Up until the very end, this was a 5-star book in my mind. The reader was fully invested in Tuesday's life, and Inmon was able to evoke a lot of emotion in Tuesday's struggles. I felt confident that this was going to be in his top 5 Middle Falls books, but with the ending, it dropped a bit. Well worth the read, and afterwards, I'd be curious to see how many people agree that there was an error in the machine's rewinding of her lives.
Spoiler:
While all readers expected that Tuesday would eventually, definitively get her legs back in one of her repeated lives, Inmon chose not to give Tuesday her legs back. I 100% understand why he made that decision, as he explains it in the afterword of the book. He chose not to give Tuesday her legs back…because she was not broken. However, I think Inmon robbed the reader (and Tuesday) of a tremendously moving moment. This book was one of his better ones, so i don't mean to imply that the book fails due to this decision; it does not. I do, however, believe it was a mistake. Inmon, the machine, Charles Weaver, or whoever is controlling Tuesday's lives was able to make the same point that he/it did, and STILL giver Tuesday her legs back eventually. Throughout the whole book, I expected her to eventually get her legs back, while making sure to marry the same man, and adopt the same child. Along the way, she would’ve abandoned volleyball and/or gymnastics, whether because she realized how many more important things there are in the world, or maybe because she now lacked the courage to do the vault after her traumatic experience. Regardless, despite the best of intentions, I think that not giving Tuesday her legs back was a large mistake. Tuesday would’ve still befriended the misfits in that last life, and would’ve gone on to do many amazing things, proving that legs were just a mode of transportation, and not something that defined her (which was the goal of not giving Tuesday her legs back). I just felt like it was a major missed opportunity. This was a 5/5 star book until that fumble, but it was still a great accomplishment. I just feel morally and ethically required to dock my rating of the book by one star due to missing perfect ending.