, with American spelling and terminology.
Q: What Perspective Is It Written In?
A: All books in the Silver Springs Mysteries are written in limited third-person point-of-view, from the main character's perspective.
Q: Where Is The Series Set?
A: The series takes place in the fictional town of Silver Springs, in Maplewood County, Vermont, in the United States.
Q: Who's The Main Character?
A: The main character is Laura Evans, a former restaurant manager from Boston turned café manager in a small town in Vermont. She's kind, loyal, observant, empathetic, and always willing to lend a hand.
January 31, 2026
~ 4.5 ⭐
On my opinion, Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival was a truly wonderful small-town cozy mystery filled to the brim with friendship, community, and belonging. We follow Laura as she tries to make a fresh start at Silver Springs, a small town in Vermont. However, a murder dashes her plans and leaves her concerned for those important to her. I loved the warmth and kindness Laura exhibited in all her interactions. She truly is a very engaging and understanding character. I loved how the author showed various characters interacting, and how different the relationship dynamics were. I also really loved the pace of the story.
With cozy mysteries, there's sometimes a lull period for me when I reach the middle, but there was none of that here. I loved everything about the Summer Cheese Festival, from the tasting to the demonstrations. I never thought I'd be so engrossed by reading someone make cheese, but here we are! Laura's persistence in finding the truth is truly inspiring and I love how she was able to put two and two together. There were some moments I felt Laura was a little too successful at getting information, but overall I loved following her investigation.
Lastly, I'm obsessed with the Maplewood Crafters Club, and I'm so jealous that I can't be a part of it (especially since my crafting skills are abysmal). I can't say enough about the way Jodie Morgan writes about food, I loved every second of it.
On my opinion, Murder at the Summer Cheese Festival was a truly wonderful small-town cozy mystery filled to the brim with friendship, community, and belonging. We follow Laura as she tries to make a fresh start at Silver Springs, a small town in Vermont. However, a murder dashes her plans and leaves her concerned for those important to her. I loved the warmth and kindness Laura exhibited in all her interactions. She truly is a very engaging and understanding character. I loved how the author showed various characters interacting, and how different the relationship dynamics were. I also really loved the pace of the story.
With cozy mysteries, there's sometimes a lull period for me when I reach the middle, but there was none of that here. I loved everything about the Summer Cheese Festival, from the tasting to the demonstrations. I never thought I'd be so engrossed by reading someone make cheese, but here we are! Laura's persistence in finding the truth is truly inspiring and I love how she was able to put two and two together. There were some moments I felt Laura was a little too successful at getting information, but overall I loved following her investigation.
Lastly, I'm obsessed with the Maplewood Crafters Club, and I'm so jealous that I can't be a part of it (especially since my crafting skills are abysmal). I can't say enough about the way Jodie Morgan writes about food, I loved every second of it.
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews