What awaits the unrepentant?Eternal conscious suffering? A second death?
With biblical clarity and personal grace, Rubel Shelly explores what the Bible says about Hell. Reasoning that its symbolism and apocalyptic language are properly read in light of Scripture’s narrative language—rather than the reverse—he explains the textual evidence and logic that combine to require rethinking the views of Augustine, Jonathan Edwards, and many contemporary evangelists.
The God of Holy Scripture is holy and just, and the judgment of sin must not be compromised. That same God is also love and grace, and his just wrath is not the merciless torture of bloodthirsty pagan deities—the image of eternal conscious torment that drives people away from the Christian gospel. How, then, should we understand what the Bible says about Hell?
God honors human choice and allows each of us to decide.
“The wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Rom 6:23).
Dr. Rubel Shelly is an author, minister, and professor Lipscomb University. He is the former president of Rochester College.
Shelly began as an instructor in the department of Religion and Philosophy at Freed-Hardeman University in 1975. In 1978, Shelly began preaching as Senior Minister for the Family of God at Woodmont Hills, formerly known as the Woodmont Hills Church of Christ, in Nashville, Tennessee where he continued until 2005. While preaching at Woodmont Hills, he also taught at Lipscomb University, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, and Tennessee State University. From 1979 to 1980 while he worked to complete his graduate work at Vanderbilt University, he served as a graduate assistant in the Department of Philosophy. From 1981 to 1983, he was an Assistant Professor of Philosophy at Lipscomb University. In 1986, while continuing his education at Vanderbilt University, he taught as an Adjunct Assistant Professor in the Department of Medicine (Medical Ethics) until 1988. From 2000 to 2004, he was an Adjunct Assistant Professor of Philosophy at Tennessee State University.
When he stepped down from the pulpit in 2005, he began teaching again as a Professor of Philosophy and Religion at Rochester College, in Rochester Hills, Michigan. He was named the President of Rochester College in May 2009. He also currently serves as a co-minister for the Bristol Road Church of Christ in Flint, Michigan. In late 2012, Shelly announced that he would be stepping from his role as President at Rochester College by September 2013.
He is known primarily as a preacher. Shelly has been involved in debates and academic lectures on Christian apologetics, ethics, and medical ethics. Shelly has also served with such groups as the AIDS Education Committee of the American Red Cross.
He is the author or co-author of more than 30 books, including several which have been translated into languages such as Korean, Japanese, Portuguese, French, and Russian. He has published widely in religious journals.
Overall, I think this is a solid popular-level presentation of an annihilationist view on Hell. It is well-written and presents the view coherently and cohesively. While it is not my position (I still lean toward an ECT view that does not hold to literal "fire" or "worms", etc.), I think this is a good presentation of the position itself. I would recommend this to people who are considering the annihilationist viewpoint.
Some points of critique:
1) I do wish that Shelly had delved more into the views of the early church fathers. I would have liked him to deal with, say, Tertullian of Carthage's comments on hellfire in Chapter 48 of his "Apology" or Justin Martyr's comment on Hell as a place of punishment for the wicked in Chapter 19 of his "First Apology". Collapsing all of church history into the thoughts of Augustine of Hippo (who only became a Christian three and a half centuries after the resurrection of Jesus), Thomas Aquinas, Dante Alighieri, and Jonathan Edwards is rather reductionistic. Further, the assertion that Augustine originated the stereotypical "eternal conscious torment" picture of Hell necessitates a demonstration that his view departed from the normal views of the church leading up to his day. This was not demonstrated on any level. I realize that this book is limited and cannot be exhaustive, but not dealing with any post-biblical views of Hell from the first three centuries after Christ is a rather shocking gap even in a popular-level work.
2) While I appreciate that Shelly is not dogmatic regarding Hell, it is worth noting that one's view of Hell is somewhat dependent on which terms one takes literally and which one takes metaphorically. This involves a choice that is difficult to substantiate solely from the text of Scripture. For example, the typical annihilationist insists that the language of "fire", "darkness", etc., is metaphorical but does not seem to consider that the language of "death", "destruction", etc., could equally be metaphorical. They simply reject the former's literal nature and accept the latter's literal nature. I would like to see more substantiation on why we should accept the latter and reject the former, especially given the fact that in Scripture "death" is often used figuratively (see Luke 15 and the comments of the father regarding the prodigal son)!
3) While I don't think Shelly fully "straw-man"s the ECT position, he fails to discuss that there are plenty of us ECT proponents who, along with him, do not read the language of "fire" and "darkness" and "worms" literally. His case is partly contingent on the assertion that a metaphorical reading of said terms logically leads to his position, but that is an over-simplification of the matter. This is a glaring gap in the book.
4) While dealing with biblical passages that would seem to contradict his view (a much appreciated "steel-man"ing of his opposition), Revelation 14:11 (in which it is stated that "the smoke of their torment goes up forever and ever; they have no rest day and night") is not dealt with at all (at least, to my memory; please correct me if I have missed this)! While it can be argued that it is unclear whether this refers to the final destination of the wicked or to something else, it still needs to be dealt with.
5) A minor quibble here, but some of Shelly's sentence structures or somewhat confusing in their structure. A little more careful editing could have helped with the flow of some sentence structures.
Overall, I would still grade this a solid "B+/A-" as a book on Hell from an annihilationist perspective aimed at a popular audience. If I were teaching a high school junior/senior level class or an undergraduate college class on the afterlife, I would probably have this book as required reading. Definitely recommended.
I appreciated this exploration of the doctrine of Hell from Dr. Shelly. His humility, affirmation of the love of God, and his emphasis that eschatology shouldn’t be seen as a “test of fellowship” (to borrow language from our common tribe) was encouraging.
However, I do have a few key issues with his argumentation, which I have intentionally not reflected in the number of starts I’ve given the book. I review based on the proposed thesis and how well the author fulfilled his stated intention, not based on my personal agreement with conclusions.
My biggest point of contention is the idea that the Trinity was broken on the day Jesus died. I believe this idea is based on upon a false sense of justice and misunderstands the function of the cross. Just as Shelly sees eternal conscious torment as flowing from the one of Augustine, I believe the doctrine of PSA has come to us ultimately from the same stream of thought. Instead, in my opinion, it is the unbroken bond of the Trinity that enters into death and defeats it. As Jesus said in John 16, his disciples would abandon him but his Father wouldn’t leave him alone. 2 Corinthians 5 likewise says that God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself.
Secondly, I take Hell seriously, but I see it as an extension of God’s love. Shelly recognizes the comparison between a loving Father who rightly disciplines his children and hates the evil that ensnares them and the role of God as Father. Yet, in a healthy family, punishment or discipline ends in an embrace. For example, Shelly cited Hebrews 6 to talk about someone who refuses follow God after tasting of the heavenly gifts. He likens this person to a field consumed with thorns. This field is burned. While it is impossible for us to restore such a one to the Christian community, isn’t the prescribed burn the Hebrews writer is alluding to for the purpose of eventual restoration? God as a consuming fire disciplines to teach and instruct in holiness (Hebrews 12). Following George MacDonald, this would seem to be a better understanding of the aim of God’s justice and wrath.
Finally, I appreciate Shelly acknowledging that those who haven’t heard the gospel aren’t really given a choice. Even someone who hears the “gospel” from an abusive or arrogant preacher hasn’t really been given a choice. The God who would accept such a person would surely embrace the one who joyfully embraces the flash of God’s love in an unfiltered and unbiased way (Shelly’s hypotheses concerning perspicacity).
Those are the beginnings of a few thoughts. Overall, I think the book is worth the read and is a great step in the right direction, especially in its example of humility, dedication to truth, and an ultimate resignation to trust that God, who is Love, will make the right decisions according to his excellent nature.
Shelly provides a very readable book about Hell. He argues against the more Medieval picture of Hell as an everlasting torment of fire, and instead, points toward the idea that Hell is separation from God, and if God is needed for life, the Hell is the eternal death. While this contrasts from the traditional view of Hell, and how it is portrayed in media and culture, it's not necessarily a new idea. This notion of Hell has been argued for a while. Ultimately, no one knows exactly what Hell will be like, and Shelly makes this point in his book. He's honest that this is his best understanding of scripture. If one wants an easily readable, easily digestible discussion of Hell, this is an excellent read. However, if one is wanting a more theological interpretation, it would be best to go elsewhere.
Good companion to his Heaven book. Formatted just the same. As with the other one, good biblical scholarship with the humility to admit there's no guarantee that the topic is definitively covered, which I appreciate.
If you are a person who believes that Hell is a biblical concept, AND you are also a person who cannot reconcile a loving God with unending torment, then this book is for you. I found Shelly's text to be biblical and insightful; it has given me a whole new understanding of God and the afterlife.