Venice, 1710, Poinsettia Girl is based on the story of Agata de la Pieta, an orphan musician of the Ospedale de la Pieta. Ten-year-old Agata's world is shaken at the sudden death of her mother. Left only with her egregious father, a working musician in Venice, her ailing grandmother sends her to the well-known orphanage, hidden from everything she's ever known. Agata auditions for the conservatory style music school where music is both salvation and spectacle. Hidden behind ornate metal grates, adorned with poinsettias in their hair, the singers are veiled in mystery, their ethereal music drawing noble audiences, including gilded young men who see them as treasures-not only for their sound but as coveted marriage prizes. Just as she reaches the height of her musical journey, a marriage proposal from someone outside the audience tempts her with the promise of a new life-a return to the old neighborhood she's longed for and a home she barely remembers. Torn between the music that has defined her and the hope of belonging to a family, Agata must confront the most profound question of her is her purpose rooted in the music that shaped her, or in the love that might free her?
It is 1710 Venice and we meet Agata Farusi who is ten years old and her mother has just died.
She now has to live with her father and her beloved Nonna.
Nonna sees that it isn't safe for Agata to live with her father, and she is getting old and frail so she places Agata in Ospedale de la Pieta.
Ospedale de la Pieta was an orphanage for children that had been abandoned or orphaned.
It wasn't like a regular orphanage, though. It was for girls who have musical talent and who remain there until they are married. It is also a place where the children/girls were treated well.
Agata loses her name when she enters and becomes Agata de la Pieta.
I enjoyed learning about the life in this time and about the orphanage and the story of Agata de la Pieta’s life. Agata is a real person.
It was also very interesting that Vivaldi was there and that he was the person who accompanied her to the Ospedale de la Pieta. 4/5
Thank you to the author for a copy of her book. All opinions are my own.
Poinsettia Girl tells the enchanting story of the women at the Ospedale de la Pieta - an all-girls’ orphanage that provides opportunity and advancement for its “foundlings” through rigorous training in music.
I absolutely loved this book. The setting in 1700s Venice was magical, and it’s hard to believe a place like the Pieta really existed. Thanks to the author’s beautiful writing, I could picture so vividly this elusive legion of women hidden behind stone walls, as well as feel their multitude of emotions; longing both for success within the Pieta and for a life outside, the camaraderie between women, grief, love, and pride.
To me, the heart of this story are the women. While the novel primarily focuses on Agata, we also get to follow Agata’s grandmother, Agata’s instructor/performer Elena, as well as a retired Poinsettia Girl who stayed at the Pieta to help other foundlings on their journey into adulthood. Each woman carves their own path, choosing at crossroads between family, their career, and more. In a time where women’s choices are constantly under attack, I found it beautiful and refreshing to see these strong women taking control over their lives—no matter what path they choose.
Poinsettia Girl was a heart-warming and transportive story. Come for 1700s Venice and the mysterious Pieta, and stay to watch Agata grow!
I really enjoyed the beautiful writing and vivid sense of place in Poinsettia Girl. The historical Venice setting is thoughtfully developed, and the musical elements add a unique and engaging layer to Agata’s story.
While parts of the middle felt a bit slow for me, I appreciated how it reflects the structured life of the orphanage. The story really opens up in the final section, where Agata’s journey becomes more dynamic and compelling.
I also loved that the character is inspired by a real historical figure, which adds depth to the story. Overall, this is a lovely, well-written book that I think would especially resonate with young adult readers who are just beginning to explore historical fiction.
Set in early eighteenth-century Venice, Poinsettia Girl unfolds the story of Agata della Pietà, who, at age ten, was placed by her dying Nonna, Guilelma, at the Ospedale de la Pietà, an orphanage that placed emphasis on nurturing musical talent and housed its own prestigious and mysterious conservatoire, the Figlie del Coro, for whom Vivaldi was a teacher and composer.
Agata is supremely gifted, not only as a soprano but also as a copyist, composer, and violinist, but childhood trauma has silenced her singing. Can she overcome her grief to become one of the Coro’s elite Poinsettia Girls, or will the past return to claim her?...
Agata della Pietà was an orphan musician of the Pietà in the early 1700s, although little is known about her. Wizbowski has taken these scant details and those of the Pietà, which are relatively substantial, and created a sumptuous, spellbinding narrative.
Wizbowski's sparkling prose is writerly and self-assured, with details and emotions precisely rendered. Yet, there is an intricacy and a lingering, dreamy eloquence to her words that absorbs and captivates.
The book is divided into three Acts, the first beginning with a ten-year-old Agata attending her mother’s funeral. This opening chapter is written from Agata’s close third-person perspective, and the reader is immediately carried through the mourning procession with her, seeing everyone and everything through a child’s eyes, which lends the scene attention and candor. Wizbowski deftly uses Agata’s emotional confusion and youth to scatter tantalizing hints for the reader throughout her observations, which suggest that a darkness surrounds the enigmatic little girl.
The primary source of this disquiet is her father, Pietro, whose malign presence spreads through the first Act and beyond. He is a damaged, ambiguous character, shape-shifting among the guises of tortured genius, cunning grifter, and ruthless predator.
The other individual whose influence filters through the novel, but for different reasons, is Nonna Guilelma, who is portrayed with warm, authentic maternalism and a tough streak of tenacity. Qualities that are later reflected for Agata in the figure of Discrete Margarita, her mentor within the walls of the Pietà.
Act II opens with a deeply traumatized Agata arriving at the Pietà, her vulnerability and disorientation starkly contrasting with the unfamiliar surroundings and strict regime of the orphanage. Layer by layer, as Agata navigates the Pietà's rules and customs, Wizbowski illuminates this mysterious, closed world and its curious inhabitants with beautiful subtleties and hushed nuances.
There are a couple of swirling intrigues involving other characters, which are delicately handled, but it’s Agata’s journey through the tiers of the Pietà as she wrestles with her grief and bewilderment that is central. Wizbowski movingly depicts the girl’s fearfulness, but also the quiet resolve that takes its place as Agata immerses herself in music and the esoteric traditions of the Pieta’s Figlie Del Coro.
It's a compelling, gently unpredictable story that resonates with the Pietà girls' bewitching singing. Agata’s demons make the reader apprehensive that she will be able to fulfil her potential or, indeed, whether outside forces will eventually steer her fate.
Act III is where all elements converge, and it has a livelier, less cloistered tone than the previous two, as the secretive girls of the Coro are now young women sought after by the Venice elite for their beguiling vocal ability and marriageability. Wizbowski wisely avoids the seemingly satisfying conclusion, preferring to remain true to Agata’s elusive nature and journey of self-actualization.
Enchanting, atmospheric, and engrossing, Poinsettia Girl is a superbly written and beautifully crafted novel. Highly recommended.
Set in 1700s Venice the book tells the story of Agatha de la Pieta, from orphan at the Ospedale de la Pieta to renown musician, we follow her journey and her tumultuous growth, personally and musically and her life dilemma, is music the vessel to set her free or love the one that will do it? It's hard to believe that this book is a debut book by the author because it is so well written, that it feels like it belongs to a more established one. The amount of historical research shines in the pages of the book, the descriptions of places and settings makes you feel you are part of the story and the music passages transport you to Baroque and Classical 1700s Venice. I received an ARC from the publisher and my opinions are my own.
“Poinsettia Girl: The Story of Agata della Pieta” by Jennifer Wizbowski is a profoundly moving book that weaves together themes of love, loss, and the transformative power of music.
The novel intricately weaves the narrative of Agata della Pietà’s childhood, focusing on her formative years within the Ospedale della Pietà. This historic Venetian institution functioned as a convent, orphanage, and music school. Established in the 16th century, it was renowned for strict discipline and a deep commitment to educating abandoned or orphaned girls. Set against vibrant yet tumultuous 18th-century Venetian society, Agata’s journey unfolds in a community that values artistry but is limited by its societal norms. As Agata faces challenges ranging from the nuns’ regimens to competitive camaraderie among the girls, we witness her struggle to find her voice in a world that has previously silenced it.
Agata is a character who quickly captures the reader’s affection with her gentle spirit. She is a sensitive child, shaped by a poignant past that profoundly influences her present. Despite the encouragement she receives from those around her, Agata steadfastly refuses to sing, gripped by the fear that doing so will cause her to forget the sweet melody of her mother’s voice, which lingers in her memories like a cherished lullaby. Initially, she shies away from the spotlight, harbouring no dreams of becoming a member of the Coro or being noticed by others; it’s as if she longs to retreat into herself, finding solace in her solitude. However, when the magic of music stirs within her, it ignites a passion that cannot be contained, propelling her on a journey of self-discovery and expression that changes everything. Agata’s transformation reflects the powerful connection between music and emotion, illustrating how it can awaken the deepest parts of the soul.
Several other notable secondary characters in this novel help to propel the story forward. Candida stands out as a close friend and confidante of Agata, providing emotional support and insight that underscores the intricate dynamics of friendship. The Madonna (the Prioress) presents as a compassionate yet authoritative figure. Signora Prudenza is portrayed as a stern and cruel figure, her harsh demeanour creating formidable conflicts that elevate the stakes for Agata and her peers, as well as the Madonna. In a more nurturing role, Maestra Elena acts as a source of wisdom and encouragement for Agata, guiding her through difficult choices and fostering her personal growth amidst the surrounding trials. Lastly, the discreet Margarita exemplifies kindness and compassion, providing a gentle and reassuring presence in the midst of a strict setting. Her caring nature serves as a delicate counterbalance to the harsher elements of their world, reminding Agata of the importance of empathy and support in relationships. The famed composer and musician, Antonio Vivaldi, also has a small part to play in this novel.
This novel delves into profoundly unsettling scenes that explore various forms of child abuse, including emotional neglect, sexual abuse and violence. The author navigates these sensitive topics with remarkable care, choosing her words with precision to capture the gravity of each situation without sensationalising the trauma involved. Through vivid imagery and intricate character development, she brings to life the impact of these experiences on the protagonist, Agata. Struggling with the psychological repercussions of her abuse, Agata’s journey is marked by intense emotions and complex thoughts that reveal her internal battle. She grapples with the devastating loss of her mother, a void that deeply affects her feeling of self-worth, and what she perceives as the abandonment by her beloved Nonna (grandmother), who once provided solace and warmth. The stark, oppressive environment of Ospedale della Pietà is a jarring contrast to the life she once knew, encapsulating her feelings of isolation and despair. Each scene is meticulously crafted to evoke a visceral reaction from readers, compelling them to confront the harrowing realities faced by those who suffer in silence. The author’s deft handling of these themes draws attention not only to the traumatic experiences but also to the resilience required to survive and heal from such deep wounds.
Each distinct space within the convent—the practice hall, steeped in the echoes of unending rehearsals, where the sound of each note hangs in the air like a forgotten prayer; the sparse dormitories, lined with narrow beds, emphasising the minimalist lifestyle enforced upon the pupils, reinforce the overarching themes of confinement and spiritual renewal. The strict rules imposed by the nuns, articulated in sharp, unyielding tones, create a structured environment where every moment is dictated by schedule. The continuous pressure of upcoming auditions looms heavily, fostering a palpable sense of claustrophobia that grips the reader, drawing them into the emotional turmoil of the students. Yet for the pupils, the convent morphs into a paradoxical sanctuary, a place where they find refuge from the chaos of the outside world. It becomes a cocoon—a space where dreams of artistic brilliance may emerge, accompanied by a sense of safety, even amidst the relentless demands of perfection that govern their lives. The duality of the setting highlights the complex relationship between their aspirations and the constraining forces that shape their existence, offering both solace and a sense of entrapment.
Wizbowski’s evocative prose brings the enchanting world of Agata to life, making it impossible for readers to put the book down once the first page is turned. This book comes highly recommended.
Poinsettia Girl: The Story of Agata della Pietà by Jennifer Wizbowski is a deeply emotional novel about love, loss, and finding your voice through music . Set in 18th-century Venice, the story follows young Agata as she grows up in the Ospedale della Pietà, a strict convent and music school for orphaned girls. Surrounded by discipline and expectations, Agata must learn how to survive in a world that both nurtures talent and limits freedom.
Agata is a gentle and sensitive character who carries the pain of losing her mother—and being separated from her beloved Nonna (grandmother) . Afraid that singing will erase her mother’s voice from memory, she hides her gift and keeps to herself. But when music finally reaches her heart, it awakens something powerful inside her. Her journey of self-discovery is beautifully written, showing how art can heal even the deepest wounds.
The supporting characters add richness to the story. From her loyal friend Candida to the kind Maestra Elena, the compassionate Madonna, and the stern Signora Prudenza, each person shapes Agata’s path in meaningful ways. Even composer Antonio Vivaldi makes a small appearance. These relationships—both kind and cruel—help Agata grow, reminding us how important empathy and guidance are in difficult times.
This novel bravely touches on heavy themes like abuse, grief, and emotional neglect . Wizbowski writes these moments with sensitivity, allowing readers to feel Agata’s pain while also witnessing her quiet strength. The convent becomes both a place of confinement and comfort, deepening the emotional impact of the story. With lyrical prose and heartfelt storytelling, this book leaves a lasting impression and is truly worth reading.
I was drawn into Agata’s story right from the start. Although I’m a music teacher, I admittedly knew almost nothing about the Ospedale de la Pieta and its connection to a famous composer (no spoilers: read the book!). Now I’m down a rabbit hole of listening to the music performed by the Poinsettia Girls and learning more about the Ospedale. Maybe I’ll visit there someday!
Poinsettia Girl: The Story of Agata della Pietà is the kind of historical novel that doesn’t just tell you about a time and place — it makes you feel it. Venice in 1710 comes alive in soft, aching detail: canals that carry secrets, music that becomes both refuge and fate, and a world where beauty is often admired from a distance, but rarely understood.
Agata’s story begins with loss, and that grief quietly shapes everything that follows. She is only ten when her life fractures, and the decision to send her to the Ospedale della Pietà feels both like abandonment and salvation. The orphanage is portrayed with a haunting duality — it is protection, yes, but it is also confinement. The girls are trained, disciplined, and transformed into performers whose voices draw noble audiences, while they themselves remain hidden behind grates like sacred relics.
What makes this book so compelling is how it captures that tension: music as freedom, and music as a cage. Agata’s talent becomes her identity, but it also becomes the reason she is watched, desired, and measured. The poinsettias in the girls’ hair feel symbolic — delicate adornments that make them look like something to be admired, even when they are still children.
The emotional heart of the novel lies in Agata’s longing — not only for a life beyond the institution, but for something even more intimate: belonging. When the possibility of marriage appears, it isn’t written as a simple romantic escape. It feels like a real temptation, because it offers what Agata has been denied for so long — a home, a name, a place in the world. And yet, leaving also means surrendering the one thing that has ever truly been hers: her music.
The writing is lyrical without being heavy, and the atmosphere is consistently immersive. The story moves with the quiet intensity of a piece of classical music — building slowly, emotionally, until the final question becomes unavoidable: do we owe our lives to what shaped us, or to what might finally set us free?
If you love historical fiction that is emotionally rich, atmospheric, and quietly powerful, this book is an unforgettable read.
Poinsettia Girl completely drew me in. I loved Agata’s story—an orphan in 18th-century Venice finding her voice through music and courage. The writing is beautiful and atmospheric without feeling heavy, and the characters felt so real. It’s one of those quiet, powerful books that stays with you long after you finish. Highly recommend!
I really enjoyed getting to know Agata de la Pieta in this book, I didn't know anything about the real-life person so it was great to get into this journey. It uses the time-period perfectly and enjoyed how it uses the Venice element. I enjoyed the idea of music and uses that element in a way that I was hoping for. I enjoyed getting to go on this journey and get to know the characters. Jennifer Wizbowski has a strong writing style and enjoyed the overall feel of the journey. It had that historical concept that I was wanting and glad I was able to read this.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Agata herself and the historical facts were interesting but the religious aspect was there too much for me.. I know it's a big part of her life but the balance was tipped too strongly in that direction.
DNF, go for it if it sounds interesting to ya 👍🏼.
Nothing against Christian fiction or settings but not for me
Poinsettia Girl by Jennifer Wizbowski is an emotional and reflective novel that explores themes of identity, family relationships, and personal growth. The story follows a young woman navigating complicated emotions tied to her past while trying to understand where she truly belongs. The overall plot unfolds in a heartfelt and believable way, balancing emotional depth with moments of hope and self discovery. I found the story engaging because the struggles and relationships felt realistic rather than overly dramatic. The pacing fits the genre of contemporary fiction well. It moves steadily, focusing more on emotional development and character interactions than fast-moving action. The writing is easy to follow and draws readers naturally into the main character’s journey. The character development is especially strong, with the protagonist feeling layered and relatable as she works through difficult memories and changing relationships. Supporting characters also add warmth and realism to the story without overshadowing the main narrative. I would recommend Poinsettia Girl to readers who enjoy thoughtful, character driven fiction with emotional themes. It is best suited for those who appreciate stories about healing, self discovery, and the complexities of family dynamics.
Poinsettia Girl is a beautifully written historical novel set in 18th-century Venice, inspired by the true story of Agata della Pieta, an orphaned girl whose life becomes entwined with music, loss, and longing.
The story follows young Agata after the death of her mother, as she is sent to the Ospedale de la Pieta, an orphanage and music conservatory where gifted girls were trained to perform behind metal grates, hidden from the world yet admired by elite audiences. Music becomes both her refuge and her identity, even as she quietly yearns for the family and freedom she left behind.
I found this story deeply moving and emotionally immersive. Agata’s inner conflict felt raw and authentic, especially her struggle between staying loyal to the music that saved her and the desire to belong to a family again. The author captures Venice with a soft, almost lyrical touch, and the atmosphere of the orphanage, the performances, and the social limitations placed on these girls felt vivid and heartbreaking. Knowing the story is rooted in real history added another layer of poignancy to every decision Agata faced.
I loved how gently the book explores purpose, sacrifice, and choice. Agata is not portrayed as a grand heroine, but as a young girl navigating grief, talent, and hope in a world that offers her very few options. I appreciated the quiet strength in her character and the way the novel respects both love and ambition without romanticizing either.
I would highly recommend Poinsettia Girl to readers who enjoy historical fiction with emotional depth, strong female voices, and stories that linger long after the final page.
Poinsettia Girl is set in Venice in the early 1700s. The story is based on the life of Agata de la Pieta, an orphan musician of the Ospedale de la Pieta.
The first part of the story revealed the early years of Agata’s life and how her grandmother came to place her with the nuns at the all-girl orphanage. This was no ordinary abbey or orphanage as it raised the girls with an emphasis on music, either with an instrument or by singing. The girls sang and played their instruments in church and at concerts. The top soloists rising to the status of a Poinsettia Girl.
I enjoyed reading about the everyday life in the orphanage with its strict rules of silence and behaviour. Many of the girls became talented musicians and vocalists and were held in high esteem. Seen rarely by the public, the young women and girls were highly sought after when they did make public appearances. A few of the older ones went on to accept offers of marriage, but I was sad to read that one of the conditions of marriage was that they gave up their music and singing. The setting and the era of this book added to make this a very interesting story and the author’s notes at the back are a must read for further background information.
I found this novel to be both emotionally satisfying and intellectually engaging. It tells the story of a remarkable young woman while also shining a light on an often-overlooked chapter of music history. Agata's life is portrayed with compassion and authenticity, allowing readers to witness her gradual transformation through discipline, friendship, and unwavering dedication to her craft. Her resilience is inspiring precisely because it feels so believable.
The supporting characters add tremendous richness to the narrative. The Maestra's demanding guidance, the unwavering loyalty of Agata's fellow musicians, and the people she encounters beyond the Pietà all contribute to her development in meaningful ways. None of these relationships feel superficial. Instead, each one reveals another aspect of Agata's personality and helps shape the woman she ultimately becomes.
What impressed me most was the novel's refusal to reduce life's biggest decisions to simple answers. Love, ambition, family, and purpose are all treated with equal respect, making Agata's final choice emotionally complex and deeply human. Jennifer Wizbowski has written a moving historical novel filled with beauty, heart, and authenticity. It is the kind of story that quietly stays with you long after the final page has been turned.
It’s darkly tender, mist soaked and strange in the way old churches are strange, beautiful because they know how to keep secrets. Poinsettia Girl follows Agata, a grieving ten year old in 1710 Venice, as she is sent to the Ospedale della Pietà after her mother’s death. Behind its walls, music becomes discipline, shelter, spectacle, and eventually the question that may define her whole life. What I loved most was the atmosphere. Venice does not sit politely in the background here. It seeps in. Gray water, narrow streets, bells, cold rooms, black cloth, candlelight, voices rising behind grates. The book has a slow hush to it, not horror exactly, but dread of another kind: the dread of a child being absorbed by an institution that can save her and claim her at the same time. Agata is drawn with real tenderness. Her longing for her Nonna, her fear of losing her mother’s voice, and her complicated hunger for belonging all felt quietly devastating. A few perspective shifts softened the intensity for me, but the beauty held. A mournful, luminous historical novel about music, confinement, grief, and the cost of being chosen.
The novel is interesting! However I find it a bit too light. Agata's character could have been developed in more depth. We only have a short insight about her psychology whereas her life must have been much more filled with conflicts than it appears here. I was a bit surprised to find words, such as sweater and booking with a modern meaning. I checked the etymology and use of these terms over the years, revealing the wrong use of these words in this novel. Overall, a light read. I received a digital copy of this novel from BookSirens and I have voluntarily written an honest review.
Poinsettia Girl: The Story of Agata della Pieta by Jennifer Wizbowski is based on the real orphanage, Ospendale de la Pieta in Venice. Though Agata della Pieta was an actual resident of the orphanage and became a renowned composer, this is a fictional story of her life. Agata was secretly admitted to Pieta when her grandma, Nonna, knew her days were numbered and she could no longer protect her from her troubled father. Agata longs for her old life and struggles to find her voice amid the orphanage's dominant musical culture. Then she comes to a crossroads and can choose between her music and returning home; she finds the voice and the choice that have been hiding deep within her.
I thoroughly enjoyed the journey Jennifer Wizbowski takes her readers on. Poinsettia Girl was full of hope, camaraderie, and hidden agendas. This is the novel you end, feeling it was time well spent as you interacted with the characters. You can tell that the author put a lot of time and research into the characters, plot, and background. It was a fabulous read.
If you like historical fiction where the suspense comes from consequence, identity, and a character earning every inch of her future, this hits. Once Agata enters the Ospedale della Pietà, the story changes gears. The world gets smaller. Bells, lessons, silence, prayer, practice. On paper, that could flatten the momentum. Instead, the repetition builds pressure because every routine is pushing Agata toward one question: will she let music become her own voice, or keep treating that voice as something tied to what she has lost? The middle is deliberately measured, and pace addicts should know that going in. This is not a novel that throws a new crisis at you every chapter. But the chapter endings keep adding small emotional turns, and the final act tightens beautifully as talent, ambition, friendship, love, and the possibility of a life beyond the Pietà begin pulling in different directions. What really got me was how the book makes choice feel dangerous without manufacturing villains. Every path costs Agata something. That gives the closing stretch real tension because there is no painless answer waiting for her.
Quietly devastating, beautifully musical, and much more emotionally sneaky than I expected. Agata is ten when grief tears apart the only life she knows and she is brought to the Ospedale della Pietà, where strict routines, faith, and relentless musical training slowly become a new kind of home. Watching her move from a frightened girl afraid that singing might drown out the memory of her mother into someone who can claim her own voice was easily my favorite part. The relationships give the story its heart. Margarita has that perfect mix of firmness and tenderness, Candida brings needed brightness, and the women around Agata make the Pietà feel like both sanctuary and cage. And Venice basically starts humming around you. 🎶 My one gripe is the middle. The routines, lessons, and institutional details sometimes slow the momentum more than I wanted, especially because the final section has much sharper emotional tension. Still, the questions about belonging, ambition, family, and what freedom actually costs landed hard. Read if you like historical fiction built around women, music, complicated choices, and atmosphere you can practically hear. This one earns its final note.
This book did not meet my expectations. I think I thought I would like it because it was about a girl who went from being an orphan to a talented person, set in Venice. I really didn't enjoy this book very much. I found it to be too long and a bit boring, especially the middle third about her earliest years at the orphanage, in which Agata and every girl there lived very structured, scheduled lives. Most days were the same. I didn't like the environment where they all dressed alike, had to be silent much of the time. The last third of the book was more interesting with more happening. It was surprising any of the girls got married since they were so sheltered from the rest of the world and didn't interact with men very often. I didn't care for the choice Agata made at the end of the book, but was not surprised. I was disappointed to find out that though Agata was a real person, most of the book is fiction. The writing is good. I think people who are musicians will appreciate this book more than me, too.
Wizbowski's prose is at its best when it trusts physical detail. The damp streets, the bakery, the bells, the white halls of the Pietà, and the strange beauty of voices hidden behind grates all feel carefully observed. Music is not treated as decoration. It becomes a discipline, a refuge, and finally a language in which Agata can say what ordinary speech cannot hold. I admired the discretion of that choice, because it would have been easy to make the musical gift merely triumphant. Here, it is bound up with labour, obedience, fear, rivalry, and hope. The characters are drawn with a real understanding of behaviour. Agata is convincing because she is not made prematurely wise. She is frightened, watchful, stubborn, and deeply loyal. Guilelma, her grandmother, struck me as one of the book's moral anchors: loving, certainly, but also practical and shrewd in the way older women often have to be when tenderness alone will not protect a child. Pietro is troubling, as he should be, but the novel resists making him a simple monster. Around Agata, the women of the Pietà, especially Margarita and Elena, show how authority can wound or shelter depending on the conscience of the person who holds it. What gave me slight pause was the amount of institutional explanation the novel sometimes has to carry. There were moments when I felt the machinery of the Ospedale being set out for me rather than absorbed through Agata's own discoveries. Even so, this is a modest reservation, because the world itself is unusual enough to justify patience, and the emotional thread is never lost for long. This is a tender and thoughtful historical novel, more interested in formation than spectacle. I would recommend it to readers who like fiction that listens closely to young people, to women, and to the small acts of courage by which a life is gradually claimed.
I really thought I would like this book after reading all the positive reviews, but I just kept findings things that ruined it for me. First, the writing felt very youth-oriented; very basic, lots of short, simple sentences. Frequent instances of using modern vernacular in conversations and inaccuracies in addressing the time period; in describing a holiday scene, the author stated, "Lights and gaiety adorned the squares...." Really, lights in 1710???? Just didn't feel authentic to the 18th century.
Basically, you know the entire story just by reading the backcover or book jacket. And although based on a real person, the author shares that the entire first third of the story was completely fictionalized (see Afterword).
I'm not trying to completely bash the book as it's obvious that many others loved it, but was really disappointed in all of the inaccuracies and youth fiction feel. A DNF for me.
Exquisitely written, this tells the story of Agata della Pieta, a soprano and composer in 1700s Italy. Learning of the foundling orphanage which trained girls to be singers and musicians was fascinating. Atmosphere is everything in this book as little happens plot wise - the girls live a quiet, gentle, secluded life, studying music. This book draws you into the hushed and hallowed halls of the Ospedale and makes it all feel reverential.
Thank you to Netgalley and Historium Press for an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I fell in love with this book. The way Jennifer described Venice, the clear love between characters, the sometimes palpable worry I felt at different moments drew me in almost immediately and kept me flying through the book. When it was over I was sad because I had really come to love the characters. Highly recommend if you like historical fiction and are looking for something to lift your spirits.
Jennifer Wizbowski’s Poinsettia Girl: The Story of Agata della Pietà is an engaging work of historical fiction that uses the remarkable musical culture of eighteenth-century Venice’s Pietà as the setting for a coming-of-age story about grief, family, artistic ambition, and the struggle to find one’s own voice.
In 1710 Venice, ten-year-old Agata is devastated by the death of her mother, Kamelia. Her grandmother, Guilelma, provides stability, but Agata remains vulnerable to her volatile father, Pietro, whose frequent absences and unpredictable behavior make life increasingly frightening. Guilelma is openly afraid to leave Agata alone with him and becomes determined to protect her granddaughter. Agata is afraid of her father, and Guilelma eventually concludes that protecting her requires a drastic solution.
Agata is secretly taken to the Pietà, an institution populated by foundlings and governed by an elaborate community of women. Wizbowski does an especially good job of making the Pietà feel like a functioning world rather than simply an interesting historical backdrop. Its religious observances, classes, hierarchy, auditions, musical instruction, rules, rivalries, and routines gradually become as important to the novel as Agata herself. The musical training is particularly rigorous: advancement through the Coro requires years of study and successive auditions before a girl can become eligible for its performing ranks.
Initially, however, Agata wants little of what the Pietà offers. She grieves for her old life and resists singing as memories of her mother become increasingly entangled with music. Gradually, the institution begins to provide what her biological family can no longer give her. She develops a close friendship with the outspoken Candida and finds mentors and protectors among the older women, particularly Discrete Margarita and her teacher Elena.
Music naturally provides the novel’s strongest through line. Agata advances through the Pietà’s demanding musical system, developing as an instrumentalist, singer, copyist, and eventually a composer. Wizbowski wisely treats this development as work rather than miraculous talent suddenly revealing itself. Lessons, rehearsals, auditions, theory, copying music, disappointments, and competition all contribute to Agata’s progress. Indeed, her work copying scores eventually leads her to begin experimenting privately with musical phrases of her own. Antonio Vivaldi appears in the story, but Wizbowski resists the temptation to make the famous composer its center. The women of the Pietà remain firmly in the spotlight.
The novel is equally interested in the peculiar combination of confinement and opportunity the Pietà represents. The girls live under restrictions that modern readers will inevitably find severe, yet within those restrictions they receive extensive education and musical training, with the most accomplished eventually eligible to audition for the performing Coro. That contradiction gives the historical setting considerably more depth than a simple tale of talented girls overcoming adversity.
There are also darker currents within the institution. The ambitious and increasingly authoritarian Prudenza demonstrates how authority can become cruelty, while Margarita represents its opposite: authority exercised through patience, observation, and compassion. Prudenza is feared by her students, and her treatment of Candida causes Margarita to watch her closely. Elena likewise undergoes changes of her own, gradually confronting the possibility that the life she assumed was permanent may not be the only one available to her.
As Agata grows older, the outside world inevitably begins intruding again. Her childhood connection with Gabriele develops into something more complicated, forcing her to consider whether the life she once desperately wanted back is still the life she wants. Their correspondence becomes increasingly important as Agata matures. That question becomes central to the latter portion of the novel. Agata must distinguish between longing for people and places she lost as a child and deciding, as a young woman, where she actually belongs.
Wizbowski is particularly effective when she connects Agata’s musical development with that larger question of identity. Finding her voice is both literal and metaphorical. The child who arrives at the Pietà largely powerless over the decisions adults make for her gradually becomes capable of making consequential choices for herself.
Poinsettia Girl combines an unusual and fascinating historical setting with an accessible story about women, music, mentorship, and belonging. Its greatest strength is the world Wizbowski constructs inside the Pietà and the community of women who inhabit it. Agata’s journey ultimately becomes less about recovering what she has lost than discovering what she can create for herself, making this a thoughtful and warmly rendered historical novel about the difficult process of turning circumstance into choice.
Poinsettia Girl: The Story of Agata della Pietà by Jennifer Wizbowski
This novel follows the life of Agata, a young girl living in early 18th-century Venice. After the sudden death of her mother, Agata’s world falls apart. Her grandmother tries her best to protect her, but failing health forces her to make a painful decision for Agata’s future. Agata is sent to the Pietà, an orphanage that also serves as a strict music school for girls. The story carefully shows Agata’s journey from grief and fear to strength and self-understanding.
Venice is beautifully shown through everyday life narrow streets, canals, churches, and the quiet routines of the people. The Pietà is described as both safe and demanding. Life there is full of rules, long hours of practice, and little freedom. At the same time, it offers Agata protection and a sense of purpose. The hidden choir and the girls singing behind screens add mystery and make the setting feel unique and memorable.
Agata is a gentle and emotional child who struggles with loss and silence. At first, she is afraid of music because it reminds her of her mother. Over time, music becomes her way of healing. Her growth is slow and realistic, shaped by discipline, friendships, and guidance from caring mentors. The supporting characters, especially her grandmother and the women at the Pietà, play important roles in shaping her life and choices.
The book explores themes of grief, safety, abuse, healing, and choice. Music is not shown as easy success but as hard work and commitment. One of the strongest parts of the story is Agata’s final choice between staying with music or choosing marriage and family. This decision feels honest and meaningful because the reader understands her journey fully.
I highly recommend Poinsettia Girl to readers who enjoy historical fiction, emotional stories, and strong female characters. This book is thoughtful, well-paced, and deeply human. It is not just about music, but about finding one’s voice after silence and learning how to move forward after loss. A meaningful and memorable read.
I read Poinsettia Girl: The Story of Agata della Pieta by Jennifer Wizbowski and was immediately drawn into its rich historical setting and emotional depth. Set in Venice in 1710, the story feels immersive and thoughtfully crafted, bringing to life a world where music, loss, and longing are deeply connected.
Agata’s journey begins with heartbreak, and her grief felt very real to me as a reader. Losing her mother and being sent away from everything familiar is a painful turning point, and the author captures that sense of fear and displacement beautifully. The Ospedale de la Pieta is portrayed as both a place of refuge and confinement, where music becomes Agata’s comfort, identity, and voice in a world that limits her choices.
What stood out most was the way music is described—not just as talent, but as survival. The image of young girls singing behind metal grates, adorned with poinsettias, felt haunting and powerful. Their music draws admiration and desire, yet their lives remain hidden, controlled, and uncertain. This contrast adds emotional weight to Agata’s story and made me reflect on how talent can both elevate and trap a person.
As Agata grows, her inner conflict becomes the heart of the book. The choice between continuing her musical life or stepping into the possibility of family and belonging is handled with sensitivity. I appreciated that the author does not make this decision feel simple or romanticized. It is layered with fear, hope, and the ache of wanting to belong somewhere.
Overall, Poinsettia Girl is a moving historical novel about identity, purpose, and choice. It explores how art can shape a life, and how love can offer both freedom and uncertainty. This book stayed with me long after I finished it, and I would recommend it to readers who enjoy emotionally rich stories set in beautifully detailed historical worlds.
Poinsettia Girl BY Jennifer Wizbowski This story starts out with Agata and her grandmother is taking care of her, Guilelma. Agate's mother has passed away and she was the one to see her lying on the floor in blood. Her dad still lives there also but as a musician in 1700's he's often on the streets so others can hear his music. He tries to teach her the music also and she gets some of it. He's often not at home, weeks at a time. Guilelma is failing in health now and relies on a friend to take Agata to the ladies orphanage and they can raise her. She has lots of money to make sure that happens. The girls are raised to be Catholic and not much talking. They obey the rules, line up in order and say their prayers. They are given time for the music also. Agata has not shown them what she can do with her voice. They train her ove the years and she did get to glimpse her father once. She also sees the man in the red coat. one she saw at the church funeral service for her mother. The goal of the girls is to be seen and heard that a man will buy them and the girl must give up her love and doing music any longer. They are able to be called a poinsettia girl as they wear that flower when performing. The struggles are long and hard for her through the years. No one comes to visit with her. At the time when she's old enough to understand she is handed things from her grandmother and other family truths come to light. Loved hearing about the customs of the Venice community, especially during the funeral and what was frowned upon. Didn't think I'd enjoy this book as much as I did. Hope to read more from this author because they make you feel as if you were there. Like that she did stay in touch with the neighbor boy and his sister. Received this review copy from the publisher and this is my honest opinion.